1

OPINIÓN CALIFICADA SOBRE EL PLAN PARA LA TRANSFORMACIÓN DE LA EDUCACIÓN DE OAXACA1

(Documento confidencial)

México, D.F., 13 de Julio de 2012 Dra. Antonia Candela Dra. María de Ibarrola Dra. Ruth Mercado Dra. Elsie Rockwell Departamento de Investigaciones Educativas Cinvestav-IPN

!!

!"#$%&'()"*+,$%$('-$*++'-+.-'%+.'('+-'+&('%*/"(#'!)0%+1$+-'+$12!'!)0%+1$+"'3'!'+4.&$"5+

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

!"#$%&'()*$"+,(+-,-.$"%$)/&)*-'()*("+$,"(0"12234"5"0-"6(%%78)"9911"()"()(,$".(":;!:<"=$.(,-.$,>"?0@,(.$".("0-"A$6-"BCDE(F<":"1)@$,'-%78)"6$G,("H$,$6I"-6-'G0(-6"5",(6$0&*7E$6",(+$,*-.$6"+$,"0-"+,()6-"0$%-0"()*,(":;;JK:;!!<"

Calzada de los Tenorios 235, Col. Granjas Coapa, C.P. 14330, México, D.F. Tel. 54 83 28 00, Fax, 56 03 39 57

2

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

3

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

4

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

5

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

6

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

2]T13?=12OU4"2#TB?U1V4"4?9?B?<^""

^"#$%&'()*$"+,(+-,-.$"%$)/&)*-'()*("+$,"(0"12234"5"0-"6(%%78)"9911"()"()(,$".(":;!:<"=$.(,-.$,>"?0@,(.$".("0-"A$6-"BCDE(F<""

7

!<K"Q("*,-*-".("&)".$%&'()*$"0-,M$I".(6$,.()-.$"5",(+(*7*7E$<"Q(")$*-"L&("(6"+,$.&%*$".("E-,7$6".$%&'()*$6"(0-G$,-.$6"+$,".7@(,()*(6"-&*$,(6"5"L&(")$"6("C7F$"&)"(6@&(,F$".(" 7)*(M,-%78)".(" (00$6" %$)@$,'("-"&)"(/(" 08M7%$".("+,$+&(6*-" %0-,-" 5" -,M&'()*-.-<"Y-5" .('-67-.-" 7)@$,'-%78)" L&(I" 67" G7()" *7()(" L&(" E(," %$)" (0" +,$M,-'-I" )$" (6*D",(0-%7$)-.-"-.(%&-.-'()*(<""S76*-.$".("6&(0$6I"076*-.$".("%07'-6I".-*$6"'&5"M()Z,7%$6"6$G,(" 0-"+$G0-%78)".(0"26*-.$I" _`ab".(" 0$6"C-G7*-)*(6"()"-0*-"'-,M7)-%78)c"6$G,("(0"+,(6&+&(6*$" -67M)-.$" -" %$)6*,&%%78)" 5" (L&7+-'7()*$I" -)(R$6" 6$G,(" 0-6" @&()*(6" .("@7)-)%7-'7()*$" @(.(,-0I" ,(@(,()%7-" 7).7@(,()%7-.-" -" d)&(6*,$6" +&(G0$6e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f"5"ag" "%$)67.(,-%7$)(6"()"0-"+-M<":`"5":hg"$G/(*7E$6".(0"+,$M,-'-I"+-M<"^!"5"^:g" (6*,-*(M7-6" L&(" %$,,(6+$).()" -" 0$6" $G/(*7E$6g" )$,'-6" -%*&-0(6" 5" )$,'-6"+,$+&(6*-6I" +-M<" ^J" 5" `;<" _26*(" %&-.,$" ,(6&0*-" (R+,(67E$" 5" %$)E7)%()*(I" +(,$" (6"-)*(%(.7.$"+$,"'&%C-6"$*,-6"",(.-%%7$)(6"L&("0(",(6*-)"@&(,F-I"-.('D6".("L&("+$.,N-"6(," 0-" '-)(,-" .(" 7)*(M,-," U4#4Q" 0$6" $G/(*7E$6" 5" %,7*(,7$6I" L&(" -.L&7,7,N-)" @&(,F-"-,M&'()*-*7E-"()"0-"'(.7.-"()"L&("6("%$'+-,()"%$)"0$6"-%*&-0(6c<""`<K"T)-" E(F".(+&,-.$" (0" *(R*$" ()" 0$" L&(" 6(" ,(@7(,(" -" (6*$6" $G/(*7E$6" 5" %,7*(,7$6I" (6*("+$.,N-" 6(," (0" 7)7%7$" .(0" .$%&'()*$" 5" (0" (/(" %$)@$,'(" -0" %&-0" 6(" $,M-)7F-,N-)" 0-6"67M&7()*(6"+-,*(6<"26"7).76+()6-G0("C-%(,"&)".7-M)86*7%$"+&)*&-0".("0-"67*&-%78)".("0-"7)@,-(6*,&%*&,-" 5" (0" (L&7+-'7()*$" _6(" C-%(" &)-" +,$+&(6*-I" " +(,$" ()" *Z,'7)$6" '&5"M()(,-0(6" 5" E-M$6c" %$)@$,'(" -" 0$6" +,7)%7+-0(6" %,7*(,7$6" +,$+&(6*$6" ()*,(" 0$6" %&-0(6".(6*-%-)>""

-c S-" E7)%&0-%78)" .(" 0$6" .$%()*(6" %$)" 0-" %$'&)7.-." -" *,-EZ6" .(" +,$5(%*$6"(.&%-*7E$6>""(6%$0-,(6"$"%$'&)7*-,7$6g"

Gc 20"@$,*-0(%7'7()*$"5",(6%-*(".(0"*,-G-/$"%$'&)-0"_*(L&7$cg"%c 20"&6$".("'-*(,7-0(6"+,$+7$6".("0-",(M78)"L&(")$"6(-)"0(67E$6"-0"()*$,)$g".c 20".76(P$".("%$)6*,&%%7$)(6"%$)"(6+(%7@7%-%7$)(6"*Z%)7%-6"-.(%&-.-6"-"0-"

.7E(,67.-."%07'D*7%-"5"$,$M,D@7%-".(")&(6*,$"(6*-.$I"%$)67.(,-).$"(0"&6$"

.("*(%)$0$MN-6""-0*(,)-*7E-6"-"0-6"-%*&-0'()*("(6*-G0(%7.-6g"(c S-"*,-)6+-,()%7-"()"(0"&6$"5"-.'7)76*,-%78)".("0$6",(%&,6$6"-67M)-.$6"-"0-"

7)@,-(6*,&%*&,-" .(" 0-" (.&%-%78)" GD67%-I" '(.7-)*(" 0$6" '(%-)76'$6" .("%$)*,$0I"6&+(,E7678)I"E7M70-)%7-"5"@76%-07F-%78)".("*$.$6"0$6"+,$%(6$6<"

"

8

"Q7)" ('G-,M$I" -0M&)$6" " .(" (6*$6" %,7*(,7$6" 6(" L&(.-)" -" )7E(0" .(" .(%0-,-%78)" .("+,7)%7+7$6I"%$'$"+$,"(/('+0$"0$6"67M&7()*(6>"""

7c 26"+,7$,7.-."L&(")&(6*,$6"+&(G0$6"%&()*()"%$)" 7)6*-0-%7$)(6"(.&%-*7E-6"-.(%&-.-6" 5" .7M)-6" +-,-" 0-" ,(-07F-%78)" .(0" +,$%(6$" (.&%-*7E$I" (6*$6"(6+-%7$6".(G()"(6*-,"(L&7+-.$6""()"%$)67.(,-%78)"-"0-6")(%(67.-.(6".("0$6"(6*&.7-)*(6I"0-6"+$67G707.-.(6"L&("G,7).("%-.-"%$)*(R*$"5"%$)",(6+(*$"-"0-"%&0*&,-"5"@$,'-6".("$,M-)7F-%78)".("0$6"+&(G0$6<""

/c B$)6*,&7," 0-" 7)@,-(6*,&%*&,-" .(" -&0-" .(" '(.7$6" 5" 6&'7)76*,-," (0"(L&7+-'7()*$")(%(6-,7$".("-%&(,.$"-"0$6",(L&(,7'7()*$6"-%*&-0(6".(0"&6$".(" 0-" *(%)$0$MN-" '()%7$)-.$6" ()" 0$6" +,$M,-'-6" 5" +0-)(6" .(" (6*&.7$"7)6*7*&%7$)-0(6<`"""

ic B$)6*,&7," 0-" 7)@,-(6*,&%*&,-" .(" G7G07$*(%-6" )(%(6-,7-" +-,-" (0" 7'+&06$" 5"@$,*-0(%7'7()*$" .(" 0$6" +,$M,-'-6" .(" 0(%*&,-" L&(" +,$'&(E()" 0-6"7)6*-)%7-6"7)6*7*&%7$)-0(6<""

"4*,$6"$G/(*7E$6",(6&0*-)".76%&*7G0(6I"()"+-,*7%&0-,"+$,L&(")$"C-5"%$)676*()%7-"7)*(,)-"%$)"0$6"+,$%(.7'7()*$6"+,$+&(6*$6>""

"@c S-"%$)%()*,-%78)".("@&)%7$)(6"()"&)-"6$0-"7)6*-)%7-".()*,$".(0"1)6*7*&*$"

26*-*-0" .("2.&%-%78)"3[G07%-" .("4-R-%-I" L&("+,7$,7%(" 5" .(@7)-" 0-6" $G,-6"L&("6(",(-07F-,D)"-)&-0'()*(g"""

Mc S-" $G07M-%78)" .(0" 26*-.$" .(" +,$+$,%7$)-," -0" !;;b" 0$6" ,(%&,6$6" +-,-"-*().(,"0-6")(%(67.-.(6".("7)@,-(6*,&%*&,-"5"(L&7+-'7()*$"(.&%-*7E$<"

Cc S-" *,-)6+-,()%7-" 5" -+(M$" -" 0-" +0-)(-%78)" L&(" 6(" .(G(" (R7M7," +-,-" 0-",(-07F-%78)".("0-6""$G,-6"L&("6(-)"(/(%&*-.-6"+$,"(0"14B1H2#"%$)@$,'("-"0$6"%,7*(,7$6"(6*-G0(%7.$6<"

"h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g")$"L&(.-" %0-,$" 67" 6(" *,-*-".("&)7.-.(6"L&("-" 6&"E(F"".(+().()"".("0$6"'&)7%7+7$6"()"(6("5"$*,$6"8,.()(6".("0-"-.'7)76*,-%78)"+[G07%-<"""

`"Q7)"('G-,M$"(00$")$".(G("67M)7@7%-,".(6+0-F-,"-"0-"G7G07$*(%-I"%$'$"C-"$%&,,7.$<"U-'+$%$".(G("67M)7@7%-,"&)-"%$'+,-"'-67E-".("0-+*$+6"+-,-"*$.$6"0$6"(6*&.7-)*(6I")7"67L&7(,-"+-,-"*$.-6"0-6"(6%&(0-6".("(L&7+$"L&("6("E&(0E("%-.&%$"()"&)$6"-P$6"%$'$"C-"67.$"+$,"(/('+0$"(0"@,-%-6$".("2)%7%0$'(.7-<""26"+-,*7%&0-,'()*("7'+$,*-)*("(E7*-,"L&("*-0"(L&7+$"7'+07L&("L&("0$6"+-.,(6".("0-"%$'&)7.-."*()M-)"L&("+-M-,"0-6"7)6*-0-%7$)(6"5"'-)*()7'7()*$I"%$'$"C-"6&%(.7.$<"26"7).76+()6-G0("%$)67.(,-,"L&("+,7'(,$"6(".(G(""%$)*-,"%$)"0-6"%$).7%7$)(6"'-*(,7-0(6"GD67%-6I""_6-08)I"(0(%*,7%7.-.I"%$)(%*7E7.-.I"7)%0&6$".(6-,,$00$6"%&,,7%&0-,(6"-.(%&-.$6"+-,-"&)"()@$L&("7))$E-.$,".(6.("0-6"U1B6c"5"%$)"(0"-+$5$"+-,-"0-"@$,'-%78)".("0$6".$%()*(6"()"(0"'-)(/$".("0-6"'76'-6I"5"@7)-0'()*("-0M$".("(L&7+$<"Y-5"$*,-6"+$67G707.-.(6"+-,-"(0"-+,().7F-/(".("0-6"U1BQ"5"(0"&6$".("7)*(,)(*""

"

9

j<""20"076*-.$".("%07'-6"5"6&(0$6"*-0"5"%$'$"-+-,(%("()"(0".$%&'()*$")$"67,E("67")$"6("%$'+0('()*(" %$)" &)-" 7.()*7@7%-%78)" *(,,7*$,7-0" .(" 0$6" '76'$6" ()" 0-" M($M,-@N-" .(0"(6*-.$"&)7.-"-"&)".7-M)86*7%$".(" 0-6" 7)@,-(6*,&%*&,-6".76+$)7G0(6"6(M[)"0$6".76*7)*$6""*(,,7*$,7$6<"20"&6$".("'-*(,7-6"+,7'-6",(M7$)-0(6"5"(0"-+,$E(%C-'7()*$".("0$6"(6+-%7$6"(R76*()*(6" L&(.-)" ()" 67'+0(" .(%0-,-%78)" 67" )$" 6(" @$,*-0(%()" %$)" (0" .7-M)86*7%$"+,$+&(6*$<""f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ch<""""a<KS-6"%7@,-6"+&)*&-0(6"L&("-+-,(%()"()" 0-6"+DM7)-6"!h"-" 0-":^I"6$G,("-&0-6I"-&0-6".("'(.7$6I"G7G07$*(%-6I"6-)7*-,7$6I""5"(L&7+-'7()*$I")(%(6-,7-6"+$,")7E(0"(.&%-*7E$"5"%$6*$".("0-6"2!/2(/*$-*/#*&,$"(2#$%($*#$*$!$4,$(*5()%#*"#+*"-',2#$%-6*)$"6("6-G(".(".8).(" +,$E7()()" )7" %8'$" 6(" -0%-)F-,$)<" #(G(,D)" .(6+,().(,6(" .(0" .7-M)86*7%$")(%(6-,7$<" " 2)" )7)M&)-" +-,*(" .(0" .$%&'()*$" 6(" *,-*-)" .(" '-)(,-" (6+(%N@7%-" 0$6".7@(,()*(6" )7E(0(6" 5" '$.-07.-.(6" (.&%-*7E-6I" .(6.(" &)7.$%()*(6" 5" *(0(6(%&).-,7-6"C-6*-"M,-).(6"(6%&(0-6"&,G-)-6<"

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cI" .(0"%&-0"6("+,(6()*-)" 0$6"-)*(%(.()*(6" @$,'-0(6I"%$'$"TO1B4"_-6N"%$)"'-5[6%&0-6"()"(0"$,7M7)-0c"",(6+$)6-G0(".("0-"7)@,-(6*,&%*&,-"5"(0"(L&7+-'7()*$"5"*$.$"(0"+-+(0"-67M)-.$"-"0-6"%$'&)7.-.(6<""" "" -c"B&D0(6"6$)"0-6"%$'&)7.-.(6"L&("6(",(0-%7$)-)"%$)"(0"1)6*7*&*$""

! B&D0(6" 6$)" 0-6" %$'&)7.-.(6" L&(" -+-,(%()" ()" 0$6" *(,,7*$,7$6" .(@7)7.$6I" *-0"+-,(%(,N-" L&(" 680$" 6(" (6*D" +,(6*-).$" -*()%78)" -" 0-6" F$)-6" ,&,-0(6" ("7).NM()-6".(0"(6*-.$"5")$"-""%$'&)7.-.(6"'D6"M,-).(6"5"'D6"%$'+0(/-6<"

! Y-5" &)-" %$)@&678)" M,-).(" ()*,(" -6-'G0(-6" %$'&)7*-,7-6I" -6-'G0(-6"'&)7%7+-0(6I"-6-'G0(-6"(6%$0-,(6<"

! O$"L&(.-"%0-,$"(0"+-+(0""L&("/&(M-)"0$6"%$)6(/$6".("+-,*7%7+-%78)"6$%7-0"()"0-6"(6%&(0-6I"_Y-6*-"L&Z"+&)*$"(R76*()" 0$6"%$)6(/$6"$"6("%$)@&).()"%$)"0-6"-&*$,7.-.(6cg""

h"2)",(-07.-."(0".$%&'()*$")$"*7()("+-M7)-%78)I"6("$G6(,E-)"-"*,-EZ6".("0-",(M0-".("0-"%$'+&*-.$,-<"

10

Gc""]&Z",(6+$)6-G707.-.(6"5".(,(%C$6"%$)%,(*$6".("0-6"%$'&)7.-.(6"()"%&-)*$"->"

! 20" .76(P$" -,L&7*(%*8)7%$" .(" 0-" %$)6*,&%%78)" (6%$0-," -.(%&-.-" -0"6&(0$I"%07'-"5",(%&,6$6"'-*(,7-0(6<"

! S-6"-+$,*-%7$)(6"+,(6&+&(6*-0(6"L&("6(",(L&7(,-)"! S-6" -+$,*-%7$)(6" ()" *,-G-/$" k" *(L&7$<" _Y-5" *$.$" &)" -+-,*-.$"

6$G,("0-"7'+$,*-)%7-".(""5"(0"+-+(0".(0"*(L&7$I".(0"'-5$,.$'$I".("0-6" @7(6*-6I".(" 0-"X&(0-M&(*F-"+(,$")$"6(" ,(0-%7$)-".7,(%*-'()*("%$)" 0-6" (6%&(0-6" .76+$)7G0(6<" U-'+$%$" C-5" &)-" %,N*7%-" -" 0-6"07'7*-%7$)(6".(0"*(L&7$"5"0-6"*()67$)(6"L&("+&(.("M()(,-,"()"0-6"%$'&)7.-.(6c<"

! S-6"-+$,*-%7$)(6"()"'-*(,7-0(6<"! S-" *,-)6+-,()%7-" ()" 0-" -.L&767%78)" 5" -67M)-%78)" .(" ,(%&,6$6"

0$%-0(6"

\"L&Z"+-+(0"/&(M-"(0"7)6*7*&*$"-0",(6+(%*$<""%c ?"0$"0-,M$".(0".$%&'()*$"5"()"0-".(6%,7+%78)".("0$6"8,M-)$6"()%-,M-.$6I"6("

+7(,.(" 0-" ,(6+$)6-G707.-." %0-,-" +$," 0-" %$)6(%&%78)" .(" .7@(,()*(6" *7+$6" .(",(%&,6$6I" 0-" '7)76*,-%78)" .(" 0$6" '76'$6" -" L&7()(6" 0$6" ,(L&7(,()I" ()"+-,*7%&0-," 0$6" L&(" 7'+07%-)" &)" (/(,%7%7$" .7,(%*$" .(" 0$6" @$).$6g" " 0-"-.'7)76*,-%78)"5" 6(M&7'7()*$".(" 0$6"'76'$6"+-,-"-0%-)F-," 0$6"+,$M,-'-6"+&)*&-0(6I"0-"*,-)6+-,()%7-"()"(0",().7'7()*$".("%&()*-6<"""

"!!<K" ?&)L&(" 6(" .7%(" +$," &)" 0-.$" L&(" (0" (6*-.$" 6(,D" ,(6+$)6-G0(" .(0" " *$*-0" .(0"@7)-)%7-'7()*$" )(%(6-,7$" +-,-" 0-" 7)@,-(6*,&%*&,-" (6%$0-,I" ()" $*,-6" +-,*(6" 6(" -67M)-)",(6+$)6-G707.-.(6" '&5" +&)*&-0(6" -" d0-6" %$'&)7.-.(6eI" ()" 0$" ,(@(,()*(" -" 0-6"%$)6*,&%%7$)(6" _.$*-%78)" .("'-*(,7-0(6I" *,-G-/$" ()" *(L&7$c" 5" -0"'-)*()7'7()*$<" ?CN")&(E-'()*(" 6(" +7(,.()" 0-6" G$).-.(6" .(" 0$6" %,7*(,7$6" 5" $G/(*7E$6" +,$+&(6*$6"-G,7Z).$6(" 0-" +$67G707.-." .(" .(+$67*-," ()" 0-6" %$'&)7.-.(6" 0-" ,(6+$)6-G707.-." .("-+$,*-,"+-,*(".("0$6",(%&,6$6"(%$)8'7%$6"L&(".7@N%70'()*("*7()()"5"L&("0(M-0'()*(")$"0(6" %$,,(6+$).(" +,$+$,%7$)-,<" 2)" -0M&)-" +-,*(" .(0" .$%&'()*$" 6(" (6*-G0(%(" L&(" (0"(6*-.$"(6",(6+$)6-G0("-0"!;;b".("0$6",(%&,6$6"+-,-"0-"(.&%-%78)"+[G07%-I"+(,$"*$.$"0$".('D6"7'+07%-"&)-"7)*()6-"%$0-G$,-%78)".("0$6"%$'&)7.-.(6"L&7()(6"-6&'()"()"'&5"G&()-"'(.7.-"0$6"%$6*$6"()"*,-G-/$"5"'-*(,7-0(6I"-+$,*-%7$)(6".7@N%70(6".("%$)*-G707F-,<"""Q("+,$+$)("6$07%7*-,"-0" M$G7(,)$" @(.(,-0"&)-"-+$,*-%78)" @7)-)%7(,-"+,D%*7%-'()*("`;"E(%(6"'-5$," -" 0-" L&(" 6(" %$)%(.(" -C$,-I" _-&)L&(" )$" 6(" .7%(" 67" 0-6" -+$,*-%7$)(6" 6$)"-)&-0(6"$"6(,D)"+$,"+0-F$6"'-5$,(6c<"\" *-'G7Z)"6("C-G0-".("6$07%7*-,"-+$5$6"-"$*,$6"$,M-)76'$6"%7E70(6<" "Q("*,-*-,N-"()*$)%(6".("&)-"-+$,*-%78)"%$'+0(/-I"%&5-"E7-G707.-.")$" (6*D" -6(M&,-.-" 5" %&5-" .76*,7G&%78)" 6(,D" .7@N%70" .(" C-%(," (L&7*-*7E-'()*(" 5" %$)"*,-)6+-,()%7-I" 6$G,(" *$.$" 67" )$" 6(" %&()*-" %$)" (0" -E-0" 5" 0-" 6&+(,E7678)" .(" %-.-"%$'&)7.-."5".(""0-6"%$'&)7.-.(6"()*,("6N<"""!:K"Q$,+,().("0-"$,M-)7F-%78)"*-)"%$'+0(/-".(0"1)6*7*&*$I"&)-"(6+(%7(".("d%$KM$G7(,)$e"()*,(" 0-" 6(%%78)" ::" 5" 0-6" -&*$,7.-.(6" (.&%-*7E-6" .(0" (6*-.$I" " -" 0-" E(F" L&(" -+-,(%()"@7M&,-6" 67).7%-0(6" )$" %$)$%7.-6" " %$'$" +$," (/('+0$>" d0$6" *Z%)7%$6" .(" 0-" 6(%%78)" ::eg"

11

-.7%7$)-0'()*("6("(6*-G0(%()"E-,7-6" 7)6*-)%7-6"L&("+$.,N-)"%$'+07%-,"5"G&,$%,-*7F-,"(0"+,$%(.7'7()*$I""+(,$"()"+-,*7%&0-,".(6*-%-""0-"-&6()%7-".(""'(%-)76'$6"%0-,$6"+-,-"0-"%$'+0(/-",(0-%78)"%$)"0-6"%$'&)7.-.(6I"+$,"0$"'()$6"()"*,(6"-6+(%*$6>"" Q&" +-,*7%7+-%78)" ()" 0-" E-07.-%78)" .(" 0-" " +,$+&(6*-" .(6.(" (0" +&)*$" .(" E76*-"" d*Z%)7%$e"" Q&"+-,*7%7+-%78)"()"0-"-&*$,7F-%78)"@7)-0"+-,-""(0"&6$".(0"(.7@7%7$"(6%$0-,<"" Q&" +-,*7%7+-%78)" ()" (0" '-)(/$" .(" 0$6" +,(6&+&(6*$6I" .(@7)7%78)" .(" %$6*$6I".(@7)7%78)".(""-C$,,$6"5"(%$)$'N-6<"2)"(@(%*$I"6("'()%7$)-"&)"d-C$,,$"+,(6&+&(6*-0e"+$," (0" &6$" .(" '-*(,7-0(6" ,(M7$)-0(6" 5" 6-G(,(6" 0$%-0(6<" S-" E-M&(.-." .(" (6*-6"+-,*7%7+-%7$)(6"$G6*-%&07F-"0-"*,-)6+-,()%7-"5"(0"&6$"%$,,(%*$".("0$6",(%&,6$6"0$%-0(6<"B$'$"+-,*(".("0-"*,-)6+-,()%7-"(6*$".(G(,D"L&(.-,"'(,7.7-)-'()*("%0-,$<""!^<K2)" (0" -)(R$" 111" 6(" .(6%,7G()" 5" (/('+07@7%-)" +,$+&(6*-6" '&5" 7)*(,(6-)*(6" 6$G,("7)@,-(6*,&%*&,-" 5" (L&7+-'7()*$" .(,7E-.$6" .(" d)&(E-6" +,$+&(6*-6" (%$08M7%-6" 5"6&6*()*-G0(6eI" " 6(,N-" %$)E()7()*(" 6-G(," +$," L&Z" 6&" +,D%*7%-" )$" 6(" C-" M()(,-07F-.$I".-.$"L&("0$6"(/('+0$6"7).7%-)"L&("5-"6("C-)"&6-.$g"")$"6("'()%7$)-"C-6*-"L&Z"+&)*$"6(,D")(%(6-,7$"%-+-%7*-,"-"0-6"%$'&)7.-.(6"()"(00$I"$"67"5-"6$)"6-G(,(6"%$'+-,*7.$6"()"(00-6"5"%8'$"6("+$).,D)"()"/&(M$<""""!`<K" Q(" C-G0-" .(" &)-" @-6(" .(" 6()67G707F-%78)" C-%7-" (0" +,$5(%*$" +-,-" 0$M,-," &)" -0*$"%$'+,$'76$"_+-M<"^hcI"+(,$")$"6("+,(EZ"(0"67M)7@7%-.$".("(6*-"(*-+-I"L&("G7()"+$.,N-",(L&(,7," " &)-" %-+-%7*-%78)" @$,'-0" 5" (0" (6*-G0(%7'7()*$" .(" @$,'-6" .(" $,M-)7F-%78)" $",(6+$)6-G707.-.",(0-*7E-'()*(".&,-.(,-"+$,"(0"+,$5(%*$<"l]&7Z)"6("C-,D"%-,M$".("(00$m"=D6" -.(0-)*(" ()" 0-" +DM7)-" ^a" 6(" '()%7$)-" L&(" 6(" (0-G$,-,D)" 0$6" 07)(-'7()*$6" .("+-,*7%7+-%78)"6$%7-0"5"%$'&)7*-,7-"+-,-"0$6",&G,$6".("6&+(,E7678)I"E7M70-)%7-I"%$)*,$0"5"@76%-07F-%78)"()"(0"&6$".("0$6",(%&,6$6"+[G07%$6"+-,-"0-"7)@,-(6*,&%*&,-"5"(L&7+-'7()*$"(.&%-*7E$<"26*$6"07)(-'7()*$6",(L&7(,()"67)".&.-"0-"+-,*7%7+-%78)".("0-6"%$'&)7.-.(6"5"-"6&"E(F"&)-"%$$,.7)-%78)"()*,("(00-6"5"-0"7)*(,7$,".("0-6"'76'-6<"""!h<K" S-" E7-G707.-." .(" *$.$" (0" +,$5(%*$" .(" )7)M&)-" '-)(,-" 6(" %$'+-M7)-" %$)" 0-6"%$)*7)&-6" C&(0M-6" 5" +-,$6" .(" 0$6" '-(6*,$6g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g" (0" +,$5(%*$" %$)%,(*$" .(" %$)6*,&%%7$)(6" %$)" G-6(" ()"'-*(,7-0(6"0$%-0(6"5""%$)67.(,-%7$)(6"6$G,("(0"&6$".(0"6&(0$"5"(0"%07'-<"26*-".(.7%-%78)"(@(%*7E-"6(,D""0-"G-6(".(0"%$'+,$'76$".("0-6"%$'&)7.-.(6"+$,"-+$5-,"(6*("(6@&(,F$"5".(" " 0-" ,(0-%78)" .(" 0-6" %$'&)7.-.(6" (@7%7()*(" 5" (@(%*7E-" %$)" 0$6" '-(6*,$6" 5" %$)" 0-6"-&*$,7.-.(6"%()*,-0(6<""" " "

""

"B4=2OU?A14Q"Q4nA2"2S"Q1QU2=?"2QU?U?S"#2"H4A=?B1WO"3A4H2Q14O?S"#2"S4Q"

UA?n?o?#4A2Q"#2"S?"2#TB?B1WO"#2"4?9?B?"_Q2H3U24c<""

12

2)"(0"30-)"+-,-" 0-"U,-)6@$,'-%78)".(" 0-"2.&%-%78)".("4-R-%-" _3U24c"6("+,$+$)(" 0-"%,(-%78)" .(" &)" Q76*('-" 26*-*-0" .(" H$,'-%78)" 3,$@(67$)-0" .(" 0$6" U,-G-/-.$,(6" .("2.&%-%78)".(0"26*-.$".("4-R-%-"_Q2H3U24c<"""3S?OU2?=12OU4Q"HTO#?=2OU?S2Q"#2S"Q2H3U24>"*K26*-"+,$+&(6*-"%$7)%7.("%$)"0-6"0N)(-6"M()(,-0(6".(0"Q76*('-"O-%7$)-0".("H$,'-%78)"B$)*7)&-" 5" Q&+(,-%78)" 3,$@(67$)-0" .(" =-(6*,$6" ()" Q(,E7%7$" _QOHBQ3c" .(" %-,D%*(,"@(.(,-0"_Q23I":;;acI""()"%&-)*$"-0"+0-)*(-'7()*$".("&)"676*('-".("@$,'-%78)"+-,-"0$6"'-(6*,$6"5"-" 0-")(%(67.-.".("L&("*-)*$"-")7E(0")-%7$)-0"%$'$"(6*-*-0"6("-,*7%&0()"0-6".7@(,()*(6" 7)6*7*&%7$)(6"5"+,$M,-'-6".(.7%-.$6"-" 0-" @$,'-%78)"%$)*7)&-".(".$%()*(6"L&("*,-G-/-)"6(+-,-.-'()*(<""KQ("-@7,'-"L&(""(0"+,$@(67$)-0".("0-"(.&%-%78)"p(6"-L&Z0"L&("6("6&6*()*-"()"&)-"*($,N-"+-,-"C-%(,".$%()%7-"(" 7)E(6*7M-%78)"+(.-M8M7%-"+$,L&(" 0("-5&.-"-"-,*7%&0-,"(0" 6-G(,"+()6-,I" (0" 6-G(," %$)$%(,I" 6-G(," C-%(," 5" (0" 6-G(," *($,7F-,<p" 3$," *-)*$I" 0-" @$,'-%78)".$%()*(".(G("-*().(,I"6(".7%("()"(0".$%&'()*$I""-"*,(6"(6@(,-6>"""p20" 6-G(," +(.-M8M7%$I" (0" 6-G(," '&0*7.76%7+07)-,7$" _(+76*('$0$MN-I" +(.-M$MN-I"6$%7$0$MN-I"-)*,$+$0$MN-I"0-"@70$6$@N-"5"0-"Z*7%-c"5"(0"6-G(,"7)E(6*7M-*7E$I"L&("6("6&6*()*-"()" 0-" (+76*('$0$MN-" .(" 0-" +,$G0('-*7F-%78)" (" 7).-M-%78)<<<p" S-6" *,(6" (6@(,-6" .(" 0-"@$,'-%78)"(6*-,D)"-,*7%&0-.-6""-"0-"%&0*&,-"%$'&)7*-,7-pI"6(M[)"0-"+,$+&(6*-<"""""KH,()*("-"0-"+(,6+(%*7E-".("0-",(@$,'-"()"'-,%C-"+-,-"0-"@$,'-%78)".$%()*("7)7%7-0"()"7)6*7*&%7$)(6")$,'-0(6I"L&("+0-)*(-" 0-" @$,'-%78)"()"%$'+(*()%7-6".("-%&(,.$"%$)" 0-",(@$,'-"-"0-"(.&%-%78)"GD67%-".(":;;JI"-'G-6"+,$E()7()*(6".("0-"?B2I"()"(0"Q2H3U24"6("+,$+$)()"*,(6"+0-)*(-'7()*$6"+,7)%7+-0(6>"qU$'-,"%$'$"(/(")(%(6-,7$".("0-"@$,'-%78)".("'-(6*,$6>"0-"$,7()*-%78)".("0-"p*($,N-"5"0-6"+(.-M$MN-6"%,N*7%-6p"_+<::".(0".$%&'()*$"-)-07F-.$c<"q1)%$,+$,-,"-"0-"@$,'-%78)""7)7%7-0"5".("'-(6*,$6"()"6(,E7%7$"(0"(6*&.7$".(".76%7+07)-6"%$'$>" pS-" @70$6$@N-I" 0-" Z*7%-I" 0-" 6$%7$0$MN-I" 0-" +(.-M$MN-I" 0-" (+76*('$0$MN-I" 0-"-)*,$+$0$MN-p"_+-M<":!I"7G7.c<"qQ&6*()*-,"0-"@$,'-%78)"5"(0"*,-G-/$".$%()*("()"0-"7)E(6*7M-%78)K-%%78)"_+-M<":!I"7G7.c<"""B4=2OU?A14Q>"*78* 9'#)'(* "#+* 5(5#+* '#$%)(+* 0,#* #+* :;<=>;?* +#* (/!4$(* (* +(* !$1#/%!4('!3$* #$* +(*&-)2('!3$*.*#+*#@#)'!'!-*"-'#$%#8**S-" 7)E(6*7M-%78)" 6$G,(" 0-" @$,'-%78)" 7)7%7-0" 5" %$)*7)&-" .(" '-(6*,$6" ()" +-N6(6" %$)"(R+(,7()%7-6".("6&%(67E-6",(@$,'-6"-"M,-)"(6%-0-I"C-%("*7('+$"C-)"-0(,*-.$"6$G,("0-6"07'7*-%7$)(6".(0"+0-)*(-'7()*$" 6$G,("(0" p.$%()*(" 7)E(6*7M-.$,p" %$'$"(/("-,*7%&0-.$,".(" 0-" @$,'-%78)" .$%()*(" ()" (.&%-%78)" GD67%-<" 2)" =ZR7%$" *-'G7Z)" @&(" %&(6*7$)-.-I"*-)*$" +$," '-(6*,$6" @$,'-.$,(6" .(" .$%()*(6" %$'$" +$," (6*&.7$6$6" .(0" %-'+$I" (6*-"+(,6+(%*7E-"-.$+*-.-"()"(0"+0-)".("(6*&.7$6".("0-"(.&%-%78)")$,'-0".("!Ja`<""2)" (0" .(G-*(" 6$G,(" (6*(" *('-I" 6(" ,(%$)$%(" 0-" E-07.(F" .(" L&(" 0$6" +,$@(6$,(6" +&(.-)"+0-)*(-,6("0-"7)E(6*7M-%78)"%$'$"&)-"$+%78)"+,$@(67$)-0I"$"L&("+&(.-)"&6-,0-"+-,-"0-"+,D%*7%-"7)@$,'-.-".("6&"*,-G-/$<"Q7)"('G-,M$I"6("%&(6*7$)-"L&("()"0-"@$,'-%78)"5"()"(0"(/(,%7%7$".(" 0-"()6(P-)F-"6(" 7)%0&5-)")(%(6-,7-'()*("-%*7E7.-.(6"$,7()*-.-6"C-%7-"

13

0-" 7)E(6*7M-%78)I" 6&+(,+&(6*-6" -" 0-6" L&(" C-)" .(" .(6-,,$00-," 0$6" +,$@(67$)-0(6" .(" 0-".$%()%7-<"""S-" -0*-" %$'+0(/7.-." L&(" ,(+,(6()*-" (0" (/(,%7%7$" .(" 0-" +,$@(678)" .$%()*(" _H&00-)" 5"Y-,M,(-E(6I"":;;;c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p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r680$r" 6(," '-(6*,$" )$" (6"6&@7%7()*(<" 26*$" 7'+07%-" &)-" E(0-.-" .(E-0&-%78)" .(" 0-" .$%()%7-" @,()*(" -" 0-"7)E(6*7M-%78)p"_=(,%-.$I"!JJ`>ac<"""dS-6" *-,(-6" .(" 0$6" '-(6*,$6" 6$)" .7@(,()*(6" .(" 0-6" *-,(-6" .(0" 7)E(6*7M-.$,e" _#N-F"n-,,7M-I"()"A$.,NM&(FI":;;h>"j`c<""pS-"@7M&,-"%$)$%7.-"%$'$"(0"d.$%()*("K"7)E(6*7M-.$,e"$"(0"d+,$@(6$,"7)E(6*7M-.$,".("6&"+,$+7-"+,D%*7%-e"sG-6-"(6-6"%$)%(+%7$)(6"()t"0-6"+$0N*7%-6"(.&%-*7E-6"L&("C-)"*,-*-.$".("'(/$,-," 0-"%-07.-.".(" 0-"(.&%-%78)" "%$)"0-"+,$+&(6*-".("L&(" 0$6"+,$@(6$,(6"C-M-)"7)E(6*7M-%78)I" " G-/$" (0" 6&+&(6*$" .(" L&(" C-5" 7'G,7%-%7$)(6" )-*&,-0(6" ()*,(" 0-"7)E(6*7M-%78)"(.&%-*7E-"5"0-"()6(P-)F-".("%-07.-.<"U-'G7Z)"G-6-)"6&6"-,M&'()*$6"()"0$6"0N'7*(6"*-)"%$)@&6$6"()*,("0-"*($,N-I"0-"7)E(6*7M-%78)"5"0-"+,D%*7%-"(.&%-*7E-I"L&("6(".(@7().(" -%*&-0'()*(" %$'$" r7)E(6*7M-%78)" k-%%78)r<" " 20" %&,,N%&0&'" .(" !Ja`" +-,-" 0-"@$,'-%78)".("+,$@(6$,(6".("+,7'-,7-""()"(0",(%7Z)".(%,(*-.$"")7E(0".("07%()%7-*&,-"6("G-68" ()" (6*(" +,7)%7+7$" L&(" *&E$" L&(" 6(," '$.7@7%-.$>" &)-" %$6-" (6" L&(" 0$6" .$%()*(6"%$)$F%-)" 0-" 7)E(6*7M-%78)"5"$*,-" %$6-"(6"L&(" 0-" *()M-)"L&(" ,(-07F-,"+-,-" 6(,"G&()$6".$%()*(6<p"_#("1G-,,$0-I":;;J>::c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

14

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g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p67'+0(6"*Z%)7%$6p"%$'$" 6&(0(" 6&M(,7,6(g" " 0-" +,$@(678)" .$%()*(" (/(,%7.-" +0()-'()*(" *-'G7Z)" 7'+07%-"-+$,*-,"-"0-"*,-)6@$,'-%78)"6$%7-0"()"*Z,'7)$6".("0$M,-,"-+,().7F-/(6"67M)7@7%-*7E$6"()"0$6"-0&')$6I"0$"%&-0"0(6"+(,'7*7,D"-+,$+7-,6(".("+,$.&%%7$)(6"%&0*&,-0(6"5"%7()*N@7%-6"-"0-6"L&("(00$6I" ()" *$.$6" 0$6" ,7)%$)(6".(0"+-N6" *7()()".(,(%C$<" " Q&+$)(,"L&(" %$)" p680$"()6(P-,p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ajg"?M&70-,I":;;^g""A$%iu(00I":;;^g""2F+(0(*-I"o<"5"v(766I":;;;g""U$,,(6I":;!;c"L&("&)$".("

15

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c" 5" +-,-" -%*&-07F-,6(<" ?" *$.$" (00$" ()" (0".$%&'()*$".(0"Q2H3U24"6("-M,(M-"(0"L&("0$6".$%()*(6",(-07%()"7)E(6*7M-%78)K-%%78)<""Q$G,("(6*("*('-I"U$,,(6"6(P-0->""

d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p"_U$,,(6I":;;;>!;c<"

"A('7*7,6("-0"%$)$%7'7()*$"+,$.&%7.$"+$,"0-"7)E(6*7M-%78)"+-,-"@$,*-0(%(,"0-"@$,'-%78)".("0$6"+,$@(6$,(6I")$"0$6"%$)E7(,*("()"'()$6",(@0(R7E$6"5"%,N*7%$6".("6&"+,D%*7%-"5".("0-6"+,$+&(6*-6"L&("0(6"00(M-)I"+$,"(0"%$)*,-,7$I"0(6"-+$,*-"(0('()*$6"+-,-"@$,*-0(%(,"0-",(@0(R78)"5"0-"%,N*7%-<"20"L&("0$6"+,$@(6$,(6"6(-)"p&6&-,7$6p".("0-"7)E(6*7M-%78)I"*Z,'7)$"-0"L&("6&(0("-67M)D,6(0("&)-"%$))$*-%78)")(M-*7E-I")$"0$6"C-%("'()$6"%,(-*7E$6")7"0$6"%$)E7(,*("()"+,$@(67$)-0(6".("6(M&).-I"'D6"G7()"-+$5-"6&"-%*&-07F-%78)"+(,'-)()*(<""""#("C(%C$I"*$.$6"6$'$6"&6&-,7$6".("0-"7)E(6*7M-%78)"5"(6$")$")$6".('(,7*-"%$'$"6(,(6"+()6-)*(6" 5" +,$@(67$)-0(6" -%*&-07F-.$6g" " 7)%0&6$" L&7()(6" '-5$,'()*(" &6-)" 0-"7)E(6*7M-%78)I" 6$)" 0$6" 7)E(6*7M-.$,(6" '76'$6I" " +(,$" *-'G7Z)" 0$6" 'Z.7%$6" 5" *$.$"+,$@(67$)-0"L&(",(L&7(,-"(6*-,"-%*&-07F-.$g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c" .(G()" (6*-," ()" 0-" G-6(" .(" 0-"@$,'-%78)"%$)*7)&-"5"-%*&-07F-%78)I"GD67%-'()*(""'(.7-)*("(0"7)*(,%-'G7$"C$,7F$)*-0"'D6" L&(" ,(%&,,7().$" -" +,D%*7%-6" .(" 7)E(6*7M-%78)<" S-" -%*&-07F-%78)" .$%()*(" ()*,("+-,(6I" ()" 0-6" [0*7'-6" .Z%-.-6" 6(" C-" 7.()*7@7%-.$" 7)*(,)-%7$)-0'()*(" %$'$" 0-" 'D6"+,$.&%*7E-I" 0-"L&("*7()("0&M-,"()"0$6"%$0(%*7E$6"(6%$0-,(6I"5-"6(-"()*,("(0"+(,6$)-0".("&)-" $" .(" E-,7-6" (6%&(0-6<" 2)" 0$6"'(/$,(6" %-6$6I" " 6$)" 0$6" +,$+7$6" +,$@(6$,(6" L&7()(6".(@7)()"(0"%$0(%*7E$I" 7.()*7@7%-)"6&6")(%(67.-.(6I" " 0$6"+,$G0('-6"+(.-M8M7%$6"L&(" 0$6"%$)E$%-)"5" ,(%&,,()"+-,-" ,(6$0E(,0$6" -" 6&"+,$+7-" (R+(,7()%7-I" -" 0-" ,(+$,*-.-"+$," 0-"7)E(6*7M-%78)I" -6N" %$'$" -" 0-" .(" +(,6$)-0" (6+(%7-07F-.$" L&(" (00$6" .(*(,'7)-)" 5" L&("+&(.("(E()*&-0'()*("-6(6$,-,0$6<""

16

"26(" *7+$" .(" +,D%*7%-6" .(" -%*&-07F-%78)" %$0(M7-.-" 6$)" 00(E-.-6" -" %-G$" +$," 0$6"+,$@(67$)-0(6" .(" $*,$6" %-'+$6" 5" (6" -0" +-,(%(," -" 0$6" .$%()*(6" -" L&7()(6" )$" 6(" 0(6",(%$)$%(" (6-" +$67G707.-." .(" -&*$)$'N-" +,$@(67$)-0<" " 2)" (0" +,$+7$" .$%&'()*$" 6(",(+$,*-)" p(6@&(,F$6" -760-.$6" .(" '-(6*,$6" L&(" C-)" .(%7.7.$" -*().(," 6&" @$,'-%78)"+(,'-)()*(" .(6.(" 6&6" %()*,$6" (6%$0-,(6" -*().7().$" -" 6&6" )(%(67.-.(6" ,(-0(6" .("@$,'-%78)" 5" 6(+-,-.$6" .(" 0-" %()*,-07F-%78)" 5" ,(0-%78)" .7,(%*-" %$)" (0" +,$M,-'-" .("B-,,(,-"=-M76*(,7-0"()"$%-67$)(6"-%$'+-P-.$6"+$,"-6(6$,(6".(0"B()*,$".("=-(6*,$6p"_Q2H3U24>"Jjc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c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w(6I"()*,("$*,-6<"""C8* 9)%!',+('!3$* "#* +(* &-)2('!3$* '-$* #+* #$%-)$-* '-2,$!%()!-* .* 5+($%#(2!#$%-*5#"(434!'-8*"2)"%&-)*$"-"0-"E7)%&0-%78)"()*,("0-"@$,'-%78)"5"0-"%$'&)7.-.I" "L&("6("+,$+$)("%$'$"%()*,-0" ()" (0" Q2H3U24I" " 6(,N-" )(%(6-,7$" (6+(%7@7%-," %8'$" 0-6" p*,(6" (6@(,-6" .(" 0-"@$,'-%78)" _(0" 6-G(," +(.-M8M7%$I" (0" '&0*7.76%7+07)-,7$" " 5" (0" 7)E(6*7M-*7E$c" (6*-,D)"-,*7%&0-.-6" -" 0-" %&0*&,-" %$'&)7*-,7-p" 5" -%0-,-," L&Z" 67M)7@7%-" 0-" -6N" 00-'-.-" p%&0*&,-"%$'&)7*-,7-p"L&("(6*D"0(/$6".("6(,"C$'$MZ)(-<""""

17

2)"-0M&)$6"+-6-/(6".(0".$%&'()*$I"0-",(.-%%78)"(6"+-,*7%&0-,'()*(".7@&6-I"+$,"0$"L&(",(6&0*-".7@N%70".70&%7.-,"-"L&Z"6(",(@7(,("%$)" 0-"p+(.-M$MN-"%,N*7%-p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p@70$6$@N-")($07G(,-0<p" "U-'G7Z)" " 6(,N-")(%(6-,7$"L&(" 0-"+,$+&(6*-"-0*(,)-*7E-" 6("(R+07%7*-,-"()"*Z,'7)$6" %$)%,(*$6I" -.('D6" .(" " p@$,'-," &)" +,$@(6$," %,(-*7E$I" ,(@0(R7E$" 5" %,N*7%$"%$'+,$'(*7.$"Z*7%-"5"6$%7-0'()*("%$)" 0-" *,-)6@$,'-%78)".(" 0$6"+&(G0$6p"_Q2H3U24>":!c"5".("-M,(M-,"$"6&6*7*&7,"'-*(,7-6"-0"%&,,N%&0$".("0-"@$,'-%78)"7)7%7-0<"""Q$G,(" (6(" -6+(%*$I" )$" (6" (R*,-P$" L&(" '&%C$6" .$%()*(6" L&(" (6*D)" E7E7().$" 0$6"+,$%(6$6"5-"7)7%7-.$6"+$,"(0"3U24",(+$,*()"%$)@&67$)(6"5"6(P-0()"L&(")$"%$'+,().()".("L&Z"6(" *,-*-)"p0-" *($,N-"5" 0-6"+(.-M$MN-6"%,N*7%-6p" "5"()"L&Z"%$)676*(",(-0'()*(" 0-"+,$+&(6*-"-0*(,)-*7E-"L&("6("0(6"+7.("00(E-,"-"0-"+,D%*7%-<"20"'76'$".$%&'()*$",(+$,*-I""%$'$",(6&0*-.$".("&)-"(R+0$,-%78)"()*,("'-(6*,$6I""L&("6("7.()*7@7%-,$)"*,(6"+$6*&,-6"+,7)%7+-0(6"6$G,("(6*-"%&(6*78)>""KS-" .(" -0M&)$6" 6(%*$,(6" .(" .$%()*(6" p+,($%&+-.$6" +$," 6(M&7," " 6$G,(" *$.$" ()" 0$".76%&,67E$"0-6"0N)(-6"*(8,7%-K+(.-M8M7%-6"*,-F-.-6"+$,"(0"$,M-)76'$"(.&%-*7E$"67).7%-0"67)"E760&'G,-,"-[)"0-"'(*-p"_6&G,-5-.$")&(6*,$c<"KS-".("$*,$6"6(%*$,(6".$%()*(6"L&("p7)*()*-)"%$'G7)-,"(0"&6$".("'-*(,7-0(6"(.&%-*7E$6"sx-)*(,7$,(6" -" 0-" A(@$,'-" 1)*(M,-0" -" 0-" 2.&%-%78)" nD67%-" %$)" 0$" +$%$" L&(" +&(.()"'-)(/-,".(0".76%&,6$"67).7%-0p"_6&G,-5-.$")&(6*,$c<"KS-" .(" &)" 6(%*$," 'D6" pL&(" -0" )$" E(," &)-" +(,6+(%*7E-" %0-,-" 6(" -%(,%-)" 'D6" " -" 0-6"+,$+&(6*-6".("0-",(@$,'-p"_QH3U24>"`;c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g" "26*,-.-I":;!!c<"*D8*E!$',+('!3$*#$%)#*&-)2('!3$*.*#1(+,('!3$*#*!$'#$%!1-/*"-'#$%#/8*"2)" (0" Q2H3U24I" %$'$" $%&,,(" " -" )7E(0" )-%7$)-0I" 6(" C-)" 6&+(,+&(6*$" +$0N*7%-6" .("@$,'-%78)" .$%()*(" %$)" +,$M,-'-6" .(" (E-0&-%78)" 5" (6*N'&0$6" .(6*7)-.$6" -0"

18

+,$@(6$,-.$g"6$)"%$)$%7.-6"0-6"%$)6(%&()%7-6")(M-*7E-6".("(6-"6&+(,+$67%78)<"3$,"6&"+-,*(" 0$6" '-(6*,$6" C-)" '$6*,-.$" L&(" )$" )(%(6-,7-'()*(" G&6%-)" '(/$,-," 6&"+,(+-,-%78)"+,$@(67$)-0" %$)" 0-"[)7%-"'$*7E-%78)".(0" (6*N'&0$"(%$)8'7%$I" -6+7,-%78)"+$,"$*,$"0-.$"7))(M-G0('()*("0(MN*7'-<"S-" E7)%&0-%78)" $G07M-.-" ()*,(" '(/$,-'7()*$" +,$@(67$)-0I" (E-0&-%78)" (" 7)%()*7E$6".$%()*(6" *-0" %$'$" 6(" C-" (6*-G0(%7.$" ()" )&(6*,$" +-N6I" C-" *,-N.$" %$)67M$" (@(%*$6"+(,E(,6$6I" 0$6"%&-0(6"6("-M,-E-)"%&-).$"-"(6*$6"(0('()*$6"6("-M,(M-" 0-" 7)*(,E()%78)".(" $,M-)76'$6" 5" %,7*(,7$6" 67).7%-0(6" .76*-)*(6" .(" 0$6" +,$@(67$)-0(6" L&(" .(G()"+,(E-0(%(,"()"(0"'(/$,-'7()*$".("0-"@$,'-%78)"%$)*7)&-".("0$6"'-(6*,$6<""""Q(,N-"%$)E()7()*(",(E76-,"0$6"-6+(%*$6"-,,7G-"%7*-.$6"()"&)"+0-)"-0*(,)-*7E$I""5-"L&("-0".(6%,7G7," p20" @&)%7$)-'7()*$".(0" Q2H3U24p" _++<" j:Kffc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g" " ()" 0-" 6(%%78)" .(0" .$%&'()*$" .()$'7)-.-" pH&)%7$)-'7()*$" .(0"Q2H3U24p" 6(" $'7*(" 0-" %$)67.(,-%78)".(0" *('-<" 1)%0&6$"+-,(%(,N-" 7'+$,*-)*(" L&(" 0-6"'76'-6" 7)6*7*&%7$)(6" @$,'-.$,-6" +&.7(,-)" %$)*,7G&7," -" 0-" (0-G$,-%78)" .(" &)-"+,$+&(6*-" -0" ,(6+(%*$" 5" +-,*7%7+-," ()" 0-6" .76%&67$)(6" 6$G,(" 0-" @$,'-%78)" 7)7%7-0" 5"%$)*7)&-".("'-(6*,$6<"""

19

A(0-%7$)-.$"%$)"(6*("+&)*$I"()"(0"Q2H3U24"6(,N-")(%(6-,7$"-'+07-,"0-",(E7678)".("0$6"+$6M,-.$6" ()" (.&%-%78)" (R76*()*(6" ()" (0" (6*-.$I" ,()M08)" L&(" %$)6*7*&5(" &)-" .(&.-"+().7()*(" %$)" (0" '-M76*(,7$<" S-6" $@(,*-6" .(" +$6M,-.$6" +-,-" (6*(" 6(%*$," 6&(0()" 6(,"$)(,$6-6" 5" .(" .&.$6-" %-07.-.I" 67*&-%78)" -'+07-'()*(" %$)$%7.-" ()" (0" (6*-.$<" 2)" (6("-6+(%*$"(0"Q2H3U24"+$.,N-"+,$+$)(,6("&)-"0N)(-".("*,-G-/$I",(6+-0.-).$"+$,"(/('+0$"-" 0-6" +,$+7-6" 7)6*7*&%7$)(6" @$,'-.$,-6" (R76*()*(6" ()" (0" (6*-.$" ()" 0-" G[6L&(.-" .("%$)E()7$6" &" $*,-6" -0*(,)-*7E-6" .(" @$,*-0(%7'7()*$" 5" -'+07-%78)" .(" 0$6" +$6M,-.$6" .("%-07.-."()"(.&%-%78)<""

!D&C"F%IJM&O!IA!OMO%"CI!W"!"EIAXIDM`F!"WXDI%MEI!W"!&IaIDI!KO""&L!

!A-!5/05*,4.-!1,!,4.,!O'4.,6-!4,!5/,4,(.-!,(!*(!10)*6,(.0!1,!bc!5T3'(-4!N*,!'()#*+,B!

[? X(-!5/,4,(.-)'2(!,(!#-!N*,!4,!)0(4'1,/-!N*,!#-!5/05*,4.-!1,!,:-#*-)'2(!,1*)-.':-!5-/-!&-<-)-!4,!)0(4./*+-!1,41,!#-!,4)*,#-!+!#-!)06*('1-1!+!N*,!:-#0/,!#-!5/T).')-!10),(.,!,(!4*!)0(.,<.0!+!#-!1'4)*4'2(!)/>.')-!N*,!-50+,!#-!;0/6-)'2(!5,1-323')-?!

U? X(-!9*4.';')-)'2(!5,/.'(,(.,!,(!#-!N*,!4,!)*,4.'0(-(!#-4!5/05*,4.-4!1,!,:-#*-)'2(!,1*)-.':-!N*,!/,;*,/S-(! #-!)065,.,()'-!+!(0!)0(4'1,/-(! #-!1':,/4'1-1!50/! #0!N*,!;06,(.-(! #-!1'4)/'6'(-)'2(7!5-/-!5#-(.,-/!N*,!,#!O""&!/,450(1,/T!-!*(!5/0+,).0!,1*)-.':0!N*,!8*4N*,!4,/!6T4!9*4.0!+!,N*'.-.':0!.06-(10!,(!)*,(.-!#-!1':,/4'1-1!)*#.*/-#!1,#!,4.-10?!

d? X(04! -(.,),1,(.,4! N*,! /,4*#.-(! Q.'#,4! 50/! 1,.-##-/! #-4! 1';,/,(.,4! ;0/6-4! 1,!,:-#*-)'2(! ,1*)-.':-! N*,! ,(!C@<')0! 4,! R-(! '65#,6,(.-10! 1,41,! 5/'()'5'04! 1,#!4'3#0!aa?!

e? A-!;*(1-6,(.-)'2(!)0(),5.*-#!8-4.-(.,!,<.,(4-!,(!#-!N*,!106'(-(!,#!\1,8,/!4,/Y!+! #04! 8*,(04! 1,4,04! 4'(! )0(4'1,/-)'0(,4! -),/)-! 1,! )260! ##,:-/! -! )-80! *(-!,:-#*-)'2(! \1'-#23')-7! /,;#,<':-7! @.')-7! 4'4.,6T.')-7! ;0/6-.':-! ,! '(.,3/-#Y7! ,(./,!0./-4! )-/-).,/>4.')-4! )060! N*,! 4,-! )',(.>;')-7! 5-/.')'5-.':-7! )0#,).':-7!)0(.,<.*-#'S-1-7!)*-#'.-.':-=)*-(.'.-.':-!+!R0#>4.')-?!!!

f? X(-! 1,4)/'5)'2(! 1,! #-! 05,/-.':'1-1! 1,#! O""&! 1,! dU! 5T3'(-47! N*,! ,4! #-! 5-/.,!4*4.-(.':-!1,#!O'4.,6-7!,(!#-!N*,!4,!'()#*+,(!,(#'4.-104!5/T).')-6,(.,!,<R-*4.':04!1,! .010! #0!N*,!4,!,:-#*-/>-7! )260!4,! /,-#'S-/>-7! )0(!N*@!601-#'1-1,47! .@)(')-4!,!'(4./*6,(.04!#-!/,-#'S-/>-(!#04!1';,/,(.,4!)0#,).':04?!A-!;0/6-!,(!#-!N*,!4,!)0()/,.-!#-!,:-#*-)'2(!,(!,4.-!4,))'2(!/,4*#.-!.0.-#6,(.,!'(05,/-8#,!,(!#-!5/T).')-?!

g? X(! 0/3-('3/-6-! 1,! *(-! W'/,))'2(! 1,#! O""&! N*,! /,5/,4,(.-/>-! *(! -5-/-.0!-16'('4./-.':0! -#.-6,(.,! )04.040! +! N*,! ##,:-/>-! -! '()/,6,(.-/! #-! ,4./*).*/-!8*/0)/T.')-!1,!#-!,1*)-)'2(!1,!&-<-)-!4'(!8,(,;')'04!-)-1@6')04!50/!),(./-/4,!,(!*(-!.-/,-!(0!1'/,).-6,(.,!;0/6-.':-?!!

!!D&C"F%IJM&OB!!I?! A-! 5/05*,4.-! 1,#! O'4.,6-! 1,! ":-#*-)'2(! "1*)-.':-! 5-/-! ,#! "4.-10! 1,!&-<-)-! ,4!6*+!'650/.-(.,!)060!-#.,/(-.':-!)0(4./*'1-!1,41,! #-!,4)*,#-!+! #-!)06*('1-1!5-/-!-50+-/! #-!

20

5/T).')-!10),(.,!1,!-)*,/10!-!#-4!)-/-).,/>4.')-4!)0(.,<.*-#,4!1,!,4.*1'-(.,4!+!10),(.,4!1,!&-<-)-?!"4.T!8',(!4*4.,(.-1-!,(!)*-(.0!-!-45,).04!,4,()'-#,4!5-/-!,:'.-/!#-!'(,N*'1-17!#-!6-/3'(-)'2(!+! #-!1,4-)/,1'.-)'2(!1,! #04!-).0/,4!,1*)-.':04?!I#3*(04!1,!,4.04!-)',/.04!;*(1-6,(.-#,4!40(!#04!4'3*',(.,4B!

-? h*,!#-!,:-#*-)'2(!.06,!,(!)*,(.-!#-4!)0(1')'0(,4!1,!./-8-90!10),(.,!+!,#!)0(.,<.0!40)'0)*#.*/-#!1,!#-!,4)*,#-!+!#04!-#*6(04?!

8? h*,! #04! -).0/,4! ,1*)-.':04! +! #-! )06*('1-1! 1,)'1-(! )*T#,4! 40(! #04! )/'.,/'04! -!,:-#*-/!1,!6-(,/-!N*,!4,!/,#-)'0(,(!)0(!*(!5/0+,).0!1,!6,90/-6',(.0!,1*)-.':0?!!

)? h*,! #-! ,:-#*-)'2(! 4,! )0()'8-! )060! *(! '(4./*6,(.0! 5-/-! -50+-/! *(! 5/0),40! 1,!1'T#030! +! /,;#,<'2(! 408/,! #-! 5/T).')-! ,1*)-.':-! 0/',(.-10! R-)'-! ,#! '65*#40! -! *(!5/0+,).0!,1*)-.':0!1,60)/T.')07!;0/6-.':0!+!1,!,N*'1-1?!

!$-/-! 1,;,(1,/! ,4.-! 504')'2(7! ,4! )0(:,(',(.,! N*,! #04! 10)*6,(.04! 1,#! $#-(! '()#*+-(! *(-!4,))'2(! N*,! 6*,4./,! ,(! N*@! 6,1'1-! +! ,(! N*@! 4,(.'104! #-4! /,-#'1-1,4! #0)-#,4! (0! 40(!)0(4'1,/-1-4!,(!#-4!5/05*,4.-4!0!'(4./*6,(.04!1,!,:-#*-)'2(!(-)'0(-#,4?!!i?!A04!)*,4.'0(-6',(.04!-!#04!4'4.,6-4!1,!,:-#*-)'2(!'65#,6,(.-104!50/!#-!O"$!,(!#-!ID"!+! ,(! "(#-),! 40(! )0//,).04! 5,/0! 4,! 501/>-! /,;0/S-/! 4*! ;*(1-6,(.-)'2(! +-! N*,! (0! 4,!,45,)';')-(!#-4!)-*4-4!50/!#-4!N*,!4,!)-/-).,/'S-(!)060!'(-1,)*-104?!KD-(1,#-7!UcceL!!!D?! A04! 5/0524'.04! +! #-4! )-/-).,/>4.')-4! 1,#! O""&! N*,! 4,! 1,4)/'8,(! ;0/6-#6,(.,! 40(!-1,)*-104?!O'(!,68-/307!-#!5-4-/!-! #-!05,/-.':'1-1!4,!R-),!*(!1,45#',3*,!,<R-*4.':0!1,!N*@7! )2607! )0(!N*'@(7! -! N*'@(! +! )*T(10!,:-#*-/! K)*-1/04!1,! #-4! 5-34?! Uf! -! ef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j,(,/-/!*(-!)065*#4'2(!,:-#*-.':-!N*,!.',(,!'65-).0!408/,!#04!10),(.,4!+!! !! !!!-#*6(04!,(!)*-(.0!-! ./-8-9-/!5-/-! #-4!5/*,8-4!,(!:,S!1,!),(./-/! #-!5/T).')-!,(!! !!!./-8-90!5,1-323')0!;0/6-.':0?!A-!5/,.,(4'2(!1,!N*,!#-!,:-#*-)'2(!4,-!! !! !! !!!5,/6-(,(.,!-3*1'S-!,#!5/08#,6-?!! =!j,(,/-/!*(-!-).'.*1!)065,.'.':-!,(./,!-#*6(047!)0#,3-4!10),(.,4!+!,4)*,#-4!N*,!! !!!50)0!)0(./'8*+,!-!#-!)0#-80/-)'2(!(,),4-/'-!5-/-!6,90/-/!#-!)-#'1-1!,1*)-.':-?!!

21

"4.,!,4!*(!5*(.0!),(./-#!+-!N*,!'65*#4-/!*(-!)*#.*/-!1,!#-!,:-#*-)'2(!,(!:,S!1,!)*#.*/-!1,!#-! )-#'1-1! ,1*)-.':-! 8-4-1-! ,(! *(! 5/0+,).0! ,1*)-.':0! )0(! 5/0524'.04! ;0/6-.':04!-)-1@6')-!+!)*#.*/-#6,(.,!.',(,!,#!/',430!1,!)0(:,/.'/!,#!6,1'0!,(!*(!;'(?!!!!IO$"D%&O!I!D&FOMW"JIJB!!+

[? F6+78+9:;+<=7>=;?@=<6+AB6C8767+<=D8B8;>87+8;+E:+<=7C@7=F;+G+AE:;8:C=F;+<8+E:+*$$"+H@8+A8BI=>:;+J:E6B:B+AB=6B=<:<87+G+CB=>8B=67+<8+:AE=C:C=F;?!-L $J:E@:C=F;+ <=:?;F7>=C:! )0(! ,#! 5/0524'.0! 1,! 1,.,/6'(-/! +! 9,/-/N*'S-/! #04!

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aDIA"?! ! %-68'@(! ,4! #-! '(.,()'2(! 1,! $MOI7! -*(N*,! #04! ,;,).04! 1-104! 50/! ,#!/-(k'(3!1,!#04!5->4,4!R-!.,('10!)0(4,)*,()'-4!-1:,/4-4?!!!

!8L $J:E@:C=F;+ @;=J8B7:E! K-! :,),4! ##-6-1-! 1,! \R'3R! 4.-k,4Y! 0! 1,! )0(4,)*,()'-4!

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

!)L );J87>=?:C=F;+KL7=C:+G+:AE=C:<:!1'4,G-1-!5-/-!,()0(./-/!,<5#')-)'0(,4!1,!#04!

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

22

!MN -:+8J:E@:C=F;+<8E++<878IA8O6+<8+E67+<6C8;>87+87+@;+AB6C876+8P>B8I:<:I8;>8+

C6IAE=C:<6+!-L -:+ 8J:E@:C=F;+ <8E+ <878IA8O6+ =;<=J=<@:E+ <8+ E67+ I:87>B67! ,4! *(! 5/0),40!

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l,47! 1,!6'3/-(.,47!.,#,4,)*(1-/'-47!.@)(')-47!5/,=,4)0#-/,47!,.)?!,.)?L!)-1-!*(-!)0(!4*4!5/05'-4!)-/-).,/>4.')-4!+!5/08#,6T.')-4!-!,:-#*-/!+!-!-50+-/7!-4>!)060!#-!3/-(!)-(.'1-1! 1,! 5/03/-6-4! 1':,/404! N*,! 1,6-(1-(! #-! 5-/.')'5-)'2(! 1,! #04!10),(.,4!1'4./-+@(10#04!1,!4*4!5/'()'5-#,4!.-/,-4!,1*)-.':-4?!!

!8L $J:E@:C=F;+ A6B+ 8E+ B8;<=I=8;>6+ <8+ E67+ 87>@<=:;>87B! X(0! 1,! #04! 5/08#,6-4!

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

!)L $J:E@:C=F;+A6B+J:E6B+:?B8?:<6?!A-!40#*)'2(!-#!5/08#,6-!-(.,/'0/!K8L!N*,!4,!R-!

,<5,/'6,(.-107!-*(N*,!,4!6T4!1';>)'#7!)0(4'4.,!,(!8-4-/! #-!,:-#*-)'2(!1,! #04!10),(.,4! 5-/)'-#6,(.,! ,(! *(-! ,:-#*-)'2(! 1,#! \:-#0/! -3/,3-10Y! 1,#!1,4,65,G0!1,! #04! -#*6(04! -! #0! #-/30!1,! )-1-! -G0!,4)0#-/?! "4.0! ,47! /,-#'S-/!*(-!,:-#*-)'2(!1'-3(24.')-!1,#! )0(0)'6',(.0!1,! #04! -#*6(04! -#! '(')'0!1,!*(!-G0!,4)0#-/!+!*(-!,:-#*-)'2(!-#!;'(-#!1,#!-G0!,4)0#-/!5-/-!1,.,/6'(-/!,#!\:-#0/!N*,! #,4! R-! -3/,3-10Y! #-! ,4)0#-/'S-)'2(! ,(! )*-(.0! -! )0(0)'6',(.04! +!

23

)065,.,()'-4?! "##0! ;-:0/,),/>-! -! -N*,##04! 10),(.,4! N*,! #03/-(! \4-)-/!-1,#-(.,Y!-!3/*504!5/08#,6T.')047!+!1,!5-40!-!#04!1'/,).0/,4!N*,!)0(4'3*,(7!)060!4,!1'),7!\#,:-(.-/!*(-!,4)*,#-Y?!!F0!084.-(.,7!.-650)0!,4.T!,<,(.-!1,!5/08#,6-47! 5*,4! /,4*#.-! 6*+! 1';>)'#! 1'4,G-/! 5/*,8-4! 5/,! +! 504.! N*,! 4,-(!/,-#6,(.,! \,N*':-#,(.,4Y! +! (0! 4,! 5*,1,! -5#')-/7! 4,3Q(! #-4! (0/6-47!,<-).-6,(.,!#-!6'46-!5/*,8-!104!:,),4?!$0/!0./-!5-/.,7!4',65/,!R-+!)',/.04!,9,4!+!)065,.,()'-4!;*(1-6,(.-#,4!N*,!(0!4,!5/,4.-(!-!4,/!,:-#*-104!50/!#04!,<T6,(,4! ./-1')'0(-#,47! 50/! ,9,65#07! #-! )-5-)'1-1! 1,! /,1-))'2(! 0!)06504')'2(!#'8/,?!

!1L $PLI8;87+ <8+ C6;6C=I=8;>67+ :C:<QI=C67+ <8+ E67+ <6C8;>87?! X(! 4,3*(10!

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

!,L $J:E@:C=F;+A6B+6K78BJ:C=F;+<=B8C>:+8;+:@E:?! A-! '(:,4.'3-)'2(!-#! /,45,).0!(0!

6*,4./-! *(-! )#-/-! )0//,#-)'2(! ,(./,! ,#! 8*,(! 1,4,65,G0! 10),(.,! ,(! #-!5/T).')-! +! 4*4! /,4*#.-104! ,(! #-4! ,:-#*-)'0(,4! -)-1@6')-4! ,(! 5-5,#?! "##0! R-!##,:-10!-!1'4,G-/!;0/6-4!1,!,:-#*-)'2(!1,#!1,4,65,G0!-)-1@6')0!50/! #-!:>-!1,! #-! 084,/:-)'2(! 1'/,).-! 1,#! ./-8-90! 1,! #04! 10),(.,47! 6,1'1-! N*,! 4,! ,4.T!'(')'-(10!,(!(*,4./0!5->4?!"#!5/060:'10!50/!,#!i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

;L $J:E@:C=F;+ A6B+ RA6B>:D6E=67Y?! "4.0! 4,! R-! *.'#'S-10! .-(.0! 5-/-! ,:-#*-/! #04!-:-(),4! 1,! #04! -#*6(047! )0(4,/:-(10!*(-!6*,4./-! 1,! 4*4! ./-8-904! ,(! )-1-!

24

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

25

4,(.'1-! 1,6-(1-! 40)'-#! 1,! N*,! #-! ,1*)-)'2(! ,4)0#-/! #03/,! N*,! #04! 92:,(,4!,:'.,(! ,()-6'(-/4,! R-)'-! #-4! 1/03-4! +! .,(3-(! *(-! 4-(-! ,1*)-)'2(! 4,<*-#^!]D260!,:-#*-/!,#!#03/0!1,#!5/03/-6-!(-)'0(-#!1,!#,).*/-!,(!)06*('1-1,4!,(!N*,!(0!R-(! ##,3-10! #04! #'8/04!1,! #-!8'8#'0.,)-!,4)0#-/^!]D260! #03/-/!N*,! #04!-5/,(1'S-9,4!1,! #04!-#*6(04!5,/1*/,(!6T4!-##T!1,! #-!,4)*,#-^!$/,3*(.-4!1,!,4.,! .'50! /,N*',/,(! *(! ./-8-90! 6*+! ),/)-(0! -! #-4! )0(1')'0(,4! /,-#,4! 1,!;*()'0(-6',(.0!1,!#-4!,4)*,#-4!,(!)-1-!)'/)*(4)/'5)'2(!#0)-#!0!/,3'0(-#?!!

!TN %6+78+9:;+C6;7=<8B:<6+E67+8D8C>67+K@B6CB:>=U:;>87+<8+E:+CB8:C=F;+<8+@;+:A:B:>6+

87>:>:E+<8+8J:E@:C=F;+;=+ E:7+A67=KE87+:E>8B;:>=J:7+<8+@;+AB6?B:I:+<8+8J:E@:C=F;+H@8++;6+B8H@=8B:+E:+=;7>:E:C=F;+<8+@;+;@8J6+FB?:;6+:<I=;=7>B:>=J6+!-L C*)R-! ,:'1,()'-! )',(.>;')-! -:-#-! #-! .,(1,()'-! -! ,4.-8#,),/! 6,)-('4604! 1,!

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

!8L F0! 084.-(.,7! R-+! .,(1,()'-4! 5/,0)*5-(.,4! ,(! .010! ,4;*,/S0! 1,!

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

!)L "(! ,4,! 4,(.'107! )0(4'1,/-604! N*,! 4,/>-! '650/.-(.,7! -*(N*,! .-68'@(! *(!

5/0+,).0! )065#')-10! ,(! )*-(.0! -! 4*! 1'4,G0! +! 3,4.'2(7! '(.,3/-/! 3/*504!/,3'0(-#,4!K#-!*('1-1!.,(1/>-!N*,!1,)'1'/4,!,(./,!S0(-47!6*(')'5'047!)0(9*(.04!1,! ,4)*,#-47! ,.)?L! )065*,4.04! 1,! 1';,/,(.,4! -).0/,4! 40)'-#,4! 1,#! 4'4.,6-!,1*)-.':0! +! 1,! #04! 5-1/,4! 1,! ;-6'#'-! +! #-4! )06*('1-1,47! -)065-G-104! 1,!

26

)0#-80/-10/,4! )0(! )0(0)'6',(.0! 1,! 5/0),1'6',(.04! )*-(.'.-.':04! +!)*-#'.-.':04! 1,! ,:-#*-)'2(! 1,! -#3*(-! '(4.'.*)'2(! -)-1@6')-! 0! &Fj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

!

OmF%"OMO!W"!MW"IO!D"F%JIA"O!!

[? X(-!1,!#-4!)-/-).,/>4.')-4!1,!#-4!,4)*,#-4!1,!&-<-)-7!)060!#-4!1,!0./04!,4.-1047!,4!#-!1,!R,.,/03,(,'1-1!40)'0)*#.*/-#!+!1,!1':,/4'1-1!,(!6Q#.'5#,4!-45,).04!50/!,40!,4! '650/.-(.,! N*,! *(! 5#-(! ,1*)-.':0! 5-/-! .010! ,#! ,4.-10! 5#-(.,,! #'(,-6',(.04!3,(,/-#,4! ;#,<'8#,4! N*,!5,/6'.-(!1,4-//0##04! #0)-#,4! -#.,/(-.':04! -1,)*-104! -! #04!1';,/,(.,4!)0(.,<.04?!!

!U? O,/>-!)0(:,(',(.,!N*,!5-/-!-80/1-/!#04!1'4.'(.04!5/08#,6-4!N*,!)0(4'1,/-!,#!$#-(!

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

!d? X(-! )-/-).,/>4.')-! 1,! .010! ,#! 10)*6,(.0! ,4! #-! 1,! 5/050(,/! 5#-(.,-6',(.04!

3,(,/-#,4!N*,!(0!4,!6-(.',(,(!)*-(10!4,!)0()/,.-(!#-4!5/05*,4.-4?!$0/!,9,65#07!-*(N*,! *(-! 0/',(.-)'2(! ),(./-#! 1,#! 10)*6,(.0! ,4! #-! 1,! 0.0/3-/! ;*,/S-! -! #04!)0#,).':04!10),(.,47!#-!;0/6-!)060!4,!)0()/,.-(!-#3*(-4!1,!#-4!5/05*,4.-4!5*,1,(!)0(1*)'/!6T4!8',(!-!*(!/,;0/S-6',(.0!1,!#-!-*.0/'1-1!4'(1')-#?!

!e? "4!(,),4-/'0!N*,!,(!.010!,#!10)*6,(.0!4,!6-(.,(3-(!,#!5-5,#!1,!#-4!)06*('1-1,4!

,(! #-! .06-! 1,! 1,)'4'0(,4! 408/,! #04! 5/03/-6-4! 1,! -50+0! )06*('.-/'07! ,(! #-!

27

;'4)-#'S-)'2(!1,#!*40!1,! #04!/,)*/404!,4.-.-#,4!+!;,1,/-#,4!-4'3(-104!-! #04!1':,/404!5/03/-6-4! +! 5/0+,).047! )060! 40(! ,(./,! 0./04! #04! 1,! '(;/-,4./*).*/-7! -4>! )060!5-/.')'5-/! ,(! #-! 3,4.'2(! +! ,(! #-! 4*5,/:'4'2(! 5-/-! N*,! 4,! )*65#-(! )0(! #-4! .-/,-4!,1*)-.':-4!1,!#-!,4)*,#-?!

!f? "(! ,#! )*/40! 1,! #-! /,,#-80/-)'2(! 1,#! 10)*6,(.07! ,(! /,#-)'2(! -#! $/03/-6-! 1,!

M(;/-,4./*).*/-! +! "N*'5-6',(.0! "1*)-.':07! .,(1/T! N*,! N*,1-/! )#-/-6,(.,!,4.-8#,)'10!K.-#!:,S!,(!2/3-(04!5-/'.-/'04L!.-(.0!#-!/,450(4-8'#'1-1!1,#!,4.-10!,(!,#!6-(,90!+!-50/.-)'2(!1,#!5/,4*5*,4.0!)060!#04!6,)-('4604!1,!5-/.')'5-)'2(!,(!#-!05,/-)'2(7! ;'4)-#'S-)'2(! 1,! #04! /,)*/404!+! ,(! #-+ >6I:+ <8+ <8C=7=6;87V! 1,! #04!)0#,).':04! )06*('.-/'04! +! 1,! #04!6-3'4.,/'-#,4! K(0! )060! /,5/,4,(.-(.,4! 1,#!4'(1')-.0L7! N*,! 40(! #04! 6T4! 1'/,).-6,(.,! '(.,/,4-104! ,(! ,#! 1'4,G0! 1,! #04!,4.-8#,)'6',(.047! )0(! 6-.,/'-#,4! +! )0(0)'6',(.04! #0)-#,47! +! ,(! ,#! 6-(,90!-1,)*-10!+!./-(45-/,(.,!1,!#04!/,)*/404?!

!g? D0(4'1,/-604!N*,!,4! '650/.-(.,!N*,!,(! .01-4! #-4!6,1'1-4!)0()/,.-4!4,!0.0/3*,!

6T4! -*.0(06>-! -! #04!6-,4./04!5-/-!N*,! /,-#'),(! #-! .-/,-! 4*4.-(.':-!1,!,(4,G-/?!!"4.0!.-68'@(!.',(,!#*3-/!,(!-#3*(04!1,!#04!5->4,4!;*,/.,4!,(!#-!&"DW?!$-/-!N*,!#04!10),(.,4! 5*,1-(! ),(./-/4,! ,(! 4*! .-/,-! -)-1@6')-! ,4! )0(:,(',(.,! N*,! 4,! #,4!1,4)-/3*,!1,!.-/,-4!-16'('4./-.':-47!1,!-50+0!-!5/03/-6-4!:-/'047!1,! ./-8-90!,(!,:-#*-)'0(,4!+!,(!5/03/-6-4!40)'-#,4!+!)06*('.-/'04?!

!n? $-/,),! '65/,4)'(1'8#,! N*,! ,(! ,#! $#-(! 4,! '()#*+-! *(! '(:,(.-/'0! 1,! #-4! 6,90/,4!

,<5,/',()'-4! ,1*)-.':-4!N*,! 4,!R-(! /,-#'S-10!,(!,#! ,4.-10!-! #0! #-/30!1,! -G04! -4>!)060!1,!#04!5/0+,).04!#0)-#,4!6T4!,<'.0404?!"4.04!5/0+,).04!5*,1,(!4,/!*(!5*(.0!1,!5-/.'1-!5-/-!0/',(.-)'0(,4!5,1-323')-4!8T4')-4!N*,!5*,1-!3,(,/-#'S-/4,!,(!,#!,4.-10! +! N*,! 5,/6'.-(! ;0/6-4! -#.,/(-.':-4! 1,! )0()/,)'2(! 4,3Q(! #-4! 1':,/4-4!)-/-).,/>4.')-4!)0(.,<.*-#,4?!

!b? "4!(,),4-/'0!N*,!*(!$#-(!,1*)-.':0!5-/-!&-<-)-!)060!,4!,4.,!'()#*+-!#'(,-6',(.04!

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

!o? "4!'650/.-(.,!,4.*1'-/!#-!)0(:,(',()'-!1,!N*,!,#!$#-(!4,!-5#'N*,!,(!,.-5-4!4,3Q(!

5/'0/'1-1,4!+!#04!/,)*/404!1'450('8#,4?!!![c?!$/050(,604!N*,!4,!,4.*1',!#-!)0(:,(',()'-!1,!1':'1'/!,#!,4.-10!,(!5,N*,G-4!S0(-4!

.,//'.0/'-#,4!N*,! '()#*+-(!*(!(Q6,/0! /,1*)'10!1,!,4)*,#-4! K-5/0<'6-1-6,(.,![c!,4)*,#-4!N*,!5*,1,(!4,/!6T4!0!6,(04!4,3Q(!5/0<'6'1-1!;>4')-!+!)*#.*/-#L7!)0(!4*4!6-,4./047!-*.0/'1-1,4!,1*)-.':-4!+!6',68/04!1,!#-4!)06*('1-1,4!/,45,).':-47!N*,!5,/6'.-!*(!'(.,/)-68'0!5/01*).':0!5-/-B!

28

= p-),/! *(-! ,:-#*-)'2(! 1'-3(24.')-! 408/,! *(! 5/08#,6-! ,1*)-.':0! 8T4')0! 1,! #-!S0(-?!

= W'4,G-/! )0#,).':-6,(.,! *(! 5/0+,).0! ,1*)-.':0! 0/',(.-10! -! /,40#:,/! #-!5/08#,6T.')-!1,.,).-1-!/,.06-(10!#-4!,<5,/',()'-4!,4.-.-#,4!N*,!6T4!-50/.,(!-#!/,45,).0?!

= $#-(.,-/! /,*('0(,4! ,(./,! 10),(.,4! 5-/-! -(-#'S-/! -/.>)*#04! 1,! '(:,4.'3-)'2(! ,!'(:'.-/! ,45,)'-#'4.-4! N*,! -50+,(! #-4! -#.,/(-.':-4! 5-/-! 4*5,/-/! #04! 5/08#,6-4!5#-(.,-104?! "4.-4! /,*('0(,4! 5*,1,(! 05,/-/! )060! 5/0),404! 1,! ;0/6-)'2(! 1,!6-,4./04!,(!4,/:')'0?!!

= O0#')'.-/!-50+04!1,!'(;/-,4./*).*/-!:'()*#-104!-#!5/0+,).0!,1*)-.':0!1'4,G-10?!= ":-#*-)'2(!1,#!5/0+,).0!,1*)-.':0!,(!4*4!1'4.'(.04!-45,).04!+!1,!#04!1';,/,(.,4!

5-/.')'5-(.,4B! ,:-#*-)'2(! 1,! :-#0/=-3/,3-107! )0=,:-#*-)'2(7! ,:-#*-)'2(!)*-(.'.-.':-!+!)*-#'.-.':-!408/,!.010!,(!/,#-)'2(!-#!5/08#,6-!N*,!4,!5/,.,(1>-!/,40#:,/?!

= "4.>6*#04! -! #04! 5-/.')'5-(.,4! ,(! ,#! 5/0+,).0! ,1*)-.':0! )*-(10! 4*4! /,4*#.-104!4,-(!4-.'4;-).0/'04?!

![[?!!P'(-#6,(.,!)0(4'1,/-604!)0(:,(',(.,!N*,!,#!10)*6,(.0!4,-!6T4!4'(.@.')07!!! 6,(04! /,5,.'.':0! ,! '1,0#03'S-107! ,4.0! ,47! N*,! 4*4! 5#-(.,-6',(.04!! 0/',(.-10/,4! 4,! )0//,450(1-(! )0(! #-4! 5/05*,4.-4! 5*(.*-#,4! ,(! )-1-! *(0! 1,! #04!! .,6-4!-80/1-104?!!!

!

"""n1nS14XA?Hy?"""?M&70-,I" B7*0-007" _!JJhc" d20" *,-G-/$" (R*,-()6(P-)F-" 5" 0-" %$)6*,&%%78)" 6$%7-0" .(" 0-"

(6%&(0-e" ()" A$%iu(00I" 2067(" _B$$,.<c" !"# $%&'$("# &)*+,+"-"I" H$).$" .(" B&0*&,-"2%$)8'7%-"_HB2cI"=ZR7%$<"

D-(1,#-7!I?!KUccfL?!";,).0!1,!#-4!,:-#*-)'0(,4!,4.-(1-/'S-1-4!,(!#04!4'4.,6-4!,1*)-.':04?!!"#$%&'(')&*+,&%-."#'UeK[LB!ef=fe?!

#(" 1G-,,$0-I" " =-,N-" _:;;Jc" B$)@(,()%7-" 7'+-,*7.-" ()" (0" 9" B$)M,(6$" O-%7$)-0" .("1)E(6*7M-%78)" 2.&%-*7E-" +$," 7)E7*-%78)" .(0" D,(-" !!<" 1)E(6*7M-%78)" .(" 0-"1)E(6*7M-%78)" 2.&%-*7E-<" " B$)6(/$" =(R7%-)$" .(" 1)E(6*7M-%78)" 2.&%-*7E-I"V(,-%,&FI"=ZR7%$I"6(+*7('G,(".(":;;J<"""

2)%7)-6I" ?G(0" _:;!!c" !)%# &)($&*+.)%# ,$# /0)1$%)0$%# &)2)# &)2'-+,",$%# ,$# /03&*+&"4#$%/"&+)%# ,$# 1)02"&+5-# ,)&$-*$<" U(676" .(" #$%*$,-.$I" #(+-,*-'()*$" .("1)E(6*7M-%7$)(6"2.&%-*7E-6".(0"B()*,$".("1)E(6*7M-%78)"5".("26*&.7$6"?E-)F-.$6".(0"1)6*7*&*$"3$07*Z%)7%$"O-%7$)-0"_#12KB1OV2QU?VK13OcI"=ZR7%$<"

26*,-.-I"3(.,$"_:;;Jc"6)02"&+5-#+-+&+"(#$-#("#7)02"(4#&)-%*0'&&+5-#,$#%+8-+1+&",)%#,$#2"$%*0)%# 9# $%*',+"-*$%# $-# ("%# /03&*+&"%# /0$%$0.+&+)<" #(+-,*-'()*$" .("1)E(6*7M-%7$)(6"2.&%-*7E-6".(0"B()*,$".("1)E(6*7M-%78)"5".("26*&.7$6"?E-)F-.$6".(0"1)6*7*&*$"3$07*Z%)7%$"O-%7$)-0I"_#12KB1OV2QU?VK13OcI""=ZR7%$<"

2F+(0(*-I" o&6*-" 5" 2.&-,.$" v(766" _:;;;c" :"2;+"0# ("# $%&'$("# 0'0"(<# =."('"&+5-#&'"(+*"*+."# ,$(# >0)80"2"# /"0"# ?;"*+0# $(# @$A"8)# =,'&"*+.)<" #(+-,*-'()*$" .("

29

1)E(6*7M-%7$)(6"2.&%-*7E-6".(0"B()*,$".("1)E(6*7M-%78)"5".("26*&.7$6"?E-)F-.$6".(0"1)6*7*&*$"3$07*Z%)7%$"O-%7$)-0"_#12KB1OV2QU?VK13OcI"=ZR7%$"

H&00-)I" =7%C-(0" 5" ?).5" Y-,M,(-E(6" _:;;;c" !"# $%&'$("# B'$# B'$0$2)%<" Q(%,(*-,N-" .("2.&%-%78)"3[G07%-"_Q23cI"n7G07$*(%-"+-,-"0-"-%*&-07F-%78)".(0"'-(6*,$I"=ZR7%$<"

j#-S,/6-(7!O?!q!I##'40(!O,';*##-R7!I?!KUc[cL!!$'/"#01#-.2$'23'-4&'5&#%4&*'!6"#$%&7&$-')*28*#7'95!):'.$';4.%#82<'=&#*'5>2'?7,#%-'@&,2*-A'DR')-30B!C-.R,6-.')-!$0#')+!/,4,-/)R7!M()?!

Y70-,7$I" O-)%5" _:;!!c">0)&$%)%# 1)02"*+.)%# $-# ("%# /03&*+&"%# /0$%$0.+&+)# ,$##$%*',+"-*$%#,$#2"8+%*$0+)4#$-*0$#("#-)02"(#9#("#/0+2"0+"<"U(676".("'-(6*,N-<"#(+-,*-'()*$".("1)E(6*7M-%7$)(6"2.&%-*7E-6".(0"B()*,$".("1)E(6*7M-%78)"5".("26*&.7$6"?E-)F-.$6".(0"1)6*7*&*$"3$07*Z%)7%$"O-%7$)-0I"=ZR7%$<"

=(,%-.$I" A&*C" _!JJ`c" H$,'-," +-,-" 0-" #$%()%7->" A(*$" .(" 0-" (.&%-%78)" )$,'-0<"T)7E(,67.-."H&*&,-<"T)7E(,67.-."?&*8)$'-"=(*,$+$07*-)-<"V$0<"jI"O['(,$"!j<"

=(,%-.$"A&*C" _:;;:c"S$6" 6-G(,(6".$%()*(6" %$'$"%$)6*,&%%78)" 6$%7-0<" S-"()6(P-)F-"%()*,-.-"()"0$6")7P$6<"H$).$".("%&0*&,-"(%$)8'7%-<"=ZR7%$<"

=(,%-.$I" A&*C" _:;;^c" d20" *,-G-/$" %$*7.7-)$" .(0"'-(6*,$" ()" 0-" (6%&(0-" +,7'-,7-e" ()"A$%iu(00I" 2067(" 5" A&*C" =(,%-.$" !"# $%&'$("# ('8"0# ,$(# *0";"C)# ,)&$-*$<#D$%&0+/&+)-$%# 9# ,$;"*$%<" B&-.(,)$6" .(" 2.&%-%78)" #(+-,*-'()*$" .("1)E(6*7M-%7$)(6"2.&%-*7E-6".(0"B()*,$".("1)E(6*7M-%78)"5".("26*&.7$6"?E-)F-.$6".(0"1)6*7*&*$"3$07*Z%)7%$"O-%7$)-0"_#12KB1OV2QU?VK13Oc"^-<"2.<I"=ZR7%$<"

A$%iu(00I" 2067(" _:;;^c" d#(" C&(00-6I" G-,.-6" 5" E(,(.-6>" &)-" C76*$,7-" %$*7.7-)-" .(" 0-"(6%&(0-e"()"A$%iu(00"2067("5"A&*C"=(,%-.$"!"#$%&'$("#('8"0#,$(#*0";"C)#,)&$-*$<#D$%&0+/&+)-$%# 9# ,$;"*$%<" B&-.(,)$6" .(" 2.&%-%78)I" #(+-,*-'()*$" .("1)E(6*7M-%7$)(6"2.&%-*7E-6".(0"B()*,$".("1)E(6*7M-%78)"5".("26*&.7$6"?E-)F-.$6".(0"1)6*7*&*$"3$07*Z%)7%$"O-%7$)-0"_#12KB1OV2QU?VK13Oc"^-<"2.<I"=ZR7%$<"

A$.,NM&(FI"3<"X<I"2.<"_:;;hc<"S7).(,$6<"#7D0$M$6"6$G,("7)E(6*7M-%78)"(.&%-*7E-<"=ZR7%$I"B4=12zB22zQ2nz1U2Q4<" Q(%,(*-,N-" .(" 2.&%-%78)" 3[G07%-" _:;;ac" Q76*('-"O-%7$)-0" .(" H$,'-%78)" B$)*7)&-" 5" Q&+(,-%78)" 3,$@(67$)-0" .(" =-(6*,$6" ()"Q(,E7%7$<"=ZR7%$<"

O:,/1#')k7!M?!KUc[UL!)20B-.%#+'(',*C%-.%#+'&$'0#'&"#01#%.D$'6&'62%&$-&+'('#017$2+')*2,1&+-#+'('&E,&*.&$%.#+'6&'#1-2&"#01#%.D$?!"1'.?!F&E"WXD?!

U$,,(6I"A$6-"=-,N-<"_:;;;c"!"#/0)1$%+5-#D)&$-*$#$-#("#$0"#,$#("#+-1)023*+&"#9#("#('&E"#&)-*0"# ("# >);0$A"<" A(&)78)" .(0" B$'7*Z" A(M7$)-0" 1)*(,M&G(,)-'()*-0" .(0"+,$5(%*$".("2.&%-%78)I"fI"TO2QB4K4A2?SBI"Q-)*7-M$".("BC70(<"

!

!!