1

ANNEX A: LIST OF PARTICIPANTS CONTACTED (JULY - AUGUST 2019)

No. Name Father/ Husband Name Village District 1 Malik Aman Nawab Khan Bareela Bala Mansehra 2 M. Khursheed M. Riaz Bareela Bala Mansehra 3 Khanizaman Amir Khan Bareela Bala Mansehra 4 M. Farid Nawab Khan Bareela Bala Mansehra 5 M. Akram M. Zaman Bareela Bala Mansehra 6 Javed Sumundar Khan Bareela Bala Mansehra 7 Duria Aman Amir Khan Bareela Bala Mansehra 8 Sumundar Khan Ali Zaman Bareela Bala Mansehra 9 Dildaar Hussain Khani zaman Bareela Bala Mansehra 10 M. Irshad Khani Zaman Bareela Bala Mansehra 11 Dilshad M. Dawood Bareela Bala Mansehra 12 Sher Khan Gohar Rehmman Khalyaala Mansehra 13 Shafiq Qalandar Khan Mohar Kalan Mansehra 14 Fida Muhammad Gohar Rehmman Khalyaala Mansehra 15 Ali Zaman M. Khan New Sadab Mansehra 16 M. Naeem Muzafar Khan Kashmir pani Mansehra 17 Jan Muhammad Ahmed Ali Kashmir Pani Mansehra 18 Mushtaq Khan Gul Kashmir Pani Mansehra 19 M. Zubair Muzafar Khan Sawan Mera Mansehra 20 M. Amjed M. Ayub Sawan Mera Mansehra 21 M. Adil Fazal Ur Rehmman Sawan Mera Mansehra 22 Sarfaraz Jan Muhammad Sawan Mera Mansehra 23 Adeel M. Ayub Sawan Mera Mansehra 24 Taj Muhammad Gul Zaman Sawan Mera Mansehra 25 Tariq Wali Muhammad Sawan Mera Mansehra 26 M. Imran M. Farooq Sawan Mera Mansehra 27 M. Waqas Abdul Hamid Sawan Mera Mansehra 28 Rafi Faqir Muhammad Sawan Mera Mansehra 29 Safeer M.Yusuf Sawan Mera Mansehra 30 Abid Mir Zaman Sawan Mera Mansehra 31 M.yunus Bahadur Khan Kat Gran Mansehra 32 M. Irfhan M. Maharoof Kat Gran Mansehra 33 Mushtaq Sattar Khan Kat Gran Mansehra 34 M. Farooq M. Miskeen Kat Gran Mansehra 35 Fida Muhammad Sher Bahadur Kat Gran Mansehra 36 M. Riaz Sultan Muhammad Kat Gran Mansehra 37 Ali Asghar Ghazi Khan Kat Gran Mansehra 38 M. Rafaqat Sher Bahadur Kat Gran Mansehra 39 Nisar Haroon M. Haroon Kat Gran Mansehra 40 Noor Muhammad Amir Khan Kat Gran Mansehra 41 Mahroof Amir Khan Kat Gran Mansehra 42 Yunus M. Farid Nakka Mansehra 43 Ali Aksar M. Farid Nakka Mansehra

44 Rustum Zaman Fazal Ur Rehmman Sawan Mera (Syedabad)

Mansehra

45 Naeed Miskeen Sawan Mera Mansehra 46 Atiq ur Rehmman Khani Zaman Sawan Mera Mansehra 47 Shafiq M. Miskeen Sawan Mera Mansehra 48 Irshad Mir Muhammad Sawan Mera Mansehra 49 Sadiq Faqir Muhammad Sawan Mera Mansehra 50 Abaidullah Sawan Mera Mansehra

2

No. Name Father/ Husband Name Village District 51 M. Naeem M. Farid Nakka Mansehra 52 Saleem M.Farid Nakka Mansehra 53 M.Javed M.Anwar Bareela Mansehra 54 M.Pervez M.Akram Katgran Mansehra 55 Sadiq Sher Zaman Sawan Mera Mansehra 56 Ayub Noor Hussain Nakka Mansehra 57 M. Mehraj M. Sarwar Nakka Mansehra 58 Syed Muzamil Mazloom Shah Kalyaala Mansehra 59 Khurshid Ali Bahadur Kalyaala Mansehra 60 Amir Shah Syed Matloob Shah Kalyaala Mansehra 61 Murad Sarwar Kalyaala Mansehra 62 Taj Muhammad Gohar Aman Kalyaala Mansehra 63 Ali Aksar Ali Bahadur Kalyaala Mansehra 64 Alamzeb Ali Bahadur Kashmir Pani Mansehra 65 M.Yusuf M.Zaman Kashmir Pani Mansehra 66 Abdul Hamid Suleman Kashmir Pani Mansehra 67 Abdul Rashid Suleman Kashmir Pani Mansehra 68 Hamayun M.Yaqoob Kashmir Pani Mansehra 69 Ashraf Zafar M. Muzafar Kashmir Pani Mansehra 70 Kaleem Muzafar Khan Kashmir Pani Mansehra 71 Saeed Ghulam Sarwar Kashmir Pani Mansehra 72 M. Shahid Rafiq Ahmed Kashmir Pani Mansehra 73 Abid Zafar M. Khalid Kashmir Pani Mansehra 74 M. Ayub Abdul Ghani Sawan Mera Mansehra 75 M. Jamil Mir Zaman Sawan Mera Mansehra 76 M. Sajjad M. Yaqub Nakka Mansehra 77 Manzoor Ali Bahadur Nakka Mansehra 78 Banarus Khan Omer Khan Nakka Mansehra 79 Ayub Noor Hussain Nakka Mansehra 80 Sardar M. Farid Nakka Mansehra 81 Taj Mohammad Sawan Mera Mansehra 82 Abdul Rashid Sultan Muhammad Sawan Mera Mansehra 83 Ms. Munaza Taweel Sawan Mera Mansehra 84 Ms. Kainat Ayub Sawan Mera Mansehra 85 Ms. Noreen Amjed Sawan Mera Mansehra 86 Zaida Ayub Sawan Mera Mansehra 87 Zohra Bibi Sarfraz Sawan Mera Mansehra 88 Nayyab Riaz Sawan Mera Mansehra 89 Tahzeem Wali Muhammad Sawan Mera Mansehra 90 Hameeda Farooq Sawan Mera Mansehra 91 Siddiqa Ejaz Sawan Mera Mansehra 92 Amraiz Rafique Sawan Mera Mansehra 93 Fatima Siddique Sawan Mera Mansehra 94 Riaz Akhtar Abdul Khaliq Kat Gran Mansehra 95 Faiza Irfhan Kat Gran Mansehra 96 Rukhsana M. Maroof Kat Gran Mansehra 97 Rashida Sabir Kat Gran Mansehra 98 Salma Yunus Kat Gran Mansehra 99 Shumaila Bashir Kat Gran Mansehra 100 Sanam Rasheed Kat Gran Mansehra 101 Makhan Jan Yaqoob Kat Gran Mansehra 102 Shamim M. Bashir Kat Gran Mansehra 103 Shabana Munir Kat Gran Mansehra 104 Zakia Bibi Riaz Kat Gran Mansehra 105 Robina Zardad Kat Gran Mansehra 106 Shaheen Akthar Zareen Kat Gran Mansehra 107 Dilbar Jan Mehmood Kat Gran Mansehra

3

No. Name Father/ Husband Name Village District 108 Makhan Jan Farid Kat Gran Mansehra 109 Omar Jan Sittar Muhammad Kat Gran Mansehra 110 Sardar Jan Shahzada Kat Gran Mansehra 111 Nazia Miraj Kat Gran Mansehra 112 Maryum Bibi Shafique Sawan Mera Mansehra 113 Ansa Khursheed Ahmed Sawan Mera Mansehra 114 Sumera Naheed Sawan Mera Mansehra 115 Rashida Saeed Sawan Mera Mansehra 116 Anila Asif Sawan Mera Mansehra 117 Fouzia Naveed Sawan Mera Mansehra 118 Asmat Jhanzeb Sawan Mera Mansehra 119 Pervin Fayyaz Sawan Mera Mansehra 120 Khushniaz Sheraz Sawan Mera Mansehra 121 Naveeda Sarfraz Sawan Mera Mansehra 122 Shazia Aslam Sawan Mera Mansehra 123 Fouzia Rashid Sawan Mera Mansehra 124 Noureen Amjed Sawan Mera Mansehra 125 Asia Majid Sawan Mera Mansehra 126 Samina Ejaz Sawan Mera Mansehra 127 Munaza Taveel Sawan Mera Mansehra 128 Miskeen Khurshaid Sawan Mera Mansehra 129 Maskeen Gulzar Sawan Mira Mansehra 130 M. Ashraf Gulzar Sawan Mira Mansehra 131 Ms. Noor u Nissa Gulzar Sawan Mira Mansehra 132 Ms Sarwar Jan Gulzar Sawan Mira Mansehra 133 Ms Zaitoon W/o Haider Sawan Mira Mansehra 134 Ms Farid Jana D/O Haider Sawan Mira Mansehra 135 Wazir Muhammad Sikendar Sawan Mira Mansehra 136 M. Maroof Abdul Latif Sawan Mira Mansehra 137 Faqir Muhammed Sultan Sawan Mira Mansehra 138 Sikendar Sultan Sawan Mira Mansehra 139 Mir Afzal Said Zaman Sawan Mira Mansehra 140 Tara Khan Said Zaman Sawan Mira Mansehra 141 Malak Aman Said Zaman Sawan Mira Mansehra 142 Ms Amirjana D/O Sher Bahader Sawan Mira Mansehra 143 Ms AnwarJana W/O Jehanzeb Sawan Mira Mansehra 144 Alam Zeb Maskeen Sawan Mira Mansehra 145 Jawaid Maskeen Sawan Mira Mansehra 146 Zarin Maskeen Sawan Mira Mansehra 147 Saleem Maskeen Sawan Mira Mansehra 148 Shamrooz Maskeen Sawan Mira Mansehra 149 Anwar Zeb Maskeen Sawan Mira Mansehra 150 Ms. Khursheeda D/O Maskeen Sawan Mira Mansehra 151 Ms. Shah Jehan D/O Maskeen Sawan Mira Mansehra 152 Ms. Nazakat D/O Maskeen Sawan Mira Mansehra 153 Ms. Naseem D/O Maskeen Sawan Mira Mansehra 154 M. Masroof Abdullatif Sawan Mira Mansehra 155 Ms. Anwar Jan W/O Maskeen Sawan Mira Mansehra 156 Jehanzeb Maskeen Sawan Mira Mansehra 157 Alam Zeb Maskeen Sawan Mira Mansehra 158 Jawaid Maskeen Sawan Mira Mansehra 159 Zarin Maskeen Sawan Mira Mansehra 160 Saleem Maskeen Sawan Mira Mansehra 161 Shamreez Maskeen Sawan Mira Mansehra 162 Anwar Zeb Maskeen Sawan Mira Mansehra 163 Ms. Khursheed D/O Maskeen Sawan Mira Mansehra 164 Ms. Shahjehan D/O Maskeen Sawan Mira Mansehra

4

No. Name Father/ Husband Name Village District 165 Ms. Nazakat D/O Maskeen Sawan Mira Mansehra 166 Ms. Naseem D/O Maskeen Sawan Mira Mansehra 167 Faqir Sultan Sawan Mira Mansehra 168 Sikendar Sultan Sawan Mira Mansehra 169 Mir Afzal Mir Zaman Sawan Mira Mansehra 170 Tara Khan Mir Zaman Sawan Mira Mansehra 171 Malak Aman Mir Zaman Sawan Mira Mansehra 172 Ms. Zaitoon W/O Haider Sawan Mira Mansehra 173 Ms. Farid Jan D/O Haider Sawan Mira Mansehra 174 Ms. Anwar Jan W/O Maskeen Sawan Mira Mansehra 175 Jehan Zeb Maskeen Sawan Mira Mansehra 176 Alam Zeb Maskeen Sawan Mira Mansehra 177 Jawaid Maskeen Sawan Mira Mansehra 178 Zarin Maskeen Sawan Mira Mansehra 179 Saleem Maskeen Sawan Mira Mansehra 180 Shamreez Maskeen Sawan Mira Mansehra 181 Anwar Zeb Maskeen Sawan Mira Mansehra 182 Ms Khurshida D/O Maskeen Sawan Mira Mansehra 183 Ms Shahjehan D/O Maskeen Sawan Mira Mansehra 184 Ms. Nazakat D/O Maskeen Sawan Mira Mansehra 185 Ms. Naseem D/O Maskeen Sawan Mira Mansehra 186 Ms Amir Jana W/O Abdul Kareem Sawan Mira Mansehra 187 Taj Muhammed Gulzaman Sawan Mira Mansehra 188 Ms. Zaiwar Jan W/O Abdul Kareem Sawan Mira Mansehra 189 Gohar Abdul Kareem Sawan Mira Mansehra 190 Ghulam Jan Abdul Kareem Sawan Mira Mansehra 191 Malak Aman Abdul Kareem Sawan Mira Mansehra 192 Maskeen Abdul Kareem Sawan Mira Mansehra 193 Yousaf Abdul Kareem Sawan Mira Mansehra 194 Ms. Umar Jana D/O Abdul Kareem Sawan Mira Mansehra

195 Ms.Qalandar Jana D/O Abdul Kareem Sawan Mira Mansehra

196 M. Ayub Abdul Ghani etc Sawan Mira Mansehra 197 Mir Muhammed Mir Zaman Sawan Mira Mansehra 108 Ms.Resham Jan D/O Mirzaman Sawan Mira Mansehra

199 Ms. Walyat u Nissa

D/O Mirzaman Sawan Mira Mansehra

200 M.s Munawar Jan D/O Sultan Sawan Mira Mansehra 201 Abdur Rasheed Sultan Sawan Mira Mansehra 202 Ms. Musarat Bi Bi D/O Sultan Sawan Mira Mansehra 203 Ms. Rehana W/O Maneez Khan Sawan Mira Mansehra 204 M. Arshad Mir Muhammad Sawan Mira Mansehra 205 M. Irshad Mir Muhammad Sawan Mira Mansehra 206 Sujjad Ahmad Mir Muhammad Sawan Mira Mansehra 207 Anwar Zeb Alam Zeb Sawan Mira Mansehra 208 Amir Zeb Alam Zeb Sawan Mira Mansehra 208 Asad Zeb Alam Zeb Sawan Mira Mansehra 210 Ahsan Zeb Alam Zeb Sawan Mira Mansehra 211 Ms.Munawar W/O Sultan Sawan Mira Mansehra 212 Abdur Rasheed Sultan Sawan Mira Mansehra 213 Ms. Musrat Bibi D/O Sultan Sawan Mira Mansehra 214 Ms. Hameeda D/O Sultan Sawan Mira Mansehra 215 Attiq u Rehman Shahab u Ddin Sawan Mira Mansehra

216 Naseem u Rehman Shahab u Ddin Sawan Mira Mansehra

217 Jameel Ahmad Mir Zaman Sawan Mira Mansehra 218 Jameel Ahmad Mir Zaman Sawan Mira Mansehra

5

No. Name Father/ Husband Name Village District 219 M. Sadq Faqir Muhammad Sawan Mira Mansehra 220 M. Saddiq Faqir Muhammad Sawan Mira Mansehra 221 Dost Muhammed Maneez Khan Sawan Mira Mansehra 222 Sheraz Faqr Muhammed Sawan Mira Mansehra 223 M. Aslam Muzafar Sawan Mira Mansehra 224 M. Ashraf Muzafar Sawan Mira Mansehra 225 Ms. Sabeha D/O Muzafar Sawan Mira Mansehra 226 Ms. Sohyna, Muzafar Sawan Mira Mansehra 227 Ms. Baid Akhtar, W/O of M. Khalid Sawan Mira Mansehra 228 M. Zahid Zafar M. Khalid Sawan Mira Mansehra 229 Ms. Zubaid Khalid D/O Khalid Sawan Mira Mansehra 230 M. Ayaz Sarfaraz Sawan Mira Mansehra 231 Ms. Kaneez M. Alyas Sawan Mira Mansehra 232 Timur, Saifur etc M. Alyas Sawan Mira Mansehra 233 Ms Shagufta M. Alyas Sawan Mira Mansehra 234 Ms. Gul Perven M. Younas u Rehman Sawan Mira Mansehra 235 Jehangir, M. Younas u Rehman Sawan Mira Mansehra 236 Shahid, Shakir Younas u Rehman Sawan Mira Mansehra 237 Ms. Riffat Bibi D/O Younas u Rehman Sawan Mira Mansehra 238 Ms. Kirn Shahzadi D/O Younas u Rehman Sawan Mira Mansehra 239 Ms Tilat W/o Younas u rehman Sawan Mira Mansehra 240 Ms Aysha Jawaid D/O Jawaid Younas Sawan Mira Mansehra 241 Ms. Saleema w/O Jehanzeb Younas Sawan Mira Mansehra 242 Umar Shahzad w/O Jehan Younas Sawan Mira Mansehra 243 Ms Rabia D/O Jehan Younas Sawan Mira Mansehra 244 Ms. Naheed Sawan Mira Mansehra

245 M. Qasim Rehman Sawan Mira Mansehra

246 Dost Muhammad Khaneez Khan Sawan Mira Mansehra 247 Ms. Naseem W/O Mutabar Sawan Mira Mansehra 248 Shahzad, Shakeel Mutabar Khan Sawan Mira Mansehra 249 Ms Farhat D/O Mutabar Khan Sawan Mira Mansehra 250 Aslam Muzafar Sawan Mira Mansehra 252 Ashraf Zafar Muzafar Sawan Mira Mansehra 252 Ms. Sabeha D/O Muzafar Sawan Mira Mansehra 253 Ms. Surya Muzafar Sawan Mira Mansehra 254 Ms. Baidar Akhtar M. Khalid Sawan Mira Mansehra 255 M. Zahid Zafar M. Khalid Sawan Mira Mansehra 256 Abid Zafar M. Khalid Sawan Mira Mansehra

257 Ms Zubaida Khalid D/O Khalid Sawan Mira Mansehra

258 Abdur Rasheed M. Maskeen Sawan Mira Mansehra 259 Ms Saleem W/o Jameel u Rehman Sawan Mira Mansehra 260 Ms Aysha Jawaid D/O Jawaid Sawan Mira Mansehra 261 Ms. Saleema W/O Jehan Zeb Sawan Mira Mansehra 262 M. Shahzad Jehanzeb Sawan Mira Mansehra 263 Ms Rabia D/O Jehanzeb Sawan Mira Mansehra 264 Ms. Naheed Jamil u Rehman Sawan Mira Mansehra 265 M. Qasim Jamil u Rehman Sawan Mira Mansehra 266 Ms. Noor Fatma D/ OJamil u Rehman Sawan Mira Mansehra 267 Ms. Gul Pervin W/O M. Younas Sawan Mira Mansehra 268 Jehangir Younas M. Younas Sawan Mira Mansehra 269 Shahid M. Younas Sawan Mira Mansehra 270 Ms Riffat bibi M. Younas Sawan Mira Mansehra

271 Ms. Kiran Shahzadi D/O Younas u Rehman Sawan Mira Mansehra

272 M. Ayaz Sarfaraz Sawan Mira Mansehra

6

No. Name Father/ Husband Name Village District 273 Ms Kaneez Fatma W/O M. Alyas Sawan Mira Mansehra 274 Timur M.Alyas Sawan Mira Mansehra 275 Ms Foqeed Naz D/OM. Alyas Sawan Mira Mansehra 276 Ms. Ambar Jan W/O Rehmat Sawan Mira Mansehra 277 Fazli Rehman Rahmat Ullah Sawan Mira Mansehra 278 Ms Amreezan D/O Rehmat Sawan Mira Mansehra 279 M. Farman Haider Zaman Sawan Mira Mansehra 280 Ms Zakia Bibi D/ O Haider Zaman Sawan Mira Mansehra

281 Khursheed Ahmad Ali Bahadar Sawan Mira Mansehra

282 Ms. Zarsheed Bibi W/O khurshad Ahmad Sawan Mira Mansehra 283 M. Arif, Tariq AlamZeb Sawan Mira Mansehra 284 Ms. Anisa Bibi D/ O Alam Zeb Sawan Mira Mansehra 285 Amjad Hussain Anwar Shah Sawan Mira Mansehra 286 Rasool Shah Barkat Shah Sawan Mira Mansehra 287 Said Shah Muborak Shah Sawan Mira Mansehra 288 Ms. Bibi Fatma D/O Muborak Shah Sawan Mira Mansehra 289 Farhan Shah Gulistan Sawan Mira Mansehra 290 Abdullah Shah Farman Shah Sawan Mira Mansehra 291 M. Jawaid Samandar Khan Sawan Mira Mansehra 292 Faiz Ullah Said Ullah Sawan Mira Mansehra 293 M. Sarwar M. Masroof Logran Mansehra 294 M. Mushatq M. Sarwar Logran Mansehra 295 Ms Asmat Bibi D/) M. sarwar Logran Mansehra 296 Asif Anwar M.Anwar Logran Mansehra 297 Azhar Saeed Ahmad Saeed Logran Mansehra 298 Ms Khursheeda D/O M. Aman Logran Mansehra 299 M. Bakhtair Sher Muhammad Logran Mansehra 300 Ms. Bibi Amria W/O M. Ashraf Logran Mansehra 301 M. Ashfaq M. Ashraf Logran Mansehra 302 Sujjad Ahmad M. Ashraf Logran Mansehra 303 Ms Bibi Nazir D/O M. Ashraf Logran Mansehra 304 M. Rafiq etc M. Sarwar Logran Mansehra 305 Ms. Noorani D/O M. Sarwar Logran Mansehra 306 Noor Hussain M. Sarwar Logran Mansehra 307 M. Raiz Sultan Muhammad Logran Mansehra 308 M. Jawaid M. Saeed Logran Mansehra 309 Mahood Khan Jalal Khan Logran Mansehra 310 Asif Anwar M. Anwar Logran Mansehra 311 M. Sarwar M. Maroof Khan Logran Mansehra 312 M. Mushtaq M. Sarwar Logran Mansehra 313 Ms Asmat Bibi D/ O M Sarwar Logran Mansehra 314 Ms Khursheeda D/O Kala Khan Logran Mansehra 315 Ms. Duri Shahwar D/O Kala Khan Logran Mansehra 316 M. Bakhtair Fid Muhammad Khan Logran Mansehra 317 Ms. Soshan Jan W/O M. Ashraf Khan Logran Mansehra 318 M. Ashfaq M. Ashraf Logran Mansehra 319 Sujjad Ahmad M. Ashraf Logran Mansehra 320 Ms. Bibi Nazir D/O M. Ashraf Logran Mansehra 321 M. Irshad M. Anwar Logran Mansehra 322 Ms. Kali Bibi W/O Ali Bahader Logran Mansehra 323 M. Yaqoob Ali Bahadar Logran Mansehra 324 Manzoor Ahmad Ali Bahadar Logran Mansehra 325 Ms Fazilat D/O Ali Bahadar Logran Mansehra 326 M. Ayub Logran Mansehra 327 M. Maskeen, Noor Hussain Logran Mansehra 328 Baigum Jan D/O Noor Hussain Logran Mansehra

7

No. Name Father/ Husband Name Village District 329 Mehmood Khan Jalal Khan Logran Mansehra 330 Sabir, Arshad Ghazi Khan Logran Mansehra 331 Asif Anwar M. Anwar Logran Mansehra 332 Ms. Ulfat Sultana Ahmad Saeed Logran Mansehra 333 Waheed Anjum Ahmad Saeed Logran Mansehra 334 M. Zahid Jan Muhammed Logran Mansehra 335 M. Sarwar Maroof Khan Logran Mansehra 336 M. Mushtaq Sarwar Khan Logran Mansehra 337 Ms. Asmat D/ O M. Sarwar Logran Mansehra 338 Ms. Khursheed D/O M. Aman Khan Logran Mansehra 339 Ms. Duri Shahwar D/O. M. Aman Logran Mansehra 340 M. Bakhtair Sher Muhammad Khan Logran Mansehra 341 Ms. Bibi Sosan W/O M. Ashraf Logran Mansehra 342 M. ashfaq M. Ashraf Logran Mansehra 343 Ms. Bibi Nazia D/O M. Ashraf Logran Mansehra 344 M. Ayub Noor Hussain Logran Mansehra 345 M. Maskeen Noor Hussain Logran Mansehra 346 Ms. Baigum Jan D/O Noor Hussain Logran Mansehra 347 M. Yaqoob Ali Bahadar Logran Mansehra 348 Manzoor Ahmad Ali Bahadar Logran Mansehra 349 Ms. Zaitoon D/O Ali Bahadar Logran Mansehra 350 Mohmood Khan Jalal Khan Logran Mansehra 351 Ali Asghar Saleem Logran Mansehra 352 Fareed Ameer Logran Mansehra 353 M. Ayub Ameer Logran Mansehra 354 Yousaf, Gohar Kwaja Muhammad Logran Mansehra 355 Asif Anwar M. Anwar Logran Mansehra 356 Ms Ulfat Sultana W/O Ahmad Saeed Khan Logran Mansehra 357 Asghar Saeed Muhammad Sher Logran Mansehra 358 M. Sarwar M. Maroof Logran Mansehra 359 M. Mushtaq M. Sarwar Logran Mansehra 360 Asmat bibi D/O M. Sarwar Logran Mansehra 361 Ms. Khursheed D/O M. Aman Logran Mansehra 362 M. Bakhtair Sher Muh,d Logran Mansehra 363 Ms. Bibi Sosin Jan M. Ashraf Logran Mansehra 364 M. Ashfaq M. Ashraf Logran Mansehra 365 Sujjad Ahmad Ashraf Logran Mansehra 366 Ms. Nazia M. Ashraf Logran Mansehra 367 Hairaj, afraz M. Sarwar Logran Mansehra 368 M. Raiz Sultan Logran Mansehra 369 M. Jawaid Anwar Khan Logran Mansehra 370 Babar Khan Haider Logran Mansehra 371 Mehnood Khan Jalal Logran Mansehra 372 M. Sarwar Maroof Khan Logran Mansehra 373 Mushtaq Sarwar Logran Mansehra 374 Ms Shahnaz M. Sarwar Logran Mansehra 375 Ms. Bibi Sosin Ashraf Logran Mansehra 376 M. Ashfaq Ashraf Logran Mansehra 377 Sujjad Ahmad M. Ashraf Logran Mansehra 378 Ms. Nazia M Ashraf Logran Mansehra 379 Bakhtair Sher Muhammad Logran Mansehra 380 M. Raiz Sultan Moh,d Logran Mansehra 381 M. Maskeen Noor Hussain Logran Mansehra 382 Ms. Noorani D/O Noor Hussain Logran Mansehra 383 M. Anwar Ali Zaman Logran Mansehra 384 Aziz Muhammed Habib Ullah Logran Mansehra 385 Mehood Jalal Khan Logran Mansehra

8

No. Name Father/ Husband Name Village District 386 Ms Khursheeda D/O Aman Logran Mansehra 387 M. Jawaid M. Anwar Logran Mansehra 388 Younas Bahadar Logran Mansehra 389 Sabir Hussain Aziz u Rehman Logran Mansehra 390 Younas etc Bahadar Logran Mansehra 391 Aziz Muh,d Habib Ullah Logran Mansehra 392 Younas etc Bahadar Logran Mansehra 393 Sabir Hussain Aziz Logran Mansehra 394 Younas Bahadar Logran Mansehra 395 Mehmood Jalaj Khan Logran Mansehra 396 Asif Anwar M. Anwar Logran Mansehra 397 Asim Saeed M. Saeed Logran Mansehra 398 M. Irshad Bahadar Logran Mansehra 399 Aziz Ullah Logran Mansehra 400 Sabir Hussain Aziz Ullah Logran Mansehra 401 Mehmood Khan Jalal Khan Logran Mansehra 402 M. Sarwar M. Maroof Logran Mansehra 403 M. Mushtaq M. Sarwar Logran Mansehra 404 Ms. Asmat bibi D/ O M. Sarwar Logran Mansehra 405 Mehmood Khan Jalal Logran Mansehra 406 M. Anwar Ali Zaman Logran Mansehra 407 Aurang Zeb Ali Zaman Logran Mansehra 408 Ms Hasan Jana D/ O Ali Zaman Logran Mansehra 409 Nadeem Gul Fam Logran Mansehra 410 M. Sarwar M. Maroof Logran Mansehra 411 Mushtaq M. Sarwar Logran Mansehra 412 Ms. Asmat M. Sarwar Logran Mansehra 413 M. Fareed Akbar Logran Mansehra 414 M. Younas M. Fareed Logran Mansehra 415 M. Banaras M. Akbar Logran Mansehra 416 Mehmood Jalal Logran Mansehra 417 M. Sarwar Maroof Logran Mansehra 418 M. Mushtaq M. Sarwar Logran Mansehra 419 Ms. Asmat bibi M.Sarwar Logran Mansehra 420 Asim Saeed M. Saeed Logran Mansehra 421 M. Basheer Yaqoob Logran Mansehra 422 M. Rasheed M. Ayub Logran Mansehra 423 Muhammad Ameer Logran Mansehra 424 M. Yaqoob Ameer Logran Mansehra 425 Afzal etc Ameer Logran Mansehra 426 Ijaz Ahmad Noor Muhd Logran Mansehra 427 Ms. Ameer Jana W/O Samandar Logran Mansehra 428 Khan Zaman Samandar Logran Mansehra 429 Kahnee Zaman Samandar Logran Mansehra 430 Jawaid Samandar Logran Mansehra 431 Ali Zaman Samandar Logran Mansehra 432 Ms. Sufida Jan D/ O Samandar Logran Mansehra 433 Asif Anwar M. Anwar Logran Mansehra 434 Gohar Aman Sher Aman Logran Mansehra 435 M. Saddiq Sher Zaman Logran Mansehra 436 M. Sarwar M. Maroof Logran Mansehra 437 M. Mushtaq M. Sarwar Logran Mansehra 438 Ms. Asmat M. Sarwar Logran Mansehra 439 Mehmood Khan Jalal Logran Mansehra 440 M. Younas Fareed Logran Mansehra 441 M. Banaras Akbar Logran Mansehra 442 M. Fareed Akbar Logran Mansehra

9

No. Name Father/ Husband Name Village District 443 Asif Anwar M. Anwar khan Logran Mansehra 444 M. Sarwar Logran Mansehra 445 M. Irshad Logran Mansehra 446 M. Ayub Logran Mansehra 447 Yaqoob Logran Mansehra 448 Ms Khursheeda D/ O M. Aman Logran Mansehra 449 Ms. Sheraz D/O M. Aman Logran Mansehra 450 Ms. Sosin Jana W/O M. Ashraf Logran Mansehra 451 M. Ashfaq Ashraf Logran Mansehra 452 Sujjad Ahmad M. Ashraf Logran Mansehra 453 Ms. Nazia D/ O M. Ashraf Logran Mansehra 454 M. Bakhtair Fid Muhd Logran Mansehra 45 Mehmood Khan Jalal Logran Mansehra 456 Asif Anwar M. Anwar Logran Mansehra 457 M. Sarwar M. Maroof Logran Mansehra 458 M. Mushtaq M. Sarwar Logran Mansehra 459 Ms. Asmat Bibi M. Sarwar Logran Mansehra 460 Ms. Khursheed D/O. M. Aman Logran Mansehra 461 Ms. Dur e Shawar D/O A. Aman Logran Mansehra 462 Ms. Bibi Sosin W/O M. Ashraf Logran Mansehra 463 M. Ashfaq M. Ashraf Logran Mansehra 464 Sujjad Ahmad M. Ashraf Logran Mansehra 465 Ms. Nazia D/O Ashraf Logran Mansehra 466 M. Raiz Sultan Muh,d Logran Mansehra 467 Bakhtair Sher Muh,d Logran Mansehra 468 M. Mirag Sarwar Logran Mansehra 469 Mahmood Khan Jalal Logran Mansehra 470 Kala Khan Noor Hussain Logran Mansehra 471 Ms. Noorani Noor Hussain Logran Mansehra 472 M. Sarwar M. Maroof khan Logran Mansehra 473 Mushtaq M. Aman Logran Mansehra 474 Ms. Asmat Bibi D/O M. Aman Logran Mansehra 475 Ms. Khurshada D/o Aman Logran Mansehra 476 Ms Duri Shahwar D/ O Aman Logran Mansehra 477 Mehmood Khan Jalal Logran Mansehra 478 Safia bibi D/O Farmanullah Logran Mansehra 479 M. Irshad M. Anwar Khan Logran Mansehra 480 M. Bakhtair Fida Muhammad Logran Mansehra 481 M. Ayub Noor Hussain Logran Mansehra 482 Maskeen Noor Hussain Logran Mansehra 483 Ms. Bagum D/O Noor Hauuain Logran Mansehra 484 Yaqoob Ali Bahadar Logran Mansehra 485 Kala Khan M. Maskeen Logran Mansehra 486 Maskeen, Shahz Ullah Logran Mansehra 487 Raza Muh,d Sher Bahadar Logran Mansehra 488 Fida Muh,d Sher Bahadar Logran Mansehra 489 Fawaad Afzal Logran Mansehra 490 Akbar Samandar Logran Mansehra 491 Banaras etc Akbar Logran Mansehra 492 Ms. Ameer Jana W/O Samandar Logran Mansehra 493 Khani Zaman Samandar Logran Mansehra 494 Ms. Sufida Jan Samandar Logran Mansehra 495 Shahid Ullah Amir Ullah Logran Mansehra 496 Ms. Sahi Jan W/O Sher Zaman Logran Mansehra 497 Gohar Aman Sher Zaman Logran Mansehra 498 M. Sadiq etc Sher Zaman Logran Mansehra 499 Ms. Anwar Jana D/O Sher Zaman Logran Mansehra

10

No. Name Father/ Husband Name Village District 500 M. Younas Fared Logran Mansehra 501 M. Sarwar Fareed Logran Mansehra 502 Maqsood Sikendar Logran Mansehra 503 Ms Umar Jana Sikendar Logran Mansehra 504 Ms. Mehroza W/o Sikender Logran Mansehra 505 M. Raiz Sultan Logran Mansehra 506 Ms Hassan Jana W/ O Anwar Logran Mansehra 507 M. Jawaid Anwar Logran Mansehra 508 Ms Naseem D/O Anwar Logran Mansehra 509 Aziz Muh,d Habib Ullah Logran Mansehra 510 M. Younas Bahadar Logran Mansehra 511 Ms. Khair un Nisa D/O Bahadar Logran Mansehra

11

12

ANNEX B: QUESTIONNAIRES FOR SOCIOECONOMIC AND CENSUS SURVEYS

SOCIO-ECONOMIC BASELINE SURVEY QUESTIONNAIRE

Date: __________ID No: Moza # Khasra # AP # _____________________________________________________________________ 1. Identification 1.1 Name of Respondent __________________1.2 Father’s Name_______________ 1.3 Status of Respondent Owner ____Tenant____ Share Cropper ____Lease ____ Squatter ____ Other_______ 1.4 Respondent CNIC No: ___________________ 1.5 Tribe _________________ 1.6 Address______________________________________________________________ Settlement: ____________________________ Tehsil: _________________________ District: _______________________________ Tel #: _________________________

1.7 Demographic Profile of Respondent’s Household

Children M ___________ F ___________ Total _____________

No.

Relationship with

Household Head

(HH) (See

codes)

Family Membe

rs

Age

D

isab

ility

Type

(Y

/N)

Educ

atio

n

(See

Cod

es)

Nam

e of

Bu

sine

ss/

Occ

upat

ion

(See

C

odes

)

Inco

me

From

Bu

sine

ss/

Occ

upat

ion

(Rs.

/ An

num

)

Dis

ease

s D

urin

g La

st Y

ear

Main Secondary Main Secondar

y

1 2 3 4

*Other: Rent from property, remittances, net sale of items during a year, net income from agriculture etc.

Demographic Codes:

13

a) Relationship: 1=Self, 2=Wife, 3=Son, 4=Daughter, 5=Father, 6=Mother, 7=Brother, 8=Sister, 9=Grand Father, 10=Grand Mother, 11=Bhabhi, 12=Nephew, 13=Father-in-Law, 14=Mother- in- Law, 15=Others

b) Sex: 1=Male, 2=Female c) Education: 1= Primary 2= Middle 3= Matric, 4= Intermediate, 5= BA/BSc, 6=

MA/MSc, 7=LLB, 8=Engineer, 9=MBBS, 10=Technical Diploma, 11=Dars-e-Nizami, 12=Can Read Quran, 13= Can Insert Signatures, 14= Illiterate,

d) Occupations: 1=Agriculturist, 2=Shopkeeper, 3= Trader, 4= Govt. Servant, 5=Private Servant, 6=Labour, 7=General Labour, 8=Livestock, 9=Fishing, 10= 8=Driver, 11=Health Related, 12=Educator/Teacher, 13=House-Maid, 14= House Wife, 15=Gone Abroad, 16=Gone out City within Pakistan 17 Retired

e) Diseases: 1=Diarrhea, 2=Measles, 3=Hepatitis, 4=Typhoid, 5=HIV/AIDS, 6=Polio, 7=Cholera, 8=Tuberculosis, 9=Heart Disease, 10=No Disease,

2. Average Monthly Expenditure on Food and Non-Food Items 2.1 Monthly Expenditure on Food & Non-Food Items (Rs.)

a) Exp. On Food Items

Sr. No. Item Qty. / Month Expenditure (Rs.)

1. Wheat / Atta (Flour)

2. Maize Flour

3. Ghee

4. Sugar

5. Pulses

6. Vegetables

7. Tea Leaves

8. Milk

9. Other Specify

10. Meat

Total:

b) Exp. On Non-Food Items:

1. Fire wood

2. Gas Cylinder

3. Kerosene Oil

4. Washing Material

5. Shoes and Clothing

6. Medicines

7. Education

8. Social Obligations

9. Others

14

Total:

2.4 Av. Monthly utility bills for: Electricity (Rs.) ________________ Communication (Rs.) __________ Water (Rs.) ___________________

3. Possession of Household Goods

Item No. Value (Rs.) Item No. Value

(Rs.)

Television Car Washing machine Vehicle Geyser Tractor Electric fan Telephone/Mobile Electric iron Electric Water Pump Sewing machine Computer Motor cycle/ scooter Other

Total: 4. Credit 4.1 Have you obtained credit during last year? Yes [ ], No. [ ], if yes, source of

credit: Formal [ ], Informal [ ]

4.2 Please write the name of relevant source Formal source (s) _____________________________________________ Informal source (s) ____________________________________________ Percentage of interest _________________________________________ 4.3 Purpose of Loan (Tick)

Purchase House Rs. _____________

Business Rs. _____________

Repair of House Rs. _____________

Medicare of Family Member Rs. _____________

Family/ Social matters Rs. _____________

Agriculture inputs Rs. _____________

Livestock Rs. _____________

15

Education Rs. _____________

Other (specify) Rs. _____________

4.4 Mode of repayment (Tick the relevant)

1) One time [ ] 2) Through installments [ ], i) Quarterly installments [ ] ii) Six monthly [ ],

iii) Annual [ ] iv) Other (specify) _________

4.5 How much repayment has been made so far? a) 100% [ ], b) 75% [ ], c) 50%

[ ], d) 25% [ ], Less than 25 % [ ], Not paid yet [ ] 5. Housing Conditions 5.1 Do you have your own house? 1) Yes ____ 2) No. ____ If yes then Total Area of the house: square ft/Marla.________ Present Value________Rs.

Type of Room No. of Room Katcha (tick) Pacca (tick)

Semi Pacca (tick)

Living rooms

Verandah

Animal shed

Other shed

Bathroom/Latrine

6. Access to Social Amenities (Tick)

Social Amenities Available Satisfactory Non-Satisfactory Electricity

Sui Gas

Water Supply

16

Social Amenities Available Satisfactory Non-Satisfactory Telephone

Sewerage/Drainage

Health Facility

Education Facility

Others

7 Land Use and Status 7.1 Number of shareholders in ownership ____________ 7.2 Land use arrangement

Self __________ Tenant (tenure of tenancy) ________ years/Months Lease (tenure of lease) ___________ Years/Months Rent (Rs. / acre) ____________ Share Cropper (Arrangements) ___________ Other _______________

Land Acre Kanal Marla

a. Total Area owned b. Total Cultivated Area • Area Under Rabi( winter) Crops • Area Under Kharif (summer) Crops c. Uncultivated Area • Waste land • Area Under Farm Houses • Barren Land

7.3 Cropping Pattern, Yield and Cost

Sr. No. Major Crops

Area Sown Av. Production

(Kgs)

Price/40 kgs (Rs.)

Total Cost Incurred

(Rs.) Acre Kanal

1 Wheat

2 Maize

3 Tobacco

4 Rice

5 Sugarcane

6 Orchards

17

Sr. No. Major Crops

Area Sown Av. Production

(Kgs)

Price/40 kgs (Rs.)

Total Cost Incurred

(Rs.) Acre Kanal

7 Vegetables

8 Other

Grand Total:

8. Livestock Inventory

Livestock No. Present Value (Rs.)

Buffaloes

Cows

Horse

Donkey

Beefarm

Sheep

Goat

Poultry

Other

9. Trees Inventory Fruit Trees _______ Other Trees _______Total _______ 10. Social Organizations 10.1 Are there any existing village/social organizations in your area? _____ (Y/N)

Category Y/N Religious

Educational

Skill Development Centre

Social Welfare

Women Organization

Other

18

10.2. Pattern of Decision Making Which types of decisions are influential in village matters?

Sr.No. Person / Status Decision Pattern % 1 Court

2 Jirga

10.3 Were their decisions considered final and implemented successfully? 1. Yes 2. No

i) Level of acceptability (%) _______ ii) Successful implementation (%)

___________ 10.4 Were you involved in any dispute in the past 01 years? 1. Yes 2. No

10.5 If yes, what was the nature of dispute and how was it resolved Nature of Dispute Method of Resolution 1. ___________________ _____________________________ 2. ___________________ _____________________________ 3. ___________________ _____________________________ 11. Women’s Participation and Decision Making in Different Activities 11.1 Women participation in different household activities:

Activities Participation (y/n) Decision Making (y/n)

Household activities

Jobs

Farm/Crop activities

Livestock rearing

Sale & Purchase of properties

Social obligations (marriage, birthday & other functions)

Local representation (councilor/ political gathering)

Education

Others

19

11.2 Women issues in the project area_____________________________________ 12. Proposed Impact of the Project

Increase Decrease − Employment opportunities − Marketing facilities opportunities − Living standard − Unemployment − Income generating activities − Mobility (Access to Resources) − Quality of drinking water − Agriculture water − Other specify________________________________

12.1 General Remarks of the Respondents

13. Resettlement Part 13.1 Ownership of Affected Structures_____________ (Self/rented/landlord property/relative property

13.2 Affected residential structures

Structures

Types of Construction Total Area (sft) Affected Area

Kacha Pacca Semi Pacca

Sq. ft. Rft.

Houses

Boundary Wall

Ladder

Other

Total

13.2 Impact on Houses

Structures Type of Construction Total Area (Sft)

Affected Area

Kacha Pacca SemiPacca Sq.ft Rft.

Rooms

Cattle Shed

Boundary Wall

20

Structures Type of Construction Total Area (Sft)

Affected Area

Kacha Pacca SemiPacca Sq.ft Rft.

Other

13.3 Impact on Commercial Structures

Structures Type of Construction Total Area Affected Area

Kacha Pacca SemiPacca Sq.ft

Shop

Wooden Cabin

DPC

Iron Cabin

Other

13.4 Impact on Community Structure

Name Type of Affected Structure (room/open area/wall)

Type of Construction Size (Sft)

Schools

Mosque

Graveyard

Health Centre

Shrine

Others

Total:

13.5 Impact on Tube wells Yes ______ No ______ If yes then

Types of Tube wells No.

Electric

Diesel

Turbine

Other

Total:

13.6 Impact on Utility

21

Yes ______ No ______ If yes then

Types Nos. / Area

Electric poles

Transformer

Transmission line

Telephone

Other

Total:

13.7 Miscellaneous Impact of the Project

Types Nos. / Area Hand Pump

Watercourse

Lawn

Other

14. Do you have any alternate residence place? Yes No

If yes then (tick relevant)

House Yes/No Location Distance from

current residence (km) Owned

Tenancy

Relative

Other

15. Vulnerability _____________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________ 16. People concern about the project? _______________________________________________________________ 17. Views / Comments of Interviewers __________________________________________________________________

22

Name & Signature of Interviewer: _______________________ Date: ____________ Checked By: _____________________ Signature ___________ Date: ____________

23

B. QUESTIONNAIRE FOR CENSUS SURVEY

ID # [ ] Date:___________

1. IDENTIFICATION Name of Respondent ___________________________ Father’s

Name

Village/Mouza:_________________

Address_____________________________

2. CATEGORY OF RESPONDENT: Status of Respondent (Tick the relevant):

Resident Owner [ ], Resident Tenant [ ], Resident Owner cum Tenant [ ], Resident Absentee [ ]

Business Owner [ ], Business Tenant [ ], Business Owner cum Tenant [ ], Business Absentee [ ]

Farm HH [ ] Tenant [ ], Owner cum Tenant [ ], Land Owner Absentee [ ]

3. DEMOGRAPHIC PROFILE Total Family member (No.) [_______] Male (No.) [______] Female (No.) [______] Children below 10 years (No.) [______] Male (No.) [______] Female (No.) [______]

Sr. No.

Sex (M / F)

Age (Yrs.) Education

Occupation Monthly Income (Rs.) Other* Annual

Earnings (Rs.)

Source of Other

Income

Main Secondary Main

Occupation

Secondary Occupation

*Other: Rent from property, remittances, pension and other incomes during the year. 3.1. Total Annual Income (Rs.) __________________________

Total Expenditures (Rs.):__________________________________

Total Expenditures on Food items (Rs.):______________________

Total Expenditures on Non-Food Items (Rs.):__________________

24

3.2. Social set-up/ethnicity (castes, tribe, decision making etc.)

____________________________________________________________

4. INVENTORY OF STRUCTURES

Sr. No.

Type of Structure

Nature of

Construction

Size Est. Cost

(Rs.) Remarks L (m) W (m)

5. INFRASTRUCTURE

Sr. No.

Type of Infrastru

cture

Nature of

Construction

Size Est. Cost (Rs.)

Remarks

L (m) W (m)

6. TREES

Sr. No.

Type of Trees

No. of Trees Av. Age

Est. Cost

(Rs. /tree) Total Cost of

the Trees (Rs.)

Remarks

7. LAND

Sr. No.

Land Use Category (such as

agri., barren,

residential, commercial,

other)

Total Land

(acres) Khewat No

Affected Land (acres)

Land Owner-

ship (S/M)

Name of

Owner

Share-holders

(no.)

Cost of Per

Acre

Total Cost of Land (Rs.)

25

8. CROP

No. Name Total Cropped Area (Acre)

Affected Cropped

Area (Acre)

Crop Name Cost of

Crop/ 40kg

Total Cost

of Crop (Rs)

9. EMPLOYEES DESCRIPTION Have you engaged any employ, yes [ ], No [ ], If yes, How many employees do you have (Nos.)? [ ].

No. Name of Employee Average Monthly

Income (Rs.)

Other* Annual Income

Stay at Site (Tick) Total Family

Member (No.)

Male

(No.)

Fem-ale

(No.)

Children

(No.) Alone with Family

*Other: Rent from property, remittances, net sale of items during a year, net income from agriculture etc.

10. DESCRIPTIVE QUESTIONS

1 For this project government need to resettle/relocate you, do you have some other place to move? Yes [ ], No. [ ]

If Yes: 1. How far away from this place? ___________ km

2. Do you own that alternate place Yes [ ], No. [ ]

26

2 MODE OF COMPENSATION

1. Land for Land Compensation: Yes [ ], No. [ ]

2. Compensation by Cash: Yes [ ], No. [ ]

3. Both (Land +Cash): Yes [ ], No. [ ]

Community Perceptions associated with the project and what kind of assistance you expect from the Government/Project?

11. IN CASE OF TENANT: i) Name of Owner: _____________ ii) Name of your Occupation/Business______

iii) Address of Owner _____________________________________________________

iv) Av. Monthly Income of Tenant (Rs.) _______v) Av. Monthly Rent (Rs.) ____

vi) Have you made any investment: Yes [ ], No [ ]

If yes, how much amount you have invested Rs. [ ]

12. GENERAL REMARKS OF THE RESPONDENT: ______________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________

12. GENERAL OBSERVATIONS OF THE INTERVIEWER: ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________

Name & Signature of Interviewer: ___________________________

27

ANNEX C – LOG FRAME FOR RECORDING GRIEVANCES AND MINUTES OF GRC MEETINGS GRIEVANCE REDRESS REGISTERING AND MONITORING FORM

Complainant Information (Person Reporting) 1. Name: 2. Address: 3. National ID: 4. Gender: Male Female 5. Telephone: 6. Email: 7. Fax: 8. Type of complainant:

a Affected person/s b Civil organization c Service organization (e.g., local government institution) d Others (specify)

9. Registration (assigned):

Complaint Details 10. Mode of receiving the grievance:

a Letter b Phone call c Fax d Email e Verbal complaint (walk-in) f Suggestion box g Others (specify)

11. Location of the problem/issue specified in the complaint: a District: b Village: c Address:

12. Type of problem/grievance: a Land acquisition b Compensation c Construction d Others (Specify)

13. Short description of the problem:

14. Short description of the factors causing the problem

15. Past action/s taken by the complainant (if any):

16. Details of the focal point that received the complaint:

28

a Name of the person who received the complaint: b Position: c Name of the receiving office: d Date:

17. Actions taken by the Receiving Office

Action 1 Action 2 Action 3 Action 4

Short Description Short Description Short Description Short Description

Name of Action Officer

Name of Action Officer

Name of Action Officer

Name of Action Officer

Office Office Office Office

Date Date Date Date

18. Final Resolution

Name of the person completing the form:

Signature:

Date:

29

FORMAT FOR RECORDING THE PROCEEDINGS OF

GRIEVANCE REDRESS COMMITTEES

1. Name of the complainant/s:

2. National identification number:

3. Address:

4. Date of the inquiry:

5. Time:

6. Whether complainant participated or not:

7. Grievance or issue (in summary):

8. Statement made by the complainant/s:

9. GRC recommendation:

10. Participants in the GRC:

11. Copies to:

30

ANNEX D - TOR FOR MONITORING AND EVALUATION SPECIALIST External Monitor expert is required to verify and assess the monitoring information relevant to the implementation of this RAP of Islamabad West Grid Station. The external expert will (i) verify the internal monitoring undertaken by PMU; (ii) conduct site visits, (iii) conduct meeting with relevant stakeholders district and provincial authorities involved in land acquisition and review implementation of resettlement activities semi-annually; (iv) review records of compensation payments, verify provision of entitlements to affected people and assess the significance of identified measures in restoring or enhancing AP’s quality of life or livelihood; (v) advise PMU on safeguard compliance issue that arise in connection with the Project and agree on timeline in the conduct of agreed activity; (v) in the event of non-compliance, report to WB any non-compliance identified and recommend corrective actions to be incorporated in the corrective action plan to be prepared by the PMU.. Scope of Work

• To prepare a monitoring and evaluation plan, for review and approval by the PMU and WB. The plan should clearly define the activities and deliverables per reporting, schedule and highlight the scope and strategy of monitoring system, key indicators and methodology in the collection and analysis of data;

• Validate the internal monitoring and reporting of PMU. The external monitor is

expected to review the adequacy of PMU’s internal monitoring and reporting procedure, including the number and qualification of company staff engaged in implementing the RAP at different stages, determine adequacy and integrity of the process, recommend corrective actions and agree on the schedule of implementation of these corrective actions, if necessary;

• Validate the adequacy of public consultation and disclosure of information as designed and described in the RAP. Where necessary, the External Monitor should advise PMU if additional public consultation and disclosure of information need to be undertaken. The External Monitor should validate on ground that appropriate consultations and information disclosure took place;

• Assess the extent to which the entitlement matrix, list of displaced/APs or households (authorized representative of affected households), and specific entitlements such as compensation amount and procedure, are followed including timeliness of payment. The Monitor must closely look into the veracity/correctness of available proof of compensation such as receipt or any other document stating acceptance of compensation by the representative of APs/households;

• Assess the adequacy of income restoration strategy and evaluate the matching of specific livelihood development activities against the needs of the intended recipients/beneficiaries. The External Monitor should document the

31

implementation of each activity and determine effectiveness to affected people including women and vulnerable groups;

• Assess the adequacy of institutional arrangements, specifically the capacity of PMU, the local authorities involved in the land acquisition and resettlement process and other organizations expected to implement the RAP to ensure that the objectives of the RAP and the OP 4.12 are achieved, and suggest necessary enhancement measures, if necessary;

• Validate the adequacy of the GRM and suggest necessary enhancement measures, subject to further public consultations and disclosure, if necessary. Verify on ground the level of awareness of the community within the project impact area on the existing GRM, common issues raised, resolution of each registered case and level of satisfaction of community on the GRM;

• Conduct an interim audit of land acquisition and compensation and resettlement activities for people affected by the Project. As part of the audit, the following will be conducted:

• Socio-economic survey will be undertaken to gather information on the AP's land area, land use including farm and livelihood activities, yield and income derived from the affected land, and APs sources of incomes, etc. prior to the Project taking possession of the land;

• Audit of status of compensation payments, use of funds received by the affected people and current socio-economic living conditions;

• Audit of project impacts on women as well as their needs and concerns and identify any additional potential assistance for women in affected villages;

• An assessment of whether compensation at replacement cost has been paid, whether the livelihoods and standard of living of the APs have been restored and whether all activities implemented are in line with WB’s policy requirements;

• Based on the findings of the audit, the external monitor will prepare a Corrective Action Plan with estimated budget, timeline and implementation arrangements;

• When unanticipated involuntary resettlement impacts are found during RAP implementation, the External Monitor should assess and advise PMU the need to conduct additional social impact assessment and/or updating of RAP, and ensure all existing applicable requirements, entitlements and provisions are followed;

• Document and highlight major problems/issues encountered and lessons learned; • Where necessary, participate in discussion with PMU and among various Project

lenders (such as WB) and its consultants; • The External Monitor will conduct semi-annual site visits, interview affected people

and conduct consultations; • Immediately after completion of RAP implementation, the External Monitor will

undertake a RAP Completion Audit covering all APs. The audit will also be supported by findings of the socio-economic survey which will include data on livelihoods and income levels of affected people that would help to determine whether affected households have been able to restore or improve their socio-economic status compared to the pre-Project level;

32

• In the event that the RAP Completion Audit finds that the objectives of the RAP and the OP 4.12 have not been met, the External Monitor will continue with the quarterly site visits during the duration of the implementation of the Corrective Action Plan; and

• Within 2 years following the completion of RAP implementation (or Corrective Action Plan in case Audit findings show non-compliance), conduct annual site visits to monitor whether affected people have maintained or improved their socio-economic status.

Deliverables The External Monitor will deliver the following reports:

A Monitoring and Evaluation Plan, within one month after appointment Interim Audit Report, within 3 months after completion of land acquisition

compensation payments External monitoring reports In the event that a Corrective Action Plan is prepared following the audit, prepare a

close out report upon completion of CAP implementation. Following completion of RAP/CAP implementation, prepare annual monitoring reports

thereafter. External monitoring reports and all other reports will be submitted simultaneously to PMU and WB. An evaluation report at the end of the project will be prepared with critical analysis of the achievements of the program and performance of the project as well as PMU. Qualification and Experience of Consultant The Consultant will have sufficient technical capacity to provide the above services and the specialists will have a Master degree in social science or relevant field and a minimum of 10 years' experience in dealing with social/community development projects and demonstrated experience in the resettlement monitoring requirements, as per involuntary resettlement/land acquisition, WB's involuntary resettlement operational policy, Pakistan's Land Acquisition Act of 1894, etc.

33

ANNEX E – EVIDENCE OF SURVEYS AND CONSULTATIONS

Coordination and Orientation with Land Revenue officers in their office

Land record and AP identification on Project site with Revenue Staff

Community participation in identification of Project Affected Persons

Field Staff and Revenue Staff checking Land record on site

34

Focus Grup Discussion (FGD) with elected representatives (Nazim, Naib Nazim and councilors of UC Sawan Mira)

Survey Staff Training at local Hotel Manshera

Survey Staff Training at local Hotel Manshera

NTDC Representative Mr Shahzad khan Deputy Director Participating in Survey Staff Training at local Hotel Manshera

35

FGD Village Kashmir Attendance Sheet of FGD Village Kashmir

Nazim UC Sawan Mira Attendance Sheet Nazim UC Sawan Mira

Community / local representatives’ councilors orientation and FGD regarding Sawan maira grid station (Attendance sheet attached)

36

FGD Nakka Village with APs with attendance sheet

Pictures of FGD village Katgran Community orientation meeting data collection and recording their concern

Meeting regarding orientation to Nazim of sawan mera UC (village Council)

Data collection from community members

37

Meeting at Village Bareela Bala and attendance list

Meeting/ FGD village sawan mera community Syedabad

FGD and attendance sheet of meeting with women (village Katgran UC sawan maira)

38

Meeting with District Forest Officer (DFO) Manshera

Consultation in Irrigation Office

Consultation in Wild Life Office Consultation in Land Record Office