Indian Academy of Sciencesrepository.ias.ac.in/83508/1/13-a.pdfq9rt|bzY Gz{xvz{y s q9~Ç|bj ¼ q...

15

Transcript of Indian Academy of Sciencesrepository.ias.ac.in/83508/1/13-a.pdfq9rt|bzY Gz{xvz{y s q9~Ç|bj ¼ q...

Page 1: Indian Academy of Sciencesrepository.ias.ac.in/83508/1/13-a.pdfq9rt|bzY Gz{xvz{y s q9~Ç|bj ¼ q Iq.q9kÈ Gq.¼ q.xvz{lIq. Éj kK Èj lblZx svq *rtz Ê kK }"mZxvrtsvlZx qp µj ntqcrtz

������������ ������������������������ ��� �"!#�� ��%$ �&! '��)(*�,+-�.!#'�� 0/21��3��45! ���� ��#67$ 4*�.! �98;:=<)>?���@!#��13�A:=�5!#������B��"! ����

$ �&! '��)(

C�D.EGFIHKJMLON5PQJRLOEGD�SKTKJMUKVWERXMPEYVWHZEGNMLO[\HO]_^�`?XREYNRF*SIEGNbac[ZdcT�e&fhg&EYD9fi�j�[email protected]�wpxvy{z�ntsvrt|Z}~���j��Iz�n�j�rtz�n�����i�j�kIo&w@���

��kK�Gshj�k���kb~�rts�rtmZrtq&z��?��q.u�|bkZz{xvz{y���i�j�kblbmGni�j�kZlbmZn��Z�;�������{���G�.�G�I��kK�Zs�j

�{������ Z¡�¢�£�¤�¥�¦;£�§G¨�©G¢�ªG¨��{«�¬Y¨�¨�§� ®­�¢\¯°­t¨�±

²�³µ´.¶.·�¸K¹�¶{º» z�nprt|Zq�lKj�~�r&�Gq.u�j{�Gq{�K}�j�k\��q.¼{z{xvmZrtsvz{kbj�n���}"mbx�rts�½¾z{�Y¿�q.ucrts�¼{q�z{lZ½rtsv}svÀ�j�rtsvz�kÁ�îÄÆÅ��"}q9rt|bzY�Gz{xvz{y�s�q9~Ç|bj�¼�q��Iq.q9kÈ�Gq.¼�q.xvz{lIq.�Éj�kK�Èj�lblZx�svq��*rtzÊ kK�}"mZxvrtsvlZx�qp�µj�ntqcrtz�½¾z{lGrts�}�j�xM~�z{xvmZrtsvz{kZ~ svk�j�~�svkby{xvq&~�sv}_mbx�j�rtsvz{k�ntmbkRË\��k�rt|bsv~lbj�lIq9n��RÌ#qÇ�Zsv~�u.mZ~�~�rt|Zntq.q��GsvÍMqcntq.k\r�u.x�j�~�~�svu�j�x�y{q.kZq9n�j�rtsvkbyÆ}qcrt|bzY�Z~.�R~�z�}qz��Ì�|Zs�u�|�Ì�q9ntq�~�mby{y�q.~�rtq��Oq.¼{q.k��Iq9�Wz�ntq�rt|bq@s�kZu.q.lGrts�z�kOz��?®ÄÆÅ�}q9rt|bzY�Gz{xvz{y�svq.~.Ë�#|Zq.~�qÆ}q9rt|bzY�G~~�lIq.u.s�j�xvsvÀ.q)svk Ê kK�ZsvkZyÎ}"mZx�rts�lZxvqÆ�µj�ntq9rtz�½¾z{lZrtsv}�j�xÏ~�z�xvmZrtsvz{kZ~svk*j�~�svkZy{xvq�~�s�}_mbx�j�rtsvz�kÎntmbkR˵Å@k5¼Gsv~�mbj�x�u9z{}lKj�ntsv~�z{kb~�z�� rt|bqQq9ÐQu.svq.k\r_�hntz{kZ½rtsvq9nt~z��Zr�j�svkZq��Ñ�Wz�n�jÒkYmb}"�Iqcn_z��@r�Ì#z5j�kK�*rt|Zntq9q9½¾z{�Y¿�q.u9rtsv¼�qÇrtq.~�rlGntz{�bxvq.}~.�rt|Zq.~�qQj�x�y�z�nts�rt|b}~@j�ntq_q.¼{j�xvmKj�rtq.�ÆÌ�s�rt|5j�kÒ®ÄÆÅÓ}q9rt|bzY�Gz{xvz{y��\ËM�#|bq�ntq.~�mZxvrt~�Gnts�kZypz�mZr�s�k\rtq9ntq9~�rts�kZypsvkZ~�s�y�|\rt~Ôj��Iz�mZrÔrt|Zq®~�r�ntq9kby�rt|Z~Ôj�kK�&Ì#q�j�ÕYkbq.~�~�q.~µz��Zrt|Zq.~�qj�lblZntz{j�u�|bq.~.Ë » mGn�rt|bq9n@svkG¼{q.~�rtsvy�j�rtsvz�kb~�z���~�mbu�|)u.x�j�~�~�svu�j�x?y{q9kbq9n�j�rts�kZy�}q9rt|ZzY�G½z�x�z�y{svq.~Ïj�kb�"rt|bq.s�n�q.¼{j�xvmKj�rtsvz�k3~�|Zz{mbx��q.kbj��bxvq�ntq.~�q�j�ntuc|Zq9nt~#rtz��Zq.~�svy{k3j�|\�Z�Gnts��}_mbx�rts�½�z��G¿�q.u9rtsv¼�qQz�lZrtsv}svÀ�j�rtsvz�k*j�xvy{z�nts�rt|b}ÖÌ�|bsvu�|Î}�j.�)�Iq�Iq9r�rtq9n�rt|bj�kÒq�j�u�|svkK�Gsv¼Gs��GmKj�xR}q9rt|ZzY�RË

× ØbÙÏÚIÛMÜ�Ý_Þ�ß�ÚMàtÜÏÙá*JMVhacfhâ�[Z`Iãt^�ä�acfWåG^Æ[GæMacfWL�fWç�EYacfW[GNèTREZd`°^�^�NéE�D.EYæMfêFIVWHÑëGD9[\g�fWNMë*EYD9^�EÎfhNèLO[IFI^�D9Nè[GæIa9f�âL�fWç�EYacfW[GN;ì®e&TM^�D9^O^�íIfWd�a�E�æMVW^�acTR[GD.EÒ[Gî@LO^�a9TM[IFMd�EGNRFèEYVWëG[GD9fhacTMLÆd_îÃ[GD�dc[GVWåKfhNMë�L3JMV�a9f�â[G`Iãt^{ä�acfWåG^�[GæIa9fhLOfWç�E\a9fh[ZNÆæMD9[G`MVW^�LÆd�ìZe&TM^_L�^�acTM[IFMdpä�EGN)`°^"FIfWåbfêFI^{FOfhNÆatg@[Çä�E\ac^�ëG[ZDcfW^�d�ïð f�ñÏä�VWEZdcdcfWä�EYVMLO^�acTM[IFMdpg�TMfêä.T)JRdc^�FIfWDc^{ä�ap[ZDÏëZD9EZFIfh^�Nba�â�`REGdc^�F�LO^�a9TM[IFMd�îÃ[ZVhVW[\g�fWNMëÇdc[GLO^LOEYacTM^�LÆE\acfêä�EGVKæMDcfWNRä�fhæMVW^�d EGNRF ð fhf�ñ�NM[ZNIâ�a9D9EZFIfhacfW[GNREGVZLO^�a9TM[IFMd#g�TMfêä.T�îÃ[ZVhVW[\gòdc[GLO^pN°E\a�âJMD9EGV;[GD�æRTbHIdcfWä�EYV;æRDcfWNRä�fWæMVW^�d�ì�ó�î�acTM^�LÎXRacTM^Ç^�åG[ZVhJMacfW[GNREGDcHÆL3JMV�a9f�â�[G`Mãt^�ä�a9fhåZ^[GæIa9fhLOfWç�EYâacfW[GN ð¾ô áÉóQñÔTREZdµ`�^�^�NÇëG^�acacfWNMë�ëGD9[\g�fWNMë�E\a�a9^�NbacfW[GN[\åZ^�DÔa9TM^ÏæREZdta?FM^�ä�EZFI^Gì{e&TM^Ïä�VWEZdcdcf�õRâä�E\a9fh[ZNÒfêd&EYVêd�[�EYæMæMD9[GæRDcfêE\a9^�îÃDc[ZLÖatgp[3[Ya9TM^�D&æ�^�D.d�æ�^�ä�acfWåG^�d�ìKe&TM^ä�VêEGd9d�fêä�EGV°EYæRæMDc[bEGä.TM^{dJRd�J°EYVWVhHéJ°d�^*FI^�ac^�D9LOfhNRfWd�acfêäÎacD.EYNRdcfhacfW[GNòD9JMVW^�d�X g�TM^�D9^�EZd�NM[GNIâ�acD.EGFMf�a9fh[ZNREYV�EYæRæMDc[bEGä.TM^{dJRd�^3dta9[Kä.T°EGd�acfêäDcJRVh^{d�ìRe&TR^�H*EYD9^�EYVêd�[)FMf�öÔ^�D9^�Nba�îÃD9[GL=^�EZä.T�[YacTR^�D�îÃD9[GL-EYNR[YacTR^�D�åKfha9EYVä�[GN°d�fêFI^�D.E\a9fh[ZN;ìZ÷pVêEGd9d�fêä�EGVIL�^�acTM[IFMdÏLO[Zd�acVWH3E\acac^�L�æMaÏac[�d9ä�EGVWEGDcfWç�^&L3JMV�a9fhæRVh^�[Z`Iãt^�ä�acfWåG^{dEYNRF5æ°^�D�îÃ[ZDcL�D9^�æ�^�EYac^{F5EGæMæMVWfWä�E\acfW[GN°dÏa9[�õRNRFÎE�dc^�a�[Gî�C EYD9^�a9[Yâ�[GæIa9fhLÆEGV°dc[GVWJIacfW[GNRd�ìRó_NacTM^@[Ya9TM^�D�TREYN°FµX ô áÉóøLO^�a9TM[IFMd#E\acac^�LOæIa�ac[�õRNRFÇLÇJMVhacfWæMVW^&C EGDc^�ac[Gâ�[ZæIacfWLÆEYVGdc[GVWJIacfW[GN°dfhN*EOd�fWNMëZVh^dcfhL3JMVWEYacfW[GNÎDcJRN;ì

ù�[\g@^�åG^�D�XMacTM^�Dc^�^�íIfWd�a"E)îÃ^�gúä�VêEGd9dcfWä�EYV;ëZ^�NM^�D9EYacfWNMë)LO^�a9TM[IFMd ð dta9[Iä.TREGd�acfêä�EYN°FÑFI^�âac^�D9LOfhNRfWd�acfêä�ñ@g�TMfêä.T�E\a�a9^�LOæIa�a9[OõRNRF5LÇJMVhacfWæMVW^�C EYD9^�ac[Gâ�[ZæIacfWLÆEYVÔd�[ZVhJMacfW[GNRd&fWN*E�dcfWNMëGVW^

Page 2: Indian Academy of Sciencesrepository.ias.ac.in/83508/1/13-a.pdfq9rt|bzY Gz{xvz{y s q9~Ç|bj ¼ q Iq.q9kÈ Gq.¼ q.xvz{lIq. Éj kK Èj lblZx svq *rtz Ê kK }"mZxvrtsvlZx qp µj ntqcrtz

d�fWLÇJMVêE\a9fh[ZN3D9JMN;X\åZ^�D9HLÇJRä.TÆdcfhLOfWVWEGD�ac[QacTR^@g&E�H ô áÉóÁLO^�a9TM[IFMd g@[GD9U�ì���N�acTRfWd#æREGæ°^�D�Xgp^)æRDc^{d�^�NZaÇacTMD9^�^ÒdcJRä.TéEGVhëZ[GD9f�a9TMLÆdÇEYN°FèæMDc[\åKfêFI^)dcfhL3JMVWEYacfW[GN D9^�dcJMVha9d�[ZNéE*NKJMLÇ`�^�D[Yî@atgp[*EYN°F a9TMD9^�^�â�[G`Mãt^�ä�a9fhåZ^O[GæIa9fhLOfWç�E\a9fh[ZNèæMDc[Z`MVW^�LÆd�ì��È^ÒEGVWdc[*ä�[GLOæREGDc^3acTR^�fWD�æ°^�D�âîÃ[GD9LOEGNRä�^g�fhacTÑEGN ô áÉóúLO^�acTR[KFM[GVW[GëGHÎEYNRF�JRNbåZ^�fWVµacTR^�æMD9[G`MVW^�L=ä�VêEGd9d�^{d&g�TM^�D9^acTR^ä�VêEGd9d�fêä�EGVMëG^�NM^�D.E\a9fhNMëLO^�acTM[IFMdpEYD9^�`°^�a�a9^�DpEGNRFOa9TM^�æMD9[G`MVW^�LÖä�VêEGd9dc^�d g�TM^�Dc^�acTM^ ô áÉóL�^�acTM[IFMdpTRE�åZ^�acTM^�fhDpNMfêä.TM^GìKe&TM^_d�acJ°FIHODc^�åG^�EGVWd#fWLOæ°[ZD�a.EYNbapfWNRdcfhëZTba9dÏEG`°[ZJIaÏa9TM^�g@[GD9UbâfhNMë*[GîÏa9TM^)EYVWëG[ZDcfhacTMLÆd�Xµg�TMfêä.TÈä�EYNè`°^)ä�[GL3`MfhNR^�F ac[GëZ^�a9TM^�DfWN E�TbHK`MD9fêF LÆEYNRNM^�DQa9[FI^�åZ^�VW[Gæ�EYN�EYVWëG[GD9fhacTML,^�åG^�N5`�^�acac^�D�acTREGN5fWNRFIfWåKfWFIJ°EYV?EGVhëZ[GD9f�a9TMLÆd�ì

� ������Kàcß �������?Ù��;Û��®ÚMàcÙ������µÚ���Ü�Ý�

� VhacTM[ZJMëGTOLO[Zd�aÏä�VêEGd9d�fêä�EGVIëG^�NM^�D.E\a9fhNMëQL3JMV�a9f�â�[G`Mãt^�ä�a9fhåZ^&[GæIa9fhLOfWç�E\a9fh[ZNOL�^�acTM[IFMd�JRd�^�EGNf�a9^�D.E\acfWåG^Æd9ä�EGVWEGDcfWç�EYacfW[GN d9ä.TM^�LO^O[Yî�d�a9EYN°FMEYD.F æRDc[Iä�^{FIJMD9^�dQdcJRä.TÈEZdQgp^�fhëZTbac^�FIâ�dcJML [ZD^�æRdcfhVW[GNMâ�ä�[GNRd�acD.EYfWNba�L�^�acTM[IFMd�� �! �XZg@^�TRE�åZ^�îÃ[GJMN°F)E\a@Vh^{EGd�aÏacTRDc^�^�ëG^�NM^�D.E\a9fhNMëÇL�^�acTM[IFMdg�TMfWä.TèE\acac^�L�æMa"a9[ÎõRNRFÉLÇJMVhacfWæMVW^)C EYD9^�ac[Gâ�[ZæIacfWLÆEYV�d�[ZVhJIa9fh[ZNRd"fhNèEÎd�fWNMëGVW^Æd�fWLÇJRVWEYacfW[GNDcJMN?ì���NÒa9TM^QîÃ[GVWVW[\g�fhNMëÆdcJM`Rdc^�ä�acfW[GNRd�XIgp^FI^{dcä�DcfW`�^_a9TM^�dc^LO^�a9TM[IFMd�ì

"�#%$ &('�)+*,.-0/�13254 &76987'�) ,�4 69:;'=< / 6>)?8(@BAC&?&(<ED� d�ac[Iä.TREZdta9fWä�LO^�acTM[IFÆîÃ[ZD�a9TM^"dc[GVWJIa9fh[ZN)[Yî;JMN°ä�[GN°dta9D9EGfhNM^{FOLÇJMVhacfhâ�[G`Iãt^{ä�acfWåG^_[GæIa9fhLOfWç�EYâacfW[GN)æMD9[G`RVh^�LOdpg&EGd�æRDc[Zæ°[bd�^{FÆ`KHÆSMä.T(FE!GÆ^�Dp^�a{ìKEGV�ì � H! ÔfhNJILKLK�IIìZe&TR^�LO^�a9TM[IF)fêdp`°EGdc^�F[GN�acTM^_d�[ZVhJIa9fh[ZNO[Yî;Ed�^�a�[Yî;d�ac[Iä.TREGd�acfêä�FIfhö�^�Dc^�NbacfêEYVM^>MZJ°E\acfW[GN°d�ìGe&TRfWd LO^�acTM[IFOD9^9MbJMfWDc^{dacTM^Æ[Z`Iãt^�ä�acfWåG^�îÃJMNRä�acfW[GNRdQa9[�`°^Æatg�fêä�^Æä�[GNbacfWNKJM[GJRdcVWHZâ�FIfhö�^�Dc^�NbacfêEY`MVW^Gì ��a�LÆE�HÑ`�^ÆJRd�^{FîÃ[GDÆa9TM^ ä�[ZLOæMJIa9EYacfW[GN�[YîEYVWV�[ZDÒEèVWEGDcëZ^�NbJRLÇ`�^�D)[GîQC EGDc^�ac[Yâ�[GæMacfWLOEGV�d�[ZVhJIa9fh[ZNRd�ìN��N^�EGä.TÁfhac^�D.E\a9fh[ZN;X�EÈacD.EGä�^�[YîQNM[GNIâ�FI[ZL�fWNREYac^�Føæ�[GfWNZa.dÆfêd)ä�[ZNRdta9DcJ°ä�ac^{Fò`KHÁä�EYVêä�JRVWEYacfWNMëE\a^�EZä.T æ�[GfWNZaPO X®E5FIfWD9^�ä�a9fh[ZN ðQ�RIð O®ñcñ_fhNÈacTR^OFM^�ä�fêdcfh[ZNÈdcæREGä�^Og�TMfWä.TÈfêdE5FIfWD9^�ä�a9fh[ZN[Yî�FI^{dcä�^�NbaÇîÃ[ZDTSVUWU�[G`Iãt^{ä�a9fhåZ^ÆîÃJMNRä�acfW[GNRd�ì�e&TR^ÎFIfWD9^�ä�a9fh[ZN [Yî_FM^�d9ä�^�NbaÇfêd3[G`Ia.EYfWNM^�F `KHd�[ZVhåKfWNMë3EXMbJREGFID.E\a9fWä�d�JM`RæMDc[Z`MVW^�L�ìIe&TM^�îÃ[ZVhVW[\g�fWNMëÇfWNMfhacfêEYVÔå\EYVWJM^_æRDc[Z`MVh^�L ð �ZY"Cpñ�îÃ[GD&ELÇJMVhacfhâ�[Z`Iãt^�ä�acfWåG^Q[GæMacfWL�fWç�EYacfW[GNÎæMD9[G`MVW^�L,fêd&a9TM^�N*dc^�a�JMæ;ï

[O]\ Q�RIð O ð_^ ñ�ña`bO ð KbñN\�O�cd`g�TM^�D9^fe�cÆfêdEÎd�a9EGD�a9fhNRëÎæ�[GfWNba�ì?e&TR^�NKJMLO^�Dcfêä�EGV�d�[ZVhJIa9fh[ZNÉ[GîÏa9TM^)EY`�[\åG^X�ZY_C ëGfWåG^{dQEd�fWNMëGVW^&æ°[ZfhNbaÏg�TR^�D9^pa9TM^&õRD.dtacâ�[ZD9FM^�D#gp^{EYUÇC EGDc^�ac[Gâ�[ZæIacfWLÆEYVWf�atH�ä�[GNRFIfhacfW[GN°d EYD9^pîÃJRV�õRVWVW^�Fµì� î�ac^�Dd�JRä.TÈEÒdc[GVWJIacfW[GN fWd"[G`Ma9EYfWNM^{FµX�E5d�^�a"[GîÏNM[ZNIâ�FM[GLOfhN°E\ac^{FÑdc[GVWJIacfW[GNRd_fêd�[Z`Ia9EGfhNM^{F`bH�æ�^�DcacJMD9`MfWNMëéfha5JRdcfWNMëøE0g@D9[\g�NMfêEYN LO[Ya9fh[ZN�ä�[GN°ä�^�æMa�ì&e&TM^ÑîÃ[ZVhVW[\g�fhNRëòdta9[Iä.TREGd�acfêäFIf�öÔ^�D9^�Nba9fWEGVµ^9MbJRE\a9fh[ZN5fêd�^�L�æRVh[\HZ^�FÒîÃ[GD&acTRfWd�æRJMDcæ�[Zdc^Gï

hdikj \ Q�RIð ikj ñ h ð_^ ñ(lnm hdopj ` i c�\�O7cL` ðrq ñg�TM^�D9^XmTstK�EGNRF opj fêdEvuÔâ�FIfWLO^�NRdcfW[GNREGV�g@D9[\g�NMfêEYN LO[GacfW[GNÈTRE�åKfhNMë5acTR^3îÃ[ZVhVW[\g�fWNMëæMDc[Zæ°^�D�a9fh^{d�ïq ì�e&TM^^�íIæ�^�ä�ac^�FÎå\EYVWJM^Qfêd�ç�^�Dc[°XIIì�e&TM^�fWNRä�D9^�LO^�Nba.d o cbX ð opj%w Q opj_x ñ�X ð opj_y Q opj%w ñ®îÃ[GD ^�åG^�DcH ^ c ð \zKZñ|{ ^~} { ^r� {������EYD9^dta9[Kä.T°EGd�acfêä�EYVWVWHÆfhNRFM^�æ�^�NRFI^�Nba�XREGNRF

Page 3: Indian Academy of Sciencesrepository.ias.ac.in/83508/1/13-a.pdfq9rt|bzY Gz{xvz{y s q9~Ç|bj ¼ q Iq.q9kÈ Gq.¼ q.xvz{lIq. Éj kK Èj lblZx svq *rtz Ê kK }"mZxvrtsvlZx qp µj ntqcrtz

� ì��M[ZD@^�åG^�DcH��P{ ^ XKa9TM^QfhNRä�Dc^�LO^�Nba ð o�� Q opj ñpfWd&NM[ZDcLÆEGVhVWH)FIfêdta9DcfW`MJIa9^�F5g�f�a9T5LO^�EGN^9MbJREGVÔac[Oç�^�Dc[OEYNRFÎE3å�EGDcfêEYN°ä�^"^9MbJREYVÔa9[ ð � Q ^ ñ��;XIg�TM^�D9^���Òfêd�EXuÔâ�FIfWLO^�NRdcfW[GNREGVfWFM^�NbacfhatHÒLÆE\a9Dcfhíµì

e&TbJ°d�XRd�a9EGD�a9fhNRë3îÃD9[GL=EYN�fWNMf�a9fWEGV®dc[GVWJIacfW[GN?XMEONbJRLÇ`�^�D�[Gî#dc[GVWJIacfW[GN°d�ä�[ZNbåZ^�D9ëGfWNMë3ac[OacTR^^�)ä�fW^�Nba#îÃDc[ZNbacfW^�D EYD9^p^�íIæ°^{ä�ac^{F�a9[Q`°^&ëG^�NM^�D.E\a9^�FÇ`bHQa9TMfêd æMD9[Kä�^�FIJRDc^Zì�e&TR^ Q�RIð i jtñ h ð_^ ñac^�D9L fWN ô MbJREYacfW[GN q fWd acTM^�FM^�ac^�DcLOfWNMfêdta9fWä�FI^{dcä�^�NbaÏæREGD�a{X\g�TMfWVh^�a9TM^�g@D9[\g�NMfWEGNÇLO[Ya9fh[ZNfWdÒacTM^ÈVW[Kä�EYV"D9EGNRFI[ZL dc^�EGD9ä.T�a9^�D9LÎì ��N2EGVhVQdcfhL3JMVWEYacfW[GNRd5TM^�Dc^ZXÏa9[ødc[GVWåG^Ña9TM^ÉEG`°[\åZ^^9MbJRE\a9fh[ZN NKJMLO^�D9fêä�EYVWVWHGXÔgp^�^�LOæMVW[\H�acTR^ ô JMVW^�D� d"LO^�a9TM[IFµì;e&TM^ÆEYæMæRDc[bEGä.T*NM^�^�FMd"atg@[æREYD.EYLO^�a9^�D.d a9[Ç`�^_dc^�apæRDc[Zæ°^�DcVWHÔï ð fêñ�acTM^_æREYD.EYLO^�ac^�D+mg�TMfWä.T5ä�[GNba9Dc[ZVWd�acTM^"EYLO[GJMNba@[YîVh[Iä�EGV;d�^{EYD.ä.TÒEYN°F ð fhf�ñpacTM^d�ac^�æÎdcfhç�^�� JRdc^�F5fWNÒa9TM^ ô JMVW^�D� d&EGæMæMD9[ZEGä.T5g�TMfêä.TÎä�[GNbacD9[GVêdacTM^EGä�ä�JMD.EGä�HO[Yî?a9TM^QfhNba9^�ëGD.E\a9fh[ZNÒæMD9[Iä�^{FIJMD9^Gì � a&acTM^Q^�N°FÒ[Gî�E3æMDc^�â�dcæ�^�ä�fhõR^{F)NKJMLÇ`�^�D[Yîµf�a9^�D.E\a9fh[ZNRd�XZENM[GNMâ�FI[ZLOfhNREYacfW[GNÆä.TM^{ä.U3[Gî�a9TM^�[Z`Ia9EGfhNM^{FÆd�[ZVhJMacfW[GNRd fêd�æ�^�DcîÃ[GD9LO^�FÆEGNRFacTM^&D9^�dcJMV�a9fhNRë_dc[GVWJIacfW[GNRd�EYD9^&FI^�ä�VWEGDc^{F�EGd?acTM^&[Z`Ia9EGfhNM^{FÇC EGDc^�ac[Yâ�[GæMacfWLOEGVGdc[GVWJIacfW[GNRd�ì��M[ZDL�[ZDc^"fWNIîÃ[GD9LÆE\acfW[GN5[GNÒacTMfêd�EYVWëG[ZDcfhacTML�XbfhNba9^�D9^�d�ac^�F5D9^�EGFM^�D.d�LÆE�HÆDc^�îÃ^�D@ac[�a9TM^Q[GD9fhëZfhNREGVdta9JRFIH � H! �ì

"�#W" �P:���� /��r2 4�� 8���� �;, 69:;8�� � ,�49/ @�< / 69) 87@ A�� � <ED� dO^�EGDcVWHéEGd�fWN q HL�dKMX#e&fhLOLO^�VP� q KV �æMDc[Zæ°[bd�^{FéEÈæ°[ZæMJMVêE\a9fh[ZNIâ�`°EGdc^�Fòd�ac[Iä.TREZdta9fWäÎEYæMâæMDc[bEGä.T îÃ[ZDOõRNRFIfWNMëèLÇJRV�a9fhæMVW^*C EYD9^�a9[Yâ�[GæIa9fhLÆEYV&dc[GVWJIacfW[GNRd�[Gî"EÈFIf�öÔ^�D9^�Nba9fWEG`MVh^�L3JMV�a9f�â[G`Iãt^{ä�acfWåG^ [ZæIacfWLOfhç{E\a9fh[ZN æRDc[Z`MVh^�L�ì���N acTMfêdÑLO^�a9TM[IFµX�õ°D9d�a EÁîÃ^�EZd�fW`MVW^éd�[ZVhJIa9fh[ZN d�^�að g@^èä�EYVWVQf�a Eøæ°[ZæMJMVêE\a9fh[ZN°ñ5fWd�D.EYNRFM[GLOVhH�ä�Dc^{E\a9^�Fµì�e&TM^èNM[ZNIâ�FM[GLOfhN°E\ac^{F2dc[GVWJIacfW[GN°dð i cp\"!>O c } `O c � `��9���a`~O c �$# ñ&EYD9^QfWFI^�NbacfhõR^�F�EYN°F)a9TM^�HÎd�^�DcåZ^QEZd@acTM^Qõ°D9d�a�EYæMæRDc[�íIfWLOEYacfW[GNac[OacTR^�C EYD9^�ac[Gâ�[ZæIacfWLÆEYVÔd�^�a�ìRe&TR^�D9^�E\î�a9^�D{XKîÃDc[ZL ^{EGä.T�d�[ZVhJIa9fh[ZNJO c % XREÆä.TMfWVWF�dc[GVWJIacfW[GNÎfWdä�D9^�E\a9^�F5fhNÎa9TM^QîÃ[GVWVh[\g�fWNMë�LÆEYNMNM^�D�ï

O }% \ Q'&( )* }^),+-)�.0/�)

ð O c % ña`g�TM^�D9^

+-)fWd�E3JMNMfhîÃ[GD9LOVhH5FIfWd�acD9fW`MJIac^{FÒD.EYN°FI[GL�NKJML3`°^�D ð `°^�atgp^�^�NTKOEYNRF q ñ@EYNRF ^

)fWd

dta9^�æIâ�Vh^�NMëYa9T*fhNÑacTM^21�â�acT [G`Iãt^{ä�acfWåG^Zì���a�fêd"E)d�fWLOæMVW^Ç^�íI^�D9ä�fWdc^Qac[Îd�TM[\g a9TRE\a�a9TM^3EG`°[\åZ^îÃ[GD9LÇJMVêE\a9fh[ZN�^�NRdcJMD9^�d?acTREYa�NR[Ya EYVWVZîÃJRNRä�a9fh[ZNRd#ä�EYNÇ`°^&g@[GD.d�^�NM^�FdcfhL3JMVha9EYNR^�[GJ°d�VWHGì�e&TKJRd�XacTM^Qä.TMfWVWFÎd�[ZVhJMacfW[GN)fêd@^�fhacTM^�D@NR[GNIâ�FI[GLOfWNRE\a9^�FOa9[Ça9TM^QæREYD9^�Nba&d�[ZVhJIa9fh[ZN�O c % XK[ZDpfha&FM[GLOf�âNRE\a9^�d@acTR^æREYD9^�Nba�ìIù�[\gp^�åG^�D{XZacTM^å\EYD9fêE\acfW[GN5[Yî®acTM^�d�ac^�æIâ�VW^�NRëYacTÎ[\åG^�D&f�a9^�D.E\acfW[GN°dpL3JRd�a`°^5LOEZFI^5ä�EYD9^�îÃJMVWVWH a9[Ñ^�NRdcJMD9^Òä�[ZNKåG^�D9ëG^�NRä�^Oa9[*acTR^Ò^�)ä�fh^�NZa3îÃDc[ZNbacfW^�D{ì®e&TM^5[GD9fhëZfhNREGVdta9JRFIH5dcJMëZëG^�d�ac^{FÆa9TM^QîÃ[GVWVh[\g�fWNMëÆdc^9MbJM^�N°ä�^"îÃ[GD�JMæÔFMEYacfWNMë ^

VWfhL) 35476 ^)\zK�`

6( )* }^)\98 ` 6( )

* }^ �){ 8 �

� î�ac^�D&acTM^ä.TMfWVêF)æ�[GæMJMVêE\a9fh[ZNÒfêd�ä�D9^�EYac^�F;XZfha�fWd�ä�[GLÇ`RfhNM^{F)g�fhacT5acTM^QæREGDc^�Nbapæ�[GæMJMVêE\a9fh[ZNEYNRF [GNMVWH�acTM^�NM[ZNIâ�FM[GLOfhN°E\ac^{FÑdc[GVWJIacfW[GNRdQEGDc^3Dc^�a9EYfWNM^{Fµì�e&TRfWdQdc^�a"acTM^�NÉ`�^�ä�[GLO^�d_acTR^d�^{ä�[GN°FòEYæRæMDc[�íIfWLÆE\acfW[GNéac[ÈacTM^*C EGDc^�ac[Yâ�[GæMacfWLOEGVpdc^�a{ì�e&TMfWdOæRDc[Iä�^{FIJMD9^5fêdOä�[ZNZa9fhNKJM^{FîÃ[GD�EOæMD9^�â�dcæ°^{ä�fhõR^�FÎNKJMLÇ`�^�D�[Yî f�a9^�D.E\a9fh[ZNRd�ì;:�[Ya9^acTREYa�acTM^Çæ°[ZæMJMVêE\acfW[GNÑdcfWç�^�ä�EGN�å�EGDcHg�f�a9TÑf�a9^�D.E\a9fh[ZNRd�ì ��N*î¾EZä�a�X�fWNÑLO[Zd�a_æMD9[G`MVW^�LÆd�X°EGNÑfhN°ä�D9^�EGdc^fWN*acTM^�æ�[GæMJMVêE\a9fh[ZN dcfhç�^�fWd^�íIæ°^{ä�a9^�Fµì

e&TM^dta9^�æIâ�Vh^�NMëYa9T�å�EGDcfêE\a9fh[ZNÒLO^�Nba9fh[ZNM^�F�EY`�[\åG^"^�N°d�JMD9^�d@a9TM^QîÃ[GVWVW[\g�fhNMëOEGdcæ�^�ä�a.d�ï

Page 4: Indian Academy of Sciencesrepository.ias.ac.in/83508/1/13-a.pdfq9rt|bzY Gz{xvz{y s q9~Ç|bj ¼ q Iq.q9kÈ Gq.¼ q.xvz{lIq. Éj kK Èj lblZx svq *rtz Ê kK }"mZxvrtsvlZx qp µj ntqcrtz

q ì�e&TM^�dta9^�æOd�fWç�^�dcTM[GJRVWF�d�VW[\g�VWH�FI^�ä�Dc^{EGdc^Ïa9["ç�^�D9["EZd#d�[ZVhJIa9fh[ZNRd#ä�VW[Zdc^�D�ac["a9TM^�C EYD9^�ac[Gâ[GæIa9fhLÆEGV?d�^�a�EYD9^_îÃ[ZJMNRF�EYN°F

IIì�e&TM^_FM^�ä�D9^�EZd�^�[GîµacTM^"dta9^�æÒdcfWç�^�L3JRd�apNM[Gap`�^_dcVh[\g�^�NR[GJMëZT)d�[a9TRE\apacTM^"EYVWëG[ZDcfhacTMLëG^�a9d�ä�EGJMëGTba�fWN�dcJM`Iâ�[GæMacfWLOEGVµæ°[ZfhNba.d�ì

e&TbJ°d�X�fha#fêd#ä�VW^�EGD?a9TRE\a�acTM^&JMæÔFMEYac^@[YîMa9TM^�dta9^�æÇVW^�NRëYacT3fWd#E"ä�D9JRä�fêEYVbæREGD�a#[YîMa9TM^&gp[ZDcUKfWNMë[Yî�a9TM^�EGVhëZ[GD9f�a9TML EYNRFÉE)a9JMNMfWNMëÎ[Yî�a9TM^3JRæ�FMEYac^Æd�acD.E\ac^�ëGHÎLÆE�H*TRE�åG^Çac[Ò`�^ÆFI[GNR^ÇîÃ[ZD^�åG^�DcHQæMD9[G`RVh^�LÎìYù�^�D9^GX�g@^pJRdc^@acTM^@îÃ[ZVhVW[\g�fhNRë"d�acD.E\a9^�ëGHÔï ^

)\����$1 ð g�TR^�D9^��pfêd�E_æ�[Zdcf�a9fhåZ^

ä�[GN°dta.EYNba.ñ�Xbg�TRfWä.TÎdcEYacfêdtõR^{dpEGVhV°acTR^QEG`°[\åZ^�â�LO^�NbacfW[GNM^{FÆä�[ZNRFIfhacfW[GNRd�ì �M[GDpacTR^_fWNbac^�D9^�d�ac^{FDc^{EGFI^�D9d�XYg@^�Dc^�îÃ^�DÏac[a9TM^�[ZDcfWëGfWNREYV°dta9JRFIH=� q KMX qdq °îÃ[GD�îÃJRD�a9TM^�D@FI^�a.EYfWVWd�ìL��a@fWdpfhNba9^�D9^�d�acfWNMëac[)NM[Gac^Qa9TRE\a�a9TMfêd�EYVWëG[ZDcfhacTRL,JRdc^�d�EGN*^�VWf�a9fWd�a_d�acD.E\ac^�ëGHZXIfhN*g�TMfêä.T*`�^�d�a�[Yî#æREYD9^�Nba�EGNRF[Yöµd�æMD9fWNMëOæ°[ZæMJMVêE\acfW[GN°d&fWd&D9^�a.EYfWNM^�Fµì

"�#�� �=8 1 � ,;� �X8�� � @ ,�1�� � 6 /�1!4>/ 'L69:%8�� � / 6>)?87@BA�� � De&TM^2:pg ��LO^�acTM[IFÑg&EGd_FI^�åZ^�VW[Gæ�^�F�`KH*]_EZd�^�a�ìÔEYV�ì � q �îÃ[GD�õRNRFIfWNMëÎE)JMNMfhîÃ[GD9L d�æRDc^{EGF[Yî�C EGDc^�ac[Gâ�[ZæIacfWLÆEYV°dc[GVWJIa9fh[ZNRdpîÃ[GD�E�ëG^�NR^�D.EYV�NM[GNMVWfWNM^�EGD@L3JMVhacfhâ�[Z`Iãt^�ä�acfWåG^"[GæIa9fhLOfWç�E\a9fh[ZNæMDc[Z`MVW^�L�ìGe&TM^�g@^�fWëGTbac^{FKâ�d�JML dcä�EYVêEYD9fhç{E\acfW[GN�EYæMæRDc[bEGä.TÇT°EGd�E"îÃJMN°FMEYLO^�Nba.EYVRFID.E�g�`REZä.U[YîQNM[Ya)`�^�fWNMëòEG`MVh^�a9[èõRNRF�EèJMNMfhîÃ[GD9L dcæMD9^�EZFø[GîQC EGDc^�ac[Gâ�[ZæIacfWLÆEYV&d�[ZVhJIa9fh[ZNRdÆëZfhåZ^�NE JMNMfhîÃ[GD9L d�æMD9^�EZF�[Yî�g@^�fWëGTba9d�ìpe&TR^ :�g|�)EGæMæMD9[ZEGä.T�JRdc^�d5Eòd9ä�EGVWEGDcfWç�EYacfW[GN�dcä.TM^�LO^g�f�a9T�E�æMD9[Gæ�^�DcatHOacT°E\a�E�JMNMfhîÃ[GD9L dcæMD9^�EGFÒfhN�æREGD9EGLO^�ac^�D9d@g�fWVhVµëZfhåZ^QDcfêd�^"a9[OE�JMNRf�îÃ[ZDcLd�æMD9^�EZFOfhN5æ°[ZfhNba.dÏ[ZNÆacTM^_^�)ä�fW^�Nba@îÃDc[ZNbacfW^�D{ì � Vêdc[RXZacTM^"LO^�acTR[KF)fWdpfhN°FI^�æ�^�NRFM^�Nba@[Gî;acTR^Dc^�VWEYacfWåG^�dcä�EYVW^�d�[YîµFIfhö�^�Dc^�Nba�[G`Iãt^{ä�acfWåG^@îÃJMN°ä�acfW[GN°d�ìGe&TR^�dcä�EYVêEYD9fhç{E\acfW[GN3dcä.TM^�LO^�fWd#`MD9fW^� RHFI^�d9ä�D9fh`�^�F5`�^�VW[\gì

�;^�a"JRdQä�[ZNRd�fêFI^�D_E5LÇJMVhacfhâ�[Z`Iãt^�ä�acfWåG^�æRDc[Z`MVh^�L EGd�L�fWN O������ ð O®ñ�XÔg�TM^�D9^�� \ !>O��� ð O®ñN\ K���� ð O;ñ�� K�` �!� O"��# # `°^&a9TM^�ä�[ZNRd�acD.EYfWNZa�dc^�a{ì$�;^�a �&% \ ð

/%} `/%� `9���9�a`

/%& ñ�'`°^ a9TM^�JIa9[GæMfêE�æ�[GfWNba?[YîbacTM^ÏLÇJMVhacfhâ�[Z`Iãt^�ä�acfWåG^ [ZæIacfWLOfhç{E\acfW[GNæRDc[Z`MVh^�L2g�fhacT&( [G`Mãt^�ä�a9fhåZ^

îÃJMNRä�a9fh[ZNRd EYN°FPuÒå\EGDcfêEY`MVW^�d�ì)�;^�a#a9TM^&fhNRFMfhåKfêFIJREYVILOfWNMfWLOE"[GîMacTM^@îÃJMN°ä�acfW[GN°d#`°^�E\aca9EGfhNM^{FE\a O %)îÃ[GD&^�EZä.T�1�\ q ` I.`9������`*(�ìIe&TM^ä�[ZNbåZ^�íÆTKJMVWVµ[Yî;a9TM^QfhNRFMfhåKfêFIJREYVµLOfWNMfWLOE�fêdpacTM^�N

[G`Ia.EYfWNM^�Fµìbe&TM^�dcfhLOæMVW^�íO[G`Ma9EYfWNM^{FO`bHÇacTM^"ä�[ZNbåZ^�íÇTKJMVWV�[YîÔacTM^�fhNRFMfhåKfêFIJREYV°LOfhNMfWLÆE�ä�EGN`°^Æ^�íKæRDc^{dcdc^�FÑEZd,+�-�X;g�TM^�Dc^.+ \ ð � ð O %} ñ ` � ð O %� ñ `9����� � ð O %& ñ�ñ"fêdE/(102( LOEYacD9f�íEYNRF�- \ ! ð # } `3# � `9���9��`*# & ñ4'5�,6 &

)* } #)\ q # ì&e&TM^È[GD9fhëZfhN°EYVQdta9JRFIH�dcJMëGëZ^�d�ac^�F2E

d�HId�ac^�LÆEYacfêäQL�^�acTM[IF*[Gî�d�^�a�acfWNMë7- åZ^�ä�ac[GD.d&fWNÑ[GD.FI^�D&a9[ÆõRNRF*E)JMNMfhîÃ[GD9L�VWH�FIfWd�acD9fW`MJIac^{Fd�^�a#[Gî�^��)ä�fW^�Nba æ°[ZfhNba9d�ìGe&TM^�:pg �#d9ä�EYVêEYD9fWç�E\a9fh[ZNÇd9ä.TM^�LO^@a9EGUG^�d#E"æ�[GfWNZa�[ZNÇa9TM^�dcfhLOæMVW^�íEYNRFOa9TM^�NÎd�^{EYD.ä.TM^�d îÃ[GDpacTM^_LOEYíIfhL3JML�FIfWd�a9EGNRä�^"EYVW[GNMë�acTM^"NM[GD9LÆEYV°æ°[ZfhNbacfWNMëÇac[\g&EYD.FMdacTM^�[ZDcfWëGfWN;ìYe&TMfêd�ä.TM[bd�^�NOæ°[ZfhNbaÏLÆE�H�[ZD�LÆE�H�NM[Yap`°^�EQC EGDc^�ac[Yâ�[GæMacfWLOEGVKæ°[ZfhNba�ìd��NONM[GNIâä�[GNKåZ^�íÒdcf�a9JRE\a9fh[ZNRd�XR^�åG^�NÒa9TM^ÇC EGDc^�ac[Yâ�[GæMacfWLOEGV°æ�[GfWNba9d�g�TRfWä.T*ä�EGNMNM[Ga&`�^�[Z`Ia9EGfhNM^{FÒ`KHacTM^5JRd�J°EYV@gp^�fhëZTZa9^�FKâ�dcJML d9ä.TM^�LO^{d�X�EYD9^)æ°[bdcdcfW`MVh^Òac[Ñ`�^Ò[Z`Ia9EGfhNR^�F `KHÉacTMfêdÇLO^�acTM[IFµìe&TM^5:�g|�pdcJM`MæRDc[Z`MVh^�L ð :�g|�98°ñpîÃ[GD�E�ëGfWåG^�N5åZ^�ä�ac[GD�-èfêd�EGd@îÃ[GVWVW[\g�d�ï

LÆE\í;: O�< j>= ^ `dcJM`Iãt^�ä�a�ac[?+�-Jl ^A@u=\ � ð O?ña`

O"B/��`ð IZñ

g�TM^�D9^ @u5fêd#acTR^�NM[GD9LÆEYVMFIfWDc^{ä�a9fh[ZN�EYa acTM^�æ�[GfWNbaC+�-Îæ�[GfWNbacfWNMëQac[\g&EYD.FMd®acTR^�[GD9fhëZfhN;ìYe&TR^d�[ZVhJIa9fh[ZN5[Gî®a9TM^ÇEG`°[\åZ^_æMD9[G`RVh^�L,ëGfWåG^{d@acTM^LÆE\íIfWLÇJML ^ EGNRF�EYVêd�[�a9TM^�ä�[ZDcD9^�dcæ°[ZNRFIfWNMë

Page 5: Indian Academy of Sciencesrepository.ias.ac.in/83508/1/13-a.pdfq9rt|bzY Gz{xvz{y s q9~Ç|bj ¼ q Iq.q9kÈ Gq.¼ q.xvz{lIq. Éj kK Èj lblZx svq *rtz Ê kK }"mZxvrtsvlZx qp µj ntqcrtz

C EYD9^�ac[Gâ�[ZæIacfWLÆEYV;dc[GVWJIacfW[GN?X�O�ì°e&TR^�LO^�acTR[KFÑgp[ZDcUId&^�åZ^�N*g�TM^�N�acTM^ÇNM[GD9LÆEYV?FIfWD9^�ä�a9fh[ZNfWdNR[Ya3EGNÈ^�íMEGä�a�[ZNM^GX?`MJIa3E=MbJREZd�fhâ�NR[GD9LOEGV FIfhD9^�ä�acfW[GN;ì®e&TM^ÆîÃ[GVWVW[\g�fhNMë=MbJREZd�fhâ�NR[GD9LOEGVFIfhD9^�ä�acfW[GNÎåG^{ä�ac[ZDpfêd�dcJMëGëZ^�d�ac^�FÒfhN�]"EGd&^�a�EGV�ì�� q �ï @u=\ Q +��bXKg�TM^�D9^��p\ ðq ` q `��9���a` q ñ 'fWd�E�( 0 q åG^{ä�ac[ZD�ì&e&TM^èEY`�[\åG^�MZJ°EGdcf�â�NM[GD9LÆEYV�FMfhD9^�ä�acfW[GN2T°EGdÒacTM^èæMD9[Gæ�^�DcatHÁacTREYa:�g|� 8 fWdpfWNRFI^�æ�^�N°FI^�Nbap[GîµacTM^_Dc^�VWEYacfWåG^�d9ä�EGVh^{d�[GîµacTM^_[G`Iãt^{ä�acfWåG^�îÃJMNRä�a9fh[ZNRd�ì � LO[KFMf�õR^{FåG^�D.dcfh[ZN�[GîµacTM^�:�g|��EYæRæMDc[bEGä.T ð ä�EYVWVh^{FOacTR^_D9^�ä�JMD9dcfWåG^�UKNM^�^_EYæMæMD9[ZEZä.T°ñ#g&EGd�FM^�åG^�Vh[Zæ°^{F^�Vêd�^�g�TM^�D9^ � I� "îÃ[GD5ä�[GNKåG^�íÁæRDc[Z`MVh^�LÆd�ì � NM[GacTM^�DÎd�acJRFMHÁ^�íKac^�N°FI^�F�a9TM^ÉEGæMæMD9[ZEZä.TÁ`KHJRd�fWNMëÆEOd�JRf�a.EY`MVW^fhNR^9MbJREYVWfhatHÒä�[ZNRdta9D9EGfhNba&ac[ÆFI^�õRNM^�EOdcJM`MæMD9[G`MVW^�L � �� �ì� �ÉÜ����p�#ÛRàbÜÏÙøàtÚ.���� ������{ØIØ��N a9TMfWdÇd�^{ä�acfW[GN?X�g@^Æä�[ZL�æ°EYD9^Ça9TM^ÆEY`�[\åG^3acTMD9^�^Æä�VêEGd9dcfWä�EYV#ëG^�NM^�D.E\a9fhNMë5LO^�acTR[KFRdQg�f�a9T:_S�� � â �~�p[ZNÎE�NKJMLÇ`�^�D�[Gî?atg@[ÆEYNRFÒacTMD9^�^�â�[Z`Iãt^�ä�acfWåG^_ac^{dta�æMD9[G`MVW^�LÆd�ìMe&TM^"ac^{dta�æMD9[G`MâVh^�LOd@EYD9^�ä.TM[bd�^�NÆfhNÒdcJRä.T)Eg&E�HOd�[ÇEZd a9[Çd�HId�ac^�LOEYacfêä�EGVhVWH3fWNKåG^{dta9fhëbE\ac^�å\EGDcfW[GJRdÏEGdcæ°^{ä�a9d[Yî�EGNÆEYVWëG[GD9fhacTML�ì���N�acTM^&a9^�d�a#æRDc[Z`MVh^�LÆd�X�a9TM^�^�íMEGä�a UbNR[\g�Vh^{FIëG^@[Yî�acTM^�C EGDc^�ac[Gâ�[ZæIacfWLÆEYVîÃDc[ZNZa�fêd�E�å\EYfWVêEY`MVW^Gì �R[GDÏä�VWEZdcdcfWä�EYVILO^�a9TM[IFMd�XGEQVhfWLOf�a9^�FOæREGD9EGLO^�acD9fêä@d�acJ°FIHÇfêd æ�^�DcîÃ[GD9L�^{FîÃ[GDÏ^{EGä.TOa9^�d�apæMD9[G`MVW^�LÖEYN°FÆDc^{d�JRV�a.d îÃD9[GL acTM^_`°^{dta@æREYD.EYLO^�a9^�DÏdc^�acacfWNMë3EGDc^�æMDc^{d�^�Nbac^�F;ì�M[GD :"S�� � â ���X°gp^QJRdc^�EOdta.EYNRFREYD.FÒD9^�EGV�â�æREYD.EYLO^�ac^�D�S.g��úEYN°FÒæ�[GVWHKNM[GLOfêEYVµLÇJMa9E\a9fh[ZN[Gæ�^�D.E\ac[ZD�g�fhacT���� \ q K*EYNRF���� \ q KMX;D9^�dcæ°^{ä�a9fhåZ^�VWH � � �ì��R[GD�EYVWVÏæMD9[G`MVW^�LÆd3d�[ZVhåZ^�FJRd�fWNMë :_S�� � â ���XRg@^QJRdc^QEOæ�[GæRJMVWEYacfW[GNÎ[Yî d�fWç�^ q KLKMì�7#%$ ��� 8��! #"%$ / 'L69:'& / � /�4 6 � 1 8�" �;/ � 4�®fWD.dta{XGg@^�ä�[ZNRd�fêFI^�D�atg@[Yâ�[G`Iãt^{ä�acfWåG^)(Ô]"eÁac^{dta@æMD9[G`MVW^�LÆd�� � X+*V �ìZe&TM^�ac^�d�aÏæMD9[G`RVh^�LOdpEYD9^d�VWfhëZTbacVWHÑLO[KFMf�õR^{FÉdc[ÎacTREYaQacTM^�H `�^�ä�[ZLO^�JRNRä�[ZNRdta9D9EGfhNR^�FÑL3JMVhacfhâ�[Z`Iãt^�ä�acfWåG^O[GæIa9fhLOfWç�EYâacfW[GNÇæRDc[Z`MVh^�LÆd�X�EGd®acTR^&SMSMá,LO^�a9TM[IFÇfêd�[GNMVWHEY`MVW^Ïa9[�a.EGä.UKVh^@JMNRä�[GNRd�acD.EYfWNM^{FæMD9[G`MVW^�LÆd�ì� ä�[GNRd�acD.EYfWNM^{FÑåG^�D9dcfW[GNÑ[Gî@SMSIá EYVWëG[ZDcfhacTML fêdQä�JMD9D9^�NbacVWH*`°^�fhNRëÎfWNKåG^{dta9fhëbE\ac^{F*`KH*acTR^EYJIa9TM[GD.d�ì

<t87@ :', / @.-0/ � $9� /34 6 � 1 81" �%/ �32 e&TR^5LO[IFIfhõR^�F3(Ô]"e q a9^�d�aOæRDc[Z`MVh^�L ä�EGNò`�^dta.E\ac^{F�EGdpîÃ[GVWVh[\g�d�ï

áÑfhNMfWLOfhç�^/}\ð O®ñN\ e } `

áÑfhNMfWLOfhç�^/�Gð O®ñN\ � ð O?ñ54 q Q76 8 w9 : O =!: `

g�TM^�D9^ � ð e�ñ+\ q l ;=< } 6 ) * � e �)`

ð � ñ

g�TM^�D9^ acTR^�`°[�íä�[ZNRd�acD.EYfWNZa.d;EYD9^�e } B�� K�` q �X�EYNRF e)B � Q q ` q YîÃ[GD 1�\zI�` � `����9� `u ì{ù�^�D9^GX

gp^)ä.TM[K[bd�^fu \ � KRì;e&TMfWd�L�[IFIfhõR^{F>(Ô]_e q æRDc[Z`MVh^�L TREZd�E*ä�[ZNbåZ^�íÉC EGDc^�ac[Gâ�[ZæIacfWLÆEYVîÃDc[ZNZa{ì;e&TM^)C EYD9^�a9[Yâ�[GæIa9fhLÆEGV#dc[GVWJIa9fh[ZNRdä�[ZDcD9^�dcæ°[ZNRF*a9[=K2� e %} � q EGNRF�e %

)\�KÎîÃ[ZD1 \ I.` � `��9���a`~u ì�e&TMfêd3æMDc[Z`MVW^�L [YöÔ^�D.dÇEÉFIf �)ä�JMV�atH fWNéTREGNRFIVWfhNRëÉEÑVêEYD9ëG^ÒNbJRLÇ`�^�D�[Yî

å�EGDcfêEY`RVh^{d�ìe&TM^ ô JRVh^�D d LO^�a9TM[IFÆg�f�a9TÒEd�ac^�æ5d�fWç�^�[Gî �T\zK�� �EYVW[GNMëg�fhacT@?|\zK�� K�A_fWdpJRdc^�FOfWN

SMSIá ì � N5fWNMfhacfêEYV;d�a9EYDcacfWNMë3æ°[ZfhNba�[email protected][GLOVhH)ä�Dc^{E\a9^�FÆJRdcfWNMë�acTM^Q`�[�íÒä�[GN°dta9D9EGfhNba9d�ì���afWd_ac[5`°^�NM[Gac^�FÑacTREYa_a9TM^ÆSMSIá L�^�acTM[IF Dc^>MZJRfhD9^�d�ëGD.EGFIfW^�Nba_fWNIîÃ[ZDcLÆE\a9fh[ZN;ìÔe?[5LOEGUG^�E

Page 6: Indian Academy of Sciencesrepository.ias.ac.in/83508/1/13-a.pdfq9rt|bzY Gz{xvz{y s q9~Ç|bj ¼ q Iq.q9kÈ Gq.¼ q.xvz{lIq. Éj kK Èj lblZx svq *rtz Ê kK }"mZxvrtsvlZx qp µj ntqcrtz

î¾EYfWD#ä�[GLOæREGDcfêd�[ZN�g�fhacTOEYN ô áÉóÁLO^�a9TM[IFI[GVW[GëZHGX{ëGD.EGFIfW^�Nba.d®EGDc^&ä�EGVWä�JMVWEYac^{F�NKJMLO^�D9fWä�EYVWVhHTM^�D9^ÏEYN°FQacTM^p[\åG^�D9EGVhV�îÃJMN°ä�acfW[GN3^�å\EYVWJREYacfW[GNRdµfêd®Dc^{ä�[GD.FI^{Fµì���fhëZJMD9^ q dcTM[\g�dÔa9TM^Ï[Z`Ia9EGfhNM^{FFIfWd�acD9fW`MJIacfW[GNÉ[YîÏ^��)ä�fW^�NbaQdc[GVWJIa9fh[ZNRd_EYî�ac^�D ILKMX KLKdK ð fWNRdc^�aQæMVh[Ga.ñ_EYNRF q KdKMX KLKLK�îÃJRNRä�a9fh[ZN^�å\EYVWJRE\a9fh[ZNRd�ìÏ]�JR^Ñac[éacTM^ÉJRd�^ [Yî�EéFI^{dcä�^�Nba5FIfWDc^{ä�a9fh[ZN;X�a9TM^ÉSMSIá�L�^�acTM[IF MbJMfêä.UKVhHä�[GNKåZ^�D9ëG^�d�NM^�EGD�a9[Òa9TM^�^�)ä�fW^�NbaQîÃDc[ZNbacfW^�D"fhN acTMfêdQæMD9[G`MVW^�L�ìÔù�[\g@^�åG^�D�XRacTM^ÆdcæMD9^�EGFÑ[Yî

Efficient frontier100,000 evaluations

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

1.4

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1

Efficient frontier20,000 evaluations

f_1

f_2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

1.4

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1

f_2

f_1

����� º��Kº �Ôq9n��Wz�nt}�j�kZu.qz������bÄ=}qcrt|bzY�Æz{k���@��Ë

Efficient frontier100,000 evaluations

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

1.4

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1

Efficient frontier20,000 evaluations

f_2

f_1

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

1.4

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1

f_2

f_1

����� º �Rº �Ôqcn��êz�nt}�j�kbu.q�z��?� ��ÄÖ}q9rt|ZzY�3z�k���@�{Ë

d�[ZVhJIa9fh[ZNRd?EGVh[ZNMë&acTR^Ï^�)ä�fh^�NZa®îÃDc[ZNbacfW^�D?fêd;åZ^�D9H"dcVW[\gì�:�[Gacfêä�^�a9TRE\a®îÃDc[ZLBILKMX KLKdKÏîÃJRNRä�a9fh[ZN^�å\EYVWJRE\a9fh[ZNRd&a9fhVWV q KLKMX KLKdK�îÃJRNRä�a9fh[ZNÑ^�å\EYVWJREYacfW[GNRd�XIacTR^�æMD9[Kä�^�FIJRDc^QõRN°FMd�EÆdcæMD9^�EGF5îÃD9[GLe } \ K�� *Ña9[]e } \ K�� �Iì®e&TM^ÎJRdc^Ò[Yî�E g@Dc[\g�NMfêEYNèLO[Ya9fh[ZNéîÃ[ZD3dcæMDc^{EGFédc^�^�LÆdac[È`�^ac[K[3ëZ^�NM^�Dcfêä�ac[�ëG^�a�EÇî¾EGd�ac^�D�dcæMD9^�EGF5EYVW[GNMëÇacTM^Q^��Æä�fh^�NbapîÃD9[GNbacfW^�D{ì � î�a9^�D�^�åZ^�N q KLKRX KdKLKîÃJMNRä�a9fh[ZN5^�å\EYVWJRE\a9fh[ZNRd�Xba9TM^d�[ZVhJIa9fh[ZNRd&EYD9^�NM[Ga�MZJRf�a9^"[ZN)a9[3a9TM^Q^�)ä�fW^�Nba@îÃDc[ZNbacfW^�D{ìKe&TR^NbJRL�^�Dcfêä�EGV�ëZD9EZFIfh^�NbaÒ^�å\EYVWJREYacfW[GN fêd5ä�[Zd�acVWHGXÏD9^9MbJMfWD9fhNMë I!u îÃJMNRä�acfW[GN2^�å\EYVWJRE\a9fh[ZNRdÆîÃ[ZD^�EGä.T�ëZD9EZFIfh^�Nba�ìN� fhacT2EèVêEYD9ëG^�NKJML3`°^�DÒ[Yîå\EYD9fêEY`MVW^�d�X�d�J°ä.T L�^�acTM[IFMdÒLÆE�Hò`�^�ä�[ZLO^ä�[GLOæMJMa9E\a9fh[ZNREYVWVWH5^�íKæ�^�N°d�fWåG^Zì°ù�[\g@^�åZ^�D{XIacTR^3dcfhL3JMVWEYacfW[GN*D9^�dcJMVha9d�dcTM[\g acT°E\a�a9TMfêd�a9^�d�aæMDc[Z`MVW^�L FI[K^{d_NR[Ya[YöÔ^�DQa9[b[�L3JRä.TÉ[Gî@EÎFIf �Æä�JMVhatHÑac[Îa9TM^)SMSIá LO^�acTR[KFÉfWN MbJMfêä.UKVhHä�[GNKåZ^�D9ëGfWNMëÇNM^{EYD&a9[3a9TM^^�)ä�fh^�NZa�îÃD9[GNba9fh^�D�ì:�^�íKa{XGg@^�EYæMæRVhH3acTM^_e�CÏá-LO^�a9TM[IFµìd�È^�`�^�ëZfhNOa9TM^_dc^�EGD9ä.TOg�fhacT)E�dcfhNRëGVW^�d�[ZVhJMacfW[GNð �]\ q ñ�X#D.EYNRFI[ZLOVhH ä�D9^�EYac^{FédcEYacfêdtîÃHKfWNMëÑa9TM^Î`°[�íòä�[GNRd�acD.EYfWNba9d�ì ��fhëZJMD9^vIÉd�TM[\g�dÇacTR^[G`Ia.EYfWNM^�FÉîÃD9[GNbaÇE\î�a9^�D ILKMX KLKLK ð fWNRdc^�a�æMVW[Ya�ñEYN°F q KLKRX KdKLKÆîÃJRNRä�a9fh[ZN ^�å\EYVWJRE\a9fh[ZNRd�ì7��a�fWdä�VW^�EYD@a9TRE\a&acTR^Qe�Cpá LO^�acTM[IF5æ°^�D�îÃ[ZDcLÆd@^�íKacD9^�LO^�VhHÆg@^�VWVµ[GN (Ô]"e q `�[Ya9T5fWNÒa9^�D9LÆd&[Yîä�[GNKåZ^�D9ëG^�N°ä�^_EGNRFÎLÆEYfWNZa9^�NREGNRä�^Q[Gî�FIfWåG^�D9dcf�atHZì

e&TM^ :�g|��LO^�a9TM[IF NR^�^�FRd"acTM^Æä�[ZLOæMJIa9EYacfW[GNÈ[YîpacTM^OJIa9[GæMfêEÒæ�[GfWNba�ì?e&TRfWd"D9^9MbJMfWDc^�âL�^�Nba5ä�EGJRd�^{d)EYN EZFMFI^�F FMf �)ä�JRV�atHøîÃ[GDÆa9TM^ :pg �OLO^�a9TM[IFµìpù�^�D9^GXÏacTM^ dcJM`MæRDc[Z`MVh^�LÆdEYD9^�d�[ZVhåZ^�FOJRdcfWNMëacTR^"dc^9MbJM^�NZa9fWEGV MbJREZFID9EYacfêä�æMD9[GëZD9EGL�LOfWNMë ð S��"Cpñ LO^�acTM[IFµì���fhëZJMDc^ �ð fWNRd�^�a.ñ#dcTM[\g�d®acTREYa acTM^�:pg ��LO^�a9TM[IFÇfêd�ä�EGæREY`RVh^@[Yî°õRNRFIfWNMë�E_ëG[K[IF3dcæMD9^�EGFÇ[YîÔC EYD9^�ac[Gâ[GæIa9fhLÆEYVÔdc[GVWJIacfW[GNRdp^�åZ^�NÆg�fhacTTIVKMX KLKdK"îÃJMNRä�acfW[GNÒ^�å\EYVWJRE\a9fh[ZNRd�ìKSKfWNRä�^ZXbE3d�HId�ac^�LÆEYacfêä�fWNMf�âacfêEYV æ�[GfWNZa.dQEYD9^�ä�[GNRdcfWFM^�D9^�FÑfWNÉacTMfêdEYæMæRDc[bEGä.T;XÔEÒëZ[K[KFÉd�æRDc^{EGFÑfêd"[G`Ia.EYfWNM^�F;ì���îpLO[GD9^-µâ�åZ^�ä�ac[GD.d&EYD9^QJRd�^{FµXMEOLO[GD9^"FM^�NRdc^�d�^�a�[Yî d�[ZVhJIa9fh[ZNRd�ä�EGN5`�^QîÃ[GJRNRFµì�®fWNREGVhVWHGXpgp^ EGæMæMVWH :"S�� � â ��OîÃ[ZDÒEèa9[Ya9EGV�[GîPILKMX KLKdK ð fhN°d�^�a5æMVW[Ya�ñ)EYN°F q KLKRX KdKLKîÃJMNRä�a9fh[ZNÑ^�å\EGVhJREYacfW[GNRd�ì ��fWëGJMD9^ *)dcTM[\g�d&acT°E\a_^�åG^�NÎg�fhacT�IVKMX KLKdK�^�å\EYVWJRE\a9fh[ZNRd�XREÆëG[K[IF

Page 7: Indian Academy of Sciencesrepository.ias.ac.in/83508/1/13-a.pdfq9rt|bzY Gz{xvz{y s q9~Ç|bj ¼ q Iq.q9kÈ Gq.¼ q.xvz{lIq. Éj kK Èj lblZx svq *rtz Ê kK }"mZxvrtsvlZx qp µj ntqcrtz

Efficient frontier100,000 evaluations

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

1.4

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1

Efficient frontier20,000 evaluations

f_1

f_2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

1.4

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1

f_2

f_1

����� º��Rº �Ôq9n��Wz�nt}�j�kbu.qÇz��p������}q9rt|ZzY��z{k���@��Ë

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

1.4

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1

Efficient frontier20,000 evaluations

f_1

f_2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

1.4

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1f_1

f_2

Efficient frontier100,000 evaluations

����� º���º �Ôq9n��Wz�nt}�j�kbu.q�z��M� �bo&w�½����°}q9rt|bzY�z{k ��@��Ë

FIfWd�acD9fW`MJIacfW[GNÆfêd�EZä.TMfh^�åG^{FµìLg&EGdc^�F�[GNÆEGVhVRacTM^{d�^�dcfWLÇJMVêE\a9fh[ZNRd�XGf�apä�EYNO`�^�ä�[ZNRä�VWJRFI^{F�acTREYaacTM^@(Ô]"e q æMD9[G`MVW^�L fêd`�^�d�adc[GVWåG^{FÑ`KHÑJRdcfWNMë*EÎdcHIdta9^�LÆE\a9fWä�æMD9[Iä�^{FIJMD9^�dcJRä.TèEGd"acTR^:�g|� LO^�acTR[KF;Xbg�TR^�D9^�EGd acTM^Qe�CÏá-[ZD :_S�� � â ��ÏEGVWdc[�æ�^�DcîÃ[GD9LOdÏgp^�VhV�[GNOa9TMfêdÏæMD9[G`RVh^�LÎì<t87@ :', / @.-0/ � " � /34 6 � 1 81" �%/ �32 e&TR^5LO[IFIfhõR^�F3(Ô]"e�I*a9^�d�aOæRDc[Z`MVh^�L ä�EGNò`�^dta.E\ac^{F�EGdpîÃ[GVWVh[\g�d�ï

á*fWNMfWL�fWç�^/} ð O?ñ+\ e } `

á*fWNMfWL�fWç�^/� ð O?ñ+\�� ð O®ñ 4 q Q�� 8 w9 : O =� � : `

g�TR^�D9^�� ð e�ñN\ q l ;=< } 6 ) * � e �)`

ð *Kñg�TM^�D9^)a9TM^�`°[�íéä�[ZNRd�acD.EYfWNZa.d3EGDc^Je } B�� K�` q �EYN°Fne

)B�� Q q ` q ÏîÃ[GD01 \ I.` � `��9��� `u ì

ù�^�D9^_EGëZEGfhNÆg@^�JRdc^�u \ � KMìbe&TMfêdÏæMD9[G`RVh^�L�T°EGd@E�NM[ZNIâ�ä�[GNKåG^�í3^��Æä�fh^�NbapîÃD9[GNbacfW^�D{ìZe&TR^C EYD9^�ac[Gâ�[ZæIacfWLÆEYVbd�[ZVhJIa9fh[ZNRd#ä�[ZDcD9^�dcæ°[ZNRFQa9[�K.� e %} � q EYNRF e %

)\ K�îÃ[ZD 1�\ I.` � `��9��� `u ì

e&TMfWdOæRDc[Z`MVh^�L æMD9[\åbfêFI^{dÇatg@[èFIf �)ä�JMV�a9fh^{dOac[ EGNò[GæMacfWL�fWç�EYacfW[GN�EYVWëG[ZDcfhacTML�ï ð f�ñ3VWEGDcëZ^NbJRLÇ`�^�D�[Yî#å\EYD9fWEG`MVW^�d&EYNRF ð fhf�ñ&E�NM[GNIâ�ä�[ZNKåG^�í)^��)ä�fW^�Nba�îÃDc[ZNbacfW^�D{ì

e&TM^ ô JMVh^�D d�LO^�acTM[IFÑg�fhacTÉEÒd�ac^�æÉd�fWç�^3[Yî �n\ K�� q EGVh[ZNMë)g�fhacT ?p\tK�� K q fêd_JRd�^{FfhN�a9TM^ÉSMSIá EYVWëG[GD9fhacTML�ì ��fWëGJMD9^ Aèd�TR[\g�dOacTM^ [G`Ia.EYfWNM^�F FIfêd�acD9fh`MJMacfW[GN [Yî�dc[GVWJIacfW[GN°dE\î�ac^�DXILKMX KLKLK�EGNRF q KdKMX KLKLK5îÃJMN°ä�acfW[GN ^�å\EYVWJRE\a9fh[ZNRd�ì � VhacTM[ZJMëGTèa9TM^5ä�[GNKåG^�DcëZ^�NRä�^ONM^�EGDacTM^�^�)ä�fW^�Nba_îÃDc[ZNZa"fWd�MbJMfêä.U�dcfWL�fWVêEYD�a9[)a9TRE\aQfhN (Ô]_e q XRa9TM^OFIfWd�acD9fW`MJIacfW[GN fWd_æ°[K[ZD�ì ��NacTM^Oe�CÏá LO^�acTM[IFµXÔg@^ÇJRdc^3EÒæ°[ZæMJMVêE\acfW[GN [YîÏdcfhç�^ q KdKÆD.EYNRFI[ZLOVhH�ä�D9^�EYac^�F dcEYacfêdtîÃHKfWNMëacTM^)`�[�í ä�[GN°dta9D9EGfhNba9d�ì?SK[ZVhJIa9fh[ZNRdÇEYî�ac^�D IVKRX KdKLK�EYNRF q KLKRX KdKLK5^�å\EYVWJRE\a9fh[ZNRd�EGDc^)dcTM[\g�NfhN ��fhëZJMDc^�Mì � ëG[K[IFÒä�[GNKåG^�DcëZ^�NRä�^�EYN°FÒFIfWåG^�D9dcf�atHÆ[Gî®dc[GVWJIacfW[GNRd@fêd@[G`Rdc^�D9åG^{Fµì ��fWëGJMD9^ �d�TM[\g�d®a9TM^�d�[ZVhJIa9fh[ZNRd�[G`Ia.EYfWNM^�FÇJRdcfhNMë_acTR^ :pg|�?LO^�a9TM[IFµì � ëG[K[IFÇdc^�a [YîÔd�[ZVhJIa9fh[ZNRd®^�åG^�Ng�f�a9T�ILKMX KLKdKÑîÃJMN°ä�acfW[GN�^�å�EGVhJ°E\acfW[GN°dOfWdÆEGæMæREYD9^�NbaOîÃD9[GL a9TM^�õRëGJRDc^Zì �®fWëGJRDc^=�èd�TR[\g�dacTM^ :"S�� � â ���dc[GVWJIa9fh[ZNRd�îÃ[ZDpIVKRX KdKLK3îÃJMNRä�acfW[GN*^�å\EGVhJREYacfW[GNRd�ì���a_fWd_ä�VW^�EYD�acTREYa�acTM^ÇNM[GNIâä�[GNKåZ^�íIf�atH�[Yîµa9TM^"^�)ä�fW^�Nba@îÃDc[ZNZa9fh^�D@FMfWFÆNR[Ya&æMDc[\åKfêFI^�EGNbHOæMD9[G`RVh^�L a9[2:pg �pEYNRF)e�CpáEYæMæMD9[ZEZä.TM^�d�Xbg�TMfhVW^QacTR^æ°^�D�îÃ[ZDcLÆEYN°ä�^Q[Yî®acTM^ÇSMSMá�EGæMæMD9[ZEZä.TÒfêd&æ°[K[GD{ì

Page 8: Indian Academy of Sciencesrepository.ias.ac.in/83508/1/13-a.pdfq9rt|bzY Gz{xvz{y s q9~Ç|bj ¼ q Iq.q9kÈ Gq.¼ q.xvz{lIq. Éj kK Èj lblZx svq *rtz Ê kK }"mZxvrtsvlZx qp µj ntqcrtz

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

1.4

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1

Efficient frontier20,000 evaluations

f_2

f_1

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

1.4

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1

f_2

f_1

Efficient frontier100,000 evaluations

����� º��Rº �Ôq9n��Wz�nt}�j�kZu.qz������bÄ=}qcrt|bzY�Æz{k�����\Ë

Efficient frontier100,000 evaluations

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

1.4

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1f_1

f_2 0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

1.4

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1

f_2

f_1

Efficient frontier20,000 evaluations

����� º��Rº �Ôqcn��êz�nt}�j�kbu.q�z��?� ��ÄÖ}q9rt|ZzY�3z�k�����YË

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

1.4

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1

f_2

f_1

Efficient frontier20,000 evaluations

Efficient frontier100,000 evaluations

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

1.4

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1f_1

f_2

����� º��Mº �Ôq9n��Wz�nt}�j�kbu.qÇz��p������}q9rt|ZzY��z{k�����\Ë

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

1.4

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1

f_2

f_1

20,000 evaluationsEfficient frontier

����� º��Rº �Ôq9n��Wz�nt}�j�kbu.q�z��M� �bo&w�½����°}q9rt|bzY�z{k ����\Ë

<t87@ :', / @.-0/ �&� � /34 6 � 1 81" �%/ �32 e&TR^5LO[IFIfhõR^�F3(Ô]"e � a9^�d�aOæRDc[Z`MVh^�L ä�EGNò`�^dta.E\ac^{F�EGdpîÃ[GVWVh[\g�d�ï

á*fWNMfWL�fWç�^/}\ð O?ñ+\ e } `

á*fWNMfWL�fWç�^/�Gð O?ñ+\�� ð eÔñ54 q Q76 8 w9 : O = Q 8 w9 : O = dcfhN ðq K���e } ñ : `

g�TR^�D9^�� ð e�ñN\ q l ;=< } 6 ) * � e �)`

ð AZñg�TM^�D9^ÆacTR^Ò`�[�í ä�[GNRd�acD.EYfWNba9d�EGDc^ke } Bt� K�` q �X®EGNRFne

)Bt� Q q ` q �îÃ[GD 1P\ I.` � `��9��� `u ì

�É^èJRdc^ u \ � KRì@e&TMfêdÎæMD9[G`MVW^�L TREZd�Eøä�[GNKåG^�í FMfWd9ä�[ZNZa9fhNKJM[ZJRd5^�)ä�fW^�Nba�îÃDc[ZNbacfW^�D{ìe&TM^ÎC EGDc^�ac[Ñ[ZæIacfWLÆEYV�dc[GVWJIacfW[GNRd�ä�[ZDcD9^�dcæ�[GNRFÈa9[�K�� e %} � q EYNRF e %

)\ KÑîÃ[GD01 \

I.` � `��9���a`~u ìRe&TM^ ô JMVh^�D d�LO^�a9TM[IF�g�f�a9TÑE)d�ac^�æ*dcfhç�^ �]\�K�� AOEYVW[GNRë�g�fhacTÉEYN ?�\zK�� K qfWdÏJRd�^{FOfhNÎSMSIá ì���fhëZJMDc^�HÇd�TM[\g�d acTM^_[G`Ia.EYfWNM^�FÆFIfêd�acD9fh`MJMacfW[GN)E\î�a9^�D q KLKRX KdKLK_îÃJMNRä�acfW[GNRd^�å\EYVWJRE\a9fh[ZNRd�ìKó_NMVWH�E�æ°[ZD�a9fh[ZNÆ[YîÔacTM^_^�)ä�fW^�Nba�îÃD9[GNba9fh^�DÏfêdÏFIfêdcä�[\åG^�Dc^{F3`KH3acTMfêd�LO^�acTM[IFµìe&TM^Çe�CÏá LO^�acTM[IF�fêd�EYæRæMVhfW^�F�g�fhacTÉEYN*fWNMf�a9fWEGV?æ�[GæMJRVWEYacfW[GN*[Yî�dcfhç�^ AIX KLKdKMXID.EYNRFM[GLOVhHä�D9^�E\a9^�Fèd9E\acfêd�îÃHbfWNMëÎacTR^)`°[�íèä�[ZNRdta9D9EGfhNba.d�ì ��fWëGJMD9^ q K*dcTM[\g�d"acTR^)[G`Ia.EYfWNM^�Fèdc[GVWJIacfW[GN°dE\î�ac^�D q KLKRX KdKLK^�å\EYVWJRE\a9fh[ZNRd�ìIe&TM^"õRëZJMD9^"dcTM[\g�dpacTREYa�EYVWVÔFMfWd9ä�[ZNMNM^�ä�ac^{FÒ^��Æä�fh^�Nba@îÃD9[GNba.d

Page 9: Indian Academy of Sciencesrepository.ias.ac.in/83508/1/13-a.pdfq9rt|bzY Gz{xvz{y s q9~Ç|bj ¼ q Iq.q9kÈ Gq.¼ q.xvz{lIq. Éj kK Èj lblZx svq *rtz Ê kK }"mZxvrtsvlZx qp µj ntqcrtz

EYD9^�FIfWd9ä�[\åZ^�D9^�F3`KHÇa9TMfWdÏLO^�acTR[KF;ìd��aÏfêd�NR[Yac^�gp[ZD�a9TKH�acT°E\aÏg�fhacTJILKMX KLKdK�^�å�EGVhJ°E\acfW[GN°d acTR^ä�[GLOæMVW^�a9^QîÃDc[ZNba&g&EGd@NM[Ga�îÃJMVWVhHÎFIfWd9ä�[\åZ^�D9^�FÒ`bH)acTM^�e�Cpá LO^�a9TM[IFµì

Efficient frontier100,000 evaluations

−1

−0.5

0

0.5

1

1.5

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1f_1

f_2

����� º��Rº �Ôq9n��Wz�nt}�j�kZu.qz������bÄ=}qcrt|bzY�Æz{k�����YË

Efficient frontier100,000 evaluations

−1

−0.5

0

0.5

1

1.5

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1

f_2

f_1

����� º����Rº �Ôqcn��êz�nt}�j�kbu.qÑz��Ç� ��Ä }q9rt|bzY�z{k ����YË

100,000 evaluationsEfficient frontier

−1

−0.5

0

0.5

1

1.5

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1f_1

f_2

����� º�� �Kº �Ôq9n��Wz�nt}�j�kbu.q&z��Ô� ���®}qcrt|bzY�z{k�����YË

−1

−0.5

0

0.5

1

1.5

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1

f_2

f_1

20,000 evaluationsEfficient frontier

����� º�� �Mº �Ôq9n��Wz�nt}�j�kZu.q z�� � �bo&wϽ¾���}q9rt|ZzY�3z{k ����YË

�®fWëGJRDc^ qdq d�TR[\g�dÔacTM^@FIfêdta9DcfW`MJIa9fh[ZN[YîKacTM^ :�g|�ÔLO^�acTR[KFÇE\î�ac^�D q KLKMX KLKdK@^�å\EYVWJRE\a9fh[ZNRd�ì��a�fêdOEYæMæREGDc^�Nba�acTREYa�NR[YaÆEYVWV@FIfêd9ä�[GNRNM^�ä�ac^�Fò^�)ä�fW^�Nba�îÃDc[ZNba9d�EYD9^5FIfêdcä�[\åG^�Dc^{FÉ`KHèa9TMfWdEYæMæMD9[ZEZä.T;ì � V�a9TM[GJMëZT*acTR^ :pg ��LO^�acTM[IFÑæ�^�DcîÃ[GD9LO^�F�åZ^�D9H5g@^�VWV®[ZN (Ô]"e q EYN°F (Ô]"e�IæMDc[Z`MVW^�LÆd�TRE�åKfhNMëQEQä�[ZNZa9fhNKJM[ZJRd�^�)ä�fW^�Nba#îÃD9[GNba�X{acTR^&FMfWd9ä�[ZNMNM^�ä�ac^{FINM^�d9d#[Yî°acTM^&^��Æä�fh^�NbaîÃDc[ZNZa9fh^�D®dc^�^�LOd;ac[_TRE�åG^�æRDc[\åKfêFI^�FQFIf �)ä�JMVhatHQac[�a9TMfêd®EGæMæMD9[ZEGä.T?ì�SKfWNRä�^pNM[Ya#EYVWVGîÃD9[GNba9d®EYD9^FIfWd9ä�[\åZ^�D9^�FµX{a9TMfWd�L�^�acTM[IFO^�NRFMd JMæ�õRN°FIfhNRë�EFI[GLOfWNRE\a9^�F3æ°[ZD�a9fh[ZN�[Gî°a9TM^&acD9JM^�^��Æä�fh^�NbaîÃDc[ZNZa9fh^�D�ì@SKfhN°ä�^*a9TM^ÑfêFI^�Eè[GîQNR[GNIâ�FI[GLOfWNRE\a9fh[ZNøfêd)NR[YaÒ`MJRfhVhaÒfWN�acTM^ :pg|�OEGæMæMD9[ZEZä.T;Xf�a�^�NRFMd3JMæ õ°NRFIfWNMë dc[GLO^)NM[ZNIâ�^��)ä�fW^�Nba3æ�[GfWNba9d�ì � ä�[GLOæREGDcfêd�[ZNèg�f�a9T acTM^ :_S�� � â �~�Dc^{d�JMVha9d ð �®fWëGJRDc^ q IZñ�fWNRFIfêä�EYac^{d�a9TM^ :_S�� � â �~�_g�fhacTÈ[GNRVhH]ILKMX KLKLKÒ^�å\EYVWJREYacfW[GNRd"fêd"EG`MVW^ac[OõRNRF�EGVhV;FIfêd9ä�[GNRNM^�ä�ac^�F5^�)ä�fh^�NZa�îÃD9[GNba.d�ì- / ��� � /34 6 � 1 8�" �;/ �32 :�^�íKa�X�gp^ÒJRd�^)acTM^ q K\â�å\EYD9fWEG`MVh^ (Ô]"e **a9^�d�a3æMD9[G`MVW^�L � � �ìe&TMfWd�æMD9[G`RVh^�L�T°EGd�E*ac[Ga9EGVp[Gî q KLK FIfWd�acfWNRä�aOVW[Iä�EGVp^��Æä�fh^�NbaÇîÃD9[GNba9d3fhNòacTM^Î[G`Mãt^�ä�a9fhåZ^

Page 10: Indian Academy of Sciencesrepository.ias.ac.in/83508/1/13-a.pdfq9rt|bzY Gz{xvz{y s q9~Ç|bj ¼ q Iq.q9kÈ Gq.¼ q.xvz{lIq. Éj kK Èj lblZx svq *rtz Ê kK }"mZxvrtsvlZx qp µj ntqcrtz

d�æREZä�^ZìGe&TM^�ëGVW[G`°EYVRC EGDc^�ac[Yâ�[GæMacfWLOEGVbdc[GVWJIa9fh[ZNRd�ä�[ZDcD9^�dcæ�[GNRFÇac[PK.� e %} � q EYN°F e %)\ K

îÃ[GD 1�\ I�` � `9���9�a`u ìbe&TM^_EGVhëZ[GD9f�a9TMLÆd#î¾EGä�^�E�FIf �)ä�JMVhatHOfhNÆ[\åZ^�D.ä�[GLOfWNMëEVêEYD9ëG^�NKJMLÇ`�^�D[Yî#Vh[Iä�EGVÔîÃDc[ZNba9d�EYN°F5ä�[GNKåG^�DcëZfhNMëÇac[�acTR^ëGVW[G`REGVÔîÃDc[ZNZa{ì

e&TM^ ô JMVW^�D� d&L�^�acTM[IFÎg�fhacTÑEOdta9^�æ*dcfhç�^[Yî �=\ K�� q EYVW[GNRë�g�fhacT ? \ K�� KdK q fWd�JRd�^{FfhN*SMSIá ìRó_NMVWH)EÇîÃ^�g2g@^�EGUÆC EYD9^�ac[Gâ�[ZæIacfWLÆEYV�d�[ZVhJIa9fh[ZNRd ð

/} \zK3EGNRF

/� \ �VKac[ �!K�� *Kñ

EYD9^_îÃ[ZJMNRFÎE\î�a9^�DpILKMX KLKLKÇ^�å\EYVWJREYacfW[GNRd�ìRSKfWNRä�^"acTR^ÇSMSIá�LO^�acTR[KFÎD9^9MbJMfWDc^{dpîÃJMNRä�a9fh[ZNRd&a9[`°^Æatg�fêä�^Æä�[GNbacfWNKJM[GJRdcVWHZâ�FIfhö�^�Dc^�NbacfêEY`MVW^ÆEYNRFèdcfhNRä�^@(Ô]"e *ÎfêdNM[Gaatg�fWä�^)FIfhö�^�Dc^�NZa9fWEG`MVW^æMDc^{ä�fêd�^�VhH�E\a�e } \BKRXRa9TM^ÇëZD9EZFIfW^�Nba_ä�[ZLOæMJIa9EYacfW[GN*fêd�^�DcD9[GNR^�[GJ°d�E\a�e } \ KRX°D9^�dcJMVhacfWNMëfhN*E3î¾EYfWVhJRDc^Q[Yî�acTR^L�^�acTM[IFµì

e&TM^Òe�CÏá LO^�a9TM[IFèfWd3EYæMæRVhfW^�Fèg�fhacT IMX KdKLKÎfWNMf�a9fWEGVpdc[GVWJIacfW[GN°dD9EGNRFI[ZL�VWHÉä�Dc^{E\a9^�FdcEYacfêdtîÃHKfWNMë�acTM^Ò`°[�íèä�[GN°dta9D9EGfhNba9d�ì7��fWëGJMD9^ q � dcTM[\g�dQacT°E\a3E*dc^�aÇ[Gî&FM[GLOfhN°E\ac^{FèVh[Iä�EYVhâC EYD9^�ac[Gâ�[ZæIacfWLÆEYV;dc[GVWJIacfW[GN°d�fêd_FIfêd9ä�[\åG^�Dc^{F�E\î�ac^�D q KLKRX KdKLK�^�å\EYVWJREYacfW[GNRd�ì°e&TM^3[GæIa9fhLOfWç�EYâacfW[GN EGVhëZ[GD9f�a9TML J°d�^{F*fhNÑacTM^�e�CÏá LO^�a9TM[IF ä�EYN*ëG^�a"d�acJRä.UÎa9[ÒE)VW[Iä�EYVhâ�[GæIa9fhLÆEYV�d�[ZVhJMâacfW[GNÉEGNRF*a9TM^ (Ô]"e *5æMD9[G`RVh^�L g�f�a9TÉLÆEYNKH�VW[Kä�EYV#^�)ä�fh^�NZa"îÃD9[GNbacfW^�DQæMD9[\åKfWFI^{d�^�NM[GJRëGTFIf �)ä�JMV�atH�ac["acTMfêd�EGæMæMD9[ZEGä.T�îÃ[GD�õRNRFIfWNMë"acTR^&acD9JM^&ëGVW[G`REGVb^��)ä�fW^�Nba#îÃDc[ZNZa9fh^�D�ì\e&TM^&L3JMV�a9f�â

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

3.5

4

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1

Efficient frontier100,000 evaluations

f_1

f_2

����� º�� �Rº �Ôq9n��êz�nt}�j�kZu.q*z��Ç� �®Ä�}q9rt|ZzY�z�k �����ZË

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

1.4

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1

f_2

f_1

100,000 evaluationsEfficient frontier

����� º�� �°º �Ôq9n��Wz�nt}�j�kZu.q z�� � �bo&wϽ¾���}q9rt|ZzY�3z{k ����GË

L�[IFMEGVhfhatH)[Gî®a9TM^�d�^{EYD.ä.TÎdcæREZä�^EYVêd�[Oä�EGJRdc^�d@acTR^5:�g|�pLO^�acTM[IF5ac[ÆNM[Ga�õRNRF5acTR^ëGVW[G`REGV^�)ä�fW^�Nba�îÃD9[GNbacfW^�D{ìGe&TM^�S��"CèL�^�acTM[IFOfêd�fWNREGFM^9MbJRE\a9^&ac[õ°NRF�acTM^�ëGVW[G`REGVI[GæIa9fhLÆEYV�d�[ZVhJMâacfW[GNRd�ì��®fWëGJRDc^ q *_dcTM[\g�d;acTREYa :"S�� � â ��?g�f�a9T q KLKMX KLKdK&^�å\EYVWJREYacfW[GNRd?fWd#EY`RVh^pac["ä�[GNKåZ^�D9ëG^ac[OacTR^"ëZVh[Z`REYVµ^��)ä�fW^�Nba�îÃDc[ZNbacfW^�D{ì

e&TM^èæMDc[Z`MVW^�L (Ô]"e *�æMD9[\åbfêFI^{d5FIf �)ä�JMVhatH2fWNÓac^�D9LÆd�[Yî�LÇJMVhacfhâ�LO[IFMEGVhfhatH�[Yî�acTR^d�^{EYD.ä.TødcæREGä�^Gì���a)fêdO^�åKfWFM^�NbaÆîÃDc[ZL acTR^Ñd�fWLÇJMVêE\a9fh[ZNøD9^�dcJMVha9d�a9TRE\aÆa9TM^Ñä�VêEGd9d�fêä�EGV&ëG^�NMâ^�D.E\acfWNMëÈLO^�acTR[KFRdOî¾EGä�^Î^�NM[GD9LO[GJRd�æMD9[G`RVh^�LOd�fWN�[\åG^�D.ä�[ZLOfhNMëÑacTM^*L3JMV�a9f�â�LO[IFMEYVWf�a9fh^{d�Xg�TM^�D9^�EZd�fWNÑacTRfWd_atHKæ°^3[YîÏæRDc[Z`MVh^�LÆd�^�åZ[GVWJIacfW[GN°EYD9H5L3JMV�a9f�â�[G`Mãt^�ä�a9fhåZ^ ð¾ô áÉóQñ�L�^�acTM[IFMdEYD9^_îÃ[ZJMNRF5ac[O`�^JRdc^�îÃJMV�ì

Page 11: Indian Academy of Sciencesrepository.ias.ac.in/83508/1/13-a.pdfq9rt|bzY Gz{xvz{y s q9~Ç|bj ¼ q Iq.q9kÈ Gq.¼ q.xvz{lIq. Éj kK Èj lblZx svq *rtz Ê kK }"mZxvrtsvlZx qp µj ntqcrtz

<t87@ :', / @ - / ��� � /�4 6 � 1 81" �;/ �32 e&TM^vu \ q K*å\EYD9fWEG`MVh^ÒL�[IFIfhõR^{F (Ô]"e *a9^�d�aæMDc[Z`MVW^�L,fêd�EGd@îÃ[ZVhVW[\g�d�ï

áÑfhNMfWLOfhç�^/} ð O®ñN\ q Q ^�íKæ ðrQ *Le } ñIdcfWN�� ð *���e } ñ `

áÑfhNMfWLOfhç�^/� ð O®ñN\ � ð O?ñ 4 q Q ��� w : O =9 : O = � � : `

g�TM^�D9^�� ð e�ñN\ q l H�� 6 ) * � e �)� ð u Q q ñ� c� �� `

ð bñ

g�TM^�D9^�acTR^�`�[�íOä�[GNRd�acD.EYfWNba9d�EGDc^ e } B�� K�` q ÔEYNRFfe)Bn� Q q ` q RîÃ[GD 1�\ I�` � `9���9�a`u ìbe&TMfWd

æMDc[Z`MVW^�L-TREGdQEÒNM[GNIâ�ä�[ZNKåG^�í*EYN°F*NM[GNMâ�JMNRf�îÃ[ZDcLOVWH�dcæREZä�^�FÉC EYD9^�a9[Yâ�[GæIa9fhLÆEYV®d�[ZVhJIa9fh[ZNRd�ìe&TM^ÎC EGDc^�ac[Gâ�[ZæIacfWLÆEYVpdc[GVWJIa9fh[ZNRdOä�[GD9D9^�dcæ°[ZNRFèac[ K�� e %} � q EYN°F0e %

)\ K îÃ[GD01X\

I.` � `��9���a`~u ì�e&TM^ ô JMVW^�D� dOL�^�acTM[IFÁg�fhacT Eèdta9^�æ d�fWç�^�[Gî � \ K�� q A EGVh[ZNMëèg�f�a9T7?=\K�� KLK q fêd�JRdc^�FOfWNÒSMSIáéì ��fhëZJMD9^ q AQdcTM[\g�d#acTR^�FIfêdta9DcfW`MJIa9fh[ZNÆ[Yîµ[G`Ia.EYfWNM^�FOdc[GVWJIacfW[GNÆEYî�ac^�Dq KLKRX KdKLK"îÃJMN°ä�acfW[GNÎ^�å\EGVhJREYacfW[GNRd�ìKe&TM^EYVWëG[GD9fhacTMLÖfêdpNR[Ya�EY`MVW^�a9[Çõ°NRFÒE3gp^�VhVhâ�ä�[GNKåZ^�D9ëG^�Fd�^�a�[Yîµd�[ZVhJIa9fh[ZNRd�ì � VhacTM[ZJMëGT�acTR^�D9^�fWd#NM[VW[Iä�EGVI^�)ä�fW^�Nba îÃD9[GNbacfW^�D�EYa acTM^�VW[Iä�E\a9fh[ZNOg�TM^�D9^acTM^ÎEYVWëG[GD9fhacTML ëG^�a.dÇd�acJRä.UÔX®æREYD.EYLO^�a9^�D.dQæMVêE�HÈEGN fhLOæ�[GDca9EYNbaÇD9[GVW^ÆfWN acTM^Îd�J°ä�ä�^{dcd�[YîSMSIá-EYNRF3fWN3a9TMfêd#æMDc[Z`MVW^�Lúfha�fWd dc^�^�NÇa9TRE\a îÃ[ZD�d�LÆEGVhVIå\EYVWJM^{d#[Yî°æ°EYD.EYLO^�a9^�D.d?a9TM^�D9^&fWd EGNEGd9ä�^�NbaÏfWNÆîÃJMN°ä�acfW[GN°d�XbfhN°dta9^�EGF)[Yî?E�FI^{dcä�^�NbapfWNÆa9TM^�L�ì � a9TM^�[ZDc^�acfêä�EYV�EYNREGVhHIdcfWdÏd�JMëZëG^{dta.dacTREYaÏE\a�^�EZä.T3æ�[GfWNbaNOÒa9TM^�FIfWDc^{ä�a9fh[ZN ðQ�RIð eÔñ�ñ#fêd EFI^�d9ä�^�Nba FMfhD9^�ä�acfW[GN�îÃ[GD�EGVhVIîÃJRNRä�a9fh[ZNRd�XTM[\gp^�åG^�D@g�fhacT*E3õRNMfhac^�d�ac^�æ*d�fWç�^"acTRfWd�D9^�dcJMVha�FI[K^�d&NM[Ga�TM[GVêFµì

e&TM^Èe�Cpá�LO^�a9TM[IF2g�fhacT q X KLKdKéfWNMfhacfêEYVQD9EGNRFI[ZLAd�[ZVhJIa9fh[ZNRdÎæMD9[KFMJRä�^{dÎEÁdc^�a�[Yîd�[ZVhJIa9fh[ZNRd@ä�VW[Zdc^�Dpac[�a9TM^Q^�)ä�fW^�Nba@îÃDc[ZNbacfW^�D{XZ`MJMapa9TM^�D9^"EGDc^_[GNMVWHÆEîÃ^�gÓdc[GVWJIacfW[GNRdÏîÃ[GJRNRF^�åG^�NÈEYî�ac^�D q KLKRX KdKLK)îÃJMNRä�a9fh[ZNè^�å\EYVWJRE\a9fh[ZNRd ð ��fWëGJMD9^ q bñ�ì �M[ZDQacTMfêdæMD9[G`RVh^�LÎXÔa9TM^�D9^OfWdE�dcVW[\g2fWL�æRDc[\åZ^�LO^�Nba&fhN�^�EZä.T5fhac^�D9EYacfW[GNÎEYNRFÎ`KHÆacTR^QacfWL�^Qa9TM^�dc[GVWJIacfW[GNÎDc^{EGä.TM^{d@NM^�EGDacTM^�^��)ä�fW^�Nba îÃDc[ZNbacfW^�D{X�acTM^�d�ac^�æÆd�fWç�^ ^ ) `�^�ä�[GLO^�d�åG^�D9HÇdcLÆEYVWVREYNRF�fhaÏg@[GJMVêF�a.EYUZ^�EQVh[ZNMëacfWL�^`�^�îÃ[ZDc^"a9TM^�d�[ZVhJMacfW[GNRd@î¾EGVhV;[ZNÒa9TM^^�)ä�fh^�NZa�îÃD9[GNba9fh^�D�ì

e&TM^ :�g|�ÇLO^�a9TM[IF ð ��fhëZJMD9^ q �YñÇæ°^�D�îÃ[ZDcLÆdOæ�[K[GD9VhH [ZNòa9TMfWd)æMDc[Z`MVW^�L�ì�SKfhN°ä�^�acTR^FI^�NRdcfhatH�[YîMdc[GVWJIacfW[GN°d;EYVW[GNMë@a9TM^ îÃD9[GNbacfW^�D;fêdµNM[ZNIâ�JMNMfhîÃ[GD9LÎX�acTM^pS��"C�L�^�acTM[IFEGVh[ZNMë&g�f�a9TacTM^ :pg|�;dta9D9EYac^�ëZH�fêd;JMNREG`MVW^ ac[�õ°NRF�E&ëG[K[IFFIfêdta9DcfW`MJIa9fh[ZN;ì�ó_NQa9TM^�[GacTM^�D;TREYN°FµX :"S�� � â��OfWd5EY`MVW^�ac[éõRNRF EèëG[K[IF�ä�[ZNbåZ^�D9ëG^�NRä�^*EYN°FÁFMfWd�acD9fh`RJIacfW[GN g�fhacT q KLKMX KLKdKÑîÃJRNRä�a9fh[ZN^�å\EYVWJRE\a9fh[ZNRd ð ��fWëGJMD9^ q �bñ�ì

g@EZd�^{FÆ[GN5acTR^�dc^"dcfhL3JMVêE\acfW[GN°d�XKg@^"fWNIîÃ^�Dpa9TRE\a�E�NM[ZNIâ�JRNMf�îÃ[ZDcL,FM^�NRdcf�atHÆ[Gî�dc[GVWJIacfW[GN°dfhN*a9TM^Ç[Z`Iãt^�ä�acfWåG^ÇdcæREZä�^ ð g�TMfWä.T [Kä�ä�JMD.d�fWNÑLÆEYNKHÎDc^{EYVhâ�g@[GD9VêF5æRDc[Z`MVh^�LÆd � � Ãñ&æMD9[\åbfêFI^{d^�NM[ZJMëGTéFIf �)ä�JMVhatHÈac[ acTM^Îä�VêEGd9d�fêä�EGV�ëG^�NM^�D.E\a9fhNMë L�^�acTM[IFMd�ì#e&TM^�dc^ÒEYD9^ÒEGNM[Ya9TM^�D�ä�VêEGd9d[Yîp[ZæIacfWLOfhç{E\a9fh[ZNÉæMD9[G`RVh^�LOdQfWNÈg�TMfWä.T ô áÉó�LO^�a9TM[IFI[GVW[GëZH*æ°^�D�îÃ[ZDcLÆdä�[ZLOæREYD.E\a9fhåZ^�VWH`°^�a�ac^�D�acT°EYNÎacTM^�ä�VWEZdcdcfêä�EYVÔLO^�a9TM[IFMd�ì

�7#W" �P) 1!/3/ �! #"%$ / 'L69: & / � /34 60� 1 81" �;/ � 4:�[\gXKgp^ä�[GNRdcfWFM^�D�E3ä�[GJMæRVh^"[Yî®acTMD9^�^�â�[Z`Iãt^�ä�acfWåG^_ac^�d�a�æMD9[G`MVW^�LÆd&FI^�åZ^�VW[Gæ�^�FÒ^�Vêd�^�g�TM^�D9^� V µac[)d�acJRFIHÒacTM^`�^�T°E�åbfW[GD&[Gî�EYVWVµîÃ[ZJMD�EYVWëG[ZDcfhacTMLÆd�ì

/ �� - "�� /�4 6 � 1 8�" �;/ �32 ��fWD9d�a�X{g@^pä�[ZNRdcfWFI^�D;a9TM^ q I�â�å\EYD9fWEG`MVh^�]"e � (7I&ac^{dta#æMD9[G`MVW^�LTRE�åKfhNMë�EÇd�æMTR^�D9fWä�EYVM^��Æä�fh^�Nba�îÃDc[ZNbapdcEYacfêdtîÃHKfWNMë / �} l / �� l / �� \ q fhNOa9TM^�D.EYNMëZ^

/} `/� B

� K�` q �ì�e&TM^ ô JMVh^�D dÆLO^�a9TM[IFÁg�f�a9T�EÈd�ac^�æ�d�fWç�^�[Gî�� \ K�� q EGNRF7? \ K�� K q fWd)JRd�^{F

Page 12: Indian Academy of Sciencesrepository.ias.ac.in/83508/1/13-a.pdfq9rt|bzY Gz{xvz{y s q9~Ç|bj ¼ q Iq.q9kÈ Gq.¼ q.xvz{lIq. Éj kK Èj lblZx svq *rtz Ê kK }"mZxvrtsvlZx qp µj ntqcrtz

Efficient frontier100,000 evaluations

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1

f_2

f_1

����� º����Rº �Ôq9n��êz�nt}�j�kZu.q�z������ZÄ }q9rt|bzY��z{k��� �YË

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

1.4

0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1

Efficient frontier100,000 evaluations

f_1

f_2

����� º����Mº �Ôqcn��êz�nt}�j�kbu.qÑz��Ç� ��Ä }q9rt|bzY�z{k �� �YË

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

1.4

0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1

Efficient frontier100,000 evaluations

f_1

f_2

����� º�� �Mº �Ôq9n��Wz�nt}�j�kbu.q&z��Ô� ���®}qcrt|bzY�z{k��� �YË

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

1.4

0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1

f_2

f_1

100,000 evaluationsEfficient frontier

����� º����Mº �Ôq9n��Wz�nt}�j�kZu.q z�� � �bo&wϽ¾���}q9rt|ZzY�3z{k �� �YË

fhN SMSIá ì �®fWëGJRDc^ q HÎdcTM[\g�dQEYVWV [G`Ia.EYfWNM^�FÈd�[ZVhJMacfW[GNRdQE\î�a9^�D q KLKMX KLKdKÆ^�å\EGVhJREYacfW[GNRd�ì���afWdä�VW^�EYD3acT°E\a�acTM^*SMSIá EYæMæRDc[bEGä.T fêd�EG`MVW^)ac[ÈëG^�a3a9TM^�d�[ZVhJIa9fh[ZNRd3[GNéa9TM^5îÃDc[ZNZa9fh^�D�X�`MJIaacTM^"FIfWd�acD9fW`MJIacfW[GNÒ[Yî?dc[GVWJIacfW[GNRd ð [Z`Ia9EGfhNM^{FÆLÆEYfWNMVWH�`KH3acTM^ g@Dc[\g�NRfWEGNOEGæMæMD9[ZEZä.T°ñ�fWdpNM[GaEGFI^>MZJ°E\ac^Zì3��a&g�fWVWVÔa9EYUZ^_^�NM[GD9LO[GJRdpNKJMLÇ`�^�D&[Gî®^�å\EGVhJREYacfW[GNRdpîÃ[ZDpa9TM^EYVWëG[ZDcfhacTML�a9[3õ°NRFE5FIfêd�acD9fh`MJMacfW[GNèEGä�D9[Zd9d�acTM^Æä�[ZLOæMVh^�ac^O^�)ä�fh^�NZaQîÃD9[GNbacfW^�D{ìµù�[\g@^�åZ^�DQEGdQEYæMæ°EYD9^�Nba�îÃD9[GLacTM^ÇõRëGJMD9^GX�FIJM^Çac[)a9TM^3FM^�d9ä�^�Nba_FMfhD9^�ä�acfW[GNÑfha_NM^�^�FMd�[GNMVWHÎîÃ^�g fhac^�D9EYacfW[GN�ac[ÒDc^{EGä.T�acTR^^�)ä�fW^�Nba�îÃD9[GNbacfW^�D{ì

e&TM^Òe&fWL�LO^�V� d�LO^�a9TM[IF fêdÇEYæRæMVhfW^�FèNR^�íKa3g�fhacT q X KdKLKÎfWNMf�a9fWEGVÏD.EYNRFM[GL d�[ZVhJIa9fh[ZNRd�ì� î�ac^�D q KdKMX KLKdK)^�å\EGVhJREYacfW[GNRd�XÔacTR^)EYæMæMD9[ZEZä.T fêd�EY`RVh^�ac[�õ°NRFèE5ëZ[K[KFÈä�[\åZ^�D.EYëZ^Ç[Yî@acTR^^�NbacfWDc^"^�)ä�fh^�NZa&îÃD9[GNbacfW^�D ð ��fWëGJMD9^ IVKZñ�ì3��a&fêd&fWNZa9^�D9^�d�acfWNMë�a9TRE\a&a9TM^Q`°[ZJMNRFMEGDcH)dc[GVWJIacfW[GN°dEYD9^)EGFI^>MZJ°E\ac^�VhHèFIfêdcä�[\åG^�Dc^{F `KHÉacTMfêd3EGæMæMD9[ZEZä.T;ì;e&TM^ :pg|�QEGæMæMD9[ZEZä.T;X?E\î�a9^�D q KLKRX KdKLK^�å\EYVWJRE\a9fh[ZNRd�X�õRNRFMd®E&îÃ^�gèg@^�VWV�â�FIfêdta9DcfW`MJIa9^�Fdc[GVWJIacfW[GN°d ð ��fWëGJMD9^ I q ñ�ìa��îMLO[ZDc^ ^�å�EGVhJ°E\acfW[GN°dEYD9^@EGVhVW[\gp^{FµX�acTM^&D9^�LÆEYfWNMfWNMë_æ�[GDcacfW[GN3[Yî°acTM^&^�)ä�fh^�NZa#îÃD9[GNbacfW^�D#LÆE�H�EYVêdc[_`�^�FIfWd9ä�[\åZ^�D9^�F`bHÑacTMfêdLO^�a9TM[IFµX?TM[\g@^�åZ^�D_acTM^ÆD9^9MbJMfWD9^�LO^�Nba[Yî�EÎVWEGDcëZ^�NKJML3`°^�D[Yî&^�å\EYVWJREYacfW[GNRd"îÃ[ZDTMfhëZTIâ�FIfhLO^�NRd�fW[GN°EYVµ[G`Mãt^�ä�a9fhåZ^"dcæREZä�^QfWd�E�FMD9E�g�`REZä.UÆ[Yî®acTMfêd�EYVWëG[ZDcfhacTRLÎì

e&TM^�dcæMDc^{EGF�[Yî;dc[GVWJIacfW[GN°d�JRdcfhNRë :_S�� � â �~� ð g�fhacTJILKMX KLKdK_^�å\EYVWJRE\a9fh[ZNRd9ñ�fêdÏdcTM[\g�NÆfWN�®fWëGJRDc^fILIIì � VhacTM[ZJMëGT acTM^�FIfêdta9DcfW`MJIa9fh[ZN fêd�NM[Ga"EZd�D9^�ëZJMVWEGD�EGd_fWNÑacTR^2:�g|��EGæMæMD9[ZEZä.T;X

Page 13: Indian Academy of Sciencesrepository.ias.ac.in/83508/1/13-a.pdfq9rt|bzY Gz{xvz{y s q9~Ç|bj ¼ q Iq.q9kÈ Gq.¼ q.xvz{lIq. Éj kK Èj lblZx svq *rtz Ê kK }"mZxvrtsvlZx qp µj ntqcrtz

0 0.2

0.4 0.6

0.8

0 0.2

0.4 0.6

0.8

0

0.4

0.8

1.2

f_2 f_1

f_3

����� º�� �Rº �Ôq9n��êz�nt}�j�kZu.q�z������ZÄ }q9rt|bzY��z{k&� � R�YË

0 0.2

0.4 0.6

0.8

0 0.2

0.4 0.6

0.8

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8

1 1.2

f_2 f_1

f_3

����� º � �Rº �Ôqcn��êz�nt}�j�kbu.qÑz��Ç� ��Ä }q9rt|bzY�z{k �� � R�YË

0 0.2

0.4 0.6

0.8

0 0.2

0.4 0.6

0.8

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8

1

f_2 f_1

f_3

����� º � �Kº �Ôq9n��Wz�nt}�j�kbu.q&z��Ô� ���®}qcrt|bzY�z{k&� � R�YË

0 0.2

0.4 0.6

0.8

0 0.2

0.4 0.6

0.8

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8

1 1.2

f_1f_2

f_3

����� º � �Mº �Ôq9n��Wz�nt}�j�kZu.q z�� � �bo&wϽ¾���}q9rt|ZzY�3z{k �� � R�YË

acTM^Î[G`Ia.EYfWNM^�F dc[GVWJIa9fh[ZNRd3dcæMD9^�EZF EGä�D9[Zd9dQa9TM^Ò^�NZa9fhD9^)îÃD9[GNba{ì � dÇæ�[GfWNbac^�Fé^�Vêd�^�g�TM^�D9^GX�E`°^�a�ac^�DÏNMfêä.TMfWNMë[Gæ�^�D.E\a9[GD#a9TREYN�acTR^�ä�D9[\g�FIfWNMëYâ�FIfêdta.EYNRä�^@[Zæ°^�D9EYac[ZD�X\dcJRä.TÆEGd�Eä�VhJRd�ac^�Dc^{F:_S�� � â �~�P� A! �[ZD�EYNM[GacTM^�D ô áÉóúdcJRä.T EZd�SIC ô � I)ä�EYN*^�LOæMVh[\H�EÆ`�^�acac^�DQFIfêdta9DcfW`MJIa9fh[ZN[Yî d�[ZVhJIa9fh[ZNRd@fhN�æMD9[G`RVh^�LOd&T°E�åbfWNMëOLO[GD9^�a9TREYNÎatg@[O[G`Iãt^{ä�acfWåG^{d�ì

��îba9TM^�dc^�EYVWëG[ZDcfhacTRLOd?EYD9^#EGæMæMVWfh^{FQ[GN]"e � ( � g�TRfWä.TQTREZd;E�NKJMLÇ`�^�D?[YîIVh[Iä�EYVY^��Æä�fh^�NbaîÃDc[ZNZa9fh^�D9dÒEGd)fWN (Ô]"e *RXÏacTM^Èä�VêEGd9d�fêä�EGV�EYVWëG[GD9fhacTMLÆdÆg�fWVhV"TRE�åZ^Ñd�fWLOfhVêEYDÒFMf �)ä�JRV�a9fh^{dÒfWNä�[GNKåZ^�D9ëGfWNMë�ac[ÉacTM^5acD9JM^5^�)ä�fW^�Nba�îÃDc[ZNZa9fh^�D�ì#e&TKJRd�X®g@^5FI[ÈNM[Ga�dcTM[\gÖacTM^ÎD9^�dcJMV�a.dÇ[ZN]_e � ( � ì/ �� -�� � /34 6 � 1 81" �%/ ��2 e&TM^�]"e � (%A"fêd E q I\â�å\EGDcfêEY`MVW^@æMDc[Z`MVW^�LúTRE�åKfWNMëEQC EYD9^�ac[Gâ[GæIa9fhLÆEYV ä�JMDcåZ^Gï

/ �� \ qpQ/ �} Q / �� g�f�a9T / } \ / � B�� K�` q �ìÔe&TMfêd�æRDc[Z`MVh^�L�XÔEGV�a9TM[GJRëGT

E)a9TMDc^�^�â�[G`Iãt^{ä�a9fhåZ^3[ZNM^GXÔTREZd"E5[GNR^�â�FIfhLO^�NRd�fW[GN°EYV#^�)ä�fW^�NbaQîÃD9[GNbacfW^�D{ì�e&TR^ÆSRSIá XµJRdcfhNRëô JMVW^�D� d�L�^�acTM[IF*g�fhacTÉEÆdta9^�æ dcfhç�^�[Yî � \�K�� AOEGNRF ?�\�K�� K q XIõRNRFRd�a9TM^�æREGD�a9fWEGVµîÃDc[ZNbaE\î�ac^�D q KLKRX KdKLK^�å\EYVWJRE\a9fh[ZNRd�XIEZd�d�TM[\g�N5fhN ��fhëZJMD9^ I � ìIe&TM^e�CÏá EYæMæMD9[ZEZä.T ð g�fhacT AVKdKfhNMfhacfê[email protected][ZL dc[GVWJIacfW[GN°d9ñ"õ°NRFMdÇacTM^Îä�[GLOæMVW^�a9^ÆîÃD9[GNba�X�EGdÇdcTM[\g�N fWN ��fhëZJMD9^JI *°ì�ó_NacTM^_[YacTR^�D@TREYNRF;XGa9TM^ :pg ��EGæMæMD9[ZEZä.T3õ°NRFMd@EÇFIfhö�^�Dc^�Nbap[GNR^�â�FIfhLO^�NRd�fW[GN°EYVRä�JMDcåZ^�EGdÏacTR^^�)ä�fW^�Nba�îÃD9[GNbacfW^�D ð ��fWëGJMD9^ I AZñ�ì

Page 14: Indian Academy of Sciencesrepository.ias.ac.in/83508/1/13-a.pdfq9rt|bzY Gz{xvz{y s q9~Ç|bj ¼ q Iq.q9kÈ Gq.¼ q.xvz{lIq. Éj kK Èj lblZx svq *rtz Ê kK }"mZxvrtsvlZx qp µj ntqcrtz

ó_NÑacTR^�[GacTM^�D_T°EYNRFµXµVWfWUG^Oe�CÏá X :_S�� � â �� ð g�f�a9T ILKMX KLKdKÆîÃJMNRä�acfW[GNÈ^�å\EYVWJREYacfW[GNRd.ñFI[K^�d"NM[YaTRE�åZ^3EGNbH*æRDc[Z`MVh^�L fhNÉõRNRFMfhNMë*E5ëG[K[IF FIfêd�acD9fh`MJMacfW[GNÈ[GNÑa9TM^�acD9JM^�îÃDc[ZNbacfW^�D{XEGd�dcTM[\g�N5fWN ��fhëZJMDc^PI Mì

1 0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 0

f_1 f_2

f_3

����� º � �Rº �Ôq9n��êz�nt}�j�kZu.q�z������ZÄ }q9rt|bzY��z{k&� � ��YË

1 0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8

f_3

f_1 f_2

����� º � �°º �Ôqcn��êz�nt}�j�kbu.qÑz��Ç� ��Ä }q9rt|bzY�z{k �� � ��YË

0 0.2

0.4 0.6

0.8 1 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

f_3

f_1

f_2

����� º � �Rº �Ôq9n��Wz�nt}�j�kbu.q&z��Ô� ���®}qcrt|bzY�z{k&� � ��YË

0 0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2f_3

0.2 0.4f_1

0.6 0.8 1 0 0.2 0.4f_2

0.6 0.8 1

����� º � �Mº �Ôq9n��Wz�nt}�j�kZu.q z�� � �bo&wϽ¾���}q9rt|ZzY�3z{k �� � ��YË

� �ÉÜpÙ�ß���ÞpKàtÜÏÙpe&TMfWdd�acJ°FIHÑ`MD9fhNRëZd"fhNba9[ÎVWfWëGTbaQacTMD9^�^ÆFIfhö�^�Dc^�Nbaä�VWEZdcdcfêä�EYV�ëG^�NM^�D.E\a9fhNRë5LO^�a9TM[IFMdQg�TMfêä.Tä�EYNÎ`�^JRd�^{F5ac[�õRNRF�EOd�^�a�[Yî#C EYD9^�ac[Gâ�[ZæIacfWLÆEYVÔd�[ZVhJMacfW[GNRd&fWN*E�dcfWNMëGVW^d�fWLÇJMVêE\a9fh[ZN5D9JMN;ìe&TM^Çä�[ZLOæREYD9fWdc[GNÎ[Yî#a9TM^�dc^�LO^�a9TM[IFMd�g�fhacT :"S�� � â ���[ZN*EÆNKJMLÇ`�^�D_[Yî#ac^{dta�æRDc[Z`MVh^�LÆdTRE�åG^ÇEZFI^9MbJREYac^�VhH�FI^�LO[ZNRdta9D9EYac^{FÎacTREYa_a9TM^�dc^ÇLO^�a9TM[IFMd_æ°^�D�îÃ[ZDcL-åG^�DcHÎg@^�VWV?g�TM^�NÑacTR^æMDc[Z`MVW^�L dcfhç�^OEGNRFÈd�^{EYD.ä.T d�æ°EGä�^Oä�[ZLOæMVh^�íIf�atH*fêdd�LÆEGVhV�ì � LO[GNMëÎa9TM^�acTMD9^�^OLO^�a9TM[IFMd�XacTM^�SMSIá=EYæRæMDc[bEGä.TÇdc^�^�LÆd?a9[�õ°NRF�[GNMVWH�E�æ°EYDca�[GîRacTR^@^�NbacfWDc^@^�)ä�fW^�Nba#îÃD9[GNba�ì\ù�[\g@^�åZ^�D{XFIJM^�a9[QacTM^�J°d�^�[GîµEFMfhD9^�ä�acfW[GNO[YîµFI^�d9ä�^�Nba�[GNÆEYVWVM[G`Mãt^�ä�a9fhåZ^&îÃJMNRä�acfW[GNRdpd�fWLÇJMVha9EGNM^�[ZJRdcVhHZXf�a&JRdcJREYVWVhHOD9^�EZä.TM^�d�EÇVh[Iä�EYV�^�)ä�fW^�NbaÏîÃD9[GNba MZJRfWä.UKVWHGìKe&TM^_e�Cpá EYæMæRDc[bEGä.TOfWd&dcfhLOfWVWEGD�a9[EYNÇ^�Vhfhac^�â�æRDc^{d�^�DcåKfWNMë�æ�[GæMJMVêE\a9fh[ZNIâ�`REGdc^�F ô áÉóÁEYæMæRDc[bEGä.Tg�fhacT3EGNÇ^�íIä�^�æIa9fh[ZNacT°E\a#g�f�a9Tf�a9^�D.E\acfW[GN°d�acTR^Çæ�[GæMJMVêE\a9fh[ZNÑd�fWç�^3ä�EYN fhNRä�Dc^{EGdc^fhN°FI^�õRNRf�a9^�VWHGX°acTM^�Dc^�`bHÎLÆEYUKfWNMëÆacTR^ÇVêE\a�âac^�D&fhac^�D9EYacfW[GNRd@d�VW[\gìKe&TM^"EGæMæMD9[ZEZä.TOEGVWdc[ÇD9^9MbJMfWD9^�dÏõMíIfhNMë�E3d�ac^�æIâ�d�fWç�^_JMæ�FRE\ac^Qd9ä.TM^�LO^GX

Page 15: Indian Academy of Sciencesrepository.ias.ac.in/83508/1/13-a.pdfq9rt|bzY Gz{xvz{y s q9~Ç|bj ¼ q Iq.q9kÈ Gq.¼ q.xvz{lIq. Éj kK Èj lblZx svq *rtz Ê kK }"mZxvrtsvlZx qp µj ntqcrtz

g�TMfWä.TòDc^>MZJRfhD9^�d�õRNM^�â�acJRNMfhNRë îÃ[ZDÇ^�åZ^�D9HÉæRDc[Z`MVh^�L�ì�e&TM^ :�g|��EGæMæMD9[ZEGä.TèfêdOE dcHKd�ac^�L�âE\acfêäÎLÆE\acTR^�LÆE\a9fWä�EYV�æMD9[GëZD9EGL�LOfWNMëÉEGæMæMD9[ZEZä.TéfhN�g�TMfêä.T�EÉNKJML3`°^�DÆ[YîQd�^{EYD.ä.TM^�d�EYD9^æ°^�D�îÃ[ZDcLO^�FÒîÃD9[GL EOJMNRf�îÃ[ZDcLOVWHZâ�FIfêdta9DcfW`MJIa9^�FÎd�^�a�[Yî�æ°[ZfhNba9d�fhNÎacTR^[G`Iãt^{ä�acfWåG^QdcæREGä�^Gì

ó_N5E3NbJRLÇ`�^�D&[Yî®atgp[�EYNRFÒacTMD9^�^�â�[Z`Iãt^�ä�acfWåG^�ac^�d�a�æMD9[G`MVW^�LÆd�Xbfha�TREGd@`�^�^�N5[Z`Rd�^�DcåZ^�FacTREYa�acTR^Çe�CÏá EGNRF :�g|��EYD9^�`�^�a�a9^�D�acTREGN�acTM^OSMSIá EGæMæMD9[ZEGä.T?ìMù�[\g@^�åG^�D�XKîÃ[ZD�æMD9[G`MâVh^�LOd&T°E�åbfWNMë�LÇJMVhacfhâ�L�[IFMEGVµ^�)ä�fW^�Nba&îÃD9[GNba9d&[ZD@NR[GNIâ�JMNMfhîÃ[GD9L,FI^�N°d�fhatH)[Yî�æ°[ZfhNba.d&fhNÎacTR^[G`Iãt^{ä�acfWåG^)dcæREZä�^GX®EYVWV�acTRDc^�^)LO^�acTR[KFRdÇFI[*NM[GaÇæ�^�DcîÃ[GD9L g@^�VWV�ì®e&TM^�HÈ^�fhacTM^�DÇëZ^�aÇd�acJRä.Uac[ÉEÑVh[Iä�EGVÏ^��Æä�fh^�NbaÇîÃD9[GNbacfW^�D�[ZD�a9[ d�JR`°[ZæIacfWLÆEYV&d�[ZVhJIa9fh[ZNRd�ì#ó_N a9TM^Ò[GacTM^�DÇTREGNRFµX?[ZNEYVWVµæMDc[Z`MVW^�LÆd&ä�[GN°d�fêFI^�D9^�FÒTM^�D9^GX;:"S�� � â ��@g�fhacT*EYNÎfWFM^�Nbacfêä�EGVµæREYD.EYLO^�a9^�D&d�^�a�a9fhNMë°XMTREZdæ°^�D�îÃ[ZDcLO^�F gp^�VhV�ì®ó_NM^�g@E�HÎa9[Î^�íKac^�N°FÑa9TM^Ædta9JRFIHÑg@[GJMVêFÑ`�^�ac[ÎDc^�æMVêEGä�^3acTR^ÆS��"C2[ZDä�VêEGd9d�fêä�EGVµ[GæIa9fhLOfWç�E\a9fh[ZN*EYæMæMD9[ZEZä.T5^�LÇ`�^�FMFM^�FÎac[Oa9TM^�dc^�ä�VêEGd9dcfWä�EYV;EYVWëG[ZDcfhacTRLOd&g�fhacTÑEGN^�åG[ZVhJMacfW[GNREGDcHOEYVWëG[ZDcfhacTML�ì � NM[GacTM^�D�EYæMæMD9[ZEZä.TÆgp[ZJMVêFÆ`°^"a9[3JRdc^Qd�[ZL�^_[Yî;a9TM^Qä�VêEGd9d�fêä�EGVæMDcfWNRä�fhæMVW^�d&EZdpEGN5EGFRFIf�a9fh[ZNREYVÔ[Zæ°^�D9EYac[GDpfhN�EYN ô áÉóÓLO^�acTM[IFI[ZVh[ZëGHGìISK[ZL�^QdcJRä.TÒ^�íba9^�NIâd�fW[GNRd3g@[GJMVêFé`�^ÎEGNòfWLOL�^{FIfêE\ac^5îÃ[Iä�JRd3îÃ[ZD3JRdc^�îÃJRV�Dc^{d�^{EYD.ä.TèEGNRFòEGæMæMVWfWä�E\a9fh[ZNéfhNøacTR^EYD9^�E3[Yî#LÇJMVhacfhâ�[Z`Iãt^�ä�acfWåG^Q[GæMacfWL�fWç�EYacfW[GN;ì

� ���C�?Û��?Ù�ß �?

�{Ë���Ë �j�~&j�kK���ZË Â Ë�&q.kZkbsv~.ËÏ�@z�nt}�j�x�½��Iz�mbkb�bj�n��3svk\rtq9nt~�q.u9rtsvz{k��Mw�kbqcÌÁ}q9rt|ZzY���êz�n&y{q9kbq9n�½j�rtsvkby�rt|bq_�®j�ntq9rtz�~�mGn���j�u9q"svk5kZz{kZx�svkZq�j�n�}_mbx�rtsvu9nts�rtq9nts�jÇz�lZrtsv}svÀ�j�rtsvz�k5lGntz{�bxvq.}~.Ë����� ������������������� "!$#&%'#)(*��!$#+���b�b�Z� ���,� ���G�,-\� ��.Y�;�*/�/{�GË

�YË���Ë &j�~®j�kK�'�ZË Â�Ë &q.kbkZsv~.ËMwpk_s�}lGntz�¼�q���rtq9uc|Zkbs)0\mbq��Wz�n#u�|bz\z�~�svkby�lKj�n�j�}q9rtqcnt~?�Wz�n��®j�ntq9rtz~�mGn���j�u.q y{q.kZq9n�j�rtsvz�kQmb~�svkby@kbz�nt}�j�x�½��Iz�mbkb�bj�n���svk\rtq9nt~�q.ucrts�z�k°ËZ��k�12���*3,454�6�#7�98�:;���<!&=>4�?@=�#7��6AB���,�C6ED�����8���4,:�:F���G�H!$�,�H3I!$��!J�K�L���"6� ��H� !$#$6�#7:,3I# �� #7�"����ME�� "!$#7%�#)(*��!$#+���Z�°�N/K/�/GË

�GË�iQË &q.�RËG O�� !$#$PQ�SR7TU4�3I!$#7V�4E�, >!$#7%'#)(*��!$#$���W�:5#7�98X4,V��K� ��!$#+���"����MX�K� 8S���,#7!&=9%':tËZY�|bsvu�|bq.~�rtq9n��[pi���\ svx�qc�\�I���{�G��Ë

�ZË�iQË &q.�°� �IË�wpy�n�j.Ì j�x���w�Ë��µn�j�r�j�l°��j�kK���@Ë�Ä�q9�Yj�ntsv¼�j�kRËYw���j�~�rµj�kK��q.xvs�rtsv~�rµ}"mZxvrts�½¾z{�Y¿�q9u9rtsv¼�qy�q.kbqcrts�u3j�xvy�z�nts�rt|b}E�µ� �bo&w�½�����Ë]�^_^�^`?������>:,�S3I!$#+���H:E���a^<V��K� ��!$#+���"���,MbD���%; "��!J��!$#+���Z��G�¾�{�,�v���{�*-b�*/S.\�°�������YË

�YË�iQË @q.�°�"Ä5Ë"Ä�z{|bj�k°�_j�kK� �IË_Ä�sv~�|Zn�jGË ��z�Ì j�n��Z~ jc0\mbsvu�Õ u.z{}lZmZr�j�rts�z�kÓz���Ì�q.xvxv½~�lGntq�j{��lKj�ntq9rtz�½¾z�lZrtsv}�j�xM~�z{xvmGrts�z�kb~.˵��kE1<���*3�454�6�#7�98�:d���e!&=>4f�g4�35����6F^<V��K� ��!$#+�������,M' O�� !$#$PDh��#7!Q4,��#+���Z�� "!$#7%�#)(*��!$#+���Gi&^j W�<P�k�lImnD����*�*4,��4,��3�4'i7oqp�Dh�srt�l�r*m��YlKj�y�q.~ ���{�N-G�����G�b����� �YË

�GË�iQË @q.�°���;Ë{�#|Zsvq.xvq{�{Ä5Ë{�°j�mZ}�j�kbkZ~.��j�kb�_Â Ë Ms�rtÀ.xvq9n�Ë��Yu�j�x�j��Zxvq }"mbx�rts�½¾z{�Y¿�q.ucrts�¼{q®z�lZrtsv}svÀ�j�½rtsvz�k)rtq9~�r&lZntz��bxvq.}~.Ëp��kZ1<���*3�45456�#7��8�:����F!&=>4BD����98��54,:5:u���O^<V��K� ��!$#+�������,MZD���%e "��!J��!$#$���i5D@^vDLPJr�kSk�r*m��Klbj�y�q.~@�{� �N-Y� ���G�°���{���\Ë

.YË�w�ËbÄ�q.~�~tj�u_j�kb�EYpËIw�ËIÄOj�r�rt~�z{kRË��pz�nt}�j�xMu.z�kb~�r�n�j�s�k\rp}q9rt|bzY�Ì�s�rt|Oy{mbj�n�j�kYrtq9q�z��;q.¼�q.kntq9lZntq.~�q.k\r�j�rts�z�kOz��Ôu.z{}lZx�qcrtq�lKj�ntqcrtz"�Wntz�kYrtsvq9n�Ë<����;�w�������,�"�K� �Ksvk�lGntq.~�~.Ë

�GË�iQËbÄ�svq9r�rtsvkbq9k°Ë<pd���"� #7��45���e O�� !$#+�SR7TU4�3I!$#7V�4u�� "!$#7%�#)(*��!$#+���ZË®i�xvm\Ì#qcn�� ��z�~�rtz{kR���*/�/K/YË/GË �IË��Gu�|qxjUyq9n���z�Ë �Yuc|Ymbx�rtÀ{�Rj�kK�)iQËg\�q.svkbÀ9s�qcntxÃË �Yrtz\u�|Kj�~�rts�u"}q9rt|bzY�Æ�êz�n�rt|bqQ~�z�x�mGrtsvz{kÎz��mZkbu.z�kb~�r�n�j�s�kZq���¼�q.u9rtz�n�z{lZrtsv}svÀ�j�rts�z�k3lGntz{�Zx�q9}~.Ë2�������,�"�K�@���'�� "!$#7%�#)(*��!$#+���W?@=H45���,Mn����6�j S �� #$3���!$#+���>:t�R�{� �b�����,� ���K/U-Y�{���Y�Ô���{�{�YË

�.�GË�o_Ë\�#s�}}q9xÃËIÂ?svk�~�rtz\uc|bj�~�rtsv~�u�|bq.~#~�mZuc|Y¼�qcn�n�j�|Zntq9kÀ.mZn®�Iq.~�rtsv}}"mZkby��Gq9n�z�lZrtsv}�j�xvq.k�Õ�z�}Q½lGntz{}svxv~�mbkZy{q.k5�Iq.s;~�r�j�rtsv~�uc|Zq.k�lIz�x�À9ÕYnts�rtq9ntsvq.xvxvq.k*z�lZrtsv}svq9ntmbkZy{~tj�mG�êy{j��Iq.kRË{A|#7:5:I}j~h}e?@�,� %u4,�����Y�Z��v� ��/U-b�U. �Z�;�*/��{�GË

���{Ë�o_Ë��#sv}}q.x�ËbÄ�zY�Zs Ê Õ�j�rtsvz�k"q.svkbq9~µ~�r�j�rtsv~�rtsv~�uc|Zq.kQ~�mbu�|Y¼�q9n��êj�|Zntq9kb~;�Zqcn;¼�q.Õ\rtz�ntz�lZrtsv}svq9ntmbkZyZËAs#7:5:I}q~h}<?@��,� %u4,�����Y� ���v� ��/U-b� ���Y�;�*/{�{�YË