lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... ·...

50
1

Transcript of lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... ·...

Page 1: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

1

!"#$#%&"%'()*(+,&(%"-%./01$),%2,)/3*,&%&"%./01$),%4%56'6789:%

!

!

!

!

!

! ;/)0,%9(-$33,%7,3%

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%<+$"-*,&(+=%'+>%?(1"+(%@/AA(%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%7(4<+$"-*,&(+=%'+>%:-&+B#%!+(#*)C,-#DE%%

%

% % % % % % !+$A/-,3%&"%"F,3/,)$G-=%%

% % % % % % '+,>%:-,%'"-$)(3,%% % % % % % '+>%H3F,+(%'0,I%

% % % % % % '+>%9+/)"%:>%2+""1,-!'+>%@,J,"3%@,&$%

!

% % % % %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%'"K*(>%&"%9$(L/01$),M%2,)/3*,&%&"%N"&$)$-,%% % % %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%7"-*+(%&"%$-F"#*$O,)$(-"#%A$(1B&$),#%"-%% % % % %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%+,&$),3"#%3$A+"#M%768P98<%

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%Q-$F"+#$&,&%&"%3,%@"KRA3$),%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%N(-*"F$&"(M%ST%&"%,A+$3%TUSV!

%

NNN<<<'''QQQ;;;:::777888WWWPPP%%%'''666%%%;;;:::%%%666PPPXXX888NNN:::%%%555@@@<<<YYY!!!:::ZZZ;;;:::PPP'''888PPP:::%%%%%%

ZZZ[[[???%%%YYY888PPP!!!:::YYY:::%%%555<<<@@@%%%HHH777888'''<<<%%%PPP888!!!@@@<<<444:::@@@:::...QQQ888'''WWWPPP888777<<<===%%%%%%"""###$$$%%%&&&'''(((""")))!!!***!!!$$$)))&&&(((###$$$+++###&&&$$$'''%%%(((!!!###&&&!!!,,,%%%!!!(((---&&&...###((('''(((!!!///###!!!,,,---000'''///)))(((!!!!!!

111''')))%%%$$$...'''222)))(((!!!///###333'''222%%%///)))(((!!!///###,,,!!!444$$$'''///)))!!!%%%333%%%555+++'''///666&&&'''$$$)))!!!!

Page 2: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

2

\P'876%%78! 3#(+"#&!*!%13#2'%.+3%(!!88888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888!!!!!!7!

98! '&.3)/+$$'6&!!888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888!!!!!!9!

!!!!!!!!!987! 6:;<=!>?@A;B=!C!DEFDB;DE!ADGB@;HGE!<D!>;@AIJD>=!!888888888888888888888888888888888888888888!!!!!!9!!!!!!!!!!989! &;@AGB;I>!K;F?<;BG!!88888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888!!!!!!!L!!!!!!!!!!!!!!98987!!!!!!!!!"DBG>;EM=E!<D!>;@AGB;I>!<D!NB;<=E!JAGE=E!!888888888888888888888888888888888888888888!!!!!!!L!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!9898787!!!!!!!!!,;F=FDA=:;<GB;I>!!88888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888!!!!!!!L!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!9898789!!!!!!!!!&;@A=JD>GB;I>!K;F?<;BG!F=A!I:;<=!>?@A;B=!!888888888888888888888888888888888888888888!!!!!!!O!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!989878P!!!!!!!!!&;@AGB;I>!K;F?<;BG!F=A!<;I:;<=!<D!>;@AIJD>=!!888888888888888888888888888888888888!!!!!!!!Q!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!989878L! !!&;@AGB;I>!K;F?<;BG!F=A!FDA=:;>;@A;@=!!8888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888!!!!!!!R!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!98989!!!!!!!!!0A=F;D<G<DE!S;=TU?M;BGE!<D!K=E!>;@A=GKTUD>=E!!888888888888888888888888888888888888!!!!!!!R!!!!!!!!!!!!!!9898P!!!!!!!!!0A=F;D<G<DE!S;=KIJ;BGE!<D!K=E!>;@A=GKTUD>=E!!888888888888888888888888888888888888888!!!!!79!!!!!!!!!!!!!!9898L! !!!!!!!0=@D>B;GK!@DAGFVU@;B=!<D!K=E!>;@A=GKTUD>=E!!88888888888888888888888888888888888888888!!!!!!7P!!!!!!!!!!98P!! 0A=E@GJKG><;>G!WXY!E;>@GEG!!8888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888!!!!!7L!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!98P87!!!!!!!!!"D@GS=K;EM=!<DK!NB;<=!GAGTU;<I>;B=!!888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888!!!!!7L!!!!!!!!!!!!!!98P89!!!!!!!!!#E@AUB@UAG!C!ZU>B;I>!<D!0WY(8!"DBG>;EM=!<D!GBB;I>!!88888888888888888888888888!!!!!7O!!!!!!!!!!!!!!98P8P!!!!!!!!!'>@DAGBB;I>!<D!0WY(!B=>!DEFDB;DE!ADGB@;HGE!<D!>;@AIJD>=!!8888888888888888888!!!!!97!!!!!!!!!!!!!!98P8L!!!!!!!!![GAMGB=K=J?G!<D!0WY(!!88888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888!!!!!97!!!!!!!!!!!98L! %>@DBD<D>@DE!G!DE@D!@AGSG\=!<D!;>HDE@;JGB;I>!!88888888888888888888888888888888888888888888!!!!!9P!

P8! )1]#.'2)(!!88888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888!!!!!9L!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!P87! )S\D@;H=!JD>DAGK!!!!!!!!!!!!P89! )S\D@;H=E!DEFDB?Z;B=E!!

L8! "#.)/),)W-%!!888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888!!!!!9^!

!!!!!!!!!L87! (?>@DE;E!<D!&)9%%!!888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888!!!!!9^!!!!!!!!!!L89! "=<UKGB;I>!<D!0WY(!F=A!&)9%%!!888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888!!!!!!9O!!!!!!!!!!L8P! 'MFGB@=!<D!&)9%%!E=SAD!FKGTUD@GE!_UMG>GE!!8888888888888888888888888888888888888888888!!!!!!P`!!!!!!!!!!L8L! 'MFGB@=!<D!&)9%%!E=SAD!KG!GB@;H;<G<!0WY(a9!D>!MGBAIZGJ=E!!8888888888888888888!!!!!PP!!!!!!!!!!L8^! &;@AGB;I>!BG@GK?@;BG!<D!%%!!888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888!!!!!!PL!!!!!!!!!!L8O! #:@AGBB;=>DE!=AJN>;BGE!!8888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888!!!!!!P^!

^8! 3#(+,.%/)(!*!/'($+('6&!!888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888!!!!!PO!

!!!!!!!!!^87! (?>@DE;E!<D!&)9%%!!888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888!!!!!PO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!^8787! !!!!!!!)F@;M;bGB;I>!<DK!AD><;M;D>@=!<D!ADGBB;I>!!8888888888888888888888888888888888888888888!!!!PO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!^8789! !!!!!!!%>NK;E;E!C!FUA;Z;BGB;I>!<D!;EIMDA=E!F=E;B;=>GKDE!<D!&)9%%!!88888888888888888!!!!!Pc!!!!!!!!!!^89!!!!! "=<UKGB;I>!<D!KG!D>b;MG!0WY(!F=A!&)9%%!!888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888!!!!!L`!!!!!!!!!!!!!!^8987! !!!!!!$GAGB@DA;bGB;I>!B;>V@;BG!<D!KG!;>_;S;B;I>!<D!0WY(!F=A!&)9%%!888888888888888!!!!!L7!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!^898787!!!!!!!!!/D@DAM;>GB;I>!<D!KGE!GB@;H;<G<DE!FDA=:;<GEG!C!B;BK==:;JD>GEG8888888!!!!!!L7!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!^898789!!!!!!!!!#ZDB@=!<D!KG!<=E;E!!8888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888!!!!!L9!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!^89878P!!!!!!!!!"=<DK=!B;>V@;B=!<D!;>_;S;B;I>!!88888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888!!!!!!L^!

Page 3: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

3

!!!!!!!!!!!^8989! !!!!!!!#HGKUGB;I>!<D!&)9%%!B=M=!F=@D>B;GK!EUE@AG@=!<D!0WY(!8888888888888888888888!!!!!^7!!!!!!!!!^898P!!!!!!!!!#ZDB@=!<D!&)9%%!E=SAD!DK!JAUF=!_DM=!<D!0WY(!!88888888888888888888888888888888!!!!!!^7!

!!!!!!!!!^8P! #E@U<;=!<D!K=E!<D@DAM;>G>@DE!DE@AUB@UAGKDE!D>!KG!;>@DAGBB;I>!!! ! 0WY(a&)9%%!!88888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888!!!!!^c!!!!!!!!!!!!!!^8P87!!!!!!!!!'>@DAGBB;I>!B=>!DK!E;@;=!GB@;H=!$)d!!8888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888!!!!!!^R!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!^8P89!!!!!!!!!'>_;S;B;I>!<D!MU@G>@DE!<D!0WY(a9!D>!ADE;<U=E!BA?@;B=E!FGAG!KG!! ! !!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!U>;I>!GK!_DM=!C!KG!U>;I>!G!%'&#(!!88888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888!!!!!!O`!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!^8P8987!!!!!!!!!"U@G>@DE!D>!DK!E;@;=!<D!U>;I>!G!%'&#(!e$)df!!888888888888888888888888888888888!!!!!!O9!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!^8P8989!!!!!!!!!"U@G>@DE!D>!DK!E;@;=!<D!U>;I>!<DK!_DM=!e0)df!!888888888888888888888888888888!!!!!!O9!! !^8P8P!!!!!!!!%>NK;E;E!FA=@DIM;B=!!888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888!!!!!!OQ!!!!!!!!!!!!!!^8P8L!!!!!!!!/=Bg;>J!M=KDBUKGA!!88888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888!!!!!!OR!!!!!!!!!!^8L! "=<DK=E!BDKUKGADE!FGAG!DE@U<;GA!KG!;>_;S;B;I>!<D!0WY(!F=A!&)9%%!!8888888888!!!!!!Q`!!!!!!!!!!!!!!^8L87!!!!!!!!#ZDB@=!<D!&)9%%!D>!KG!GB@;H;<G<!<D!MGBAIZGJ=E!MUA;>=E!!88888888888888888888!!!!!!Q`!!!!!!!!!!!!!!^8L89!!!!!!!!#ZDB@=!<D!&)9%%!D>!KG!GB@;H;<G<!<D!FKGTUD@GE!_UMG>GE!!8888888888888888888888!!!!!Q7!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!^8L8987!!!!!!!![=AMGB;I>!<D!FA=<UB@=E!<DA;HG<=E!<DK!%%!<UAG>@D!KG!GB@;HGB;I>!!!!!!!!! !!!!! ! !!FKGTUD@GA;G!!888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888!!!!!!Q9!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!^8L8989!!!!!!!!!%JADJGB;I>!FKGTUD@GA;G!!88888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888!!!!!!Q^!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!^8L898P!!!!!!!!!3=K!<DK!h&)!!888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888!!!!!!QQ!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!^8L898L!!!!!!!!!"=H;K;bGB;I>!<D!BGKB;=!C!<DJAG>UKGB;I>888888888888888888888888888888888888888888!!!!!!!QR!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!^8L898^!!!!!!!!!3=K!<D!KG!FA=@D?>G!TU;>GEG!$!!8888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888!!!!!!c7!!!!!!!!!!^8^! &;@AGB;I>!BG@GK?@;BG!<D!%%!F=A!0WY(!D>!FADED>B;G!<D!DEFDB;DE!ADGB@;HGE!<DK!!!! ! >;@AIJD>=!!8888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888!!!!!c^!!!!!!!!!!!!!!^8^87!!!!!!!!!/D@DBB;I>!C!G>NK;E;E!<D!K=E!FA=<UB@=E!<D!0WY(!Z=AMG<=E!D>!FADED>B;G!<D!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!FDA=:;>;@A;@=!!88888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888!!!!!!c^!!!!!!!!!!!!!!^8^89!!!!!!!!!%>NK;E;E!<D!K=E!FA=<UB@=E!Z=AMG<=E!D>!FADED>B;G!<D!>;@A;@=!8888888888888888!!!!!!!cc!!!!!!!!!!!!!!^8^8P!!!!!!!!!%>NK;E;E!<D!K=E!FA=<UB@=E!Z=AMG<=E!D>!FADED>B;G!<D!I:;<=!>?@A;B=!888888!!!!!!!cR!!!!!!

O8!! $)&$,+(')&#(!*!0#3(0#$.'2%(888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888!!!!!!RP!

Q8! %W3%/#$'"'#&.)(88888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888!!!!!!!R^!

c8! 3#[#3#&$'%(8888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888!!!!!!RO!

R8! 0+1,'$%$')&#(888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888!!!!7`c!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

Page 4: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

4

S>% @"#/1"-%!

#K!I:;<=!>?@A;B=! eh&)f!BUMFKD!F=@D>@DE!GBB;=>DE! ADJUKG<=AGE!D>! KG! ZU>B;I>!BDKUKGA!C!H;GS;K;<G<! @;EUKGA8! ,G! <;EM;>UB;I>! D>! EU! S;=<;EF=>;S;K;<G<! =SEDAHG<G! <UAG>@D! FA=BDE=E!;>ZKGMG@=A;=E! BAI>;B=E! C! GJU<=E! ADEF=><D! G! EU! @AG>EZ=AMGB;I>! D>! DEFDB;DE! ADGB@;HGE! <DK!>;@AIJD>=! e#3&f! C! @;D>D! U>! A=K! BA?@;B=! D>! KG! ADJUKGB;I>! <D! KG! =:;<GB;I>! K;F?<;BG! C! D>! KG!B=>EDBUD>@D! Z=AMGB;I>!<D!<DA;HG<=E!>;@AG<=E!<D! K?F;<=E! e>;@A=GKTUD>=Ef! B=>!DZDB@=E! G>@;a;>ZKGMG@=A;=E8!,=E!>;@A=K?F;<=E!ED!Z=AMG>!!"#$!$%!C!ED!_G>!B=>HDA@;<=!D>!K=E!iK@;M=E!9`!Gj=E!D>! U>=! <D! K=E! FA;>B;FGKDE! =S\D@=E! <D! DE@U<;=! D>! DK! NADG! <D! KG! TU?M;BG! =:;<G@;HG! <D!MGBA=M=KVBUKGE8!&UDE@A=!JAUF=!_G!BGAGB@DA;bG<=!TU?M;BGMD>@D!KG!E?>@DE;E!C!FUA;Z;BGB;I>!<D!NB;<=!>;@A=GAGTU;<I>;B=! e&)9%%fk!U>!>;@A=GKTUD>=!B=>!FA=F;D<G<DE!S;=KIJ;BGE!GE=B;G<GE!G!EU! BGFGB;<G<! G>@;a;>ZKGMG@=A;G8! #K! NB;<=! GAGTU;<I>;B=! e%%hf! DE! FADBUAE=A! <D! U>G! GMFK;G!HGA;D<G<! <D! K?F;<=E! S;=GB@;H=Ek! D>@AD! DKK=E! K=E! D;B=EG>=;<DE! <DA;HG<=E! <D! KG! H?G!0A=E@GJKG><;>G! WXY! E;>@GEG! e0WY(fk! C! F=E@UKGM=E! TUD! EU! >;@AGB;I>! FGAG! Z=AMGA! &)9%%!F=<A?G! ADFADED>@GA! U>! MDBG>;EM=! ZU><GMD>@GK! <D! M=<UKGB;I>! <D! K=E! FA=BDE=E!;>ZKGMG@=A;=E! H;>BUKG<=E! GK! %%8! #>! DED! B=>@D:@=! ;>@DJAGM=E! @VB>;BGE! S;=TU?M;BGEk!FA=@DIM;BGE!C!B=MFU@GB;=>GKDE!FGAG!BGAGB@DA;bGA!B;>V@;BG!C!DE@AUB@UAGKMD>@D!KG!;>@DAGBB;I>!<D!&)9%%!B=>!0WY(a7!C!0WY(a98!/DM=E@AGM=E!TUD!DK!&)9%%! !DE!BGFGb!<D! ;>GB@;HGA!DE@GE!D>b;MGE! D>! Z=AMG! ;AADHDAE;SKDk! D:_;S;D><=! U>G! F=@D>B;G! B=MFGAGSKD! G! KG! <D! KGE! <A=JGE!G>@;;>ZKGMG@=A;GE! >=! DE@DA=;<DGE! e%'&#(f8! .AGEKG<GM=E! DE@D! ADEUK@G<=! G!M=<DK=E! BDKUKGADE!<D! ADKDHG>B;G! S;=KIJ;BG! D>! DK! MD@GS=K;EM=! <D! %%l! FKGTUD@GE! _UMG>GE! C! MGBAIZGJ=E!MUA;>=E8! #K! &)9%%! ;>_;S;I! KG! GB@;H;<G<! 0WY(a7! C! 0WY(a9! !"# $!$%k! D\DAB;D><=! U>! F=@D>@D!DZDB@=!G>@;aGJADJG>@D!D>!FKGTUD@GE!M=<UKG><=!DK!MD@GS=K;EM=!>=AMGK!<DK!%%!EUMG<=!G!EU!GBB;I>! E=SAD! SKG>B=E! G<;B;=>GKDE! G! 0WY(a78! [;>GKMD>@Dk! F=>DM=E! G! FU>@=! U>! E;E@DMG! <D!ADGBB;=>DE!FGAG!DHGKUGA!KG!E?>@DE;E!BG@GK?@;BG!<D!&)9%%!F=A!KG!GB@;H;<G<!0WY(!C!FA=F=>DM=E!U>!F=E;SKD!MDBG>;EM=!<D!ADJUKGB;I>!FKGTUD@GA;G!!"#$!$%8!!%

%

:9@6]8:!Q@:Y=% )/5k! 7Yam7k9kLn=:G<;Gb=K=mLkPaGnTU;>=:GK;>Ga7a=>Go! %$/k! GBD@G@=aB;@AG@=aJKUB=EGo! .$#0k! NB;<=!

PkP′kP′′aZ=EZG>D@A;K@A;FA=FG>=;B=o!%%(k!NB;<=!GBD@;KEGK;B?K;B=o!%%k!NB;<=!GAGTU;<I>;B=o!%W'k!NB;<=!JAGE=! ;>EG@UAG<=o!%W"'k!

NB;<=! JAGE=! M=>=a;>EG@UAG<=o! %W0'k! NB;<=! JAGE=! F=K;;>EG@UAG<=o! &)9%%k! NB;<=! >;@A=GAGTU;<I>;B=o! &)9,%k! NB;<=!

>;@A=K;>=KD;B=o! &)9)%k! NB;<=! >;@A==KD;B=o! .$%k! NB;<=! @A;BK=A=GBV@;B=o! Y#.#Ek! NB;<=E! _;<A=:;D;B=EG@D@AGD>=;B=Eo! %>Ja''k!

G>J;=@D>E;>Ga''o! G0WY(k! GF=a0WY(o!h%%k! AG<;BGK! GAGTU;<=>;K=o! $)dk! B;BK=:;JD>GEGo! $%/k! B=K;EE;=>! GB@;HG@D<!<;E=B;G@;=>o!

.,$k! BA=MG@=JAGZ?G! D>! BGFG! Z;>Go!/%Wk! <;GB;KJK;BDA=Ko!h&)9k! <;I:;<=! <D! >;@AIJD>=o! %'&#(k! <A=JGE! G>@;a;>ZKGMG@=A;GE! >=!

DE@DA=;<DGEo!#('k!DKDB@A=EFGAC!;=>;bG@;=>o!%3#Ek!DKDMD>@=E!<D!ADEFUDE@G!G>@;=:;<G>@Do!#0'k!D>_G>BD<!FA=<UB@! ;=>!EBG>o!

#3&k!DEFDB;DE!ADGB@;HGE!<D!>;@AIJD>=o![D9pa00'dk![D

9paFA=@=F=AZ;A;>G!'do![D

Ppa00'dk![D

PpaFA=@=F=AZ;A;>G!'do!0"([k!ZKU=AUA=!

<D! ZD>;KMD@;KEUKZ=>;K=o! 0"%k! Z=AS=K! 79aM;A;E@G@=! 7PaGBD@G@=o! 0'09k! Z=EZG@;<;K;>=E;@=K! Lk^aS;Z=EZG@=o! 0,%9k! Z=EZ=K;FGEG! %9o!

EW$k! JUG>;KG@=! B;BKGEG! E=KUSKDo! Y)a7k! _DM=! =:;JD>GEGa7o! ,))Yk! _;<A=FDAI:;<=! K;F?<;B=o! _0WY(k! _=K=a0WY(o! ,)dk!

K;F=:;JD>GEGo!"(k!MGEE! EFDB@A=MD@ACo!"0)k!M;DK=FDA=:;<GEGo!"#qX#Agk!M;@=JD>! FA=@D;>! g;>GED! g;>GEDXD:@AGBDKKUKGAa

E;J>GK!ADJUKG@D<!g;>GEDo!"3"k!MUK@;FKD!ADGB@;=>!M=>;@=A;>Jo!."0/k!&k&k&rk&ra@D@AGMD@;KaZD>;KD>D<;GM;>Go!&):k!&%/0Y!

=:;<GEGo!&)Pak! >;@AG@=o!&)9ak! >;@A;@=o!&)(9k!&)(! ;><UB;SKDo!&)(k! I:;<=! >;@A;B=! E;>@GEGEo!h&)k! I:;<=! >?@A;B=o! =:;YSk! =:;a

_DM=JK=S;>Go! #[)dk! =:=a<DA;HG<=E! DKDB@A=Z?K;B=Eo! 0)dk! FDA=:;<GEGo! Y9)9k! FDAI:;<=! <D! _;<AIJD>=o! 0W'9k! FA=E@GB;BK;>Go!

0WY(k!FA=E@GJKG><;>G!WXY!E;>@GEGo!0Wk!FA=E@GJKG><;>Go!0q$k!FA=@D?>G!TU;>GEG!$o!,)hk!AG<;BGK!GKB=:;K=o!,

hk!AG<;BGK!GKTU;K=o!

,))hk! AG<;BGK! FDA=:;K=o! 0%3k! ADBDF@=A! GB@;HG<=! F=A! FA=@DGEGo! ()/k! EUFDAI:;<=! <;EMU@GEGo! )9

hak! EUFDAI:;<=o! &9)Lk!

@D@AGI:;<=!<D!<;>;@AIJD>=o!&9)Pk!@A;I:;<=!<D!<;>;@AIJD>=o!.:%9k!@A=MS=:G>=!%9o!.:19k!@A=MS=:G>=!198%

Page 5: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

5

T>% 8P!@<'Q778WP%%!

T>S% W^$&(%-0*+$)(%E%"#K")$"#%+",)*$F,#%&"%-$*+GO"-(%!#K!h&)!DE!U>!AG<;BGK!K;SAD!FA=<UB;<=!F=A!BVKUKGE!<D!MGM?ZDA=!C!E;>@D@;bG<=!F=A!KG!ZGM;K;G!

<D!D>b;MGE!<D>=M;>G<G!I:;<=!>?@A;B=!E;>@GEGE!e&)(f!TUD!BG@GK;bG>!KG!=:;<GB;I>!<D!,aGAJ;>;>G!G!,aB;@AUK;>G!D>!FADED>B;G!<D!=:?JD>=!M=KDBUKGA! e)9f!C!&%/0Y8!,GE! ;E=Z=AMGE!<D! KG!&)(!ED!<;H;<D>! D>l! !&! &)(! >DUA=>GK! B=>E@;@U@;HG! e>&)(fk! !!&! &)(! ;><UB;SKD! e&)(9f! FADED>@D! D>!MGBAIZGJ=Ek!C! !!!&!&)(!B=>E@;@U@;HG!GE=B;G<G!G!KG!MDMSAG>G!<D!BVKUKGE!D><=@DK;GKDE!eD&)(f!m7k!9n8!%!<;ZDAD>B;G!<D!=@A=E!AG<;BGKDEk!DK!h&)!>=!DE!U>!=:;<G>@D!>;!U>!AD<UB@=A!ZUDA@D!F=A!K=!BUGK! DE! ADKG@;HGMD>@D! DE@GSKD8! (U! H;<G!MD<;G! D>! E;E@DMGE! GDAIS;B=E! DE! <D! ^aO`! EDJU><=E!<DFD><;D><=! <D! KG! FADED>B;G! <D! SKG>B=E! S;=KIJ;B=E! eD\8! JUG>;KG@=! B;BKGEG! E=KUSKD! eEW$fk!EUFDAI:;<=! e)9

haff! C! <D! EU! B=MFGA@;MD>@GK;bGB;I>! mPa^no! DE@G! H;<G! MD<;G! DE! K=!EUZ;B;D>@DMD>@D! KGAJG! FGAG! FDAM;@;AKD! <;ZU><;A! C! GB@UGA! B=M=! EDJU><=! MD>EG\DA=!FA=<UB;D><=! EUE! DZDB@=E! S;=KIJ;B=E8! #K! h&)! GB@iG! B=M=!MD<;G<=A! <D! KG! ADJUKGB;I>! <D! KG!FADE;I>! EG>JU?>DGk! KG! GJADJGB;I>! FKGTUD@GA;Gk! C! KG! FKGE@;B;<G<! >DUA=>GK! mPa^n8! #K! h&)!FA=<UB;<=! F=A! KGE! BVKUKGE! D><=@DK;GKDE! D>! ADEFUDE@G! G! <;HDAE=E! GJ=>;E@GE! eSAG<;TU;>;>Gk!GBD@;KB=K;>Gk!E_DGA!E@ADEEf!<;ZU><D!_GE@G!DK!B;@=E=K!<D!KGE!BVKUKGE!MUEBUKGADE!K;EGE!<D!KG!MD<;G!HGEBUKGA! C! GB@;HG! KG! EW$k! TUD! G! @AGHVE! <D! KG! FA=<UBB;I>! <D! W"0! B?BK;B=! eBW"0f! ;><UBD! KG!ADKG\GB;I>!<DK! HGE=! EG>JU?>D=! mOn8! #K! h&)!@GMS;V>! ADJUKG!MiK@;FKDE!FA=BDE=E!S;=KIJ;B=E!<D!MG>DAG! ;><;ADB@G8! ,G! Z=AMGB;I>! <D! DEFDB;DE! ADGB@;HGE! <DA;HG<GE! <DK! h&)! e#3&f! DE@N!;>H=KUBAG<G!D>!FA=BDE=E!<D!ADJUKGB;I>!Z;E;=KIJ;BG!C!@GMS;V>!MUC!GE=B;G<G!G!KG!FG@=Z;E;=K=J?G!<D! KG! ;>ZKGMGB;I>8! ,GE!FA;>B;FGKDE! ADGBB;=>DE!<DK! h&)!E=>l! !&! B=MS;>GB;=>DE! AG<;BGKaAG<;BGK!FGAG!Z=AMGA!DEFDB;DE!<D!MGC=A!ADGB@;H;<G<k!!!&!Z=AMGB;I>!<D!B=MFKD\=E!>;@A=E;K=!B=>!BD>@A=E!MD@NK;B=E! <D! @AG>E;B;I>! =! G<UB@=E! >;@A=E=! B=>! S;=M=KVBUKGEk! C! !!!&! ADGBB;=>DE! AD<=:! mQn!e[;JUAG!7f8!!

!#K!FDA=:;>;@A;@=!DE!U>!F=<DA=E=!=:;<G>@D!TUD!ED!Z=AMG!!"#$!$%!F=A!KG!ADGBB;I>!B=>@A=KG<G!

F=A!<;ZUE;I>!D>@AD!DK!h&)!C!DK!)9ha!e'#s!L8P:7`R!a!7:7`7`!"a7Ea7f!mck!Rn!e[;JUAG!7f8!#K!h&)!FUD<D!

B=MFD@;A! B=>! KG! EUFDAI:;<=! <;EMU@GEG! e()/f! F=A! DK! )9ha! K=! BUGK! ADEUK@G! D>! U>! ZKU\=!

DE@GB;=>GA;=!<D!FDA=:;>;@A;@=!TUD! ED!DE@GSKDBD!D>!DK! AG>J=!<D! B=>BD>@AGB;=>DE!>G>=M=KGA!m7`n8! #>! DK! MD<;=! S;=KIJ;B=! DK! FGA! )&))aX)&))Y! DE@GSKDBD! U>! ANF;<=! DTU;K;SA;=!<DFD><;D>@D!<D!FY! eFqGsO8c!G!PQt$f!C! ADGBB;=>G!MD<;G>@D! !&! =:;<GB;I>!<;ADB@G!F=A!U>=!=!<=E!DKDB@A=>DE!eZ;JUAG!7fk! !!&!G<;B;I>!>UBKD=Z?K;BG!G!<;I:;<=!<D!BGAS=>=!e$)9f!AD<;A;J;D><=!KG!GB@;H;<G<! S;=KIJ;BG! <DK! FDA=:;>;@A;@=! m77a7^n! _GB;G! Z=AMGB;I>! <DK! ;>@DAMD<;GA;=! G>;I>!>;@A=E=FDA=:=BGAS=>G@=!e)&)9$)9

af!e'#s!^8c:7`L!"a7Ea7f!m77nk!TUD!ED!<DEB=MF=>D!Z=AMG><=!<;I:;<=!<D!>;@AIJD>=!eh&)9f!C!G>;I>!AG<;BGK!BGAS=>G@=!e$)P

haf!m7Onk!=!>;@AG@=!e&)Paf!m77k!7Lk!

7^n! e[;JUAG!7fk!=! !!!&!BK;HG\D!_=M=K?@;B=!<DK!NB;<=!FDA=:;>;@A=E=!e)&))Yf!eZ;JUAG!7f!G!h&)9!C!AG<;BGK!_;<A=:;K=!eh)Yf!=!;E=MDA;bGB;I>!<;ADB@GMD>@D!G!&)P

a!!e[;JUAG!7f!mRn8!$UG><=!GUMD>@G!KG! FA=<UBB;I>! <D! h&)! C! )9

ha! KG! E?>@DE;E! <D! FDA=:;>;@A;@=! G<TU;DAD! ADKDHG>B;G! S;=KIJ;BGl! KG!DEFDB;D!G>;I>;BG!a!)&))a!a!C!EU!NB;<=!B=>\UJG<=!a!)&))Y!a!C!KGE!#3&!<DA;HG<GE!<D!KG!G<;B;I>!<DK!FDA=:;>;@A;@=!GK!$)9k! C!D>!MD>=A!MD<;<G! KGE!#3&!<DA;HG<GE!<D!EU!_=MIK;E;Ek!M=<;Z;BG>!U>G! JAG>! HGA;D<G<! <D! SKG>B=E! S;=KIJ;B=E8! ,GE! #3&! @;D>D>! U>G! ADGB@;H;<G<! i>;BG! _GB;G!

Page 6: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

6

FA=@D?>GE! m7Qnk! K?F;<=E! m7ca97n! C! %/&! m99k! 9Pn! FA=M=H;D><=! ADGBB;=>DE! <D! >;@A=EGB;I>k!>;@AGB;I>! CX=! =:;<GB;I>8! #E@GE! M=<;Z;BGB;=>DE! ;><UBD>! ADEFUDE@GE! B;@=@I:;BGE! TUD!FA=MUDHD>! KGE! ADEFUDE@GE! ;>ZKGMG@=A;GE! C! FA=BDE=E! >DUA=<DJD>DAG@;H=E! m9Lk! 9^nk! C! MNE!ADB;D>@DMD>@D!@GMS;V>!ED!_G!ADB=>=B;<=!TUD!GB@iG>!B=M=!MD<;=!<D!EDjGK;bGB;I>!AD<=:!D>!KG! ADJUKGB;I>! <D! FA=BDE=E! S;=KIJ;B=Ek! D>! FGA@;BUKGA! KG! >;@AGB;I>! <D! ADE;<U=E! @;A=E;>G! D>!FA=@D?>GE!C!KG!>;@AGB;I>!<D!NB;<=E!JAGE=E!;>EG@UAG<=E!m9Ok!9Qn8!!

!#K!h&)9!DE!U>!AG<;BGK!GK@GMD>@D!=:;<G>@D!<DEBA;F@=!;>;B;GKMD>@D!B=M=!U>!B=>@GM;>G>@D!

GMS;D>@GK8!(U! Z=AMGB;I>! !"#$!$%#ED!<DSD!FA;>B;FGKMD>@D!G! KG! !&!GU@==:;<GB;I>!<DK!h&)!e'#s!9:7`O!"a9Ea7fk!!!&!=:;<GB;I>!<D!>;@A;@=!e&)9

af!F=A!_DM=FDA=:;<GEGEk!C!!!!&!_=MIK;E;E!<D!)&))Y!e[;JUAG! 7f! mQn8! ,GE!M=KVBUKGE! JGED=EGE! <D! h&)9! Z=AMG<GE! DE@GSKDBD>! U>! DTU;K;SA;=! B=>! EU!<?MDA=k!DK!&9)L8!#>!FADED>B;G!<D!GJUG!DK!&9)L!ED!<DEB=MF=>D!ANF;<GMD>@D!G!&)9

a!C!&)Pa8!

%K@DA>G@;HGMD>@Dk!DK!h&)9!ADGBB;=>G!B=>!h&)!FGAG!Z=AMGA!&9)Pk!U>!GJD>@D!>;@A=EG>@D!TUD!ED!

<DEB=MF=>D! G! &)9a! D>! FADED>B;G! <D! GJUG! e[;JUAG! 7f8! #>! GMS;D>@DE! GB?<;B=E! B=>! GK@GE!

B=>BD>@AGB;=>DE! <D! &)9ak! B=M=! DK! B=MFGA@;MD>@=! JNE@A;B=k! DK! DTU;K;SA;=! ZGH=ADBD! KG!

Z=AMGB;I>!<D!h&)9!G!FGA@;A!<D!&9)P!m9ck!9Rn8!!!

%

2$O/+,%S>%5+$-)$K,3"#%1"),-$#1(#%&"%+",))$G-%&"%hP<%E%J(+1,)$G-%&"%6@P>%#K!h&)!ED!EUZAD!ADGBB;=>DE!<D!@;F=!

AD<=:!eD\8!=:;<GB;=>DE!=!AD<UBB;I>!F=A!U>!DKDB@AI>fk!GU@=a=:;<GB;I>k!=!B=MS;>GB;I>!B=>!=@A=E!AG<;BGKDE!eD\8l!

)9ha! FGAG! Z=AMGA!FDA=:;>;@A;@=f8! #K! FDA=:;>;@A;@=! DE! U>G!DEFDB;D!>=! AG<;BGKGA! GK@GMD>@D!=:;<G>@Dk! TUD! Z=AMG!

h&)9!F=A! HGA;GE! H?GE8! #>b;MGE! B=M=! KG!M;DK=FDA=:;<GEG! e"0)f! FA=MUDHD>! KG! =:;<GB;I>!F=A! U>! DKDB@AI>!<D!

&)9a! FGAG! Z=AMGA! h&)9! <DFD><;D>@D! <D! KG! FADED>B;G! <D! Y9)98! ,=E! AG<;BGKDE% C% DEFDB;DE! ;>H=KUBAG<GE! D>! KG!

>;@AGB;I>!K;F?<;BG!ED!MUDE@AG>!D>!A=\=8!

e"=<;Z;BG<=!<D!/D>;B=KG!()#*+,k!%AB_;HDE!=Z!1;=B_DM;E@AC!G><!1;=F_CE;BEk!7RROk!2=K8!PPPk!C!<D!3G<;!()#*+,k!&;@A;B!):;<Dl!

1;=K=JC!G><!0G@_=S;=K=JCk!9```k!$_8!Lf8!

Page 7: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

7

T>T% P$*+,)$G-%3$K0&$),%!! ,G! ADGBB;I>! <DK! h&)! C! KGE! #3&! B=>! NB;<=E! JAGE=E! ;>EG@UAG<=E! e%W'Ef! JD>DAG! U>G!HGA;D<G<!<D!FA=<UB@=E!=:;<G<=E!C!>;@AG<=Ek!TUD!F=EDD>!FA=F;D<G<DE!S;=KIJ;BGE!ADKDHG>@DE!m7ck! P`aP9n8! (D! _G>! ;<D>@;Z;BG<=k! <D@DB@G<=! C! BUG>@;Z;BG<=! <DA;HG<=E! >;@AG<=E! <D! %W'E! D>!FKGEMG!C!@D\;<=E!<D!FGB;D>@DE!>=AMGKDE!D!_;FDAB=KDE@DA=KVM;B=E!GE?!B=M=!D>!MDMSAG>GE!<D!JKISUK=E!A=\=E!mPPk!PLno!G<DMNEk!ED!_G!<DM=E@AG<=!TUD!EU!Z=AMGB;I>!ED!;><UBD!D>!E;E@DMGE!D:FUDE@=E! G! DE@?MUK=E! ;>ZKGMG@=A;=E! mP^aPcnk! C! ED! _G! <DEBA;F@=! EU! A=K! B=M=! >UDH=E!B=MFUDE@=E!TUD!M=<UKG>!H?GE!<D! EDjGK;bGB;I>! BDKUKGA! JD>DAGKMD>@D!GE=B;G<GE!G!FA=BDE=E!;>ZKGMG@=A;=E!mPRk!L`n8!!!

T>T>S% N"),-$#1(#%&"%-$*+,)$G-%&"%_)$&(#%O+,#(#%!! ,=E! @AGSG\=E! F;=>DA=E! <D! u;KK;GM! 0AC=A! <UAG>@D! KG! <VBG<G! <D! 7Rc`! ZUDA=>! K=E!FA;MDA=E! D>! GF=A@GA! ;>Z=AMGB;I>! E=SAD! K=E! MDBG>;EM=E! AG<;BGKGADE! ;>H=KUBAG<=E! D>! KG!E?>@DE;E! <D! K=E! >;@A=GKTUD>=E! mL7k! L9n8! /UAG>@D! DE@D! FDA?=<=! ED! B=>E;<DAGSG! B=M=! i>;BG!ZUD>@D!<D!>;@AGB;I>!G!KGE!@=:;>GE!>=AMGKMD>@D!FADED>@DE!D>!DK!G;AD!B=M=!B=>EDBUD>B;G!<D!KG!F=KUB;I>! GMS;D>@GK! =! DK! _UM=! <D! B;JGAA;KK=k! FA;>B;FGKMD>@D! h&)98! #>! 7Rcc! ]8,! 'J>GAA=! C!B=KGS=AG<=ADE!<DEBUSA;DA=>!TUD!DK!ZGB@=A!<D!ADKG\GM;D>@=!<DA;HG<=!<DK!D><=@DK;=!e#/3[k!<DK!;>JKVEf! DAG! DK! h&)! mLPnk! C! ANF;<GMD>@D! ED! EUF=! TUD! KG! E?>@DE;E! D><IJD>G! <D! DEFDB;DE!ADGB@;HGE!<DA;HG<GE!<DK!h&)!DE@GSG!;>H=KUBAG<G!D>!KG!ADJUKGB;I>!<D!FA=BDE=E!Z;E;=KIJ;B=E8!%!FGA@;A!<D!KG!<VBG<G!<D!7RR`!KG!>;@AGB;I>!K;F?<;BG!MD<;G<G!F=A!#3&!JG>G!ADKDHG>B;G!S;=KIJ;BG!B=M=!F=@D>B;GK!H?G!<D!ADJUKGB;I>!AD<=:!<D!FA=BDE=E!BDKUKGADE!m7cn8!!!

#K! MDBG>;EM=! <D! E?>@DE;E! <D! >;@A=K?F;<=E! !"# $!$%! ED! <DEB=>=BDk! FDA=! >UMDA=E=E!@AGSG\=E! !"# $!)-%! EDjGKG>! TUD! KGE! H?GE!MNE! FA=SGSKDE! ;>H=KUBAG>! KG! ADGBB;I>! <D! K=E! NB;<=E!JAGE=E! B=>! h&)9k! FDA=:;>;@A;@=k!

h&)k! =! &)9a! D>! MD<;=! NB;<=! eH?G! Z=AMGB;I>! <D! h&)9fk! C!

FGA@;BUKGAMD>@D!h&)9! mP9k!LLn8!,G!D:@AGF=KGB;I>!<D!DE@GE!=SEDAHGB;=>DE!GK!MD<;=!S;=KIJ;B=!ADFADED>@G! U>! <DEGZ?=! <DS;<=! G! KG! B=MFKD\;<G<! <DK! E;E@DMGk! <=><D! ED! <DSD! B=>E;<DAGA! DK!E;@;=! BDKUKGA! <D! E?>@DE;E! C! KG! <;E@A;SUB;I>! BDKUKGA! <D! KGE! DEFDB;DE! ADGB@;HGE! ADEF=>EGSKDEk! KG!H;<G!MD<;G!<D!KGE!DEFDB;DE!;>@DAMD<;GA;GEk!C!KG!FADED>B;G!<D!@GAJD@E!S;=KIJ;B=E!TUD!F=<A?G>!B=MFD@;A!F=A!KGE!DEFDB;DE!>;@AG>@DE8!!T>T>S>S%% ;$K(K"+(^$&,)$G-%!! ,G! K;F=FDA=:;<GB;I>! DE! DK! FA=BDE=! F=A! DK! BUGK! ED! ;>B=AF=AG!)9! G! K?F;<=E! ;>EG@UAG<=E!e,Yf!FGAG! Z=AMGA!_;<A=FDAI:;<=E! K;F?<;B=E! e,))Yf! e[;JUAG!9f8!#E!BKGHD!<;EBU@;A!DE@D!FA=BDE=!FGAG!D>@D><DA!DK!MDBG>;EM=!<D!>;@AGB;I>!K;F?<;BG8!!! ,G!D@GFG!<D!;>;B;GB;I>!<D!KG!K;F=FDA=:;<GB;I>!B=>E;E@D!D>!U>!G@GTUD!G!,Y!F=A!FGA@D!<D!BUGKTU;DA!DEFDB;D!EUZ;B;D>@DMD>@D!ADGB@;HG!B=M=!FGAG!GSE@AGDA!U>!N@=M=!<D!_;<AIJD>=!<D!U>!JAUF=!MD@;KD>=!<D!KG!BG<D>G!K;F?<;BG!eD\8k!h)Yf!mL^n8!$GAGB@DA?E@;BGMD>@Dk!K=E!N@=M=E!<D!_;<AIJD>=!U>;<=E!G!BGAS=>=E!G<CGBD>@DE!G!U>!<=SKD!D>KGBD!DE@GSKDBD>!D>KGBDE!MNE!KNS;KDE!

Page 8: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

8

e_;<AIJD>=E! GK?K;B=Ef8! +>! NB;<=! JAGE=! M=>=a;>EG@UAG<=! e%W"'f! @;D>D! <=E! F=E;B;=>DE!GK?K;BGEk! M;D>@AGE! TUD! K=E! NB;<=E! JAGE=E! F=K;a;>EG@UAG<=E! e%W0'f! @;D>D>! ./0! F=E;B;=>DE! S;EaGK?K;BGEk!E;D><=!.#DK!>iMDA=!<D!<=SKDE!D>KGBDE!<D!KG!M=KVBUKG!mLOn8!0=A!K=!@G>@=k!K=E!%W0'!E=>!MNE!EUEBDF@;SKDE!G!KG!K;F=FDA=:;<GB;I>!TUD!K=E!NB;<=E! JAGE=E! EG@UAG<=E! =! K=E! %W"'! mLQn8! #>!JD>DAGKk!KGE!ADGBB;=>DE!<D!;>;B;GB;I>!MD<;G<GE!F=A!AG<;BGKDE!K;SADE!FA=F=AB;=>G>!MNE!D>DAJ?G!TUD! KG! FDA<;<G! F=A! KG! <;E=B;GB;I>! <DK! D>KGBD!BGAS=>=a_;<AIJD>=k! <D! MG>DAG! TUD! KG!GSE@AGBB;I>!<DK!_;<AIJD>=!GK?K;B=!<DK!,Y!Z=AMG!U>G! M=KVBUKG! >=! AG<;BGKGA! MNE! DE@GSKD! C! U>!AG<;BGK! GKTU;K=! BD>@AG<=! D>! BGAS=>=! e,hf!;>DE@GSKD!D>!FADED>B;G!<D!)9k! AG<;BGKDE! K;SADE!C! GJD>@DE! AD<UB@=ADE! mLOn8! )@AGE! ZUD>@DE! <D!;>;B;GB;I>! <D! KG! BG<D>G! E=>! K=E! MD@GKDE! <D!@AG>E;B;I>k! B=M=!DK! B=SAD!U! DK! _;DAA=k! B;DA@=E!E;E@DMGE!D>b;MN@;B=E!=! KG! AG<;GB;I>! ;=>;bG>@D!mLcn!e#ETUDMG!7f8!!!! /UAG>@D! KG! D@GFG! <D! FA=FGJGB;I>! ED!G<;B;=>G! U>! )9! GK! AG<;BGK! GKTU;K=k! ,

hk! <G><=!B=M=! FA=<UB@=! U>! AG<;BGK! FDA=:;K=! BD>@AG<=!D>!)9k!,))

h8!,G!ADGBB;I>!D>@AD!K=E!AG<;BGKDE!,h!

C!DK!)9!@;D>D!U>!B=MF=A@GM;D>@=!E;M;KGA!G!U>!FA=BDE=! MD<;G<=! F=A! <;ZUE;I>! mLOn8! ,=E!

AG<;BGKDE!,))h!<D!%W'!FUD<D>!G<=F@GA!<;ZDAD>@DE!;E=MDA;EM=E!JD=MV@A;B=E!C!F=E;B;=>GKDEk!<D!GBUDA<=!FA;>B;FGKMD>@D!G!KG!FADED>B;G!<D!N@=M=E!<G<=ADE!<D!_;<AIJD>=!D>!DK!GMS;D>@D!<D! KG! ADGBB;I>k! TUD! BGF@UAG>! G! K=E! AG<;BGKDE! ,))h! FGAG! JD>DAGA! ,))Y8! ,G! BG>@;<G<! <D!;EIMDA=E! <D! ,))Y! Z=AMG<=E! GUMD>@G! D>! FA=F=AB;I>! GK! >iMDA=! <D! ;>E@GUAGB;=>DE!FADED>@DE!D>!DK!%W'!mLRn8!#K!AG<;BGK!,))h!ADEUK@G>@D!GSE@AGD!U>!_;<AIJD>=!<D!=@AG!M=KVBUKG!K;F?<;BGk!<G><=! KUJGA!G!=@A=! AG<;BGK! ,hk! TUD!DE!DK!FA;MDA=!<D! KG! BG<D>G!<D!FA=FGJGB;I>8! ,G!HDK=B;<G<!<D!FA=FGJGB;I>!<DFD><D!<D! KG! ZUDAbG!<DK! D>KGBD!$aY!<DK! K?F;<=!TUD!DE@N! E;D><=!=:;<G<=o! DK! AG<;BGK! ADGBB;=>G! FADZDAD>B;GKMD>@D! B=>! K=E! _;<AIJD>=E! D>! KGE! F=E;B;=>DE! S;EaGK?K;BGEk!ADEUK@G><=!D>!KG!Z=AMGB;I>!<D!U>!AG<;BGK!FD>@G<;D>;K=!GK@GMD>@D!<DEK=BGK;bG<=!mLcn!e#ETUDMG!7f8!!!! #>!KG!D@GFG!<D!@DAM;>GB;I>!DK!GB=FKGM;D>@=!<D!<=E!AG<;BGKDE!<G!KUJGA!G!U>!FA=<UB@=!>=!AG<;BGKGA!mLcn!e#ETUDMG!7f8!#>!DK!MD<;=!BDKUKGA!=BUAAD>!FA=BDE=E!<D!@DAM;>GB;I>!<DS;<=!G!KG!FADED>B;G!<D!G>@;=:;<G>@DE!>G@UAGKDE!e>=!AG<;BGKGADEf!TUD!BGF@UAG>!G!K=E!;>@DAMD<;GA;=E!<D!K;F=FDA=:;<GB;I>!,))h!

!&!F=A!@AG>EZDAD>B;G!<D!U>!N@=M=!<D!_;<AIJD>=!Z=AMG><=!,))Y!C!

2$O/+,%T>%2(+1,)$G-%&"%C$&+(K"+G^$&(#%&/+,-*"%

3,%3$K(K"+(^$&,)$G->%#>!KG!D@GFG!<D!;>;B;GB;I>!ED!

Z=AMG!U>!AG<;BGK! K;F?<B=! e,hf!F=A!GSE@AGBB;I>!<D!

U>! _;<AIJD>=! KNS;K! <D! KG! BG<D>G!

_;<A=BGAS=>G<Gk! Z=AMG><=! D>! DK! BGE=! <D! %W0'!

U>! AG<;BGK! FD>@G<;D>;K=! F=A! GSE@AGBB;I>! <D! U>!

_;<AIJD>=! S;EaGK?K;B=8! ,=E! AG<;BGKDE! ,))h!

Z=AMG<=E! F=A! G<;B;I>! <D! )9! FUD<D>! G<=F@GA!

<;ZDAD>@DE! ;E=MDA;EM=E! JD=MV@A;B=E! C!

F=E;B;=>GKDE!D>! ZU>B;I>!<D! K=E! N@=M=E!<G<=ADE!

<D! _;<AIJD>=! D>! DK! GMS;D>@D! <D! KG! ADGBB;I>k!

TUD!BGF@UAG>!G! K=E!AG<;BGKDE!,))h!FGAG!JD>DAGA!

K=E! FDAI:;<=E! K;F?<;B=Ek! ,))Y8! ,G! BG>@;<G<! <D!

;EIMDA=E! <D! ,))Y! Z=AMG<=E! GUMD>@G! B=>! DK!

>iMDA=!<D!;>E@GUAGB;=>DE!FADED>@DE!D>!DK!%W'8!

;?%

;`%

;<<`%

;<<?%

Page 9: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

9

U>! AG<;BGK! <DA;HG<=! <DK! G>@;=:;<G>@Dk! =! !!&! F=A! U>!GB=FKGM;D>@=! AG<;BGKGA! D>@AD! DK! AG<;BGK! <DA;HG<=!<DK! G>@;=:;<G>@D! C! DK! AG<;BGK! ,))h8! ,G! @DAM;>GB;I>!S;=KIJ;BG! <D! KG! K;F=FDA=:;<GB;I>! <;EM;>UCD! DK!B=>EUM=! GU@=:;<G@;H=! <D! %W'k! B=>! U>! DZDB@=!FA=@DB@=A! E=SAD! KGE! BVKUKGE! m^`n8! #K! =AJG>;EM=!BUD>@G! G<DMNE! B=>! U>G! EDA;D! <D! E;E@DMGE! <D!<DZD>EG! B=>@AG! KG! K;F=FDA=:;<GB;I>8! #>@AD! DKK=E! ED!D>BUD>@AG>! K=E! G>@;=:;<G>@DE! D>b;MN@;B=E! e()/k!JKU@G@;I>! FDA=:;<GEGk! BG@GKGEGf! C! K=E! G>@;=:;<G>@DE!>=! D>b;MN@;B=E! <D! SG\=! FDE=! M=KDBUKGA! eva@=B=ZDA=Kk! GEB=ASG@=k! NB;<=! K;F=;B=k! JKU@G@;I>k!UAG@=f8! #>@AD! K=E! G>@;=:;<G>@DE! <D! SG\=! FDE=!M=KDBUKGAk! DK! MNE! <DE@GBG<=! DE! KG! H;@GM;>G! #!eMDbBKG!<D!@=B=ZDA=KDEk!<D!K=E!BUGKDE!DK!va@=B=ZDA=K!DE! DK! MNE! GSU><G>@D! C! F=@D>@Df! m^7k! ^9n8!%K@DA>G@;HGMD>@Dk! KG! K;F=FDA=:;<GB;I>! D>! KG!MDMSAG>G!FUD<D!@DAM;>GAED!F=A!h&)9!=!F=A!

h&)k!Z=AMG><=!FA=<UB@=E!>;@A=JD>G<=E!m7ck!^Pn8!+>G!FAD<=M;>G>B;G!<D!KG!>;@AGB;I>!K;F?<;BG!F=A!E=SAD! KG! =:;<GB;I>! K;F?<;BG! DE! DEFDAGSKD! D>! B=><;B;=>DE! _;FI:;BGE! eD\8! ;ETUDM;GaAD=:;JD>GB;I>k!;>ZKGMGB;I>fk!<=><D!DK!>;HDK!<D!)9!@;EUKGA!DE@N!<;EM;>U;<=!C!_GC!U>!GUMD>@=!D>!KG!FA=<UBB;I>!<D!h&)8!!!T>T>S>T% P$*+(O"-,)$G-%3$K0&$),%K(+%`P<%!! #K!h&)!C!EUE!#3&!<DA;HG<GE!ADGBB;=>G>!B=>!S;=M=KVBUKGE!BA?@;BGE!GK@DAG><=!EU!ZU>B;I>!m^Ln8! #K! h&)! @;D>D! U>! DZDB@=! <UGK! B=M=! MD<;G<=A! S;=KIJ;B=! TUD! TUD<G! FDAZDB@GMD>@D!;KUE@AG<=!D>!DK!FA=BDE=!<D!K;F=FDA=:;<GB;I>!m7ck!^Pn8!+>G!@?F;BG!BUAHG!<=E;EXADEFUDE@G!FGAG!h&)!MUDE@AG! TUD! BUG><=! KG! ADKGB;I>! h&)X)9

ha! DE! SG\Gk! DK! GUMD>@=! D>! K=E! >;HDKDE! <D! h&)!DE@;MUKG! KG! FA=<UBB;I>! <D! FDA=:;>;@A;@=! BGFGb! <D! ;>;B;GA! KG! K;F=FDA=:;<GB;I>! eDZDB@=! FA=a=:;<G>@Dfo! BUG><=! KG! ADKGB;I>! h&)X)9

ha! DE! ;JUGK! =! MGC=A! G! KG! U>;<G<! DK! h&)! GB@iG! B=M=!@DAM;>G<=A! <D! KG! K;F=FDA=:;<GB;I>! eDZDB@=! G>@;a=:;<G>@Df! m7cn8! (;! S;D>! DK! h&)! >=! DE! K=!EUZ;B;D>@DMD>@D!ADGB@;H=!FGAG!;>;B;GA!KG!FDA=:;<GB;I>!K;F?<;BGk!DE!GK@GMD>@D!ADGB@;H=!B=>!K=E!;>@DAMD<;GA;=E!TUD!ED!Z=AMG>!<UAG>@D!KG!FA=FGJGB;I>!<DK!FA=BDE=!e,)hk!=!,))hf!e's7aP:7`R!"a7Ea7f!m^^nk!<G><=!KUJGA!G!KG!Z=AMGB;I>!<D!U>G!HGA;D<G<!<D!FA=<UB@=E!>;@A=JD>G<=E!e[;JUAG!Pf8! ,G! ADGB@;H;<G<! <DK! h&)! B=>! K=E! AG<;BGKDE! K;F?<;B=E! DE!MGC=A! TUD! FGAG! DK! @=B=ZDA=K! e'! w!^:7`^! "a7Ea7f! m^Onk! ;><;BG><=! TUD! DK! h&)! F=<A?G! FA=@DJDA! GK! @=B=ZDA=K! FADED>@D! D>!MDMSAG>GE!S;=KIJ;BGE!<D!K=E!FA=BDE=E!=:;<G@;H=E8!!!

,G! >;@AGB;I>! <D! NB;<=E! JAGE=E! !"# $!$%! =BUAAD! FA;>B;FGKMD>@D! D>! B=MFGA@;MD>@=E!_;<A=ZIS;B=E! B=M=! KG! S;BGFG! K;F?<;BG! BDKUKGAk! =! D>! DK! ;>@DA;=A! K;F=Z?K;B=! <D! K;F=FA=@D?>GE8! #K!h&)! <;ZU><D! K;SADMD>@D! _GB;G! DK! ;>@DA;=A! <D! MDMSAG>GE! C! K;F=FA=@D?>GEk! <DS;<=! G! EU!FDTUDj=! AG<;=! M=KDBUKGAk! BGAJG! >DU@AG! C! BGANB@DA! _;<A=ZIS;B=8! #E@D! xDZDB@=! KUFGy! <D! KG!

6#L/"1,% S>! @",))$(-"#% &"% 3,%%

3$K(K"+(^$&,)$G->! a:b! #BUGB;I>! JK=SGK8!

a9b! 3DGBB;=>DE! <D! 'f! ;>;B;GB;I>k! ''f!

FA=FGJGB;I>k!C!'''f!@DAM;>GB;I>8!

0&3k!FA=<UB@=E!>=!AG<;BGKGADE!

! A

!B

Page 10: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

10

MDMSAG>G!DE! ADEF=>EGSKD!<D!TUD!GFA=:;MG<GMD>@D!DK!R`z!<D! KG!GU@=:;<GB;I>!<DK!&)!ED!KKDHD! G! BGS=! D>! DE@D! B=MFGA@;MD>@=k! G! FDEGA! <D! TUD! ADFADED>@G! i>;BGMD>@D! DK! Pz! <DK!H=KUMD>!BDKUKGA!@=@GK!m^Qa^Rn8!!

!T>T>S>V% P$*+,)$G-%3$K0&$),%K(+%`P<T%!! %!<;ZDAD>B;G!<DK!h&)k!DK!h&)9!DE!U>!F=@D>@D!GJD>@D!=:;<G>@D!C!>;@AG>@D8!,G!ZUD>@D!MNE!FA=SGSKD! <D! h&)9! D>! K=E! B=MFGA@;MD>@=E! _;<A=ZIS;B=E! DE! KG! GU@=:;<GB;I>! <D! h&)k! TUD! G!FDEGA! <D! @D>DA! U>G! B=>E@G>@D! <D! HDK=B;<G<! ADKG@;HGMD>@D! SG\G! egs9:7`O! "a7Ea7f! m^Qn! DE@N!GK@GMD>@D!ZGH=ADB;<G!F=A!DK!DZDB@=!KUFG!<D!KG!MDMSAG>G!m^cn,##K!h&)9!MD<;G!KG!=:;<GB;I>!C!>;@AGB;I>!<D!%W'E!F=A!!&!GSE@AGBB;I>!<D!_;<AIJD>=!<D!KG!BG<D>G!!mL7nk!!!&!G<;B;I>!M=KDBUKGA!G!U>! BD>@A=! <D! BGAS=>=! mL7n8! #E@GE! ADGBB;=>DE! JD>DAG>! U>G! MDbBKG! <D! FA=<UB@=E!;E=MDA;bG<=Ek!=:;<G<=Ek!<DA;HG<=E!>;@A=aGK?K;B=Ek!>;@A=GKTUD>=Ek!<;a>;@A=!=!>;@A=a_;<A=:;KG<=E!mP7k!O`n!e[;JUAG!Lf8!#K!FDAZ;K!<D! K=E!FA=<UB@=E!JD>DAG<=E!<DFD><D!ZU><GMD>@GKMD>@D!<D! KG!B=>BD>@AGB;I>!<D!h&)9!C!)9!FADED>@D8!%!SG\GE!B=>BD>@AGB;=>DE!<D!

h&)9!FAD<=M;>G!KG!H?G!<D!!

2$O/+,% V>% N"),-$#1(#% K+(K/"#*(#% &"% -$*+,)$G-% 3$K0&$),% K(+% `P<8! ,G! G<;B;I>! <D! h&)! G! MDbBKGE! K;F?<;BGE!

<UAG>@D! KG! K;F=FDA=:;<GB;I>! ;>_;SD!DK! B=>EUM=!<D!)9k! TUD! ED! ADBUFDAG!i>;BGMD>@D! BUG><=! @=<=!DK! h&)!ED!

B=>EUM;I8!,G!DE@DTU;=MD@A?G!<D!KG!ADGBB;I>!DE!<D!GK!MD>=E!<=E!M=KVBUKGE!!<D!h&)!F=A!BG<G!,))h!Z=AMG<=8!#K!

FA=<UB@=! ;>;B;GK! <D! KG! ADGBB;I>! DE! U>! FDA=:;>;@A;@=! =AJN>;B=! e,))&)fk! U>! ;>@DAMD<;GA;=! ;>DE@GSKD! TUD! ED!

<DEB=MF=>D! F=A! HGA;GE! H?GE8! ,G! _=MIK;E;E! <DK! D>KGBD! )a)! D>! ,))&)! Z=AMG! ,)h! C! h&)9k! C! U>G! EDJU><G!

M=KVBUKG!<D!h&)!ED!B=>EUMD!D>!KG!ADGBB;I>!B=>!,)h!JD>DAG><=!U>!GKTU;K>;@A;@=!e,)&)f!B=M=!FA=<UB@=!Z;>GK8!

2?GE!GK@DA>G@;HGE!<G>!KUJGA!G!=@A=E!FA=<UB@=E!>;@A=JD>G<=E8!!

e[;JUAG!G<GF@G<G!<D!){/=>>DKK!()#*+,k!1;=B_DM;E@ACk!7RRQk!2=K8!POf!

%

Page 11: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

11

!!

! A

!B

?P<T%

2$O/+,%c>!N"),-#$1(#%&"%-$*+,)$G-%3$K0&$),%K(+%`P<T>!a:b!#K!h&)9!FUD<D!GSE@AGDA!U>!_;<AIJD>=!GK?K;B=!=!S;Ea

GK?K;B=! <D! U>! %W'! Z=AMG><=! U>! AG<;BGK! K;F?<;B=! BD>@AG<=! D>! BGAS=>=! C! NB;<=! >;@A=E=! eY)&)fk! TUD! ED!

<DEB=MF=>D!ANF;<GMD>@D!@=A>G><=!KG!ADGBB;I>!;AADHDAE;SKD8!%!SG\G!@D>E;I>!<D!)9k!U>G!EDJU><G!M=KVBUKG!

Page 12: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

12

GSE@AGBB;I>!<D!_;<AIJD>=! e[;JUAG!L%f8!#>! @VAM;>=E!JD>DAGKDEk! KG!GSE@AGBB;I>!<D!_;<AIJD>=!F=A!h&)9!DE!U>G!ADGBB;I>!MUC!KD>@Gk!FDA=!D>!E;E@DMGE!B=>!N@=M=E!<D!_;<AIJD>=!GB@;HG<=E!eD\8! _;<AIJD>=E! S;EaGK?K;B=E! D>! BD>@A=E!MD@;KD>=f! ED! @=A>G!MUC! ZGH=AGSKD! D! ;AADHDAE;SKD8! #K!MDBG>;EM=!<D!>;@AGB;I>!F=A!h&)9!<D!MGC=A!ADKDHG>B;G!S;=KIJ;BG!DE!KG!G<;B;I>!G!U>!BD>@A=!<D!BGAS=>=! ;>EG@UAG<=o! DE! U>G! ADGBB;I>! ADHDAE;SKD! TUD! ED! HD! ZGH=ADB;<G! BUG><=! KG!B=>BD>@AGB;I>!<D!h&)9!DE!DKDHG<G!e[;JUAG!L1f8!#K!FA;MDA! ;>@DAMD<;GA;=!<D! KG!ADGBB;I>!DE!DK!AG<;BGK! |a>;@A=GKTU;K=k! C! K=E! FA=<UB@=E! Z;>GKDE! <DFD><D>! <D! KG! F=KGA;<G<! <DK! MD<;=!!eGMS;D>@DE!_;<A=Z?K;B=E!ZGH=ADBD>!KG!;E=MDA;bGB;I>!G!)-*"1f!C!<D!KG!@D>E;I>!<D!)9!e[;JUAG!L1f8!,=E! >;HDKDE! <D! )9! @;D>D>! U>! ZUDA@D! ;MFGB@=! E=SAD! DK! AD><;M;D>@=! <D! =:;<GB;I>! HDAEUE!>;@AGB;I>k!U>G!HDb!TUD!DK!h&)9!;>;B;I!DK!FA=BDE=!<D!=:;<GB;I>!K;F?<;BG!mL7k!O7k!O9n!

!T>T>S>c%%% P$*+,)$G-%3$K0&$),%K(+%K"+(^$-$*+$*(%!! #K! FDA=:;>;@A;@=! ADGBB;=>G! B=>! U>G! HGA;D<G<! <D! SKG>B=E! S;=KIJ;B=Ek! ;>BKUCD><=!ADE;<U=E!<D!@;A=E;>G!D>!FA=@D?>GEk!@;=KDEk!C!%W'E!m7Qk!P`k!OPk!OLn8!3DFADED>@G!U>G!ZUD>@D!<D!h&)9!D>!MDMSAG>GE!K;F?<;BGEk!D>!<=><D!;>JADEG!F=A!<;ZUE;I>!e)&))Yf!=!G!@AGHVE!<D!BG>GKDE!G>;I>;B=E! e)&))af! mO^n8! #K! FGE=! K;M;@G>@D! <D! KG! >;@AGB;I>! <D! %W'E! F=A! FDA=:;>;@A;@=! DE! KG!Z=AMGB;I>!<D!h&)9!F=A!_=MIK;E;E!<D!)&))Y!=!<D!)&)9$)9

ak!CG!TUD!>=!_GC!ADGBB;I>!<;ADB@G!<D!)&))a! =!)&))Y!B=>! K=E! BD>@A=E! BGAS=>=! ;>EG@UAG<=E! m7cn8! $GMS;=E! D>!DK! FY! C! D>! KG!B=>BD>@AGB;I>!<D!$)9! E=>! ;MF=A@G>@DE!D>! KG!M=<UKGB;I>!<D! KG!ADGB@;H;<G<!<D!FDA=:;>;@A;@=!B=>!NB;<=E!JAGE=Ek!C!FUD<D>!ZGH=ADBDA!KG!>;@AGB;I>!K;F?<;BG!E=SAD!KGE!ADGBB;=>DE!<D!=:;<GB;I>!mOOn8!!!

T>T>T% 5+(K$"&,&"#%A$(L/01$),#%&"%3(#%-$*+(,3L/"-(#%%!! ,G!FADED>B;G!<D!>;@A=!ea&)9f!D>!U>!BD>@A=!;>EG@UAG<=!<D!KG!BG<D>G!_;<A=BGAS=>G<G!<D!U>!NB;<=!JAGE=!<G!KUJGA!G!U>!>;@A=GKTUD>=k!B=>!FA=F;D<G<DE!Z;E;B=TU?M;BGE!i>;BGE!ADEFDB@=!G!EU!FGA!>=!>;@AG<=8! ,=E!>;@A=GKTUD>=E!E=>!KDHDMD>@D!MNE!F=KGADE!TUD!K=E!NB;<=E!JAGE=E!>=!>;@AG<=Ek!FDA=!Gi>!MG>@;D>D>!U>G!GK@G!_;<A=Z=S;B;<G<!<DS;<G!G! KG!BG<D>G!_;<A=BGAS=>G<G8!

<D!h&)9!ADGBB;=>G!B=>!DK!AG<;BGK!,h!Z=AMG><=!U>!>;@A=GKBG>=!e=!<DA;HG<=!>;@A=aGK?K;B=f8!$UG><=!KG!@D>E;I>!<D!

)9!DE!MNE!DKDHG<Gk!ED!Z=AMG!U>!AG<;BGK!>;@A=aFDA=:;K=!TUD!DE!GK@GMD>@D!;>DE@GSKD!C!FUD<D!ADGBB;=>GA!B=>!U>!

%W'!HDB;>=!FGAG!;>;B;GA!KG!K;F=FDA=:;<GB;I>o!GK@DA>G@;HGMD>@D!ADGBB;=>G!B=>!U>G!EDJU><G!M=KVBUKG!<D!h&)9!

FGAG! Z=AMGA! U>! >;@A=a>;@AG@=! GKBG>=8! a9b! %! B=>BD>@AGB;=>DE!MNE! DKDHG<GEk! DK! h&)9! ADGBB;=>G! F=A! G<;B;I>!

_=M=K?@;BG! G! U>! BD>@A=! ;>EG@UAG<=! FGAG! Z=AMGA! U>! AG<;BGK! |a>;@A=GKTU;K=8! #>! MD<;=! GBU=E=! DK! FA;>B;FGK!

FA=<UB@=!DE!)-*"1a%W'8!#>!GMS;D>@DE!GF=KGADE!C!G!SG\G!@D>E;I>!<D!)9k!DK!AG<;BGK!ADGBB;=>G!B=>!U>G!EDJU><G!

M=KVBUKG!<D!h&)9!Z=AMG><=!U>!<;>;@A=aGKBG>=!CX=!U>!>;@A=a>;@A;@=!GKBG>=k!;>@DAMD<;GA;=E!;>DE@GSKDE!TUD!ED!

<DEB=MF=>D>! G! >;@A=GKTUD>=! D>! 2!1! =! )-*"1! eM;>=A;@GA;=f! C! Y)&)8! %K@DA>G@;HGMD>@Dk! KG! _;<AIK;E;E! <D! K=E!

GKBG>=E! >;@A=JD>G<=E! FUD<D!<GA! U>!>;@A=aGKB=_=K8! $UG><=! KG! @D>E;I>!<D!)9! DE!MNE! DKDHG<Gk! ED! Z=AMG!U>!

AG<;BGK!>;@A=aFDA=:;K=! BGFGb!<D! ;>;B;GA! KG!FDA=:;<GB;I>! K;F?<;BG!=!<D! ADGBB;=>GA! B=>!=@AG!M=KVBUKG!<D! h&)9!

FGAG!Z=AMGA!U>!>;@A=a>;@AG@=!GKBG>=8!

e[;JUAG!G<GF@G<G!<D!0AC=A!u%8!()#*+8k!]8!%M8!$_DM8!(=Bk!7Rc9k!2=K8!7`Lo!WGKK=>!%%8!D)#*+,k!,;F;<Ek!7RRPk!2=K8!9co!WGKK=>!

%%8!()#*+,k!,;F;<Ek!7RRLk!2=K8!9Ro!)}/=>>DKK!()#*+,k!$_DM8!3DE8!.=:;B=Kk!7RRRk!2=K8!79f!

Page 13: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

13

,G!<DZ;B;D>B;G!<D!DKDB@A=>DE!<DK!JAUF=! a&)9!GUMD>@G! KG!GB;<Db!<D! K=E!_;<AIJD>=E!U>;<=E!G!K=E!BGAS=>=E!G<CGBD>@DE8!,=E!_;<AIJD>=E!S;EaGK?K;B=E!<D!JAUF=E!MD@;KD>=!D>!>;@A=a%W0'!E=>!FGA@;BUKGAMD>@D! ADGB@;H=EXKNS;KDE! D:FK;BG><=! KG! DE@GS;K;<G<! AD<UB;<G! <D! K=E! >;@A=a%W0'!ADEFDB@=!G!K=E!>;@A=a%W"'!D>!MD<;=!GBU=E=!mO`n8!!! ,G!<DZ;B;D>B;G!<D!DKDB@A=>DE!<DK!JAUF=!a&)9!B=>Z;DAD!<D!U>G!DKDHG<G!DKDB@A=Z;K;B;<G<!GK!BGAS=>=! |aG<CGBD>@D! D>! KG! BG<D>G! _;<A=BGAS=>G<G! C! ZGH=ADBD! EU! ADGBB;I>! B=>! BD>@A=E!>UBKD=Z?K;B=E!eD\8l!B;E@D?>GEk!_;E@;<;>Gk!=!K;E;>G!FADED>@DE!D>!KGE!FA=@D?>GEk!JKU@G@;I>!eW(Yf!D>!DK!B;@=E=Kk!D@Bf!F=A!U>G!G<;B;I>!<D!";B_GDKk!>=AMGKMD>@D!KKGMG<G!x>;@A=GKTU;KGB;I>y!BUG><=!DK!DKDB@AIZ;K=!DE!U>!>;@A=GKTUD>=!e[;JUAG!^%f!mOQk!Ocn8!,=E!G<UB@=E!<D!";B_GDK!Z=AMG<=E!E=>!ZNB;KMD>@D!ADHDAE;SKDE!D>!DK!AG>J=!<D!B=>BD>@AGB;I>!Z;E;=KIJ;BG!<D!W(Y8!(D!_G>!;<D>@;Z;BG<=!G<UB@=E!<D!W(Y!B=>!NB;<=!>;@A=a=KD;B=!e&)9)%f!C!>;@A=aK;>=KD;B=!e&)9,%f!D>!JKISUK=E!A=\=E!_UMG>=E!<D!H=KU>@GA;=E!EG>=E!mOQn8!,=E!>;@A=GKTUD>=E!@;D>D>!FA=F;D<G<DE!DEFDB@AGKDE!D>!DK!

2$O/+,%d>%@",))$G-%&"%N$)C,"3%"-*+"%/-%-$*+(,3L/"-(%E%/-,%"#K")$"%-/)3"(J03$),>!a:b!#>!KG!G<;B;I>!<D!";B_GDK!DK! >UBKDIZ;K=! ADGBB;=>G! B=>! DK! DKDB@AIZ;K=! D>! KG! F=E;B;I>! |! Z=AMG><=! U>! G<UB@=! B=HGKD>@D8! a9b! %>NK;E;E!DEFDB@AGK!<D!KG!ADGBB;I>!<D!&)9%%!B=>!!JKU@G@;I>8!!

ea:b%ED!D:@AG\=!<D!1GgDA!()#*+,3!]=UA>GK!=Z!1;=K=J;BGK!$_DM;E@ACk!9``Qk!2=K8!9c9f!

A

B

O3/*,*$G-II%

Page 14: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

14

+2! BGAGB@DA?E@;BGEk! TUD! BGMS;G>! BUG><=! DE@GSKDBD>! U>! G<UB@=! B=HGKD>@D! B=>! B;E@D?>G! =!JKU@G@;I>8!#K!NB;<=!>;@A=GAGTU;<I>;B=!e&)9%%f!@;D>D!U>!MN:;M=!<D!GSE=ASG>B;G!GKAD<D<=A!<D!9Q`! >M! D>! E=KHD>@DE! GF=KGADEk! BGAGB@DA?E@;B=! <DK! E;E@DMG! B=>\UJG<=! TUD! ED! Z=AMG! D>! KG!BG<D>G!_;<A=BGAS=>G<G!F=A!G<;B;I>!<DK!JAUF=!a&)9!G!U>!JAUF=!H;>;K=8!#>!DK!@AG>EBUAE=!<D!KG!>;@A=GKTU;KGB;I>! DK! JAUF=! &)9aH;>;K=! ED! AD<UBD! G! &)9aGK;K=! e<=><D! a&)9! DE@N! U>;<=! G! U>!BD>@A=! $a$! EG@UAG<=f! C! D>! B=>EDBUD>B;G! ED! =SEDAHG! U>G! <;EM;>UB;I>! D>! DK! MN:;M=! <D!GSE=ASG>B;G! e[;JUAG! ^1f! mOcn8! #E@G! FA=F;D<G<! FA=F=AB;=>I! U>! MV@=<=! ED>B;KK=! FGAG! KG!BGAGB@DA;bGB;I>!B;>V@;BG!<D!KG!ADGBB;I>!<D!>;@A=GKTUD>=E!B=>!FDTUDj=E!@GAJD@E!>UBKD=Z?K;B=E8!,G!ADGBB;I>!<D!&)9)%!C!&)9,%!B=>!B;E@D?>G!e's7cP!G><!P^^!"

a7Ea7k!ADEFDB@;HGMD>@Do!FY!Q8Lk!.sPQ~$f!ZUD! ;JUGK!=!MNE!ANF;<G!TUD!FGAG!=@A=E!DKDB@AIZ;K=E! K;F?<;B=E!<D!ADKDHG>B;G!S;=KIJ;BG!eD\8!_;<A=:;>=>D>GKk!;E=FA=E@G>=Ek!D@Bf!mOcn8!!!! ,G!DE@GS;K;<G<!S;=KIJ;BG!<D!K=E!>;@A=K?F;<=E!<DFD><D!ZU><GMD>@GKMD>@D!<DK!DTU;K;SA;=!TUD!ED!DE@GSKDBD!D>@AD!EU!<DEB=MF=E;B;I>!D>!MD<;=!GBU=E=k!<=><D!E=>!;>DE@GSKDE!mO`nk!C!KG!ADGB@;H;<G<! DKDB@A=Z?K;BG! B=>! SKG>B=E! S;=KIJ;B=Ek! D\8! M=<;Z;BGB;=>DE! F=E@a@AG<UBB;=>GKDE! <D!FA=@D?>GE! mOQn8! ,=E! >;@A=GKTUD>=E! JD>DAG<=E! !"# 1!)4! =! GKMGBD>G<=E! F=A! DE@DA;Z;BGB;I>! G!B=MF=>D>@DE!K;F?<;B=E!<D!MDMSAG>G!E=>!DE@GSKDE!C!>=!ADGB@;H=E8!#>!ADEFUDE@G!GK!GUMD>@=!<D! KG! B=>BD>@AGB;I>! ;>@AGBDKUKGA! <D! BGKB;=! e$G9pf! E=>! K;SDAG<=E! GK! B;@=E=K! F=A! GBB;I>! <D! KG!Z=EZ=K;FGEG!%9!e0,%9fk!C!ED!M=H;K;bG>!FGAG!GKBG>bGA!EUE!@GAJD@E!BDKUKGADE!Z=AMG><=!G<UB@=E!<D!";B_GDK! B=>!FA=@D?>GE!C! @;=KDE!<D!SG\=!FDE=!M=KDBUKGA! m97k!P9n8! ,G!<DEB=MF=E;B;I>!<D! K=E!>;@A=GKTUD>=E!D>!MD<;=!GBU=E=!JD>DAG! h&)!mO`n!C!@AG>EBUAAD!MD<;G>@D! !&!U>G!ADGBB;I>!<D!&DZ!M=<;Z;BG<Gk! TUD! ;>H=KUBAG! KG! Z=AMGB;I>!<D!U>! ;>@DAMD<;GA;=! ;>DE@GSKD! >;@A=E=k! =! !!&#DK!ADGAADJK=!<DK!>;@A=GKTUD>=!G!DE@DA!<D!>;@A;@=k!EDJU;<=!<D!KG!_=MIK;E;E!<DK!D>KGBD!&a$!mO`k!ORn8!,=E!>;@A=GKTUD>=E!E=>!BGFGBDE!<D!;><UB;A!HGE=ADKG\GB;I>!F=A!GB@;HGB;I>!<D!KG!EW$!mORaQ7n!C!F=<A?G>!BUMFK;A!U>!A=K!B=M=!ADEDAH=A;=E!D><IJD>=E!<D!h&)8!(;>!DMSGAJ=k!KG!MGC=A?G!<D!KGE!FA=F;D<G<DE! S;=KIJ;BGE! <DEBA;F@GE! FGAG! >;@A=GKTUD>=E! <DFD><D>! <D! KG! M=<;Z;BGB;I>! F=E@a@AG<UBB;=>GK!<D!FA=@D?>GE!F=A!>;@A=GKTU;KGB;I>!m9Qn!e.GSKG!7f8!!

!

Page 15: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

15

(;! S;D>! ED! B=>=BD! MUC! F=B=! E=SAD! K=E! MDBG>;EM=E! <D! MD@GS=K;bGB;I>k!@AG>EZ=AMGB;I>!C!<DJAG<GB;I>!<D!>;@A=GKTUD>=E!!"#$!$%k!ED!_G!<D@DAM;>G<=!TUD!;>JADEG>!D>!KG!H?G!<D! KG!|a=:;<GB;I>!_DFN@;BG! mQ9nk! E;D><=!DK!FU>@=! Z;>GK!<D! KG!<DJAG<GB;I>!=:;<G@;HG!DK!BGAS=>=!GK!BUGK!ED!D>BUD>@AG!U>;<=!DK!JAUF=!a&)9k!E;D><=!F=E;SKD!TUD!B=MFGA@G>!=@AGE!H?GE!MD@GSIK;BGE!<D!K=E!<D!NB;<=E!JAGE=E!>=!M=<;Z;BG<=E8!!!

T>T>V%5+(K$"&,&"#%A$(3GO$),#%&"%3(#%-$*+(,3L/"-(#%!

% ,G! >;@AGB;I>! K;F?<;BG! ADFADED>@G! U>! >UDH=! MDBG>;EM=! <D! EDjGK;bGB;I>! D>! KG!M=<UKGB;I>! <D! KGE! ADEFUDE@GE! BDKUKGADE! G>@;a;>ZKGMG@=A;GE! C! G<GF@G@;HGE! mQPn8! ,=E!>;@A=GKTUD>=E! M=<UKG>! DK! ZD>=@;F=! ;>ZKGMG@=A;=! <D! MGBAIZGJ=E! C! >DU@AIZ;K=Ek! ADJUKG>! KG!GB@;H;<G<!<D!ZGB@=ADE!<D!@AG>EBA;FB;I>! ;>H=KUBAG<=E!D>!<;HDAE=E!FA=BDE=E!BDKUKGADE!mO`k!QLaQOnk! D\DABD>! DZDB@=E! BGA<;=FA=@DB@=ADE! <UAG>@D! KG! ;>\UA;G! F=A! ;ETUDM;G! ADFDAZUE;I>! =! DK!FADGB=><;B;=>GM;D>@=! ;ETUVM;B=!D>!M=<DK=E!<D! B=AGbI>!G;EKG<=k! C!M=<UKG>! KG!GB@;HGB;I>!<D! KGE! @DAM;>GB;=>DE!>DAH;=EGE!>=B;BDF@;HGE! GE=B;G<G! GK! DE@AVE! >;@A=a=:;<G@;H=! mPQk! OQk! QQk!Qcn8!,GE!FA=F;D<G<DE!<DEBA;F@GE!;>;B;GKMD>@D!D>!M=<DK=E!!"#$!)-%k!G<TU;A;DA=>!JAG>!F=@D>B;GK!S;=KIJ;B=!BUG><=!ED!<DM=E@AI!KG!E?>@DE;E!D><IJD>G!<D!>;@A=K?F;<=E!D>!B=><;B;=>DE!>=AMGKDE!C!ZAD>@D!G!DE@?MUK=E!FA=a;>ZKGMG@=A;=E!mPPk!PLk!PQk!Pck!OQk!QRac7n8!!! ,G! ;>ZKGMGB;I>! DE! U>G! B=MFKD\G! ADEFUDE@G! <DK! =AJG>;EM=! G! KG! FD>D@AGB;I>! <D! U>!GJD>@D!;>ZDBB;=E=!=!<Gj=!BDKUKGAk!B=>!DK!Z;>!ADM=HDA!DK!DE@?MUK=!<D!KG!;>\UA;G!GE?!B=M=!;>;B;GA!DK! FA=BDE=! >DBDEGA;=! FGAG! EG>GA! DK! @D\;<=! mc9n8! #E! U>! FA=BDE=! Z;E;=KIJ;B=! BA?@;B=! FGAG! DK!MG>@D>;M;D>@=!<D! KG!_DM=E@GE;Gk!FDA=!DE@N! @GMS;V>!GE=B;G<=!GK!<DEGAA=KK=!<D!>UMDA=EGE!FG@=K=J?GE! B=M=! KG! G@DA=EBKDA=E;E! =! DK! ;>ZGA@=! <D! M;=BGA<;=! mcPn8! ,=E! >DU@AIZ;K=Ek!M=>=B;@=EXMGBAIZGJ=Ek! FKGTUD@GE! C! BVKUKGE! D><=@DK;GKDEk! ADEF=><D>! G! KG! DE@;MUKGB;I>! F=A!GJ=>;E@GE! G<=F@G><=! U>! ZD>=@;F=! FA=a;>ZKGMG@=A;=! TUD! ED! BGAGB@DA;bG! F=A! !&! KG! M;JAGB;I>!BDKUKGA!_GB;G!DK!Z=B=!;>ZKGMG@=A;=k!!!&!KG!D:F=E;B;I>!<D!FA=@D?>GE!<D!EUFDAZ;B;D!eD\8l!EDKDB@;>GEf!TUD!ZGB;K;@G>!DK!ADBAU@GM;D>@=!<D!KDUB=B;@=E!_GB;G!DK!E;@;=!<D! ;>ZKGMGB;I>!F=A!G<_DE;I>!B=>!FKGTUD@GE!C!BVKUKGE!D><=@DK;GKDEk!!!!&!KG!FD>D@AGB;I>!<D!KGE!BVKUKGE!EG>JU?>DGE!G!@AGHVE!<D!KGE!FGAD<DE! HGEBUKGADE! mcLk! c^n8! (DBU><GA;GMD>@D! GK! BGMS;=! ZD>=@?F;B=k! KGE! BVKUKGE! GB@;HG<GE!K;SDAG>! MD<;G<=ADE! ;>ZKGMG@=A;=E! B=M=! KGE! B;@=TU;>GEk! TUD! ADJUKG>! KG! ADEFUDE@G!;>ZKGMG@=A;G8!%KJU>=E!<D!KGE!D>b;MGE!BUCG!D:FADE;I>!ED!;><UBD!D>!ADEFUDE@G!G!KG!GB@;HGB;I>!<D!JD>DE!;>ZKGMG@=A;=E!E=>!KG!0,%9k!0WY(a9k!&)(9k!C!KGE!&%/0Y!=:;<GEGE!e&):f8![;>GKMD>@Dk!KG! ADE=KUB;I>!<D! KG! ;>ZKGMGB;I>!DE!>DBDEGA;G!FGAG!FA=@DJDA!G! KGE! BVKUKGE! EG>GE!<D!<Gj=8! ,G!;>ZKGMGB;I>! FDAE;E@D>@D! =! BAI>;BG! ;><UBD! U>! BGMS;=! FA=JADE;H=! D>! K=E! @;F=E! BDKUKGADE!FADED>@DE!D>!DK!E;@;=!<D!;>ZKGMGB;I>!C!DK!<DEGAA=KK=!<D!U>G!EDA;D!<D!FG@=K=J?GE!ADKGB;=>G<GE!mc9k!cPn8!!! ,=E! >;@A=GKTUD>=E! G@D>iG>! DK! BGMS;=! ZD>=@?F;B=! <D! BVKUKGE! ;>ZKGMG@=A;GE! F=A!MDBG>;EM=E!;><DFD><;D>@DE!<D!KG!K;SDAGB;I>!<D!h&)!mQ^k!QOn8!#K!&)9,%k!F=A!D\DMFK=k!;>_;SD!KG!GB@;H;<G<!<D!KGE!BVKUKGE!;>ZKGMG@=A;GE!M=>=B;@=EXMGBAIZGJ=E!C!<D!>DU@AIZ;K=E!mPck!Q^k!QOk!cOn8!%<DMNEk!;>_;SD!KG!GB@;HGB;I>!<D!FKGTUD@GE!F=A!U>!MDBG>;EM=!<DFD><;D>@D!<D!B%"0k!D!;>_;SD! KG! GB@;HGB;I>! <D! BVKUKGE! D><=@DK;GKDE! mPck! Q^k! QOk! cOn8! ,G! GB@;HGB;I>! <D!MGBAIZGJ=E!

Page 16: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

16

;><UBD! KG! E?>@DE;E! D><IJD>G! <D! >;@A=K?F;<=Ek! TUD! <;EM;>UCD>! KG! ADEFUDE@G! ;>ZKGMG@=A;G! C!ZGB;K;@G>!KG!ADE=KUB;I>!<D!KG!;>ZKGMGB;I>!mPcn8!,=E!>;@A=GKTUD>=E!<;EM;>UCD>!KG!D:FADE;I>!<D!&)(9! C! KG! EDBADB;I>! <D! KGE! B;@=TU;>GE! FA=a;>ZKGMG@=A;GE! ',aO! C! .&[v! D>! ADEFUDE@G! G!K;F=F=K;EGBNA;<=E! e,0(f! F=A! MDBG>;EM=E! ;><DFD><;D>@DE! <D! KG! Z=AMGB;I>! <D! h&)k! KG!GB@;HGB;I>! <DK! ADBDF@=A! 00%3�k! =! KG! ;><UBB;I>! D>! KG! D:FADE;I>! <D! KG! D>b;MG! G>@;a=:;<G>@D!_DM=! =:;JD>GEGa7! eY)a7f! mcOn8! .GMS;V>! ;>_;SD>! KG! G<_DE;I>! <D! K=E! M=>=B;@=E! GK! KDB_=!D><=@DK;GK! mcOnk! ;MF;<;D><=!KG!M;JAGB;I>!@AG>ED><=@DK;GK!_GB;G! KG! ?>@;MG!C!EU!<;ZDAD>B;GB;I>!_GB;G! MGBAIZGJ=E! MD<;G>@D! KG! ;>_;S;B;I>! <D! KGE! M=KVBUKGE! <D! G<_DE;I>! FADED>@DE! D>! KGE!BVKUKGE! D><=@DK;GKDE! GB@;HG<GE! eD\8l! 0aEDKDB@;>Gk! #aEDKDB@;>Gk! M=KVBUKG! <D! G<_DE;I>!;>@AGBDKUKGAa7k!=!2$%"a7f! mcOn8!%!M=<=!<D!D\DMFK=k!DK!<DA;HG<=!>;@AG<=!<DK!%%! ;MF;<;I!DK!D>EGMSKG\D!<D!KG!&):!C! KG!FA=<UBB;I>!<D!AG<;BGK!)9

ha!D>!U>!M=<DK=!G>;MGK!<D!;>ZKGMGB;I>!mcQn8! $=>! ADEFDB@=! G! K=E! MDBG>;EM=E! <D! GBB;I>! FA=FUDE@=E! FGAG! DE@GE! GB@;H;<G<DE! G>@;a;>ZKGMG@=A;GEk! ED! F=E@UKG! TUD! KG! M=<UKGB;I>! <D! KGE! BVKUKGE! FA=a;>ZKGMG@=A;GE! F=A!>;@A=GKTUD>=E! DE@N! MD<;G<Gk! GK! MD>=E! D>! FGA@Dk! F=A! KG! >;@A=GKTU;KGB;I>! <D! ZGB@=ADE! <D!@AG>EBA;FB;I>! >UBKDGA8! #K!&)9)%! C!&)9,%! GKTU;KG>! 00%3�! D>! U>! ADE;<U=! <D! B;E@D?>G! BA?@;BG!mPPnk!K=!BUGK!FA=SGSKDMD>@D!@;D>D!B=>EDBUD>B;GE!>=!E=K=!D>!K=E!FA=BDE=E!;>ZKGMG@=A;=E!E;>=!@GMS;V>! D>! KG! ADJUKGB;I>! <DK! SGKG>BD! D>DAJV@;B=! C! KG! G<;F=JV>DE;E! mPPk! ORn8! #K! ZGB@=A! <D!@AG>EBA;FB;I>!&[�1! @;D>D!U>! A=K! ;MF=A@G>@D!D>! KG! ADJUKGB;I>!<D! KG! EDBADB;I>!<D! B;@=TU;>GE!FA=a;>ZKGMG@=A;GEk! ZGB@=ADE! <D! BADB;M;D>@=k! M=KVBUKGE! <D! G<_DE;I>! C! FA=@D?>GE! <D! ZGED!GJU<G8! .GMS;V>! DE! ADJUKG<=! >DJG@;HGMD>@D! F=A! GKTU;KGB;I>! <D! ADE;<U=E! GK@GMD>@D!B=>EDAHG<=E! <D! B;E@D?>G! D>! KG! EUSU>;<G<! FO^! <D! U>;I>! G! %/&! mcOn8! #K! &)9,%! ;><UBD! KG!D:FADE;I>! <D! Y)a7! mcOk! cck! cRnk! TUD! @GMS;V>! DE! SKG>B=! FGAG! =@A=E! K?F;<=E! S;=GB@;H=E!<DA;HG<=E! <DK! %%k! B=M=! 7^<a0W]9! mR`n8! ,G! Y)a7!MD<;G! DHD>@=E! BKGHDE! D>! KGE! ADEFUDE@GE!B;@=FA=@DB@=AGE! <DED>BG<D>G<GE! <UAG>@D! KG! ;>ZKGMGB;I>8! ,G! ADJUKGB;I>! <D! KG! D:FADE;I>! <D!Y)a7!DE@N!MD<;G<G!F=A!DKDMD>@=E!<D!KG!ADEFUDE@G!G>@;=:;<G>@D!e%3#Ef!C!DE!F=E;SKD!TUD!K=E!>;@A=GKTUD>=E! ;><UbBG>! KG! D:FADE;I>! D>! Y)a7! F=A! ADJUKGB;I>! <D! 00%3�! =! &[�1! mcRn8! ,=E!>;@A=GKTUD>=E! @GMS;V>! ;>_;SD>! KG! EDjGK;bGB;I>! FA=a;>ZKGMG@=A;G! MD<;G<G! F=A! (.%.!e@AG>E<UB@=A!<D!EDjGK!C!GB@;HG<=A!<D!KG!@AG>EBA;FB;I>#P#3#ZGB@=A!<D!ADEFUDE@G!<D!ZGED!GJU<Gf!MD<;G>@D!KG!;><UBB;I>!<D!"%0!TU;>GEG!Z=EZG@GEGa7!e"%0qa7fk!U>G!Z=EZG@GEG!TUD!B=>@A;SUCD!G!KG!ADE=KUB;I>!<D!KG!;>ZKGMGB;I>!F=A!GK@DAGB;I>!<D!KG!@AG<UBB;I>!<DK!%3&M!G!FA=@D?>GE!mR7n8!,G! ;><UBB;I>!<D!"%0qa7!F=A!>;@A=GKTUD>=E!DE! ;><DFD><;D>@D!<D!KG!GB@;HGB;I>!<D!00%3�k! KG!K;SDAGB;I>!<D!h&)!C!<DK!FA=BDE=!<D!>@;A=GKTU;KGB;I>k!<DM=E@AG><=!TUD!D:;E@D>!MDBG>;EM=E!<D!GBB;I>!<D!K=E!>;@A=GKTUD>=E!Gi>!>=!;<D>@;Z;BG<=E8!

!

T>T>c% 5(*"-)$,3%*"+,KB/*$)(%&"%3(#%-$*+(,3L/"-(#%! !! 0=A!@=<=!K=!G>@DE!D:FUDE@=k!KG!>;@AGB;I>!K;F?<;BG!ADFADED>@G!U>!MDBG>;EM=!F=A!DK!BUGK!DK!h&)!C!EUE!#3&!<DA;HG<GE!@AG<UBD>!;>Z=AMGB;I>!;>ZKGMG@=A;G!C!MD@GSIK;BG8!,=E!>;@A=K?F;<=E!DE@N>! FADED>@DE! D>! KG! HGEBUKG@UAG! mc`n! C! ED! Z=AMG>! D>! B=><;B;=>DE! ;>ZKGMG@=A;GE! mPcn!FGA@;B;FG><=! D>! KG! EDjGK;bGB;I>! AD<=:! G<GF@G@;HG! TUD! FA=MUDHD! KG! ADE=KUB;I>! <D! KG!;>ZKGMGB;I>8! (U! _;<A=Z=S;B;<G<! D! ;>DE@GS;K;<G<! <;Z;BUK@G>! EU! BUG>@;Z;BGB;I>k! FDA=! ED! _G>!<D@DB@G<=!D>!DK!AG>J=!>G>=M=KGA!<D!B=>BD>@AGB;I>k!K=!BUGK!DE!EUZ;B;D>@D!FGAG!FA=M=HDA!KGE!GBB;=>DE! S;=KIJ;BGE! ADF=A@G<GEk! ;>BKUCD><=! KG! ;>_;S;B;I>! <D! KG! GB@;H;<G<! <D! FKGTUD@GE! C!

Page 17: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

17

MGBAIZGJ=E!mLLn8!%B@UGKMD>@Dk!U>=!<D!K=E!FA;>B;FGKDE!;>@DADEDE!D>!DK!NADG!DE!<D@DAM;>GA!E;!KG! EUFKDMD>@GB;I>! D:IJD>G! B=>! >;@A=GKTUD>=E! FUD<D! EDA! SD>DZ;B;=EG! D>! DK! <DEGAA=KK=! <D!D>ZDAMD<G<DE!;>ZKGMG@=A;GE8!,UDJ=!<D!KG!D:@D>E;HG!<DM=E@AGB;I>!<DE<D!DK!Gj=!9```!<D!KGE!FA=F;D<G<DE! S;=KIJ;BGE! <D! >;@A=K?F;<=E! D>! M=<DK=E! BDKUKGADEk! D:;E@D>! HGA;=E! @AGSG\=E!ADB;D>@DE!<=><D!ED!DHGKiG!DK!DZDB@=!<D!>;@A=GKTUD>=E!B=M=!M=<UKG<=ADE!ZGAMGB=KIJ;B=E!D>!DK! @AG@GM;D>@=! <D! D>ZDAMD<G<DE! ;>ZKGMG@=A;GE! D>! M=<DK=E! G>;MGKDE! mP^k! PQk! R9n8! ,G!G<M;>;E@AGB;I>! <D! &)9)%! EUSBU@N>DG! G! AG@=>DE! @AG@G<=E! B=>! G>J;=@D>E;>G! ''! e%>Ja''f!<;EM;>UCI! E;J>;Z;BG@;HGMD>@D! KG! FADE;I>! EG>JU?>DG! C! KG! ADEFUDE@G! B=>@ANB@;K! G! %>Ja''! D>!GA@DA;GE! MDED>@VA;BGEk! F=A! K=! BUGK! GB@UGKMD>@D! ED! DHGKiG! DK! F=@D>B;GK! ZGAMGB=KIJ;B=! <D!&)9)%! B=M=!M=<UKG<=A! <D! KG! _;FDA@D>E;I>! ;><UB;<G! F=A!%>Ja''! mR9n8! #>! AG@=>DE! $^QX1,O!E=MD@;<=E! G! U>! DF;E=<;=! <D! ;ETUDM;GXADFDAZUE;I>k! KG! G<M;>;E@AGB;I>! D:IJD>G! <D! &)9)%!<UAG>@D!DK!DF;E=<;=!<D!;ETUDM;G!@UH=!DZDB@=E!FA=@DB@=ADEk!AD<UB;D><=!DK!@GMGj=!<DK!;>ZGA@=!C!FADEDAHG><=!KG!ZU>B;I>!HD>@A;BUKGA!;bTU;DA<G!mP^n8!#K!M;EM=!JAUF=!<D!;>HDE@;JGB;I>!DHGKUI!KG! G<M;>;E@AGB;I>! EUSBU@N>DG! <D!&)9)%! G! AG@=>DE! g>=Bga=U@! FGAG! GF=K;F=FA=@D?>G! #! TUD!<DEGAA=KKG>! G@DA=EBKDA=E;E! <D! Z=AMG! FADB=bk! C! =SEDAHGA=>! U>G! Z=AMGB;I>! AD<UB;<G! <D! KG!KDE;I>! G@DA=EBKDAI@;BG! BUG><=! ED! G<M;>;E@AI! DK! >;@A=K?F;<=k! ADHDKG><=! U>! F=@D>B;GK!G>@;G@DA=JV>;B=!FGAG!K=E!>;@A=GKTUD>=E!mcQk!RPn8!!! +>! GEFDB@=! MUC! ;MF=A@G>@D! D>! KG! <D@DAM;>GB;I>! <DK! F=@D>B;GK! @DAGFVU@;B=! <D! K=E!>;@A=K?F;<=E! DE! TUDk! E;! S;D>! ED! ! _G>! B=>Z;AMG<=! MUB_=E! A=KDE! FA=@DB@=ADEk! Gi>! >=! _GC!DE@U<;=E!TUD!DHGKiD>!KG!@=:;B;<G<!DEFDAG<G!F=A!KG!G<M;>;E@AGB;I>!<D!DE@=E!FA=<UB@=E!D>!DK!B=>@D:@=!<D!U>!@AG@GM;D>@=!BK?>;B=8!.GMS;V>!DE!>DBDEGA;=!U>!DE@U<;=!ZGAMGB=KIJ;B=!<D!K=E!>;HDKDE! DZDB@;H=E! GKBG>bG<=Ek! KG! S;=<;E@A;SUB;I>! <D! K=E! >;@A=GKTUD>=E! G<M;>;E@AG<=Ek! C! KGE!<;ZDAD>B;GE!TUD!D:;E@D>!D>@AD!KGE!H?GE!<D!G<M;>;E@AGB;I>!eD\8!=AGK!HDAEUE!EUSBU@N>DGf8!!

T>V%% 5+(#*,O3,-&$-,%Z[?%#$-*,#,%%!

T>V>S% N"*,A(3$#1(%&"3%::%!! #K! %%! =! NB;<=! D;B=BEG@D@AGD>=;B=! DE! U>! %W0'! B=>! BUG@A=! <=SKDE! D>KGBDE! =:;<GSKDE!e9`lL!∆^kck77k7Lf! FADBUAE=A! <D! U>G! JAG>! ZGM;K;G! <D! K?F;<=E! S;=GB@;H=E8! (U! MD@GS=K;EM=! DE@N!Z;>GMD>@D! ADJUKG<=! G! >;HDK! BDKUKGAk! <=><D! ED! DE@GSKDBD! U>! SGKG>BD! D>@AD! EU! E?>@DE;Ek!@AG>EZDAD>B;G! D>@AD! Z=EZ=K?F;<=E! <D! MDMSAG>G! C! <DE<D! KGE! FA=@D?>GE! @AG>EF=A@G<=AGEk! C!K;SDAGB;I>! GK! B;@=E=K! mRLn8! (D! E;>@D@;bG! G! FGA@;A! <DK! NB;<=! JAGE=! DED>B;GK! K;>=KDG@=! e�Of! D>!ZU>B;I>! <DK! GF=A@D! <D! =A;JD>! <;D@V@;B=k! C! EU! B=>BD>@AGB;I>! BDKUKGA! ;>ZKUCD! D>! KG! ZU>B;I>!BDKUKGA!>=AMGK!C!DK!<DEGAA=KK=!<D!D>ZDAMD<G<DE!mRLaRQn8!'>BKUE;HD!ED!_G!FKG>@DG<=!TUD!U>G!<;D@G! F=SAD! D>! %%! <;EM;>UCD! KG! FA=<UBB;I>! <D! D;B=EG>=;<DE! FA=a;>ZKGMG@=A;=E!B=>@A;SUCD><=!G!KG!ADE=KUB;I>!<D!D>ZDAMD<G<DE!BAI>;BGE!mRLn8!!! #K!%%!ED!K;SDAG!_GB;G!DK!B;@=E=K!BDKUKGA!F=A!GBB;I>!<D!KG!0,%9k!D>!DK!FGE=!K;M;@G>@D!FGAG!EU! ;>JADE=! D>! <;ZDAD>@DE! H?GE! <D! MD@GS=K;bGB;I>! TUD! B=>BKUCD>! D>! KG! E?>@DE;E! <D! K?F;<=E!S;=GB@;H=E!e[;JUAG!Of!mQPn8!,G!MD@GS=K;bGB;I>!<DK!%%!F=A!KG!H?G!K;F=:;JD>GEG!e,)df!ED!Z=AMG>!KDUB=@A;D>=E! e,.Efk! K;F=:;>GEk! C! NB;<=E! _;<A=:;D;B=EG@D@AGD>=;B=E! eY#.#Ef! mRLn8! ,G! H?G! 0WY(!

Page 18: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

18

BG@GK;bG! DK! FGE=! K;M;@G>@D! D>! KG! E?>@DE;E! <D! K=E! FA=E@G>=;<DE! eFA=E@GB;BK;>Gk! 0W'9k!FA=E@GJKG><;>G!#9k!0W#9k!@A=MS=:G>=!%9k!.:%9k!D@Bf!mRck!RRn8!#>!KG!H?G!<D!KGE!D>b;MGE!0L^`!ED!=:;<G! DK! %%! G! FA=<UB@=E! <DK! NB;<=! D;B=EG@A;D>=;B=! e##.Ef! m7``n8! %<DMNE! <D! KGE! H?GE!D>b;MN@;BGEk!DK!%%!DE!SKG>B=!<D!=:;<GB;=>DE!>=!D>b;MN@;BGE!F=A!AG<;BGKDE!K;SADE!FGAG!Z=AMGA!;E=FA=E@G>=E!!D!;E=KDUB=@A;D>=E!m7`7k!7`9n8!!!! ,G!FA=<UBB;I>!<D!K?F;<=E!S;=GB@;H=E!<DA;HG<=E!<DK!%%!D>!K=E!E;@;=E!<D!;>ZKGMGB;I>!DE@N!ADJUKG<G! F=A! DE@?MUK=E! FADED>@DE! D>! KG! ADEFUDE@G! ;>MU>=KIJ;BG! >=AMGK! e',a7k! .&[aGKZGk!

2$O/+,%e>%N"*,A(3$#1(%&"3%_)$&(%,+,L/$&G-$)(>%#>!ADEFUDE@G!G!KG!DE@;MUKGB;I>!<D!ADBDF@=ADE!<D!MDMSAG>Gk!

KG!_;<AIK;E;E!<D!Z=EZ=K?F;<=E!K;SDAG!%%!<DE<D!KGE!MDMSAG>GE!_GB;G!DK!B;@=E=K8!#K!%%!K;SDAG<=!DE!FADBUAE=A!<D!U>G!

HGA;D<G<!<D!K?F;<=E!S;=GB@;H=Ek! ;>BKUCD><=!KGE!FA=E@GJKG><;>GEk!@A=MS=:G>=Ek! KDUB=@A;D>=E!C!FA=<UB@=E!<D!KG!

K;F=:;JD>GEGk% ;>H=KUBAG<=E!D>!U>G!JAG>!BG>@;<G<!<D!FA=BDE=E! Z;E;=KIJ;B=E!ADKDHG>@DE!<UAG>@D! KG! ;>ZKGMGB;I>k!

DE@AVE!=:;<G@;H=!C!EDjGK;bGB;I>!BDKUKGA8!%

Page 19: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

19

K;F=F=K;EGBNA;<=Ek!D@B8f!C!F=A!ADEFUDE@GE!<DK!MD@GS=K;EM=!SGEGK8!#K!<DE@;>=!MD@GSIK;B=!TUD!E;JUD! DK! %%! K;SDAG<=! GK! B;@=E=K! DE! BGAGB@DA?E@;B=! <D! BG<G! @D\;<=k! C! G! MD>U<=! D>! @D\;<=E!<;ZDAD>@DE!U>!M;EM=!FADBUAE=A!<G!=A;JD>!G!FA=<UB@=E!B=>! ZU>B;I>!G>@GJI>;BG! mRRn! e[;JUAG!Of8! +>=! <D! K=E! D\DMFK=E!MNE! BKGA=E! DE! DK! xM=<DK=! <DK! C;>JaCG>Jy! FGAG! DK! SGKG>BD! <D! K=E!D;B=EG>=;<DE! .:%9X0W'9! D>! DK! MG>@D>;M;D>@=! <DK! @=>=! HGEBUKGA! m7`Pn8! ,G! GB@;H;<G<! 0WY(!Z=AMG! DK! FA=<UB@=! FA=E@GJKG><;>G! Y9! e0WY9fk! D>! DK! FGE=! K;M;@G>@D! D>! KG! E?>@DE;E! <D!FA=E@G>=;<DE8!,GE!D>b;MGE!TUD!BG@GK;bG>!KG!E?>@DE;E!<D!K=E!FA=E@G>=;<DE!G!FGA@;A!<D!0WY9!ED!D:FADEG>!<;ZDAD>B;GKMD>@D!D>!K=E!@D\;<=El!D>!FKGTUD@GE!KG!.:%9!E;>@GEG!BG@GK;bG!KG!E?>@DE;E!<D!.:%9k!C!D>!KG!HGEBUKG@UAG!ED!D:FADEG!0W'9!E;>@GEGk!TUD!BG@GK;bG!KG!Z=AMGB;I>!<D!0W'9!e[;JUAG!Of8!#K! <DESGKG>BD! D>! KG! ADKGB;I>! .d%9X0W'9! >=AMGK! ED! D>BUD>@AG! D>! KG! SGED! <D! HGA;GE!D>ZDAMD<G<DE!BGA<;=HGEBUKGADE!m7`Ln8!.:%9!C!0W'9!@;D>D>!DZDB@=E!=FUDE@=E!eHGE=B=>E@A;BB;I>!C!HGE=<;KG@GB;I>k!ADEFDB@;HGMD>@Dfk!C!D>!SGED!G!DE@=!DE!<;Z?B;K!D>@D><DA!TUD!KG!;>_;S;B;I>!<D!0WY(! @D>JG! U>! DZDB@=! >D@=! <D! FA=@DBB;I>! HGEBUKGA8! ,G! DH;<D>B;G! EUJ;DAD! TUD! GK! ;>_;S;AED!0WY(! K=E! DZDB@=E! G>@;@A=MSI@;B=E! D>! FKGTUD@GE! FAD<=M;>G>! E=SAD! K=E! DZDB@=E!FA=@A=MSI@;B=E!D>!KG!HGEBUKG@UAG!m7`^nk!CG!TUD!DK!FA;>B;FGK!MD<;G<=A!<DK!@=>=!HGEBUKGA!DE!DK!h&)k! C! KG! ADJUKGB;I>! F=A! 0W'9! E=K=! JG>G! ADKDHG>B;G! BUG><=! K=E! >;HDKDE! <D!

h&)! DE@N>!<;EM;>U;<=E! m7`On8! )@A=! D\DMFK=! <D! <;E@A;SUB;I>! BGAGB@DA?E@;BG! <D! K?F;<=E! S;=GB@;H=E! D>!<;ZDAD>@DE! @D\;<=E! E=>! K=E! KDUB=B;@=E! C!M=>=B;@=Ek! TUD! FA=<UBD>! FA=E@G>=;<DE! eF=A! KG! H?G!0WY(f! C! KDUB=@A;D>=E! eF=A! KG! H?G! ,)df! G! FGA@;A! <D! %%k! C! K=E! JAG>UK=B;@=Ek! TUD! FA=<UBD>!ZU><GMD>@GKMD>@D!KDUB=@A;D>=E!G!FGA@;A!<D!%%!mRLk!7`Qk!7`cn8!! !

T>V>T% 6#*+/)*/+,%E%J/-)$G-%&"%5Z?Y>%N"),-$#1(%&"%,))$G-%!

,G! 0WY(! ED! D>BUD>@AG! D>! DK! ;>;B;=!<D!KG!BGEBG<G!MD@GSIK;BG!TUD!B=>H;DA@D!GK! %%! D>! FA=E@GJKG><;>GE! e0WEf! mRcnk!MD<;G<=ADE! D>! KG! EDjGK;bGB;I>! BDKUKGA!B=>!GBB;I>! @;F=!_=AM=>GK!TUD! ADJUKG>!U>G! D>=AMD! HGA;D<G<! <D! FA=BDE=E!Z;E;=KIJ;B=E! ;>BKUCD><=! KG!HGE=<;KG@GB;I>XHGE=B=>E@A;BB;I>k! KG!D:BADB;I>! <D! E=<;=! C! ADGSE=AB;I>! <D!GJUG! G! >;HDK! AD>GKk! DK! SGKG>BD! <D! KG!GJADJGB;I>! FKGTUD@GA;Gk! KG! ADEFUDE@G!;>MU>=KIJ;BGk! KG! ADFA=<UBB;I>k! C! DK!B;BK=! EUDj=aH;J;K;G8! #>! HDA@DSAG<=E!D:;E@D>! 9! ;E=Z=AMGE! <D! 0WY(! e7! C! 9f!B=>!U>G!DKDHG<G!_=M=K=J?G!eO`zf!C!U>!FKDJGM;D>@=! ;<V>@;B=k! GU>TUD! DE@N>!B=<;Z;BG<GE! F=A! <=E! JD>DE! B=>!ADJUKGB;I>! ;><DFD><;D>@Dl! KG! ;E=Z=AMG!0WY(a7! ED! D:FADEG! B=>E@;@U@;HGMD>@D!D>! FANB@;BGMD>@D! @=<=E! K=E! @D\;<=Ek!

6#*+/)*/+,% &"% 5Z?Y>! 0WY(! DE! U>! _=M=a<?MDA=! TUD! ED!

;>EDA@G! FDAMG>D>@DMD>@D! D>! KG! MDMSAG>G! BDKUKGA! <D!

MG>DAG! M=>=@?F;BGk! =A;D>@G><=ED! _GB;G! DK! KiMD>! <D!

AD@?BUK=!D><=FKNEM;B=!=!KG!BGAG!;>@DA>G!<D!KGE!D>H=K@UAGE!

>UBKDGADE8!$G<G!M=>IMDA=!U>D!<D!MG>DAG!>=!B=HGKD>@D!

U>! JAUF=! _DM=k! C! DE@N! B=>E@;@U?<=! F=A! U>! <=M;>;=! <D!

U>;I>!G!MDMSAG>Gk!U>!<=M;>;=!#W[! eDF;<DAMGK!JA=�@_!

ZGB@=Afk!C!U>!<=M;>;=!BG@GK?@;B=!eDK!MNE!H=KUM;>=E=f8!

Page 20: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

20

B=>E;E@D>@D! B=>! U>! A=K! D>! DK! MG>@D>;M;D>@=!_=MD=E@N@;B=! BDKUKGAk! C!0WY(a9! ED!D:FADEG!SGEGKMD>@D!D>!GKJU>=E!@D\;<=Ek!FDA=!DE!ZU><GMD>@GKMD>@D!;><UB;SKD!D>! ADEFUDE@G! G! KG! DE@;MUKGB;I>! BDKUKGA! F=A! GJ=>;E@GE!mRcn8! 0WY(a9! DE@N!MUC! H;>BUKG<G! GK! BN>BDA! m7`Ra777n! C!@GMS;V>! G! KG! E?>@DE;E! <D! FA=E@G>=;<DE! D>! K=E! E;@;=E! <D!;>ZKGMGB;I>! D>! ADEFUDE@G! G! ',a7k! .&[aGKZGk! =!K;F=F=K;EGBNA;<=E8!.GMS;V>!BUMFKD!ZU>B;=>DE!Z;E;=KIJ;BGE!D>! DK! BDADSA=k! K=E! A;j=>DE! C! DK! E;E@DMG! BGA<;=HGEBUKGAk!E;@;=E! <=><D! ED! D:FADEG! B=>E@;@U@;HGMD>@D! mRcn8! #>!BGA<;=M;=B;@=Ek! F=A! D\DMFK=k! FA=<UBD! 0W'9! B=>! U>! A=K!FA=@DB@=A!ZAD>@D!G!KG!;>\UA;G!=:;<G@;HG!m779n8!!!

0WY(! DE! U>! _=M=<?MDA=! K=BGK;bG<=! _GB;G! DK! KG<=!KUM;>GK! <D! KG! MDMSAG>G! <DK! AD@?BUK=! D><=FKNEM;B=! C!D>H=K@UAGE! >UBKDGADEk! ADFADED>@G><=! U>=! <D! K=E! F=B=E!D\DMFK=E! <D! FA=@D?>GE! ;>EDA@G<GE! D>! KG! MDMSAG>G! <D!Z=AMG!M=>=@?F;BG8!$G<G!EUSU>;<G<!eQ`!g/Gf!B=>@;D>D!U>!JAUF=! _DM=! Z=AMG<=! F=A! [DPpaFA=@=F=AZ;A;>G! 'd! e[DPpa00'dfk! BA?@;B=! FGAG! KG! GB@;H;<G<! mRck! 77Pn8! ,G! D>b;MG!BG@GK;bG! KG! =:;<GB;I>! AG<;BGKGA! C! KG! F=E@DA;=A! S;Ea=:;JD>GB;I>! <D! %%k! D>! U>! MDBG>;EM=! TUD! _G! E;<=!<DEBA;F@=!B=M=!U>G!xGU@=:;<GB;I>!AG<;BGKGA!B=>@A=KG<Gy!<DS;<=! G! TUD! ED! Z=AMG>! AG<;BGKDE! GAGTU;<=>;K=! e%%hf!B=M=!;>@DAMD<;GA;=E!<D!KG!ADGBB;I>k!EUZA;D><=!KG!G<;B;I>!<D!M=KVBUKGE!<D!)9!<D!MG>DAG!DE@DA=a!C!ADJ;=aDEFDB?Z;BG!mRck!RRk!77Lk!77^n8!(D!@AG@G!<D!U>G!D>b;MG!S;ZU>B;=>GKl!KG!S;Ea=:;JD>GB;I>!<DK!%%!FGAG!Z=AMGA!0WW9!DE@N!MD<;G<G!F=A! KG! GB@;H;<G<! B;BK=:;JD>GEG! e$)dfk! C! KG! F=E@DA;=A!AD<UBB;I>!<D!0WW9!G!0WY9!DE@N!MD<;G<G!F=A!KG!GB@;H;<G<!FDA=:;<GEG! e0)df! e[;JUAG!Qf8!,GE!GB@;H;<G<DE!0)d!C!$)d!ED! KKDHG>! G! BGS=! D>! <=E! E;@;=E! GB@;H=E! <;ZDAD>@DEk!B=MU>;BG<=E! ZU>B;=>GKMD>@D! D>@AD! E?8! #K! E;@;=! GB@;H=!0)dk!TUD!B=>@;D>D!GK!JAUF=!_DM=k!ED!D>BUD>@AG!BDABG>=!G! KG! EUFDAZ;B;D!<D! KG!FA=@D?>G!C! ADKG@;HGMD>@D!D:FUDE@=!

GK! E=KHD>@D! e[;JUAG!cf8!#K! E;@;=!GB@;H=!$)d!ED! K=BGK;bG!GK! Z=><=!<D!U>!BG>GK!_;<A=ZIS;B=!TUD!G@AGH;DEG!DK!;>@DA;=A!<D!KG!FA=@D?>G!<DE<D!DK!<=M;>;=!<D!U>;I>!G!MDMSAG>G!_GE@G!DK!<=M;>;=!BG@GK?@;B=k!C!DE!<=><D!ED!KKDHG!G!BGS=!KG!<;=:;JD>GB;I>!<DK!%%!m77On!e[;JUAG!cf8!!

!%<DMNE!<D!AD<UB;A!G!0WW9k! KG!GB@;H;<G<!0)d!DE!>DBDEGA;G!FGAG!;>;B;GA!DK!B;BK=!BG@GK?@;B=!

<D!KG!D>b;MG!m77Qk!77cn8!,G!Z;JUAG!R!MUDE@AG!DK!MDBG>;EM=!<D!GBB;I>!<D@GKKG<=!<D!0WY(!C!KG!;>@DAADKGB;I>!D>@AD!KGE!GB@;H;<G<DE!0)d!C!$)d!mRRk!77Lk!77^n8!#K!JAUF=!_DM=!D>!DK!E;@;=!GB@;H=!0)d! DE! =:;<G<=! F=A! <=E! DKDB@A=>DE! FGAG! AD<UB;A! DK! EUE@AG@=! _;<A=FDAI:;<=! G! EU! GKB=_=K!

2$O/+,% f>% @",))$(-"#% 7<g% E% 5<g%

),*,3$I,&,#% K(+% 5Z?Y>% ,G! GB@;H;<G<!

$)d! BG@GK;bG! KG! GU@=a=:;<GB;I>!

B=>@A=KG<G!<D!%%k!Z=AMG><=!U>!AG<;BGK!

GAGTU;<=>;K=k! C! EU! F=E@DA;=A!

<;=:;JD>GB;I>! GK! _;<A=FDA=:;a

D><=FDAI:;<=! 0WW98! ,G! GB@;H;<G<! 0)d!

BG@GK;bG! KG! AD<UBB;I>! <D! 0WW9! GK!

FA=<UB@=! Z;>GKk! DK! _;<A=:;a

D><=FDAI:;<=!0WY98!

e[;JUAG! D:@AG?<G! <D! (M;@_! ()# *+,k!

0A=E@GJKG><;>E! �! =@_DA! K;F;<! MD<;G@=AEk!

9``9k!2=K8!Ocf%

Page 21: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

21

B=AADEF=><;D>@Dk!Z=AMG><=!U>!BG@;I>!AG<;BGK!=:;ZDAA;K=!<DA;HG<=!<DK!_DM=!eB=MFUDE@=!'f8!%!B=>@;>UGB;I>k!DK!B=MFUDE@=! '!DE!AD<UB;<=!F=A!U>!DKDB@AI>!FA=HD>;D>@D!<DK!ADE;<U=!@;A=E;>G!e.CAf! BA?@;B=! .CAPc^k! FA=<UB;D><=! U>! AG<;BGK! @;A=E;K=! D>! KG! F=E;B;I>! Pc^! C! U>! B=MFUDE@=!=:;ZDAA;K=! <DA;HG<=! <DK! _DM=! e;>@DAMD<;GA;=! ''f8! [;>GKMD>@Dk! DK! AG<;BGK! @;A=E;K=! GSE@AGD! U>!_;<AIJD>=! <DK! %%! U>;<=! FA=<UB@;HGMD>@D! GK! E;@;=! GB@;H=! $)d! <G><=! B=M;D>b=! GK! B;BK=! <D!=:;JD>GB;I>!D!;E=MDA;bGB;I>!TUD!ED!MUDE@AG!D>!KG!Z;JUAG!Q8!,G!GB@;H;<G<!0)d!DE!;>DEFDB?Z;BG!C!FUD<D!AD<UB;A!U>G!HGA;D<G<!<D!_;<A=FDAI:;<=E8!+>G!HDb!Z=AMG<=!DK!FA;MDA!AG<;BGK!@;A=E;K=!GK!

! A

!B

2$O/+,%h>%6#*+/)*/+,%&"%3(#%#$*$(#%,)*$F(#%7<g%E%5<g>%a:b!,G!D>@AG<G!GK!E;@;=!GB@;H=!$)d!B=M;D>bG!D>!KG!SGED!<DK!<=M;>;=!<D!U>;I>!G!MDMSAG>G!C!B=>@;>iG!B=>!U>!BG>GK!_;<A=ZIS;B=!TUD!G@AGH;DEG!DK!B=AD!<D!KG!FA=@D?>G!_GE@G! DK! <=M;>;=! BG@GK?@;B=8! #>! KG! ;>@DAZGED! D>@AD! K=E! <=M;>;=E! BG@GK?@;B=! C! <D! U>;I>! G!MDMSAG>G! D:;E@D! U>!G>;KK=!=!B=>E@A;BB;I>!TUD!EDFGAG!DK!xK=SSCy!<DK!E;@;=!GB@;H=8!,G!DE@AUB@UAG!<D!GMSGE!;E=Z=AMGE!<D!0WY(!DE!MUC!E;M;KGAk!FDA=!D>!0WY(a9!DK!BGMS;=!<D!K=E!ADE;<U=E!'KD^9P!D!Y;E^7P!eD>!0WY(a7f!G!2GK^9P!C!%AJ^7P!Z=AMG!U>!S=KE;KK=!KG@DAGK!_;<A=ZIS;B=!TUD!GUMD>@G!DK!H=KUMD>!<DK!E;@;=!GB@;H=!$)d!D>!0WY(a98!a9b!)FUDE@=!GK!E;@;=!$)d!D>! DK! <=M;>;=! BG@GK?@;B=! ED! D>BUD>@AG! DK! E;@;=! GB@;H=! 0)dk! TUD! CGBD! D>! KG! SGED! <D! U>G! _D><;<UAG! B=>! U>G!B=>E;<DAGSKD!F=AB;I>!<DK!_DM=!D:FUDE@G!GK!E=KHD>@D8!#K!K;JG><=!FA=:;MGK!GK!_DM=!DE!Y;EPcck!TUD!ED!D>BUD>@AG!U>;<=!F=A!D>KGBD!<D!_;<AIJD>=!G!Y;EPcO8!^�!F=A!D>B;MG!<DK!_DM=!ED!D>BUD>@AG!Y;E9`Q8!,=E!@ADE!ADE;<U=E!<D!Y;E! E=>!>DBDEGA;=E!FGAG!DE@GS;K;bGA! KG!U>;I>!<DK!_DM=!C!E=>!BA?@;B=E!FGAG! KG!GB@;H;<G<8!%K! ;JUGK!TUD! D>!=@AGE!FDA=:;<GEGEk!>=!_GC!U>!K;JG><=!FA=@D;B=!<;E@GK!GK!_DM=8!,GE!_;E@;<;>GE!BA?@;BGE!ED!EDjGKG>!D>!A=EG<=k!DK!_DM=!ED!EDjGKG!D>!A=\=k!KGE!_VK;BDE!<D!D>@AG<G!GK!E;@;=!$)d!ED!EDjGKG>!D>!H;=KD@Gk!DK!%%!U>;<=!GK!E;@;=!$)d!ED!EDjGKG!D>!GbUbKk!DK!ADE;<U=!BA?@;B=!.CAPc^!ED!EDjGKG!D>!GMGA;KK=!e567#0689f8!!

Page 22: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

22

;>;B;=! <DK! B;BK=! BG@GK?@;B=k! =@A=E! _;<A=FDAI:;<=E! FADED>@DE! D>! DK!MD<;=k! FGA@;BUKGAMD>@D! DK!;>@DAMD<;GA;=! <D! ADGBB;I>! 0WW9k! FDAM;@D>! TUD! DK! B;BK=! $)d! B=>@;>iD! GU@=BG@GK?@;BGMD>@D!;><DFD><;D>@DMD>@D! <D! KG! GB@;H;<G<! 0)d! mRRk! 77On8! #E@=! TU;DAD! <DB;A! TUD! DK! B=MFUDE@=!=:;ZDAA;K=! <DA;HG<=! <D! _DM=! e;>@DAMD<;GA;=! ''! X! B=MFUDE@=! ''f! FUD<D! EDA! AD<UB;<=! F=A! 7!DKDB@AI>!FA=HD>;D>@D!<D!U>!B=aEUE@AG@=!AD<UB@=A!FGAG!ADJD>DAGA!DK!_DM=!D>!<DEBG>E=!e[DPpa00'df! e[;JUAG! Rf! M;D>@AGE! DK! B;BK=! $)d! B=>@;>iG! Z=AMG><=! %%h! B=M=! ;>@DAMD<;GA;=! <D!ADGBB;I>!C!0WW9!B=M=!FA=<UB@=!Z;>GK!<D!ADGBB;I>!m77Lk!77^n8!!!! #K! E;@;=! GB@;H=! $)d! DE! GK@GMD>@D! DEFDB?Z;B=! FGAG! %%8! #K! FGE=! K;M;@G>@D! D>! KG! S;Ea=:;JD>GB;I>!<D!%%!F=A!0WY(!DE! KG!GSE@AGBB;I>!<D!U>!N@=M=!<D!_;<AIJD>=!S;EaGK?K;B=!D>! KG!F=E;B;I>! $7P! <DK! %%! FGAG! JD>DAGA! U>! AG<;BGK! FD>@G<;D>;KaGAGTU;<I>;B=! e[;JUAGE! Q! C! Rf8! ,G!DKDHG<G!ADJ;=DEFDB;Z;B;<G<!<D! KG!GSE@AGBB;I>!<D!_;<AIJD>=!FGADBD!<DSDAED!G! KG!=A;D>@GB;I>!<DK!%%!U>;<=!GK! E;@;=!GB@;H=!$)d8!#K!%%!G<=F@G!U>G! Z=AMG!<D!x,yk! B=>!DK!$7P!=BUFG><=!DK!

2$O/+,%i>%N"),-$#1(%&"%,))$G-%&"%5Z?Y=%,)*$F$&,&"#%5<g%E%7<g>%#K!MDBG>;EM=!SNE;B=!<D!KG!GB@;H;<G<!0)d!B=>E;E@D! D>! KG! AD<UBB;I>! <D! U>! _;<A=FDAI:;<=! F=A! DK! _DM=! D>! <DEBG>E=! FGAG! Z=AMGA! DK! GKB=_=K!B=AADEF=><;D>@D!C!B=MFUDE@=!'!eAG<;BGK!BG@;I>!=:;ZDAA;K=f8!/=E!AD<UBB;=>DE!B=>EDBU@;HGE!<DK!B=MFUDE@=!'!F=A!U>! DKDB@AI>! ADJD>DAG>! DK! _DM=! D>! <DEBG>E=8! #K! FA;MDA! FGE=! BG@GK;bG<=! F=A! KG! GB@;H;<G<! $)d! D>! BG<G! B;BK=!BG@GK?@;B=!ADTU;DAD!KG!=:;<GB;I>!;>;B;GK!<DK!JAUF=!_DM=!FGAG!Z=AMGA!DK!B=MFUDE@=!'k!AD<UB;<=!G!;>@DAMD<;GA;=!''!e=:;ZDAA;K=!<DK!_DM=f!F=A!DK!ADE;<U=!BA?@;B=!.CAPc^!TUD!ED!=:;<G!G!AG<;BGK!@;A=E;K=8!#K!AG<;BGK!@;A=E;K=!BG@GK;bG!KG!GSE@AGBB;I>!<D!_;<AIJD>=!<DE<D!DK!%%k!ADJD>DAG><=!@;A=E;>G!C!Z=AMG><=!DK!AG<;BGK!GAGTU;<=>;K=!TUD!B=M;D>bG!DK!B;BK=!<D!=:;JD>GB;=>DE!C!B;BKGB;=>DE!FGAG!Z=AMGA!0WW98!/UAG>@D!DK!ADE@=!<DK!B;BK=!BG@GK?@;B=k!KGE!GB@;H;<G<DE!CG!>=!DE@N>!GB=FKG<GE!C!FUD<D>!ZU>B;=>GA!<D!MG>DAG!;><DFD><;D>@D8!!e[;JUAG!D:@AG?<G!<D!(M;@_!()#*+,k!0A=E@GJKG><;>E!�!=@_DA!K;F;<!MD<;G@=AEk!9``9k!2=K8!Ocf!

Page 23: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

23

HVA@;BD!<D!KG!x,y!C!DE@GSKDB;D><=!KG!M?>;MG!<;E@G>B;G!F=E;SKD!B=>!DK!ADE;<U=!BA?@;B=!<D!.CAPc^8!#K!%%hk!TUD!;>;B;GKMD>@D!@;D>D!DK!DKDB@AI>!<DEGFGADG<=!BD>@AG<=!D>!DK!$7Pk!ED!;E=MDA;bG!G!U>!AG<;BGK!BD>@AG<=!D>!DK!$77!eC!D>!MUB_G!MD>=A!MD<;<G!BD>@AG<=!D>!$7P!=!$7^f8!,G!G<;B;I>!<D!KG!FA;MDA!M=KVBUKG!<D!)9!Z=AMG!DK!FA=<UB@=!;>@DAMD<;GA;=!77e:fa,))hk!TUD!ED!ADGAADJKG!Z=AMG><=!U>!D><=FDAI:;<=!D>@AD!DK!$77!C!DK!$Rk!TUD!B;BKG!<=E!HDBDE!B=>EDBU@;HGE!FGAG!<GA!U>! D><=FDAI:;<=! B?BK;B=! B=>! U>! AG<;BGK! BD>@AG<=! D>! DK! $7^! C! D>! DK! $7P8! +>G! EDJU><G!M=KVBUKG!<D!)9!DE!G<;B;=>G<G!GK!$7^k!Z=AMG><=!U>!D><=FDAI:;<=!<;=:;JD>G<=!B=>!U>!AG<;BGK!FDA=:;K=! D>! KG! F=E;B;I>! 7^o! DK!M;EM=! GSE@AGD! U>! N@=M=! <D! _;<AIJD>=! <DK! ADE;<U=! .CAPc^!ADJD>DAG><=! DK! AG<;BGK! @;A=E;K=! C! Z=AMG><=! KG! 0WW98! ,G! 0WW9! ED! @AG>EF=A@G! _GB;G! DK! E;@;=!GB@;H=! 0)d! F=A! U>! FA=BDE=! Gi>! <DEB=>=B;<=! <=><D! DE! AD<UB;<G! GK! FA=<UB@=! Z;>GKk! 0WY9!

e[;JUAG! Rf! mRck! 77On8! .GMS;V>! ED! _G! =SEDAHG<=! KG! Z=AMGB;I>! <D! FA=<UB@=E! M;>=A;@GA;=E!!<;ZDAD>@DE! GK! 0WW9! e77:aY#.#k! 7^;aY#.#! C! 7^:aY#.#k! FA=<UB@=E! >=AMGKDE! <D! KG! D>b;MG!K;F=:;JD>GEGfk!<DS;<=!G!TUD!KG!G<;B;I>!<D!GMSGE!M=KVBUKGE!<D!)9!ED!FUD<D!<GA!D>!=BGE;=>DE!D>!E;@;=E!<;ZDAD>@DE!GK!$77!C!$7^!m77Rn8!! !

%<DMNE!<D!BG@GK;bGA!KG!Z=AMGB;I>!<DK!FA;MDA!;>@DAMD<;GA;=!%%h!D>!DK!B;BK=!BG@GK?@;B=k!C!<D! AD<UB;A! K=E! ;>@DAMD<;GA;=E! <D! ADGBB;I>! 0WW9! GK! FA=<UB@=! Z;>GK! 0WY9k! KG! GB@;H;<G<! 0)d!FGADBD! EDA! KG! ADEF=>EGSKD! <D! KG! x;>GB@;HGB;I>! EU;B;<Gy! @G>! BGAGB@DA?E@;BG! <D! 0WY(! mRcn8! #K!EDJU;M;D>@=! B;>V@;B=! <D! KG! ADGBB;I>! D>@AD! 0WY(! C! U>! EUE@AG@=! FDA=:;<NE;B=! eD\8l! Y9)9f!MUDE@AG! U>! FDA?=<=! +*<! ;>;B;GKk! U>G! ZGED! ANF;<G! <D! ADGBB;I>k! C! U>G! BG?<G! JAG<UGK! <D! KG!FD><;D>@D!_GE@G!TUD!KG!GB@;H;<G<!ED!HUDKHD!>UKG8!,=!M;EM=!ED!=SEDAHG!GK!EDJU;A!KG!ADGBB;I>!F=A!=:;MD@A?G!D>!FADED>B;G!<D!%%8!#E@G!ANF;<G!GU@=a;>GB@;HGB;I>!eG!@;DMF=!7a9!M;>U@=E!<D!ADGBB;I>f! =BUAAD! ;><DFD><;D>@DMD>@D! <D! KG! B=>BD>@AGB;I>! =! >G@UAGKDbG! <DK! EUE@AG@=8!%FGAD>@DMD>@D! <DFD><D! <D! KG! Z=AMGB;I>! <DEB=>@A=KG<G! <D! AG<;BGKDE! GM;>=GB?<;B=E! TUD!FA=<UBD>!U>G!D>b;MG!;>GB@;HGk!C!FA=SGSKDMD>@D!ADFADED>@G!U>!MDBG>;EM=!ADJUKG@=A;=!FGAG!K;M;@GA!KG!BG>@;<G<!<D!0W!E;>@D@;bG<G!!"#$!$%!mRRn8!!

0GAG!GMSGE! ;E=Z=AMGE!<D!0WY(! KG!HDK=B;<G<!<D!ADBGMS;=!<D! KG!GB@;H;<G<!$)d!DE!<D!wP^``! M=KDE! <D! %%! F=A! M;>U@=! F=A! M=K! <D! <?MDA=! D>b;MN@;B=! m79`nk! C! KG! B=>E@G>@D! <D!";B_GDK;Ea"D>@D>! e=>f! FGAG! DK! %%! DE! <D! w^! �"! m797nk! ;JUGK! TUD! FGAG! DK!)9! m799n8! #K! E;@;=!GB@;H=!$)d!DE!E;J>;Z;BG@;HGMD>@D!MNE!JAG><D!D>!KG!;E=Z=AMG!0WY(a9!<DS;<=!G!KG!EUE@;@UB;I>!<D!U>!ADE;<U=!<D!HGK;>G!F=A!U>=!<D!;E=KDUB;>G!D>!KG!F=E;B;I>!9^Pk!K=!BUGK!GSAD!D>!0WY(a9!DK!GBBDE=!G!U>!S=KE;KK=!_;<A=ZIS;B=!;>GBBDE;SKD!D>!0WY(a78!#E@G!<;ZDAD>B;G!DE@AUB@UAGK!D:FK;BG!KG!<;ZDAD>B;G! D>! DEFDB;Z;B;<G<DE! <DK! E;@;=! $)dl! ! 0WY(a7! DE! GK@GMD>@D! DEFDB?Z;BG! FGAG! %%k!M;D>@AGE! TUD! 0WY(a9! @GMS;V>! GBDF@G! B=M=! EUE@AG@=! $)d! GK! 9aGAGTU;<=>;KaJK;BDA=K! e9a%Wf!FGAG! Z=AMGA! DK! FA=<UB@=! 9a0WW9aJK;BDA=K8! 9a%W! DE! U>! BG>GS;>=;<D! D><IJD>=! TUD! MD<;G!EDjGKDE! G>@;a;>ZKGMG@=A;GE! G! @AGHVE! <D! K=E! ADBDF@=ADE! BG>GS;>=;<DEk! C! EDjGKDE! FA=a;>ZKGMG@=A;GE!G!@AGHVE!<D!K=E!MD@GS=K;@=E!Z=AMG<=E!F=A!GBB;I>!<D!0WY(a9!m79Pa79^n8!!!

%%T>V>V% 8-*"+,))$G-%&"%5Z?Y%)(-%"#K")$"#%+",)*$F,#%&"%-$*+GO"-(%

!

Page 24: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

24

#K! h&)! C! KGE! #3&! M=<UKG>! KG! GB@;H;<G<! 0WY(! !"# $!$%# m79Ok! 79Qnk! FDA=! D:;E@D! U>G!<;EBADFG>B;G!D>!KG!K;@DAG@UAG!ADEFDB@=!GK!DZDB@=!<D!DE@G!M=<UKGB;I>k!<=><D!ED!_G!ADF=A@G<=!TUD! DK! h&)! ;>_;SD! m79ck! 79Rn! C! GB@;HG! G! 0WY(! ! m7`7k! 7P`a7PLn8! #K! h&)! F=<A?G! ;>_;S;A! G! KG!D>b;MG!Z=AMG><=!U>!B=MFKD\=!_;DAA=a>;@A=E;K=!m79ck!7P^k!7POn8!.GMS;V>!ED!_G!FA=FUDE@=!KG!ADGBB;I>!<DK!h&)!B=>!DK!AG<;BGK!@;A=E;K=!BA?@;B=!FGAG!KG!GB@;H;<G<!D>b;MN@;BG!m79Rn8!,G!ADGBB;I>!<D! h&)! B=>! K=E! AG<;BGKDE! ;>@DAMD<;GA;=E! <D! KG! ADGBB;I>! $)d! F=<A?G! Z=AMGA! >UDH=E!B=MFUDE@=E!>;@A=JD>G<=E!TUD! B=A@G>!DK! B;BK=! BG@GK?@;B=!<D! KG! D>b;MG! m7P^k!7POn8! #K! A=K! <DK!FDA=:;>;@A;@=! DE@N!MD\=A! <D@DAM;>G<=8! %! ZKU\=E! SG\=E! GB@;HG! G! 0WY(! CG! TUD! =:;<G! F=A! <=E!DKDB@A=>DE! GK! _DM=! <G><=! KUJGA! G! KG! Z=AMGB;I>! <D! B=MFUDE@=! '! C! &)9

a! m79ck! 7PQn8! %!B=>BD>@AGB;=>DE! MNE! DKDHG<GEk! DK! FDA=:;>;@A;@=! ;>GB@;HG! G! KG! D>b;MG! D>! FGAGKDK=! B=>! KG!Z=AMGB;I>!<D!Pa>;@A=!@;A=E;>G!m7Pcn8!!!

T>V>c%%2,+1,)(3(O0,%&"%5Z?Y%!

/UAG>@D! Gj=E! ED! U@;K;bGA=>! B=MFUDE@=E! =A;J;>GKMD>@D! <DA;HG<=E! <D! FKG>@GE! FGAG!GK;H;GA!K=E!E?>@=MGE!GE=B;G<=E!B=>!D>ZDAMD<G<DE!;>ZKGMG@=A;GE!C!FGAG!BGKMGA!DK!<=K=A!e@=<=E!B=>@D>?G>! EGK;B;KG@=Efk! FDA=! >=! ZUD! _GE@G! 7RQ7! TUD! ]838! 2G>D! GE=B;I! K=E! DZDB@=E! G>@;a;>ZKGMG@=A;=E!<D!%'&#(!B=>!KG!;>_;S;B;I>!<D!0WY(!m7PRn8!%K!@AGSG\=!=A;J;>GK!<D!2G>D!E;JU;I!U>!D:FK=E;H=!<DEGAA=KK=!C!BADB;M;D>@=!<DK!NADGk!GB=MFGjG<=!F=A!M;KDE!<D!@AGSG\=E!FUSK;BG<=E8!/DS;<=! GK! UE=! @G>! D:FG><;<=! <D! K=E! %'&#(k! KG! ADJUKGB;I>! <D! 0WY(! @;D>D! U>G! D>=AMD!ADKDHG>B;G! ZGAMGB=KIJ;BG8! #K! BG>GK! <D! ;>JADE=! GK! E;@;=! GB@;H=! $)d! <DE<D! KG! EUFDAZ;B;D! <D! KG!D>b;MG! eDK! xK=SSCyfk! @;D>D! U>! G>;KK=! =! B=>E@A;BB;I>! Z=AMG<G! F=A! @ADE! ADE;<U=E! e%AJ79`k!.CAP^^!C!WKU^9Lf!TUD!<DSD!D:FG><;AED!FGAG!FDAM;@;A!DK! ;>JADE=!<D!M=KVBUKGE!GK! Z=><=!<DK!BG>GKk!<=><D!ED!U>D!DK!%%8!,G!MGC=A?G!<D!K=E!%'&#(!;>@DAGBB;=>G>!<D!MG>DAG!>=!B=HGKD>@D!B=>! K=E! ADE;<U=E! TUD! B=>Z=AMG>! DK! G>;KK=k! SK=TUDG><=! KG! D>@AG<G! <DK! %%! <D! MG>DAG!B=MFD@;@;HG! mRck!7L`n8!+>G!D:BDFB;I>!G!DE@D!MDBG>;EM=!JD>DAGK!DE!DK!NB;<=!GBD@;KEGK;B?K;B=!e%%(fk!TUD!;>GB@;HG!G!0WY(!F=A!U>;I>!B=HGKD>@D!GK!ADE;<U=!(DA^P`k!TUD!GFGAD>@DMD>@D!\UDJG!U>!A=K!;MF=A@G>@D!D>!DK!B=>@A=K!<D!KG!DE@DA=DEFDB;Z;B;<G<!<D!KG!=:;JD>GB;I>!D>!DK!$7^!<D!%%!<UAG>@D!KG!Z=AMGB;I>!<D!0WW9!m7L7n8!!! !

#>!7RR7!ED!<DEBUSA;I!KG!D:;E@D>B;G!<D!U>G!;E=Z=AMG!;><UB;SKD!<D!0WY(k!<D>=M;>G<G!0WY(a9k!G!KG!TUD!ED!G<\U<;BG!U>!A=K!ZU><GMD>@GKMD>@D!FA=a;>ZKGMG@=A;=!m7L9n8!(UAJ;I!D>!KG!E;JU;D>@D! <VBG<G! U>! AD>=HG<=! ;>@DAVE! F=A! DK! <DEGAA=KK=! <D! ;>_;S;<=ADE! 0WY(k! SUEBG><=!JD>DAGA! <A=JGE! EDKDB@;HGE! FGAG! 0WY(a9! TUD! B=>EDAHD>! KGE! FA=F;D<G<DE! G>GKJVE;BGE! <D! K=E!%'&#(! eGE=B;G<G! G! KG! ;>_;S;B;I>! <D! 0WY(a9f! E;>! FADED>@GA! @=:;B;<G<! JNE@A;BG! eGE=B;G<G! G! KG!;>_;S;B;I>! <D! 0WY(a7k! TUD! BUMFKD! A=KDE! FA=@DB@=ADE! D>! KG!MUB=EGf8! 0GAG! DK! <DEGAA=KK=! <D!<A=JGE! EDKDB@;HGE! ED!GFA=HDB_G! KG!<;ZDAD>B;G!DE@AUB@UAGK!TUD!D:;E@D!D>@AD! K=E! E;@;=E!$)d!<D!GMSGE!;E=Z=AMGE!m7L`k!7L9k!7LPn8!,G!_;FI@DE;E!<D!;>_;S;B;I>!EDKDB@;HG!<D!0WY(a9!ZUD!HGK;<G<G!D>! M=<DK=E! G>;MGKDE! C! D>! FAUDSGE! BK?>;BGE! B=>! _UMG>=Ek! B=>Z;AMG><=! U>! @=:;B;<G<!JGE@A=;>@DE@;>GK! AD<UB;<G8! #>! DK! Gj=! 7RRRk! CG! ED! D>B=>@AGSG! <;EF=>;SKD! D>! DK! MDABG<=! KG!FA;MDAG!JD>DAGB;I>!<D!;>_;S;<=ADE!EDKDB@;H=E!<D!0WY(a9!eBDKDB=:;S!C!A=ZDB=:;Sf8!%!FDEGA!<D!TUD! M=E@AGA=>! U>G! FADHD>B;I>! M=<DAG<G! D>! DK! <DEGAA=KK=! <D! G<D>=BGAB;>=MGEk! KG!G<M;>;E@AGB;I>!BAI>;BG!<D!;>_;S;<=ADE!EDKDB@;H=E!<D!0WY(a9!ED!B=AADKGB;=>I!B=>!U>!GUMD>@=!

Page 25: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

25

D>! KG! ;>B;<D>B;G! <D! DHD>@=E! BGA<;=HGEBUKGADEk! F=A! K=! TUD! ZUDA=>! AD@;AG<=E! <DK! MDABG<=!>=A@DGMDA;BG>=!D>!DK!Gj=!9``^!m7LLn8!/DE<D!D>@=>BDE!G!KG!GB@UGK;<G<!KG!_;FI@DE;E!<D!0WY(a9k! <DEGAA=KKG<G! B=>! @G>@=! D>@UE;GEM=!D>! KG! <VBG<G!<D! 7RR`k! _G! E;<=!MUC! BUDE@;=>G<G8! #K!FGFDK! <D! 0WY(a9! D>! MiK@;FKDE! D>ZDAMD<G<DE! C! D>! KG! FG@=JV>DE;E! <D! KG! ;>ZKGMGB;I>! ED!D>BUD>@AG! BG<G! HDb!MD\=A! BGAGB@DA;bG<=k! FDA=! _=C! @GMS;V>! EGSDM=E!TUD! 0WY(a9! BUMFKD!A=KDE! Z;E;=KIJ;B=E! D>! HGA;=E! @D\;<=Ek! F=A! K=! BUGK! G! FDEGA! <D! EDJU;A! E;D><=! U>! SKG>B=!ZGAMGB=KIJ;B=!<D!;>@DAVEk!EU!M=<UKGB;I>!ZGAMGB=KIJ;BG!E;>!DZDB@=E!G<HDAE=E!ADFADED>@G!U>!<DEGZ?=8!! !! ,GE! FKGTUD@GE! ADFADED>@G>! U>=! <D! K=E! SKG>B=E! ZGAMGB=KIJ;B=E! <D! %'&#(! MNE!;MF=A@G>@DE! m7L^n8! ,GE! FKGTUD@GE! E=>! BVKUKGE! EG>JU?>DGE! B;ABUKG>@DE!TUD!>=AMGKMD>@D!>=!;>@DAGBB;=>G>!B=>! KG!FGAD<!HGEBUKGA8!$UG><=!GFGADBD!U>G! ;>\UA;G!D>!DK!D><=@DK;=k!<G! ;>;B;=!U>G! ANF;<G! C! B=MFKD\G! ;>@DAGBB;I>! D>@AD! KGE! FKGTUD@GE! C! KGE! DE@AUB@UAGE! EUSaD><=@DK;GKDE!D:FUDE@GE8!#E@G!;>@DAGBB;I>!DE@N!MD<;G<G!F=A!ADBDF@=ADE!BDKUKGADE!FADED>@DE!D>!KG!EUFDAZ;B;D!<D!FKGTUD@GE!C!BVKUKGE!D><=@DK;GKDE!C!F=A!FA=@D?>GE!G<_DE;HGE!B=M=!DK!Z;SA;>IJD>=!=!DK!ZGB@=A!<D!H=>!u;KKDSAG><!eHu[fk!ADEUK@G><=!D>!KG!G<_DE;I>!<D!KGE!FKGTUD@GE!G!KG!FGAD<!HGEBUKGA!C!KG!GJADJGB;I>!<D! KGE!FKGTUD@GE!D>@AD! E?8! #E@G! ZU>B;I>! Z;E;=KIJ;BG!B=>E@;@UCD! KG!FA;MDA! K?>DG!<D!<DZD>EG!B=>@AG!DK!EG>JAG<=k!FDA=!@GMS;V>!B=>@A;SUCD!G!KG!Z=AMGB;I>!FG@=KIJ;BG!<D!@A=MS=E!BUG><=!_GC!U>!GUMD>@=!<DK! ZGB@=A! @;EUKGA!C!<D!FA=@D?>GE! ADGB@;HGE!<D! ZGED!GJU<G!B=M=!DK!Z;SA;>IJD>=! m7LOk! 7LQn8! ,G! ;>_;S;B;I>! <D! 0WY(a7! D>! FKGTUD@GE! DE! KG! SGED!M=KDBUKGA! <D! KG!BGA<;=FA=@DBB;I>!TUD!SA;><G!KG!G<M;>;E@AGB;I>!BAI>;BG!<D!SG\GE!<=E;E!<D!%%(k!CG!TUD!DK!.:%9!B=>@A;SUCD!G!K=E!DF;E=<;=E!@A=MSI@;B=E!GJU<=E!GE?!B=M=!G!K=E!DHD>@=E!FA=aG@DA=JV>;B=E!<D!@;F=!BAI>;B=!m7Lck!7LRn8!#K!.:%9!DE!U>!GJ=>;E@G!<VS;K!TUD!GMFK;Z;BG!KGE!EDjGKDE!<D!GB@;HGB;I>!<D!=@A=E!GJ=>;E@GE!C!>=!DE!BA?@;B=!FGAG!KG!GB@;HGB;I>!FKGTUD@GA;Gk!CG!TUD!DE!>DBDEGA;=!;>_;S;A!DK! R^z! <D! KG! Z=AMGB;I>! <D! .:%9! FGAG! HDA! U>G! ;>ZKUD>B;G! !"# $!$%! m7^`n8! 'JUGKMD>@Dk! KG!G<M;>;E@AGB;I>! BAI>;BG! <D! %%(! <;EM;>UCD! KG! GB@;HGB;I>! FKGTUD@GA;G! <DS;<=! G! U>! DZDB@=!GBUMUKG@;H=l! KG! (DA^P`! DE@N! ;AADHDAE;SKDMD>@D! M=<;Z;BG<G! F=A! %%(! C! KGE! FKGTUD@GE! >=!FUD<D>!D:FADEGA!>UDHG!FA=@D?>G!CG!TUD!E=>!G>UBKDG<GE!m7^`n8!!

!! ,G! @A=MS;>G! D:FUDE@G! D>! U>G! KDE;I>! D><=@DK;GK! ;><UBD! KG! G<_DE;I>! C! GJADJGB;I>!FKGTUD@GA;G! D>! U>! FA=BDE=! >=! GZDB@G<=! F=A! DK! %%(! m7`^k! 7^7n8! #E@=! ED! B=>=BD! B=M=! DK!ZD>IMD>=! <D! xADE;E@D>B;G! GK! %%(y! C! ED! FADED>@G! D>! GKJU>=E! FGB;D>@DE! <D! MG>DAG!GFGAD>@DMD>@D! GKDG@=A;Gk! G@A;SU;SKD! G! <;HDAEGE! BGUEGE8! #>! GKJU>=E! BGE=E! ED! _G! K=JAG<=!ADHDA@;A!KG!ADE;E@D>B;G!G!%%(!GUMD>@G><=!KG!<=E;Ek!FDA=!KG!;>BDA@;<UMSAD!TUD!DE@D!ZD>IMD>=!FA=<UBD! D>! DK! @AG@GM;D>@=! <D! D>ZDAMD<G<DE! FA=a@A=MSI@;BGE! FA=MUDHD>! DK! BADB;D>@D!;>@DAVE!F=A!>UDHGE!<A=JGE!G>@;FKGTUD@GA;GE!MNE!DZ;B;D>@DEk!TUD!>=!FADED>@D>!ADE;E@D>B;G!D>!K=E!FGB;D>@DEk!C!TUD!G<DMNE!>=!;>@DAZ;DAG>!B=>!KG!_DM=E@GE;G!FA;MGA;G!eED!DH;<D>B;G!F=A!DK!GUMD>@=!D>!DK!@;DMF=!<D!EG>JA?Gf!m7LRn8!!!

%T>c%:-*")"&"-*"#%,%"#*"%*+,A,j(%&"%$-F"#*$O,)$G-%!

Page 26: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

26

! ,G!>;@AGB;I>!<D!%%!G!&)9%%!=@=AJG!G!DE@D!NB;<=!JAGE=!DZDB@=E!G>@;a;>ZKGMG@=A;=E!TUD!_G>! E;<=! <DM=E@AG<=E! F=A! >UDE@A=! JAUF=8! #>@AD! DKK=E! ED! D>BUD>@AG>! KG! ;>_;S;B;I>! <D! KG!D:FADE;I>!<D!&)(9!G!@AGHVE!<D!MDBG>;EM=E!<DFD><;D>@DE!<D!00%3a�!D! ;><DFD><;D>@DE!<D!h&)k!KG!;><UBB;I>!<D!KG!D:FADE;I>!<D!KG!D>b;MG!Y)a7k!KG!;>_;S;B;I>!D>!KG!GB@;HGB;I>!<DK!&[�1k!KG! BGFGB;<G<!<D! K;SDAGA! h&)!B=>!DZDB@=E! HGE=ADKG\G>@DEk! C! KG! ADJUKGB;I>!>DJG@;HG!<DK! FDAZ;K!;>ZKGMG@=A;=!D>!MGBAIZGJ=E! m9`k!9Qk!Pck!Q7k!cQk!7^9n8!.A=E@B_G>EgC!()#*+,! ADF=A@GA=>!D>!DK!Gj=!9``Q!m7^Pn!TUD!D:;E@D!U>G! ;>@DAGBB;I>!D>@AD! KGE!DEFDB;DE! ADGB@;HGE! h&)!C!FDA=:;>;@A;@=!B=>!0WY(k!C!FKG>@DGA=>!TUD!D>!B=><;B;=>DE!<D!DE@AVE!>;@A=a=:;<G@;H=!F=<A?G!EDA!F=E;SKD! KG!>;@AGB;I>! <D!%%! BG@GK;bG<G! F=A! KG! GB@;H;<G<!$)d!<D! KG! D>b;MG8! #>! DE@D! B=>@D:@=! B=M;D>bG!DE@D!@AGSG\=!<D!;>HDE@;JGB;I>!D>!DK!Gj=!9``c!B=>!DK!=S\D@;H=!<D!DHGKUGA!E;!_GC!U>!DZDB@=!<D!&)9%%! E=SAD! KG! GB@;H;<G<! 0WY(! C! E;! DE! F=E;SKD! KG! E?>@DE;E! BG@GK?@;BG! <DK! >;@A=GKTUD>=! F=A!GBB;I>!<D!KG!D>b;MG8!!!!

!!

!!!!!!

!

Page 27: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

27

V>% <9k6!8]<Y%%

V>S% <Aj"*$F(%O"-"+,3%%

#K! =S\D@;H=! <D! DE@G! @DE;E! ZUD! DE@U<;GA! DK! DZDB@=! <D! &)9%%! E=SAD! DK! MD@GS=K;EM=!>=AMGK! <DK! %%! !"# $!)-%#C! D>! BVKUKGEk! B=>! V>ZGE;E! D>! KG! H?G! D>b;MN@;BG! <D! 0WY(k! C! D:FK=AGA!F=@D>B;GKDE!H?GE!<D!ADJUKGB;I>!TUD!;>H=KUBAD>!KG!FA=<UBB;I>!!"#$!$%!<D!&)9%%8!!

V>T% <Aj"*$F(#%"#K")0J$)(#%%0&! "D\=AGA! K=E! FA=BD<;M;D>@=E! <D! E?>@DE;E! C! FUA;Z;BGB;I>! <D! &)9%%! C! <D! K=E! ;EIMDA=E!>;@AG<=E!<DK!%%k!ADGK;bG><=!BGMS;=E!D>!DK!FA=@=B=K=!TUD!FDAM;@G>!GUMD>@GA!DK!AD><;M;D>@=!<D!Z=AMGB;I>!<D!&)9%%!C!GFK;BG><=!MV@=<=E!<D!EDFGAGB;I>!FADFGAG@;H=E8!!

?&!$GAGB@DA;bGA!KG!;>@DAGBB;I>!<D!&)9%%!B=>!KGE!D>b;MGE!0WY(a7!C!0WY(a9k!<D@DAM;>G><=!E;!D:;E@D!U>!DZDB@=!E=SAD!KG!GB@;H;<G<!D>b;MN@;BG!BGFGb!<D!M=<UKGA!KG!Z=AMGB;I>!<DK!FA=<UB@=!<D!ADGBB;I>k!TUD!DE!EUE@AG@=!FGAG!KG!F=E@DA;=A!E?>@DE;E!<D!D;B=EG>=;<DE8##

@&! #E@U<;GA! K=E! DZDB@=E! <D! &)9%%! E=SAD! DK! MD@GS=K;EM=! <DK! %%! D>! U>! M=<DK=! BDKUKGAk!DHGKUG><=!K=E!DZDB@=E!<DK!>;@A=GKTUD>=!E=SAD!KG!GB@;H;<G<!0WY(k!KG!E?>@DE;E!<D!D;B=EG>=;<DEk!C!KG!;>@DAGBB;I>!B=>!=@A=E!SKG>B=E8!!

A&!#HGKUGA!E;!DE!F=E;SKD!Z=AMGA!FA=<UB@=E!>;@A=JD>G<=E!<DA;HG<=E!<D!%%!F=A!GBB;I>!BG@GK?@;BG!<D! 0WY(! D>! FADED>B;G! <D! DEFDB;DE! ADGB@;HGE! <D! >;@AIJD>=k! GFK;BG><=! U>G! HGA;D<G<! <D!MD@=<=K=J?GE!GK!DE@U<;=!<D!KG!;>@DAGBB;I>!<D!0WY(!B=>!FDA=:;>;@A;@=k!&)9

a!C!h&)!<UAG>@D!DK!ADBGMS;=!D>b;MN@;B=8!!!

Page 28: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

28

c>% N6!<'<;<Z\:%

c>S% Y0-*"#$#%&"%P<T::!!

!

<K*$1$I,)$G-%&"3%+"-&$1$"-*(%&"%#0-*"#$#%

! 0GAG! GUMD>@GA! DK! AD><;M;D>@=! <D! E?>@DE;E! <D! &)9%%! M=<;Z;BGM=E! U>G! @VB>;BG!

FADH;GMD>@D!<DEBA;F@G!FGAG!KG!>;@AGB;I>!<D!%W'E!F=A!&)9a!D>!MD<;=!NB;<=!mO`k!Q7k!7^Lk!7^^n8!

#K! %%! e7^`! MJk! &Ua$_DBg! 0ADFk! #KCE;G>k! "&f! ED! ;>BUSI! B=>! &G&)9! e(;JMG! $_DM;BGKEk!

ADKGB;I>!>l>!7l7f!D>!U>!H;GK!<D!H;<A;=!B=>!_D:G>=!eL!M,f!G!@DMFDAG@UAG!GMS;D>@D8!,G!E=KUB;I>!

ED! SGAS=@DI! B=>! GAJI>! F=A! 7^!M;>U@=E! FGAG! <;EM;>U;A! KG! @D>E;I>! <D!)9! C! ED! EDKKI! B=>! U>!

EDF@=!<D!J=MG8!(D!;>;B;I!KG!ADGBB;I>!F=A!G<;B;I>!<D!7`!�,!Y9()L!B=>BD>@AG<=!C!ED!;>BUSI!P`!

M;>U@=E!SG\=!GJ;@GB;I>!G>@DE!<D!GJADJGA!>UDHGMD>@D!&G&)9!C!Y9()L8!%! K=E!P`!M;>U@=E!ED!

<D@UH=!KG!ADGBB;I>!F=A!G<;B;I>!<D!GBD@G@=!<D!D@;K=!eHXH!7l7f!C!&G$K!EG@UAG<=!eMDbBKGl&G$K!HXH!

7l9f8!,G!ZGED!_;<A=Z?K;BG!ED!KGHI!GK!MD>=E!U>G!HDb!B=>!GBD@G@=!<D!D@;K=!C!DK!H=KUMD>!=S@D>;<=!

ED!EDBI!B=>!&G9()L!G>_;<A=!e`8^!JAf!C!ED!DHGF=AI!D>!GMS;D>@D!<D!&9!_GE@G!=S@D>DA!U>!GBD;@D!

GMGA;KKD>@=8! ,G!MDbBKG! =S@D>;<G! eGBD;@Df! ED! G>GK;bI! F=A! .,$! eBA=MG@=JAGZ?G! D>! BGFG! Z;>Gf!

G>GK?@;BG! e%>GK@DB_f! U@;K;bG><=! _D:G>=l<;D@;KV@DAlGBV@;B=! ec`l9`l`87f! B=M=! ZGED! MIH;K! C!

G>;EGK<D_?<=! B=M=! ADHDKG<=Ak! =! F=A! DEFDB@A=MD@A?G! <D! MGEG! e"(f8! .=<=E! K=E! E=KHD>@DE!

U@;K;bG<=E!E=>!BGK;<G<!Y0,$8!

!

5/+$J$),)$G-%,%O+,-%"#),3,%%

0GAG! KG! FUA;Z;BGB;I>! G! JAG>! DEBGKG! <D! &)9%%! G! FGA@;A! <D! KG! MDbBKG! <D! ADGBB;I>!

DMFGTUD@GM=E!U>G!B=KUM>G!<D!H;<A;=!<D!9O!:!^!BM!B=>!E?K;BG!C!KG!DTU;K;SAGM=E!D>!_D:G>=8!

,G! GK@G! BGFGB;<G<! <D! KG! B=KUM>G! FDAM;@;I! EDMSAGA! D>! U>G! i>;BG! HDb! DK! GBD;@D! =S@D>;<=! G!

FGA@;A!<D!<;Db!E?>@DE;E8!.AGE!KG!E;DMSAG!<DK!GBD;@Dk!KG!ZGED!DE@GB;=>GA;G!ZUD!KGHG<G!B=>!_D:G>=!

eP`!M,f!C!G!B=>@;>UGB;I>!FGEGM=E!F=A!J=@D=!KG!ZGED!MIH;Kk!_D:G>=l<;D@;KV@DA!ec`l9`k!7^`!M,o!

C!Q`lP`!FGAG!KGE!ZAGBB;=>DE!E;JU;D>@DEf8!%>GK;bGM=E!@=<GE!KGE!ZAGBB;=>DE!B=KDB@G<GE!e<D!Q!M,!

BG<G!U>Gf!F=A!.,$!G>GK?@;BG8!,GE!ZAGBB;=>DE!B=>!&)9%%!FUA=!ZUDA=>!DHGF=AG<GE!D>!GMS;D>@D!

<D!&9k!ADEUEFD><;<GE!D>!MD@G>=Kk!C!G>GK;bG<GE!C!BUG>@;Z;BG<GE!F=A!,$a"(X"(!mQ7n8!!

!

:-_3$#$#%E%)/,-*$J$),)$G-%

% ,=E!DE@U<;=E!<D!"(!ED!ADGK;bGA=>!B=>!U>!@A;FKD!BUG<AUF=K=!DTU;FG<=!B=>!@AGMFG!<D!

;=>DE! e5.3%0! 9```k! %FFK;D<! 1;=ECE@DMEX"/(! ($'#df! e[;JUAG! 7`%fk! B=>! U>G! ZUD>@D! <D!

;=>;bGB;I>!F=A!DKDB@A=EFAGC!G!FADE;I>!G@M=EZVA;BG!e#('a"(f8!0GAG!KG!;<D>@;Z;BGB;I>!<D!&)9%%!

C!DK!G>NK;E;E!<D!KG!MDbBKG!<D!ADGBB;I>!U@;K;bGM=E!K=E!E;JU;D>@DE!M=<=E!<D!DEBG>D=l!!&!57!EBG>l!

D>!DE@D!M=<=!ED!G>GK;bG>!KGE!ADKGB;=>DE!MGEGXBGAJG!eBCDf!<D!@=<=E!K=E!FA=<UB@=E!FADED>@DE!

D>! KG! E=KUB;I>!D>!DK! AG>J=!<D!BCD# EDKDBB;=>G<=o! !!&! D>_G>BD<!FA=<UB@! ;=>! EBG>! e#0'fl! DE@D!

M=<=! ED! U@;K;bG! FGAG! GUMD>@GA! KG! ED>E;S;K;<G<! C! JD>DAGA! U>! FG@AI>! BGAGB@DA?E@;B=! <D!

Page 29: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

29

ZAGJMD>@GB;I>o! ED! EDKDBB;=>G! DK! ;=>! G! G>GK;bGA! D>! 57! C! ED! ZAGJMD>@G! D>! 59! MD<;G>@D!

<;E=B;GB;I>!GB@;HG<G!F=A!B=K;E;I>!e$%/f8!,=E!;=>DE!_;\=E!ADEUK@G>@DE!ED!G@AGFG>!C!GBUMUKG>!D>!

KG! @AGMFG! <D! ;=>DE! e5Pf! C! KUDJ=! ED! K;SDAG>! FGAG! EU! <D@DBB;I>o! !!!&! MUK@;FKD! ADGB@;=>!

M=>;@=A;>J!e"3"f!EBG>l!DE@D!M=<=!FDAM;@D!DEBG>DGA!U>G!=!MNE!@AG>E;B;=>DE!<D!;=>DE!B=>!

GK@G! ED>E;S;K;<G<! FGAG! EU! BUG>@;Z;BGB;I>8! #>! DE@D! M=<=! ED! EDKDBB;=>G! U>=! =! MNE! ;=>DE!

FGAD>@GKDE!D>!57!C!ED!EDKDBB;=>G!D>!5P! KG!BCD!DEFDB?Z;BG!<DK! ZAGJMD>@=!_;\=!EDKDBB;=>G<=!

m7^On8! ,GE! MUDE@AGE! ;>JADEGA=>! GK! G>GK;bG<=A! B=M=! DKUG@=! <D! U>! Y0,$! GB=FKG<=! GK!

DEFDB@AIMD@A=!e"3"fk!=!ED! ;>CDB@GA=>!<;ADB@GMD>@D!D>!KG!ZUD>@D!G!U>!ZKU\=!<D!7`!µ,XM;>!

e57k!#0'f8!,G!BUG>@;Z;BGB;I>!<D!&)9%%!ED!ADGK;bI!F=A!,$!"(X"(!D>!M=<=!"3"!SUEBG><=!KG!

@AG>E;B;I>!BCD!PLcXP`7k!BGAGB@DA?E@;BG!<D! KG!FVA<;<G!>DU@AG!<DK!JAUF=!a&)9k!=!PLcXLOk!TUD!

FA=F=AB;=>G!MGC=A!ED>E;S;K;<G<8!(;DMFAD!ED!HDA;Z;BI!TUD!>=!_US;DAG!B=>@GM;>GB;I>!B=>!%%!

eBCD!P`PX9^Rf!>;!B=>!=@AGE!DEFDB;DE!<DA;HG<GE!<D!KG!ADGBB;I>!D>!MD<;=!NB;<=k!B=M=!FUD<D>!

EDA! DEFDB;DE! <;a>;@AG<GEk! U! =:;<G<GE8! ,G! BUAHG! <D! BGK;SAGB;I>! ED! B=>E@AUCI! FGAG! BG<G!

BUG>@;Z;BGB;I>!B=>!%%! eDE@N><GA!D:@DA>=f!C!%%EF! eDE@N><GA! ;>@DA>=f!=S@D>;<=E!<D!$GCMG>!

$_DM;BGKE!mQ7n8!

!

5/+$J$),)$G-%&"%$#G1"+(#%K(#$)$(-,3"#%%

/D!GBUDA<=!G!ADF=A@DE!FADH;=E!<D!>UDE@A=!KGS=AG@=A;=!mQ7nk!KG!>;@AGB;I>!<D!%%!JD>DAG!

U>G!MDbBKG!<D!;EIMDA=E!F=E;B;=>GKDE!TUD!FUD<D>!EDA!EDFGAG<=E!F=A!Y0,$o!SGEG<=E!D>!DE@D!

ADF=A@D! FAD@D><;M=E! DEBGKGA! <D! Z=AMG! FADFGAG@;HG! KG! FUA;Z;BGB;�=>! <D! BG<G! ;EIMDA=8!!

+@;K;bGM=E!FGAG!DKK=!U>G!B=KUM>G!$7c!EDM;aFADFGAG@;HG!e^!�Mk!7`MM!:!9^BMk!+K@AGEF_DAD!

)/(k! 1DBgMG>! $=UK@DA! $A=MG@=JAGF_Cf! B=>! U>! E;E@DMG! JAG<;D>@D! D>@AD! %! eGJUGXNB;<=!

ZIAM;B=!`8`^zf!C!1!eGBD@=>;@A;K=XNB;<=!ZIAM;B=!`8`^!zf!D>!KGE!E;JU;D>@DE!B=><;B;=>DEl!P^!z!1!

e`! G! 7`!M;>fk! 7``!z!1! e7`! G! P^!M;>fk! P^!z!1! eP^! G! L^!M;>f! mQ7n! G! U>! ZKU\=! <D! 9!M,XM;>8!

'>CDB@GM=E!_GE@G!7!MJ!<D!&)9%%!FUA=!F=A!B=AA;<G!C!KGE!SG><GE!B=>!MN:;M=!<D!GSE=ASG>B;G!

G!9QL!>M!ZUDA=>!B=KDB@G<GE!G!KG!EGK;<G!<DK!Y0,$!D>!_D:G>=X;E=FA=FG>=KXNB;<=!GBV@;B=!FGAG!

ADGK;bGA! U>G! D:@AGBB;I>! K;F?<;BG! F=A! _D:G>=8! '<D>@;Z;BGM=E! K=E! ;EIMDA=E! FADED>@DE! D>! BG<G!

SG><G!B=KDB@G<G!F=A!57!EBG>!=FDAG><=!D>!DK!M=<=!<D!;=>;bGB;I>!F=E;@;H=!D>!FADED>B;G!<D!

GBD@G@=! <D! K;@;=! ^! M"8! #>! FADED>B;G! <D! K;@;=k! ED! SK=TUDG! U>G! BGAJG! F=E;@;HG! D>! DK! JAUF=!

BGAS=:;K=! <DK! >;@A=GKTUD>=! K=! TUD! ZGH=ADBD! KG! ZAGJMD>@GB;I>! <D! KG!M=KVBUKG! G! @AGHVE! <DK!

D>KGBD! ;>EG@UAG<=! $a$! <=><D! ED! D>BUD>@AG! DK! JAUF=! a&)9k! JD>DAG><=! ZAGJMD>@=E! <D!BCD!

BGAGB@DA?E@;BG!FGAG!BG<G!;EIMDA=!F=E;B;=>GK!F=E;SKD!mQ7n8!

!

c>T% N(&/3,)$G-%&"%5Z?Y%K(+%P<T::%

%

! ! 0GAG! ADGK;bGA! K=E! D:FDA;MD>@=E! TUD! ED! <D@GKKG>! G! B=>@;>UGB;I>! ED! U@;K;bI!

FDAI:;<=!<D!_;<AIJD>=!eY9)9fk!&k&k&rk&ra@D@AGMD@;KaZD>;KD>D<;GM;>G!e."0/fk!SGED!.3'�"%k!

Z=EZG@=! <D! E=<;=k! C! ZD>=K! <D! (;JMG! $_DM;BGKEo! 0W#9EA! <D! $GCMG>! $_DM;BGKE8! ,=E!

Page 30: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

30

>;@A=GKTUD>=E! &)9)%! C! &)9,%! E=>! U>G! <=>GB;I>! <DK! /A8! 1AUBD! [ADDMG>! e+>;HDAE;@C! =Z!

0;@@ESUAJ_k!+(%f8!!

%

5/+$J$),)$G-%&"%5Z?Y%%

% 0WY(a7!ZUD!FUA;Z;BG<G!B=M=!GF=D>b;MG!eG0WY(a7f!G!FGA@;A!<D!HDE?BUKGE!EDM;>GKDE!<D!

=HD\G! m7^Qn! C! 0WY(a9! ADB=MS;>G>@D! <D! =A;JD>! MUA;>=! ED! D:FADEI! F=A! ADB=MS;>GB;I>!

_=MIK=JG!D>!U>!E;E@DMG!<D!BVKUKGE!<D!;>EDB@=!EZR!m7^cn8!,G!B=>BD>@AGB;I>!<D!KG!D>b;MG!ZUD!

<D@DAM;>G<G!F=A!DK!MV@=<=!<DK!NB;<=!S;B;>B=>?>;B=!e1$%f!C!F=A!DEFDB@A=Z=@=MD@A?G! e�9c`!s!

R^k^c`! "a7BMa7f8! %MSGE! D>b;MGE! ZUDA=>! <=>G<GE! F=A! DK! /A8! ,8]8! "GA>D@@! e+>;HDAE;@C! =Z!

2G><DAS;K@k! +(%f8! ,G! MU@GJV>DE;E! <;A;J;<G! <D! 0WY(a9! FGAG! JD>DAGA! MU@G>@DE! D>! DK! E;@;=!

GB@;H=!$)d!e379`%k!*P^^[!=!(^P`%f!C!0)d!eY9`Q%k!YPcc[k!YPcO%f!ED!ADGK;bI!D>!DK!MGAB=!<D!

U>G! FGEG>@?G! <D! ;>HDE@;JGB;I>! D>! DK! KGS=AG@=A;=! <DK! /A8! "GA>D@@k! <D! GBUDA<=! G! MV@=<=E!

FUSK;BG<=E!m7^Rk!7O`n8!

%

:)*$F$&,&%"-I$1_*$),%

G0WY(a7! C! 9! ED! ADB=>E@;@UCDA=>! B=>! 78^! DTU;HGKD>@DE! <D! _DM=! e[DPpa00'df! F=A! P`!

M;>U@=E!G!L!t$!FADH;=!G!BG<G!D>EGC=!e�L77!s!79P!M"a7BMa7f!mRcn8!#E@U<;GM=E!KG!GB@;H;<G<!0)d!

F=A!!DEFDB@A=Z=@=MD@A?G!e(_;MG<bU!+29L`+f!U@;K;bG><=!DK!D>EGC=!<DK!&k&k&�k&�a@D@AGMD@;KaFa

ZD>;KD>D<;GM;>G!e."0/f!G!9^!t$!D>!U>!GM=A@;JUG<=A!Z=EZG@=!^`!M"k!FY!Q8L!eεO77!s!79!M"a

7BMa7f! mRcn8! ,GE! MDbBKGE! <D! ADGBB;I>! <D! L``!µ,! B=>@D>?G>! 0WY(a7! e9`! >"f! =! 9! e9^! >"fk!

."0/!e9^`!µ"f!C!Y9)9!eP``!µ"fk!G!MD>=E!TUD!ED!DEFDB;Z;TUD!<;ZDAD>@D8!#>!@=<=E!K=E!BGE=E!

<D@DAM;>GM=E!KG!=:;<GB;I>!>=!D>b;MN@;BG!<DK!."0/8!,G!GB@;H;<G<!0)d!ED!D:FADEG!B=M=!M=K!

."0/=:XM;>!<D!ADGBB;I>XMJ!<D!FA=@D?>G!C!B=AADEF=><D!G!MD<;<GE!<D!HDK=B;<G<!;>;B;GK8!,G!

GB@;H;<G<!$)d!ED!DE@U<;I!F=A!=:;MD@A?G!C!KG!GB@;H;<G<!@=@GK!F=A!,$!"(X"(8!#K!B=>EUM=!<D!)9!

ED!DHGKUI!U@;K;bG><=!U>!=:?MD@A=!e)3)1)3)(!)9gf!G!PQ!t$!D>!GM=A@;JUG<=A!Z=EZG@=!^`!M"k!

FY!Q8L8!,G!MDbBKG!<D!ADGBB;I>!<D!9!M,!B=>@D>?G!0WY(a7!e9^!>"f!=!9!e7``!>"fk!ZD>=K!e^``!

µ"f!C!%%!e7^!µ"fk!G!MD>=E!TUD!ED!DEFDB;Z;TUD!<;ZDAD>@D8!,G!GB@;H;<G<!ED!D:FADEG!B=M=!M=K!

)9! B=>EUM;<=XM;>! <D! ADGBB;I>XMJ! <D! FA=@D?>G! C! B=AADEF=><D! G! MD<;<GE! <D! HDK=B;<G<!

;>;B;GK8! ,G! Z=AMGB;I>!<DK!FA=<UB@=!<D!<DBG;M;D>@=!F=A!_;<AIK;E;E!<D! KG! ADGBB;I>! e0W#9k!BCD!

P^7X9Q7f!ED!BUG>@;Z;BI!F=A!,$!"(X"(!e._DAM=!(B;D>@;Z;B!.(5!5UG>@UM!+K@AGk!=!5.3%0!9```k!

%FFK;D<!1;=ECE@DMEX"/(!($'#df! B=M=! ?><;BD!<D!GB@;H;<G<!D>b;MN@;BG! @=@GK!D>!DK!M=<=!<D!

;=>;bGB;I>! >DJG@;H=! U@;K;bG><=! 0W#9EA! eB=>! BUG@A=! N@=M=E! <D! <DU@DA;=f! B=M=! DE@G><GA!

;>@DA>=!eBCD!P^^X9Q^f8!,GE!ADGBB;=>DE!ED!KKDHGA=>!G!BGS=!G!PQ!t$!D>!GM=A@;JUG<=A!Z=EZG@=!^`!

M"k! FY! Q8Lk! C! B=>@D>?G>! 0WY(a9! e9^! >"f! C! %%! e^! µ"f! D>! U>! H=KUMD>! <D! 9``! µ,8! (D!

<D@UH;DA=>!G!K=E!P`!EDJU><=E!F=A!D:@AGBB;I>!B=>!GBD@G@=!<D!D@;K=!EUFKDMD>@G<=!B=>!0W#9EA#

eP``! FM=Kfk! C! KGE! ZGEDE! _;<A=ZIS;BGE! ED! EDBGA=>! e,GSB=>B=f! C! ADB=>E@;@UCDA=>! D>!MD@G>=K!

^`z!FGAG!EU!G>NK;E;E!F=A!,$!"(X"(8!0GAG!ADE=KHDA!DK!0W#9!Z=AMG<=k!U@;K;bGM=E!U>G!B=KUM>G!

$7c!e^BM!:!7MMk!^�f!B=>!U>!E;E@DMG!<D!DKUB;I>!B=MFUDE@=!F=A!U>!JAG<;D>@D!<D!GBD@=>;@A;K=!

Page 31: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

31

D>!GJUG!e^z!G!R^z!D>!O!M;>f!G!U>!ZKU\=!<D!P``!�,XM;>8!0GAG! KGE!MU@G>@DE!<D!0WY(a9!B=>!

GB@;H;<G<!AD<UB;<G!=!FGAB;GKMD>@D!;>GB@;HG<GE!G\UE@GM=E!KGE!B=>BD>@AGB;=>DE!<D!EUE@AG@=!C!

D>b;MG!=!DK!@;DMF=!<D!ADGBB;I>!_GE@G!=S@D>DA!U>G!GB@;H;<G<!<D!GK!MD>=E!^z!ADEFDB@=!G!KG!

FA=@D?>G!>G@;HG8!,G!MU@G>@D!D>!Y;EPcc!>=!@UH=!GB@;H;<G<!0)d!<D@DB@GSKD8!!

!

8-C$A$)$G-%&"%3,%,)*$F$&,&%

,=E!;>_;S;<=ADE!ED!GJADJGA=>!D>!MD@G>=K!G!KGE!MDbBKGE!<D!ADGBB;I>!e;>ZDA;=A!G!7z!HXHf!

\U>@=!B=>!DK!EUE@AG@=!=!ED!FAD;>BUSGA=>!B=>!0WY(!F=A!@;DMF=E!HGA;GSKDE8!0GAG!DE@GSKDBDA!E;!

DK!&)9%%!B=MF;@D!B=>!DK!%%!F=A!DK!E;@;=!GB@;H=!$)dk!KG!GB@;H;<G<!ED!<D@DAM;>I!F=A!=:;MD@A?G!

G!B=>BD>@AGB;I>!<D!EUE@AG@=!EG@UAG>@D! e7^`!�"fk!BDABG>=!GK!q"! e7^!�"fk!=! ;>@DAMD<;G! eP`!

�"!C!Q`!�"fk!B=>!&)9%%!_GE@G!77`!�"8!0GAG!<D@DAM;>GA!DK!M=<DK=!B;>V@;B=!<D!;>_;S;B;I>!

KGE! ;E=Z=AMGE!0WY(a7!=!9! ED!FAD;>BUSGA=>!B=>!U>G!B=>BD>@AGB;I>! Z;\G!<D!&)9%%! e`89!G!7`!

�"f!F=A!@;DMF=E!<D!FAD;>BUSGB;I>!BADB;D>@DE!e`!G!P``!EDJfk!C!ED!<D@DAM;>I!KG!GB@;H;<G<!0)d8!

)S@UH;M=E!ADKGB;=>DE!<D!GB@;H;<G<!D>b;MN@;BG!$1,!@;DMF=!<D!FAD;>BUSGB;I>!TUD!G\UE@GM=E!G!

U>G! D:F=>D>B;GK! <D! =A<D>! 7! FGAG! =S@D>DA! K=E! HGK=ADE! <D! '=SE8! 0GAG! <D@DAM;>GA! KG!

ADHDAE;S;K;<G<!<D! KG! ;>_;S;B;I>! ;>BUSGM=E!GF=a!C!_=K=a!0WY(a7!C!9! eP8^!�"f!B=>!&)9%%! e7!

M"f!=!;><=MD@GB;>G!e7!M"f!F=A!7`!M;>U@=Ek!Z;K@AGM=E!KGE!MUDE@AGE!F=A!UK@AGBD>@A;ZUJGB;I>!

e";BA=! 1;=a(F;>fk! ADB=>E@;@U?M=E! B=>! 78^! DTU;HGKD>@DE! <D! _DM=k! C! <D@DAM;>GM=E! KGE!

GB@;H;<G<DE!0)d!C!$)d8!0GAG!_0WY(!@GMS;V>!<D@DAM;>GM=E!KG!GB@;H;<G<!D>b;MN@;BG!FADH;=!GK!

Z;K@AG<=8!0GAG!<DEBGA@GA!U>!A=K!<D!&)9%%!B=M=!B=aEUE@AG@=!AD<UB@=A!<D!0WY(k!KG!D>b;MG!e9^!

>"f!ED!FAD;>BUSI!B=>!HD_?BUK=!eMD@G>=Kf!=!&)9%%!e^!C!9`!�"fk!C!ED!;>;B;I!KG!ADGBB;I>!B=>!

7^aYF#.#! e9`! �"f! D>! FADED>B;G! U! GUED>B;G! <D! ZD>=K! e^``! �"f8! %! K=E! B;>B=! M;>U@=E! ED!

<D@DAM;>I!KG!AD<UBB;I>!<D!7^aYF#.#!F=A!DK!D>EGC=!<D![)dk!TUD!ED!SGEG!D>!KG!=:;<GB;I>!<D!

;=>DE!ZDAA=E=!G!ZVAA;B=!BG@GK;bG<G!F=A!_;<A=FDAI:;<=E!D>!B=><;B;=>DE!GB?<;BGEk!D>!FADED>B;G!

<DK!;><;BG<=A!<D!;I>!ZVAA;B=!>GAG>\G!<D!:;KD>=K!m7O7k!7O9n8!

!

7,1A$(#%"-%"3%C"1(%

! #HGKUGM=E!DK!DZDB@=!<D!&)9%%!E=SAD!DK!GMS;D>@D!<DK!_DM=!<D!HGA;GE!MG>DAGE8!!&!,G!

DZ;B;D>B;G! <D! U>;I>! <D! _DM=! G! G0WY(! @AG@G<G! B=>!&)9%%!=! ;><=MD@GB;>G! ED! DE@U<;I! F=A!

DEFDB@A=Z=@=MD@A?G! G! L77! >M8! ,G! MUDE@AG! ZUD! Z;K@AG<G! e";BA=! 1;=a(F;>f! FGAG! DK;M;>GA! DK!

D:BDE=!<D!;>_;S;<=A!FADH;=!G! KG!G<;B;I>!<DK!_DM=!C! KG!DZ;B;D>B;G!<D!U>;I>!ED!D:FADEI!B=M=!

%SE9c`X%SEL778! #>! @=<=E! K=E! BGE=E! ED!B=>E;<DAI! KG!<;KUB;I>!<D! KG!FA=@D?>G!F=A!DK! Z;K@AG<=8! !!&!

.;@UKGM=E!G0WY(! e9!�"f!FAD;>BUSG<G!F=A!7`!M;>U@=E!B=>!HD_?BUK=!=!B=>!&)9%%!e7`!C!P^!

�"f!B=>!GK?BU=@GE!<D!_DM=!e`89!�"f!C!ADJ;E@AGM=E!BG<G!HDb!KG!%SEL778!!!!&!$UG>@;Z;BGM=E!DK!

_DM=! FADED>@D! D>! _=K=0WY(! e_0WY(f! @AG@G<G! B=>! HD_?BUK=! =! &)9%%! F=A! DK! D>EGC=! <D!

F;A;<;>G!_DM=BA=M=!m7OPn8!_0WY(!e^!�"f!ED!;>BUSI!B=>!&)9%%!e^`!�"f!F=A!7`!M;>U@=Ek!ED!

Z;K@AI!FGAG!ADM=HDA! ;>_;S;<=A!C!_DM=!D>!D:BDE=k!C!ED!GJADJI!G!Q`!�,! !<D!MUDE@AGl!9!�,!<D!

q)Y!^!"k!P`!�,!<D!F;A;<;>Gk!C!<;@;=>;@=!EUZ;B;D>@D!FGAG!AD<UB;A!_DM;BA=M=E!G!_DM=BA=M=E!

Page 32: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

32

<D!F;A;<;>G8!%!K=E!<=E!M;>U@=E!ADJ;E@AGM=E!DK!DEFDB@A=!D>!DK!H;E;SKD!TUD!@UH=!U>!MN:;M=!<D!

GSE=ASG>B;G!G!^^O!>M8!$=>E@AU?M=E!U>G!BUAHG!<D!BGK;SAGB;I>!e%SE^^O!$1! m_DM=nf!U@;K;bG><=!

U>! DE@N><GA! <D! _DM=! e`! G! 9`! �"f! C! <D@DAM;>GM=E! DK! HGK=A! �^^OsPL8^P! M"a7BMa78# !$&!

#E@U<;GM=E! K=E! BGMS;=E! DEFDB@AGKDE! eP^`! G! ^^`! >Mf! <D! [D9pa00'da0WY(! e7^8O! �"f! D>!

FADED>B;G! <D! &)9%%! e7^`! �"f8! [D9pa00'da0WY(! ED! =S@UH=! F=A! AD<UBB;I>! B=>! <;@;=>;@=8! #K!

GM=A@;JUG<=A!ZUD!D:@D>EGMD>@D!<DJGEDG<=!D>!GAJI>k!C! KG!BUHD@G!ED!EDKKI!B=>!U>!EDF@=!<D!

J=MG!FGAG!D>KD>@DBDA!KG!ADa=:;<GB;I>!<DK!_DM=!ZDAA=E=!G!ZVAA;B=!<UAG>@D!DK!ADJ;E@A=!<D!K=E!

DEFDB@A=E! eO`!M;>U@=Ef8!#K!_DM=! ZDAA=E=!U>;<=!G!0WY(! @UH=!U>!MN:;M=!<D!GSE=ASG>B;G!G!

L9c!>Mk!C!DK!_DM=!ZDAA=E=!K;SAD!@UH=!U>!MN:;M=!<D!GSE=ASG>B;G!G!L79!>M8!$&!#HGKUGM=E!KG!

M=<;Z;BGB;I>!<D!_DM=! K;SAD!F=A!&)9%%! e7`:f!F=A!"(! eD>!57f!C!F=A!DK!MV@=<=!<D!F;A;<;>G!

_DM=BA=M=8!

!

5+(*"G3$#$#%K(+%*+$K#$-,%

! %F=a!=!_=K=a!0WY(a7!e9!�"f!ED!;>BUSI!G!9^!t$!F=A!B;>B=!M;>U@=E!D>!@A;EaY$K!7``!M"k!

FY!c8`k!B=>!&)9%%!eL``!�"f!=!;><=MD@GB;>G!e^``!�"f8!'>BUSGM=E!KG!FA=@D?>G!B=>!@A;FE;>G!

eP87!�"f!G!9^!t$!C!<D@UH;M=E!KG!ADGBB;I>!G!K=E!P`!EDJU><=E!F=A!;>BUSGB;I>!B=>!ZKU=AUA=!<D!

ZD>;KMD@;KEUKZ=>;K=!e0"([f!e78^!M"f!<UAG>@D!B;>B=!M;>U@=E!G!L!t$!m7OLn8!/DE>G@UAGK;bGM=E!

GK?BU=@GE!<D!0WY(a7! e9!�"f!BGKD>@G><=!@ADE!M;>U@=E!G!R^!t$!D>!SUZZDA!<D! KG!MUDE@AG!B=>!

(/(!C!B=AA;M=E!KGE!MUDE@AGE!F=A!(/(a0%W#!D>!U>!JDK!<D!F=K;GBA;KGM;<G!GK!7`z8!,G!@;>B;I>!ED!

ADGK;bI!B=>!$==MGEE;D!1A;KK;G>@!1KUD!3a9^`8!

!

:-_3$#$#%K+(*"G1$)(%

! 0GAG! DK! G>NK;E;E! F=A! "%,/'a.)[! e1AUgDA! /GK@=>;BE! %U@=ZKD:! "%,/'X.)[! 0A=@D=M;BE!

%>GKCbDAf!GF=!C!_=K=!0WY(a9! eD>@DAGf! ED!FAD;>BUSI!D>!GM=A@;JUG<=A! @A;EaY$K!7``!M"k!FY!

c8`k! B=>!&)9%%! e7`df! F=A! _GE@G! L! _=AGE8! 0GAG! <DEGKGA! KGE!MUDE@AGE! DHGKUGM=E! <;ZDAD>@DE!

FA=@=B=K=E! =S@D>;D><=! EDjGK! FA=@D;BG! BUG><=! ;>@DABGMS;GM=E! DK! GM=A@;JUG<=A! F=A! `87z!

.[%X7`z! GBD@=>;@A;K=8! %>GK;bGM=E! MUDE@AGE! >G@;HGE! C! <DE>G@UAGK;bG<GE! B=>! @A;Ea9a

BGAS=:;D@;KZ=EZ;>G!e.$#0f8!,G!MG@A;b!U@;K;bG<G!ZUD!NB;<=!αaB;G>=aLa_;<A=:;B;>NM;B=!e$Y$%f!e9`!

MJXM,f! B=>! NB;<=! E;>GF?>;B=! e9`! MJXM,f8! 0GAG! DK! G>NK;E;E! F=A! ,$! "(X"(! <D! 0WY(!

FA=@D=K;bG<G!U@;K;bGM=E!U>!DTU;F=!._DAM=!,.5! e._DAM=!#KDB@A=>k! (G>! ]=EDk!$%f!DTU;FG<=!

B=>!U>G!ZUD>@D!<D!M;BA=aDKDB@A=EFAGC8!!#K!JAG<;D>@D!<D!E=KHD>@DE!DMFKDG<=!ZUD!GJUGX`87z!

NB;<=!ZIAM;B=!C!GBD@=>;@A;K=X`87z!NB;<=!ZIAM;B=k!D>!U>G!B=KUM>G!BGF;KGA!<D!E?K;BG!e7``!�M!:!

77!BMf!DMFGTUD@G<G!B=>!$7c!=!$L!e0_D>=MD>D:k!.=AAG>BDk!$%f8!,GE!MUDE@AGE!eGF=!C!_=K=!

0WY(a9!@AG@G<GE!B=>!HD_?BUK=!=!&)9%%f!ED!FADB;F;@GA=>!B=>!NB;<=!@A;BK=A=GBV@;B=!e.$%fk!ED!

AD<U\DA=>!B=>!.$#0k!C!ED!GKTU;KGA=>!C!<;J;A;DA=>!B=>!@A;FE;>G!=!TU;M=@A;FE;>Gk!G!FY!Q8`!=!R8`8!

.GMS;V>! ED! G>GK;bGA=>! MUDE@AGE! TUD! >=! ZUDA=>! AD<UB;<GEXGKTU;KG<GE8! #HGKUGM=E! KG!

>;@A=GKTU;KGB;I>! FDF@?<;BG! F=A! G>NK;E;E! <D! K=E! <G@=E! B=>! (BGZZ=K<! 0A=@D=MD! (=Z@�GAD8

! #E@=E! D:FDA;MD>@=E! ED! ADGK;bGA=>! D>! DK! KGS=AG@=A;=! $GFA;=K;! C! D>! DK! BD>@A=! <D!

Page 33: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

33

DEFDB@A=MD@A?G!<D!MGEG!<D!KG!+>;HDAE;<G<!<D!2G><DAS;K@k!+(%k!D>!DK!MGAB=!<D!U>G!FGEG>@?G!

<D!;>HDE@;JGB;I>!D>!DK!KGS=AG@=A;=!<DK!/A8!,8]8!"GA>D@@8!!

'()D$-O%1(3")/3,+%

! #>EGCGM=E! B=MFU@GB;=>GKMD>@D! KG! BGFGB;<G<! <D! %%! C! HGA;=E! >;@A=GKTUD>=E! eRa

&)9)%k!C!Rak!79ak!7La!C!7^a&)9%%f!<D!U>;AED!G!0WY(a9k!U@;K;bG><=!(UAZKD:/=Bg! m7O^n! m7OOn!

m7OQnk!B=>@D>;<=!D>!DK!FGTUD@D!<D!M=<DKG<=!M=KDBUKGA!(CSCK7c87!m7Ocn8!0ADH;=!GK!<=Bg;>Jk!

@=<=E! K=E!B=MFUDE@=E!ED!=F@;M;bGA=>! !"#$*24%!B=>E;<DAG><=!DK!DZDB@=!<D! KGE!M=KVBUKGE!<D!

GJUGk!B=M=!ED!_G!ADF=A@G<=!G>@DE!m7ORn8!#K!<=Bg;>J!<D! K=E!>;@A=GKTUD>=E!ED! ADGK;bI!D>! K=E!

E;@;=E!GB@;H=E!$)d!C!0)d!<D!0WY(a9! e0/1!PY(^f8!+@;K;bG><=!DE@D!BA;E@GK! B=M=!B=MFKD\=!<D!

ADZDAD>B;Gk!ED!JD>DAI!U>!FA=@=M=Kk!U>G!ADFADED>@GB;I>!B=MFU@GB;=>GK!<DK!F=@D>B;GK!E;@;=!<D!

U>;I>! G! <=><D! K=E! K;JG><=E! FU@G@;H=E! E=>! GK;>DG<=E8! ,G! B=>E@AUBB;I>! ED! SGEI! D>! ADE;<U=E!

FA=@D;B=E!FADED>@DE!D>! K=E!E;@;=E!$)d!C!0)d!<D!0WY(a98!#K!FA=@=M=K!<D!(UAZKD:/=Bg!U@;K;bG!

ZAGJMD>@=E! $YLk! $s)! C! &Y! FGAG! <;A;J;A! KG! ;>@DAGBB;I>! ;>;B;GK! <D! K=E! K;JG><=E! <UAG>@D! DK!

FA=BDE=! <D! <=Bg;>J8! #K! <=Bg;>J! <D! BG<G! K;JG><=! FU@G@;H=! SA;><I! _GE@G! 9`! =A;D>@GB;=>DE!

F=E;SKDEk! TUD! ED! D:FADEG>! B=>! U>! ?><;BD! <D! GZ;>;<G<k! aK=J7`! eq<f8! #K! MV@=<=! (UAZKD:/=Bg!

FDAM;@;I! EDKDBB;=>GA! KG! =A;D>@GB;I>! B=>!MGC=A! GZ;>;<G<!G!FGA@;A! <D!MiK@;FKDE!F=E;S;K;<G<DE!

FGAG!U>!K;JG><=8!!

!

c>V% 81K,)*(%&"%P<T::%#(A+"%K3,L/"*,#%C/1,-,#%!

! #>! K=E! D:FDA;MD>@=E! TUD! ED! <D@GKKG>! G! B=>@;>UGB;I>! ED! U@;K;bGA=>! K=E! E;JU;D>@DE!

ADGB@;H=E! <D! $GCMG>! $_DM;BGKE! e%>>! %AS=Ak! "'fl! 79aY#.#EFk! %%EFk! U>G! MDbBKG! <D!

D;B=EG>=;<DE!FGAG!,$a"(!e0W/9k!!0W#9k!!

Oga0W[7vk!0W[9v!C!.:19fk!D!;><=MD@GB;>G8!,=E!ADGB@;H=E!0"%k!@A=MS;>G!<D!FKGEMG!S=H;>=k!79a

e9a$;G>=D@;KfaOkQk79k7Pa@DAG_;<A=a7PaMD@;Ka^a=:=a^Ya;><=Km9kPaGnF;AA=K=mPkLaBnBGASGb=KD! aJ�!

ORQOfk! W[7`R9`Pd! eW[7`fk! C! 7Yam7k9kLn=:G<;Gb=K=mLkPaGnTU;>=:GK;>Ga7a=>G! e)/5fk! C! DK!

G>@;BUDAF=! G>@;ava@USUK;>G! E=>! <D! (;JMGa%K<A;B_8! #K! 9aeLaBGAS=:;ZD>;K=faLkLk^k^a!

@D@AGMD@;K;M;<Gb=K;>Ga! 7a=:;KaPa=:;<=! eBGAS=:;0.')f! ZUD! B=MFAG<=! D>!/=\;><=! ,GS=AG@=A;DE!

e]GFG>f8! ,=E! G>@;BUDAF=E! G>@;a0q$! C! G>@;a0aEDKDB@;>G! E=>! <D! (G>@G! $AUb! 1;=@DB_>=K=JC8! ,=E!

G>@;BUDAF=E!G>@;a#Ag7X9!e<=>GB;I>!<DK!/A8!]=EV!1=JJ;Gf!C!G>@;aF#Ag7X9!E=>!<D!$DKK!(;J>GK;>J!

.DB_>=K=JC8! ,=E!G>@;BUDAF=E! EDBU><GA;=E! B=>\UJG<=E!G! ZKU=A=BA=M=E!<DK! ;>ZAGAA=\=! E=>!<D!

,;a$=A!1;=EB;D>B;DE8!#K!;><;BG<=A!<D!$G9p![KU=aP!%"!e<=>GB;I>!<D!KG!/AG8![K=AD>B;G!'A;J=;>f!DE!

<D!"=KDBUKGA!0A=SDE8!.=<=E!K=E!E=KHD>@DE!U@;K;bG<=E!ZUDA=>!BGK;<G<!Y0,$8!,=E!ADEUK@G<=E!E=>!

ADFADED>@G@;H=E! <D! GK! MD>=E! @ADE! D:FDA;MD>@=E! ;><DFD><;D>@DEk! U@;K;bG><=! FKGTUD@GE!

FUA;Z;BG<GE!<D!<;ZDAD>@DE!<=>G>@DE8! ,=E! HGK=ADE! ED! D:FADEG>! B=M=!DK! DAA=A! DE@N><GA!<D! KG!

MD<;G!�!(#"!e>sPf8!0GAG!B=MFGAGA!HGA;=E!JAUF=E!ADGK;bGM=E!DK!G>NK;E;E!<D!HGA;G>bG!%&)2%!

Page 34: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

34

B=>!DK!MV@=<=!<D!(@U<D>@a&D�MG>aqDUKE!e(a&aqf!FGAG!HGA;G>bGE!_=M=JV>DGE8!,G!<;ZDAD>B;G!

<D!MD<;GE!ED!B=>E;<DAI!E;J>;Z;BG@;HG!G!F!G#`8`^8!

%

5/+$J$),)$G-%&"%K3,L/"*,#%3,F,&,#%

! ,GE!FKGTUD@GE!ED!G;EKGA=>!<D!FKGEMG!ZADEB=!<D!H=KU>@GA;=E!EG>=E! K;SAD!<D!%%(!F=A!GK!

MD>=E!<=E!EDMG>GE8!,G!EG>JAD!D>@DAG!e9^!G!^`!M,f!ED!B=KDB@I!F=A!FU>B;I>!HD>=EG!U@;K;bG><=!

U>G!E=KUB;I>!<D!GBD@G@=aB;@AG@=aJKUB=EG!e%$/f!B=M=!G>@;B=GJUKG>@D!eEG>JADl%$/k!7l7kR!HXHfk!

E;JU;D><=! U>! FA=@=B=K=! GFA=SG<=! F=A! DK! B=M;@V! <D! V@;BG! <D! KG! [GBUK@G<! <D! "D<;B;>Gk!

+>;HDAE;<G<! <D! KG! 3DFiSK;BG! e#:F8! &t! `Q77L`a```9^ca79f8! #K! FKGEMG! A;B=! D>! FKGTUD@GE! ED!

=S@UH=! F=A! BD>@A;ZUJGB;I>! <D! KG! EG>JAD! D>@DAG! G! 9^`J! F=A! 7`! M;>U@=E! G! @DMFDAG@UAG!

GMS;D>@D8! ,GE! FKGTUD@GE! ED! FUA;Z;BGA=>!<DK! FKGEMG!D>!U>G! EDJU><G! BD>@A;ZUJGB;I>! G! R``J!

F=A!7`!M;>U@=E!G!@DMFDAG@UAG!GMS;D>@D8!#K!FDKKD@!=S@D>;<=!ED!KGHI!G!c``J!F=A!7`!M;>U@=E!G!

@DMFDAG@UAG!GMS;D>@Dk!D>!9!M,!<D!E=KUB;I>!.CA=<D}E! e7PL!M"!&G$Kk!79!M"!&GY$)Pk!98R!

M"! q$Kk! `8PL!M"!&G9Y0)Lk! 78`!"J$K9k! 7`!M"! YDFDEk! ^! M"! JKUB=EGk! FY! Q8Lf! B=>! %$/!

e.CA=<D}El%$/! Rl7! HXHf8! ,GE! FKGTUD@GE! KGHG<GE! =S@D>;<GE! ED! B=>@GA=>! B=>! U>G! BNMGAG! <D!

&DUSGUDA! C! ED! U@;K;bGA=>! D>! KGE! B;>B=! _=AGE! E;JU;D>@DE8! [UD! BA?@;B=! DH;@GA! M=H;M;D>@=E!

SAUEB=E!<D!KGE!MUDE@AGE!C!BGMS;=E!D>!KG!@DMFDAG@UAG!G!K=!KGAJ=!<D!@=<=!DK!FA=BD<;M;D>@=k!

FGAG!DH;@GA!KG!GJADJGB;I>!>=!<DEDG<G!<D!KGE!FKGTUD@GE8!0GAG!B=>Z;AMGA!U>!DZDB@=!<D!&)9%%!

;><DFD><;D>@D!<D!0WY(a7k!DK!FKGEMG!A;B=!D>!FKGTUD@GE!ED! ;>BUSI!F=A!7`!M;>U@=E!B=>!%%(!

e7``!�"f!C!KUDJ=!ED!B=>@;>UI!KG!FUA;Z;BGB;I>!B=M=!ED!<D@GKKG!GAA;SG8!

!

8-)(+K(+,)$G-%&"%P<T::%

! 0GAG! <D@DAM;>GA! KG! ZAGBB;I>! DZDB@;HG! <D! &)9%%! TUD! ;>JADEG! G! KGE! FKGTUD@GE! D>!

EUEFD>E;I>! e=! FDAMG>DBD! D>! KG! MDMSAG>Gf! KUDJ=! <D! <=E! M;>U@=E! <D! FAD;>BUSGB;I>! D>!

E=KUB;I>!.CA=<D}E!G!PQ!t$!SG\=!GJ;@GB;I>!EUGHDk! ;>BUSGM=E!P``!FM=K!<D!&)9%%!B=>!L:7`c!

FKGTUD@GEXM,k! C! SG\GM=E! KGE! FKGTUD@GE! F=A! BD>@A;ZUJGB;I>! e7^k```Jk! P`! EDJU><=Ef! G!

<;ZDAD>@DE! @;DMF=E! e`! G! 9! M;>U@=Efk! EDFGAGM=E! DK! E=SAD>G<G>@Dk! GJADJGM=E! %%EF! B=M=!

DE@N><GA! ;>@DA>=!C!ADGK;bGM=E!U>G!D:@AGBB;I>!=AJN>;BG!B=>!GBD@G@=!<D!D@;K=8!$UG>@;Z;BGM=E!

DK!&)9%%!D>!DK!E=SAD>G<G>@D!G!<;ZDAD>@DE!@;DMF=E!<D!FAD;>BUSGB;I>!F=A!,$!"(X"(8!!

!

2(+1,)$G-%&"%K+(&/)*(#%&"+$F,&(#%&"%::%

! #E@U<;GM=E!F=A!"(!DK! <DE@;>=!MD@GSIK;B=!<D!%%!D>!FKGTUD@GE! GB@;HG<GE8! 0KGTUD@GE!

KGHG<GE!e9:7`cXM,f!ZUDA=>!GB@;HG<GE!B=>!@A=MS;>G!e`89!+XM,f!D>!FADED>B;G!<D!$G9p!e7!M"f!C!

MD@G>=K! =! &)9%%! e9! M;>fk! D>! E=KUB;I>! .CA=<DrE! G! PQ~$! SG\=! GJ;@GB;I>! EUGHD8! %! K=E! P`!

M;>U@=Ek!GJADJGM=E!79aY#.#EF#eP`!>Jf!G!KGE!MUDE@AGE!C!ADGK;bGM=E!U>G!D:@AGBB;I>!K;F?<;BG!

B=>! _D:G>=8! 0GAG! EDFGAGA! K=E! K?F;<=E! D>! KG! MDbBKG! =S@D>;<G! U@;K;bGM=E! U>G! B=KUM>G!

BA=MG@=JANZ;BG! $7c! )/(! e^! �Mk! 7^`! :! L8O! MMk! uG@DAE! ,@<8f! B=>! U>! E;E@DMG! JAG<;D>@D!

B=MFUDE@=!F=A!%sY9`XGBD@=>;@A;K=XGBV@;B=!eQ^l9^l`87!HXHf!C!1sMD@G>=KXGBD@=>;@A;K=XGBV@;B=!

Page 35: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

35

eO`lL`l`87!HXHfk!TUD!GKBG>bI!R`z!<D!1!e<DE<D!^`zf!D>!L`!M;>U@=E!G!U>!ZKU\=!<D!`8^!M,XM;>8!

,=E!FA=<UB@=E!ED!G>GK;bGA=>!F=A!"3"!=FDAG><=!D>!DK!M=<=!<D!;=>;bGB;I>!>DJG@;H=!e%FFK;D<!

1;=ECE@DME!5a.AGF!9```fk!B=>E;<DAG><=!KGE!E;JU;D>@DE!@AG>E;B;=>DEl!BCD!P7RX7QR!e7^aY#.#fk!

BCD!PORX7OR!e.:19f!G><!BCD!P9QX7cL87!e79aY#.#aEFf!m7Q`n8!

%

:O+"O,)$G-%%

! ,G!GJADJGB;I>!FKGTUD@GA;G!ED!DE@U<;I!F=A!@AG>EM;@G>B;G!<D! KUb!G!Q``!>M!G!@AGHVE!<D!

BUSD@GE! <D! FKNE@;B=! <D! 9! M,! <D! H=KUMD>k! G! PQ! t$! C! SG\=! GJ;@GB;I>! B=>@;>UG!

eDEFDB@A=Z=@IMD@A=!2GA;G>a$GAC!+2aH;Ef8!,GE!FKGTUD@GE!e7!:!7`c!XM,f!ED!<;KUCDA=>!G!9!M,!D>!

E=KUB;I>!.CA=<D{E!C!DHGKUGM=E!KG!GJADJGB;I>!;><UB;<G!F=A!@A=MS;>G!e`8`9k!`8`^k!=!`8^!+XM,fk!

0"%!e7``!>"fk!%%!e^`!�"fk!=!%/0!ePc!�"f8!,GE!FKGTUD@GE!D>!.CA=<D}E!ED!FAD;>BUSGA=>!F=A!

<=E!M;>U@=E!B=>!$G9p!e7!M"f!k!C!F=A!U>!M;>U@=!B=>!;>_;S;<=A!=!HD_?BUK=k!G>@DE!<D!GJADJGA!DK!

GJ=>;E@G8! ,G! ;>BUSGB;I>! B=>!)/5! eL! �"f! ED! DZDB@UI! F=A! 9`!M;>U@=Ek! C! KG! ;>BUSGB;I>! B=>!

BGAS=:;0.')!e7!M"f!F=A!7`!M;>U@=E8!,G!=:;a_DM=JK=S;>G!e=:;YSf!ED!FUA;Z;BI!<D!EG>JAD!ZADEBG!

m7Q7nk! <D@DAM;>G><=! DEFDB@A=Z=@=MV@A;BGMD>@D! U>! DE@G<=! AD<=:! <D! GK! MD>=E! Rcz!

AD<UB;<Gk!C!ED!GJADJI!e^`!�"f!E;MUK@N>DGMD>@D!B=>!DK!&)9%%8!0GAG!<DEBGA@GA!KG!M=<UKGB;I>!

<D! @A=MS;>G! F=A! &)9%%k! FAD;>BUSGM=E! @A=MS;>G! e`8`^! +XM,f! B=>! &)9%%! e7! �"f! C! !&!

GJADJGM=E! KG! MDbBKG! G! U>G! EUEFD>E;I>! <D! FKGTUD@GE! e7:7`c! XM,fk! =! !!&! GJADJGM=E! KG!

EUEFD>E;I>! <D! FKGTUD@GE! G! KG! MDbBKG! @A=MS;>Ga&)9%%8! 0=E@DA;=AMD>@D! ADJ;E@AGM=E! KG!

GJADJGB;I>!FKGTUD@GA;G8!!

'"O+,-/3,)$G-%E%1(F$3$I,)$G-%&"%7,Tl%

! #E@U<;GM=E! KG! D:F=E;B;I>! <D! 0aEDKDB@;>G! D>! KG! BGAG! D:@DA>G! <D! KG! MDMSAG>G!

FKGTUD@GA;G!C!DK!GUMD>@=!D>!KG!B=>BD>@AGB;I>!;>@AGBDKUKGA!<D!$G9p!F=A!B;@=MD@A?G!<D!ZKU\=!e1/!

[%$($GK;SUAf8! 0GAG! DHGKUGA! K=E! DZDB@=E! <D! &)9%%! E=SAD! KG! <DJAG>UKGB;I>k! FAD;>BUSGM=E!

FKGTUD@GE!KGHG<GE!e7:7`O!XM,f!D>!E=KUB;I>!.CA=<D}E!B=>!$G9p!e7!M"f!F=A!<=E!M;>U@=E!G>@DE!

<D!KG!G<;B;I>!<D!@A=MS;>G!e`8`^!=!`8^!+XM,f8!,=E!;>_;S;<=ADE!ED!GJADJGA=>!G!KG!EUEFD>E;I>!<D!

FKGTUD@GE!U>!M;>U@=!G>@DE!<DK!GJ=>;E@G8!%!K=E!7^!M;>U@=E!GJADJGM=E!DK!G>@;BUDAF=!<D!AG@I>!

G>@;a0aEDKDB@;>G! _UMG>G! B=>\UJG<=! G! ZKU=ADEBD?>G! @;=B;G>G@=! e['.$k! �D:BsLR^!>M! C!

�DMs^97!>Mfk!D! ;>BUSGM=E!G!L!t$!F=A!P`!M;>U@=E8!$=M=!B=>@A=K! ;E=@?F;B=!U@;K;bGM=E!'JW7�!

<D!AG@I>!B=>\UJG<=!G!['.$8!,GHGM=E!C!Z;\GM=E!KGE!MUDE@AGE!B=>!Z=AMGK<D_?<=!789^z!D>!01(!

ZA?=8!0GAG!DHGKUGA!E;!DK!&)9%%!GZDB@G!KG!M=H;K;bGB;I>!;>@AGBDKUKGA!<D!$G9p!BGAJGM=E!FKGTUD@GE!

KGHG<GE!e7:7`c!XM,f!B=>!KG!E=><G!ZKU=ADEBD>@D!<D!U>;I>!G!$G9p![KU=aPX%"!eP!�"f!m7Q9n!F=A!

;>BUSGB;I>!G!PQt$!F=A!P`!M;>U@=E8!%!B=>@;>UGB;I>!KGHGM=E!KGE!FKGTUD@GE!ec``Jk!7`!M;>U@=E!

G!99!t$f!C! KGE!ADEUEFD><;M=E!D>!.CA=<D}El%$/!eRl7!HXHf!G!U>G!B=>BD>@AGB;I>!<D!7:7`cXM,8!

0GAG!BG<G!B=><;B;I>!ADJ;E@AGM=E!U>!B;>V@;B=!<D! KG! ZKU=ADEBD>B;G!SGEGK!<DK![KU=aPX%"!D>! KG!

EUEFD>E;I>!<D!FKGTUD@GE!<UAG>@D!7`!EDJU><=Ek! ;>@DAAUMF;M=E!SADHDMD>@D!DK!GEF;AG<=!<D!

KGE!MUDE@AGE!F=A!DK!B;@IMD@A=!FGAG!GJADJGA!KG!@A=MS;>G!e`8`^k!`89!=!`8^!+XM,f!C!ADEUM;M=E!

Page 36: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

36

DK! ADJ;E@A=k! =S@D>;D><=! _;E@=JAGMGE! BG<G! ^! EDJU><=E! <UAG>@D! 9! M;>U@=E8! #K! HD_?BUK=! =!

;>_;S;<=A! ED! GJADJI! 7! M;>U@=! G>@DE! TUD! KG! @A=MS;>G8! ,=E! ADEUK@G<=E! ED! D:FADEG>! B=M=!

F=ABD>@G\D!<D!KG!F=SKGB;I>!<DZ;>;<G!B=M=!"78!

!

!+,-#3(),)$G-%&"%K+(*"0-,%L/$-,#,%7%a5m7b%

! #HGKUGM=E! KG! @AG>EK=BGB;I>! G! MDMSAG>G! <D! v0q$! F=A! ;>MU>=ZKU=ADEBD>B;G! C!

M;BA=EB=F?G!B=>Z=BGK!m7QPn8!0KGTUD@GE!KGHG<GE!eL:7`cXM,f!G!PQ!t$!D>!E=KUB;I>!.CA=<D}E!B=>!

$G9p!e7!M"k!9!M;>f!ZUDA=>!GB@;HG<GE!B=>!@A=MS;>G!e`8`^!+XM,f!D>!FADED>B;G!<D!MD@G>=K!=!

&)9%%!e7`!�"k!7!M;>f8!%!K=E!@ADE!M;>U@=Ek!KG!EUEFD>E;I>!<D!FKGTUD@GE!ED!BD>@A;ZUJI!G!7`k```!

J!F=A!P`!EDJ!C! ED! Z;\I!B=>!9z! Z=AMGK<D_?<=a01(!F=A!7^!M;>U@=E!G! @DMFDAG@UAG!GMS;D>@D8!

,GHGM=E! KGE!FKGTUD@GE! Z;\G<GE! B=>!01(!C!FDAMDGS;K;bGM=E!B=>!`8^z!.�DD>9`a01(!B=>!7z!

1(%8!'>BUSGM=E!79!_=AGE!G!L!t$!B=>!K=E!G>@;BUDAF=E!FA;MGA;=E!!<D!B=>D\=!eG>@;av0q$f!C!!<D!

AG@I>! eG>@;ava@USUK;>Gf! e<;KUB;I>! 7X7``f8! %! B=>@;>UGB;I>k! ADEUEFD><;M=E! KGE! MUDE@AGE! D>!

`8^z!.�DD>a9`a01(!D!;>BUSGM=E!F=A!U>G!_=AG!B=>!K=E!G>@;BUDAF=E!EDBU><GA;=E!G>@;a'JW!<D!

B=>D\=! C! AG@I>! B=>\UJG<=E! G! %KD:GLcc! C! 3aZ;B=DA;@A;>Gk! ADEFDB@;HGMD>@D! e<;KUB;I>! 7X^``f8!

[;>GKMD>@Dk! M=>@GM=E! KGE! MUDE@AGE! D>! FKGBGE! C! =S@UH;M=E! KGE! ;MNJD>DE! B=>! U>!

M;BA=EB=F;=!�D;EE!,("^7`!e<;EF=>;SKD!D>! KG!U>;<G<!<D!S;=K=J?G!BDKUKGA!<DK! '>E@;@U@!0GE@DUAk!

"=>@DH;<D=f!U@;K;bG><=!U>!=S\D@;H=!<D!;>MDAE;I>!dO`8!

!

2(#J(+$3,)$G-%&"%6+DT%K(+%$-1/-("-#,E(%

! 0GAG! K=E!DE@U<;=E!<D!Z=EZ=A;KGB;I>!FAD;>BUSGM=E!FKGTUD@GE!e78c:7`cXM,f!D>!E=KUB;I>!.CA=<D}E!B=>!$G9p! e7!M"k!9!M;>f!C!GB@;HGM=E!B=>!@A=MS;>G!e`8^!+XM,f8!/=E;E!MD>=ADE!<D!@A=MS;>G!>=!;><UBD>!KG!Z=EZ=A;KGB;I>!<D!#Ag9!!"#$!)-%!m7QLk!7Q^n8!,=E!;>_;S;<=ADE!e7`!�"f!ED!GJADJGA=>!U>!M;>U@=!FADH;=!G!KG!@A=MS;>G8!,GE!FKGTUD@GE!@AG@G<GE!ZUDA=>!K;EG<GE!G!K=E!R`!C!7c`! EDJU><=E! B=>! GM=A@;JUG<=A! <DE>G@UAGK;bG>@D! eB=>! (/(f! G! R^~$! F=A! B;>B=!M;>U@=Ek! C!B=AA;M=E! KGE! MUDE@AGE! F=A! DKDB@A=Z=ADE;E! (/(a0%W#! D>! U>! JDK! <D! F=K;GBA;KGM;<G! 79z8!.AG>EZDA;M=E!G!MDMSAG>G!<D!>;@A=BDKUK=EGk!SK=TUDGM=E!D>!01(!B=>!^z!1(%X`87z!.�DD>a9`!F=A!U>G!_=AGk!D!;>BUSGM=E!B=>!K=E!G>@;aBUDAF=E!FA;MGA;=E!G>@;a#Ag7X9!e<;KUB;I>!7X^``f!C!G>@;aF#Ag7X9!e<;KUB;I>!7X7```f!F=A!79!_=AGE!G!L!~$8!,GHGM=E!D:@D>E;HGMD>@D!B=>!.�DD>a9`!`87z!D>!01(k!D!;>BUSGM=E!KG!MDMSAG>G!B=>!K=E!G>@;BUDAF=E!EDBU><GA;=E!BGSAG!G>@;aAG@I>!'3!/CDOc`! C! BGSAG! G>@;aB=>D\=! '3!/CDc``! e<;KUB;I>! 7X7^k```f! F=A! P`!M;>U@=E! G! @DMFDAG@UAG!GMS;D>@D8! ,GE! ;MNJD>DE! ZUDA=>! =S@D>;<GE! U@;K;bG><=! DEBN>DA! ;>ZAGA=\=! e)<CEEDC! '>ZAGAD<!'MGJ;>J! (CE@DMk! <D! ,;a$=Ak! ,;>B=K>k! &#f8! (D! <D@DAM;\I! DK! B=B;D>@D! F#Ag7X9! E=SAD! #Ag7X9!MD<;G>@D!G>NK;E;E!D>!DK!FA=JAGMG!'MGJD]!e&'Yk!+(%f8!

%

c>c% 81K,)*(%&"%P<T::%#(A+"%3,%,)*$F$&,&%5Z?Y4T%"-%1,)+GJ,O(#%

! !

! +@;K;bGM=E!U>G!K?>DG!<D!MGBAIZGJ=E!MUA;>=E!]QQL%87!e%.$$a.'1aOQk!+(%f!MG>@D>;<G!F=A!FGEG\D!D>!/"#"!B=>!,aJKU@GM;>G!eL!M"fk!FD>;B;K;>G! e7``!+XM,fk!DE@ADF@=M;B;>G! e7``!MJXM,f! C! EUFKDMD>@G<G! B=>! 7`! z! <D! EUDA=! ZD@GK! S=H;>=! ;>GB@;HG<=! F=A! BGK=A8! ,=E!

Page 37: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

37

MGBAIZGJ=E!ZUDA=>!FKGTUDG<=E!D!;>BUSG<=E!G!PQt$!D>!U>G!G@MIEZDAG!<D!^!z!$)9!mcQn8!0GAG!DHGKUGA! KG! GB@;H;<G<! 0)d! <DFD><;D>@D! <D! %%k! GB@;HGM=E! G! ]QQL%87! D>! FKGBGE!MUK@;F=B;KK=!e7:7`O! BVKXF=B;KK=f! B=>! ,0(! ec! MJXM,f! F=A! 7O! =! 9`! _=AGEk! D>! FADED>B;G! <D! &)9%%! =!;><=MD@GB;>G!e7!M"f8!Y=M=JD>D;bGM=E!KGE!BVKUKGE!C!ADGK;bGM=E!DK!D>EGC=!ZKU=A;MV@A;B=!<D!GMFKD:! AD<! m7QOn! e'>H;@A=JD>a"=KDBUKGA! 0A=SDEk! $%k! +(%f! FGAG! <D@DAM;>GA! KG! GB@;H;<G<!0WY(a98! #K! D>EGC=! ED! SGEG! D>! DK! <DEGAA=KK=! <D! B=K=A! D>! DK! _=M=JD>G@=! <D! MGBAIZGJ=E!GB=FKG<=! G! KG! B=>HDAE;I>! <D! 0WW9! G! 0WY9! D>! FADED>B;G! <D! !&! GMFKD:! AD<! e^`! �"k! P`!M;>U@=Efk! TUD! GB@iG! B=M=! EUE@AG@=! FDA=:;<NE;B=! C! ED! =:;<G! Z=AMG><=! DK! ZKU=AIA=Z=!ADE=AUZ;>G!e�D:s^O`>Mk!�DMs^c^>Mfk!C!!!&!%%!D:IJD>=!e7``!�"fk!TUD!FDAM;@D!<D@DAM;>GA!KG!GB@;H;<G<!<D!FDA=:;<GEGE!BUC=!EUE@AG@=!DE!%%8!! /D@DAM;>GM=E!DK!;MFGB@=!<D!&)9%%!E=SAD!KG!D:FADE;I>! <D! 0WY(a9! F=A! ;>MU>=B;@=TU?M;BG! D>! MGBAIZGJ=E! ]QQL%87! DE@;MUKG<=E! B=>!,0(X'&[�!e7c!_=AGEf!D>!FADED>B;G!=!GUED>B;G!<D!&)9%%!e7`!�"f!C!%%!e7`!�"f!U@;K;bG><=!U>!

G>@;BUDAF=!B=>@AG!0WY(a9!e(G>@G!$AUb!1;=@DB_>=K=JCk!'>Bf8!,G!@;>B;I>!>UBKDGA!ED!ADGK;bI!B=>!/%0'8!!

c>d% P$*+,)$G-%),*,30*$),%&"%::%%!! 0GAG!K=E!DE@U<;=E!<D!KG!>;@AGB;I>!D>b;MN@;BG!<DK!%%!ED!U@;K;bI!FDA=:;>;@A;@=!E;>@D@;bG<=!G!FGA@;A!<D!&G&)9!C!Y9)9!D>!U>!G@AGFG<=A!<D!ZKU\=!<D@D>;<=!mP`n8!#K!Y9)9!ADE;<UGK!ED!DK;M;>I!B=>! ">)9! C! DK! &)9

a! ADMG>D>@D! ZUD! MD>=A! G! 9`z8! ,G! B=>BD>@AGB;I>! <D! FDA=:;>;@A;@=! ED!<D@DAM;>I!DEFDB@A=Z=@=MV@A;BGMD>@D!e�P`9s78OQ!M"a7BMa7f8!,GE!E=KUB;=>DEk!D>!&G)Y!7`zk!FDAMG>DB;DA=>!DE@GSKDE!<UAG>@D!DK! @;DMF=!<D! K=E!D:FDA;MD>@=E8!0GAG!<;EM;>U;A! KG! @D>E;I>!<D!)9! ED!SGAS=@DI!D:@D>E;HGMD>@D!DK!GM=A@;JUG<=A! eZ=EZG@=!<D!E=<;=!^`!M"k!FY!Q8Lf!B=>!GAJI>k!ED!EDKKI!B=>!U>!EDF@=!<D!J=MGk!C!ED!U@;K;bI!<D!;>MD<;G@=8!/D!K=!B=>@AGA;=!U@;K;bGM=E!GM=A@;JUG<=A!DTU;K;SAG<=!D>!G;AD8!,GE!MDbBKGE!<D!ADGBB;I>!<D!79`!�,!B=>@D>?G>!0WY(a7!=!9!e9! �"fk! %%! e^``! �"f! ! C! ZD>=K! e^``! �"f! D>! B=>BD>@AGB;=>DE! HGA;GSKDE8! #K! HD_?BUK=! e&G)Y!7`zf!=!FDA=:;>;@A;@=!ED!G<M;>;E@AI!D>!ZKU\=E!<D!`87!G!7!�"XM;>!;>MD<;G@GMD>@D!<DEFUVE!<D!KG!G<;B;I>!<D!%%8!%!@;DMF=E!HGA;GSKDE!eP`!EDJU><=E!G!P!M;>U@=Ef!KG!ADGBB;I>!ED!<D@UH=!F=A!D:@AGBB;I>! =AJN>;BG! B=>! GBD@G@=! <D! D@;K=! C! ED! G>GK;bGA=>! K=E! FA=<UB@=E! K;F?<;B=E! F=A! .,$!G>GK?@;BGk! Y0,$! C! "(8! #E@U<;GM=E! KG! BGFGB;<G<! <D! 0WY(a9! <D! =:;<GA! &)9

a! G! h&)9! F=A! KG!GB@;H;<G<! 0)d! <D! KG! D>b;MG! m7QQn! ;>BUSG><=! 0WY(a9! e9! �"f! B=>! %%! e^`! �"f! D>! U>!GM=A@;JUG<=A!Z=EZG@=!<D!E=<;=!^`!M"k!FY!Q8Lk!EUFKDMD>@G<=!B=>!&G&)9!e7!G!7``!�"f8!,G!ADGBB;I>! @AG>EBUAA;I! G! @DMFDAG@UAG! GMS;D>@D! SG\=! GJ;@GB;I>8! .AG>EBUAA;<=! 7! =! ^!M;>U@=E!<D@UH;M=E! KG! ADGBB;I>! B=>! !&! SUZZDA! <D! KG! MUDE@AGk! FGAG! <D@DAM;>GA! KG! FADED>B;G! <D! Pa>;@A=@;A=E;>G!F=A!;>MU>=D>EGC=k!=! !!&!GBD@G@=!<D!D@;K=k!FGAG!DHGKUGA!KG!Z=AMGB;I>!<D!K?F;<=E!>;@AG<=E! F=A! "(! C! .,$! G>GK?@;BG8! 0GAG! DK! ;>MU>=D>EGC=! F=A! uDE@DA>! 1K=@! B=AA;M=E! KG!MUDE@AG! F=A! DKDB@A=Z=ADE;E! D>! JDK! <D! F=K;GBA;KGM;<G! e(/(a0%W#f! GK! 7`zk! @AG>EZDA;M=E! G!MDMSAG>G!<D!>;@A=BDKUK=EGk!SK=TUDGM=E!B=>!KDB_D!D>!F=KH=!e^z!D>!01(f!<UAG>@D!7!_=AG!G!@DMFDAG@UAG! GMS;D>@Dk! ;>BUSGM=E! B=>! K=E! G>@;BUDAF=E!FA;MGA;=E! G>@;a0WY(a9! C!F=K;BK=>GK!<D!B=>D\=!G>@;aPa>;@A=@;A=E;>G!<DEGAA=KKG<=!D>!>UDE@A=!KGS=AG@=A;=!m7Qcn!D>!^z!KDB_D!X!`87z!.�DD>a9`!D>!01(!<UAG>@D!c!_=AGE!G!L!t$k!KGHGM=E!D>!.�DD>a9`!`87z!D>!01(k!D!;>BUSGM=E!F=A!P`!M;>U@=E!B=>!K=E!G>@;BUDAF=E!EDBU><GA;=E!<D!BGSAG!G>@;aAG@I>!'3!/CDOc`!C!G>@;aB=>D\=!'3! /CDc``! e<;KUB;I>! 7X7^k```f8! ,GE! ;MNJD>DE! ZUDA=>! =S@D>;<GE! B=M=! FADH;GMD>@D8! ,G!

Page 38: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

38

Z=AMGB;I>! <D! FA=<UB@=E! >;@A=JD>G<=E! <DA;HG<=E! <D! %%! <UAG>@D! KG! ADGBB;I>! <D! 0WY(! D>!FADED>B;G!<D!h&)!ED!ADGK;bI!D>!B=KGS=AGB;I>!B=>!DK!/DFGA@MD>@!=Z!0_GAMGBDU@;BGK!(B;D>BDEk!&=A@_! /Gg=@G! (@G@D! +>;HDAE;@Ck! +(%8! #K! E;E@DMG! <D! ADGBB;I>! DE@UH=! B=>E@;@U;<=! F=A! 0WY(!e^```!+XMKfk! vaeLa0;A;<;Ka7a=:;<=faHa)(-)aSU@;K>;@A=>G!0)1&! e7``!M"k! EF;>! @AGFfk! C! _DM;>G!e^`!�"f!D>!GM=A@;JUG<=A!.A;E�Y$Kk!FY!c8`8!0WY(!ED!FAD;>BUSI!F=A!^!M;>!B=>!_DM;>G!G!PQ~$!C! O``! AFMk! C! KG! ADGBB;I>! ED! ;>;B;I! F=A! G<;B;I>! <DK! GJD>@D! AD<UB@=A! _;<A=TU;>=>G! e^!M"f!\U>@=! G! %%! e9! M"f8! ,G! ADGBB;I>! ED! <D@UH=! G! K=E! P`! M;>! B=>! GBD@=>;@A;K=k! C! ED! ADGK;bI! DK!G>NK;E;E!F=A!=ZZK;>D!DKDB@A=>!EF;>!ADE=>G>BD!e#(3f!GB=FKG<=!G!,$X"(8!0GAG!DHGKUGA!DK!DZDB@=!<D!&)9%%!=!

h&)!D>!KG!=:;<GB;I>!<D!%%!BG@GK;bG<G!F=A!0WY(k!ED! ;>@A=<U\=!DK!<G<=A!<D!h&)!&)$!79!e7!M"f!=!&)9%%!e7`!a!7``!�"f!G!KG!MDbBKG!<D!ADGBB;I>8!!

c>e% 6^*+,))$(-"#%(+O_-$),#%!93$OC%,-&%'E"+%! $=>E;E@D! D>! DK! GJADJG<=! <D! 989! H=KiMD>DE! <D! MD@G>=K! F=A! H=KUMD>! <D! MUDE@AG!EDJU;<=!<D!GJ;@GB;I>8!#>!DK! BGE=!<D!DE@GA! @AGSG\G><=!B=>!E?K;BG! eD\8l!FUA;Z;BGB;I>!<D!&)9%%!F=A!.,$!FADFGAG@;HGfk!ED!GJADJG!FA;MDA=!U>G!FGA@D!<D!GJUG!C!G!B=>@;>UGB;I>!ED!<D\G!ADF=EGA!B=>! DK! MD@G>=K! F=A! ^! M;>U@=E8! ,UDJ=! ED! GJADJG! 7! H=KUMD>! <D! <;BK=A=MD@G>=! C! ED! GJ;@G!H;J=A=EGMD>@D! _GE@G! =S@D>DA! U>G! E=KG! ZGED8! (;! >=! ED! =S@;D>D! U>G! E=KG! ZGEDk! ED! GJADJG>!FDTUDj=E! H=KiMD>DE! <D! MD@G>=K! _GE@G! =S@D>DAKG8! #>! BGE=! <D! EDA! >DBDEGA;=k! D>! DE@D!M=MD>@=! ED! GJADJG! U>G! BG>@;<G<! B=>=B;<G! <D! DE@N><GA! ;>@DA>=8! [;>GKMD>@D! ED! A=MFD! KG!M=>=ZGED!B=>!DK!GJADJG<=!<D!7!H=KUMD>!<D!Y9)!C! KUDJ=!=@A=!<D!<;BK=A=MD@G>=k! E;DMFAD!EDJU;<=!<D!GJ;@GB;I>!H;J=A=EG8!(D!BD>@A?ZUJG!G!c``!AFM!F=A!7`!M;>U@=E!C!ED!EDFGAG! KG!ZGED!=AJN>;BG!eKG!;>ZDA;=Af8!#>!DK!BGE=!<D!@AGSG\GA!B=>!E?K;BGk!_GC!TUD!GEDJUAGAED!TUD!KG!E?K;BG!TUD<D!D>@AD!KGE!<=E!ZGEDE!=!D>!DK!Z=><=!<DK!@US=8!!?"^,-(%%! ,=E! K?F;<=E! ED! D:@AGD>! B=>! U>G!MDbBKG! <D! _D:G>=X;E=FA=FG>=KXGBV@;B=! 7"! eP`l9`l9!HXHf!D>!U>G!ADKGB;I>!MUDE@AGlE=KHD>@D!<D!7l98^!eHXHf8!(;!DE!>DBDEGA;=k!ED!GJADJG!DK!DE@N><GA!;>@DA>=! D>! U>G! BG>@;<G<! B=>=B;<G! C! ED! GJ;@G! H;J=A=EGMD>@D8! (D! GJADJG>! 98^! FGA@DE! <D!_D:G>=!C!ED!BD>@A;ZUJG!<UAG>@D!B;>B=!M;>U@=E!G!7k^``!AFMk!FGAG!ZGB;K;@GA!KG!EDFGAGB;I>!<D!KGE!ZGEDE8!(D!@=MG!KG!ZGED!_D:G>=!eKG!EUFDA;=Af!C!KG!ZGED!GBU=EG!ED!HUDKHD!G!KGHGA!B=>!98^!FGA@DE!<D!_D:G>=8!,G!MUDE@AG!ED!DHGF=AG!C!ADEUEFD><D!D>!DK!E=KHD>@D!EDKDBB;=>G<=8!!:)"*,*(%&"%"*$3(%! (D! U@;K;bI! FGAG! FADFGAGA! MUDE@AGE! FGAG! G>NK;E;E! F=A! "(8! $=>E;E@D! D>! GJADJGA! G! KG!MUDE@AG!7!FGA@D!eHXHf!<D!GBD@G@=!<D!D@;K=!ZA?=!B=>!NB;<=!GBV@;B=!`87!z!C!DK!DE@N><GA!;>@DA>=!D>!BG>@;<G<!B=>=B;<G8!(D!EDFGAG>!KGE!ZGEDE!F=A!GJ;@GB;I>!H;J=A=EG!C!ED!@=MG!KG!ZGED!=AJN>;BG!eKG!EUFDA;=Afk!ED!DHGF=AG!C!ED!ADEUEFD><D!D>!DK!E=KHD>@D!EDKDBB;=>G<=8!! !! $UG><=!DE@U<;GM=E!KG!;>B=AF=AGB;I>!<D!&)9%%!G!FKGTUD@GEk!KG!D:@AGBB;I>!F=A!GBD@G@=!<D! D@;K=! ADEUK@I! U>! c`z! MNE! DZ;B;D>@D! D>! KG! ADBUFDAGB;I>! <DK! >;@A=GKTUD>=! <DE<D! DK!E=SAD>G<G>@Dk!B=MFGAG<=!B=>!KG!D:@AGBB;I>!F=A!_D:G>=8!

Page 39: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

39

!

d>% @6YQ;!:'<Y%n%'8Y7QY8WP%%d>S% Y0-*"#$#%&"%P<T::%

!

! ,G! E?>@DE;E! <D!&)9%%! ZUD! FUDE@G! G! FU>@=! D>! >UDE@A=! KGS=AG@=A;=! F=A! DK! /A8! %><AVE!

.A=E@B_G>EgC! mQ7n8! (D! ADGK;bG! F=A! ;>BUSGB;I>! <D! %%! B=>! >;@A;@=! <D! E=<;=! e&G&)9f! D>!

B=><;B;=>DE! NB;<GEk! TUD! ZGH=ADBD>! KG! Z=AMGB;I>! <D! h&)9! mPPk! O`k! 7^Ln8! )S@D>DM=E! U>G!

MDbBKG! ADKG@;HGMD>@D! B=MFKD\G! <D! FA=<UB@=El! <DA;HG<=E! ;E=MDA;bG<=E! e@AG>Ea%%! DE! DK!

FA;>B;FGK! FA=<UB@=! <D! KG! ADGBB;I>fk! =:;<G<=Ek! CX=! >;@A=aGKTUD>=Ek! >;@A=aGKBG>=Ek! <;a>;@A=!

GKTUD>=EXGKBG>=Ek! C!>;@A=a_;<A=:;!<DA;HG<=E! m7^Lk!7^^n8! #K!&)9%%! ED!FUA;Z;BG!G!FGA@;A!<D! KG!

D:@AGBB;I>!K;F?<;BG!<D!KG!MDbBKG!F=A!.,$!FADFGAG@;HGk!C!ED!G>GK;bG!C!BUG>@;Z;BG!F=A!,$!"(X"(!

mQ7n!U@;K;bG><=!U>!DEFDB@AIMD@A=!<D!MGEG!@A;FKD!BUG<AUF=K=!B=>!@AGMFG!<D!;=>DE!DTU;FG<=!

B=>!U>G!ZUD>@D!<D!;=>;bGB;I>!F=A!DKDB@A=EFAGC!G!FADE;I>!G@M=EZVA;BG!e5.3%0!9```k!%FFK;D<!

1;=ECE@DMEX"/(!($'#df!e[;JUAG!7`%f8!#K!%%!ED!B=>BD>@AG!C!ADEUDKHD!F=A!,$!!C!@;D>D!U>!FG@AI>!

<D! ZAGJMD>@GB;I>! BGAGB@DA?E@;B=! TUD! FDAM;@D! B=>Z;AMGA! EU! ;<D>@;<G<! D>! DK! M=<=! "3"!

eMUK@;FKD! ADGB@;=>!M=>;@=A;>Jf! E;JU;D><=! KG! FVA<;<G! >DU@AG! <DK! JAUF=! a&)9! eBCD! PLcXP`7o!

BCD!PLcXLOf!e[;JUAG!7`1f8!0GAG!KG!BUG>@;Z;BGB;I>!B=>E@AU;M=E!BUAHGE!<D!BGK;SAGB;I>!B=M=!ED!

MUDE@AG!D>!KG!Z;JUAG!7`$8!!

!

d>S>S% % <K*$1$I,)$G-%&"3%+"-&$1$"-*(%&"%+",))$G-%

!

! ,G! E?>@DE;E! NB;<G! <D! &)9%%! @GK! B=M=! ED! <D@GKKG! D>! mQ7n! @;D>D! U>! AD><;M;D>@=! <D!

Z=AMGB;I>!<D!FA=<UB@=!MD>=A!GK!7`zk!<D!KG!BUGK!ED!=S@;D>D>!GFA=:;MG<GMD>@D!`8^!MJ!<D!

&)9%%!G!FGA@;A!<D!Q^!MJ!;>;B;GKDE!<D!%%8#+>=!<D!K=E!=S\D@;H=E!<D!DE@D!@AGSG\=!ZUD!=F@;M;bGA!

KGE!B=><;B;=>DE!<D!@AGSG\=!FGAG!GUMD>@GA!DK!AD><;M;D>@=!<D!Z=AMGB;I>!<D!&)9%%8!.GK!B=M=!

ED!<;EBU@;I!D>!KG!;>@A=<UBB;I>k!DK!h&)9!DE!U>!;>;B;G<=A!;MF=A@G>@D!<D!KG!=:;<GB;I>!K;F?<;BGk!C!KG!

FADHGKD>B;G!<D! KGE!ADGBB;=>DE!<D!>;@A=JD>GB;I>!F=A!E=SAD! KGE!<D!=:;<GB;I>!<D! K=E!AG<;BGKDE!

K;F?<;B=E! Z=AMG<=E! <DFD><D! FA;>B;FGKMD>@D! <D! KG! B=>BD>@AGB;I>! <D! )9! D>! DK! MD<;=! <D!

ADGBB;I>! m7^^k! 7QRn8! #>! DE@D! ED>@;<=! DK! ! FA;MDA! BGMS;=! D>! DK! FA=@=B=K=! <D! E?>@DE;E! ZUD!

<;EM;>U;A!KG!@D>E;I>!<D!)9!D>!DK!MD<;=!<D!ADGBB;I>8!0GAG!DKK=!SGAS=@DGM=E!KG!MDbBKG!<D!%%!C!

&)9a!D:@D>EGMD>@D!B=>!%AJI>k!C! KG!EDKKGM=E!B=>!U>!EDF@=!<D!J=MG!FADH;=!G!KG!G<;B;I>!<DK!

NB;<=8! .GMS;V>! DHGKUGM=E! DK! DZDB@=! <DK! DEBGKG<=! e:9k! :P! C! :Lfk! <DK! E=KHD>@D! <D! ADGBB;I>!

U@;K;bG<=!e_D:G>=!HE8!GBD@=>;@A;K=fk!C!<DK!NB;<=!DMFKDG<=!eNB;<=!BK=A_?<A;B=!B=>BD>@AG<=!HE8!

NB;<=!EUKZiA;B=!B=>BD>@AG<=f8!$UG><=!DEBGKGM=E!GK!<=SKD!eDK!H=KUMD>!9:k!M=KDE!<D!ADGB@;H=E!

9:k! C! @;DMF=! <D! ADGBB;I>! 9:f! C! U@;K;bGM=E! Y9()L! B=>BD>@AG<=! B=M=! NB;<=k! K=JAGM=E!

GUMD>@GA!^!HDBDE!KG!DZ;B;D>B;G!<D!>;@AGB;I>!<D!%%!e[;JUAG!77f8!%<DMNEk!FUE;M=E!G!FU>@=!U>G!

BA=MG@=JAGZ?G!D>!B=KUM>G!U@;K;bG><=!E?K;BG!B=M=!ZGED!DE@GB;=>GA;G!FGAG!KG!FUA;Z;BGB;I>!<D!!

Page 40: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

40

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

XIC of -MRM (5 pairs): 348,200/46,100 Da from Sample 4 (ii 1/100) of Data220... Max. 1170,0 cps.

0,5 1,0 1,5 2,0 2,5 3,0 3,5 4,0 4,5Time, min

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

1100

1170

In

te

ns

it

y, c

ps

1,45

3,51

2,702,06 4,932,921,730,10 2,622,370,64 1,96 4,073,34

! A

!B

!C

2$O/+,% SU>% :-_3$#$#% K(+% NY% &"% P<T::>% a:b! #K! B=>@A=K! <D! FUADbG! GE?! B=M=! KG! BUG>@;Z;BGB;I>! <DK! &)9%%! ED!ADGK;bG>!F=A!ESI-MS y LC- ESI-MS/MS utilizando un QTRAP2000.%a9b!#K!&)9%%!ED!<D@DB@G!F=A!,$!"(X"(!D>!DK!M=<=!<D! ;=>;bGB;I>!>DJG@;H=!F=A!"3"!E;JU;D><=! KG!FVA<;<G!>DU@AG!<DK!JAUF=!>;@A=! eBCD!PLcXP`7f8! '>EDA@=l!FGAG!B=>Z;AMGA!KG!;<D>@;<G<!<DK!FA=<UB@=!ED!G>GK;bG!D>!DK!M=<=!#0'!eD>_G>BD<!FA=<UB@!;=>f!EDKDBB;=>G><=!DK!;I>! FGAD>@GK! eBCD! PLcf! FGAG! =S@D>DA! DK! FG@AI>! <D! ZAGJMD>@GB;I>! BGAGB@DA?E@;B=! <D! &)9%%k! <=><D! E;DMFAD!DE@N>! FADED>@DE! K=E! ZAGJMD>@=E# BCD! P`7! C! 9^Q8! a7b! #K! FA=<UB@=! FUA=! ED! BUG>@;Z;BG! U@;K;bG><=! %%EF! eBCD!P77X9OQf! B=M=! DE@N><GA! ;>@DA>=! C! %%! B=M=! DE@N><GA! D:@DA>=! eBCD# P`PX9^Rf8! 0GAG! B=>E@AU;A! KG! BUAHG! <D!BGK;SAGB;I>k! ED! Z;\G! KG! B=>BD>@AGB;I>!<D!DE@N><GA! ;>@DA>=!C! ED!U@;K;bG>! B=>BD>@AGB;=>DE! BADB;D>@DE!<D!%%8! (D!JAGZ;BG! KG! ADKGB;I>! <D! NADGE! FGAG! KGE! @AG>E;B;=>DE! G<DBUG<GE! D>! ZU>B;I>! <D! KG! ADKGB;I>! <D! B=>BD>@AGB;I>!B=AADEF=><;D>@Dk!C!ED!;>@AGF=KG>!KGE!NADGE!=S@D>;<GE!FGAG!DK!&)9%%!eBCD!PLcXP`7f8!!

Page 41: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

41

&)9%%8!,GE!<;MD>E;=>DE!<D!KG!B=KUM>G!U@;K;bG<G!e9O!:!P!

BMf! FDAM;@D>! U>G! JAG>! E;DMSAG! <D! FA=<UB@=! <D!

ADGBB;I>!e_GE@G!7!J!GFA=:;MG<GMD>@Dfk!F=A!K=!BUGK!ZUD!

B=>HD>;D>@D!ADGK;bGA!C!\U>@GA!HGA;GE!E?>@DE;E!D>!FGAGKDK=!

B=>! KGE!B=><;B;=>DE!=F@;M;bG<GE8!#K!UE=!<D! KG!B=KUM>G!

FDAM;@;I! FUA;Z;BGA! @=<=! DK! FA=<UB@=! =S@D>;<=! D>! U>G!

E=KG!;>E@G>B;G!C!<D!MG>DAG!MUC!DB=>IM;BG!ADEFDB@=!GK!

UE=! <D! .,$! FADFGAG@;HG8! 0=A! =@AG! FGA@Dk! DE@GM=E!

F=>;D><=! G! FU>@=! KG! >;@AGB;I>! <D! %%! F=A!

>;@A=EDKD>GB;I>k! U>! MV@=<=! TUD! _G! E;<=! ADF=A@G<=!

FADH;GMD>@D! D>! KG! E?>@DE;E! <D! >;@A=GKTUD>=Ek! C! TUD!

FADED>@G! KG! HD>@G\G! <D!=S@D>DA! U>! ;EIMDA=!DEFDB?Z;B=!

B=>! U>! GK@=! AD><;M;D>@=! mc`n8! ,=E! D:FDA;MD>@=E! G!

BGAJ=!<D!KG!/AG8!2;AJ;>;G!,IFDb!_G>!FDAM;@;<=!E;>@D@;bGA!

U>G! MDbBKG! <DK! ;EIMDA=! >;@A=GKTUD>=! Oa&)9%%! C! <DK!

>;@A=GKBG>=!^a&)9%%8!

!

! "#$!%#&!'()*+#&!+$,-#./'+.#&!0$!0%!1-#,#'#%#!.0!

&2$,0&+&! .0! 34566! (/)0$,()#&! 0%! -0$.+)+0$,#! 7!

80'0&! 9! #*,/8+)#&! (1-#:+)(.()0$,0! 5;;! )<! .0!

34566! =80-&/&! %#&! ;>7)<! #*,0$+.#&! '#$! 0%! 1-#,#'#%#!

($,0-+#-?>!!

!

d>S>T% %%%%%%%%%:-_3$#$#% E% K/+$J$),)$G-% &"% $#G1"+(#%

K(#$)$(-,3"#%&"%P<T::%

!

! #K!&)9%%!=S@D>;<=!G!FGA@;A!<D!KG!FUA;Z;BGB;I>!<D!

KG!MDbBKG!<D!ADGBB;I>!DE@N!B=>E@;@U?<=!F=A!U>G!MDbBKG!

<D! ;EIMDA=E!F=E;B;=>GKDEk!<=><D!DK!JAUF=! a&)9!FUD<D!

U>;AED! G! <;ZDAD>@DE! BD>@A=E! ;>EG@UAG<=E8! 3DF=A@GM=E! FADH;GMD>@D! KG! EDFGAGB;I>! F=A! 30a

Y0,$! <D! P! F;B=Ek! <=><D! ED! ADEUDKHD>! 9! ;EIMDA=E! eRa! C! 7La!&)9%%fk!M;D>@AGE! TUD! K=E! <=E!

ADE@G>@DE!B=aDKUCD>!e79a!C!7^a!&)9%%f!mQ7nk!D>!U>!MV@=<=!TUD!DE!SUD>=!<DE<D!DK!FU>@=!<D!

H;E@G!G>GK?@;B=!FDA=!MUC!;>DZ;BGb!FGAG!KG!FUA;Z;BGB;I>!C!B=>BD>@AGB;I>!<D!;EIMDA=E8!0=A!@G>@=!

>=E!FKG>@DGM=E!B=M=!=S\D@;H=!G>GK;bGA!C!FUA;Z;BGA!KG!MDbBKG!;E=MVA;BG!=S@D>;<G!G!FGA@;A!<DK!

>UDH=!FA=@=B=K=!<D!E?>@DE;E!D>!MD<;=!NB;<=8##

#

! !

2$O/+,% SS>% <K*$1$I,)$G-% &"3%

+"-&$1$"-*(% &"% #0-*"#$#% &"% P<T::>! #K!

&)9%%! ED! E;>@D@;bG! G! FGA@;A! <D! %%! D>!

_D:G>=! B=>! &)9a! D>! MD<;=! NB;<=8! (D!

Z=AMG>! U>G! EDA;D! <D! FA=<UB@=E!

=:;<G<=E! C! >;@AG<=Ek! <D! <=><D! ED!

FUA;Z;BG! F=E@DA;=AMD>@D! DK! &)9%%! F=A!

.,$! =! BA=MG@=JAGZ?G! D>! B=KUM>G8! 0GAG!

GUMD>@GA!DK!AD><;M;D>@=!<D!KG!ADGBB;I>!

DHGKUGM=E! F=A! .,$! G>GK?@;BG! DK! DZDB@=!

<Dl!DKK!DEBGKG<=!e:7k!:9!C!:Pfk!DK!E=KHD>@D!

<D! ADGBB;I>! e_D:G>=! $1,! GBD@=>;@A;K=fk! C!

DK! NB;<=! U@;K;bG<=! eY$K! O&! $1,! NB;<=!

EUKZiA;B=!B=>BD>@AG<=f8!

! !"#$%&

Page 42: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

42

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

*

(M-Li-HNO2)+

(M-Li)+

! A !B

!

1

!

*

!C

!

2

2$O/+,% ST>% :-_3$#$#% E% K/+$J$),)$G-% &"% $#G1"+(#% K(#$)$(-,3"#% &"% P<T::>! a:b! ,=E! ;EIMDA=E! F=E;B;=>GKDE! <D!

&)9%%! ED! ADEUDKHD>! FGAB;GKMD>@D! F=A! Y0,$! B=>! <D@DBB;I>! D>! DK! +2! e9QL! >Mf8! 0GAG! EU! FUA;Z;BGB;I>! ED!

B=KDB@GA=>!KGE!SG><GE!7!C!9!C!ED!D:@AG\DA=>!D>!_D:G>=l;E=FA=FG>=KlGBV@;B=!eP`l9`l9f8!a9b!,GE!MUDE@AGE!ED!ADa

;>CDB@GA=>!D>!KGE!M;EMGE!B=><;B;=>DE!FGAG!B=>Z;AMGA!KG!FUADbG8!a7b!$=>Z;AMGM=E!KG!;<D>@;<G<!<D!KGE!MUDE@AGE!

C! <D@DAM;>GM=E! KG! F=E;B;I>! <DK! JAUF=! �&)9! F=A! DE@U<;=E! <D! "(X"(! B=>! ,;9p! D>! DK! M=<=! <D! ;=>;bGB;I>!

F=E;@;HG8!

Page 43: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

43

#K!G>NK;E;E!<D!&)9%%!F=A!Y0,$!D>!ZGED!ADHDAEG!e30aY0,$f!B=>!<D@DBB;I>!G!9QL!>M!FDAM;@;I!

<;E@;>JU;A!BUG@A=!F;B=E!FGAB;GKMD>@D!ADEUDK@=Ek!>=!FADED>@DE!D>!DK!SKG>B=!<D!MD@G>=K!e[;JUAG!

79%f8!$=KDB@GM=E!K=E!F;B=E!G!KG!EGK;<G!<DK!Y0,$!ADGK;bG><=!U>G!D:@AGBB;I>!B=>!_D:G>=k!B=M=!

ED!<DEBA;SD!D>! KG! EDBB;I>!D:FDA;MD>@GK8!$UG><=! K=E!F;B=E! B=KDB@G<=E! ZUDA=>! ADa;>CDB@G<=E!

=SEDAHGM=E!TUD!EIK=!FU<;M=E!G;EKGA!G!KGE!DEFDB;DE!7!C!9!e[;JUAG!791fk!M;D>@AGE!TUD!K=E!=@A=E!

F;B=E! >=! FU<;DA=>! ADE=KHDAED8! 0GAG! ;<D>@;Z;BGA! K=E! ;EIMDA=E! FADED>@DE! G>GK;bGM=E! KGE!

MUDE@AGE! F=A! "(! ZAGJMD>@G><=! B=>! K;@;=k! TUD! SK=TUDG! KG! BGAJG! F=E;@;HG! D>! DK! D:@ADM=!

BGAS=:;K=! C! <D@DAM;>G! TUD! K=E! ;=>DE! ED! ZAGJMD>@D>! G! @AGHDE! <DK! <=SKD! D>KGBD! <=><D! ED!

D>BUD>@AG! DK! JAUF=! a&)9k! E;D><=! ZNB;K! FAD<DB;A! KG! BCD! FGAG! K=E! <;ZDAD>@DE! ZAGJMD>@=E!

DEFDAG<=E!<D! GBUDA<=!G! KGE! F=E;B;=>DE!TUD!FUD<D!G<=F@GA! DK! a&)9! D>! KG! BG<D>G! mQ7n8! ,GE!

DEFDB;DE! 7! C! 9! B=AADEF=><;DA=>! G! K=E! ;EIMDA=E! 77a! C! 7La&)9%%k! ADEFDB@;HGMD>@D! e[;JUAG!

79$f!eKG!B=MF=E;B;I>!<D!KG!MDbBKG!D>@DAG!<D!&)9%%!ZUD!<D!Ok!ck!Rk!77!C!7La&)9%%f8!.AGE!DK!

G>NK;E;E!G>GK?@;B=!<D!KG!MDbBKG!;E=MVA;BGk!FUA;Z;BGM=E!K=E!;EIMDA=E!77!C!7La&)9%%!U@;K;bG><=!

U>G!B=KUM>G!$7c!EDM;aFADFGAG@;HGk!B=M=!ED!<D@GKKG!D>!KG!MD@=<=K=J?G8!!

!

! 6!10&(-!.0!@(*0-!10-.+.#!)/'@(!)/0&,-(!./-($,0!%(&!0,(1(&!.0!%(!1/-+A+'('+B$!.0!

%#&! +&B)0-#&! =+$90''+B$C! .+%/'+B$! 0$! %(! '#%/)$(C! '#%0''+B$! (! %(! &(%+.(! .0! %(! '#%/)$(! 0$!

&#%80$,0&!1(-(!%(!0:,-(''+B$!#-<D$+'(C!08(1#-('+B$C!0,'?!#*,/8+)#&!5CE!)<!.0!FFG34566!9!

HCI!)<!.0!FHG34566!1/-#&>!"#$,(-!'#$!+&B)0-#&!1#&+'+#$(%0&!.0!34566!0$!0&,(.#!1/-#!0&!

A/$.()0$,(%! 1(-(! 08(%/(-! &+! %#&! 0A0',#&! *+#%B<+'#&! .0&'-+1,#&! 1(-(! 0%! 34566! &#$!

'(-(',0-2&,+'#&!.0!/$!+&B)0-#!0$!1(-,+'/%(->!

!

d>T%% % N(&/3,)$G-%&"%3,%"-I$1,%5Z?Y%K(+%P<T::%%

%

! #K!%%!DE!DK!FADBUAE=Ak!F=A!H?GE!D>b;MN@;BGE!C!>=!D>b;MN@;BGEk!<D!U>G!HGA;G<G!ZGM;K;G!<D!

K?F;<=E!S;=GB@;H=E!<D!JAG>!;MF=A@G>B;G!Z;E;=KIJ;BG!B=M=!KGE!0WEk!@A=MS=:G>=Ek!KDUB=@A;D>=E!=!

MD<;G<=ADE!<D!DE@AVE!=:;<G@;H=!B=M=!K=E![9a;E=FA=E@G>=E!e[;JUAG!Of8!$UG><=!ED!>;@AGk!DK!%%!

G<TU;DAD! U>G! EDA;D! <D! GB@;H;<G<DE! S;=KIJ;BGE! TUD! K=! F=E;B;=>G>! B=M=! U>! F=@D>B;GK!

M=<UKG<=A!AD<=:!!"#$!$%8!,=E!>;@A=GKTUD>=E!ED!Z=AMG>!D><IJD>GMD>@D!mPQk!Pck!cOk!7c`nk!C!

MNE!ADB;D>@DMD>@D!ED!<;EBU@D!C!FA=CDB@G!EU!F=@D>B;GK!ZGAMGB=KIJ;B=!m9Qn8!#>!DE@D!B=>@D:@=!

DAG! ;MF=A@G>@D! DE@U<;GA! C! <D@DAM;>GA! E;! DK! &)9%%! DAG! BGFGb! <D! M=<;Z;BGA! KGE! H?GE! <D!

EDjGK;bGB;I>!_GS;@UGKDE!<DK!%%k!K=!BUGK!F=<A?G!ADFADED>@GA!U>!MDBG>;EM=!<D!!M=<UKGB;I>!<D!

K=E!FA=BDE=E! ;>ZKGMG@=A;=E!H;>BUKG<=E!GK!%%8!#KDJ;M=E!B=M=!BD>@A=!<D!DE@U<;=!G! KG!D>b;MG!

S;aZU>B;=>GK!0WY(k!TUD!BG@GK;bG!DK!FGE=! K;M;@G>@D!D>! KG!E?>@DE;E!<D!FA=E@G>=;<DE!G!FGA@;A!<D!

%%k! ED! D:FADEG! D>! @=<=E! K=E! @D\;<=Ek! DE! U>! SKG>B=! ZGAMGB=KIJ;B=! <D! JAG>! ADKDHG>B;G! D>! DK!

@AG@GM;D>@=!<D!MUB_GE!FG@=K=J?GEk!C!DE!DK!FA;>B;FGK!<DE@;>=!<DK!%%!TUD!DE!K;SDAG<=!GK!B;@=E=K!

BDKUKGA!F=A!GBB;I>!<D!KG!0,%98!

!

Page 44: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

44

d>T>S% 7,+,)*"+$I,)$G-%)$-B*$),%&"%3,%$-C$A$)$G-%&"%5Z?Y%K(+%P<T::%

%

d>T>S>S% '"*"+1$-,)$G-%&"%3,#%,)*$F$&,&"#%5<g%E%7<g%

!

! ,G!U>;I>!KNS;K!<DK!JAUF=!_DM=!U>;<=!>=!B=HGKD>@DMD>@D!G!0WY(!ED!F;DA<D!<UAG>@D!KG!

FUA;Z;BGB;I>!<D!KG!D>b;MGk!F=A!K=!BUGK!FGAG!K=E!D:FDA;MD>@=E!!"#$!)-%!B=>!0WY(a7!C!9!KG!GF=a

FA=@D?>G! ZUD! ADB=>E@;@U?<G! B=>! [DPpa00'dk! B=M=! ED! <D@GKKG! D>! KG! EDBB;I>! D:FDA;MD>@GK8!

#E@U<;GM=E! KG! GB@;H;<G<! 0)d! F=A! DK! D>EGC=! <DK! ."0/k! GMFK;GMD>@D! ADZDAD>B;G<=! D>! KG!

K;@DAG@UAG! m7c7n8! #>! DK! D>EGC=! ED! UEG! DK! BA=MIZ=A=! ."0/k! TUD! GB@iG! B=M=! B=aEUE@AG@=!

AD<UB@=A! BD<;D><=! DKDB@A=>DE! <UAG>@D! KG! ADJD>DAGB;I>! <DK! _DM=! G! EU! Z=AMG! GB@;HG! e[DPpa

2$O/+,% SV>%'"*"+1$-,)$G-% &"% 3,% ,)*$F$&,&% "-I$1_*$),% &"% 5Z?Y>% ,G! GB@;H;<G<! D>b;MN@;BG! D>! DE@D! @AGSG\=! ED!

<D@DAM;>I!F=A!a:b!DK!D>EGC=!<DK!."0/!eGB@;H;<G<!0)dfk!a9b!=:;MD@A?G!eGB@;H;<G<!$)dfk!C!a7b!"(!E;JU;D><=!KG!

Z=AMGB;I>!<DK!FA=<UB@=!<D!<DBG;M;D>@=!<D!0WY9k!KG!FA=E@JKG><;>G!0W#9!eGB@;H;<G<!$)df8!

!B B

! A

Page 45: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

45

00'df! e[;JUAG! Rf8! ,G! =:;<GB;I>! <DK! ."0/! ED!

GB=MFGjG! <D! U>! BGMS;=! <D! B=K=A! TUD! ED!

ADJ;E@AG!G!O77>M!F=A!DEFDB@A=Z=@=MD@A?G!D>!

DK!H;E;SKD! e[;JUAG!7P%f8!,G!GB@;H;<G<!$)d!ZUD!

DE@U<;G<G! F=A! =:;MD@A?Gk! K=! BUGK! @GMS;V>!

ADFADED>@G!U>!MV@=<=!DE@N><GAk! E;! S;D>!>=!

DE! DK! i>;B=k! D>! DK! DE@U<;=! <D! KG! GB@;H;<G<!

D>b;MN@;BG! <D! 0WY(! e[;JUAG! 7P1f8!

$=MFKDMD>@GM=E! DE@=E! FA=@=B=K=E! D>! DK!

MGAB=! <D! U>G! FGEG>@?G! <D! ;>HDE@;JGB;I>! D>!

DK! KGS=AG@=A;=! <DK! /A8! ,8]8! "GA>D@@!

e2G><DAS;K@! '>E@;@U@D! =Z! $_DM;BGK! 1;=K=JC8!

+>;HDAE;@C! =Z! 2G><DAS;K@! a! "D<;BGK! (B_==Kk!

.&k! ##++fk! TUD! FDAM;@;I! F=>DA! G! FU>@=! D>!

>UDE@A=! KGS=AG@=A;=! KG! <D@DAM;>GB;I>! <D! KG!

GB@;H;<G<! $)d! F=A! ,$! "(X"(k! E;JU;D><=! KG!

Z=AMGB;I>! <D! 0W#9! eFA=<UB@=! DE@GSKD! <DK!

<DBG;M;D>@=! D>! MD<;=! GBU=E=! <D! 0WY9f8!

/DS;<=! G! KG! FADED>B;G! <D! U>! JAUF=! NB;<=! a

$))Y!eBGAS=:?K;B=f!K;SAD!D>!0W#9k!DK!;I>!m"a

Yna! TUD! ED! =S@;D>D! F=A! #('! DE! MUC!

GSU><G>@D! m7Q`n8! (U! ZAGJMD>@GB;I>!

BGAGB@DA?E@;BG!FA=<UBD!DK! ;I>!<DA;HG<=!<D! KG!

FVA<;<G! <D! <=E! M=KVBUKGE! <D! GJUG! C! U>G!

M=KVBUKG! <D! a$)9! eBCD! P^7X9Q7f! e[;JUAG!

7P$f8!0=A!DE@G! AGbI>k!U>G!<D! KGE!FA;>B;FGKDE!

HD>@G\GE! <D! DE@D! FA=@=B=K=! ZUD! U>! JAG>!

GUMD>@=!D>!KG!ED>E;S;K;<G<!ADEFDB@=!GK!UE=!<D!=:;MD@A?G!D>!KG!<D@DAM;>GB;I>!<D!KG!GB@;H;<G<!

$)dk!C!DE@=!EDAN!ADKDHG>@D!FGAG!>UDE@A=!@AGSG\=k!B=M=!ED!HDAN!MNE!G<DKG>@D8!!

! ,G! Z;JUAG! 7L!MUDE@AG! DK! DETUDMG!JD>DAGK! <D! ADGBB;=>DE! BG@GK;bG<GE!F=A! 0WY(! C! K=E!

;>@DAMD<;GA;=E! ;>H=KUBAG<=E! D>! K=E! MV@=<=E! <D! <D@DAM;>GB;I>! <D! GB@;H;<G<! D>b;MN@;BG!

U@;K;bG<=E!F=A!>=E=@A=E8!!

!

d>T>S>T%%6J")*(%&"%3,%&(#$#%

!

! 0A;MDA=! DHGKUGM=E! KG! M=<UKGB;I>! <D! KG! GB@;H;<G<! D>b;MN@;BG! D>! ZU>B;I>! <D! KG!

B=>BD>@AGB;I>8!J%!34566!+$@+*+B!%(!(',+8+.(.!K4L!0$!()*(&!+&#A#-)(&!.0!%(!0$M+)(!e[;JUAG!

7^%f8!,G!i>;BG!ADZDAD>B;G!D>!KG!K;@DAG@UAG!G!U>!;>_;S;<=A!<D!KG!GB@;H;<G<!0)d!D>!0WY(!DE!FGAG!

2$O/+,% Sc>% '"*"+1$-,)$G-% &"% 3,% ,)*$F$&,&%

"-I$1_*$),% &"% 5Z?Y>% #K! B=>EUM=! <D! )9! DE! U>G!

MD<;<G! <;ADB@G! <D! KG! GB@;H;<G<! $)dk! M;D>@AGE!

TUD! DK! ."0/! DE! U>G! MD<;<G! ;><;ADB@G! <D! KG!

GB@;H;<G<! 0)d! CG! TUD! DK! ."0/! GB@iG! B=M=! B=a

EUE@AG@=! AD<UB@=A! BD<;D><=! DKDB@A=>DE! G! K=E!

B=MFUDE@=E! '! C! ''! <UAG>@D! KG! ADJD>DAGB;I>! <DK!

_DM=!ZVAA;B=k!C!=:;<N><=ED!G!U>!B=MFUDE@=!GbUK!

B=>! MN:;M=! <D! GSE=ASG>B;G! G! O77>M8! ,G!

Z=AMGB;I>!<D!0W#9!DE!U>G!MD<;<G!;><;ADB@G!<D!KG!

GB@;H;<G<! $)dk! TUD! FA=F=AB;=>G! MUB_G! MGC=A!

ED>E;S;K;<G<!ADEFDB@=!G!KG!=:;MD@A?G8!

Page 46: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

46

DK!ADEHDAG@A=Kk!U>!FA=<UB@=!>G@UAGK!<D!=A;JD>!HDJD@GK!TUD!GB@iG!B=M=!B=aEUE@AG@=!AD<UB@=A!

<UAG>@D! DK! B;BK=! BG@GK?@;B=! <D! KG! GB@;H;<G<! 0)d! e<D! 0WY(a7fk! <G><=! KUJGA! G! U>G! Z=AMG! >=!

FA=<UB@;HG! <D! KG! D>b;MG! m7c9n8! ,=E! ;>_;S;<=ADE! <D! GFK;BGB;I>! BK?>;BG! e%'&#(! D! ;>_;S;<=ADE!

DEFDB?Z;B=E! <D! 0WY(a9f! ;>@DAGBB;=>G>! B=>! 0WY(! D>! DK! E;@;=! GB@;H=! $)dk! <;EM;>UCD><=! DK!

B=>EUM=!<D!)9! E;>!GZDB@GA! KG!GB@;H;<G<!0)d! m7L`n8!#K!&)9%%!<;EM;>UCI!DK! B=>EUM=!<D!)9!

EDKDB@;HGMD>@D!D>!0WY(a7k!BUG><=!DHGKUGM=E!KG!GB@;H;<G<!$)d!F=A!=:;MD@A?G!e[;JUAG!7^1f8!

#E@=! ZUD! <;Z?B;K! <D! B=MFAD><DA! <G<=! TUD! KG! GB@;H;<G<! 0)d! DE! BA?@;BG! FGAG! <GA! ;>;B;=! G! KG!

GB@;H;<G<!$)d!C!FGADB?G!F=B=!FA=SGSKD!TUD!GZDB@GA!G!KG!FA;MDAG!>=!@UH;DAG!DZDB@=E!E=SAD!KG!

! A

!B

!C

2$O/+,%Sd>%6J")*(%&"%3,%&(#$#%&"%P<T::%#(A+"%3,%,)*$F$&,&%"-I$1_*$),%&"%5Z?Y%S%E%T%a:b!'>_;S;B;I>!<=E;Ea

<DFD><;D>@D!<D!KG!GB@;H;<G<!0)d!<D@DAM;>G<G!F=A!DK!D>EGC=!<DK!."0/8!0WY(a9!ED!MUDE@AG!D>!DK! ;>EDA@=8!

a9b!'>_;S;B;I>!<=E;E!<DFD><;D>@D!<D!KG!GB@;H;<G<!$)d!<D@DAM;>G<G!F=A!=:;MD@A?G8!0WY(a9!ED!MUDE@AG!D>!DK!

;>EDA@=8!a7b!'>_;S;B;I>!<D!KG!GB@;H;<G<!$)d!<D!0WY(a9!F=A!&)9%%!e7`!�"f!<D@DAM;>G<G!F=A!,$!"(X"(8%,=E!

ADEUK@G<=E!B=AADEF=><D>!G!K=E!FA=MD<;=E!!!(8#8k!"sPk!<D!D:FDA;MD>@=E!F=A!@A;FK;BG<=8%

Page 47: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

47

EDJU><G8!,=E!<;ZDAD>@DE!ADTUDA;M;D>@=E!<D!EUE@AG@=!FDA=:;<NE;B=!e9`!>"!FGAG!0WY(a7!HE8!9!

>"!FGAG!0WY(a9!FGAG!Y9)9f!_GBD>!G!0WY(a7!MNE!EUEBDF@;SKD!G!K=E!;>_;S;<=ADE!FDA=:;<NE;B=E!

m7cPnk! F=A! K=! BUGK! DE! F=E;SKD! TUD! KG! GB@;H;<G<! $)d! <D! 0WY(a9! EIK=! ZUDAG! ED>E;SKD! G!

B=>BD>@AGB;=>DE!MGC=ADE!<D!;>_;S;<=A!0)d8!%K@DA>G@;HGMD>@Dk!DE!F=E;SKD!TUD!DK!&)9%%!>=!

GZDB@D! <;ADB@GMD>@D! KG! =:;JD>GB;I>! <D! %%k! E;>=! TUD! KG! ;>_;S;B;I>! <D! KG! GB@;H;<G<! $)d!

=SEDAHG<G! FGAG! KG! ;E=Z=AMG! B=>E@;@U@;HG! ADEF=><G! D:BKUE;HGMD>@D! G! KG! ;>_;S;B;I>! <D! KG!

GB@;H;<G<!0)d8!#>!DE@D!BGE=!U>!MDBG>;EM=!<D!;>_;S;B;I>!<;ZDAD>@D!=!U>G!F=@D>B;G!<DE;JUGK!

<DK!&)9%%!_GB;G!KGE!;E=Z=AMGE!7!C!9!<D!0WY(!F=<A?G!D:FK;BGA!TUD!DK!>;@A=GKTUD>=!>=!@D>JG!

DZDB@=E!E=SAD!KG!GB@;H;<G<!$)d!<D!0WY(a98!N(!(',+8+.(.!0$M+)D,+'(!,#,(%!=.0,0-)+$(.(!1#-!

N"!OPQOP?C!)#&,-B! R/0! 0%! 34566! +$@+*0! %(! A#-)('+B$! .0! KSJ5! 0$! ()*(&! +&#A#-)(&! .0!

KSTP!=U+</-(!F7"?>!!

!

! .=<=E! K=E! D>EGC=E! D>! DE@D! @AGSG\=! ZUDA=>! ADGK;bG<=E! U@;K;bG><=!MUDE@AGE! FUAGE! <D!

&)9%%!B=MFUDE@GE!F=A!U>G!MDbBKG!<D!;EIMDA=E!F=E;B;=>GKDE8!$UG><=!DHGKUGM=E!DK!DZDB@=!

<D!;EIMDA=E!FUA=E!<D!&)9%%!E=SAD!KG!GB@;H;<G<!0)d!=SEDAHGM=E!U>G!;>_;S;B;I>!<DK!P`!GK!^`!

zk!B=MFGAGSKD!G! KG! ;>_;S;B;I>!<G<G!F=A! KG!MDbBKG! ;E=MVA;BG! e[;JUAG!7Ofk!M=E@AG><=!TUD! KG!

;>_;S;B;I>! <D! 0WY(! DE! ;><DFD><;D>@D! <D! KG! F=E;B;I>! TUD! =BUFG! DK! a&)9! D>! KG! BG<D>G!

_;<A=BGAS=>G<G! <DK! ;>_;S;<=A8! 4,-#&! $+,-#(%R/0$#&! =345N6! 9! 34546?! A/0-#$! 08(%/(.#&C!

10-#!$#!,/8+0-#$!$+$<V$!0A0',#!&#*-0!%(!(',+8+.(.!K4L!.0!KSTPGF!#!5C!)#&,-($.#!R/0!%(!

+$@+*+'+B$!.0!%(!0$M+)(!$#!0&!<0$W-+'(!(!%#&!$+,-#(%R/0$#&!&+$#!0&10'2A+'(!1(-(!0%!34566>!

2$O/+,%Se>%6J")*(%&"%3(#%$#G1"+(#%K(#$)$(-,3"#%&"%P<T::%#(A+"%3,%,)*$F$&,&%5<g>%,G!MDbBKG!<D!&)9%%!TUD!

U@;K;bGM=E! D>! DE@D! @AGSG\=! DE@N! B=MFUDE@G! F=A! U>G!MDbBKG! <D! ;EIMDA=E! F=E;B;=>GKDE8! %TU?! FUA;Z;BGM=E! K=E!

;EIMDA=E!<D! KG!MDbBKG!F=A!Y0,$!C!DHGKUGM=E!EU!DZDB@=!E=SAD! KG!GB@;H;<G<!0)d!<D!0WY(8!#K!DZDB@=!E=SAD! KG!

GB@;H;<G<! D>b;MN@;BG! no mostró diferencias significativas entre los distintos isómeros. ,=E! ADEUK@G<=E!

B=AADEF=><D>!G!K=E!FA=MD<;=E!!!(8/8k!B=>!"sPk!<D!D:FDA;MD>@=E!F=A!@A;FK;BG<=8!

Page 48: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

48

d>T>S>V%%N(&"3(%)$-B*$)(%&"%$-C$A$)$G-%

!

"UB_=E! <D! K=E! ;>_;S;<=ADE! ADF=A@G<=E! ;>_;SD>! G! 0WY(! eGB@;H;<G<! $)df! <D! MG>DAG!

@;DMF=a<DFD><;D>@D!mRRk!7L`n8!0WY(!FAD;>BUSG<G!B=>!&)9%%!FADH;=!GK!;>;B;=!<D!KG!ADGBB;I>!

M=E@AI!U>G!GB@;H;<G<!0)d!e[;JUAG!7Q%f!C!$)d!e[;JUAG!7Q1f!AD<UB;<G!;><;BG><=!TUD!DK!@;DMF=!

DE! U>! ZGB@=A! BKGHD! D>! KG! ;>_;S;B;I>! <D! 0WY(! MD<;G<G! F=A! &)9%%8! ,G! <;EM;>UB;I>! D>! KG!

HDK=B;<G<! ;>;B;GK! <D! KG! ADGBB;I>! B=>B=M;@G>@D! GK! GUMD>@=! D>! DK! @;DMF=! <D! FAD;>BUSGB;I>!

! A

!B

2$O/+,%Sf>%6J")*(%&"3%*$"1K(%"-%3,%$-C$A$)$G-%&"%5Z?Y>!a:b!!WANZ;B=E!FA;MGA;=E!<D!KG!GB@;H;<G<!0)d!<D!0WY(a7!

e9`!>"f!FGAG!<;ZDAD>@DE!@;DMF=E!<D!FAD;>BUSGB;I>!0WY(a&)9%%k!<D@DAM;>G<G!F=A!DK!D>EGC=!<DK!."0/8!Los

resultados que se muestran son representativos de PGHS-1 y 5 µM NO2AA! a9b!%B@;H;<G<!$)d!<D!0WY(a9!D>!

FADED>B;G! <D! <=E;E! BADB;D>@DE! <D! &)9%%k! FAD;>BUSG<=! B=>! KG! D>b;MG! <UAG>@D! 7! =! 7^! M;>U@=E! FADH;=! G! KG!

<D@DAM;>GB;I>! <D! 0W#9k! F=A! "(X"(8! ,=E! ADEUK@G<=E! B=AADEF=><D>! G! K=E! FA=MD<;=E!!! (8#8k! B=>! "sPk! <D!

D:FDA;MD>@=E!F=A!<UFK;BG<=8%

Page 49: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

49

D>b;MGaEUE@AG@=!e[;JUAG!7Q%f!ADZKD\I!TUD!KG!;>@DAGBB;I>!D>b;MGa;>_;S;<=A!e#a'f!@;D>D!KG!M;EMG!

DEBGKG! @DMF=AGK! TUD! DK! ADBGMS;=! e=! @UA>=HDAf! <D! KG! D>b;MG! m7cLn8! #:;E@D>! GK! MD>=E! @ADE!

M=<DK=E!<D! ;>@DAGBB;I>!#a'! B=>!VE@G! B;>V@;BG!<D!U>;I>! KD>@G! BGAGB@DA?E@;BG!<D!U>! ;>_;S;<=A!

@;DMF=a<DFD><;D>@D! e#ETUDMG! 9f8! 0GAG! BGAGB@DA;bGA! B;>V@;BGMD>@D! KG! ;>_;S;B;I>k! DE! BKGHD!

B=>=BDA! KG! ADKGB;I>!D>@AD! KGE!B=>E@G>@DE!=SEDAHG<GE!<D! ;>_;S;B;I>! e'=SEf!C! KG!B=>BD>@AGB;I>!

<DK! ;>_;S;<=A8!%TU?! <D@DAM;>GM=E! BG<G!'=SE! FGAG!0WY(a7! e[;JUAG!7cf! C! 0WY(a9! e[;JUAG!7Rf!

G\UE@G><=!D:F=>D>B;GKMD>@D!D>!=A<D>!7!KG!GB@;H;<G<!0)d!ADMG>D>@D!D>!ZU>B;I>!<DK!@;DMF=!

<D! FAD;>BUSGB;I>! B=>! U>G! B=>BD>@AGB;I>! Z;\G! <D! &)9%%! e[;JUAGE! 7c! C! 7Rk! ;>EDA@=f8!

3DFADED>@GM=E! KGE! B=>E@G>@DE! =S@D>;<GE! D>! ZU>B;I>! <D! KG! B=>BD>@AGB;I>! <D! &)9%%! FGAG!

<D@DAM;>GA!BUNK!<D!K=E!M=<DK=E!;KUE@AG<=E!D>!DK!DETUDMG!9!ED!G\UE@G!G!KG!;>@DAGBB;I>!0WY(a

&)9%%! e[;JUAG! 9`f8! %>@DE! <D! ADGK;bGA! DK! G\UE@D!MG@DMN@;B=! CG! ED! FU<=! <D@DAM;>GA! TUD! KG!

;>@DAGBB;I>!>=!B=AADEF=><D!G!U>G! ADGBB;I>!S;M=KDBUKGA! E;MFKD! e#ETUDMG!9k!M=<DK=! ;;fk! CG!

TUD!>=! DE! K;>DGK! KG! ADKGB;I>! D>@AD!'=SE! C! m&)9%%n8! 0=A! DK! B=>@AGA;=k! KGE!'=SE!M=E@AGA=>!U>G!

ADKGB;I>! _;FDASIK;BG! B=>! KG! B=>BD>@AGB;I>! <D! &)9%%! D>! GMSGE! ;E=Z=AMGE! <D! KG! D>b;MG!

e[;JUAG!9`fk!ADFADED>@G@;H=!<D!U>!;>_;S;<=A!TUD!GB@iG!D>!<=E!FGE=Eo!ED!DE@GSKDBD!U>!FA;MDA!

DTU;K;SA;=!<D!U>;I>!D>@AD!D>b;MG!D! ;>_;S;<=A!eB=>!U>G!B=>E@G>@D!<D!DTUK;SA;=!<D@DAM;>G<G!

F=A!'7!C!'9!D>!K=E!M=<DK=E!;;;!C!;H!<DK!DETUDMG!9fk!EDJU;<=!<D!U>G!M=<;Z;BGB;I>!<D!KG!D>b;MG!

TUD!ADEUK@G!D>!U>G! ;>_;S;B;I>!ADHDAE;SKD! eM=<DK=! ;;;k!#ETUDMG!9f!=! ;AADHDAE;SKD! eM=<DK=! ;Hk!

#ETUDMG!9f!m7cLn8!,=E!JANZ;B=E!<D!'=SE!HE8!m&)9%%n!ED!G\UE@GA=>!MD\=A!G!KGE!DBUGB;=>DE!FGAG!

DK!M=<DK=!<D!;>_;S;B;I>!@;DMF=a<DFD><;D>@D!D>!<=E!FGE=E!e#ETUDMG!Pf!C!=S@UH;M=E!K=E!!

6#L/"1,%T>%N(&"3(#% )$-B*$)(#%&"% $-C$A$)$G-% *$"1K(4&"K"-&$"-*">% a+b% @DGBB;I>! D>b;MN@;BG! D>! GUED>B;G! <D!

;>_;S;<=A8! a++b! '>_;S;B;I>! E;MFKDk! ADGBB;I>! S;M=KDBUKGA! D>@AD! KG! D>b;MG! e#f! C! DK! ;>_;S;<=A! e'f8! ,G! F=@D>B;G! C!

ADHDAE;S;K;<G<! DE@N! <G<G! F=A! K=E! HGK=ADE! <D! '7! e'=>f! C! '9! e'=ZZf8! %K@DA>G@;HGMD>@Dk! ED! FUD<D! DE@GSKDBDA! U>G!

;>@DAGBB;I>!D>@AD!KG!D>b;MG!C!DK!;>_;S;<=A!Z=AMG><=!U>!B=MFKD\=!e#'f!D>!U>G!FA;MDAG!ADGBB;I>k!EDJU;<=!<D!U>G!

EDJU><G!ADGBB;I>!<=><D!KG!D>b;MG!EUZAD!U>G!M=<;Z;BGB;I>!!a+++b!ADHDAE;SKD!=!x;E=MDA;bGB;I>!D>;bMN@;BGy!=!a+8b!

;AADHDAE;SKD8!,G!BGAGB@DA;bGB;I>!B;>V@;BG!FDAM;@D!<D@DAM;>GA!DK!FGE=!K;M;@G>@D!e'=>!FUD<D!B=AADEF=><DA!G!'7!=!

'Pf!C!KG!ADHDAE;S;K;<G<!<D!KG!;>_;S;B;I>!eHGK=A!<D!'Lf8!

e%<GF@G<=!<D!$=FDKG><k!38!%8!e9```f!I"DJB(1/#KL*M)(-#Fk!9><!#<;@;=>!D<>8f!

%

+?!

++?!

+++?!

+8?!

Page 50: lucia bonilla - tesis doctorado - fq.edu.uyriquim.fq.edu.uy/archive/files/c8bc46ec90d10a0da2c... · 9!&!!&!!!& &)!!&!!&!!!&!!"#$!$%!e'# 7`!" a!&!!& $) '#!" &) P!!!&&)!C! ...

50

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

! A

!B

2$O/+,%Sh>%'"*"+1$-,)$G-%&"%X(A#%K,+,%3,%$-C$A$)$G-%&"%3,%,)*$F$&,&%5<g%"-%5Z?Y4S>!(D!MUDE@AG>!ADEUK@G<=E!

ADFADED>@G@;H=E!FGAG!KG!D>b;MG!;>_;S;<G!B=>!&)9%%!a:b!P!U"!C!a9b!c!U"8!%!FGA@;A!<D!K=E!<G@=E!FA;MGA;=E!<D!

."0/=:! FGAG! @;DMF=E! <D! FAD;>BUSGB;I>! B=>! B=>BD>@AGB;=>DE! BADB;D>@DE! <D! &)9%%! BADB;D>@DE! e;>EDA@=f!

BGKBUKGM=E! KG! GB@;H;<G<! DEFDB?Z;BG! 0)d! eHDK=B;<G<! ;>;B;GKk! P`! EDJU><=Ef! C! ADFADED>@GM=E! JANZ;BGMD>@D! KG!

GB@;H;<G<!0)d!ADMG>D>@D!FGAG!@;DMF=E!<D!FAD;>BUSGB;I>!BADB;D>@DE8!%\UE@GM=E!K=E!<G@=E!G!U>G!D:F=>D>B;GK!

<D!=A<D>!7!FGAG!=S@D>DA! K=E!HGK=ADE!<D!'=SE8! ,=E! ADEUK@G<=E!B=AADEF=><D>!G! K=E!FA=MD<;=E!!! (8/8k!"sPk!<D!

D:FDA;MD>@=E!GK!MD>=E!@A;FK;BG<=E8!