Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

231
7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 1/231 Design of Seismic- Resistant Steel Building Structures Prepared by: Michael D. Engelhardt University of Texas at Austin with the support of the American Institute of Steel Construction. Version 1 - March 2007 2. Moment Resisting Frames

Transcript of Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

Page 1: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 1/231

Design of Seismic-Resistant Steel

Building Structures

Prepared by:

Michael D. EngelhardtUniversity of Texas at Austin

with the support of the American Institute of Steel Construction.

Version 1 - March 2007

2. Moment Resisting Frames

Page 2: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 2/231

Page 3: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 3/231

2 - Moment Resisting Frames

• Definition and Basic Behavior of Moment Resisting

Frames

• Beam-to-Column Connections: Before and After

Northridge

• Panel-Zone Behavior

• AISC Seismic Provisions for Special Moment Frames

Page 4: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 4/231

Moment Resisting Frames

• Definition and Basic Behavior of Moment Resisting

Frames

• Beam-to-Column Connections: Before and After

Northridge

• Panel-Zone Behavior

• AISC Seismic Provisions for Special Moment Frames

Page 5: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 5/231

MOMENT RESISTING FRAME (MRF)

Advantages

• Architectural Versatility• High Ductility and Safety

Disadvantages

• Low Elastic Stiffness

Beams and columns with moment resistingconnections; resist lateral forces by flexure andshear in beams and columns

Develop ductility by:- flexural yielding of beams

- shear yielding of column panel zones- flexural yielding of columns

Page 6: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 6/231

Moment Resisting Frame

Page 7: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 7/231

Page 8: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 8/231

Page 9: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 9/231

Page 10: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 10/231

Achieving Ductile Behavior:

• Choose frame elements ("fuses") that willyield in an earthquake, i.e, choose plastic

hinge locations.• Detail plastic hinge regions to sustain

large inelastic rotations prior to the onsetof fracture or instability.

•Design all other frame elements to bestronger than the plastic hinge regions.

Understand and Control Inelastic Behavior:

Page 11: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 11/231

Behavior of an MRF Under Lateral Load:Internal Forces and Possible Plastic Hinge Locations

Page 12: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 12/231

Page 13: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 13/231M V

Page 14: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 14/231

Possible Plastic Hinge Locations

Beam(Flexural Yielding)

Panel Zone(Shear Yielding)

Column(Flexural & Axial

Yielding)

Page 15: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 15/231

Plastic HingesIn Beams

Page 16: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 16/231

Plastic HingesIn Column Panel Zones

Page 17: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 17/231

Plastic HingesIn Columns:

Potential for SoftStory Collapse

Page 18: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 18/231

Critical Detailing Area for Moment Resisting Frames:

Beam-to-Column Connections

Design Requirement:Frame must develop large ductilitywithout failure of beam-to-columnconnection.

Page 19: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 19/231

Page 20: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 20/231

Moment Connection Design Practice Prior to1994 Northridge Earthquake:

Welded flange-boltedweb moment connectionwidely used from early1970’s to 1994

Page 21: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 21/231

Pre-NorthridgeWelded Flange – Bolted Web Moment Connection

Backup Bar

Beam Flange

Column FlangeStiffener

Weld Access Hole

Page 22: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 22/231

Page 23: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 23/231

Page 24: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 24/231

Page 25: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 25/231

Page 26: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 26/231

Page 27: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 27/231

Page 28: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 28/231

Page 29: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 29/231

Page 30: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 30/231

Page 31: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 31/231

Page 32: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 32/231

Page 33: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 33/231

Experimental Data on “Pre -Northridge”Moment Connection

Typical ExperimentalSetup:

Page 34: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 34/231

Page 35: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 35/231

Initial Tests on Large Scale Specimens:

• Tests conducted at UC Berkeley ~1970• Tests on W18x50 and W24x76 beams• Tests compared all-welded connections

with welded flange-bolted web connections

Page 36: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 36/231

Page 37: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 37/231

Page 38: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 38/231

Page 39: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 39/231

Page 40: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 40/231

Page 41: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 41/231

Welded Flange – Bolted Web Detail

Page 42: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 42/231

Page 43: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 43/231

Page 44: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 44/231

Observations from Initial UC Berkeley Tests:

• Large ductility developed by all-weldedconnections.

• Welded flange-bolted web connections developedless ductility, but were viewed as still acceptable.

Page 45: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 45/231

Subsequent Test Programs:

• Welded flange-bolted web connections showedhighly variable performance.

• Typical failure modes: fracture at or near beamflange groove welds.

• A large number of laboratory tested connectionsdid not develop adequate ductility in the beam

prior to connection failure.

Page 46: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 46/231

Page 47: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 47/231

Page 48: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 48/231

-5000

-4000

-3000

-2000

-1000

0

1000

2000

3000

4000

5000

-0.04 -0.03 -0.02 -0.01 0 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04

Drift Angle (rad)

B e n

d i n g

M o m

e n

t ( k N - m )

Brittle Fracture at BottomFlange Weld

Mp

Mp

Pre-Northridge Connection

Page 49: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 49/231

Summary of Testing Prior toNorthridge Earthquake

• Welded flange – bolted web connection showedhighly variable performance

• Many connections failed in laboratory with littleor no ductility

Page 50: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 50/231

1994 Northridge Earthquake

Widespread failure of welded flange - boltedweb momentconnections

Page 51: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 51/231

1994 Northridge Earthquake

• January 17, 1994

• Magnitude = 6.8

• Epicenter at Northridge - San Fernando Valley(Los Angeles area)

• Fatalities: 58

• Estimated Damage Cost: $20 Billion

Page 52: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 52/231

Northridge - Ground Accelerations

• Sylmar: 0.91g H 0.60g V

• Sherman Oaks: 0.46g H 0.18g V

• Granada Hills: 0.62g H 0.40g V

• Santa Monica: 0.93g H 0.25g V

• North Hollywood: 0.33g H 0.15g V

Page 53: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 53/231

Page 54: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 54/231

Page 55: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 55/231

Page 56: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 56/231

Page 57: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 57/231

Damage Observations:Steel MomentConnections

Pre-Northridge

Page 58: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 58/231

Backup Bar

Beam Flange

Column FlangeStiffener

Weld Access Hole

Pre-NorthridgeWelded Flange – Bolted Web Moment Connection

Page 59: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 59/231

Page 60: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 60/231

Page 61: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 61/231

Page 62: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 62/231

Page 63: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 63/231

Page 64: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 64/231

Page 65: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 65/231

Page 66: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 66/231

Page 67: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 67/231

Page 68: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 68/231

Page 69: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 69/231

Page 70: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 70/231

Page 71: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 71/231

Page 72: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 72/231

Page 73: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 73/231

Page 74: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 74/231

Page 75: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 75/231

Page 76: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 76/231

Page 77: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 77/231

Damage Observations

• A large number of steel moment frame buildingssuffered connection damage

• No steel moment frame buildings collapsed• Typical Damage:

– fracture of groove weld

– “divot” fracture within column flange – fracture across column flange and web

Page 78: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 78/231

Page 79: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 79/231

Response to Northridge Moment ConnectionDamage

• Nearly immediate elimination of welded flange -bolted web connection from US building codes anddesign practice

• Intensive research and testing efforts to understandcauses of damage and to develop improvedconnections – AISC, NIST, NSF, etc. – SAC Program (FEMA)

Page 80: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 80/231

Causes of Moment ConnectionDamage in Northridge

• Welding

• Connection Design

• Materials

Causes of Northridge Moment Connection

Page 81: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 81/231

Damage:

Welding Factors

• Low Fracture Toughness of Weld Metal

• Poor Quality• Effect of Backing Bars and Weld Tabs

Page 82: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 82/231

Weld Metal Toughness

• Most common Pre-Northridge welding electrode(E70T-4) had very low fracture toughness.

Typical Charpy V-Notch: < 5 ft.-lbs at 70 0F(7 J at 21 0C)

Page 83: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 83/231

Page 84: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 84/231

Welding Quality

• Many failed connections showed evidence of poor weld quality

• Many fractures initiated at root defects in bottomflange weld, in vicinity of weld access hole

Page 85: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 85/231

Page 86: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 86/231

Page 87: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 87/231

Page 88: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 88/231

Page 89: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 89/231

Page 90: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 90/231

Causes of Northridge Moment ConnectionD

Page 91: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 91/231

Design Factors:

Stress/Strain Too High at Beam Flange Groove Weld

• Inadequate Participation of Beam Web Connection inTransferring Moment and Shear

• Effect of Weld Access Hole

• Effect of Column Flange Bending

• Other Factors

Damage:

s s

Fu

Page 92: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 92/231

Mp

Increase in Flange Stress Due toInadequate Moment Transfer Through Web Connection

F l a n g e

S t r e s

Fy

Page 93: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 93/231

Vflange

Increase in Flange Stress Due to Shear in Flange

Page 94: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 94/231

Page 95: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 95/231

Page 96: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 96/231

Page 97: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 97/231

Strategies for Improved Performanceof Moment Connections

• Welding

• Materials

• Connection Design and Detailing

Strategies for Improved Performance of Moment

Page 98: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 98/231

Connections:

WELDING

• Required minimum toughness for weld metal:

– Required CVN for all welds in SLRS:20 ft.-lbs at 0 0 F

– Required CVN for Demand Critical welds:20 ft.-lbs at -20 0 F and 40 ft.-lbs at 70 0 F

Page 99: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 99/231

Page 100: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 100/231

Page 101: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 101/231

Page 102: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 102/231

Page 103: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 103/231

Strategies for Improved Performance of MomentConnections:

Page 104: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 104/231

Materials (Structural Steel)

• Introduction of “expected yield stress” into designcodes

Fy = minimum specified yield strength

R y = 1.5 for ASTM A36

= 1.1 for A572 Gr. 50 and A992(See AISC Seismic Provisions - Section 6 for other values of R y )

Expected Yield Stress = R y Fy

Strategies for Improved Performance of MomentConnections:

Page 105: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 105/231

Materials (Structural Steel)

• Introduction of ASTM A992 steel for wide flangeshapes

ASTM A992Minimum F y = 50 ksi

Maximum F y = 65 ksi

Minimum F u = 65 ksi

Maximum F y / Fu = 0.85

Strategies for Improved Performance of MomentConnections:

Page 106: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 106/231

Connections:

Connection Design

• Improved Weld Access Hole Geometry

Page 107: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 107/231

Improved Weld AccessHole

See Figure 11-1 in the2005 AISC Seismic Provisions for dimensionsand finish requirements

Page 108: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 108/231

Strategies for Improved Performance of MomentConnections:

Page 109: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 109/231

Connections:

Connection Design

• Development of Improved Connection Designsand Design Procedures

– Reinforced Connections

– Proprietary Connections

– Reduced Beam Section (Dogbone)

Connections – Other SAC Investigated Connections

Page 110: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 110/231

Page 111: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 111/231

Page 112: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 112/231

Page 113: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 113/231

Page 114: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 114/231

Page 115: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 115/231

Page 116: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 116/231

Page 117: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 117/231

Proprietary Connections

SIDE PLATE

Page 118: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 118/231

SIDE PLATECONNECTION

SLOTTED WEB

Page 119: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 119/231

SLOTTED WEBCONNECTION

Page 120: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 120/231

Connections Investigated ThroughSAC-FEMA Research Program

Reduced BeamSection

Page 121: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 121/231

Section

Page 122: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 122/231

WeldedUnreinforcedFlange - BoltedWeb

WeldedUnreinforced

Page 123: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 123/231

Flange - WeldedWeb

Free Flange

Page 124: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 124/231

Free FlangeConnection

Welded FlangePlate Connection

Page 125: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 125/231

Plate Connection

Bolted UnstiffenedEnd Plate

Page 126: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 126/231

End Plate

Bolted StiffenedEnd Plate

Page 127: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 127/231

Bolted FlangePlate

Page 128: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 128/231

Double Split Tee

Page 129: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 129/231

Double Split Tee

Results of SAC-FEMA Research ProgramR d d S i i D i C it i

Page 130: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 130/231

Recommended Seismic Design Criteriafor Steel Moment Frames

• FEMA 350Recommended Seismic Design Criteria for New Steel Moment-Frame Buildings

• FEMA 351Recommended Seismic Evaluation and Upgrade Criteria for Existing Welded Steel Moment-Frame Buildings

• FEMA 352Recommended Postearthquake Evaluation and Repair Criteriafor Welded Steel Moment-Frame Buildings

• FEMA 353Recommended Specifications and Quality AssuranceGuidelines for Steel Moment-Frame Construction for Seismic

Applications

Page 131: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 131/231

FEMA 350

Moment Resisting Frames

Page 132: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 132/231

• Definition and Basic Behavior of Moment ResistingFrames

• Beam-to-Column Connections: Before and After

Northridge

• Panel-Zone Behavior

• AISC Seismic Provisions for Special Moment Frames

Column Panel Zone

Page 133: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 133/231

Colum n Panel Zon e: - subject to high shear - shear yielding and large

shear deformations possible(forms “shear hinge”)

- provides alternate yieldingmechanism in a steel momentframe

Page 134: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 134/231

Joint deformationdue to panel zoneshear yielding

Page 135: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 135/231

Plastic Shear HingesIn Column Panel Zones

Page 136: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 136/231

Page 137: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 137/231

Page 138: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 138/231

Page 139: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 139/231

Page 140: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 140/231

"kink" at corners of panel zone

400C i RBS S i i h

Page 141: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 141/231

-400

-300

-200

-100

0

100

200

300

-0.08 -0.06 -0.04 -0.02 0 0.02 0.04 0.06 0.08

Story Drift Angle (rad)

C o

l u m n

T i p

L o a

d ( k i p s

)

Composite RBS Specimen withWeak Panel Zone

1200Composite RBS Specimen with

Page 142: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 142/231

-1200

-800

-400

0

400

800

-0.08 -0.06 -0.04 -0.02 0 0.02 0.04 0.06 0.08

Panel Zone g (rad)

P a n e

l Z o n e

S h e a r

F o r c e

( k i p s )

Weak Panel Zone

g

Observations on Panel Zone Behavior

Page 143: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 143/231

Observations on Panel Zone Behavior

• Very high ductility is possible.

• Localized deformations (“kinking”) at corners of panelzone may increase likelihood of fracture in vicinity of beam flange groove welds.

• Building code provisions have varied greatly on panelzone design.

• Current AISC Seismic Provisions permits limited

yielding in panel zone.• Further research needed to better define acceptable

level of panel zone yielding

Moment Resisting Frames

Page 144: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 144/231

• Definition and Basic Behavior of Moment ResistingFrames

• Beam-to-Column Connections: Before and After

Northridge

• Panel-Zone Behavior

• AISC Seismic Provisions for Special Moment Frames

Page 145: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 145/231

2005 AISC Seismic Provisions

Section 9 Special Moment Frames (SMF)

Section 10 Intermediate Moment Frames (IMF)

Section 11 Ordinary Moment Frames (OMF)

Section 9Special Moment Frames (SMF)

Page 146: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 146/231

p ( )9.1 Scope

9.2 Beam-to-Column Joints and Connections

9.3 Panel Zone of Beam-to-Column Connections

9.4 Beam and Column Limitations

9.5 Continuity Plates

9.6 Column-Beam Moment Ratio

9.7 Lateral Bracing of at Beam-to-Column Connections

9.8 Lateral Bracing of Beams

9.9 Column Splices

AISC Seismic Provisions - SMF 9.1 Scope

Page 147: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 147/231

Special moment frames (SMF) are expected to withstandsignificant inelastic deformations when subjected to theforces resulting from the motions of the designearthquake.

Page 148: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 148/231

AISC Seismic Provisions - SMF - Beam-to-Column Connections9.2a Requirements

Page 149: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 149/231

Beam-to-column connections shall satisfy the following three

requirements:

1. The connection shall be capable of sustaining aninterstory drift angle of at least 0.04 radians.

2. The measured flexural resistance of theconnection, determined at the column face, shall

equal at least 0.80 M p of the connected beam atan interstory drift angle of 0.04 radians.

9.2a Requirements

Beam-to-column connections shall satisfy the following three

Page 150: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 150/231

requirements (cont):

3. The required shear strength of the connectionshall be determined using the following quantityfor the earthquake load effect E :

E = 2 [ 1.1R y

M p

] / Lh

(9-1)

where:

R y = ratio of the expected yield strength to theminimum specified yield strength

M p = nominal plastic flexural strength

Lh = distance between plastic hinge locations

Required Shear Strength of Beam-to-Column Connection

Page 151: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 151/231

Lh

(1.2 + 0.2S DS ) D + 0.5 L or (0.9-0.2S DS ) D1.1 R y M p 1.1 R y M p

V u = 2 [ 1.1 R y M p ] / L h + V gravity

V u V u

AISC Seismic Provisions - SMF - Beam-to-Column Connections9.2b Conformance Demonstration

Page 152: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 152/231

Demonstrate conformance with requirements of Sect. 9.2a by one of

the following methods:

I. Conduct qualifying cyclic tests in accordance with Appendix S.

Tests conducted specifically for the project, with test specimens thatare representative of project conditions.

or

Tests reported in the literature (research literature or other

documented test programs), where the test specimens arerepresentative of project conditions.

9.2b Conformance Demonstration

Demonstrate conformance with requirements of Sect 9 2a by one of

Page 153: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 153/231

Demonstrate conformance with requirements of Sect. 9.2a by one of the following methods (cont):

II. Use connections prequalified for SMF in accordance with Appendix P

Use connections prequalified by the AISC ConnectionPrequalification Review Panel (CPRP) and documented in StandardANSI/AISC 358 -"Prequalified Connections for Special and IntermediateSteel Moment Frames for Seismic Applications"

or

Use connection prequalified by an alternative review panel that isapproved by the Authority Having Jurisdiction.

9.2b Conformance Demonstration - by Testing

Page 154: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 154/231

Test connectionin accordancewith Appendix S

Appendix SQualifying Cyclic Tests of Beam-to-Column

and Link-to-Column Connections

Page 155: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 155/231

Testing Requirements:

• Test specimens should be representative of prototype(Prototype = actual building)

• Beams and columns in test specimens must be nearly full-scalerepresentation of prototype members:

- depth of test beam ≥ 0.90 depth of prototype beam- wt. per ft. of test beam ≥ 0.75 wt. per ft. of prototype beam

- depth of test column ≥ 0.90 depth of prototype column

• Sources of inelastic deformation (beam, panel zone, connectionplates, etc) in the test specimen must similar to prototype.

Appendix S

Testing Requirements (cont):

Page 156: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 156/231

• Lateral bracing in test specimen should be similar to prototype.• Connection configuration used for test specimen must match

prototype.

• Welding processes, procedures, electrodes, etc. used for test

specimen must be representative of prototype.

See Ap pendix S for o th er requirements .

Typical Test Subassemblages

Page 157: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 157/231

Exterior Subassemblage Interior Subassemblage

Typical Exterior Subassemblage

Page 158: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 158/231

Δ

Lbeam

Interstory Drift Angle = Δ Lbeam

Typical Exterior Subassemblage

Page 159: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 159/231

Δ Typical Interior Subassemblage

Page 160: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 160/231

Hcolumn

Interstory Drift Angle = Δ

Hcolumn

Typical Interior Subassemblage

Page 161: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 161/231

Page 162: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 162/231

Appendix S

Testing Requirements - Loading History

Page 163: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 163/231

Apply the following loading history:6 cycles at = 0.00375 rad.

6 cycles at = 0.005 rad.

6 cycles at = 0.0075 rad.

4 cycles at = 0.01 rad.

2 cycles at = 0.015 rad.

2 cycles at = 0.02 rad.

2 cycles at = 0.03 rad.2 cycles at = 0.04 rad.

continue at increments of 0.01 rad, with twocycles of loading at each step

Appendix S Testing Requirements - Loading History

Page 164: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 164/231

-0.05

-0.04

-0.03

-0.02

-0.010

0.01

0.02

0.03

0.040.05

0.06

I n t e

r s t o

r y D r

i f t A n g

l e

Acceptance Criteria for SMF Beam-to-Column Connections: After completing at least one loading cycle at 0.04 radian, the measured flexuralresistance of the connection, measured at the face of the column, must be at least0.80 M p of the connected beam

Example of Successful Conformance Demonstration Testper Appendix S:

Page 165: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 165/231

-40000

-30000

-20000

-10000

0

10000

20000

30000

40000

-0.08 -0.06 -0.04 -0.02 0 0.02 0.04 0.06 0.08

Interstory Drift Angle (rad)

B e a m

M

o m e n

t a

t F a c e o f

C o

l u m n

( i n - k

i p s )

0.8 M p

- 0.8 M p

M0.04 0.8 M p

M0.04 0.8 M p

9.2b Conformance Demonstration........by use of Prequalified Connection

Page 166: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 166/231

A Prequalified connection is one that has undergone sufficient

testing (per Appendix S)

analysis

evaluation and review

so that a high level of confidence exists that the connection canfulfill the performance requirements specified in Section 9.2a for

Special Moment Frame Connections

9.2b Conformance Demonstration .....by use of Prequalified Connection

Page 167: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 167/231

Requirements for Prequalification of Connections:Appendix P - Prequalification of Beam-to-Column

and Link-to-Column Connections

Authority to Prequalify of Connections:AISCConnection Prequalification Review Panel (CPRP)

Information on Prequalified Connections:Standard ANSI/AISC 358 - "Prequalified Connections for Special and Intermediate Steel Moment Frames for Seismic Applications "

Page 168: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 168/231

ANSI/AISC 358 - "Prequalified Connections for Special and I di S l M F f S i i A li i "

Page 169: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 169/231

Intermediate Steel Moment Frames for Seismic Applications "

Connections Prequalified in ANSI/AISC 358 (1st Ed - 2005)

• Reduced Beam Section (RBS) Connection

• Bolted Unstiffened and Stiffened Extended End-Plate Connection

Reduced Beam Section (RBS) Moment Connection

Page 170: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 170/231

RBS Concept:

• Trim Beam Flanges Near Connection

• Reduce Moment atConnection

• Force Plastic Hinge Awayfrom Connection

Example of laboratory performance of an RBS connection:

Page 171: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 171/231

Whitewashed connection prior to testing:

Page 172: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 172/231

Whitewashed connection prior to testing:

Page 173: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 173/231

Connection at 0.02 radian......

Page 174: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 174/231

Connection at 0.02 radian......

Page 175: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 175/231

Connection at 0.03 radian......

Page 176: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 176/231

Connection at 0.04 radian......

Page 177: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 177/231

3000

4000

5000

Mp

Page 178: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 178/231

-5000

-4000

-3000

-2000

-1000

0

1000

2000

3000

-0.05 -0.04 -0.03 -0.02 -0.01 0 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05

Drift Angle (radian)

B e n

d i n g

M o m e n

t ( k N - m

)

RBS Connection

Mp

ANSI/AISC 358:

Prequalification Requirements for RBS in SMF

Page 179: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 179/231

• Beam depth: up to W36• Beam weight: up to 300 lb/ft

• Column depth: up to W36 for wide-flange

up to 24-inches for box columns• Beam connected to column flange

(connections to column web not prequalified)

• RBS shape: circular

• RBS dimensions: per specified design procedure

ANSI/AISC 358:Prequalification Requirements for RBS in SMF

cont......

Page 180: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 180/231

Beam flange welds: - CJP groove welds- Treat welds asDemand Critical - Remove bottom flange backing and provide

reinforcing fillet weld

- Leave top flange backing in-place; fillet weldbacking to column flange

- Remove weld tabs at top and bottom flanges

Beam web to column connection:

- Use fully welded web connection (CJP weldbetween beam web and column flange)

See ANSI/AISC 358 for additional requirements (continuity plates, beamlateral bracing, RBS cut finish req'ts., etc.)

RBS with welded web

Page 181: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 181/231

RBS with welded web

connection:

Page 182: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 182/231

Page 183: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 183/231

Examples of RBS Connections.....

Page 184: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 184/231

Page 185: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 185/231

AISC Seismic Provisions - SMF - Panel Zone Requirements9.3a Shear Strength

Page 186: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 186/231

The minimum required shear strength,R u , of the panel zone shall betaken as the shear generated in the panel zone when plastic hinges formin the beams.

To compute panel zone shear.....Determine moment at beam plastic hinge locations

(1.1 R y M p or as specified in ANSI/AISC 358)

Project moment at plastic hinge locations to the faceof the column (based on beam moment gradient)

Compute panel zone shear force.

Panel Zone Shear Strength (cont)

Page 187: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 187/231

M pr-2 M pr1

V beam-2

V beam-1

Beam 1 Beam 2

Plastic Hinge Location

Plastic Hinge Location

s h s h

M f1 M f2

M pr = expected moment at plastic hinge = 1.1R y M p or as specified in ANSI/AISC 358

V beam = beam shear (see Section 9.2a - beam required shear strength)

sh = distance from face of column to beam plastic hinge location (specified in ANSI/AISC 358)

Page 188: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 188/231

Panel Zone Shear Strength (cont)

Page 189: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 189/231

c

f b

f u V

t d

M R Panel Zone Required Shear Strength =

Panel Zone Shear Strength (cont)

Panel Zone Design Requirement:

Page 190: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 190/231

Panel Zone Design Requirement:

R u v R v wh ere v = 1.0

R v = nominal shear strength, basedon a limit state of shear yielding, ascomputed per Section J10.6 of the

AISC Specification

Panel Zone Shear Strength (cont)

To compute nominal shear strength, R v , of panel zone:

Page 191: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 191/231

When P u 0.75 P y in column:

pc b

2 cf cf

pc y v

t d d

t b31t d F 6 .0 R

(AISC Spec EQ J10-11)

Where: d c = column depth

d b = beam depth

bcf = column flange width

t cf = column flange thickness

F y = minimum specified yield stress of column web

t p = thickness of column web including doubler plate

Panel Zone Shear Strength (cont)

To compute nominal shear strength, R v , of panel zone:

Page 192: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 192/231

When P u > 0.75 P y in column (not recommended) :

y

u

pc b

2 cf cf pc y v P

P 2 .19.1t d d t b31t d F 6 .0 R (AISC Spec EQ J10-12)

If shear strength of panel zone is inadequate:

- Choose column section with larger web area

Page 193: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 193/231

- Weld doubler plates to column

Options for Web Doubler Plates

AISC Seismic Provisions - SMF 9.4 Beam and Column Limitations

Beam and column sections must satisfy the width-

Page 194: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 194/231

y

thickness limitations given in Table I-8-1

y

s

f

f

F E 30 .0

t 2 b

Beam Flanges

Beam Web

y

s

w F E

45 .2 t h

b f

t f

h

t w

Column Flanges sf E 30 .0

b ≤

9.4 Beam and Column Limitations

Page 195: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 195/231

y f F t 2

Column Web

125 .0 P

P

y

u ≤

y

u

y

s

w P

P 54.11

F

E 14.3

t

h

125 .0

P

P

y

u

y

s

y

u

y

s

w F E

49.1P

P 33.2

F E

12 .1t h

Note: Column flange and web slenderness limits can be taken as p in AISCSpecificationTable B4.1, if the ratio for Eq. 9-3 is greater than 2.0

AISC Seismic Provisions - SMF 9.5 Continuity Plates

Page 196: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 196/231

Continuity Plates

9.5 Continuity Plates

Page 197: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 197/231

Continuity Plates

Page 198: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 198/231

AISC Seismic Provisions - SMF 9.5 Continuity Plates

Page 199: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 199/231

Continuity plates shall be consistent with therequirements of a prequalified connection as specified inANSI/AISC 358 (Prequalified Connections for Special and Intermediate Steel Moment Frames for Seismic Applications)

or

As determined in a program of qualification testing inaccordance with Appendix S

ANSI/AISC 358 -Continuity Plate Requirements

Continuity PlatesFor Wide-Flange Columns:

Page 200: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 200/231

Continuity plates are required, unless:

yc yc

ybybbf bf cf F R

F R t b8 .14.0 t

6 b

t bf cf

and

t cf = column flange thickness

bbf = beam flange width

t bf = beam flange thickness

ANSI/AISC 358 -Continuity Plate Requirements

For Box Columns:

Page 201: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 201/231

Continuity Plates

For Box Columns:

Continuity plates must be provided.

ANSI/AISC 358 -Continuity Plate Requirements

Required thickness of continuity plates

Page 202: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 202/231

a) For one-sided (exterior) connections, continuity plate thickness shall beat least one-half of the thickness of the beam flange.

b) For two-sided (interior) connections, continuity plate thickness shall be atleast equal to the thicker of the two beam flanges on either side of the

column

For other design, detailing and welding requirements for continuity plates - See ANSI/AISC 358

t

ANSI/AISC 358 -Continuity Plate Requirements

Page 203: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 203/231

t cp

t bf t cp ≥ 1/2 t bf

t cp

ANSI/AISC 358 -Continuity Plate Requirements

Page 204: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 204/231

p

t bf-2 t bf-1

t cp ≥ larger of ( t bf-1 and t bf-2 )

Page 205: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 205/231

Page 206: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 206/231

Page 207: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 207/231

Page 208: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 208/231

Page 209: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 209/231

Page 210: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 210/231

AISC Seismic Provisions - SMF 9.6 Column-Beam Moment Ratio

Section 9.6 requires strong column - weak girder design for SMF (with a few exceptions)

Page 211: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 211/231

design for SMF (with a few exceptions)

Purpose of strong column -weak girder requirement:

Prevent Soft Story Collapse

AISC Seismic Provisions - SMF 9.6 Column-Beam Moment Ratio

The following relationship shall be satisfied at beam-to-l ti

Page 212: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 212/231

column connections:

0 .1M

M * pb

* pc Eqn. (9-3)

9.6 Column-Beam Moment Ratio

0 .1M

M * pb

* pc

Page 213: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 213/231

pb

* pc M the sum of the moments in the column above and below the joint at

the intersection of the beam and column centerlines.∑M *

pc is determined by summing the projections of thenominal

flexural strengths of the columnsabove and below the joint to thebeam centerline with a reduction for the axial force in the column.

It is permitted to take ∑M * pc = ∑Z c ( F yc - P uc /Ag )

* pbM the sum of the moments in the beams at the intersection of the beamand column centerlines.

∑M * pb is determined by summing the projections of theexpected

flexural strengths of the beamsat the plastic hinge locations to thecolumn centerline.

C ColumnL0 .1M M

* pb

* pc

Page 214: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 214/231

C BeamL

M* pc-top

M* pc-bottom M* pb-left

M* pb-right

Note:M* pc is based on minimum specified yieldstress of column

M* pb is based on expected yield stress of beamand includes allowance for strain hardening

V beam-right

Left Beam Right Beam

Plastic Hinge Location

Computing M* pb

Page 215: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 215/231

M pr-right M pr-left

beam right

V beam-left Plastic Hinge Location

s h+d col /2

M pr = expected moment at plastic hinge = 1.1R y M p or as specified in ANSI/AISC 358

V beam = beam shear (see Section 9.2a - beam required shear strength)sh = distance from face of column to beam plastic hinge location (specified in

ANSI/AISC 358)

M* pb-left M* pb-r ight

s h+d col /2

M* pb = M pr + V beam (s h + d col /2 )

Top Column

Computing M* pc M pc- top

M* pc- top

V col-top

Page 216: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 216/231

Bottom Column

M pc = nominal plastic moment capacity of column, reduced for presence of axial force; cantake M pc = Z c (F yc - P uc / Ag ) [or use more exact moment-axial force interaction

equations for a fully plastic cross-section]V col = column shear - compute from statics, based on assumed location of column inflectio

points (usually midheight of column)

M* pc-bot tom

M* pc = M pc + V col (d beam /2 )

M pc-bot tom

d beam

V col-bottom

AISC Seismic Provisions - SMF 9.8 Lateral Bracing of Beams

Must provide adequate lateral bracing of beams in SMF

Page 217: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 217/231

Must provide adequate lateral bracing of beams in SMFso that severe strength degradation due to lateraltorsional buckling is delayed until sufficient ductility isachieved

(Sufficient ductility = interstory drift angle of at least 0.04rad is achieved under Appendix S loading protocol)

Lateral Torsional BucklingLateral torsionalbuckling controlled by: b

r

L

Page 218: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 218/231

y r

L b = dis tanc e betw een beam lateral br aces

r y = w eak axis radius o f gyrat ion

L b L b

Beam lateral braces (top & bottom flanges)

Page 219: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 219/231

Page 220: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 220/231

Page 221: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 221/231

Effect of Lateral Torsional Buckling on Flexural Strength and Ductility:

M

Page 222: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 222/231

M

M p

Increasing L b / r y

Page 223: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 223/231

Page 224: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 224/231

Page 225: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 225/231

AISC Seismic Provisions - SMF 9.8 Lateral Bracing of Beams

In addition to lateral braces provided as a maximum spacing

Page 226: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 226/231

of Lb = 0.086r y E / F y :

Lateral braces shall be placed near concentrated forces, changes in cross-section and other locations where analysis indicates that a plastic hinge

will form.

The placement of lateral braces shall be consistent with that specified inANSI/AISC 358 for aPrequalified Connection , or as otherwise determined

by qualification testing.

Page 227: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 227/231

Page 228: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 228/231

ANSI/AISC 358 -Lateral Bracing Requirements for the RBS

For beams with an RBS connection:

Page 229: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 229/231

When a composite concrete floor slab is present, no additionallateral bracing is required at the RBS.

When a composite concrete floor slab is not present, provide anadditional lateral brace at the RBS. Attach brace just outside of the RBS cut, at the end farthest from the column face.

Page 230: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 230/231

Section 9Special Moment Frames (SMF)

9.1 Scope

Page 231: Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

7/27/2019 Presentaion-AISC Seismic Design-Module2-Moment Resisting Frames

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentaion-aisc-seismic-design-module2-moment-resisting-frames 231/231

9.2 Beam-to-Column Joints and Connections9.3 Panel Zone of Beam-to-Column Connections

9.4 Beam and Column Limitations

9.5 Continuity Plates9.6 Column-Beam Moment Ratio

9.7 Lateral Bracing of at Beam-to-Column