Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept...

51
Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting Gabriel Abadal Berini Departament d’Enginyeria Electrònica Escola d’Enginyeria Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona Bellaterra (Barcelona). SPAIN NiPS Summer School 2010. Energy Harvesting at micro and nanoscale, August 1-6, 2010 La Tenuta dei Ciclamini, Avigliano Umbro (TR) - Italy

Transcript of Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept...

Page 1: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting

Gabriel Abadal Berini Departament d’Enginyeria Electrònica

Escola d’Enginyeria Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona

Bellaterra (Barcelona). SPAIN

NiPS Summer School 2010. Energy Harvesting at micro and nanoscale, August 1-6, 2010 La Tenuta dei Ciclamini, Avigliano Umbro (TR) - Italy

Page 2: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

Vinci Toscana

235 Km

Page 3: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

Vinci Toscana

…was FASCINATED by the incredible speed of the electricity circulating through an electrical wire and light propagating through the space…

To know more about this story: COSMOS by Carl Sagan, chapter VIII

…among others, he had a big PASSION: design and fabricate a flying machine…

1890

1480

Page 4: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

Technology Revolutions

21st Century ? 19th Century

Energy

Movement

20th Century

ICTs

Electronics

Page 5: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

Technology Revolutions

Energy

Movement

Recycle Efficiency

ICT future devices

19th Century 21st Century

Page 6: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

Which is our particular DREAM?

What is the idea that we are FASCINATED by?

In which topic we are PASSIONATELY working?

Page 7: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

Comming back to the present at 21st century… Comming back to the italian Umbria at this summer school… and envisaging the future…

The aim of this lecture is none other than try to inspire new dreams, new ideas, new passions related to the topic of

ENERGY HARVESTING

Page 8: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

NiPS Summer School 2010

Nanotechnology

Page 9: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

NiPS Summer School 2010

Electronics

Microelectronics

Nanoelectronics

Nanotechnology

Biology

Microsystems Technology (MST) or MEMS Technology

NEMS Technology

BOTTOM-UP

TOP-DOWN

Materials science

Medicine Chemistry

Page 10: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

NiPS Summer School 2010

Electronics

Microelectronics

Nanoelectronics

Nano-Sensing

Biology

Microsystems Technology (MST) or MEMS Technology

NEMS Technology

BOTTOM-UP

TOP-DOWN

Materials science

Medicine Chemistry

Page 11: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

NiPS Summer School 2010

Electronics

Microelectronics

Nanoelectronics

Nano-computing

Biology

Microsystems Technology (MST) or MEMS Technology

NEMS Technology

BOTTOM-UP

TOP-DOWN

Materials science

Medicine Chemistry

Page 12: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

NiPS Summer School 2010

Electronics

Microelectronics

Nanoelectronics

Nano-energy harvesting

Biology

Microsystems Technology (MST) or MEMS Technology

NEMS Technology

BOTTOM-UP

TOP-DOWN

Materials science

Medicine Chemistry

Page 13: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

Which is our particular DREAM?

What is the idea that we are FASCINATED by?

In which topic we are PASSIONATELY working?

Page 14: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

NiPS Summer School 2010

Prokaryotic cell

1-10 µm

Eukaryotic cell

10-100 µm

Page 15: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

NiPS Summer School 2010

Talk and listen to a cell

1-10 µm 10 cm

Miniaturization to the nanoscale

NANODEVICE

In particular:

Miniaturization of the BATTERY

Page 16: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

NiPS Summer School 2010

Tracking cells

Page 17: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

NiPS Summer School 2010

Tracking cells

Page 18: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

NiPS Summer School 2010

A. E. Pelling, S.Sehati, E. B. Gralla, J. S. Valentine, and J. K. Gimzewski, “Local Nanomechanical Motion of the Cell Wall of Saccharomyces cerevisiae," Science, 305, 1147-1150 (2004)

We demonstrate that the cell wall of living Saccharomyces cerevisiae (baker's yeast) exhibits local temperature-dependent nanomechanical motion at characteristic frequencies. The periodic motions in the range of 0.8 to 1.6 kHz with amplitudes of 3 nm were measured using the cantilever of an atomic force microscope (AFM). Exposure of the cells to a metabolic inhibitor causes the periodic motion to cease. From the strong frequency dependence on temperature, we derive an activation energy of 58 kJ/mol, which is consistent with the cell's metabolism involving molecular motors such as kinesin, dynein, and myosin. The magnitude of the forces observed (10 nN) suggests concerted nanomechanical activity is operative in the cell.

Listen to yiest cell sound

Prof. JAMES K. GIMZEWSKI UCLA Chemistry & Biochemistry Department

AFM probe

Page 19: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

NiPS Summer School 2010

STM (Scanning Tunneling Microscope)

H. Rohrer G. Binnig

Physics Nobel Prize 1986

Page 20: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

NiPS Summer School 2010

Page 21: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

NiPS Summer School 2010

Page 22: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

NiPS Summer School 2010

T.R. Albrecht, C.F. Quate, J. Vac. Sci. Technol. A 6, 271 (1988). O. Wolter, Th Bayer, J. Greschner, J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B 9, 1353 (1991).

AFM (Atomic Force Microscopy) G.Binnig, C.F. Quate, Ch. Gerber, Phys Rev. Lett. 56, 930 (1986)

AFM Local Probe: Force transducer

δx=1 pm δF=1 pN

Page 23: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

NiPS Summer School 2010

R. Berger, Ch. Gerber, H.P. Lang, J.K. Gimzewski Micromechanics: A Toolbox for Femtoscale Science: “Towards a Laboratory on a Tip” Microelectronic Engineering 35, 373-379 (1997)

“...almost every signal domain can be transduced into a micromechanical actuation detected with picometer resolution.”

Mass Stress Temperature

δm=1 pgr δs=10-5 N/m δT=10-5 K

δQ=1 pJ

Page 24: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

NiPS Summer School 2010

Page 25: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

NiPS Summer School 2010

Talk and listen to a cell

1-10 µm 10 cm

Miniaturization to the nanoscale

NANODEVICE

In particular:

Miniaturization of the BATTERY

Page 26: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

NiPS Summer School 2010

Electrochemical battery evolution vs. ICT technologies

Main drawbacks:

•  Size

•  Only for energy storage

•  Recharge / Replaceability

Page 27: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

NiPS Summer School 2010

ULTRALOWPOWER Circuitry design

POWER USER SYSTEM

NANOHARVESTING devices

POWER SUPPLIER SYSTEM

nm

µm

pW

µW

Convergent point solution

Page 28: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

NiPS Summer School 2010

Smart Dust US project (2002)

Page 29: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

NiPS Summer School 2010

Page 30: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

NiPS Summer School 2010

Sensing electronics

Processing electronics

Transmission electronics

ENERGY USER

ENERGY SUPPLIER

Energy source

Interface electronics Power converted

management

Energy storage

Harvesting nanotransducer

103 µm3

<1 nJ

<1 µW

Page 31: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

NiPS Summer School 2010

Sensing electronics

Processing electronics

Transmission electronics

ENERGY USER

ENERGY SUPPLIER

Energy source

Interface electronics Power converted

management

Energy storage

Harvesting nanotransducer

Page 32: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

NiPS Summer School 2010

Processing electronics

Transmission electronics

ENERGY USER

ENERGY SUPPLIER

Energy source

Interface electronics Power converted

management

Energy storage

Harvesting nanotransducer

Prof. M.L. Roukes

Page 33: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

NiPS Summer School 2010

Sensing electronics

Processing electronics

ENERGY USER Energy source

Interface electronics Power converted

management

Energy storage

Harvesting nanotransducer

Prof. C.T.-C. Nguyen

Page 34: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

NiPS Summer School 2010

Sensing electronics

Processing electronics

Transmission electronics

ENERGY USER Energy source

Interface electronics Power converted

management

Energy storage

Harvesting nanotransducer

Solution: Replacement of these external elements by integrated high-Q RF-MEMS resonators capacitively transduced.

Prof. C.T.-C. Nguyen

Page 35: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

NiPS Summer School 2010

Energy source

Interface electronics Power converted

management

Energy storage

Harvesting nanotransducer

Precedents: Thesis:

“...almost every signal domain can be transduced into a micromechanical actuation detected with picometer resolution.”

NEMS can satisfy the needed requirements in nanoscale EH:

•  Ultrasmall volume

•  Adapted to low energy levels

•  Multidomain energy source

•  Other…?

Page 36: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

NiPS Summer School 2010

Some basics on NEMS. Mechanical characteristics

l

t w Young modulus: ESi=1.79·1011 N/m2 Density: ρSi=2.33·103 kg/m3

MEMS

NEMS

Page 37: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

NiPS Summer School 2010

Some basics on NEMS. Transduction techniques

DRIVING DETECTION

Electrostatic Capacitive

Electrothermal Piezoresistive

Electromagnetic Inductive

Optothermal Optical

Piezoelectric Piezoelectric

Page 38: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

NiPS Summer School 2010

Some basics on NEMS. Modelization tools

Finite elements commercial softwares

ANSYS Allows to analyze macro and microsistems. Multidomain: mechanics, thermal, fluidics, etc…

COMSOL Multiphysics. Allows to co-simulate several domains: MEMS, electromagnetics, heat transfer, etc…

CoventorWare MEMS oriented. Allows the design of MEMS elements from the fabrication process and their simulation. Also multidomain at the microscale.

Page 39: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

NiPS Summer School 2010

Bulk micromachining Surface micromachining

•  Two sides accessibility •  Crystal Si structure •  Complex process

•  Simple process •  Polysilicon structure •  Residual stress •  Adhesion to the substrate

Some basics on NEMS. Fabrication technologies

TOP-DOWN APPROACH

Page 40: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

NiPS Summer School 2010

Some basics on NEMS. Fabrication technologies

BOTTOM-UP APPROACH

Page 41: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

NiPS Summer School 2010

Power Management

Energy storage

Harvesting nanotransducer

Energy source: Thermomechanical noise (thermal fluctuations)

Page 42: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

NiPS Summer School 2010

Power Management

Energy storage

Harvesting nanotransducer

Energy source: Thermomechanical noise (thermal fluctuations)

Page 43: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

NiPS Summer School 2010

Power Management

Energy storage

Harvesting nanotransducer

Energy source: Thermomechanical noise (thermal fluctuations)

Mass resolution (minimum mass detectable)

Spectral density of frequency fluctuations

Ftermomec

NEMS Resonator

piezo

Page 44: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

NiPS Summer School 2010

Power Management

Energy storage

Harvesting nanotransducer

Energy source: Thermomechanical noise (thermal fluctuations)

Figure 2: Color map of the cantilever on-plane vibration amplitude for different conditions of charge, Q, and electrode distance, d. Inset: potential energy at the regions of low interaction (a), maximum hoping (b) and strong interaction (c). Cantilever dimensions: l=28um; w=0.1um; t=1.0um; QF=1000, material: silicon. T=300K and B=1MHz

Efficient non-linear NEMS based energy harvesting from thermomechanical noise M. López-Suárez1, G. Murillo1, J. Agustí1, H. Vocca2, L. Gammaitoni2 and G. Abadal1

1 Department d’Enginyeria Electrònica, Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona (UAB), Bellaterra, 08193 Barcelona, Spain

2 NiPS Laboratory, Dipartimento di Fisica, Universitá di Perugia, 06100 Perugia, Italy and INFN Sezione di Perugia, 06100 Perugia, Italy

Page 45: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

NiPS Summer School 2010

Power Management

Energy storage

Harvesting nanotransducer

Energy source: Electromagnetic radiation

Rectenna concept

Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, (2004)

GHz rectenna

Alda et al. Opt. Lett. (2009)

THz optical rectenna

Page 46: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

NiPS Summer School 2010

Power Management

Energy storage

Harvesting nanotransducer

Q

Felectrostatic

piezo RF wave

NEMS Resonator

Energy source: Electromagnetic radiation

Page 47: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

EH Transducer

Controller

Storage element

NiPS Summer School 2010

Power Management

Energy storage

Harvesting nanotransducer

Page 48: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

NiPS Summer School 2010

Power Management

Energy storage

Harvesting nanotransducer

Europractice-STIMESI. MEMS and System Package Workshop – IMEC November 2007

Page 49: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

NiPS Summer School 2010

Power Management

Energy storage

Harvesting nanotransducer

Page 50: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

NiPS Summer School 2010

“If at first, the idea is not absurd, then there is no hope for it”

ALBERT EINSTEIN

Page 51: Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting · Dynamic NEMS based energy harvesting ... Rectenna concept Hagerty et al., “IEEE Trans on MTT”, ... GAB lecture.ppt Author:

NiPS Summer School 2010

Abstract

Nanoelectromechanical systems, NEMS, have been investigated in the last decade with a special emphasis in the detection of fundamental magnitudes. NEMS, as a natural consequence of the MEMS downscaling, inherit their multi-domain response with a dramatic improvement in terms of sensitivity, resolution and energy consumption. The unique miniaturization and low-consumption opportunities that offer resonant NEMS have also been studied in the field of integrated radio communications. In this lecture we will analyze the potential possibilities that NEMS also offer in the field of energy scavenging from ambient sources. Modeling and design issues, as well as their link to top-down and bottom-up technologies and fabrication processes will be introduced. A special emphasis will be dedicated to the linear resonance and non-linear mechanical characteristics of NEMS, as a key point in terms of energy efficiency in the transduction process. A complete self-powered system will be described, considering the transduction-management-storage chain of the energy, as well as the application subsystem that uses the harvested energy. NEMS role in the power management and storage blocs will also be introduced. Finally, the complementarity of NEMS based energy harvesters with ongoing sensing and communications NEMS based applications will be envisaged.