· PV\1001717ES.doc PE516.894v01-00 ES Unida en la diversidad ES PARLAMENTO EUROPEO 2009 - 2014...
Transcript of · PV\1001717ES.doc PE516.894v01-00 ES Unida en la diversidad ES PARLAMENTO EUROPEO 2009 - 2014...
PV\1001717ES.doc PE516.894v01-00
ES Unida en la diversidad ES
PARLAMENTO EUROPEO 2009 - 2014
Comisión de Medio Ambiente, Salud Pública y Seguridad Alimentaria
ENVI_PV(2013)0710_1
ACTAReunión de los días 10 de julio de 2013, de las 9.00 a las 12.30 y de las 15.00 a las
18.30 horas,y 11 de julio de 2013, de las 9.00 a las 12.30 horas y de las 15.00 a las 18.30 horas
BRUSELAS
La reunión comienza el miércoles 10 de julio de 2013, a las 9.05 horas, bajo la presidencia de Matthias Groote (presidente).
1. Aprobación del orden del día ENVI_OJ (2013)0710_1v01-00
Se aprueba el orden del día en la forma reflejada por la presente acta.
2. Comunicaciones de la presidencia
Servicio de interpretación: se dispone de todas las lenguas excepto de estonio y maltés.
Información actualizada del presidente sobre los diálogos a tres bandas en curso
Mecanismo de protección civil de la Unión Europea, ponente Elisabetta Gardini: el segundo diálogo a tres bandas tuvo lugar el 8 de julio; el último diálogo a tres bandas está previsto para la segunda mitad de septiembre.
Anuncio de taller sobre salud electrónica el martes 24 de septiembre por la mañana(organizado por el Departamento Temático A).
3. Intercambio de puntos de vista con Valentinas Mazuronis (Ministro de Medio Ambiente de Lituania)ENVI/7/12015
Presentación del programa de la Presidencia del Consejo
PE516.894v01-00 2/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Intervienen: Matthias Groote, Valentinas Mazuronis, Christa Klaß, Linda McAvan, Gerben-Jan Gerbrandy, Satu Hassi, Anna Rosbach, Radvilė Morkūnaitė-Mikulėnienė, Bas Eickhout, Pavel Poc, Marusya Lyubcheva, Corinne Lepage, Justas Vincas Paleckis, Sophie Auconie, Salvatore Tatarella.
4. Intercambio de puntos de vista con Vigilijus Jukna (Ministro de Agricultura de Lituania)ENVI/7/12016
Presentación del programa de la Presidencia del Consejo
Intervienen: Matthias Groote, Vigilijus Jukna, Dagmar Roth-Behrendt, Esther de Lange, Anna Rosbach, Margrete Auken, Mario Pirillo, Corinne Lepage, Horst Schnellhardt, Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Radvilė Morkūnaitė-Mikulėnienė, Franco Bonanini, Marusya Lyubcheva.
5. Presupuesto de 2014
Examen del proyecto de opinión
Intervienen: Jutta Haug, José Manuel Fernandes, Dagmar Roth-Behrendt.
* * *
La reunión se suspende a las 12.37 horas y se reanuda a las 15.05 horas bajo la presidencia de Matthias Groote (presidente).
* * *
6. Derechos del Parlamento en el procedimiento de nombramiento de los futuros directores ejecutivos de la Agencia Europea del Medio Ambiente - modificación del artículo 9 del Reglamento (CE) nº 401/2009 del Parlamento Europeo y del Consejo, de 23 de abril de 2009, relativo a la Agencia Europea del Medio Ambiente y a la Red Europea de Información y de Observación sobre el Medio AmbienteENVI/7/12255
2013/2089(INI)
Ponente: Matthias Groote (S&D) PR – PE510.522v01-00AM – PE514.680v01-00
Fondo: ENVI –
Aprobación del proyecto de informe
Decisión: se aprueba el proyecto de informe así modificado por 64 votos a favor, 0 votos en contra y 0 abstenciones. Se aprueba en su conjunto el proyecto de resolución legislativa por 55 votos a favor, 0 votos en contra y 0 abstenciones.
PV\1001717ES.doc 3/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
7. Programa General de Medio Ambiente de la Unión hasta 2020: «Vivir bien, respetando los límites de nuestro planeta»ENVI/7/11383***I 2012/0337(COD) COM(2012)0710 – C7-0392/2012
Ponente: Gaston Franco (PPE)Fondo: ENVI –Opiniones: EMPL, ITRE, REGI, AGRI, PECH
Aprobación del texto acordado en las negociaciones interinstitucionales de conformidad con el artículo 70, apartado 5
Decisión: se aprueba el texto acordado en las negociaciones interinstitucionales por 54 votos a favor, 6 votos en contra y 6 abstenciones.
8. Reciclado de buquesENVI/7/09192***I 2012/0055(COD) COM(2012)0118 – C7-0082/2012
Ponente: Carl Schlyter (Verts/ALE)Fondo: ENVI –Opiniones: ITRE, TRAN, JURI
Aprobación del texto acordado en las negociaciones interinstitucionales de conformidad con el artículo 70, apartado 5
Decisión: se aprueba el texto acordado en las negociaciones interinstitucionales por 58 votos a favor, 5 votos en contra y 1 abstención.
9. Aproximación de las disposiciones legales, reglamentarias y administrativas de los Estados miembros en materia de fabricación, presentación y venta de los productos del tabaco y los productos relacionadosENVI/7/11570***I 2012/0366(COD) COM(2012)0788 – C7-0420/2012
Ponente: Linda McAvan (S&D) PR – PE508.085v03-00AM – PE510.717v02-00AM – PE510.712v01-00AM – PE510.720v01-00AM – PE510.721v01-00AM – PE510.722v01-00AM – PE510.714v01-00AM – PE510.716v01-00AM – PE510.713v01-00AM – PE510.719v01-00AM – PE510.711v02-00AM – PE510.718v02-00AM – PE510.715v01-00
Fondo: ENVI –Opiniones: INTA – Metin Kazak (ALDE) AD – PE510.734v03-00
AM – PE513.031v01-00
PE516.894v01-00 4/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
ITRE – Robert Goebbels (S&D) AD – PE508.180v02-00AM – PE510.829v01-00AM – PE510.761v01-00
IMCO – Małgorzata Handzlik (PPE) AD – PE508.048v03-00AM – PE510.660v01-00AM – PE510.679v02-00
AGRI – Csaba Sándor Tabajdi (S&D) AD – PE507.956v03-00AM – PE510.614v01-00AM – PE510.646v01-00
JURI – Jiří Maštálka (GUE/NGL)JURI – Klaus-Heiner Lehne (PPE) AD – PE510.591v02-00
AM – PE513.109v02-00
Aprobación del proyecto de informeIntervienen sobre la cuestión de observancia del Reglamento en relación con la lista de votación:
Renate Sommer, que afirma que la enmienda de transacción 24, las enmiendas consolidadas 46, 50 y 53, así como la enmienda de transacción 54, reproducen el texto de la Comisión sin modificación alguna1, lo que, en su opinión, no se ajusta al Reglamento (véase la declaración del anexo II);
Chris Davies, que se muestra de acuerdo con Renate Sommer y añade que, aunque es posible que, técnicamente, la lista de votación respete las normas, podría haber un abuso del principio subyacente a estas, es decir, que los diputados que presentaron enmiendas independientes no tuvieron una oportunidad real de que estas se examinaran como corresponde; el presidente, Matthias Groote, que responde lo siguiente en cuanto a las cuestiones de observancia del Reglamento planteadas por Renate Sommer y Chris Davies:• La votación fue posterior a varios meses de trabajo entre los diputados, la
ponente y de los ponentes alternativos sobre la cuestión en la que se centra la propuesta. En las tres semanas previas a la votación, se elaboró la lista de votación en intensos debates entre la secretaría, el personal de todos los grupos y los ponentes alternativos. Se celebraron varios debates sobre la composición de la lista de votación, en los que participaron la ponente y los ponentes alternativos.
• Para concluir, el presidente confirma que la lista de votación es conforme con el Reglamento.2
1 Enmienda de transacción 24, respaldada por el PPE, S&D, ALDE, Verts/ALE, ECR, GUE/NGL y EFD.Enmienda consolidada 46, respaldada por el S&D, ALDE, Verts/ALE, GUE/NGL y EFD.Enmienda consolidada 50, respaldada por el S&D, ALDE, Verts/ALE y GUE/NGL.Enmienda consolidada 53, respaldada por el PPE, S&D, ALDE, Verts/ALE, GUE/NGL y EFD.Enmienda de transacción 54, respaldada por el PPE, S&D, ALDE, Verts/ALE, ECR, GUE/NGL y EFD.
2 Artículo 161, en particular el párrafo 3: «3. El Presidente podrá someter a votación en primer lugar el texto inicial o la enmienda que se aparte menos de dicho texto, con prioridad sobre la que se aparte más. Si uno u otra obtienen mayoría, decaerán las demás enmiendas al mismo texto». Las disposiciones del artículo 161 son aplicables al comité por analogía, véase el artículo 196.
PV\1001717ES.doc 5/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
• La enmienda de transacción 54 ha recibido el respaldo de todos los grupos políticos y debe entenderse como una solicitud por parte de todos ellos para que se vote el texto de la Comisión en primer lugar.
• El presidente anuncia que los Coordinadores debatirán el asunto y que ya se puede proceder a la votación.
Tras la declaración de la presidencia, no se plantean más objeciones.
Decisión: se aprueba el proyecto de informe así modificado por 51 votos a favor, 12 votos en contra y 8 abstenciones. Se aprueba en su conjunto el proyecto de resolución legislativa por 50 votos a favor, 13 votos en contra y 8 abstenciones.(Véase el resultado de la votación en el anexo III).
* * *
Se suspende la reunión a las 18.30 horas y se reanuda el 11 de julio, a las 9.05 horas, bajo la presidencia de Matthias Groote, presidente.
* * *
10. Modificación de la Directiva relativa a la calidad de los combustibles y de la Directiva sobre energías renovables (cambios de uso de la tierra)ENVI/7/11007***I 2012/0288(COD) COM(2012)0595 – C7-0337/2012
Ponente: Corinne Lepage (ALDE) PR – PE508.236v01-00AM – PE513.032v01-00AM – PE513.034v01-00AM – PE513.033v01-00AM – PE513.035v01-00
Fondo: ENVI* –Opiniones: DEVE – Filip Kaczmarek (PPE) AD – PE510.683v02-00
AM – PE513.092v01-00INTA – Josefa Andrés Barea (S&D) AD – PE508.023v02-00
AM – PE510.651v01-00ITRE* – Alejo Vidal-Quadras (PPE) AD – PE508.012v02-00
AM – PE510.730v01-00AM – PE510.481v01-00
IMCO – Decisión: sin opiniónTRAN – Sabine Wils (GUE/NGL) AD – PE506.337v02-00
AM – PE508.281v02-00REGI – Riikka Pakarinen (ALDE) AD – PE508.069v02-00
AM – PE510.584v01-00AGRI – Béla Glattfelder (PPE) AD – PE508.068v02-00
AM – PE508.271v01-00
Aprobación del proyecto de informe
Decisión: se aprueba el proyecto de informe así modificado por 43 votos a
PE516.894v01-00 6/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
favor, 26 votos en contra y 1 abstención. Se aprueba en su conjunto el proyecto de resolución legislativa por 43 votos a favor, 26 votos en contra y 1 abstención.
(Véase el resultado de la votación en el anexo IV).
11. Modificación de la Directiva 2011/92/UE, relativa a la evaluación de las repercusiones de determinados proyectos públicos y privados sobre el medio ambienteENVI/7/11120***I 2012/0297(COD) COM(2012)0628 – C7-0367/2012
Ponente: Andrea Zanoni (ALDE) PR – PE508.221v01-00AM – PE510.827v01-00AM – PE510.872v01-00AM – PE510.871v01-00AM – PE510.870v01-00
Fondo: ENVI –Opiniones: TRAN – Joseph Cuschieri (S&D) AD – PE510.526v02-00
AM – PE513.124v01-00REGI – Decisión: sin opiniónCULT – Decisión: sin opiniónLIBE – Decisión: sin opiniónPETI – Nikolaos Chountis (GUE/NGL) AD – PE507.937v02-00
AM – PE510.694v02-00
Aprobación del proyecto de informe
Decisión: se aprueba el proyecto de informe así modificado por 43 votos a favor, 13 votos en contra y 3 abstenciones. Se aprueba en su conjunto el proyecto de resolución legislativa por 48 votos a favor, 15 votos en contra y 4 abstenciones.(Véase el resultado de la votación en el anexo V).
12. La reunión de los coordinadores se celebra a puerta cerrada (véase el resultado en el anexo I)
* * *
La reunión se suspende a las 12.30 horas y se reanuda a las 15.00 horas bajo la presidencia de Matthias Groote (presidente).
* * *
13. Intercambio de puntos de vista con Vytenis Povilas Andriukaitis (Ministro de Sanidad de Lituania)ENVI/7/12017
PV\1001717ES.doc 7/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Presentación del programa de la Presidencia del Consejo
Intervienen: Matthias Groote, Vytenis Povilas Andriukaitis, Peter Liese, Linda McAvan, Antonyia Parvanova, Carl Schlyter, Anna Rosbach, Justas Vincas Paleckis, Vittorio Prodi, Dagmar Roth-Behrendt, Radvilė Morkūnaitė-Mikulėnienė, Biljana Borzan.
14. Próxima(s) reunión(es) 5 de septiembre de 2013, en Bruselas 18 de septiembre de 2013, de las 9.00 a las 12.30 horas y de las 15.00 a las 18.30
horas, en Bruselas
* * *
La reunión termina a las 16.20 horas.
* * *
PE516.894v01-00 8/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
ITEM 12 - ANNEX I
EUROPEAN PARLIAMENTCOMMITTEE ON THE ENVIRONMENT, PUBLIC HEALTH AND FOOD SAFETY
CO-ORDINATORS' MEETING
Thursday 11 July 2013, 11.30 - 12.30
Room JAN 4Q2
RESULTS
11 July 2013
PresentMr Groote, ChairmanMr Liese, Co-coordinator of the EPP GroupMs Roth-Behrendt, replacing the Coordinator of the S&D GroupMr Davies, Coordinator of the ALDE GroupMs Hassi, Coordinator of the Greens/EFA GroupMs Girling, replacing the Coordinator of the ECR GroupMr Cymański, Coordinator of the EFD Group
Also presentMr Gerbrandy, 1st Vice-chair
Apologies:Mr Seeber, Co-coordinator of the EPP GroupMs McAvan, Coordinator of the S&D GroupMs Rosbach, Coordinator of the ECR GroupMs Liotard, Coordinator of the GUE/NGL Group
In camera
Decisions on procedure
Reports
A.1. Amending Directives in the fields of environment, agriculture, social policy and public health by reason of the change of status of Mayotte with regard to the UnionENVI/7/13045***I 2013/0192(COD) COM(2013)0418 – C7-0176/2013
Responsible: ENVI –Opinions: EMPL –
PV\1001717ES.doc 9/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
REGI –AGRI –
[JV]
Decision: The Chairman was invited to be the rapporteur for this file
A.2. Fees payable to the European Medicines Agency for the conduct of pharmacovigilance activities in respect of medicinal products for human useENVI/7/13158***I 2013/0222(COD) COM(2013)0472 – C7-0196/2013
Responsible: ENVI –Opinions: ITRE –
IMCO –[NK]
Decision: Rapporteur Ms McAvan (continuation of previous report)
A.3. Monitoring, reporting and verification of carbon dioxide emissions from maritime transport and amendment of Regulation (EU) No 525/2013ENVI/7/13206***I 2013/0224(COD) COM(2013)0480 – C7-0201/2013
Responsible: ENVI –Opinions: ITRE –
TRAN –[GA]
Decision: Rapporteur to be nominated by the ALDE Group
Opinions
A.4. Amending Regulations in the field of fisheries and animal health by reason of the change of status of Mayotte with regard to the UnionENVI/7/13043***I 2013/0191(COD) COM(2013)0417 – C7-0175/2013
Responsible: PECH –[JV]
Decision: No opinion
PE516.894v01-00 10/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
A.5. Financial management for certain Member States experiencing or threatened with serious difficulties with respect to their financial stabilityENVI/7/13056***I 2013/0200(COD) COM(2013)0428 – C7-0178/2013
Responsible: PECH –[JV]
Decision: No opinion
A.6. Voluntary Partnership Agreement between the EU and the Republic of Indonesia on forest law enforcement, governance and trade in timber products to the EUENVI/7/13089*** 2013/0205(NLE) COM(2013)0433
Responsible: INTA –[EC]
Decision: No opinion
A.7. Copernicus ProgrammeENVI/7/13115***I 2013/0164(COD) COM(2013)0312 – C7-0195/2013
Responsible: ITRE –[EI]
Decision: Rapporteur for opinion to be nominated by the EPP Group.
A.8. Adapting a number of legal acts providing for the use of the regulatory procedure with scrutiny to Article 290 of the TFEUENVI/7/13175***I 2013/0218(COD) COM(2013)0451 – C7-0198/2013
Responsible: JURI – József Szájer (PPE)[MF]
Decision: The Chairman was invited to be the rapporteur for opinion.
A.9. Electronic invoicing in public procurementENVI/7/13245***I 2013/0213 (COD) COM(2013)0449 – C7-0208/2013
PV\1001717ES.doc 11/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Responsible: IMCO –[MF]
Decision: No opinion
Documents received for information
[none]
*
* * *
B. DECISIONS ON OTHER ACTIVITIES
B.1. Ongoing own-initiative reports (no more than 6 at any given time):Only for information (the deadline for requesting authorisation of own-initiative reports has expired)
The following ordinary INI reports are currently progressing:
1. On 12 September 2012, the coordinators decided to seek authorisation for the following new own-initiative report "Eco-innovation - Jobs and Growth through environmental policy - approved by CCC on 22 October, CoP 15 November) -Rapporteur Ms KADENBACH, S&D, adoption in ENVI foreseen for 26 September 2013 [MF]
2. Report from the Commission to the Council on the basis of Member States' reports on the implementation of the Council Recommendation (2009/C 151/01) on patient safety, including the prevention and control of healthcare associated infections -COM(2012)0658 - Coordinators' decision of 29 November 2012 - Rapporteur: Mr ROSSI, EFD, approved by CCC 15 January 2013, CoP 6 February 2013 [Vote in ENVI foreseen for 18 September 2013 [EC]
3. On 24 January 2013, the coordinators decided to seek authorisation for the following new own-initiative report Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament, the Council, the European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions: eHealth Action Plan 2012-2020 - Innovative healthcare for the 21st century - COM(2012)0736 - the coordinators decided on 18 December 2012 to short-list this paper as a candidate for a possible own-initiative report, approved by CCC 12 March 2013, CoP on 11 April 2013; rapporteur Ms AYUSO, EPP [Vote in ENVI planned for 5 November 2013 [EC]
4. European Strategy on Plastic Waste in the Environment - Coordinators' decision of 21 March 2013, approved by CCC 21 May 2013, rapporteur Mr PRODI, S&D -adoption in ENVI planned for 5 November 2013 [ZL]
PE516.894v01-00 12/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
5. The food crisis, fraud in the food chain and the control thereof - Coordinators' decision of 21 March 2013, CCC on 16 April 2013, CoP on 16 May 2013; rapporteur Ms DE LANGE, EPP [Vote in ENVI foreseen for 5 November 2013 [EC]
6. Rule 51 to ENVI-ITRE joint own-initiative report on "A 2030 framework for climate and energy policies", as decided in the CCC on 11 June 2013. Authorised by the Conference on 27 June 2013 - timetable to be agreed by rapporteurs DELVAUX (ENVI/EPP) and SZYMANSKI (ITRE/ECR) [MF]
Plus the following legislative own-initiative report:
Parliament's rights in the appointment procedure of future Executive Directors of the European Environment Agency – amendment of Article 9 of Regulation (EC) No 401/2009 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 23 April 2009 on the European Environment Agency and the European Environment Information and Observation Network - On 21 March, the Coordinators, acting on the basis of recommendation from the Conference of Presidents decided to seek authorisation for this legislative INI report, CCC on 16 April 2013, CoP on 16 May 2013, rapporteur Mr GROOTE, Chairman, adopted in ENVI on 10 July 2013 [EI]
B.2. Ongoing implementation reportsOnly for information
One per year - this one for 20131:
Developing and applying carbon capture & storage technology in Europe -Coordinators' decision of 21 March 2013; CCC on 16 April 2013, CoP on 16 May 2013, rapporteur Mr DAVIES, ALDE, vote in ENVI on 27 November 2013 [IF]
B.3. Petitions received for information
1. none
1 The implementation report for 2012: "Improving the delivery of benefits from EU environment measures:
building confidence through better knowledge and responsiveness" - Rapporteur Mr ROSSI, EFD - was adopted on 23 January 2013.
PV\1001717ES.doc 13/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
C. DECISIONS ON OTHER ISSUES
C.1. Calendar for parliamentary work in 2014 - preliminary information on likely number of ENVI meetings before the elections[JK, VPH]
The papers for the meeting include the parliamentary calendar for 2014.
Decision
The Coordinators noted that:
the last plenary session will take place on 14-17 April 2014
a one month cooling off period (counted from the day of the adoption of a report) is usually applied before items can be put on the plenary session agenda
full two-day ENVI meetings will be requested for the following weekso Week 4 (20-23 January)o Week 7 (10-13 February)o Week 12 (17-20 March)o Week 13 (24-27 March) - as a reserve meeting date
Additional half-days (Monday p.m. and/or Thursday a.m. or p.m., depending on availability) will be requested in the following weeks
o Week 5o Week 8o Week 10
The Coordinators agreed to decide on the final ENVI Calendar at a later stage, on the basis of a proposal with more concrete dates and meeting times.
C.2. Additional joint ENVI-ITRE meeting (Rule 51) on "A 2030 framework for climate and energy policies"[MF]
Decision
The Coordinators
agreed that an additional (joint) meeting might be convened on Thursday 7 November 2013, a.m., for a joint exchange of views (rapporteurs Delvaux and Szymanski.
noted that the remaining calendar remained subject to verifications and agreed that the final vote should take place in 2013, i.e. ahead of the presentation of the
PE516.894v01-00 14/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Commission's next communication and of the March 2014 European Council, where the climate and energy framework would be discussed.1
C.3. Organisation of a public hearing on Official Controls (Pirillo report) on 3 October 2013 p.m. - request from Linda McAvan[EC]
Decision
The coordinators :
noted the draft proposal and agreed to organise the proposed hearing during an extraordinary ENVI meeting to be held on Thursday 3 October 2013, 15.00 -18.00 hrs);
agreed to invite up to 8 reimbursed experts, the names of whom shall be agreed among the political groups at a later stage.
agreed that the detailed structure of the hearing would be fine-tuned by the political groups after the summer recess;
instructed the chairman to write to the President, with a view to obtaining authorisation by the Bureau of the European Parliament (meeting on 9 September 2013).
C.4. Provisional agreement on CO2 from cars and vans - decision on steps to be taken
[IF]
Decision
The coordinators held an exchange of views and agreed to return to the matter in September.
1 "The European Council welcomes the Commission's Green Paper on a 2030 framework for climate and
energy policies and will return to this issue in March 2014, after the Commission comes forward with more concrete proposals, to discuss policy options in that regard, bearing in mind the objectives set for the COP 21 in 2015."
http://www.consilium.europa.eu/ueDocs/cms_Data/docs/pressData/en/ec/137197.pdf
PV\1001717ES.doc 15/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
C.5. Wildlife crime - Oral question in plenary plus resolution - request from Chris Davies
[JV]
Decision
The coordinators
decided that ENVI should adopt an Oral Question in plenary, accompanied by a draft resolution;
invited the groups to nominate one co-sponsor of the resolution; decided that the Oral Question shall be tabled on behalf of the Chairman.
C.6. Package on animal and plant health, plant reproductive material, management of expenditure and official controls - requests for Rule 50
[NH]
Proposed action:
The Coordinators took note of the various requests for the application of Rule 50 and agreed that ENVI's powers and responsibilities in this field should be defended.
C.7. Financial consequences of cancellations of participation in committee delegations
[NK & EI]
Proposed action
The agreed that the chair should write to the Director-General of DG Finance in order to raise issues related to practical arrangements pertaining to the cancellation of participation in EP delegations.
PE516.894v01-00 16/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
C.8. Proposal by Satu Hassi to co-organise a seminar with the SEDE committee on Humanitarian Consequences of Nuclear Weapons
Decision
The Coordinators agreed to await further clarifications on this planned event before taking a final decision.
** *
D. DOCUMENTS FOR INFORMATION
1) Letter of 19 June 2013 from Commissioner Hedegaard to Mr Groote on updates on international negotiations
2) Letter of 12 June 2013 from Mr. Groote to Mr. Lehne on the request for Rule 50 status to ENVI, in the relation to the proposals on plant reproductive material and animal health
3) Letter of 25 June 2013 from Mr. De Castro to Mr. Lehne on the request for the application of the procedure with associated committee, under Rule 50, on the Commission proposal on the Official controls Regulation
4) Letter of 25 June 2013 from Mr. De Castro to Mr. Lehne on the request by the Committee on Environment for the application of the procedure with associated committee, under Rule 50, on the Commission proposal on animal health (COM (2013)0260)
5) Letter of 26 June 2013 from Mr. De Castro to Mr. Lehne on argumentation by the Committee on Agriculture against the request by the Committee on Environment for the application of the procedure with associated committee, under Rule 50, on the Commission proposal on plant reproductive material (COM (2013)0262)
6) Calendar of 2014 activities
7) A table from DG Environment on international activities
8) A letter from STOA (call for new STOA projects) - decision to be taken in September
PV\1001717ES.doc 17/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
ANNEX II
Statement by Renate Sommer - Point of order - see Item 9 of the minutes
"WORTMELDUNG ZUR GESCHÄFTSORDNUNG ART. 161(ENVI 10.07.2013)
Ich melde mich zum Geschäftsordnungsartikel Nr. 161 in Bezug auf die nun anstehende Abstimmung über die Tabakproduktrichtlinie und bitte um die Aufnahme meiner Bedenken ins Protokoll!
Die Stimmliste ist nach meiner Auffassung so wie sie ist nicht rechtmäßig:
Sehr viele der sog. "Kompromissänderungsanträge" sind tatsächlich keine Kompromisse, sondern "Consolidated Amendments".
Fünf der sog. Kompromisse, die auch Consolidates umfassen, sind identisch mit dem Kommissionstext:
COMP. 24 zu Rec. 41,Consolidated AM 46 zu Art. 12, Para 2Consolidated AM 50 zu Art. 13, Para 4 (Del. Acts)Consolidated AM 53 zu Art. 14, Para 9 (Del. Acts)COMP. 54 zu Art. 15
Zusätzlich umfassen sehr viele dieser sog. "Kompromissänderungsanträge" ganze Artikel und beinhalten in einzelnen Paragraphen (Absätzen) den Original-Kommissionstext.
Zum Beispiel um nur ein Beispiel zu nennen in Compr. 59 zu Artikel 19 da sind die Absätze 1 und 2 identisch mit dem Kommissionstext, der 3. Absatz ist dann geändert aber alles wird in einem abgestimmt.
Nach meiner Auffassung ist das nicht zulässig, denn Kompromisse können sich nur aus gestellten Änderungsanträgen zusammensetzen, nicht jedoch der reine Kommissionstext ohne jegliche Änderung sein.
Gleichzeitig ist die Komposition der Stimmliste mit diesen zweifelhaften sog. Kompromissen, die ganze Artikel umfassen, aus demokratischer Sicht unverantwortlich. Alle weiteren Änderungsanträge zu den entsprechenden Artikeln sollen jeweils fallen mit Annahme der falschen, partiell den reinen Kommissionstext beinhaltenden sog. Kompromissen. Die Abstimmung von Änderungsanträgen zu Paragraphen bzw. Absätzen, zu denen der sog Kompromiss den reinen KOM-Text beinhaltet, wird so gezielt verhindert.
In meiner 14jährigen Erfahrung im EP habe ich eine derartige Manipulation einer Abstimmung noch in keinem Ausschuss erfahren.
Der Ausschussvorsitzende beruft sich offensichtlich in seiner Zustimmung zur Stimmliste auf Artikel 161 Absatz 3 der Geschäftsordnung. Ich meine aber dass Absatz 1 dieses Artikels dem entgegen steht.
PE516.894v01-00 18/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Ich fordere daher, dass dieser Fall dem Geschäftsordnungsausschuss des EP zur Prüfung und Entscheidung vorgelegt wird und gebe auch dieses zu Protokoll und ich hätte gerne Herr Vorsitzender dass Sie Stellung dazu nehmen."
PV\1001717ES.doc 19/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Item 9 - ANNEX III
VOTING RESULTSon the proposal for a directive of the European Parliament and of the Council on the approximation of the laws, regulations and administrative provisions of the Member
States concerning the manufacture, presentation and sale of tobacco and related products
PR PE508.085v03-00 + AM PE510.713v01-00 + AM PE510.714v01-00 + PE510.715v01-00 + AM PE510.716v01-00 + AM PE510.717v02-00 + AM PE510.718v02-00 + AM
PE510.719v01-00 + AM PE510.720v01-00 + AM PE510.721v01-00 + AM PE510.722v01-00 + AD AGRI PE507.956v03-00 + AD IMCO PE508.048v02-00 + AD INTA PE510.734v03-
00 + AD ITRE PE508.180v02-00 + AD JURI PE510.591v02-00PR PE508.085v03-00 + PE510.714v01-00
Rapporteur: Linda McAvan
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Rejection AM 57 P. van der Kammen
All the amendments
will fall if AM 57 Adopted
-
CONS 25
Article 1
S&D - EPP -ALDE -
GREENS/EFA - EFD -
GUE/NGL
+
Article 1 paragraph 1 introductory part
AM 247 Sari Essayah Falls if CONS 25 Adopted
All Amendments covered by
CONS 25 FellArticle 1 paragraph 1 point b
AM 248 Renate Sommer
Falls if CONS 25 Adopted
Article 1 paragraph 1 point c
AM 249 Morten Messerschmidt
Article 1 paragraph 1 point c
AM 250 C. Engström, C. Davies, C.Fjellner
Falls if CONS 25 Adopted
Identical Deletion
Article 1 paragraph 1 point d
AM 252 Frédérique Ries, Corinne Lepage
Falls if CONS 25 Adopted
Article 1 paragraph 1 point d
AM 251 Martina Anderson
Falls if CONS 25 AM 252 Adopted
PE516.894v01-00 20/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 1 - point d AM 15 Linda McAvan
Article 1 paragraph 1 point d
AM 253 Cristian Silviu Busoi
Article 1 paragraph 1 point d
AM 255 G. Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, C.Morganti,L.Fontana
Article 1 paragraph 1 point d
INTA 13 INTA
Article 1 paragraph 1 point d
IMCO 23 IMCO
Article 1 paragraph 1 point d
AM 254 Eija-Riitta Korhola
Identical
Falls if CONS 25 AM 252-251
Adopted
Article 1 - point e AM 16 Linda McAvan
Withdrawn
Falls if CONS 25 Adopted
W
Article 1 paragraph 1 point f
AM 256 Martina Anderson, Kartika Tamara Liotard
Falls if CONS 25 Adopted
Article 1 paragraph 1 point f
AM 257 Frédérique Ries
Falls if CONS 25 Adopted
CompatibleArticle 1 paragraph 1 point f a (new)
Tracking and tracing TP system
INTA 14 INTA 14 Falls if CONS 25 Adopted
Article 1 paragraph 1 subparagraph 2
AM 258 Petru Constantin Luhan
Falls if CONS 25 Adopted
Article 1 -paragraph 1 -subparagraph 2
AM 17 Linda McAvan
Falls if CONS 25 AM 258
Adopted
Article 1 paragraph 1 subparagraph 2
AM 2591st part
Frédérique Ries
Falls if CONS 25 AM 258-17
Adopted
PV\1001717ES.doc 21/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 1 paragraph 1 subparagraph 2
AM 2592nd part
Frédérique Ries
Falls if CONS 25 Adopted
Compatible as addition
Article 1 paragraph 1 subparagraph 2
AM 260 K-H.Florenz, P. Liese, T.Ulmer,C.Klaß, R.Seeber, R.Sommer
Falls if CONS 25 Adopted
Linguistic AmDE version
COMP 26
Article 2
S&D - EPP -ALDE -
GREENS/EFA - ECR - EFD -
GUE/NGL
+
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 2
AM 261 Holger Krahmer
All Amendments covered by
COMP 26 FellArticle 2 paragraph 1 point 2
AM 262 P. Bartolozzi, E. Gardini, S.Berlato, S.Tatarella, G.La Via,R.Angelilli
Falls if COMP 26 Adopted
IdenticalDeletion
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 2
AM 263 Karl-Heinz Florenz, Thomas Ulmer
Withdrawn
Falls if COMP 26 AM 261-262
Adopted
W
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 2
AM 264 María Auxiliadora Correa Zamora, Esther Herranz García
Falls if COMP 26 AM 261-
262-263 Adopted
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 2
ITRE 22 ITRE Falls if COMP 26 AM 261-262-263-264
AdoptedArticle 2 paragraph 1 point 3
AM 265 J.E. Hibner, M. Handzlik, B. Sonik
Falls if COMP 26 Adopted
PE516.894v01-00 22/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 3
AM 266 P. Bartolozzi, E. Gardini, S.Berlato, G.La Via, R.Angelilli
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 3
IMCO 24 IMCO
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 3
AM 267 G. Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, C.Morganti,L.Fontana
Identical Deletion
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 3
JURI 19 JURI Falls if COMP 26 AM 265 to 267 Adopted
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 4
AM 268 Erik Bánki
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 4
AM 269 J.E. Hibner, M. Handzlik, B. Sonik
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 4
AM 270 Jaroslaw Kalinowski
Falls if COMP 26 Adopted
Identical Deletion
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 4
AM 283 M.Anderson, G.Willmott, K.Tamara Liotard, C.Schlyter, N.Childers, C.Stihler, A.Parvanova
Falls if COMP 26 AM 268-
269-270 Adopted
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 4
AM 273 María Auxiliadora Correa Zamora, Esther Herranz García
Falls if COMP 26 AM 268-269-270-283 Adopted
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 4
AM 271 Holger Krahmer
Falls if COMP 26 AM 268-269-270-273 Adopted
Compatible with 283
PV\1001717ES.doc 23/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 4
INTA 16 INTA 16 Falls if COMP 26 AM 283-268-269-270-273-271
Adopted
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 4
AM 272 Renate Sommer
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 4
AM 277 Christofer Fjellner, Jaroslaw Leszek Walesa
Identical
Falls if COMP 26 AM 268-269-270-273-273-1-
INTA 16 Adopted
Compatible with 283
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 4
AM 275 Frédérique Ries
Falls if COMP 26 AM 268-269-
270-271-273-INTA 16- 272-277 Adopted
Compatible with 283
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 4
AM 274 Marian-Jean Marinescu
Falls if COMP 26 AM 268-269-
270-271-273-272-277-275 Adopted
Compatible with 283
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 4
AM 276 K-H.Florenz, P. Liese, T.Ulmer, R.Seeber
Falls if COMP 26 AM 268-269-270-271-INTA
16- 275 Adopted
Linguistic AmDE version
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 4
AM 278 Jutta Haug Falls if COMP 26 AM 268-269-
270-271-273-INTA 16 -272-277-275-274
Adopted
Compatible with 283
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 4
JURI 20 JURI Falls if COMP 26 AM 268-269-
270-271-273-INTA 16- 272-
277-275-274-278 Adopted
Compatible with 283
PE516.894v01-00 24/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 4
ITRE 23 ITRE Falls if COMP 26 AM 268-269-
270-271-273-INTA 16- 272-
277-275-274-278-JURI 20 Adopted
Compatible with 283
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 4
AM 281 G. Franco, J.E. Hibner, B. Sonik, E.Gardini
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 4
IMCO 25
Identical
Falls if COMP 26 AM 268-269-
270-271-273-INTA 16- 272-
277-275-274-278-JURI 20-ITRE
23 Adopted
Compatible with 283
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 4
AM 279 Ewald Stadler
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 4
AM 284 Milan Cabrnoch
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 4
AM 282 Erik Bánki
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 4
AGRI 21 AGRI
Falls if COMP 26 AM 268-269-
270-271-273-INTA 16 - 272-
277-275-274-278-JURI 20-ITRE 23-281 Adopted
Identical
Compatible with 283
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 4
AM 280 Maria do Céu Patrão Neves
Falls if COMP 26 AM 268-269-
270-271-273-INTA 16 -272-
277-275-274-278-JURI 20-ITRE 23-281-279-284-282-IMCO 25
Adopted
Compatible with 283
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 6
INTA 17 INTA 17 Falls if COMP 26 Adopted
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 8
AM 286 Paul Nuttall, Godfrey Bloom
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 8
AM 287 Holger Krahmer
Falls if COMP 26 INTA 17
Adopted
Identical Deletion
PV\1001717ES.doc 25/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 8
AM 288 Timothy Kirkhope
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 8
IMCO 26 IMCO
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 8
INTA 18 INTA 18
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 8
AM 290 María Auxiliadora Correa Zamora, Esther Herranz García
Falls if COMP 26 INTA 17 and AM 286 to INTA
18 Adopted
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 8
AM 289 Renate Sommer, Monika Hohlmeier
Falls if COMP 26 INTA 17 and AM 286 to INTA 18 and AM 290
Adopted
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 11 introductory part
AM 292 Milan Cabrnoch
Falls if COMP 26 Adopted
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 11 introductory part
AM 293 G. Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, C.Morganti,L.Fontana
Falls if COMP 26 Adopted
Compatible
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 11 point a
AM 294 G. Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, C.Morganti,L.Fontana
Falls if COMP 26 Adopted
Deletion
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 11 point b
AM 295 G. Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, C.Morganti,L.Fontana
Falls if COMP 26 Adopted
Deletion
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 13
AM 297 Jaroslaw Kalinowski
Falls if COMP 26 Adopted
DeletionArticle 2 paragraph 1 point 13
AM 298 Holger Krahmer
Falls if COMP 26 AM 297
Adopted
PE516.894v01-00 26/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 13
AGRI 22 AGRI Falls if COMP 26 AM 297-298
Adopted
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 13
AM 299 María Auxiliadora Correa Zamora, Esther Herranz García
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 13
INTA 19 INTA 19
IdenticalFalls if COMP
26 AM 297 Adopted
Compatible with 298-AGRI 22
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 18
AM 300 Renate Sommer
Falls if COMP 26 Adopted
DeletionArticle 2 paragraph 1 point 18
AM 301 Karl-Heinz Florenz, Thomas Ulmer
Withdrawn
Falls if COMP 26 COMP 26
AM 300 Adopted
W
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 18
AM 303 P. Bartolozzi, E. Gardini, S.Berlato, S.Tatarella, G.La Via,R.Angelilli
Falls if COMP 26 AM 300-301
Adopted
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 18
AM 302 Holger Krahmer
Falls if COMP 26 AM 300-301-
303 Adopted
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 18
INTA 20 INTA 20
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 18
ITRE 24 ITRE
IdenticalFalls if COMP
26 AM 300-301-303-302 Adopted
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 18
AM 304 María Auxiliadora Correa Zamora, Esther Herranz García
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 18
AM 305 Milan Cabrnoch
Identical
Falls if COMP 26 AM 300-301-303-302-INTA
20 Adopted
PV\1001717ES.doc 27/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 18
AM 307 G. Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F.E. Speroni, C.Morganti, L.Fontana
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 18
AGRI 23 AGRI
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 18
AM 306 Izaskun Bilbao Barandica
Falls if COMP 26 AM 300-
301-303-302-INTA 20 -304-
305-307 Adopted
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 19
AM 311 Sergej Kozlík
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 19
AM 312 Eleni Theocharous
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 19
AM 313 Milan Cabrnoch
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 19
JURI 21 JURI
Falls if COMP 26 Adopted
Identical Deletion
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 19
AM 316 P. Bartolozzi, E. Gardini, S.Berlato, S.Tatarella, G.La Via,R.Angelilli
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 19
AGRI 25 AGRI
IdenticalFalls if COMP
26 AM 311-312-313 Adopted
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 19
AM 314 Holger Krahmer
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 19
AM 315 María Auxiliadora Correa Zamora, Esther Herranz García
Identical
Falls if COMP 26 AM 311-312-313-316
Adopted
PE516.894v01-00 28/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 19
AM 317 G. Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F.E. Speroni, C.Morganti, L.Fontana
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 19
IMCO 27 IMCO
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 22
AM 318 Holger Krahmer
Falls if COMP 26 Adopted
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 23
AM 319 Holger Krahmer
Falls if COMP 26 Adopted
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 23
AM 320 Erminia Mazzoni
Falls if COMP 26 AM 319
Adopted
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 23
AM 321 G. Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F.E. Speroni, C.Morganti, L.Fontana
Falls if COMP 26 Adopted
Linguistic amendment of
Italian text
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 23
IMCO 28 IMCO Falls if COMP 26 Adopted
Linguistic amendment does
not affect EN version
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 24 a (new)
Outside transport packaging
AM 323 Martina Anderson, Kartika Tamara Liotard
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 24 a (new)
Outside transport packaging
AM 324 Linda McAvan
Falls if COMP 26 Adopted
Identical
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 25
IMCO 29 IMCO
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 25
INTA 22 INTA 22
Falls IF COMP 26 Adopted
Identical
PV\1001717ES.doc 29/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 25
AM 325 P. Bartolozzi, E. Gardini, S.Berlato, G.La Via, R.Angelilli
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 25
AM 326 G. Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, C.Morganti, L.Fontana
Identical
Falls if COMP 26 IMCO 29
Adopted
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 25
JURI 22 JURI Falls if COMP 26 AM 325-
326-IMCO 29-INTA 22 Adopted
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 26
IMCO 30 IMCO Falls if COMP 26 Adopted
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 26
AM 327 Milan Cabrnoch
Falls if COMP 26 IMCO 30
Adopted
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 26 a (new)
Water pipe tobacco
AM 328 Frédérique Ries
Falls IF COMP 26 Adopted
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 33 a (new)
Tobacco for water pipes
AM 344 Claudiu Ciprian Tanasescu, Minodora Cliveti
Falls if AM 328 Adopted
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 28
IMCO 31 IMCO
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 28
AM 330 Marian Harkin, Pat the Cope Gallagher, Jim Higgins
Falls if COMP 26 IMCO 31
Adopted
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 28
AM 329 Frédérique Ries
Falls if COMP 26 IMCO 31AM 330 Adopted
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 28
AM 331 Emma McClarkin
Falls if COMP 26 IMCO 31
Adopted
Compatible with 330-329
PE516.894v01-00 30/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 30
AM 333 Timothy Kirkhope
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 30
ITRE 26 ITRE 26
Falls if COMP 26 Adopted
IdenticalDeletion
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 30
25% throughout the Union
AM 343 G. Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F.E. Speroni, C.Morganti, L.Fontana
Falls if COMP 26 AM 333 Adopted
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 30
10% in at least five Member States representing at least 5% of the population of the EU
AM 334 Frédérique Ries
Falls if COMP 26 AM 333-343-
Adopted
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 30
20% in the 10 biggest volume Member Statesmarkets
AM 337 María Auxiliadora Correa Zamora, Esther Herranz García
Falls if COMP 26 AM -333-343-
334 Adopted
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 30
20% in the
INTA 23 INTA 23 Falls if COMP 26 AM -333-343-334-337 Adopted
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 30
10% in at least the 10 Member States with the largest market volume
AM 341 Andrés Perelló Rodríguez
Falls if COMP 26 AM 333-343-
334-337 INTA 23 Adopted
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 30
least 10 % in at least the 10 Member States with the highest per capita consumption
AM 342 Izaskun Bilbao Barandica
Falls if COMP 26 AM 333-343-334-337 INTA
23- 341 Adopted
PV\1001717ES.doc 31/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 30
by at least 20%
AM 335 Holger Krahmer
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 30
AM 336 Toine Manders
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 30
AM 338 Renate Sommer
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 30
IMCO 32 IMCO
Identical
Falls if COMP 26 AM 333-343-334-337 INTA 23- 341 342
Adopted
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 30
AM 339 Theodoros Skylakakis
Falls if COMP 26 AM 333-343-334-337 INTA 23- 341 342
AdoptedArticle 2 paragraph 1 point 30
AM 340 Milan Cabrnoch
Falls if COMP 26 Adopted
Compatible as addition
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 34
AM 345 Georgios Koumoutsakos
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 34
AGRI 26 AGRI
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 34
AM 348 María Auxiliadora Correa Zamora, Esther Herranz García
Falls if COMP 26 Adopted
Identical
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 34
AM 346 Frédérique Ries
Falls if COMP 26 Adopted
CompatibleArticle 2 paragraph 1 point 34
AM 347 Cristian Silviu Busoi
Falls if COMP 26 Adopted
CompatibleArticle 2 paragraph 1 point 36
AM 349 Theodoros Skylakakis
Falls if COMP 26 Adopted
PE516.894v01-00 32/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 18 c (new)
Natural constituent
AM 310 G. Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F.E. Speroni, C.Morganti, L.Fontana
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 18 c (new)
Natural constituent
AGRI 24 AGRI
Identical
Falls if COMP 26 Adopted
NEW DEFINITIONS
To be voted as addition
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 36 a (new)
Imitation tobacco products
AGRI 27 AGRI +
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 36 a (new)
Imitation tobacco products
AM 350 Esther de Lange
Falls if AGRI 27 Adopted
F
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 36 b (new)
Passive smoking
AM 351 Frédérique Ries, Corinne Lepage
+
Article 2 - point 36 a (new)
Reduced risk product
AM 209 Maria do Céu Patrão Neves
-
Article 2 - point 36 a (new)
IMCO 34 IMCO
Identical
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 2 a (new)
Essential Additive
INTA 15 INTA 15 -
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 4 a (new)
Menthol Flavour
AM 285 Frédérique Ries
Falls if AM 281 Adopted
-
PV\1001717ES.doc 33/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 8 a (new)
E-Cigarettes definition
AM 291 Martina Anderson, Kartika Tamara Liotard
-
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 18 a (new)
Reconstituted tobacco
INTA 21 INTA 21 -
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 36 a (new)
ITRE 27 ITRE
Identical
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 18 a (new)
Reconstituted tobacco
AM 308 G. Franco Falls if INTA 21-ITRE 27
Adopted
-
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 18 b (new)
Tobacco definition
AM 309 Karl-Heinz Florenz, Thomas Ulmer
Withdrawn W
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 28 a (new)
Make-your-own tobacco
AM 332 Emma McClarkin
-
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 36 point a (new)
Reduced-harm tobacco product
JURI 23 JURI -
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 23 point i (new)
Tobacco produts lower risk
ITRE 25 ITRE Falls if AM JURI 23 Adopted
-
PE516.894v01-00 34/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 23 point i (new)
Reduced-risk tobacco product
AM 322 Mario Pirillo, Gianni Pittella
Falls if AM JURI 23-ITRE
25 Adopted
-
Article 3 paragraph 1Introductory part
ITRE 28 ITRE -
Article 3 paragraph 1
IMCO 35 1st part
IMCO Compatible+
(+ 43-24)Article 3 paragraph 1 point a
AM 352 Daniël van der Stoep
Falls if IMCO 35 1st part Adopted
F
Article 3 paragraph 1 point b
AM 353 Daniël van der Stoep
Falls if IMCO 35 1st part Adopted
F
Article 3 paragraph 1 point c
AM 354 Daniël van der Stoep
Falls if IMCO 351st part Adopted
F
Article 3 paragraph 1 point c a (new)
Polonium 210
AM 355 Carl Schlyter, Satu Hassi
Compatible as addition
-(+35-35)
CONS 27
Article 3 paragraph 2
S&D - EPP -ALDE -
GREENS/EFA - EFD -GUE/NGL
+
Article 3 paragraph 2
AM 356 Paul Nuttall, Godfrey Bloom
All Amendments covered by
CONS 27 FellArticle 3 paragraph 2
AM 357 Paul Nuttall, Godfrey Bloom
Article 3 paragraph 2
AM 358 Gaston Franco
Article 3 paragraph 2
AM 359 Milan Cabrnoch
Article 3 paragraph 2
AM 360 Sergej Kozlík
Article 3 paragraph 2
AM 361 Holger Krahmer
Falls if CONS 27 Adopted
Identical Deletion
PV\1001717ES.doc 35/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 3 paragraph 2
AM 362 Morten Messerschmidt
Article 3 paragraph 2
AM 363 Eleni Theocharous
Article 3 paragraph 2
AM 364 Cristian Silviu Busoi
Article 3 paragraph 2
AM 365 Renate Sommer, Monika Hohlmeier
Article 3 paragraph 2
AM 366 P. Bartolozzi, E. Gardini, S.Berlato, S.Tatarella, G.La Via,R.Angelilli
Article 3 paragraph 2
AM 367 Ewald Stadler
Article 3 paragraph 2
AM 368 Andrés Perelló Rodríguez
Article 3 paragraph 2
AM 369 Erik Bánki
Article 3 paragraph 2
JURI 24 JURI
Article 3 paragraph 2
ITRE 29 ITRE
Article 3 paragraph 2
IMCO 352nd part
IMCO
Article 3 paragraph 2
AM 370 Martin Callanan
Article 3 paragraph 2
AM 372 Georgios Koumoutsakos
Falls if COMP 27 AM 356 to 370 Adopted
Article 3 paragraph 2
AGRI 28 AGRI Falls if COMP 27 AM 356 to 370 - AM 372
AdoptedArticle 3 paragraph 2
AM 371 María Auxiliadora Correa Zamora, Esther Herranz García
Falls if COMP 27 AM 356 to
370 - AM 372 -AGRI 28 Adopted
PE516.894v01-00 36/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 3 paragraph 2
AM 374 Petru Constantin Luhan
Falls if COMP 27 AM 356 to 370 - AM 372-371-AGRI 28
AdoptedArticle 3 -paragraph 2
AM 18 Linda McAvan
Falls if COMP 27 AM 356 to 370 AM 372-
AGRI 28-371-374 Adopted
Article 3 paragraph 2
AM 373 G. Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F.E. Speroni, C.Morganti, L.Fontana
Falls if COMP 27 AM 356 to 370 AM 372-
AGRI 28-371-374- 18 Adopted
COMP 28
Article 3 paragraph 3
S&D - EPP -ALDE -
GREENS/EFA - ECR - EFD -
GUE/NGL
+
Article 3 paragraph 3
AM 375 Paul Nuttall, Godfrey Bloom
All Amendments covered by
COMP 28 FellArticle 3 paragraph 3
AM 376 Gaston Franco
Article 3 paragraph 3
AM 377 Milan Cabrnoch
Article 3 paragraph 3
AM 378 Sergej Kozlík
Article 3 paragraph 3
AM 379 Eleni Theocharous
Article 3 paragraph 3
AM 380 Cristian Silviu Busoi
Article 3 paragraph 3
AM 381 Erik Bánki
Article 3 paragraph 3
AM 382 Martin Callanan
Article 3 paragraph 3
ITRE 30 ITRE
Article 3 paragraph 3
JURI 25 JURI
Article 3 paragraph 3
AM 383 Christel Schaldemose
Falls if COMP 28 Adopted
Identical Deletion
Article 3 paragraph 3
AM 384 Holger Krahmer
Article 3 paragraph 3
AM 385 Renate Sommer
IdenticalFalls if COMP 28 AM 375 to 383 Adopted
PV\1001717ES.doc 37/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 3 paragraph 3
AM 386 P. Bartolozzi, E. Gardini, S.Berlato, S.Tatarella, G.La Via,R.Angelilli
Article 3 paragraph 3
AM 387 Ewald Stadler
Article 3 paragraph 3
AM 388 Andrés Perelló Rodríguez
Article 3 paragraph 3
AM 389 G. Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F.E. Speroni, C.Morganti, L.Fontana
Article 3 paragraph 3
IMCO 353rd part
IMCO
Article 3 paragraph 3
AM 390 Georgios Koumoutsakos
Falls if COMP 28 AM 375 to
383 or AM 384 to 389 Adopted
Article 3 paragraph 3
AGRI 29 AGRI Falls if COMP 28 AM 375 to
383 or AM 384 to 389 and AM 390 Adopted
Article 3 paragraph 3
AM 391 María Auxiliadora Correa Zamora, Esther Herranz García
Falls if COMP 28 AM 375 to
383 or AM 384 to 389 and AM 390- AGRI 29
Adopted
Article 3 -paragraph 3
AM 19 Linda McAvan
Falls if COMP 28 AM 375 to
383 or AM 384 to 389 and AM 390-AGRI 29-391 Adopted
Article 3 paragraph 3
AM 392 Izaskun Bilbao Barandica
Falls if COMP 28 AM 375 to
383 or AM 384 to 389 Adopted
Compatible with others
PE516.894v01-00 38/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 3 paragraph 3 a (new)
AM 394 G. Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F.E. Speroni, C.Morganti, L.Fontana
Falls if COMP 28 AM 390-391
Adopted
Compatible with others
COMP 2Recital 10Article 3 paragraph 3 a (new)
S&D - EPP -ALDE -
GREENS/EFA - ECR - EFD -
GUE
+
Article 3 paragraph 3 a (new)
Maximum yields for other emissions of cigarettes and for emissions of tobacco products other than cigarettes
AM 393 Christel Schaldemose
Falls if COMP 2 AM 390-19-394 Adopted
All Amendments covered by
COMP 2 Fell
COMP 29
Article 4 paragraph 1 1-2
S&D - EPP -ALDE -
GREENS/EFA - ECR - EFD -
GUE/NGL
+
Article 4 paragraph 1 subparagraph 1
AM 395 Paul Nuttall, Godfrey Bloom
Falls if COMP 29 Adopted
Deletion
All Amendments covered by
COMP 29 FellArticle 4 -paragraph 1subparagraph 1
AM 201st Part
Linda McAvan
Article 4 -paragraph 1subparagraph 1
IMCO 36 1st part
IMCO
Falls if COMP 29 Adopted
IdenticalFalls if COMP
29AM 395 Adopted
Subparagraph 1Article 4 -paragraph 1subparagraph 2
AM 202nd Part
Linda McAvan
Article 4 -paragraph 1subparagraph 2
IMCO 36 2nd part
IMCO
Falls if COMP 29 Adopted
Identical
PV\1001717ES.doc 39/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 4 paragraph 2 subparagraph 1
AM 398 Claudiu Ciprian Tanasescu, Minodora Cliveti
Falls if COMP 29 Adopted
Article 4 paragraph 2 subparagraph 1
IMCO 363rd part
IMCO Falls if COMP 29 AM 398
Adopted
Article 4 paragraph 2 subparagraph 2
AM 399 Paul Nuttall, Godfrey Bloom
Falls if COMP 29 Adopted
DeletionArticle 4 paragraph 2 subparagraph 2
AM 400 Christel Schaldemose, Dan Jørgensen
Falls if COMP 29 AM 399
Adopted
Article 4 paragraph 2 subparagraph 2
IMCO 364th part
IMCO Falls if COMP 29 AM 399-400
Adopted
Article 4 paragraph 1 subparagraph 2 a (new)
ISO standard to measure Polonium 210
AM 397 Carl Schlyter, Satu Hassi
+
(+35-34)
Article 4 paragraph 1 subparagraph 2 a (new)
Tests verifying the validity of the result supplied by the tobacco companies
AM 396 Anna Rosbach
+
CONS 30
Article 4 paragraph 3
S&D - EPP -ALDE -
GREENS/EFA - EFD -
GUE/NGL
+
Article 4 paragraph 3
AM 401 Paul Nuttall, Godfrey Bloom
All Amendments covered by
CONS 30 FellArticle 4 paragraph 3
AM 402 Gaston Franco
Article 4 paragraph 3
AM 403 Milan Cabrnoch
Falls if CONS 30 Adopted
Identical Deletion
PE516.894v01-00 40/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 4 paragraph 3
ITRE 31 ITRE
Article 4 paragraph 3
AM 404 Holger Krahmer
Article 4 paragraph 3
AM 406 Georgios Koumoutsakos
Falls if CONS 30 AM 401-402-403-404
AdoptedArticle 4 paragraph 3
AM 405 María Auxiliadora Correa Zamora, Esther Herranz García
Article 4 paragraph 3
AGRI 30 AGRI
IdenticalFalls if CONS 30 AM 401-
402-403-404-406 Adopted
Article 4 paragraph 3
IMCO 365th part
IMCO IdenticalFalls if CONS 30 AM 401-
402-403-404-406-405 Adopted
COMP 31
Article 4 paragraph 4
S&D - EPP -ALDE -
GREENS/EFA - ECR - EFD -
GUE/NGL
+
Article 4 paragraph 4
AM 407 Paul Nuttall, Godfrey Bloom
All Amendments covered by
COMP 31 FellArticle 4 paragraph 4
AM 408 Gaston Franco
Article 4 paragraph 4
AM 409 Milan Cabrnoch
Article 4 paragraph 4
AM 410 Holger Krahmer
Article 4 paragraph 4
AGRI 31 AGRI
Article 4 paragraph 4
ITRE 32 ITRE
Article 4 paragraph 4
AM 411 Christel Schaldemose
Falls if COMP 31 Adopted
Identical Deletion
Article 4 paragraph 4
IMCO 366th part
IMCO Falls if COMP 31 AM 407-
408-409-410-411 Adopted
PV\1001717ES.doc 41/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 4 paragraph 4
AM 412 Georgios Koumoutsakos
Falls if COMP 31 AM 407-
408-409-410-411-IMCO 36
6th part Adopted
Article 4 paragraph 4
AM 413 G. Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F.E. Speroni, C.Morganti, L.Fontana
Falls if COMP 31 AM 407-
408-409-410-411 Adopted
Compatible with 412-
IMCO 36th 6th part
Article 4 paragraph 4
AM 414 Martina Anderson, Kartika Tamara Liotard
Falls if COMP 31 AM 407-
408-409-410-411 Adopted
Compatible with IMCO 36 6th part-412-
413Article 4 paragraph 4 a (new)
Notification to the Commission of any methods of measurement
AM 416 G. Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F.E. Speroni, C.Morganti, L.Fontana
Falls if COMP 31 Adopted
Compatible
Article 4 paragraph 4 a (new)
Accordance to ISO 8243
IMCO 36 7thpart
IMCO Compatible as addition
+
Article 4 paragraph 4 a (new)
New standard methods of measurement for nicotin tar and carbon monoxide and other emissions
AM 415 Christel Schaldemose
Falls if COMP 2 Adopted
F
COMP 32
Article 5 paragraph 1 subparagraph 1
S&D - EPP -ALDE -
GREENS/EFA - ECR - EFD -
GUE/NGL
+
PE516.894v01-00 42/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 5 paragraph 1 subparagraph 1
AM 417 Paul Nuttall, Godfrey Bloom
Falls if COMP 32 Adopted
Deletion
All Amendments covered by
COMP 32 FellArticle 5 paragraph 1 subparagraph 1
AM 418 Holger Krahmer
Falls if COMP 32 AM 417
Adopted
Article 5 paragraph 1 subparagraph 1
AM 419 Frédérique Ries, Corinne Lepage
Falls if COMP 32 AM 417-418 Adopted
Article 5 paragraph 1 subparagraph 1
AM 420 Milan Cabrnoch
Falls if COMP 32 AM 417-418 Adopted
Compatible with 419
Article 5 paragraph 1 subparagraph 1
ITRE 33 ITRE Falls if COMP 32 AM 417
Adopted
Compatible with others
Article 5 paragraph 1 subparagraph 1
IMCO 37 Falls if COMP 32 AM 417
Adopted
Compatible with others
Article 5 paragraph 1 subparagraph 1
AM 421 Georgios Koumoutsakos
Falls if COMP 32 AM 417-IMCO 37 Adopted
Compatible with others
Article 5 paragraph 1 a (new)
Precautionary principleREACH compliance and scientific dossiers to ECHA
AM 422 Karl-Heinz Florenz, Thomas Ulmer, Sophie Auconie
Falls if COMP 32 Adopted
Article 5 paragraph 1 subparagraph 2
AM 423 Paul Nuttall, Godfrey Bloom
Falls if COMP 32 Adopted
DeletionArticle 5 paragraph 1 subparagraph 2
AM 424 Holger Krahmer
Falls if COMP 32 AM 423
Adopted
PV\1001717ES.doc 43/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 5 paragraph 1 subparagraph 2
AM 425 K-H.Florenz, P. Liese, T.Ulmer, S.Auconie
Falls if COMP 32 AM 423-424
Adopted
Article 5 -paragraph 2
AM 21 Linda McAvan
Article 5 paragraph 2
AM 426 Milan Cabrnoch
Article 5 paragraph 2
AM 427 Martin Callanan
Article 5 paragraph 2
ITRE 34 ITRE
Falls if COMP 32 Adopted
Identical
Article 5 paragraph 3
AM 428 Paul Nuttall, Godfrey Bloom
Article 5 paragraph 3
AM 429 Renate Sommer, Monika Hohlmeier
Falls if COMP 32 Adopted
Identical Deletion
Article 5 paragraph 4
AM 430 Holger Krahmer
Article 5 paragraph 4
AM 431 Renate Sommer, Monika Hohlmeier
Falls if COMP 32 Adopted
Identical Deletion
Article 5 paragraph 4
AM 432 Izaskun Bilbao Barandica
Falls if COMP 32 AM 430-431
Adopted
Article 5 paragraph 4
AM 433 Sari Essayah Falls if COMP 32 AM 430-431-432 Adopted
Article 5 paragraph 4
AM 434 Theodoros Skylakakis
Falls if COMP 32 AM 430-
431-432 Adopted
Compatible with 433
Article 5 paragraph 5
AM 435 Paul Nuttall, Godfrey Bloom
Article 5 paragraph 5
AM 436 Renate Sommer, Monika Hohlmeier
Falls if COMP 32 AdoptedIdentical Deletion
Article 5 paragraph 5
AM 437 Milan Cabrnoch
Falls if COMP 32 AM 435-436
Adopted
PE516.894v01-00 44/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 5 -paragraph 5 a (new)
Commission Report on information under art 5
AM 23 Linda McAvan
Falls if COMP 32 Adopted
Article 5 -paragraph 6
AM 24 Linda McAvan
Falls if COMP 32 Adopted
Article 5 paragraph 6 a (new)
AM 438 Renate Sommer
Falls if COMP 32 AM 417-421 Adopted
Article 5 paragraph 6 a (new)
Temporary exemption from the requirement on info on emissions and yields
AM 439 Holger Krahmer
Article 5 paragraph 6 a (new)
IMCO 38 IMCO
Falls if COMP 32 AM 417-421
Adopted
Article 5 paragraph 6 a (new)
Proportionate fees may be charged by Member States for personalised medicines
AM 440 Petru Constantin Luhan
Falls if COMP 32 Adopted
Article 5 -paragraph 4 a (new)
Disclosure of the expenditure on advertising, promotion and sponsorship
AM 22 Linda McAvan
+(+40-30)
Article 5 paragraph 6 a (new)
Temporary exemption from the requirement on info on emissions and yields
AM 441 G. Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F.E. Speroni, C.Morganti, L.Fontana
Falls if AM 439 Adopted
-
CONS 33
Article 6
S&D - EPP -GREENS/EFA
- EFD -GUE/NGL
+(+45-24)
PV\1001717ES.doc 45/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 6 AM 442 Daniël van der Stoep
Falls if CONS 33 Adopted
Deletion
All Amendments covered by
CONS 33 FellArticle 6 IMCO 39 IMCO Falls if CONS
33 AM 442 Adopted
Article 6 ITRE 35 ITRE Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39 Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 1
AM 443 Paul Nuttall, Godfrey Bloom
Deletion
Falls if 442-IMCO 39-ITRE 35 Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 1 subparagraph 1
AM 446 Milan Cabrnoch
Article 6 paragraph 1 subparagraph 1
AM 447 Godfrey Bloom
Article 6 paragraph 1 subparagraph 1
AM 448 Jaroslaw Kalinowski
Article 6 paragraph 1 subparagraph 1
AM 449 Renate Sommer, Monika Hohlmeier
Article 6 paragraph 1 subparagraph 1
AM 450 Marian-Jean Marinescu
Identical Deletion
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-443 Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 1 subparagraph 1
Positive List
AM 445 Karl-Heinz Florenz, Thomas Ulmer
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-443-446 to 450 Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 1 subparagraph 1
Positive List
AM 451 G. Willmott, K.T. Liotard, C. Schlyter, N. Childers, C. Stihler, A.
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-443-446 to 450 and 445 Adopted
PE516.894v01-00 46/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Parvanova, K. Van Brempt
Split Voterequested by S&D:First part:The whole textwithout the words"or substances that increase palatability"
2nd part:these words
Article 6 paragraph 1 subparagraph 1
AM 444 Toine Manders
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-443-446-to 450 and
445-451Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 1 subparagraph 1
AM 452 Erik Bánki Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-443-and 446 to 450
and 445-444 Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 1 subparagraph 1
INTA 24 INTA 24 Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-443-and 446 to 450 and 445-444-452 Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 1 subparagraph 1
AM 453 Marian Harkin, Pat the Cope Gallagher, Jim Higgins
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-443-and 446 to 450 and 445-444-452 INTA 24
AdoptedArticle 6 paragraph 1 subparagraph 1
AM 461 Christian Engström, Chris Davies, Christofer Fjellner
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-443-and 446 to 450 and 445-444-
452 INTA 24 -453 Adopted
PV\1001717ES.doc 47/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 6 paragraph 1 subparagraph 1
AM 454 María Auxiliadora Correa Zamora, Esther Herranz García
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-443-and 446 to 450 and 445-444-
452 INTA 24 -453-461 Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 1 subparagraph 1
AGRI 33 AGRI Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-443-and 446 to 450 and 445-444-
452 INTA 24 -453-454 Adopted
Compatible with 461
Article 6 paragraph 1 subparagraph 1
AM 455 Andrés Perelló Rodríguez
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-443-and 446 to 450 and 445-444-
452 INTA 24 -453-454 -AGRI 33 Adopted
Compatible with 461
Article 6 paragraph 1 subparagraph 1
AM 458 Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Malgorzata Handzlik, Boguslaw Sonik
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-443-and 446 to 450 and 445-444-
452 INTA 24 -453-454 -AGRI 33 Adopted
Compatible with 461-455
PE516.894v01-00 48/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 6 paragraph 1 subparagraph 1
AM 456 Anna Rosbach
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-443-and AM 446 to 450-444-445-
451-452-Adopted
Compatible as addition to
453-AGRI 33-461-454-455-
458Article 6 paragraph 1 subparagraph 1
AM 457 Claudiu Ciprian Tanasescu, Minodora Cliveti
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-443-and AM 446 to 450-444-445-
451-452-AGRI 33 Adopted
Compatible as addition to
453-461-454-455-458-456
Article 6 paragraph 1 subparagraph 1
AM 459 Georgios Koumoutsakos
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-443-and AM 446 to 450-444-445-
451-452-Adopted
Compatible as addition to
453-AGRI 33-461-454-455-458-456-457
Article 6 paragraph 1 subparagraph 1
AM 460 Christofer Fjellner
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-443-and AM 446 to 450-444-445-
451-452-AGRI 33-454-455-457
Adopted
Compatible as addition to
453-461-458-456-459
PV\1001717ES.doc 49/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 6 paragraph 1 subparagraph 1
JURI 26 JURI Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-443-and AM 446 to
450-451 and 457-458 Adopted
Compatible as addition to
othersArticle 6 paragraph 1 subparagraph 2
AM 462 Karl-Heinz Florenz, Thomas Ulmer
DeletionFalls if CONS 33 AM 442-
IMCO 39-ITRE 35-443AdoptedFalls if AM 445 NOT Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 1 subparagraph 2
AM 478 Elena Oana Antonescu
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-443-462 Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 1 subparagraph 2
AM 479 G. Willmott, K.T. Liotard, C. Schlyter, N. Childers, C. Stihler, A.Parvanova, K. Van Brempt
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-443-462-478 Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 1 subparagraph 2
AM 466 Godfrey Bloom
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-443-462-478-479
Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 1 subparagraph 2
AM 477 Marian Harkin, Pat the Cope Gallagher, Jim Higgins
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-443-462-478-479-466 Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 1 subparagraph 2
AM 465 Marian-Jean Marinescu
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-443-462-478-479-
466-477 Adopted
PE516.894v01-00 50/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 6 paragraph 1 subparagraph 2
AGRI 34 AGRI Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-443-462-478-479-466-477-465
Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 1 subparagraph 2
AM 467 María Auxiliadora Correa Zamora, Esther Herranz García
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-443-462-478-479-466-477-465
AGRI 34 Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 1 subparagraph 2
AM 469 Jaroslaw Kalinowski
Article 6 paragraph 1 subparagraph 2
AM 471 Erik Bánki
Identical
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-443-462-478-479-466-477-465-AGRI 34-467
Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 1 subparagraph 2
AM 463 Milan Cabrnoch
Article 6 paragraph 1 subparagraph 2
AM 464 J.E. Hibner, M. Handzlik, B. Sonik
Article 6 paragraph 1 subparagraph 2
AM 470 Renate Sommer, Monika Hohlmeier
Article 6 paragraph 1 subparagraph 2
JURI 27 JURI 27
IdenticalFalls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-443-462-478-479-466-477-465-
AGRI 34-467-469-471 Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 1 subparagraph 2
AM 468 P. Bartolozzi, E. Gardini, S.Berlato, G.La Via, R.Angelilli
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-443-462-478-479-466-477-465-
AGRI 34-467-469-471-463-
464-470 Adopted
PV\1001717ES.doc 51/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 6 paragraph 1 subparagraph 2
AM 472 Holger Krahmer
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-443-462-478-479-466-477-465-
AGRI 34-467-469-471-463-464-470-468
Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 1 subparagraph 2
AM 474 Claudiu Ciprian Tanasescu, Minodora Cliveti
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-443-462-478-479-466-477-465-
AGRI 34-467-469-471-463-
464-470 Adopted
Compatible with 468-472
Article 6 paragraph 1 subparagraph 2
AM 473 Frédérique Ries
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-443-462-AGRI 34
Compatible with others as
additionArticle 6 paragraph 1 subparagraph 2
AM 475 Marit Paulsen
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-443-462-479
Compatible with others
Article 6 paragraph 1 subparagraph 2
AM 476 Christian Engström, Chris Davies, Christofer Fjellner
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-443-462-466
Compatible with others
Article 6 paragraph 1 subparagraph 3
AM 480 Milan Cabrnoch
Article 6 paragraph 1 subparagraph 3
AM 481 Renate Sommer, Monika Hohlmeier
Falls if CONS 33 442-IMCO 39-ITRE 35
Adopted
Identical Deletion
PE516.894v01-00 52/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 6 paragraph 1 subparagraph 3
AM 482 Karl-Heinz Florenz, Thomas Ulmer
Article 6 paragraph 1 subparagraph 3
AM 483 G. Willmott, K.T. Liotard, C. Schlyter, N. Childers, C. Stihler, A.Parvanova, K. Van Brempt
AM 482 Falls also if AM 445 NOT Adopted
AM 483 Falls also if AM 451 NOT Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 1 subparagraph 3
AM 484 Riikka Manner
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-480-481-482-483
AdoptedArticle 6 paragraph 2
AM 485 Erik Bánki
Article 6 paragraph 2
AM 486 G. Willmott, K.T. Liotard, C. Schlyter, N. Childers, C. Stihler, A.Parvanova, K. Van Brempt
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-445-451 Adopted
Identical Deletion
AM 486 Falls also if AM 451 NOT Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 2 subparagraph 1
AM 487 Milan Cabrnoch
Article 6 paragraph 2 subparagraph 1
AM 488 Holger Krahmer
Article 6 paragraph 2 subparagraph 1
AM 489 Jaroslaw Kalinowski
Article 6 paragraph 2 subparagraph 1
AM 490 Renate Sommer, Monika Hohlmeier
Article 6 paragraph 2 subparagraph 1
AM 491 Jutta Haug
Article 6 paragraph 2 subparagraph 1
AM 492 Karl-Heinz Florenz, Thomas Ulmer
Identical Deletion
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35 485-486 Adopted
492 Falls also if AM 445 NOT
Adopted
PV\1001717ES.doc 53/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 6 paragraph 2 subparagraph 1
JURI 28 JURI
Article 6 paragraph 2 subparagraph 1
AM 493 Evelyn Regner, Karin Kadenbach
Article 6 paragraph 2 subparagraph 1
AM 494 Elena Oana Antonescu
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-445-451-485-486
and 487 to 493 Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 2 subparagraph 1
AM 495 María Auxiliadora Correa Zamora, Esther Herranz García
Article 6 paragraph 2 subparagraph 1
AGRI 35 AGRI
Identical
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-485-486 and 487 to 493 and 494
Adopted
Article 6 -paragraph 2 -subparagraph 1
AM 25 Linda McAvan
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35- 445-451-485-486
and 487 to 493 and 494 Adopted
Compatible with 495
Article 6 paragraph 2 subparagraph 2
AM 496 Milan Cabrnoch
Article 6 paragraph 2 subparagraph 2
AM 497 Jaroslaw Kalinowski
Article 6 paragraph 2 subparagraph 2
AM 498 María Auxiliadora Correa Zamora, Esther Herranz García
Identical Deletion
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-485-486 Adopted
AM 500 Falls also if AM 445 NOT Adopted
PE516.894v01-00 54/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 6 paragraph 2 subparagraph 2
AM 499 Renate Sommer, Monika Hohlmeier
Article 6 paragraph 2 subparagraph 2
JURI 29 JURI
Article 6 paragraph 2 subparagraph 2
AM 500 Karl-Heinz Florenz, Thomas Ulmer
Article 6 -paragraph 2 -subparagraph 2
AM 26 Linda McAvan Falls if CONS
33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-445-451-485-486
and AM 496 to 500 Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 2 subparagraph 2
AM 501 G. Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F. E. Speroni, C.Morganti, L.Fontana
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-445-451-485-486
and AM 496 to 500 and AM 26
AdoptedArticle 6 paragraph 3
AM 502 Gaston Franco
Article 6 paragraph 3
AM 503 Holger Krahmer
Article 6 paragraph 3
AM 504 María Auxiliadora Correa Zamora, Esther Herranz García
Article 6 paragraph 3
AM 505 Renate Sommer
Article 6 paragraph 3
AM 506 Jaroslaw Kalinowski
Article 6 paragraph 3
AM 507 Jutta Haug
Article 6 paragraph 3
AM 508 Karl-Heinz Florenz, Thomas Ulmer
Article 6 paragraph 3
AM 509 Erik Bánki
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-ITRE 35 AdoptedIdentical Deletion
AM 508 Falls also if AM 445 NOT Adopted
PV\1001717ES.doc 55/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 6 paragraph 3
AM 510 Milan Cabrnoch
Article 6 paragraph 3
JURI 30 JURI
Article 6 paragraph 3
AGRI 36 AGRI
Article 6 paragraph 3
AM 511 Georgios Koumoutsakos
Falls if CONS 33 442-IMCO 39-ITRE 35
AGRI 32 AM 502 to 510 Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 3
AM 512 G. Willmott, K.T. Liotard, C. Schlyter, N. Childers, C. Stihler, A.Parvanova, K. Van Brempt
Falls if CONS 33 442-IMCO 39-ITRE 35
AM 502 to 510 and AM 511
Adopted
Falls also if AM 451 NOT
Adopted
Split Voterequested by S&D:First part:The whole textwithout the words"or increase palatability"
2nd part:these words
Article 6 paragraph 4
AM 513 Holger Krahmer
Article 6 paragraph 4
AM 514 Karl-Heinz Florenz, Thomas Ulmer
Identical Deletion
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-ITRE 35Adopted
AM 514 Falls also if AM 445 NOT Adopted
Article 6paragraph 4 introductory part
AM 515 Renate Sommer
Falls if CONS 33 442-IMCO
39-ITRE 35 AM 513-514
Adopted
PE516.894v01-00 56/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 6 paragraph 4 introductory part
AM 516 G. Willmott, K.T. Liotard, C. Schlyter, N. Childers, C. Stihler, A.Parvanova, K. Van Brempt
Falls if CONS 33 442-IMCO 39-ITRE 35
AM 513-514-515 Adopted
Falls also if AM 451 NOT
Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 4 point a
AM 517 Karl-Heinz Florenz, Thomas Ulmer
Deletion
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35 513-514 Adopted
AM 517 Falls also if AM 445 NOT Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 4 point a
AM 518 María Auxiliadora Correa Zamora, Esther Herranz García
Article 6 paragraph 4 point a
AM 519 Izaskun Bilbao Barandica
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35 AM 513-514-517
Identical
Article 6 paragraph 4 point a a (new)
Sugar or similar additives
AM 520 Martina Anderson, Kartika Tamara Liotard
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35 AM 513-514-517
Article 6 paragraph 4 point b
AM 521 Karl-Heinz Florenz, Thomas Ulmer
Deletion
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35 AM 513-514 Adopted
And if AM 445 NOT Adopted
PV\1001717ES.doc 57/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 6 paragraph 4 point b
AM 522 María Auxiliadora Correa Zamora, Esther Herranz García
Article 6 paragraph 4 point b
AM 523 Izaskun Bilbao Barandica
Identical
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35 AM 513-514-521
Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 4 point c
AM 524 Karl-Heinz Florenz, Thomas Ulmer
Deletion
Falls if CONS 33 A AM 442-
IMCO 39-ITRE 35 M
513-514 Adopted
And if AM 445 NOT Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 4 point c
AGRI 37 AGRI Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35 AM 513-514-524
AdoptedArticle 6 paragraph 4 point c a (new)
Commercial references to any form of additive
AM 526 Izaskun Bilbao Barandica
Falls if AM 442-IMCO 39-ITRE 35 AM
513-514 Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 5
AM 527 Milan Cabrnoch
Article 6 paragraph 5
AM 528 Holger Krahmer
Article 6 paragraph 5
AM 529 Renate Sommer
Article 6 paragraph 5
AM 530 Karl-Heinz Florenz, Thomas Ulmer
Identical Deletion
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-ITRE 35 Adopted
AM 530 Falls also if AM 445 NOT Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 5
AM 531 Jaroslaw Kalinowski
Falls if AM 442-IMCO 39-ITRE 35 AM
527 to 530 Adopted
PE516.894v01-00 58/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 6 paragraph 5
AM 532 G. Willmott, A.Perelló Rodríguez, K.Tamara Liotard, C. Schlyter, N.Childers, C.Stihler, A.Parvanova, K.Van Brempt
Falls if AM 442-IMCO 39-ITRE 35 AM 527 to 530 and 531 Adopted
Falls also if AM 451 NOT
AdoptedArticle 6 paragraph 5
AGRI 39 AGRI Falls if AM AM 442-IMCO
39-ITRE 35 527 to 530 and
531-532 Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 5
JURI 31 JURI Falls if AM AM 442-IMCO
39-ITRE 35 527 to 530 and 531 Adopted
Compatible with 532-AGRI
39Article 6 paragraph 5
AM 533 Jutta Haug Falls if AM AM 442-IMCO
39-ITRE 35 527 to 530 and 531 Adopted
Compatible with 532-JURI
31-AGRI 39Article 6 paragraph 5
AM 534 Gaston Franco
Falls if AM 527 to 530 and 531
Adopted
Compatible with 532-JURI 31-AGRI 39-
533
Linguistic amendments
to be votedArticle 6 paragraph 5
AM 535 J.E. Hibner, M. Handzlik, B. Sonik
Falls if AM AM 442-IMCO
39-ITRE 35 527 to 530 and 531-JURI 31
Adopted
Compatible with 532-AGRI
39-533-534
PV\1001717ES.doc 59/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 6 paragraph 5
AM 536 Claudiu Ciprian Tanasescu, Minodora Cliveti
Falls if AM 527 to 530 and 531
Adopted
Compatible with others
Article 6 paragraph 6
AM 539 Karl-Heinz Florenz, Thomas Ulmer
Deletion
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-ITRE 35Adopted
Falls if AM 445 NOT Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 7 subparagraph 1
AM 540 Karl-Heinz Florenz, Thomas Ulmer
DeletionFalls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-ITRE 35Adopted
Falls if AM 445 NOT Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 7 subparagraph 1
AM 542 G. Willmott, K.T. Liotard, C. Schlyter, N. Childers, C. Stihler, A.Parvanova, K. Van Brempt
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35 540 Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 7 subparagraph 1
AM 541 Claudiu Ciprian Tanasescu, Minodora Cliveti
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35 540-542 Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 7 subparagraph 1
AM 543 Izaskun Bilbao Barandica
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35 540-542-541 Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 7 subparagraph 1
AM 546 Evelyn Regner, Karin Kadenbach
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35 540-542-541-543
Adopted
PE516.894v01-00 60/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 6 -paragraph 7
AM 27 Linda McAvan
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35 540-542-541-543-546 Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 7 subparagraph 1
AM 545 María Auxiliadora Correa Zamora, Esther Herranz García
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35 540-542-541-543-546 Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 7 subparagraph 1
AM 544 Theodoros Skylakakis
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35 540-541 Adopted
Compatible with others
Article 6 paragraph 7 subparagraph 2
AM 547 Karl-Heinz Florenz, Thomas Ulmer
Article 6 paragraph 7 subparagraph 2
AM 548 G. Willmott, K.T. Liotard, C. Schlyter, N. Childers, C. Stihler, A.Parvanova, K. Van Brempt
Identical Deletion
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-ITRE 35Adopted
AM 547 Falls if AM 445 NOT
Adopted
AM 548 Falls also if AM 451 NOT Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 8
AM 549 Jaroslaw Kalinowski
Article 6 paragraph 8
AM 550 Renate Sommer, Monika Hohlmeier
Article 6 paragraph 8
AM 551 Karl-Heinz Florenz, Thomas Ulmer
Article 6 paragraph 8
AM 552 Erik Bánki
Identical Deletion
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-ITRE 35Adopted
AM 551 Falls if AM 445 NOT
Adopted
PV\1001717ES.doc 61/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 6 paragraph 8
AM 553 G. Willmott, K.T. Liotard, C. Schlyter, N. Childers, C. Stihler, A.Parvanova, K. Van Brempt
AM 553 Falls also if AM 451 NOT Adopted
Article 6 -paragraph 8
AM 28 Linda McAvan
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-549 to 553 Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 9
AM 554 Gaston Franco
Article 6 paragraph 9
AM 555 Renate Sommer
Article 6 paragraph 9
AM 556 Karl-Heinz Florenz, Thomas Ulmer
Article 6 paragraph 9
AM 557 Erik Bánki
Article 6 paragraph 9
AM 558 María Auxiliadora Correa Zamora, Esther Herranz García
Article 6 paragraph 9
JURI 32 JURI
Article 6 paragraph 9
AGRI 41 AGRI
Identical Deletion
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-ITRE 35Adopted
AM 556 Falls if AM 445 NOT
Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 9
AM 559 G. Willmott, K.T. Liotard, C. Schlyter, N. Childers, C. Stihler, A.Parvanova, K. Van Brempt
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-ITRE 35
554 to 558 Adopted
Falls also if AM 451 NOT
AdoptedArticle 6 paragraph 9
AM 561 Evelyn Regner, Karin Kadenbach
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-ITRE 35
554 to 558-559 Adopted
PE516.894v01-00 62/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 6 paragraph 9
AM 560 Georgios Koumoutsakos
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-ITRE 35
554 to 558-559-561Adopted
Article 6 -paragraph 9
AM 29 Linda McAvan
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-ITRE 35
554 to 558-559-561Adopted
Compatible with 560
Article 6 paragraph 10
AM 562 Gaston Franco
Article 6 paragraph 10
AM 563 Sari Essayah
Article 6 paragraph 10
AM 564 Milan Cabrnoch
Article 6 paragraph 10
AM 565 Riikka Manner
Article 6 paragraph 10
AM 566 Martina Anderson, Kartika Tamara Liotard
Article 6 paragraph 10
AM 567 Karl-Heinz Florenz, Thomas Ulmer
Article 6 paragraph 10
AM 568 G. Willmott, K.T. Liotard, N. Childers, C. Stihler, A.Parvanova, K. Van Brempt
Identical Deletion
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-ITRE 35Adopted
AM 567 Falls if AM 445 NOT
Adopted
AM 568 Falls also if AM 451 NOT Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 10
AM 570 Carl Schlyter Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-562 to 568 Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 10
AM 569 B. Bendtsen, J.L. Walesa, J.E. Hibner, C. Fjellner, M. Weber, A. Rosbach, B. Sonik
Identical
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-562 to 568 and AM 570 Adopted
PV\1001717ES.doc 63/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 6 paragraph 10
AM 571 Renate Sommer
Article 6 paragraph 10
JURI 33 JURI
Article 6 paragraph 10
AM 572 A.Weisgerber, K-H.Florenz, M.Hohlmeier, R. Sommer, H. Krahmer
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-562 to 568 and AM 570 and 569-571 Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 10
AM 574 Holger Krahmer
Article 6 paragraph 10
AM 575 P. Bartolozzi, E. Gardini, S.Berlato, S.Tatarella, G.i La Via, R.Angelilli
Article 6 paragraph 10
AM 576 Erik Bánki
Article 6 paragraph 10
AM 577 Martin Callanan
Identical
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-562 to 568 and AM 570 and 569-571 and 572
Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 10
AM 573 María Auxiliadora Correa Zamora, Esther Herranz García
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-562 to 568 and AM
570 and 569 to 571 and 572
and 576 to 577 Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 10
AM 5781st part
Frédérique Ries
Article 6 paragraph 10
AM 580 Claudiu Ciprian Tanasescu, Minodora Cliveti
Article 6 paragraph 10
AM 582 O. Rossi, M.Salvini, F.E. Speroni, C.Morganti, L. Fontana
Identical
Falls if CONS 33 AM 5442-
IMCO 39-ITRE 35-62 to 568 and AM 570 Adopted
Compatible with others
PE516.894v01-00 64/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 6 paragraph 10
AM 5782nd part
Frédérique Ries
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-562 to 568 and AM
570 and 569 to 571 and 572
and 576 to 577 and 573 Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 10
AM 579 Manfred Weber
Falls if CONS 33 AM442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35- 562 to 568 and AM 570 Adopted
Compatible with others
Article 6 paragraph 10
AM 581 Georgios Koumoutsakos
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35-562 to 568 Adopted
Compatible with others
Article 6 paragraph 4 point c a (new)
Prohibition of the use of flavourings in the components of tobacco products (filters, papers..)
AM 525 Renate Sommer
Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-IMCO 39-
ITRE 35 AM 513-514 Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 7 a new
Menthol TP
AGRI 40 AGRIFalls if CONS
33 Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 4 point c a new
Additives with a characterising flavour
AGRI 38 AGRI
Falls if CONS 33 Adopted
Article 6paragraph -1 new
Negative list of additives
AGRI 32 AGRI Falls if CONS 33 AM 442-
445-451 Adopted
PV\1001717ES.doc 65/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 6 paragraph 10 a (new)
Procedure for Ingredients in Annex -I
AM 583 G. Willmott, K.T. Liotard, C. Schlyter, N. Childers, C. Stihler, A.Parvanova, K. Van Brempt
Falls if CONS 33AM IMCO 39-ITRE 35
Adopted
Recital 8 a (new)
Industry commitment
AM 75 C.Schaldemose, D.Jørgensen
Falls if CONS 33 Adopted
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 35 a (new)
Traditional tobacco Flavour
IMCO 33 IMCO Falls if CONS 33 Adopted
Article 6 paragraph 10 a (new)
Exemption for Snuss
AM 584 Åsa Westlund, Marita Ulvskog
-
(+34-34)
Article 6 paragraph 5 a (new)
Technical features aiming to reduce some harmful components of smoke
AM 538 G. Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F. E. Speroni, C.Morganti, L.Fontana
-
Article 6 paragraph 5 a (new)
Technical features aiming to reduce some harmful components of smoke
AM 537 Gaston Franco
Falls if AM 538-539 Adopted
Compatible with others
-
Article 6 a (new)
Support fund for tobacco growers
AM 585 Czeslaw Adam Siekierski, Jaroslaw Kalinowski
-
COMP 34
Article 7
S&D - EPP -ALDE -
GREENS/EFA - ECR - EFD -
GUE/NGL
+
COMP 35
Article 7 anew
S&D - EPP -ALDE -
GREENS/EFA - ECR - EFD -
GUE/NGL
+
PE516.894v01-00 66/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 7 IMCO 40 IMCO Falls if COMP 34 Adopted
All Amendments covered by
COMP 34-35 Fell
Article 7 paragraph 1
AM 586 Marit Paulsen
Falls if COMP 34 IMCO 40
AdoptedArticle 7 paragraph 1
AM 587 P. Ayuso, M.Auxiliadora Correa Zamora, E.Herranz García
Falls if COMP 34 IMCO 40
Adopted
Compatible with 586
Article 7 paragraph 2
AM 588 Daniël van der Stoep
Falls if COMP 34 IMCO 40
Adopted
Article 7 paragraph 3
AM 589 Daniël van der Stoep
Falls if COMP 34 IMCO 40
Adopted
DeletionArticle 7 paragraph 3
AM 590 Milan Cabrnoch
Falls if COMP 34 IMCO 40
AM 589 Adopted
Article 7 paragraph 3
AM 591 Renate Sommer
Falls if COMP 34 IMCO 40
AM 589Adopted
Compatible with 590
Article 7 paragraph 3
AM 592 Paul Nuttall, Godfrey Bloom
Falls if COMP 34 IMCO 40
AM 589 Adopted
Compatible with 590-591
Article 7 paragraph 3
AM 594 Holger Krahmer
Falls if COMP 34 IMCO 40
AM 589 Adopted
Compatible with 590-591-
592
PV\1001717ES.doc 67/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 7 paragraph 3
AM 595 K-H.Florenz, P. Liese, C.Klaß, T.Ulmer, R.Seeber, R.Sommer
Falls if COMP 34 IMCO 40
AM 589 Adopted
Compatible with others as
addition
Article 7 paragraph 3
AM 593 Frédérique Ries
Falls if IMCO 40 AM 589-595
Adopted
Compatible with others as
additionArticle 7 paragraph 3
ITRE 36 ITRE Falls if COMP 34 IMCO 40 AM 589-590
Adopted
Compatible with others as
additionArticle 7 paragraph 3
AM 596 Izaskun Bilbao Barandica
Falls if COMP 34 IMCO 40 AM 589-595-593 Adopted
Compatible with others as
additionArticle 7 paragraph 3 a (new)
Adhesive labels
AM 597 Andrés Perelló Rodríguez
Falls if COMP 34 Adopted
Compatible with all
Article 7 paragraph 4
AM 599 Petru Constantin Luhan
Falls if COMP 34 IMCO 40
Adopted
Article 7 -paragraph 4
AM 30 Linda McAvan
Withdrawn
Falls if COMP 34 IMCO 40
AM 599 Adopted
W
Article 7 paragraph 4
AM 598 Renate Sommer, Monika Hohlmeier
Falls if COMP 34 IMCO 40
Adopted
Compatible with others
PE516.894v01-00 68/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 7 paragraph 5
AM 600 Georgios Koumoutsakos
Falls if COMP 34 IMCO 40
Adopted
Article 7 paragraph 6
AM 601 Christine De Veyrac, Sophie Auconie, Brice Hortefeux
Falls if COMP 34 IMCO 40
Adopted
Article 7 paragraph 7
AM 602 Georgios Koumoutsakos
Falls if COMP 34 IMCO 40
Adopted
DeletionArticle 7 paragraph 7 a (new)
Printed vouchers offering discounts
AM 603 Andrés Perelló Rodríguez
Compatible as addition
+
COMP 36
Article 8
S&D - EPP -ALDE -
GREENS/EFA ECR- EFD -GUE/NGL
+
Article 8 AM 604 Daniël van der Stoep
Falls if COMP 36 Adopted
Deletion
All Amendments covered by
COMP 36 Fell
Article 8 paragraph 2 subparagraph 1 introductory part
AM 605 Erik Bánki Falls if COMP 36 AM 604
AdoptedArticle 8 paragraph 2 subparagraph 1 subparagraph 1
AM 606 Erik Bánki Falls if COMP 36 AM 604
Adopted
DeletionArticle 8 paragraph 2 subparagraph 1 subparagraph 1
AM 607 Andrés Perelló Rodríguez
Falls if COMP 36 AM 604-606
Adopted
Article 8 paragraph 3
AM 608 Godfrey Bloom
Falls if COMP 36 AM 604
Adopted
Article 8 paragraph 3
AM 609 James Nicholson, Diane Dodds
Falls if COMP 36 AM 604-608
Adopted
PV\1001717ES.doc 69/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 8 paragraph 3
AM 610 Renate Sommer, Monika Hohlmeier
Falls if COMP 36 AM 604-
608-609 Adopted
Article 8 paragraph 3
AM 612 Maria do Céu Patrão Neves
Falls if COMP 36 AM 604-608-609-610
Adopted
Article 8 paragraph 3
AM 611 G. Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F. E. Speroni, C.Morganti, L.Fontana
Falls if COMP 36 AM 604-
608-609-610-612 Adopted
Article 8 paragraph 3
AM 613 Cristiana Muscardini
Article 8 paragraph 3
AM 614 Milan Cabrnoch
Article 8 paragraph 3
AM 615 Christa Klaß
Article 8 paragraph 3
AM 616 José Manuel Fernandes
Article 8 paragraph 3
AM 617 P. Bartolozzi, E. Gardini, S.Berlato, S.Tatarella, G.i La Via, R.Angelilli
Article 8 paragraph 3
INTA 25 INTA 25
Article 8 paragraph 3
JURI 34 JURI
Article 8 paragraph 3
AM 618 Erik Bánki
Article 8 paragraph 3
AM 619 Georgios Koumoutsakos
Article 8 paragraph 3
ITRE 37 ITRE
Article 8 paragraph 3
AGRI 42 AGRI 42
Identical
Falls if COMP 36 AM 604-
608-609-610-612-611 Adopted
PE516.894v01-00 70/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 8 paragraph 3
AM 622 Theodoros Skylakakis
Falls if COMP 36 AM 604-
608-609-610-612-611 and 613 to 619 Adopted
Article 8 paragraph 3
AM 621 G. Willmott, K.T. Liotard, C. Schlyter, N. Childers, C. Stihler, A.Parvanova
Article 8 paragraph 3
AM 620 Martina Anderson, Kartika Tamara Liotard
Identical
Falls if COMP 36 AM 604
Adopted
Compatible as addition to all other Ams Art
8 para 3
COMP 37
Article 8 paragraph 4
S&D - EPP -ALDE -
GREENS/EFA - ECR - EFD -
GUE/NGL+
Article 8 paragraph 4
AM 623 Gaston Franco
All Amendments covered by
COMP 37 FellArticle 8 paragraph 4
AM 624 Holger Krahmer
Article 8 paragraph 4
AM 625 Ewald Stadler
Article 8 paragraph 4
ITRE 38 ITRE
Article 8 paragraph 4
AM 626 Renate Sommer, Monika Hohlmeier
Falls if COMP 37 AM 604
Adopted
Identical Deletion
Article 8 paragraph 4 -introductory part
AGRI 43 AGRI Falls if COMP 37 AM 604 and
623 to 626 Adopted
Article 8 paragraph 4 point a
AM 627 Erik Bánki Falls if COMP 37 AM 604 and
623 to 626 Adopted
Deletion
PV\1001717ES.doc 71/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 8 paragraph 4 point b
AM 628 Milan Cabrnoch
Article 8 paragraph 4 point b
AM 629 Sergej Kozlík
Article 8 paragraph 4 point b
AM 630 Eleni Theocharous
Article 8 paragraph 4 point b
AM 631 Cristian Silviu Busoi
Article 8 paragraph 4 point b
AM 632 Erik Bánki
Article 8 paragraph 4 point b
AM 633 P. Bartolozzi, E. Gardini, S.Berlato, S.Tatarella, G.i La Via, R.Angelilli
Article 8 paragraph 4 point b
IMCO 41 IMCO
Article 8 paragraph 4 point b
JURI 35 JURI
Article 8 paragraph 4 point b
AGRI 44 AGRI
Falls if COMP 37 AM 604 and
623 to 626 Adopted
IdenticalDeletion
Article 8 paragraph 4 point b
AM 634 G. Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F. E. Speroni, C.Morganti, L.Fontana
Falls if COMP 37 AM 604 and
623 to 626 And 628 to 633
Adopted
CONS 39
Article 9Paragraph 1-2
75%
S&D - ALDE -GREENS/EFA
-GUE/NGL
Order of votes authorised by the Chaimanin accordance to art 161 para
3
+(+37-33)
CONS 38
Article 9Paragraph 1
65%
EPP- ECR Falls if CONS 39 Adopted
F
PE516.894v01-00 72/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 9 IMCO 42 IMCO Falls if CONS 39-38 Adopted
All Amendments covered by
CONS 39 FellArticle 9 title AM 635 Daniël van der
StoepFalls if CONS 39-38 IMCO 42 Adopted
Article 9 title AM 636 Mario Pirillo Falls CONS 39-38 IMCO 42-AM 635
AdoptedArticle 9 paragraph 1 introductory part
AM 640 Renate Sommer, Monika Hohlmeier
Falls CONS 39-38 IMCO 42 Adopted
Article 9 paragraph 1 introductory part
INTA 26 INTA 26 Falls CONS 39-38 IMCO 42 -AM 640
AdoptedArticle 9 paragraph 1 introductory part
AM 637 Christa Klaß
Article 9 paragraph 1 introductory part
AM 638 Holger Krahmer
Article 9 paragraph 1 introductory part
AM 639 Daniël van der Stoep
Falls CONS 39-38 IMCO 42 AM 640-
INTA 26 Adopted
Identical
Article 9 paragraph 1 introductory part
AM 641 Martina Anderson, Kartika Tamara Liotard
Falls CONS 39-38 IMCO 42 AM 640-
INTA 26- and 637 to 639 Adopted
Article 9 paragraph 1 introductory part
AGRI 45 AGRI Falls CONS 39-38 IMCO 42 INTA 26
Adopted
Compatibble with others as
additionArticle 9 paragraph 1 point a
AM 642 Daniël van der Stoep
Deletion
Article 9 paragraph 1 point a
AM 643 Godfrey Bloom
Falls CONS 39-38 IMCO 42 AM 642
AdoptedArticle 9 paragraph 1 point a
AM 644 Christa Klaß
Article 9 paragraph 1 point a
AM 645 Holger Krahmer
Falls CONS 39-38 IMCO
42 AM 642-643 Adopted
PV\1001717ES.doc 73/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 9 paragraph 1 point a
AM 646 Renate Sommer, Monika Hohlmeier
Identical
Article 9 -paragraph 1 -point a
AM 31 Linda McAvan
Falls CONS 39-38 IMCO
42 AM 642-643 and 644 to 646
AdoptedArticle 9 paragraph 1 point a
AM 647 Milan Cabrnoch
Falls CONS 39-38 IMCO
42 AM 642-643 and 644 to 646
Adopted
Compatible with 31
Article 9 paragraph 1 point a
AM 648 Georgios Koumoutsakos
Falls CONS 39-38 IMCO
42 AM 642-643 and 644 to 646
Adopted
Compatible with 31
Article 9 paragraph 1 point a a (new)
Combined Health warnings - Member States may require
AM 649 Christa Klaß Falls if AM 641-31
Adopted
Compatible as addition
Article 9 paragraph 1 point a b (new)
Combined Health warnings - Member Statesmay request authorisation
AM 650 Holger Krahmer
Falls CONS 39-38 AM 641-
31-649 Adopted
Compatible as addition
Article 9 paragraph 1 point b
JURI 36 JURI Falls CONS 39-38 IMCO 42 Adopted
Article 9 paragraph 1 point c
30% only back
AM 654 Godfrey Bloom
Falls CONS 39-38 IMCO 42 Adopted
Article 9 paragraph 1 point c
30%
AM 655 Daniël van der Stoep
Falls CONS 39-38 IMCO 42-AM 654
AdoptedArticle 9 paragraph 1 point c
30%-40%
AM 653 Timothy Kirkhope
Falls if CONS 39-38 IMCO
42-AM 654-655 Adopted
PE516.894v01-00 74/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 9 paragraph 1 point c
30%-40%
AM 652 Milan Cabrnoch
Falls if CONS 39-38 IMCO 42 AM 654-
655-653 Adopted
Article 9 paragraph 1 point c
40%-30%
AM 658 Erik Bánki Falls if CONS 39-38 IMCO 42 AM 654-655-653-652
AdoptedArticle 9 paragraph 1 point c
40%
AM 656 Renate Sommer, Monika Hohlmeier
Article 9 paragraph 1 point c
AM 657 Paul Nuttall, Godfrey Bloom
Identical
Falls if CONS 39-38 IMCO 42 AM 654-
655-653-652-658 Adopted
Article 9 paragraph 1 point c
40%-50%
AM 659 Sergej Kozlík Falls if CONS 39-38 IMCO 42 AM 654-
655-653-652-658-656 Adopted
Article 9 paragraph 1 point c
43%-62%
AM 660 Ewald Stadler Falls if CONS 39-38 IMCO 42 AM 654-
655-653-652-658-656-659
AdoptedArticle 9 paragraph 1 point c
50% + roll your own
AM 661 Pat the Cope Gallagher, Jim Higgins
Falls if CONS 39-38 IMCO 42 AM 654-
655-653-652-658-656-659-660 Adopted
Article 9 paragraph 1 point c
50% + 50% of the area with info on smoking cessation
ITRE 39 ITRE Falls if CONS 39-38 IMCO 42 AM 654-
655-653-652-658-656-659-660 Adopted
Article 9 paragraph 1 point c
50%
AM 651 Toine Manders
Article 9 paragraph 1 point c
AM 662 Christa Klaß
Article 9 paragraph 1 point c
AM 663 Marian-Jean Marinescu
Article 9 paragraph 1 point c
AM 664 José Manuel Fernandes
Identical50%
Falls if CONS 39-38 IMCO 42 AM 654-
655-653-652-658-656-659-
660-661-ITRE 39 Adopted
PV\1001717ES.doc 75/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 9 paragraph 1 point c
AM 665 Eleni Theocharous
Article 9 paragraph 1 point c
AM 666 Maria do Céu Patrão Neves
Article 9 paragraph 1 point c
AM 667 Holger Krahmer
Article 9 paragraph 1 point c
AM 668 C. De Veyrac, S. Auconie, J-P. Audy, B.Hortefeux
Article 9 paragraph 1 point c
AM 669 Cristiana Muscardini
Article 9 paragraph 1 point c
INTA 27 INTA 27
Article 9 paragraph 1 point c
AM 670 G. Scottà, O.Rossi, F. E. Speroni, C.Morganti, L.Fontana
Article 9 paragraph 1 point c
AM 671 Georgios Koumoutsakos
Article 9 paragraph 1 point c
AM 672 P. Bartolozzi, E. Gardini, S.Berlato, S.Tatarella, G. La Via, R.Angelilli
Article 9 paragraph 1 point c
JURI 37 JURI
Article 9 paragraph 1 point c
AGRI 46 AGRI
Article 9 paragraph 1 point c
AM 673 Pilar Ayuso, María Auxiliadora Correa Zamora, Esther Herranz García
PE516.894v01-00 76/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 9 paragraph 1 point c
50%-75%
AM 674 Kristian Vigenin
WithdrawnAuthor no longer a Member
Falls if CONS 39-38 IMCO 42 AM 654-
655-653-652-658-656-659-
660-661-ITRE 39 and 651 to 673 Adopted
W
Article 9 paragraph 1 point c
65%
AM 675 Karl-Heinz Florenz, Peter Liese, Thomas Ulmer
Falls if CONS 39-38 IMCO 42 AM 654-
655-653-652-658-656-659-
660-661-ITRE 39 and 651 to
673 -674 Adopted
Article 9 paragraph 1 point c
80%
AM 677 G. Willmott, C.Schaldemose, K. T. Liotard, C. Schlyter, N.Childers, C.Stihler, A.Parvanova
Article 9 paragraph 1 point c
AM 678 Martina Anderson, Kartika Tamara Liotard
Identical
Falls if CONS 39-38 IMCO 42 AM 654-
655-653-652-658-656-659-
660-661-ITRE 39 and 651 to 673 -674-675
Adopted
Article 9 paragraph 1 point c
AM 676 Marian Harkin Falls if CONS 39-38 IMCO 42 AM 654-
655-653-652-658-656-659-
660-661-ITRE 39 and 651 to 673 -674-675-
677-678 Adopted
Article 9 paragraph 1 point d
AM 679 Godfrey Bloom
Article 9 paragraph 1 point d
AM 680 Daniël van der Stoep
Falls if CONS 39-38 IMCO 42 Adopted
IdenticalDeletion
Article 9 paragraph 1 point d
AM 681 Renate Sommer, Monika Hohlmeier
Falls if CONS 39-38 IMCO 42-AM 679-
680- Adopted
PV\1001717ES.doc 77/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 9 paragraph 1 point d
AM 682 Milan Cabrnoch
Falls if CONS 39-38 IMCO 42- AM 679-
680-681 Adopted
Article 9 paragraph 1 point e
AM 683 Godfrey Bloom
Falls if CONS 39-38 IMCO 42 Adopted
DeletionArticle 9 paragraph 1 point e
AM 685 Christa Klaß
Article 9 paragraph 1 point e
AM 686 Holger Krahmer
Article 9 paragraph 1 point e
AM 687 Pilar Ayuso, María Auxiliadora Correa Zamora, Esther Herranz García
Article 9 paragraph 1 point e
AM 688 P. Bartolozzi, E.Gardini, S.Berlato, S.Tatarella, G. La Via, R.Angelilli
Article 9 paragraph 1 point e
AGRI 47 AGRI
Identical
Falls if CONS 39-38 IMCO 42-AM 683
Adopted
Article 9 paragraph 1 point e
JURI 38 JURI
Article 9 paragraph 1 point e
ITRE 40 ITRE
Identical
Falls if CONS 39-38 IMCO 42 AM 683 and 685 to 688 Adopted
Article 9 paragraph 1 point e
AM 694 Izaskun Bilbao Barandica
Falls if CONS 39-38 IMCO
42-AM 683 and 685 to 688 and
JURI 38 Adopted
Article 9 paragraph 1 point e
AM 684 Milan Cabrnoch
Falls if CONS 39-38 IMCO
42-AM 683 and 685 to 688-
JURI 38 and 694 Adopted
Article 9 paragraph 1 point e
AM 691 Marian-Jean Marinescu
Falls if CONS 39-38 IMCO
42-AM 683 and 685 to 688 -
JURI 38 and 694-684 Adopted
PE516.894v01-00 78/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 9 paragraph 1 point e
AM 692 C. De Veyrac, J-P Audy, B.Hortefeux
Falls if CONS 39-38 IMCO
42 AM 683 and 685 to 688-
JURI 38- and 694-684-691
Adopted
Article 9 paragraph 1 point e
AM 689 Sergej Kozlík
Article 9 paragraph 1 point e
AM 690 Erik Bánki
Article 9 paragraph 1 point e
INTA 28 INTA 28
Article 9 paragraph 1 point e
AM 693 Eleni Theocharous
Article 9 paragraph 1 point e
AM 695 Kristian Vigenin
Identical
Falls if CONS 39-38 IMCO
42 AM 683 and 685 to 688-
JURI 38- and 694-684-691-692 Adopted
695 Withdrawn
Article 9 paragraph 1 point e a (new)
AM 696 Milan Cabrnoch
Falls if CONS 39-38 IMCO
42 AM 683 and 685 to 688-
JURI 38- and 694-684-691-
692 and 689 to 695 Adopted
Article 9 paragraph 1 point f
AM 697 Renate Sommer, Monika Hohlmeier
Falls if CONS 39-38 IMCO 42 Adopted
Deletion
Article 9 paragraph 1 point f
AM 698 G. Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F. E. Speroni, C.Morganti, L.Fontana
Falls if CONS 39-38 IMCO 42 AM 697
Adopted
Article 9 paragraph 1 point g
AM 699 Renate Sommer, Monika Hohlmeier
Article 9 paragraph 1 point g
INTA 29 INTA 29
Article 9 paragraph 1 point g
AM 700 Milan Cabrnoch
Article 9 paragraph 1 point g
AM 701 Christa Klaß
IdenticalDeletion
Falls if CONS 39-38 IMCO 42 Adopted
Deletion
PV\1001717ES.doc 79/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 9 paragraph 1 point g
AM 702 Sergej Kozlík
Article 9 paragraph 1 point g
AM 703 Holger Krahmer
Article 9 paragraph 1 point g
AM 704 Eleni Theocharous
Article 9 paragraph 1 point g
AM 705 José Manuel Fernandes
Article 9 paragraph 1 point g
AM 706 Maria do Céu Patrão Neves
Article 9 paragraph 1 point g
AM 707 Marian Harkin, Pat the Cope Gallagher, Jim Higgins
Article 9 paragraph 1 point g
AM 708 Erik Bánki
Article 9 paragraph 1 point g
AM 709 Christine De Veyrac, Jean-Pierre Audy
Article 9 paragraph 1 point g
AM 710 Jaroslaw Kalinowski
Article 9 paragraph 1 point g
AM 711 P. Bartolozzi, E. Gardini, S.Berlato, S.Tatarella, G. La Via, R.Angelilli
Article 9 paragraph 1 point g
AM 712 G. Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F. E. Speroni, C.Morganti, L.Fontana
Article 9 paragraph 1 point g
AGRI 48 AGRI
Article 9 paragraph 1 point g
JURI 39 JURI
Article 9 paragraph 1 point g point i
JURI 40 JURI
Article 9 paragraph 1 point g point ii
JURI 41 JURI
PE516.894v01-00 80/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 9 paragraph 1 point g point ii
ITRE 41 ITRE
Article 9 paragraph 1 point g
AM 713 Izaskun Bilbao Barandica
Article 9 paragraph 1 point g
AM 714 Georgios Koumoutsakos
Article 9 paragraph 1 point g point i
32 mm
AM 715 Daniël van der Stoep
Falls if CONS 39-38 IMCO 42 AM 699 to 714 Adopted
Article 9 paragraph 1 point g point i
75% of the area
AM 720 Edite Estrela, Luís Paulo Alves
Falls if CONS 39-38 IMCO 42 AM 699 to
714-715 Adopted
Article 9 paragraph 1 point g point i
46 mm
AM 716 Pilar Ayuso, María Auxiliadora Correa Zamora, Esther Herranz García
Falls if CONS 39-38 IMCO 42 AM 699 to 714 and AM
715-720 Adopted
Article 9 paragraph 1 point g point i
50 mm
AM 717 Marian-Jean Marinescu
Falls if CONS 39-38 IMCO 42 AM 699 to 714 and AM 715-720-716
AdoptedArticle 9 paragraph 1 point g point i
55 mm
AM 718 Karl-Heinz Florenz, Peter Liese, Thomas Ulmer
Falls if CONS 39-38 IMCO 42 AM 699 to 714 and AM 715-720-716-717 Adopted
Article 9 paragraph 1 point g point i
68 mm
AM 719 Martina Anderson, Kartika Tamara Liotard
Falls if CONS 39-38 IMCO 42 AM 699 to 714 and AM 715-720-716-
717-718 Adopted
Article 9 paragraph 1 point g point ii
AM 722 Daniël van der Stoep
Falls if CONS 39-38 IMCO 42 Adopted
Article 9 paragraph 1 point g point ii
AM 721 James Nicholson, Diane Dodds
Falls if CONS 39-38 IMCO 42 AM 722 Adopted
PV\1001717ES.doc 81/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 9 paragraph 1 point g point ii
AM 723 Edite Estrela, Luís Paulo Alves
Falls if CONS 39-38 IMCO
42 AM 722-721 Adopted
Article 9 paragraph 1 point g point anew
Packaging of roll-your-own
ITRE 42 ITRE Falls if CONS 39-38 Adopted
Article 9 paragraph 2
AM 724 Jim Higgins, Marian Harkin, Pat the Cope Gallagher
Falls if CONS 39 IMCO 42
Adopted
Deletion
Article 9 paragraph 2
AM 725 Frédérique Ries
Falls if CONS 39 IMCO 42
AM 724 Adopted
Article 9 paragraph 2
AM 726 Evelyn Regner, Karin Kadenbach
Falls if CONS 39 IMCO 42 AM 724-725
AdoptedArticle 9 paragraph 2
AM 727 Daniël van der Stoep
Article 9 paragraph 2
AM 728 Renate Sommer, Monika Hohlmeier
Identical
Falls if CONS 39 IMCO 42 AM 724-725-726 Adopted
Article 9 -paragraph 2
AM 32 Linda McAvan
Falls if CONS 39 IMCO 42 AM 724-725
Adopted
Compatible with others
Article 9 paragraph 2
AM 729 Andrés Perelló Rodríguez
Falls if CONS 39 IMCO 42 AM 724-726
Adopted
Compatible with others
Article 9 paragraph 2
AM 730 Petru Constantin Luhan
Falls if CONS 39 IMCO 42 AM 724-726
Adopted
Compatible with others
PE516.894v01-00 82/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 9 paragraph 2
AM 731 Theodoros Skylakakis
Falls if CONS 39 IMCO 42
AM 724 Adopted
Compatible as addition to the
othersCOMP 40
Article 9 paragraph 3
S&D - EPP -ALDE -
GREENS/EFA-ECR- EFD -GUE/NGL
+
Article 9 paragraph 3
AM 733 Gaston Franco All Amendments covered by COMP 40
FellArticle 9 paragraph 3
AM 734 Daniël van der Stoep
Article 9 paragraph 3
AM 735 Ewald Stadler
Article 9 paragraph 3
ITRE 43 ITRE
Article 9 paragraph 3
AM 736 Renate Sommer, Monika Hohlmeier
Falls if COMP 40 IMCO 42
Adopted
Identical Deletion
Article 9 paragraph 3introductory part
AGRI 49 AGRI Falls if COMP 40 IMCO 42 AM 733 to 736 Adopted
Article 9 paragraph 3 point c
AM 737 Milan Cabrnoch
Article 9 paragraph 3 point c
AM 738 Sergej Kozlík
Article 9 paragraph 3 point c
AM 739 Holger Krahmer
Article 9 paragraph 3 point c
AM 740 Christa Klaß
Article 9 paragraph 3 point c
AM 741 Cristian Silviu Busoi
Article 9 paragraph 3 point c
AM 742 Marian Harkin, Pat the Cope Gallagher, Jim Higgins
Identical Deletion
Falls if COMP 40 IMCO 42
AM 733 to 736 Adopted
741 Withdrawn
PV\1001717ES.doc 83/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 9 paragraph 3 point c
AM 743 Evelyn Regner, Karin Kadenbach
Article 9 paragraph 3 point c
AGRI 50 AGRI
Article 9 paragraph 3 point c
JURI 42 JURI
Article 9 paragraph 3 point c
AM 744 Erik Bánki
Article 9 paragraph 3 point c
AM 745 P. Bartolozzi, E.Gardini, S.Berlato, S.Tatarella, G. La Via, R.Angelilli
Article 9 paragraph 3 point c
AM 746 G. Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F. E. Speroni, C.Morganti, L.Fontana
Falls if COMP 40 IMCO 42
AM 733 to 736 and 737 to 745
AdoptedArticle 9 paragraph 3 point c
AM 747 Eleni Theocharous
Falls if COMP 40 IMCO 42
AM 733 to 736 and 737 to 745-
746 AdoptedArticle 9 paragraph 3 point c
AM 748 Georgios Koumoutsakos
Falls if COMP 40 IMCO 42
AM 733 to 736 and 737 to 745-
747 AdoptedArticle 9 paragraph 3 point d
AM 749 Milan Cabrnoch
Article 9 paragraph 3 point d
AM 750 Sergej Kozlík
Article 9 paragraph 3 point d
AM 751 Holger Krahmer
Article 9 paragraph 3 point d
AM 752 Eleni Theocharous
Article 9 paragraph 3 point d
AM 753 Pat the Cope Gallagher, Jim Higgins
Article 9 paragraph 3 point d
AGRI 51 AGRI
Identical Deletion
Falls if COMP 40 IMCO 42
Adopted
PE516.894v01-00 84/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 9 paragraph 3 point d
AM 754 Erik Bánki
Article 9 paragraph 2 point 1 (new)
Smoking prevention campaigns
AM 732 Mario Pirillo Compatible as addition to the
others-
(+31-36)
COMP 41
Article 10
S&D - EPP -ALDE -
GREENS/EFA - ECR - EFD -
GUE/NGL+
Article 10 AM 755 Riikka Manner
All Amendments covered by
COMP 41 FellArticle 10 AM 756 Sari EssayahArticle 10 AM 757 G. Willmott, K.
T. Liotard, C.Schlyter, N.Childers, C.Stihler, A.Parvanova
Falls if COMP 41 Adopted
Identical Deletion
Article 10 IMCO 43 IMCO Falls if COMP 41 AM 755 to 757 Adopted
Article 10 ITRE 44 ITRE Falls if COMP 41 AM 755 to 757 IMCO 43 Adopted
Article 10 paragraph 1 subparagraph 1
AM 761 Martina Anderson
Falls if COMP 41 AM 755 to 757-IMCO 43-ITRE 44-Adopted
Article 10 paragraph 1 subparagraph 1
AM 762 Georgios Koumoutsakos
Falls if COMP 41 AM 755 to 757-IMCO 43-ITRE 44- and 761 Adopted
Article 10 paragraph 1 subparagraph 1
AM 760 Renate Sommer, Monika Hohlmeier
Falls if COMP 41 AM 755 to 757-IMCO 43-
ITRE 44-Adopted
Compatible with 761-762
Article 10 paragraph 1 subparagraph 1
AM 759 Frédérique Ries
IdenticalFalls if COMP 41 AM 755 to
PV\1001717ES.doc 85/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 10 paragraph 1 subparagraph 1
AM 758 Claudiu Ciprian Tanasescu, Minodora Cliveti
757-IMCO 43-ITRE 44-Adopted
Compatible with 761-762-
760Article 10 paragraph 1 subparagraph 2
AM 763 Renate Sommer, Monika Hohlmeier
Falls if COMP 41 AM 755 to 757-IMCO 43-ITRE 44-Adopted
Article 10 paragraph 1 subparagraph 2
INTA 30 INTA 30 Falls if COMP 41 AM 755 to 757-IMCO 43-ITRE 44- And Am 763 Adopted
Article 10 paragraph 1 subparagraph 2
AM 764 Izaskun Bilbao Barandica
Falls if COMP 41 AM 755 to 757-IMCO 43-ITRE 44- and AM 763 Adopted
Compatible with INTA 30
Article 10 paragraph 2
AM 766 Martina Anderson
Falls if COMP 41 AM 755 to 757-IMCO 43-ITRE 44-Adopted
Article 10 paragraph 2
AM 765 Daniël van der Stoep
Falls if COMP 41 AM 755 to 757-IMCO 43-ITRE 44- and AM 766 Adopted
Article 10 paragraph 2
AM 768 Izaskun Bilbao Barandica
Falls if COMP 41 AM 755 to 757-IMCO 43-ITRE 44-Adopted
Compatible with AM 766-
765
Article 10 paragraph 2
AM 767 G. Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F. E. Speroni, C.Morganti, L.Fontana
Article 10 paragraph 2
AGRI 52 AGRI
Identical
Falls if COMP 41 AM 755 to 757-IMCO 43-
ITRE 44-Adopted
Compatible with AM 766-765-768
PE516.894v01-00 86/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 10 paragraph 3
AM 771 Martina Anderson
Falls if COMP 41 AM 755 to 757-IMCO 43-ITRE 44- and AM Adopted
Article 10 paragraph 3
AM 769 Daniël van der Stoep
Falls if COMP 41 AM 755 to 757-IMCO 43-ITRE 44- and AM 771 Adopted
Article 10 paragraph 3
AM 770 Renate Sommer
Falls if COMP 41 AM 755 to 757-IMCO 43-ITRE 44- and AM 771-769
AdoptedArticle 10 paragraph 3
AM 772 G. Scottà, Lo.Fontana, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F.E. Speroni, C.Morganti
Identical
Falls if COMP 41 AM 755 to 757-IMCO 43-ITRE 44- and
AM 770 Adopted
Compatible with others
Article 10 paragraph 3
AM 773 Izaskun Bilbao Barandica
Falls if COMP 41 AM 755 to 757-IMCO 43-ITRE 44-Adopted
Compatible with others
Article 10 paragraph 4 point a
AM 778 Daniël van der Stoep
Falls if COMP 41 AM 755 to 757-IMCO 43-ITRE 44-Adopted
Article 10 paragraph 4 point a
AM 777 Toine Manders
Article 10 paragraph 4 point a
INTA 31 INTA 31
Identical in content
Falls if COMP 41 AM 755 to 757-IMCO 43-
ITRE 44-Adopted
Compatible with 778
PV\1001717ES.doc 87/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 10 paragraph 4 point a
AM 776 Holger Krahmer
Falls if COMP 41 AM 755 to 757-IMCO 43-ITRE 44- and
AM 777 Adopted
Article 10 paragraph 4 point b
AM 779 Izaskun Bilbao Barandica
Falls if COMP 41 AM 755 to 757-IMCO 43-ITRE 44-Adopted
Article 10 paragraph 4 point b
INTA 32 INTA 32 Falls if COMP 41 AM 755 to 757-IMCO 43-
ITRE 44-Adopted
Compatible with 779
Article 10 paragraph 4 point c
AM 782 Daniël van der Stoep
Falls if COMP 41 AM 755 to 757-IMCO 43-ITRE 44-Adopted
Article 10 paragraph 4 point c
AM 780 Christa Klaß
Article 10 paragraph 4 point c
AM 781 Holger Krahmer
Identical
Falls if COMP 41 AM 755 to 757-IMCO 43-ITRE 44- and
AM 782 Adopted
Article 10 paragraph 3 a (new)
AM 775 K-H Florenz, P. Liese, T.s Ulmer, T.Manders
+
(+38-31)
Article 10 paragraph 3 a (new)
AM 774 Holger Krahmer
Identical
Falls if AM 755 to 757-IMCO 43-ITRE 44-
Adopted
CONS 42
Article 10 paragraph 5
S&D - EPP -ALDE -
GREENS/EFA - EFD -
GUE/NGL+
Article 10 paragraph 5
AM 783 Gaston Franco Identical Deletion
Falls if CONS
All Amendments covered by
CONS 42 Fell
PE516.894v01-00 88/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 10 paragraph 5
AM 784 Milan Cabrnoch
Article 10 paragraph 5
AM 785 Holger Krahmer
Article 10 paragraph 5
AM 786 Ewald Stadler
Article 10 paragraph 5
AM 787 Renate Sommer, Monika Hohlmeier
Article 10 paragraph 5
AM 788 P. Bartolozzi, E. Gardini, S.Berlato, S.Tatarella, G.La Via, R.Angelilli
Article 10 paragraph 5
AM 789 Timothy Kirkhope
Article 10 paragraph 5
AM 790 Erik Bánki
Article 10 paragraph 5
AGRI 53 AGRI
Article 10 paragraph 5
AM 791 MartinCallanan
Article 10 paragraph 5
JURI 43 JURI
Article 10 paragraph 5
AM 792 Toine Manders
42 AM 755 to 757-IMCO 43-ITRE 44-Adopted
Article 10 paragraph 5
AM 794 Claudiu Ciprian Tanasescu, Minodora Cliveti
Falls if CONS 42 AM 755 to 757-IMCO 43-ITRE 44- and 783 to 792 Adopted
Article 10 paragraph 5
AM 793 María Auxiliadora Correa Zamora, Esther Herranz García
Falls if CONS 42 AM 755 to 757-IMCO 43-ITRE 44- and 783 to 792 and AM 794 Adopted
COMP 43
Article 11
S&D - EPP -ALDE -
GREENS/EFA - ECR - EFD -
GUE/NGL
+
PV\1001717ES.doc 89/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 11 IMCO 44 IMCO Falls if COMP 43 Adopted
All Amendments covered by
COMP 43 FellArticle 11 paragraph 1 subparagraph 1 introductory part
AM 795 Marit Paulsen Falls if COMP 43 IMCO 44
Adopted
Article 11 paragraph 1 subparagraph 1 introductory part
AM 797 RenateSommer, Peter Liese
Falls if COMP 43 IMCO 44
AM 795 Adopted
Article 11 paragraph 1 subparagraph 1 introductory part
AM 796 Cristian Silviu Busoi
Withdrawn
Compatible with Falls if COMP 43 IMCO 44
Adopted both
W
Article 11 paragraph 1 subparagraph 2
AM 801 K-H. Florenz, P. Liese, T.Ulmer, E. O. Antonescu, R.Seeber, S.Auconie
Falls if COMP 43 IMCO 44
Adopted
Article 11 paragraph 1 subparagraph 2
AM 798 Georgios Koumoutsakos
Article 11 paragraph 1 subparagraph 2
AM 800 Maria do Céu Patrão Neves, José Manuel Fernandes
Identical
Falls if COMP 43 IMCO 44-
AM 801 Adopted
Article 11 paragraph 1 subparagraph 2
AM 799 Christian Engström, Chris Davies, Christofer Fjellner
Falls if COMP 43 IMCO 44
Adopted
Compatible as addition
Article 11 paragraph 2 point a
ITRE 45 ITRE
Article 11 paragraph 2 point b
AM 805 Daniël van der Stoep
Falls if COMP 43 IMCO 44 Adopted
Article 11 paragraph 2 point b
AM 804 Ewald Stadler Falls if COMP 43 IMCO 44
AM 805 Adopted
Article 11 paragraph 2 point b
AM 803 Renate Sommer
Falls if COMP 43 IMCO 44 AM 805-804
Adopted
PE516.894v01-00 90/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 11 paragraph 2 point b
AM 806 G. Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F. E. Speroni, C.Morganti, L.Fontana
Article 11 paragraph 2 point b
AGRI 54 AGRI
Identical
Falls if COMP 43 IMCO 44
AM 806 Adopted
Compatible with others
Article 11 paragraph 2 subparagraph 1 (new)
Micro-packagings
AM 807 Renate Sommer
-
CONS 44
Article 11 paragraph 3
S&D - EPP -ALDE -
GREENS/EFA EFD -
GUE/NGL
+
Article 11 paragraph 3
AM 808 Gaston Franco All Amendments covered by
CONS 44 FellArticle 11 paragraph 3
AM 809 Milan Cabrnoch
Article 11 paragraph 3
AM 810 Ewald Stadler
Article 11 paragraph 3
ITRE 46 ITRE
Article 11 paragraph 3
AGRI 55 AGRI
Article 11 paragraph 3
AM 811 Renate Sommer, Monika Hohlmeier
Identical Deletion
Falls if CONS 44 IMCO 44 Adopted
COMP 45
Article 12 paragraph 1
S&D - EPP -ALDE -
GREENS/EFA - ECR - EFD -
GUE/NGL
+
Article 12 paragraph 1
AM 812 Christa Klaß All Amendments covered by
COMP 45 FellArticle 12 paragraph 1
AM 813 Holger Krahmer
Falls if COMP 45 Adopted
Identical Deletion
Falls if Adopted
Article 12 paragraph 1
ITRE 47 para 1
ITRE Falls if COMP 45 AM 812-813
Adopted
PV\1001717ES.doc 91/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 12 paragraph 1 introductory part
AM 817 Karl-Heinz Florenz, Thomas Ulmer
Falls if COMP 45 AM 812-813 Adopted
Compatible with ITRE 47.
1
Article 12 paragraph 1 introductory part
AM 814 Marit Paulsen Falls if COMP 45 AM 812-813
Adopted
Compatible with ITRE 47.
1
Article 12 paragraph 1 introductory part
AM 815 Andrés Perelló Rodríguez
Falls if COMP 45 AM 812-813 Adopted
Compatible with 814
Compatible with ITRE 47.
1
Article 12 paragraph 1 introductory part
AM 816 Riikka Manner
Falls if COMP 45 AM 812-
813-815 Adopted
Compatible with 814 ITRE
47. 1
Article 12 paragraph 1 point a
AM 818 Andrés Perelló Rodríguez
Falls if COMP 45 AM 812-813
Adopted
Compatible with ITRE 47.
1
Article 12 paragraph 1 point a
JURI 44 JURI Falls if COMP 45 AM 812-813
Adopted
Compatible with 818
Compatible with ITRE 47.
1
PE516.894v01-00 92/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 12 paragraph 1 point a a (new)
A particular tobacco products is less harmful
AM 819 Ewald Stadler Falls if COMP 45 AM 812-813
Adopted
Compatible with ITRE 47.
1
Article 12 paragraph 1 point b
AM 820 Izaskun Bilbao Barandica
Falls if COMP 45 AM 812-813
Adopted
Compatible with ITRE 47.
1
Article 12 paragraph 1 point b
AM 821 Ewald Stadler Falls if COMP 45 AM 812-
813-820 Adopted
Compatible with ITRE 47.
1
Article 12 paragraph 1 point b
AM 822 P. Bartolozzi, E.Gardini, S.Berlato, S.Tatarella, G. La Via, R.Angelilli
Falls if COMP 45 AM 812-813-820-821
Adopted
Compatible with ITRE 47.
1
Article 12 paragraph 1 point b
AM 823 Renate Sommer, Herbert Reul, Monika Hohlmeier
Article 12 paragraph 1 point b
IMCO 45 lett b
IMCO
IdenticalFalls if COMP
45 AM 812-813-820-821-822 Adopted
Compatible with ITRE 47.
1
Article 12 paragraph 1 point b
AM 825 Jutta Haug Falls if COMP 45 AM 812-
813-820-821-822 Adopted
Compatible with 823 ITRE
47. 1
PV\1001717ES.doc 93/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 12 paragraph 1 point b
AM 824 Andrés PerellóRodríguez
Falls if COMP 45 AM 812-
813-820 Adopted
Compatible with others
Article 12 paragraph 1 point c
AM 826 Milan Cabrnoch
Article 12 paragraph 1 point c
AM 827 Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Malgorzata Handzlik, Boguslaw Sonik
Article 12 paragraph 1 point c
AM 828 Renate Sommer
Article 12 paragraph 1 point c
INTA 33 INTA 33
Article 12 paragraph 1 point c
AM 829 P. Bartolozzi, E. Gardini, S.Berlato, S.Tatarella, G.La Via, R.Angelilli
Article 12 paragraph 1 point c
JURI 45 JURI
Article 12 paragraph 1 point c
ITRE 47 lett c ITRE
Article 12 paragraph 1 point c
AGRI 56 AGRI
Article 12 paragraph 1 point c
AM 830 Jaroslaw Kalinowski
Identical Deletion
Falls if COMP 45 AM 812-813
Adopted
Article 12 paragraph 1 point d
AM 831 Renate Sommer, Herbert Reul
Deletion
Falls if COMP 45 AM 812-813
Adopted
Article 12 paragraph 1 point d
AM 833 P. Bartolozzi, E.Gardini, S.Berlato, S.Tatarella, G. La Via, R.Angelilli
Falls if COMP 45 AM 812-
813-831 Adopted
PE516.894v01-00 94/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 12 paragraph 1 point d
AM 832 Andrés Perelló Rodríguez
Falls if COMP 45 AM 812-
813-831 Adopted
Compatible with 833
Article 12 paragraph 1 point d a new
IMCO 45 lett d a new
IMCO Compatible +
CONS 46
Article 12 paragraph 2
S&D - ALDE -GREENS/EFA
- EFD -GUE/NGL
+
(+47-24)
Article 12 paragraph 2
AM 834 Paul Nuttall, Godfrey Bloom
Article 12 paragraph 2
AM 835 Erminia Mazzoni
Article 12 paragraph 2
JURI 46 JURI
Falls if CONS 46 Adopted
Identical Deletion
Article 12 paragraph 2
AM 836 Renate Sommer, Herbert Reul, Monika Hohlmeier
Falls if CONS 46 AM 834-835
Adopted
Article 12 paragraph 2
IMCO 45Para 2
IMCO Falls if AM 834-835-836
Adopted
Article 12 paragraph 2
AM 837 P. Bartolozzi, E.Gardini, S.Berlato, S.Tatarella, G. La Via, R.Angelilli
Article 12 paragraph 2
AM 838 Cristiana Muscardini
Identical
Falls if CONS 46 AM 834-
835-836-IMCO 45 para 2 Adopted
Article 12 paragraph 2
INTA 34 INTA 34 Falls if CONS 46 AM 834-
835-836-IMCO 45 para 2-837-838 Adopted
Article 12 paragraph 2
AM 839 Christa Klaß
Article 12 paragraph 2
AM 840 Holger Krahmer
IdenticalFalls if CONS 46 AM 834-
835-836-IMCO 45 para 2-837-838-INTA 34
Adopted
PV\1001717ES.doc 95/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 12 paragraph 2
AM 841 Kristian Vigenin
Withdrawn
Falls if CONS 46 AM 834-
835-836-IMCO 45 para 2-837-838-INTA 34-
839-840 Adopted
W
Article 12 paragraph 2
AM 842 Milan Cabrnoch
Falls if CONS 46 AM 834-
835-836-IMCO 45 para 2-837-838-INTA 34-839-840-841
Adopted
Article 12 paragraph 2
AM 843 Jaroslaw Kalinowski
Article 12 paragraph 2
AGRI 57 AGRI
IdenticalFalls if CONS 46 AM 834-
835-836-IMCO 45 para 2-837-838-INTA 34-839-840-841-842 Adopted
Article 12 paragraph 2
AM 848 Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Malgorzata Handzlik, Boguslaw Sonik
Falls if CONS 46 AM 834-
835-836-IMCO 45 para 2-837-838-INTA 34-839-840-841-
842-843 AGRI 57 Adopted
Article 12 paragraph 2
AM 844 Marian-Jean Marinescu
Article 12 paragraph 2
AM 845 Timothy Kirkhope
Article 12 paragraph 2
AM 846 Maria do Céu Patrão Neves
Article 12 paragraph 2
AM 847 Eleni Theocharous
Article 12 paragraph 2
AM 849 Paul Nuttall, Godfrey Bloom
Article 12 paragraph 2
AM 850 Sergej Kozlík
Article 12 paragraph 2
AM 851 Daniël van der Stoep
Article 12 paragraph 2
AM 854 Ewald Stadler
Article 12 paragraph 2
AM 855 Erik Bánki
Identical
Falls if CONS 46 AM 834-
835-836-IMCO 45 para 2-837-838-INTA 34-839-840-841-842-843-848
Adopted
PE516.894v01-00 96/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 12 paragraph 2
ITRE 47 para 2
Article 12 paragraph 2
AM 856 Georgios Koumoutsakos
Article 12 paragraph 2
AM 852 Sari Essayah Falls if CONS 46 AM 834-
835-836-IMCO 45 para 2-837-838-INTA 34-839-840-841-842-843-848
and AM 844 to 856 Adopted
Article 12 paragraph 2
AM 853 Eleni Theocharous
Falls if CONS 46 AM 834-
835-836-IMCO 45 para 2-837-838-INTA 34-839-840-841-842-843-848
and AM 844 to 856 Adopted
Compatible with AM 852
Article 12 paragraph 2 point 1 (new)
Scientifically established communications
AM 857 Eleni Theocharous
-
Article 12 paragraph 2 subparagraph 1 (new)
Filter cigarettes
AM 858 R. Sommer, H. Reul, K-H.Florenz, P. Liese, E. Brok
+
Article 12 paragraph 2 point 1 (new)
Watermarks on cigarette paper
AM 859 R. Sommer, H. Reul, K-H.Florenz, P. Liese
+
Article 12 paragraph 2 a (new)
Misleading texts and graphics
AM 860 Milan Cabrnoch
-
(+14-56)
PV\1001717ES.doc 97/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 12 paragraph 2 a (new)
Variety of tobacco/country of origin
AM 861 G. Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F. E. Speroni, C.Morganti, L.Fontana
-(+32-33)
Article 12 paragraph 2 a (new)
AGRI 58 AGRI
Identical
Oral Amendment by Greens/Efa:Change the text as follows:"and its country of origin shall be indicated"If OA not adopted
Amendment without the oral
amendment
+
(+35-31)
CONS 47
Article 13
S&D - EPP -ALDE - ECR
+
Article 13 AM 862 Paul Nuttall, Godfrey Bloom
All Amendments
covered by CONS 47 Fell
Article 13 AM 863 P. Bartolozzi, E. Gardini, S.Berlato, S.Tatarella, G.La Via, R.Angelilli
Article 13 INTA 35 INTAArticle 13 ITRE 48 ITREArticle 13 AM 864 Pilar Ayuso,
María Auxiliadora Correa Zamora, Esther Herranz García
Falls if CONS 47 Adopted
Identical Deletion
Article 13 paragraph 1
AM 865 Cristiana Muscardini
Article 13 paragraph 1
AM 866 Paul Nuttall, Godfrey Bloom
Article 13 paragraph 1
AM 867 Paul Nuttall, Godfrey Bloom
Article 13 paragraph 1
AM 868 Christa Klaß
Article 13 paragraph 1
AM 869 Godfrey Bloom
Article 13 paragraph 1
AM 870 Erminia Mazzoni
Article 13 paragraph 1
AM 871 Marian-Jean Marinescu
Falls if CONS 47 Adopted
Identical Deletion
Falls if AM 862 to 864 Adopted
PE516.894v01-00 98/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 13 paragraph 1
AGRI 59 AGRI
Article 13 IMCO 46 IMCO Falls if CONS 47 AM 862 to
864 and 865 to 871 Adopted
Article 13 paragraph 1
JURI 47 JURI Falls if CONS 47 AM 862 to
864 and 865 to 871-IMCO 46-
AdoptedArticle 13 paragraph 1
Unit packet of cigarettes: 33 g in total- Roll your own 80 gr
AM 882 Toine Manders
Falls if CONS 47 AM 862 to
864 and 865 to 871-IMCO 46--
JURI 47 Adopted
Article 13 paragraph 1
Unit packet of cigarettes: 10 cigarettes in total - Roll your own 12,5 g
AM 878 James Nicholson, Diane Dodds
Falls if CONS 47 AM 862 to
864 and 865 to 871-IMCO 46-and JURI 47-882 Adopted
Article 13 paragraph 1
Roll your own 20 g
AM 883 Milan Cabrnoch
Falls if CONS 47 AM 862 to 864 and 865 to 871-IMCO 46-and JURI 47-882-878 Adopted
Article 13 paragraph 1
Roll your own 50 g
AM 884 Claudiu Ciprian Tanasescu, Minodora Cliveti
Falls if CONS 47 AM 862 to
864 and 865 to 871-IMCO 46-and JURI 47-882-878-883
AdoptedArticle 13 paragraph 1
19 Cigarettes
AM 885 Erik Bánki Falls if CONS 47 AM 862 to
864 and 865 to 871-IMCO 46-and JURI 47-882-878-883-884 Adopted
Article 13 paragraph 1
AM 877 Karl-Heinz Florenz, Peter Liese, Thomas Ulmer
Article 13 paragraph 1
AM 876 Renate Sommer
Identical
Falls if CONS 47 AM 862 to
864 and 865 to 871-IMCO 46-and JURI 47-882-878-883-
884-885 Adopted
PV\1001717ES.doc 99/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 13 paragraph 1
AM 879 Marian Harkin, Pat the Cope Gallagher, Jim Higgins
Falls if CONS 47 AM 862 to
864 and 865 to 871-IMCO 46-and JURI 47-882-878-883-884-885-877-876 Adopted
Article 13 paragraph 1
AM 875 Holger Krahmer
Falls if CONS 47 AM 862 to
864 and 865 to 871-IMCO 46-and JURI 47-882-878-883-884-885-877-
876-879 Adopted
Article 13 paragraph 1
AM 880 Julie Girling Falls if CONS 47 AM 862 to
864 and 865 to 871-IMCO 46-and JURI 47-882-878-883-884-885-877-876-879-875
AdoptedArticle 13 paragraph 1
AM 874 Rebecca Taylor, Matthias Groote
Falls if CONS 47 AM 862 to
864 and 865 to 871-IMCO 46-and JURI 47-882-878-883-884-885-877-876-879-875-880 Adopted
Article 13 paragraph 1
AM 872 Timothy Kirkhope, Renate Sommer
Article 13 paragraph 1
AM 873 Emma McClarkin
Identical
Falls if CONS 47 AM 862 to
864 and 865 to 871-IMCO 46-and JURI 47-882-878-883-884-885-877-876-879-875-
880-874 Adopted
PE516.894v01-00 100/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 13 paragraph 1
AM 881 Michèle Striffler
Falls if CONS 47 AM 862 to
864 and 865 to 871-IMCO 46-and JURI 47-878-883-877-876-879-875-880-874-872-873 Adopted
Compatible with 882-884-
885
Article 13 paragraph 1
AM 886 Theodoros Skylakakis
Falls if CONS 47 AM 862 to
864 and 865 to 871-IMCO 46-and JURI 47-883-877-876-
Adopted
Compatible with 882-878-884-885-879-875-880-874-
872-873CONS 48
Article 13paragraph 1a new and 2
S&D - ALDE -ECR - EFD
+
Article 13 paragraph 2
AM 887 Paul Nuttall, Godfrey Bloom
All Amendments covered by CONS 48
FellArticle 13 paragraph 2
AM 888 Milan Cabrnoch
Article 13 paragraph 2
AM 889 Holger Krahmer
Article 13 paragraph 2
AM 890 Karl-Heinz Florenz, Peter Liese, Thomas Ulmer, Christa Klaß
Article 13 paragraph 2
JURI 48 JURI
Falls if CONS 48 AM 862 to
864 and IMCO 46 Adopted
Identical Deletion
Article 13 paragraph 2
AM 891 Julie Girling Falls if CONS 48 AM 862 to
864 and IMCO 46 - 887 to 890 Adopted
PV\1001717ES.doc 101/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 13 paragraph 2
AM 892 Erminia Mazzoni
Falls if CONS 48 AM 862 to
864 and IMCO 46 -887 to 890 and AM 891 Adopted
Article 13 paragraph 2
AM 894 James Nicholson, Diane Dodds
Article 13 paragraph 2
AGRI 60 AGRI
Identical
Falls if CONS 48 AM 862 to
864 and IMCO 46 - 887 to 890 and AM
891-892 Adopted
Article 13 paragraph 2
AM 893 Rebecca Taylor
Falls if CONS 48 AM 862 to
864 and IMCO 46 - 887 to 890 and AM
891-892-894 Adopted
Article 13 -paragraph 2
AM 33 Linda McAvan
Falls if CONS 48 AM 862 to
864 and IMCO 46 - 887 to 890 Adopted
Compatible with others
Article 13 paragraph 2
AM 895 Renate Sommer, Herbert Reul, Peter Liese
Falls if CONS 48 AM 862 to
864 and IMCO 46 - 887 to 890 Adopted
Compatible as addition
Article 13 paragraph 2
AM 896 Theodoros Skylakakis
Falls if CONS 48 AM 862 to
864 and IMCO 46 - 887 to 890 and AM
891-892-894 Adopted
Compatible with 893-33-
895CONS 51
Article 13 -paragraph 2 a (new)
S&D -GREENS/EFA
- GUE/NGL
-
(+28-41)
PE516.894v01-00 102/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 13 -paragraph 2 a (new)
Standardised outer surface unit packet and outside packaging
AM 34 Linda McAvan
-
(+32-37)
Article 13 -paragraph 2 b (new)
AM 35 Linda McAvan
Falls if CONS 51 Adopted
VOTE IN BLOCK
Article 13 paragraph 2 a (new)
-
(+29-41)
AM 897 G. Willmott, K. T. Liotard, C. Schlyter, N.Childers, C.Stihler, A.Parvanova
Falls if CONS 51 AM 34-35
Adopted
Oral Amendment by Greens/Efa:Change the text as follows:"tobacco for smoking not regulated by articles 7, 8 and 9shall be standardised.."If OA not adopted
Amendment without the oral
amendment
-
(+30-40)
COMP 49
Article 13 paragraph 3
S&D - EPP -ALDE -
GREENS/EFA - ECR - EFD -
GUE/NGL
+
Article 13 paragraph 3
AM 898 Cristiana Muscardini
All Amendments covered by COMP 49
FellArticle 13 paragraph 3
AM 899 Gaston Franco
Article 13 paragraph 3
AM 900 MilanCabrnoch
Article 13 paragraph 3
AM 901 Christa Klaß
Article 13 paragraph 3
AM 902 Holger Krahmer
Article 13 paragraph 3
AM 903 Jaroslaw Kalinowski
Article 13 paragraph 3
AM 904 Godfrey Bloom
Falls if COMP 49 AM 862 to
864 and IMCO 46Adopted
Identical Deletion
PV\1001717ES.doc 103/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 13 paragraph 3
AM 905 James Nicholson, Diane Dodds
Article 13 paragraph 3
AM 906 Julie Girling
Article 13 paragraph 3
AM 907 Ewald Stadler
Article 13 paragraph 3
AM 908 Evelyn Regner, Karin Kadenbach
Article 13 paragraph 3
AM 909 Erik Bánki
Article 13 paragraph 3
AM 910 G. Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F. E. Speroni, C.Morganti, L.Fontana
Article 13 paragraph 3
JURI 49 JURI
Article 13 paragraph 3
AGRI 61 AGRI
Article 13 paragraph 3
AM 911 R. Sommer, H. Reul, P. Liese, M.Hohlmeier, E.Brok
Article 13 paragraph 3
AM 913 Jutta Haug
Identical in content
Falls if COMP 49 AM 862 to
864 and IMCO 46-898
to 910 Adopted
Article 13 paragraph 3
AM 912 Georgios Koumoutsakos
Falls if COMP 79 AM 862 to
864 and IMCO 46- 898 to 910 and AM
911-913 Adopted
Article 13 paragraph 3
AM 914 Erminia Mazzoni
Falls if COMP 49 AM 862 to 864 and IMCO 46- 898 to 910 and AM 911-913-912 Adopted
Article 13 -paragraph 3
AM 36 Linda McAvan
Falls if COMP 49 AM 862 to
864 and IMCO 46- 898 to 910 and AM
911-913-912-914 Adopted
Falls if AM 34 Not Adopted
PE516.894v01-00 104/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
CONS 50
Article 13 paragraph 4
S&D - ALDE -GREENS/EFA
- GUE/NGL
+
(+36-33)
Article 13 paragraph 4
AM 915 Cristiana Muscardini
All Amendments covered byCONS 50
FellArticle 13 paragraph 4
AM 916 Gaston Franco
Article 13 paragraph 4
AM 917 Milan Cabrnoch
Article 13 paragraph 4
AM 918 Christa Klaß
Article 13 paragraph 4
AM 919 Holger Krahmer
Article 13 paragraph 4
AM 920 Godfrey Bloom
Article 13 paragraph 4
AM 921 James Nicholson, Diane Dodds
Article 13 paragraph 4
AM 922 Julie Girling
Article 13 paragraph 4
AM 923 Ewald Stadler
Article 13 paragraph 4
AM 924 Renate Sommer, Monika Hohlmeier
Article 13 paragraph 4
AM 925 Karl-HeinzFlorenz, Thomas Ulmer
Article 13 paragraph 4
AM 926 Evelyn Regner, Karin Kadenbach
Article 13 paragraph 4
AM 927 Erik Bánki
Article 13 paragraph 4
AM 928 G. Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F. E. Speroni, C.Morganti, L.Fontana
Article 13 paragraph 4
AGRI 62 AGRI
Article 13 paragraph 4
JURI 50 JURI
Falls if CONS 50 AM 862 to
864 and IMCO 46Adopted
IdenticalDeletion
PV\1001717ES.doc 105/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 13 paragraph 4
AM 929 Erminia Mazzoni
Article 13 paragraph 4
AM 930 Georgios Koumoutsakos
Falls if CONS 50 862 to 864 and IMCO 46Adopted AM
915 to 929 Adopted
CONS 52
Article 14
S&D - EPP -ALDE -
GREENS/EFA GUE/NGL
+
Article 14 AM 931 Paul Nuttall, Godfrey Bloom
All Amendments covered by
CONS 52 FellArticle 14 AM 932 Renate
Sommer
Falls if CONS 52 Adopted
Identical Deletion
Article 14 paragraph 1
AM 933 Cristiana Muscardini
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-932
Adopted
DeletionArticle 14 IMCO 47 IMCO Falls if CONS
52 AM 931-932 -933- Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 1
INTA 36 INTA 36
Article 14 paragraph 1
JURI 51 JURI
Identical in content
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-932 -933-IMCO 47-
Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 1
AM 936 Bernadette Vergnaud
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-932 -933-IMCO 47-
-INTA 36 Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 1
AM 940 Linda McAvan
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-932 -933-IMCO 47-INTA 36-936
Adopted
Article 14 -paragraph 1
AM 37 Linda McAvan
Withdrawn
IdenticalFalls if CONS
52 AM 931-932 -933-IMCO 47-INTA 36-936-940 Adopted
W
PE516.894v01-00 106/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 14 paragraph 1
AM 934 Nessa Childers
IdenticalFalls if CONS
52 AM 931-932 -933-IMCO 47-INTA 36-936-940 Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 1
AM 935 Marit Paulsen Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-932 -933-IMCO 47-
INTA 36-Adopted
Compatible with others
Article 14 paragraph 1
AM 937 Georgios Koumoutsakos
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-932 -933-IMCO 47-
INTA 36 Adopted
Compatible with others
Article 14 paragraph 1
ITRE 49 ITRE Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-932 -933-IMCO 47-INTA 36-936
Adopted
Compatible with others
Article 14 paragraph 1
AM 938 Gilles Pargneaux
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-932 -933-IMCO 47-INTA 36-936-
ITRE 49 Adopted
Compatible with others
Article 14 paragraph 1
AM 939 Erik Bánki Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-932 -933-IMCO 47-
Adopted
Compatible with others as
addition
PV\1001717ES.doc 107/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 14 paragraph 1 a (new)
Link between the unique identifier of the packet and transport packaging
AM 941 Linda McAvan
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-932 -933-IMCO 47-
Adopted
Article 14 -paragraph 2 a (new)
AM 38 Linda McAvan
Withdrawn
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-932 -933-IMCO 47-
941 Adopted
W
Article 14 -paragraph 2 a (new)
INTA 37 INTA 37 Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-932 -933-IMCO 47-
941-38 Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 2 introductory part
AM 942 Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Malgorzata Handzlik, Boguslaw Sonik
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-932
Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 2 introductory part
ITRE 50 ITRE Compatible
Article 14 paragraph 2 point e
AM 943 Erik Bánki
Article 14 paragraph 2 point e
JURI 52 JURI
Identical
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47- Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 2 point e
INTA 38 INTA 38 Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47-943 Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 2 point f
AM 944 Cristiana Muscardini
Deletion
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47-Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 2 point g
AM 945 Cristiana Muscardini
Article 14 paragraph 2 point g
AM 946 Milan Cabrnoch
IdenticalDeletion
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
PE516.894v01-00 108/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 14 paragraph 2 point g
AM 947 P. Bartolozzi, E. Gardini, S.Berlato, G. La Via, R.Angelilli
932-IMCO 47-Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 2 point g
INTA 39 INTA 39
Article 14 paragraph 2 point g
AM 949 Bernadette Vergnaud
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47-INTA 39 Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 2 point g
AM 948 Gilles Pargneaux
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47-INTA 39-949
Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 2 point g
AM 950 Izaskun Bilbao Barandica
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47-INTA 39Adopted
Compatible with 949-948
Article 14 paragraph 2 point h
AM 951 Cristiana Muscardini
Article 14 paragraph 2 point h
AM 952 Milan Cabrnoch
Article 14 paragraph 2 point h
AM 953 P. Bartolozzi, E. Gardini, S.Berlato, G. La Via, R.Angelilli
IdenticalDeletion
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47-Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 2 point i
AM 954 Cristiana Muscardini
Deletion
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47-Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 2 point i
JURI 53 JURI Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47-954 Adopted
PV\1001717ES.doc 109/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 14 paragraph 2 point i
AM 955 P. Bartolozzi, E. Gardini, S.Berlato, G. La Via, R.Angelilli
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47-954-JURI 53
Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 2 point i
AM 958 Georgios Koumoutsakos
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47-954-JURI 53-955 Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 2 point i
AM 956 Cristian Silviu Busoi
W
Article 14 paragraph 2 point i
AM 957 Izaskun Bilbao Barandica
Withdrawn(Author no
longer a Member)
Identical
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47-954-JURI 53-
955-958 Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 2 point j
AM 959 Cristiana Muscardini
Article 14 paragraph 2 point j
AM 960 Georgios Koumoutsakos
IdenticalDeletion
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47-Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 2 point j
JURI 54 JURI Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47-959-960 Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 2 point j
Customer
AM 961 Cristian Silviu Busoi
Article 14 paragraph 2 point j
Customer
ITRE 51 ITRE
Article 14 paragraph 2 point j
AM 964 Izaskun Bilbao Barandica
Article 14 paragraph 2 point j
Buyer
AM 962 Milan Cabrnoch
Identicalin content
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47-959-960 and
JURI 54 Adopted
PE516.894v01-00 110/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 14 paragraph 2 point j
Purchaser
AM 963 P. Bartolozzi, E. Gardini, S.Berlato, G. La Via, R.Angelilli
Article 14 paragraph 2 point k
AM 965 Cristiana Muscardini
Article 14 paragraph 2 point k
AM 966 Georgios Koumoutsakos
IdenticalDeletion
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47-Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 2 point k
JURI 55 JURI Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47--965-966 Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 2 point k
Customer
AM 967 Cristian Silviu Busoi
W
Article 14 paragraph 2 point k
Customer
ITRE 52 ITRE
Article 14 paragraph 2 point k
Buyer
AM 968 Milan Cabrnoch
Article 14 paragraph 2 point k
Purchaser
AM 969 P. Bartolozzi, E. Gardini, S.Berlato, G. La Via, R.Angelilli
Withdrawn(Author no
longer a Member)
Identical in content
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47--965-966-JURI
55 Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 2 a (new)
AM 970 Nessa Childers
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47--941 Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 2 a (new)
Safeguard against counterfeiting
AM 971 Jutta Haug Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47-Adopted
PV\1001717ES.doc 111/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 14 paragraph 3
AM 973 Milan Cabrnoch
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47-Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 3
INTA 40 INTA 40 Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47--973 Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 3
AM 972 Nessa Childers
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47--973-INTA 40
Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 3
AM 976 P. Bartolozzi, E. Gardini, S.Berlato, G. La Via, R.Angelilli
Article 14 paragraph 3
JURI 56 JURI
Identical
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47--973-INTA 40
Adopted
Compatible with 972
Article 14 -paragraph 3
AM 39 Linda McAvan
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47--973-INTA 40-972 Adopted
Compatible with others
Article 14 paragraph 3
AM 974 Martina Anderson, Kartika Tamara Liotard
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47--973-INTA 40-
972-39 AdoptedAdopted
Compatible with 973-976
Article 14 paragraph 3
AM 975 Cristian Silviu Busoi
W
Article 14 paragraph 3
AM 977 Izaskun Bilbao Barandica
975 Withdrawn(Author no
longer a Member)
PE516.894v01-00 112/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 14 paragraph 3
ITRE 53 ITREIdentical
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47--973-INTA 40-976 Adopted
Compatible with others
Article 14 paragraph 3 a (new)
Technology for tracking and tracing
AM 978 Pilar Ayuso Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47-Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 3 a (new)
Seul Protocol illicit trade
INTA 41 INTA 41 Falls if AM 978 Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 4
AM 979 Cristiana Muscardini
Deletion
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47-Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 4
AM 980 Milan Cabrnoch
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47--979 Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 4
JURI 57 JURI IdenticalFalls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47--979-980 Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 4
AM 982 Cristian Silviu Busoi
W
Article 14 paragraph 4
AM 984 Izaskun Bilbao Barandica
Identical982
Withdrawn(Author no
longer a Member)
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47--979-980-JURI
57 Adopted
PV\1001717ES.doc 113/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 14 paragraph 4
AM 983 P. Bartolozzi, E. Gardini, S.Berlato, G. La Via, R.Angelilli
Article 14 paragraph 4
ITRE 54 ITRE
Identical
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47--979-980-JURI
57-982 Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 4
AM 981 Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Malgorzata Handzlik, Boguslaw Sonik
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47--979 Adopted
Compatible with others
Article 14 paragraph 5
AM 985 Cristiana Muscardini
DeletionFalls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47-Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 6
AM 986 Cristiana Muscardini
Deletion
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47-Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 6
INTA 42 INTA 42 Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47--986 Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 6
AM 987 Nessa Childers
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47--986-INTA 42
Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 6
AM 988 Carl Schlyter Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47--986-INTA 42-987 Adopted
PE516.894v01-00 114/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 14 -paragraph 6
AM 40 Linda McAvan
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47--986-INTA 42-
987-988 Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 6
AM 989 Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Malgorzata Handzlik, Boguslaw Sonik
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47--986-INTA 42-
987-988 Adopted
Compatible with Am 40
Article 14 paragraph 6
JURI 58 JURI Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47--986- Adopted
Compatible with others
Article 14 paragraph 7
AM 990 Cristiana Muscardini
Deletion
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47-Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 8
AM 995 Erik Bánki Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47-Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 8
AM 996 Izaskun Bilbao Barandica
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47-Adopted
Compatible with 995
Article 14 paragraph 8
AM 994 Cristian Silviu Busoi
Identical994
W
PV\1001717ES.doc 115/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 14 paragraph 8
JURI 59 JURI Withdrawn(Author no
longer a Member)
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47--996 Adopted
Compatible with 995
Article 14 paragraph 8
AM 992 Milan Cabrnoch
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47-996 Adopted
Compatible with others
Article 14 paragraph 8
ITRE 55 ITRE Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47-Adopted
Compatiblewith others
Article 14 -paragraph 8
AM 41 Linda McAvan
Article 14 paragraph 8
AM 991 Nessa Childers
Identical
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47--996-992 Adopted
Compatible with others
Article 14 paragraph 8
AM 993 Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Malgorzata Handzlik, Boguslaw Sonik
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47-Adopted
Compatible with others
CONS 53
Article 14 paragraph 9
S&D - EPP -ALDE -
GREENS/EFA - EFD -
GUE/NGL
+
Article 14 paragraph 9
AM 997 Cristiana Muscardini
All Amendments
covered by CONS 53 Fell
Article 14 paragraph 9
AM 998 Gaston Franco
Falls if CONS 53 Adopted
DeletionIdentical
PE516.894v01-00 116/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 14 paragraph 9
AM 999 Milan Cabrnoch
Article 14 paragraph 9
AM 1000 Ewald Stadler
Article 14 paragraph 9
AM 1001 Erik Bánki
Falls if AM 931-932-IMCO
47- Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 9 introductory part
AM 1002 P. Bartolozzi, E. Gardini, S.Berlato, S.Tatarella, G.La Via, R.Angelilli
Falls if CONS 53 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47-and AM 997 to 1001 Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 9 point a
AM 1003 Cristiana Muscardini
Deletion
Falls if CONS 53 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47-and AM 997 to 1001 Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 9 point b
AM 1004 Cristiana Muscardini
Deletion
Falls if CONS 53 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47-and AM 997 to 1001 Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 9 point b
AM 1005 Evelyn Regner, Karin Kadenbach
Falls if CONS 53 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47-and AM 997 to 1001 and 1004
Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 9 point b
AM 1006 P. Bartolozzi, E. Gardini, S.Berlato, S.Tatarella, G.La Via, R.Angelilli
Falls if CONS 53 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47-and AM 997 to 1001 and 1004-1005 Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 9 point c
AM 1007 Cristiana Muscardini
Article 14 paragraph 9 point c
AM 1008 P. Bartolozzi, E. Gardini, S.Berlato, S.Tatarella, G.La Via, R.Angelilli
Article 14 paragraph 9 point c
JURI 60 JURI
DeletionIdentical
Falls if CONS 53 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47-and AM 997 to 1001 Adopted
PV\1001717ES.doc 117/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 14 paragraph 9 subparagraph 1 a (new)
Delegated acts -relevant requirements
AM 1009 Cristian Silviu Busoi
Withdrawn(Author no
longer a Member)
Falls if CONS 52 AM 931-
932-IMCO 47-Adopted
W
Article 14 paragraph 10
AM 1010 Cristiana Muscardini
-
Article 14 paragraph 10
AM 1011 Sari Essayah
Deletion
Falls if AM 931-932-IMCO
47- Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 10
AM 1012 Holger Krahmer
-
(+16-54)Article 14 paragraph 10
AM 1014 G. Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F. E. Speroni, C.Morganti, L.Fontana
Article 14 paragraph 10
JURI 61 JURI
Article 14 paragraph 10
ITRE 56 ITRE
Article 14 paragraph 10
AGRI 63 AGRI
Identical
Falls if AM 931-932-IMCO 47- and 1010-1011 Adopted
Article 14 paragraph 10
AM 1013 Claudiu Ciprian Tanasescu, Minodora Cliveti
Falls if AM 931-932-IMCO 47- and 1010-1011 Adopted
Compatible with 1012-1014
-
COMP 54
Article 15
S&D - EPP -ALDE -
GREENS/EFA - ECR - EFD -
GUE/NGL
Vote of the original text
authorised by the Chaimanin accordance to art 161 para
3
+
Title 2 - Chapter 3 - Title
INTA 43 INTA All Amendments covered by COMP 54
FellTitle 2 - Chapter 3 - Title
IMCO 48 IMCO
Falls if COMP 54 Adopted
Identical
PE516.894v01-00 118/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 15 AM 1015 C.Fjellner, J. L. Walesa, B.Bendtsen, R. Sommer
Article 15 INTA 44 INTA 44
Falls if COMP 54 Adopted
IdenticalFalls if COMP
54 Adopted
DeletionArticle 15 paragraph 1
AM 1016 Daniël van der Stoep
Falls if COMP 54 AM 1015 -
INTA 44 Adopted
Article 15 paragraph 1
AGRI 64 AGRI Falls if COMP 54 AM 1015 -INTA 44-1016
AdoptedArticle 15 paragraph 1
AM 1017 Morten Messerschmidt
Falls if COMP 54 AM 1015-
INTA 44-1016-AGRI 64 Adopted
Article 15 paragraph 1
AM 1023 Christofer Fjellner, Renate Sommer, Jaroslaw Leszek Walesa, Nils Torvalds
Falls if COMP 54 AM 1015-
1016-1017 Adopted
Article 15 paragraph 1
AM 1020 Christian Engström, Chris Davies, Christofer Fjellner
Falls if COMP 54 AM 1015-1016-1017-
1023 Adopted
Article 15 paragraph 1
AM 1021 Sari Essayah Falls if COMP 54 AM 1015-
1016-1017 Adopted
Compatible with 1023-1020
Article 15 paragraph 1
AM 1022 Nils Torvalds Falls if COMP 54 AM 1015-1016-1017-1023-1020 Adopted
Compatible with 1021
PV\1001717ES.doc 119/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 15 paragraph 1
AM 1018 B.Bendtsen, J.E. Hibner, J. L. Walesa, C.Fjellner, M.Weber, A.Rosbach, B.Sonik
Article 15 paragraph 1
ITRE 57 ITRE
Article 15 paragraph 1
JURI 62 JURI
Identical
Falls if COMP 54 AM 1015-1016-1017-1023-1020-
1022 Adopted
Compatible with 1021
Article 15 paragraph 1
AM 1019 Riikka Manner
Compatible as addition
Article 15 paragraph 1 a (new)
Maximum limits for toxic and carcinogenic substances in smokeless
AM 1024 Christian Engström, Chris Davies, Christofer Fjellner
Article 15 paragraph 1 a (new)
IMCO 49 IMCO
Falls if COMP 54-
1021 Adopted
Identical
Article 15 paragraph 1 a (new)
Content of Snus
AM 1025 Åsa Westlund, Marita Ulvskog
Falls if COMP 54 Adopted
Article 15 paragraph 1 a (new)
Exemption for Snus
AM 1026 C.Fjellner, J. L. Walesa, B.Bendtsen, R. Sommer
Falls if COMP 54 Adopted
Article 15 paragraph 1 b (new)
Delegated act for annex III
AM 1027 Christian Engström, Chris Davies, Christofer Fjellner
Article 15 paragraph 1 b (new)
IMCO 50 IMCO
Falls if COMP 54 Adopted
Identical
Annex 2 a (new)
Maximum permissible content in smokeless tobacco
AM 1359 Christian Engström, Chris Davies, Christofer Fjellner
Annex 2 a (new) IMCO 72 IMCO
Identical
Falls if CONS 54
Adopted AM 1024 NotAdopted
PE516.894v01-00 120/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
CONS 55
Article 16
S&D - EPP -ALDE -
GREENS/EFA - EFD -
GUE/NGL
+
Title 2 chapter 4 title
AM 1029 G.Willmott, A.Perelló Rodríguez, K. T. Liotard, C.Schlyter, N.Childers, C.Stihler, A.Parvanova
Falls if CONS 55 Adopted
All Amendments covered by
CONS 55 Fell
Title 2 chapter 4 title
AM 1028 Frédérique Ries, Corinne Lepage
Falls if CONS 55 AM 1029
AdoptedArticle 16 title AM 1031 G. Willmott,
A. Perelló Rodríguez, C.Schlyter, N.Childers, C.Stihler, A.Parvanova
Article 16 title AGRI 65 AGRI
Identical
Article 16 title AM 1030 Frédérique Ries, Corinne Lepage
Falls if CONS 55 AM 1031
AdoptedArticle 16 paragraph 1 introductory part
AM 1033 Riikka Manner
Article 16 paragraph 1 introductory part
AM 1032 Andrés Perelló Rodríguez
Falls if CONS 55 AM 1033
AdoptedArticle 16 paragraph 1 introductory part
Prohibit cross-border distance sales of TP
AM 1034 Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Malgorzata Handzlik, Boguslaw Sonik
Article 16 paragraph 1 introductory part
AM 1039 Eija-Riitta Korhola
Article 16 paragraph 1 introductory part
AM 1041 Erik Bánki
Article 16 paragraph 1 introductory part
AM 1040 Sari Essayah
Identical in content
Falls if CONS 55 AM 1033-1032 Adopted
PV\1001717ES.doc 121/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 16 paragraph 1 introductory part
INTA 45 INTA 45 Falls if CONS 55 AM Falls if
CONS 55 AM 1033-1032 and
AM 1034 to 1040 Adopted
Article 16 paragraph 1 introductory part
AM 1035 Martina Anderson
Falls if CONS 55 AM Falls if AM 1033-1032 and AM 1034 to 1040 INTA 45 Adopted
Article 16 -paragraph 1
AM 42 Linda McAvan
Article 16 paragraph 1 introductory part
AM 1036 Cristian Silviu Busoi
Article 16 paragraph 1 introductory part
AM 1042 Giancarlo Scottà, Oreste Rossi, Matteo Salvini, Claudio Morganti, Lorenzo Fontana
Identical
1036Withdrawn(Author no
longer a Member)
Falls if CONS 55 AM 1033-1032 and AM 1034 and to
1040 - INTA 45 and AM 1035
AdoptedArticle 16 paragraph 1 introductory part
IMCO 51 1st part
IMCO Falls if CONS 55 AM 1033-1032 and AM 1034 and to
1040 - INTA 45 and AM 1035-42-1036-1042
AdoptedArticle 16 paragraph 1 introductory part
AM 1037 P. Bartolozzi, E. Gardini, S.Berlato, G. La Via, R.Angelilli
Falls if CONS 55 AM 1033-1032 and AM 1034 and to
1040 - INTA 45 and AM 1035-42-1036-1042-IMCO 51 1st
AdoptedArticle 16 paragraph 1 introductory part
Internet sales
AM 1043 G. Willmott, A. Perelló Rodríguez, C.Schlyter, N.Childers, C.Stihler, A.Parvanova
Article 16 paragraph 1 introductory part
Internet sales
AGRI 66 1st part
Introductory part
AGRI
Identical
Falls if CONS 55 AM 1033-1032 and AM 1034 and to
1040 - INTA 45 and AM 1035-42-1036-1042-IMCO 51 1st-1037 Adopted
PE516.894v01-00 122/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 16 paragraph 1 introductory part
Internet sales
AM 1038 Frédérique Ries, Corinne Lepage
Falls if CONS 55 AM 1033-1032 and AM 1034 and to
1040 - INTA 45 and AM 1035-42-1036-1042-IMCO 51 1st-
1037-1043 Adopted
Article 16 paragraph 1 a (new)
Internet sales
AM 1046 Corinne Lepage
Falls if CONS 55 AM 1043-1038 Adopted
Article 16 paragraph 1 a (new)
Prohibit distribution of free or discounted TP
AM 1047 G. Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F. E. Speroni, C.Morganti, L.Fontana
Article 16 paragraph 1 a (new)
AGRI 67 AGRI
Article 16 paragraph 1 a (new)
IMCO 512nd part
Falls if CONS 55 Adopted
Identical
Article 16 -paragraph 1 a (new)
Prohibit distribution of free or discounted TP
AM 43 Linda McAvan
Article 16 paragraph 1 a (new)
AM 1044 Cristian Silviu Busoi
Article 16 paragraph 1 a (new)
INTA 50 INTA 50
IdenticalFalls if CONS
55 AM 1047 AdoptedIdentical
1044 Withdrawn
(Author no longer a
Member)
Article 16 paragraph 1 a new
Restrictions for personal use
INTA 49 INTA 49
Article 16 paragraph 1 point a
AM 1048 Martina Anderson, Kartika Tamara Liotard
Falls if CONS 55
IdenticalDeletion
PV\1001717ES.doc 123/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 16 paragraph 1 point a
AM 1049 Cristian Silviu Busoi
Article 16 paragraph 1 point a
AM 1050 Riikka Manner
Article 16 paragraph 1 point a
INTA 46 INTA 46
Article 16 paragraph 1 point a
AM 1051 Erik Bánki
Article 16 paragraph 1 point a
AM 1052 Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Malgorzata Handzlik, Boguslaw Sonik
Article 16 paragraph 1 point a
AM 1053 P. Bartolozzi, E. Gardini, S.Berlato, G. La Via, R.Angelilli
Article 16 paragraph 1 point a
AM 1054 Sari Essayah
Article 16 paragraph 1 point a
AM 1055 G. Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, C.Morganti, L.Fontana
Article 16 paragraph 1 point a
IMCO 51point a
IMCO
Article 16 paragraph 1 point a
AGRI 662nd part
AGRI
1049 Withdrawn(Author no
longer a Member)
Article 16 paragraph 1 point b
AM 1056 Martina Anderson, Kartika Tamara Liotard
Article 16 paragraph 1 point b
AM 1057 Cristian Silviu Busoi
Article 16 paragraph 1 point b
AM 1058 Riikka Manner
Article 16 paragraph 1 point b
AM 1059 Erik Bánki
Falls if CONS 55
IdenticalDeletion
1057 Withdrawn(Author no
longer a Member)
PE516.894v01-00 124/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 16 paragraph 1 point b
INTA 47 INTA 47
Article 16 paragraph 1 point b
AM 1060 Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Malgorzata Handzlik, Boguslaw Sonik
Article 16 paragraph 1 point b
AM 1061 P. Bartolozzi, E. Gardini, S.Berlato, G. La Via, R.Angelilli
Article 16 paragraph 1 point b
AGRI 663rd part
AGRI
Article 16 paragraph 1 point b
AM 1062 Sari Essayah
Article 16 paragraph 1 point b
IMCo 51point b
IMCO
Article 16 paragraph 1 point b
AM 1063 G. Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, C.Morganti, L.Fontana
Article 16 paragraph 1 point c
AM 1064 Martina Anderson, Kartika Tamara Liotard
Article 16 paragraph 1 point c
AM 1065 Cristian Silviu Busoi
Article 16 paragraph 1 point c
AM 1066 Riikka Manner
Article 16 paragraph 1 point c
AM 1067 Erik Bánki
Article 16 paragraph 1 point c
AM 1068 Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Malgorzata Handzlik, Boguslaw Sonik
Falls if CONS 55 Adopted
IdenticalDeletion
1065 Withdrawn(Author no
longer a Member)
PV\1001717ES.doc 125/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 16 paragraph 1 point c
AM 1069 P. Bartolozzi, E. Gardini, S.Berlato, G. La Via, R.Angelilli
Article 16 paragraph 1 point c
INTA 48 INTA 48
Article 16 paragraph 1 point c
AM 1070 Sari Essayah
Article 16 paragraph 1 point c
AGRI 664th part
AGRI
Article 16 paragraph 1 point c
IMCO 51point c
IMCO
Article 16 paragraph 1 point c
AM 1071 G. Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, C.Morganti, L.Fontana
Article 16 -paragraph 2
AM 44 Linda McAvan
Article 16 paragraph 2
AM 1072 Riikka Manner
Article 16 paragraph 2
AM 1073 Martina Anderson, Kartika Tamara Liotard
Article 16 paragraph 2
AM 1074 Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Malgorzata Handzlik, Boguslaw Sonik
Article 16 paragraph 2
AM 1075 Cristian Silviu Busoi
Article 16 paragraph 2
AM 1076 P. Bartolozzi, E. Gardini, S.Berlato, G. La Via, R.Angelilli
Article 16 paragraph 2
AM 1077 Eija-Riitta Korhola
Article 16 paragraph 2
AM 1078 Sari Essayah
Article 16 paragraph 2
AM 1079 Erik Bánki
Article 16 paragraph 2
AGRI 665th part
AGRI
Falls if CONS 55 Adopted
IdenticalDeletion
1075 Withdrawn(Author no
longer a Member)
PE516.894v01-00 126/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 16 paragraph 2
IMCO 51Para 2
Article 16 paragraph 2
INTA 51 INTA 51
Article 16 paragraph 2
AM 1080 G. Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, C.Morganti, L.Fontana
Article 16 -paragraph 3
AM 45 Linda McAvan
Article 16 paragraph 3
AM 1082 Riikka Manner
Article 16 paragraph 3
AM 1083 Martina Anderson, Kartika Tamara Liotard
Article 16 paragraph 3
AM 1084 Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Malgorzata Handzlik, Boguslaw Sonik
Article 16 paragraph 3
AM 1085 Cristian Silviu Busoi
Article 16 paragraph 3
AM 1086 P. Bartolozzi, E. Gardini, S.Berlato, G. La Via, R.Angelilli
Article 16 paragraph 3
AM 1087 Eija-Riitta Korhola
Article 16 paragraph 3
AM 1088 Sari Essayah
Article 16 paragraph 3
AM 1089 Erik Bánki
Article 16 paragraph 3
INTA 52 INTA 52
Article 16 paragraph 3
AGRI 667th part
AGRI
Article 16 paragraph 3
IMCO 51Para 3
IMCO
Article 16 paragraph 3
AM 1090 G. Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, C.Morganti, L.Fontana
Falls if CONS 55 Adopted
IdenticalDeletion
1085 Withdrawn(Author no
longer a Member)
Article 16 -paragraph 4
AM 46 Linda McAvan
Falls if CONS 55 Adopted
PV\1001717ES.doc 127/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 16 paragraph 4
AM 1091 Riikka Manner
Article 16 paragraph 4
AM 1092 Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Malgorzata Handzlik, Boguslaw Sonik
Article 16 paragraph 4
AM 1093 Martina Anderson
Article 16 paragraph 4
AM 1094 Cristian Silviu Busoi
Article 16 paragraph 4
AM 1095 P. Bartolozzi, E. Gardini, S.Berlato, G. La Via, R.Angelilli
Article 16 paragraph 4
AM 1096 Eija-Riitta Korhola
Article 16 paragraph 4
INTA 53 INTA 53
Article 16 paragraph 4
IMCO 51Para 4
IMCO
Article 16 paragraph 4
AM 1097 Erik Bánki
Article 16 paragraph 4
AM 1098 G. Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, C.Morganti, L.Fontana
IdenticalDeletion
1094 Withdrawn(Author no
longer a Member)
Article 16 -paragraph 5
AGRI 668th part
Falls if CONS 55 Adopted
Article 16 -paragraph 5
AM 47 Linda McAvan
Article 16 paragraph 5
AM 1099 Riikka Manner
Article 16 paragraph 5
AM 1100 Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Malgorzata Handzlik, Boguslaw Sonik
Article 16 paragraph 5
AM 1101 Martina Anderson
Article 16 paragraph 5
AM 1102 Cristian Silviu Busoi
Article 16 paragraph 5
AM 1103 P. Bartolozzi, E. Gardini, S.Berlato, G. La Via, R.Angelilli
Falls if CONS 55 Adopted
IdenticalDeletion
PE516.894v01-00 128/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 16 paragraph 5
AM 1104 Eija-Riitta Korhola
Article 16 paragraph 5
AM 1105 Sari Essayah
Article 16 paragraph 5
INTA 54 INTA 54
Article 16 paragraph 5
AGRI 669th part
Article 16 paragraph 5
IMCO 51Para 5
Article 16 paragraph 5
AM 1106 Erik Bánki
Article 16 paragraph 5
AM 1107 G. Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, C.Morganti, L.Fontana
Article 16 a (new)
Cross-border sales of Tobacco Products
AM 1108 Gaston Franco Falls if AM from 1032 to 1046 Adopted -
Article 16 paragraph 1 a (new)
Restrictions on import of TP for personal use
AM 1045 Françoise Grossetête, Gaston Franco
Falls if INTA 49 Adopted
+
(-29+40)
Article 16 paragraph 2
AM 1081 Frédérique Ries, Corinne Lepage
Falls if AM 44 to 1080
Adopted+
Article 16 a (new)
Point of sale of Tobacco
AM 1109 Martina Anderson
-
Article 16 a (new)
Quantitative limits on cross-border movements
AM 1110 Corinne Lepage
-
COMP 56
Novel Tobacco Products
Article 17
S&D - EPP -ALDE -
GREENS/EFA - ECR - EFD -
GUE/NGL
+
Title 2 chapter 5 title
AM 1111 Holger Krahmer
Falls if COMP 56 Adopted
All Amendments covered by COMP 56
Fell
PV\1001717ES.doc 129/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 17 AM 1112 Sari Essayah Falls if COMP 56 Adopted
DeletionArticle 17 Title AM 48 Linda
McAvanWithdrawn
Falls if COMP 56 AM 1112
Adopted
W
Article 17 title AM 1117 P. Bartolozzi, E. Gardini, S.Berlato, S.Tatarella, G.La Via, R.Angelilli
Identical
Falls if COMP AM 1112-48
Adopted
Article 17 title IMCO 52 IMCO Falls if COMP 56 AM 1112-
48-1117 Adopted
Article 17 title AM 1118 Erminia Mazzoni
Falls if COMP 56 AM 1112-
48-1117-IMCO 52Adopted
Article 17 title ITRE 58 ITRE Falls if COMP 56 AM 1112-48-1117-1118-
IMCO 52 Adopted
Article 17 title AM 1113 Gaston Franco
Article 17 title AM 1115 Maria do Céu Patrão Neves
Identical in Content
Falls if COMP 56 AM 1112-48-1117-1118-
IMCO 52 Adopted
Article 17 title AM 1114 Holger Krahmer
Falls if COMP 56 AM 1112-48-1117-1118-
IMCO 52-1113-1115 Adopted
Article 17 title AM 1116 Mario Pirillo, Gianni Pittella
Falls if COMP 56 AM 1112-48-1117-1118-
IMCO 52-1113-1115-
1114 AdoptedArticle 17 -Paragraph -1 a (new)
Pre-authorisation of any novel TP
AM 49 Linda McAvan
Withdrawn W
PE516.894v01-00 130/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 17 paragraph 1 introductory part
AM 1119 Sari Essayah Falls if COMP 56 AM 1112
Adopted
Article 17 paragraph 1 introductory part
AM 1120 Erminia Mazzoni
Falls if COMP 56 AM 1112-1119 Adopted
Article 17 paragraph 1 introductory part
ITRE 59 ITRE Falls if COMP 56 AM 1112-
1119-1120 Adopted
Article 17 -Paragraph 1
AM 50 Linda McAvan
Withdrawn
Falls if COMP 56 AM 1112-1119-1120-ITRE 59-Adopted
W
Article 17 paragraph 1 introductory part
AM 1121 Holger Krahmer
Falls if COMP 56 AM 1112-1119-1120-
ITRE 59--50 Adopted
Article 17 paragraph 1 introductory part
AM 1125 Mario Pirillo, Gianni Pittella
Falls if COMP 56 AM 1112-1119-1120-
ITRE 59--1121 Adopted
Compatible with 50
Article 17 paragraph 1 introductory part
AGRI 68 AGRI Falls if COMP 56 AM 1112-1119-Adopted
Compatible with 1120-
ITRE 59--50-1121-1125
Article 17 paragraph 1 introductory part
AM 1122 Maria do Céu Patrão Neves
Article 17 paragraph 1 introductory part
IMCO 53 IMCO
Identical in content
Falls if COMP 56 AM 1112-
1119-AGRI 68 Adopted
Compatible with 1120-
ITRE 59--50-1121-1125
PV\1001717ES.doc 131/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 17 paragraph 1 introductory part
AM 1123 Bernadette Vergnaud
Falls if COMP 56 AM 1112-1119-1120-ITRE 59--
1125-AGRI 68-1122 Adopted
Compatible with 1120-
ITRE 59--50-1121
Article 17 paragraph 1 introductory part
AM 1124 Gaston Franco
Falls if COMP 56 AM 1112-1119-1122-
1125-AGRI 68-1123 Adopted
Compatible with 1120-
ITRE 59--50-1121
Article 17 paragraph 1 point a
AM 1127 Holger Krahmer
Falls if COMP 56 AM 1112
Adopted
Article 17 paragraph 1 point a
ITRE 60 ITRE Falls if COMP 56 AM 1112
Adopted
Article 17 paragraph 1 point a
AM 1126 Milan Cabrnoch
Falls if COMP 56 AM 1112-
1127-ITRE 60 Adopted
Article 17 paragraph 1 point a
IMCO 54 IMCO Compatible as addition
Article 17 paragraph 1 point a new
Informaation to competent agencies
IMCO 55 IMCO
Article 17 paragraph 1 point b
ITRE 61 ITRE
Article 17 paragraph 1 point b
AM 1128 Holger Krahmer
Falls if COMP 56 AM 1112-
ITRE 61 Adopted
Article 17 paragraph 1 point b
AM 1129 Izaskun Bilbao Barandica
Falls if COMP 56 AM 1112-
Adopted
Compatible with others
PE516.894v01-00 132/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 17 paragraph 1 point b
AM 1130 Theodoros Skylakakis
Falls if COMP 56 AM 1112-
Adopted
Compatible with others
Article 17 paragraph 1 point c a (new)
Member States'specific rules for reduced risk products
AM 1131 Gaston Franco
Article 17 paragraph 2
AM 1132 Sari Essayah DeletionFalls if COMP 56 AM 1112 Adopted
Article 17 paragraph 2
ITRE 62 ITRE
Article 17 -Paragraph 2
AM 51 Linda McAvan
Withdrawn
Falls if COMP 56 AM 1112-
1132-ITRE 62 Adopted
W
Article 17 paragraph 2
AM 1134 Erminia Mazzoni
Falls if COMP 56 AM 1112-
1132-ITRE 62-51 Adopted
Article 17 paragraph 2
AM 1133 Holger Krahmer
Falls if COMP 56 AM 1112-
1132-ITRE 62-51-1134 Adopted
Article 17 paragraph 2
AM 1135 Mario Pirillo, Gianni Pittella
Falls if COMP 56 AM 1112-
1132-ITRE 62-51-1134-1133
AdoptedArticle 17 paragraph 2
AM 1136 Paolo Bartolozzi, Elisabetta Gardini, Sergio Berlato, Salvatore Tatarella, Giovanni La Via, Roberta Angelilli
Article 17 paragraph 2
IMCO 56 IMCO
Identical
Falls if COMP 56 AM 1112-
1132-ITRE 62-51-1134-1133-1135 Adopted
PV\1001717ES.doc 133/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 17 paragraph 3
AM 1137 Sari Essayah Deletion
Falls if COMP 56 AM 1112
AdoptedArticle 17 paragraph 3
ITRE 63 ITRE Falls if COMP 56 AM 1112-1137 Adopted
Article 17 paragraph 3
AM 1138 Holger Krahmer
Falls if COMP 56 AM 1112-
1137-ITRE 63-Adopted
Article 17 paragraph 3
AM 1139 Erminia Mazzoni
Falls if COMP 56 AM 1112-
1137-ITRE 63--1138 Adopted
Article 17 paragraph 3
AM 1141 P. Bartolozzi, E.Gardini, S.Berlato, S.Tatarella, G. La Via, R.Angelilli
Article 17 paragraph 3
IMCO 57 IMCO
Identical
Falls if COMP 56 AM 1112-
1137-ITRE 63--1138-1139
Adopted
Article 17 paragraph 3
JURI 64 JURI Falls if COMP 56 AM 1112-
1137-ITRE 63--1138-1139-
1141 AdoptedArticle 17 paragraph 3
AM 1140 Milan Cabrnoch
Falls if COMP 56 AM 1112-
1137-ITRE 63--1138 Adopted
Compatible with others as
additionArticle 17 paragraph 3 point 1 (new)
Study on health effect of passive inhalation novel products
AM 1142 Mario Pirillo -
Article 17 paragraph 3 a (new)
Members States' rules on less harmful products
AM 1143 Milan Cabrnoch
Falls if JURI 63 Adopted
-
PE516.894v01-00 134/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 17 paragraph 3 a (new)
Delegated Acts on significantly less harmful products
AM 1144 Bernadette Vergnaud
-
Article 17 paragraph 3 a (new)
IMCO 58 IMCO
Identical
Falls if AM JURI 63- 1143
Adopted
Article 17 paragraph 3 a (new)
AM 1145 Erminia Mazzoni
Falls if AM 1112-1137-ITRE 63 Adopted
-
CONS 58
e-cigarettes
Article 18
ALDE-ECR -EFD
-
(+25-45)
CONS 57
e-cigarettesMedicine Regime
Article 18
S&D-Greens/Efa-GUE/NGL
FALLS IF CONS 58 Adopted
+
(+44-27)
TITLE III ITRE 64 ITRE FALLS IF CONS 57-58
Adopted
Deletion
All Amendments covered by
CONS 57 FellArticle 18 AM 1146 P.Bartolozzi,
E. Gardini, S.Berlato, S.Tatarella, G.La Via, R.Angelilli
Article 18 ITRE 65 ITRE
FALLS IF CONS 57-58
Adopted
IdenticalDeletion
Article 18 paragraph 1
AM 1148 Renate Sommer
Deletion
Falls if CONS 57-58 Adopted
Article 18 AM 1147 Linda McAvan
VoteIn block
PV\1001717ES.doc 135/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 18 a (new)
Nicotine containing products authorisation ex Directive 2001/83/EC
AM 1250 Linda McAvan, Karl-Heinz Florenz
Falls if CONS 57-58 AM 1146-1147Adopted
Article 18 JURI 65 JURI Falls if CONS 57-58 AM 1146-1147-1148-1250 Adopted
Article 18 IMCO 59 IMCO Falls if CONS 57-58 AM 1146-1147-1148-1250-
JURI 65 Adopted
Article 18 paragraph 1 introductory part
AM 1149 Frédérique Ries
Falls if CONS 57-58 AM 1146-1147-1148-1250-JURI 65-IMCO 59-Adopted
Article 18 paragraph 1 introductory part
AM 1151 G.Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F. E. Speroni, C. Morganti
Falls if CONS 57-58 AM 1146-1147-1148-1250-JURI 65-
IMCO 59--1149 Adopted
Article 18 paragraph 1 introductory part
AM 1160 Holger Krahmer
Falls if CONS 57-58 AM 1146-1147-1148-1250-JURI 65-
IMCO 59--1149-1151 Adopted
Article 18 paragraph 1 introductory part
AM 1150 C.Engström, C.Davies, C.Fjellner, R.Taylor
Falls if CONS 57-58 AM 1146-1147-1148-1250-JURI 65-
IMCO 59--1149-1151-
1160 AdoptedArticle 18 paragraph 1 introductory part
AM 1152 Martin Callanan
Identical
Falls if CONS
PE516.894v01-00 136/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 18 paragraph 1 introductory part
INTA 55 INTA 55 57-58 AM 1146-1147-1148-1250-JURI 65-
IMCO 59--1149-1151-1160-1150 Adopted
Article 18 paragraph 1 introductory part
AM 1153 Christel Schaldemose, Judith A.Merkies
Falls if CONS 57-58 AM 1146-1147-1148-1250-JURI 65-
IMCO 59--1149-1151-1160-1150-
1152 AdoptedArticle 18 paragraph 1 introductory part
AM 1154 Erik Bánki
Article 18 paragraph 1 introductory part
AM 1155 Sari Essayah
Article 18 paragraph 1 introductory part
AM 1156 G.Willmott, A.Perelló Rodríguez, K.T. Liotard, C.Schlyter,C. Stihler, A.Parvanova
Article 18 paragraph 1 introductory part
AM 1157 Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Malgorzata Handzlik, Boguslaw Sonik
Article 18 paragraph 1 introductory part
AM 1158 Hannu Takkula
Article 18 paragraph 1 introductory part
AM 1159 Françoise Grossetête
Article 18 paragraph 1 introductory part
AGRI 691st part
AGRI
Identical
Falls if CONS 57-58 AM 1146-1147-1148-1250-JURI 65-
IMCO 59--1149-1151-1160-1150-1152-1153 Adopted
If 1154 to 1159 adopted
1171 to 1179and 1182 to
1192and 1196 to
1206 deemed to be adopted
PV\1001717ES.doc 137/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 18 paragraph 1 a (new)
Ban in public place
AM 1161 Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Malgorzata Handzlik, Boguslaw Sonik
Compatible with all
Article 18 paragraph 1 a (new)
AM 1165 G.Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F. E. Speroni, C. Morganti, Lorenzo Fontana
Falls if CONS 57-58 AM 1146-1147-1250-1153-
1156 Adopted
Article 18 paragraph 1 a (new)
Exemption
AM 1162 C.Engström, C.Davies, C.Fjellner, R.Taylor
Falls if CONS 57-58 AM 1146-1147-
1165 Adopted
Article 18 paragraph 1 a (new)
Marketing restrictions
AM 1163 Rebecca Taylor
Compatible with all
Article 18 paragraph 1 e (new)
age required
AM 1170 Christian Engström, Christofer Fjellner, Rebecca Taylor, Chris Davies
Falls if CONS 57-58 AM
1250-JURI 65-IMCO 59-Adopted
Article 18 paragraph 1 a (new)
age required
AM 1164 Françoise Grossetête
Falls if CONS 57-58 AM
1250-JURI 65-IMCO 59--
1170 Adopted
Article 18 paragraph 1 b (new)
age required
AM 1166 Jolanta EmiliaHibner, Malgorzata Handzlik, Boguslaw Sonik
Falls if CONS 57-58 AM
1250-JURI 65-IMCO 59--1170-1164 Adopted
PE516.894v01-00 138/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 18 paragraph 1 b (new)
AM 1167 C.Engström, C.Davies, C.Fjellner, R.Taylor
Falls if CONS 57-58 AM 1146-1147-1148-1250--1153-1154 to
AGRI 69-JURI 65-IMCO 59-
AdoptedArticle 18 paragraph 1 c (new)
Compliance EU consumer protection, safety legislation
AM 1168 C.Engström, C.Davies, C.Fjellner, R.Taylor
Falls if AM 1153-1154 to
AGRI 69 Adopted
Compatible with others
Article 18 paragraph 1 d (new)
Report to the Commission on measures to implement and inforce
AM 1169 C.Engström, C.Davies, C.Fjellner, R.Taylor
Falls if CONS 57-58 AM 1156-1153-
1154 to 1159 Adopted
Article 18 paragraph 1 point a
AM 1171 C.Engström, C.Davies, C.Fjellner, R.Taylor
Article 18 paragraph 1 point a
AM 1172 Martin Callanan
Article 18 paragraph 1 point a
AM 1173 G.Willmott, A.Perelló Rodríguez, K.T. Liotard, C.Schlyter, C. Stihler, A.Parvanova
Article 18 paragraph 1 point a
AM 1174 Françoise Grossetête
Article 18 paragraph 1 point a
AM 1175 Renate Sommer
Article 18 paragraph 1 point a
AM 1176 Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Malgorzata Handzlik, Boguslaw Sonik
Falls if CONS 57-58 AM 1146-1147-1148-1250-JURI 65-IMCO 59-Adopted
If 1154 to 1159 adopteddeemed to be
adopted
IdenticalDeletion
PV\1001717ES.doc 139/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 18 paragraph 1 point a
AM 1177 Hannu Takkula
Article 18 paragraph 1 point a
AM 1178 G.Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F. E. Speroni, C. Morganti, Lorenzo Fontana
Article 18 paragraph 1 point a
AGRI 692nd part
AGRI
Article 18 paragraph 1 point a
AM 1179 Sari Essayah
Article 18 paragraph 1 point a
AM 1180 Frédérique Ries
Falls if CONS 57-58 AM 1146-1147-1148-1250-JURI 65-
IMCO 59- and AM 1171 to
1179 Adopted
Article 18 paragraph 1 point a
AM 1181 Holger Krahmer
Falls if CONS 57-58 AM 1146-1147-1148-1250-JURI 65-
IMCO 59- and AM 1171 to
1179 and 1180 Adopted
Article 18 paragraph 1 point b
AM 1182 C.Engström, C.Davies, C.Fjellner, R.Taylor
Article 18 paragraph 1 point b
AM 1183 Martin Callanan
Article 18 paragraph 1 point b
AM 1184 Erik Bánki
Falls if CONS 57-58 AM 1146-1147-1148-1250-JURI 65-IMCO 59- Adopted
If 1154 to 1159 deemed to be adopted
PE516.894v01-00 140/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 18 paragraph 1 point b
AM 1185 G.Willmott, A.Perelló Rodríguez, K.T. Liotard, C.Schlyter, C. Stihler, A.Parvanova
Article 18 paragraph 1 point b
AM 1186 Françoise Grossetête
Article 18 paragraph 1 point b
AM 1187 Renate Sommer
Article 18 paragraph 1 point b
AM 1188 Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Malgorzata Handzlik, Boguslaw Sonik
Article 18 paragraph 1 point b
AM 1189 Hannu Takkula
Article 18 paragraph 1 point b
AM 1190 Frédérique Ries
Article 18 paragraph 1 point b
AGRI 69 3rd part
AGRI
Article 18 paragraph 1 point b
AM 1191 G.Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F. E. Speroni, C. Morganti, L. Fontana
Article 18 paragraph 1 point b
AM 1192 Sari Essayah
IdenticalDeletion
Article 18 paragraph 1 point b
AM 1193 Christofer Fjellner, Jaroslaw Leszek Walesa
Falls if CONS 57-58 AM 1146-1147-1148-1250-JURI 65-
IMCO 59- and AM 1182 to
1192 Adopted
PV\1001717ES.doc 141/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 18 paragraph 1 point b
AM 1195 Ewald Stadler
Falls if CONS 57-58 AM 1146-1147-1148-1250-JURI 65-
IMCO 59- and AM 1182 to 1192-1193 Adopted
Article 18 paragraph 1 point b
AM 1194 Holger Krahmer
Falls if CONS 57-58 AM 1146-1147-1148-1250-JURI 65-
IMCO 59- and AM 1182 to 1192-1193-
1195 AdoptedArticle 18 paragraph 1 point c
AM 1196 C.Engström, C.Davies, C.Fjellner, R.Taylor
Article 18 paragraph 1 point c
AM 1197 Martin Callanan
Article 18 paragraph 1 point c
AM 1198 Erik Bánki
Article 18 paragraph 1 point c
AM 1199 G. Willmott, A. Perelló Rodríguez, K.T. Liotard, C. Schlyter, C.Stihler, A.Parvanova
Article 18 paragraph 1 point c
AM 1200 Françoise Grossetête
Article 18 paragraph 1 point c
AM 1201 Renate Sommer
Article 18 paragraph 1 point c
AM 1202 Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Malgorzata Handzlik, Boguslaw Sonik
Falls if CONS 57-58 AM 1146-1147-1148-1250-JURI 65-IMCO 59-Adopted
If 1154 to 1159 adopted
deemed to be adopted
IdenticalDeletion
PE516.894v01-00 142/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 18 paragraph 1 point c
AM 1203 Hannu Takkula
Article 18 paragraph 1 point c
AM 1204 Frédérique Ries
Article 18 paragraph 1 point c
AM 1205 G.Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F. E. Speroni, C. Morganti, Lorenzo Fontana
Article 18 paragraph 1 point c
AGRI 69 4th part
Article 18 paragraph 1 point c
AM 1206 Sari Essayah
Article 18 paragraph 1 point c
AM 1207 Holger Krahmer
Falls if CONS 57-58 AM 1146-1147-1148-1250-JURI 65-
IMCO 59- and AM 1196 to
1206 Adopted
Article 18 paragraph 2
AM 1208 Françoise Grossetête
Article 18 paragraph 2
AM 1209 Renate Sommer
Article 18 paragraph 2
AM 1210 Gaston Franco
Article 18 paragraph 2
AM 1211 Milan Cabrnoch
Article 18 paragraph 2
AM 1212 Holger Krahmer
Article 18 paragraph 2
AM 1213 Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Malgorzata Handzlik, Boguslaw Sonik
Article 18 paragraph 2
AM 1214 Martin Callanan
Article 18 paragraph 2
AM 1215 Erik Bánki
Falls if CONS 57-58 AM 1146-1147-
1250-JURI 65-IMCO 59-Adopted
IdenticalDeletion
PV\1001717ES.doc 143/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 18 paragraph 2
AM 1216 G.Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F. E. Speroni, C. Morganti, Lorenzo Fontana
Article 18 paragraph 2
AGRI 695th part
Article 18 paragraph 2
AM 1217 Sari Essayah
Article 18 paragraph 2
AM 1218 C.Engström, C.Davies, C.Fjellner, R.Taylor
Falls if CONS 57-58 AM 1146-1147-
1250-JURI 65-IMCO 59-
1153-1154 to AGRI 69- and
AM 1208 to 1217 Adopted
Article 18 paragraph 2
AM 1219 Hannu Takkula
Falls if CONS 57-58 AM 1146-1147-
1250-JURI 65-IMCO 59- and
AM 1208 to 1217 and 1218
AdoptedArticle 18 paragraph 2 a (new)
AM 1220 Theodoros Skylakakis
Falls if CONS 57-58 AM 1146-1147-
1250-JURI 65-IMCO 59- and
AM 1208 to 1217 Adopted
Article 18 paragraph 3
AM 1221 Erik Bánki
Article 18 paragraph 3
AM 1222 Françoise Grossetête
Article 18 paragraph 3
AM 1223 Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Malgorzata Handzlik, Boguslaw Sonik
Article 18 paragraph 3
AGRI 696th part
AGRI
Falls if CONS 57-58 AM 1146-1147-
1250-JURI 65-IMCO 59-Adopted
IdenticalDeletion
PE516.894v01-00 144/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 18 paragraph 3
AM 1224 G.Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F. E. Speroni, C. Morganti, Lorenzo Fontana
Article 18 paragraph 3 introductory part
AM 1225 Renate Sommer
Article 18 paragraph 3 introductory part
AM 1229 Christian Engström, Christofer Fjellner, Rebecca Taylor, Chris Davies
Identical
Falls if CONS 57-58 AM 1146-1147-
1250-JURI 65-IMCO 59-
1153-1154 to AGRI 69- and
AM 1221 to 1224 Adopted
Article 18 paragraph 3 introductory part
AM 1226 Georgios Koumoutsakos
Falls if CONS 57-58 AM 1146-1147-
1250-JURI 65-IMCO 59-
1153-1154 to AGRI 69-and AM 1221 to
1224 and 1225-1229 Adopted
Article 18 paragraph 3 introductory part
AM 1228 Hannu Takkula
Falls if CONS 57-58 AM 1146-1147-
1250-JURI 65-IMCO 59-
1153-1154 to AGRI 69- and
AM 1221 to 1224 and 1225-
1229-1226 Adopted
Article 18 paragraph 3 introductory part
AM 1227 Holger Krahmer
Article 18 paragraph 3 introductory part
AM 1230 Sari Essayah
Identical
Falls if CONS 57-58 AM 1146-1147-
1250-JURI 65-IMCO 59-
1153-1154 to AGRI 69- and
AM 1221 to 1224 and 1225-
1229-1226-1228 Adopted
PV\1001717ES.doc 145/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 18 paragraph 3 subparagraph 1
AM 1233 Christian Engström, Christofer Fjellner, Rebecca Taylor, Chris Davies
Falls if CONS 57-58 AM 1146-1147-
1250-JURI 65-IMCO 59-
1153-1154 to AGRI 69 Adopted
Article 18 paragraph 3 subparagraph 1
AM 1231 Georgios Koumoutsakos
Falls if CONS 57-58 AM 1146-1147-
1250-JURI 65-IMCO 59-
1153-1154 to AGRI 69-1233
AdoptedArticle 18 paragraph 3 subparagraph 1
AM 1232 Frédérique Ries
Falls if CONS 57-58 AM 1146-1147-
1250-JURI 65-IMCO 59-
1153-1154 to AGRI 69 Adopted
Compatible with 1233-1231
Article 18 paragraph 4
AM 1234 Françoise Grossetête
Article 18 paragraph 4
AM 1235 Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Malgorzata Handzlik, Boguslaw Sonik
Article 18 paragraph 4
AM 1236 Erik Bánki
Article 18 paragraph 4
AGRI 697th part
Article 18 paragraph 4
AM 1237 G.Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F. E. Speroni, C. Morganti, Lorenzo Fontana
Falls if CONS 57-58 AM 1146-1147-
1250-JURI 65-IMCO 59-Adopted
IdenticalDeletion
PE516.894v01-00 146/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 18 paragraph 4 point b
AM 1238 Daniël van der Stoep
Falls if CONS 57-58 AM 1146-1147-
1250-JURI 65-IMCO 59- and
AM 1234 to 1237 Adopted
Article 18 paragraph 4 a (new)
Opinion of the SCENIHR on harmful effect of ecig
AM 1239 Frédérique Ries, Corinne Lepage
Article 18 paragraph 5
AM 1240 Françoise Grossetête
Article 18 paragraph 5
AM 1241 Gaston Franco
Article 18 paragraph 5
AM 1242 Milan Cabrnoch
Article 18 paragraph 5
AM 1243 Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Malgorzata Handzlik, Boguslaw Sonik
Article 18 paragraph 5
AM 1244 Ewald Stadler
Article 18 paragraph 5
AGRI 698th part
Article 18 paragraph 5
AM 1245 Erik Bánki
Article 18 paragraph 5
AM 1246 G.Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F. E. Speroni, C. Morganti, Lorenzo Fontana
Falls if CONS 57-58 AM 1146-1147-
1250-JURI 65-IMCO 59-Adopted
IdenticalDeletion
Article 18 paragraph 5 a (new)
Whether propose further legislation
AM 1249 Holger Krahmer Falls if AM
1153-1154 to AGRI 69Adopted
Compatible with all
PV\1001717ES.doc 147/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 18 paragraph 5
AM 1247 Renate Sommer
Falls if CONS 57-58 AM 1146-1147-
1250-JURI 65-IMCO 59-
1153-1154 to AGRI 69- and
am 1240 to 1246 Am 1249
AdoptedArticle 18 paragraph 5
AM 1248 Martin Callanan
Falls if CONS 57-58 AM 1146-1147-
1250-JURI 65-IMCO 59-
1153-1154 to AGRI 69- and
am 1240 to 1246 and 1249-1247 Adopted
Article 2 paragraph 1 point 12 a (new)
Information on e-cigarette's ingredients
AM 296 Martina Anderson, Kartika Tamara Liotard
Falls if CONS 57-58 Adopted
Article 11 paragraph 1 a (new)
Health warning for electronic inhalers
AM 802 Cristian Silviu Busoi
Falls if CONS 57-58
Adopted
Article 17 paragraph 2 a (new)
Authorisation for reduced-harm TP
JURI 63 JURI Falls if CONS 57-58
Adopted
Recital 33 a (new)
Ecig: essential ingredients statement
AM 197 F. Ries, C.Lepage
Falls if CONS 57 Adopted
COMP 59
Article 19
S&D - EPP -ALDE -
GREENS/EFA - ECR - EFD -
GUE/NGL
+
Article 19 title AM 1251 Riikka Manner
Falls if COMP 59 Adopted
All Amendments covered by COMP 59
Fell
PE516.894v01-00 148/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 19 paragraph 1 introductory part
AM 1252 Riikka Manner
Falls if COMP 59 Adopted
Article 19 paragraph 1 introductory part
AM 1253 Sari Essayah Falls if COMP 59 Adopted
Compatible with 1252
Article 19 paragraph 1 subparagraph 1
AM 1254 Georgios Koumoutsakos
Article 19 paragraph 1 subparagraph 1
AM 1256 Riikka Manner
Article 19 paragraph 1 subparagraph 1
AM 1257 K-H.Florenz, P. Liese, T.Ulmer, R.Seeber, S.Auconie, E. O. Antonescu
Falls if COMP 59 Adopted
Identical
Article 19 paragraph 1 subparagraph 1
AM 1255 Frédérique Ries
Falls if COMP 59 Adopted
CompatibleArticle 19 paragraph 1 subparagraph 1
IMCO 60 IMCO Falls if COMP 59 Adopted
CompatibleArticle 19 paragraph 2
AM 1258 Milan Cabrnoch
Falls if COMP 59 Adopted
Article 19 paragraph 3
AM 1259 Daniël van der Stoep
Falls if COMP 59 Adopted
Article 19 paragraph 3
AM 1260 Ewald Stadler
Falls if COMP 59 AM 1258
AdoptedArticle 19 paragraph 3
AM 1261 G.Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F. E. Speroni, C. Morganti, Lorenzo Fontana
Article 19 paragraph 3
IMCO 61 IMCO
Article 19 paragraph 3
AGRI 70 AGRI
Falls if COMP 59 Adopted
IdenticalCompatible
with 1258-1259
PV\1001717ES.doc 149/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 19 a (new)
Imitation TP
AM 1263 Gerben-Jan Gerbrandy
+
Article 19 a (new)
Imitation TP
AM 1262 Esther de Lange
Falls if AM 1263 Adopted
F
Article 20 -Paragraph 3
AM 52 Linda McAvan
+
Article 20 -Paragraph 3
JURI 66 JURI Falls if AM 52 Adopted
F
Article 20 paragraph 3 a (new)
Negative and social consequences
AM 1264 Róza Gräfin von Thun und Hohenstein, Boguslaw Sonik, Czeslaw Adam Siekierski
-
Article 22 paragraph 1
AM 1266 Ewald Stadler
Falls if AM 1265 Adopted
-
Article 22 paragraph 1 a (new)
AM 1267 Anna Rosbach
To be voted -
COMP 60
Article 22 paragraph 2
S&D - EPP -ALDE -
GREENS/EFA - ECR - EFD -
GUE/NGL
+
Article 22 AM 1265 Gaston Franco
Falls if COMP 60 Adopted
Deletion
All Amendments covered by COMP 60
FellArticle 22 paragraph 2
2 years
AM 1269 Ewald Stadler
Falls if COMP 60 Adopted
Vote on the duration on the
delegation
Falls if COMP 60 AM 1265
Adopted
PE516.894v01-00 150/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 22 paragraph 2
3 years
AM 1273 P.Bartolozzi, E.Gardini, S.Berlato, S.Tatarella, G.La Via, R.Angelilli
Vote on the duration on the
delegation
Falls if COMP 60 AM 1265-1269 Adopted
Article 22 paragraph 2
5 years
AGRI 71 AGRI
Article 22 paragraph 2
5 years
AM 1272 G.Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F. E. Speroni, C. Morganti, Lorenzo Fontana
Article 22 paragraph 2
5 years
IMCO 62 IMCO
Identical
Vote on the duration on the
delegation
Falls if COMP 60 AM 1265-
1269-1273 Adopted
Article 22 paragraph 2
5 years and tacit extension
AM 1270 Martin Callanan
Vote on the duration on the
delegation
Falls if COMP 60 AM 1265-1269-1273-
AGRI 71-1272-IMCO 62-Adopted
Article 22 paragraph 2
AM 1268 Georgios Koumoutsakos
Not To VoteTo be updated to the outcome of the vote on the corresponding
provisions
Falls if COMP 60 AM 1265-1269-1273-
AGRI 71-1272-IMCO 62-1270
Adopted
PV\1001717ES.doc 151/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 22 paragraph 2
ITRE 66 ITRE Not To VoteTo be updated to the outcome of the vote on the corresponding
provisions
Falls if COMP 60 AM 1265-1269-1273-
AGRI 71-1272-IMCO 62-1270-1268 Adopted
Article 22 paragraph 2
JURI 67 JURI Not To VoteTo be updated to the outcome of the vote on the corresponding
provisions
Falls if COMP 60 AM 1265-1269-1273-
AGRI 71-1272-IMCO 62-1270-1268-ITRE 66 Adopted
Article 22 paragraph 2
AM 1274 María Auxiliadora Correa Zamora, Esther Herranz García
Not To VoteTo be updated to the outcome of the vote on the corresponding
provisions
Falls if COMP 60 AM 1265-1269-1273-
AGRI 71-1272-IMCO 62-1270-1268-
ITRE 66-JURI 67 Adopted
PE516.894v01-00 152/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 22 paragraph 2
AM 1271 Karl-Heinz Florenz, Thomas Ulmer
Not To VoteTo be updated to the outcome of the vote on the corresponding
provisions
Falls if COMP 60 AM 1265-1269-1273-
AGRI 71-1272-IMCO 62--1270-1268-
ITRE 66-JURI 67-1274 Adopted
Article 22 paragraph 2
AM 1278 Milan Cabrnoch
Not To VoteTo be updated to the outcome of the vote on the corresponding
provisions
Falls if COMP 60 AM 1265-1269-1273-
1272-IMCO 62--AGRI 71-
1270-1268-ITRE 66-JURI 67-1274-1271
AdoptedArticle 22 paragraph 2
AM 1275 Eleni Theocharous
Article 22 paragraph 2
AM 1276 Sergej Kozlík
Article 22 paragraph 2
AM 1277 Cristian Silviu Busoi
Not To VoteTo be updated to the outcome of the vote on the corresponding
provisions
IdenticalFalls if COMP 60 AM 1265-1269-1273-
1272-IMCO 62--AGRI 71-
1270-1268-ITRE 66-JURI 67-1274-1271-1278 Adopted
Article 22 paragraph 2 a (new)
Transitional period
AM 1279 Jaroslaw Kalinowski
To be voted -
PV\1001717ES.doc 153/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 22 paragraph 3
AM 1281 Martin Callanan
Not To VoteTo be updated to the outcome of the vote on the corresponding
provisions
Falls if AM 1265 Adopted
Article 22 paragraph 3
AM 1280 Ewald Stadler
Not To VoteTo be updated to the outcome of the vote on the corresponding
provisions
Falls if AM 1265-1281 Adopted
Article 22 paragraph 3
ITRE 67 ITRE Not To VoteTo be updated to the outcome of the vote on the corresponding
provisions
Falls if AM 1265-1281-
1280 AdoptedArticle 22 paragraph 3
JURI 68 JURI Not To VoteTo be updated to the outcome of the vote on the corresponding
provisions
Falls if AM 1265-1281-
1280-ITRE 67-Adopted
Article 22 paragraph 3
AGRI 72 AGRI Not To VoteTo be updated to the outcome of the vote on the corresponding
provisions
Falls if AM 1265-1281-
1280-ITRE 67-JURi 68 Adopted
PE516.894v01-00 154/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 22 paragraph 3
AM 1282 María Auxiliadora Correa Zamora, Esther Herranz García
Not To VoteTo be updated to the outcome of the vote on the corresponding
provisions
Falls if AM 1265-1281-
1280-ITRE 67--JURI 68-AGRI 72 Adopted
Article 22 paragraph 3
AM 1284 G.Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F. E. Speroni, C. Morganti, Lorenzo Fontana
Not To VoteTo be updated to the outcome of the vote on the corresponding
provisions
Falls if AM 1265-1281-
1280-ITRE 67--JURI 68-
AGRI 72-1282 Adopted
Article 22 paragraph 3
IMCO 63 IMCO Not To VoteTo be updated to the outcome of the vote on the corresponding
provisions
Falls if AM 1265-1281-
1280-ITRE 67--JURI 68-
AGRI 72-1282-1284 Adopted
Article 22 paragraph 3
AM 1283 Karl-Heinz Florenz, Thomas Ulmer
Not To VoteTo be updated to the outcome of the vote on the corresponding
provisions
Falls if AM 1265-1281-
1280-ITRE 67--JURI 68-
AGRI 72-1282-1284 Adopted
PV\1001717ES.doc 155/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 22 paragraph 3
AM 1287 Milan Cabrnoch
Not To VoteTo be updated to the outcome of the vote on the corresponding
provisions
Falls if AM 1265-1281-
1280-ITRE 67--JURI 68-
AGRI 72-1282-1284-1283 Adopted
Article 22 paragraph 3
AM 1285 Cristian Silviu Busoi
Article 22 paragraph 3
AM 1288 Sergej Kozlík
Article 22 paragraph 3
AM 1286 Eleni Theocharous
IdenticalNot To Vote
To be updated to the outcome of the vote on the corresponding
provisions
Falls if AM 1265-1281-
1280-ITRE 67--JURI 68-
AGRI 72-1282-1284-1283-
1287 AdoptedArticle 22 paragraph 5
AM 1289 Ewald Stadler
Not To VoteTo be updated to the outcome of the vote on the corresponding
provisions
Falls if AM 1265 Adopted
Article 22 paragraph 5
AGRI 73 AGRI
Article 22 paragraph 5
ITRE 68 ITRE
Identical
Not To VoteTo be updated to the outcome of the vote on the corresponding
provisions
Falls if AM 1265-1289 Adopted
PE516.894v01-00 156/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 22 paragraph 5
AM 1290 Jaroslaw Kalinowski
Not To VoteTo be updated to the outcome of the vote on the corresponding
provisions
Falls if AM 1265-1289-AGRI 73 Adopted
Article 22 paragraph 5
JURI 69 JURI Not To VoteTo be updated to the outcome of the vote on the corresponding
provisions
Falls if AM 1265-1289-
AGRI 73-1290 Adopted
Article 22 paragraph 5
IMCO 64 IMCO Not To VoteTo be updated to the outcome of the vote on the corresponding
provisions
Falls if AM 1265-1289-
AGRI 73-1290-JURI 69 Adopted
Article 22 paragraph 5
AM 1291 Martin Callanan
Not To VoteTo be updated to the outcome of the vote on the corresponding
provisions
Falls if AM 1265-1289-
AGRI 73-1290-JURI 69 Adopted
PV\1001717ES.doc 157/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 22 paragraph 5
AM 1292 María Auxiliadora Correa Zamora, Esther Herranz García
Not To VoteTo be updated to the outcome of the vote on the corresponding
provisions
Falls if AM 1265-1289-
AGRI 73-1290-JURI 69-1291
AdoptedArticle 22 paragraph 5
AM 1294 G.Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F. E. Speroni, C. Morganti, L. Fontana
Not To VoteTo be updated to the outcome of the vote on the corresponding
provisions
Falls if AM 1265-1289-
AGRI 73-1290-JURI 69-1291-1292 Adopted
Article 22 paragraph 5
AM 1293 Karl-Heinz Florenz, Thomas Ulmer
Not To VoteTo be updated to the outcome of the vote on the corresponding
provisions
Falls if AM 1265-1289-
AGRI 73-1290-JURI 69-1291-
1292-1294-Adopted
Article 22 paragraph 5
AM 1295 Milan Cabrnoch
Not To VoteTo be updated to the outcome of the vote on the corresponding
provisions
Falls if AM 1265-1289-
AGRI 73-1290-JURI 69-1291-
1292-1294-1293 Adopted
Article 22 paragraph 5
AM 1296 Sergej Kozlík
Article 22 paragraph 5
AM 1297 Eleni Theocharous
Identical
Not To VoteTo be updated to the outcome of
PE516.894v01-00 158/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 22 paragraph 5
AM 1298 Cristian Silviu Busoi
the vote on the corresponding
provisions
Falls if AM 1265-1289-
AGRI 73-1290-JURI 69-1291-
1292-1294-1293-1295 Adopted
Article 23 AM 1299 Paul Nuttall, Godfrey Bloom
Deletion -
Article 23paragraph 1 introductory part
ITRE 69 ITRE Falls if AM 1299 Adopted
+
(+43-24)Article 23
paragraph 2 subparagraph 1 introductory part
AGRI 74 AGRI Falls if AM 1299 Adopted
-
(+34-34)
Article 23
paragraph 1 subparagraph 2
IMCO 65 IMCO -
Article 23 paragraph 1 a (new)
Report on economic and social consequences
AM 1300 Róza Gräfin von Thun und Hohenstein, Boguslaw Sonik, Czeslaw AdamSiekierski
-
Article 23 paragraph 1 a (new)
JURI 70 JURI
Falls if AGRI 74 Adopted
Identical
Article 23 -Paragraph 2 -point b
AM 53 Linda McAvan
Withdrawn
Falls if AM 1299 Adopted
W
Article 23 paragraph 2 subparagraph 1 point b
AM 1301 Milan Cabrnoch
Falls if AM 1299 AdoptedCompatible
-
PV\1001717ES.doc 159/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 23 paragraph 2 subparagraph 1 point c a (new)
Toxic exposure
AM 1302 Christel Schaldemose, Dan Jørgensen
Falls if AM 1299 Adopted
-
Article 23 paragraph 2 subparagraph 1 point c a (new)
Impact on Tobacco cultivation
AM 1303 María Auxiliadora Correa Zamora, Esther Herranz García
-
(+29-38)
Article 23 paragraph 2 subparagraph 1 point c h (new)
Impact on tobacco growing
AGRI 76 AGRI
Identical in content
Falls if AM 1299 Adopted
Article 23 paragraph 2 subparagraph 1 point c b (new)
Evaluation of addictive effects
AM 1304 Christel Schaldemose, Dan Jørgensen
Falls if AM 1299 Adopted
+
Article 23 paragraph 2 subparagraph 1 point c c (new)
Products reduced harm
AM 1305 Christel Schaldemose, Dan Jørgensen
Falls if AM 1299 Adopted
-
Article 23 paragraph 2 subparagraph 1 point c d (new)
Standardised testing methods measures
AM 1306 Christel Schaldemose, Dan Jørgensen
Falls if AM 1299 Adopted
+
Article 23 paragraph 2 subparagraph 1 point c e (new)
Toxicological data
AM 1307 Christel Schaldemose, Dan Jørgensen
Falls if AM 1299 Adopted
+
PE516.894v01-00 160/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 23 paragraph 2 subparagraph 1 point c f (new)
Standards for products others than cigarettes
AM 1308 Christel Schaldemose, Dan Jørgensen
Falls if AM 1299 Adopted
+
(+38-32)
Article 23 paragraph 2 subparagraph 1 point c g (new)
Impact on employement
AGRI 75 AGRI -
(+32-36)
Article 23 paragraph 3 a (new)
MS Reporting
AM 1309 Carl Schlyter +
(+35-34)
Article 23 paragraph 3 a (new)
Commission's powers
ITRE 70 ITRE -
COMP 61
Article 24
S&D - EPP -ALDE -
GREENS/EFA - ECR - EFD -
GUE/NGL
+
Article 24 paragraph 1
AM 1310 Martin Callanan
Falls if COMP 61 Adopted
All Amendments covered by COMP 61
FellArticle 24 paragraph 1
AGRI 77 AGRI Falls if COMP 61 Adopted
CompatibleArticle 24 paragraph 2
JURI 71 JURI Falls if COMP 61 Adopted
DeletionArticle 24 paragraph 2
AM 1311 Holger Krahmer
Article 24 paragraph 2
ITRE 71 ITRE
Article 24 paragraph 2
IMCO 66 IMCO
Identical in content
Falls if COMP 61 JURI 71
Adopted
PV\1001717ES.doc 161/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 24 paragraph 2
AM 1312 Martin Callanan
Falls if COMP 61 JURI 71-AM 1311 Adopted
Article 24 paragraph 2
AM 1313 Georgios Koumoutsakos
Falls if JURI 71-AM 1311-1312
Adopted
Article 24 paragraph 2
AM 1315 Frédérique Ries
Falls if COMP 61 JURI 71-AM 1311-1312-1313
AdoptedArticle 24 paragraph 2
AM 1314 Milan Cabrnoch
Falls if COMP 61 JURI 71-AM 1311-1312-1313
Adopted
Compatible with 1315
Article 24 -Paragraph 2
AM 54 Linda McAvan
Falls if COMP 61 JURI 71-AM 1311-1312-1313
Adopted
Compatible with 1315-1314
Article 24 -Paragraph 2
INTA 56 INTA 56 Falls if COMP 61 JURI 71-AM 1311-1312-1313
Adopted
Compatible with 1315-1314-54
Article 24 paragraph 2
AM 1316 Martina Anderson, Kartika Tamara Liotard
Falls if COMP 61 AM 1311-
1312-1313 Adopted
Compatible with 1315-1314-54-
INTA 56Article 24 paragraph 2
AM 1317 Renate Sommer
Falls if COMP 61 JURI 71-AM 1311-1312-1313
Adopted
Compatible with 1315-1314-54-INTA 56-1316
Article 24 paragraph 3
AM 1318 Holger Krahmer
Article 24 paragraph 3
ITRE 72 ITRE
Identical
Deletion
Article 24 paragraph 3
AM 1319 Martin Callanan
Falls if COMP 61 AM 1318
AdoptedArticle 24 paragraph 3
AM 1320 Ewald Stadler
Falls if COMP 61 AM 1318-1319 Adopted
PE516.894v01-00 162/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 24 -Paragraph 3
AM 55 Linda McAvan
Falls if COMP 61 AM 1318-1319 Adopted
Compatible with 1320
Article 24 paragraph 3 a (new)
MS'right to adopt more stringent rules on public health
AM 1321 Ewald Stadler
Falls if COMP 61 Adopted
Article 25 paragraph 1
JURI 72 JURI -
Article 25 paragraph 1
AM 1322 Milan Cabrnoch
-
Article 25 paragraph 1
IMCO 67 IMCO
Identical
Falls if JURI 72 Adopted
Article 25 paragraph 1
AM 1323 Karl-Heinz Florenz, Thomas Ulmer
Falls if JURI 72 Adopted
and if AM 445 and COMP on
Positive list NOT Adopted
Compatible with 1322
+
(+52-18)
CONS 62
Article 26
S&D-GREENS/EFA
-GUE/NGL
+
(+44-26)CONS 63
Article 26
ALDE ECR -EFD
Falls if CONS 62 Adopted
F
Article 26 AM 1324 Paul Nuttall, Godfrey Bloom
Falls if CONS 62 Adopted
Deletion
All Amendments covered by
CONS 62 FellArticle 26 paragraph 1 introductory part
IMCO 68 IMCO Falls if CONS 62 AM 1324
Adopted
Article 26 paragraph 1 introductory part
AM 1328 Timothy Kirkhope
Falls if CONS 62 AM 1324-IMCO
68 Adopted
Article 26 paragraph 1 introductory part
INTA 57 INTA 57
Article 26 paragraph 1 introductory part
AM 1327 Renate Sommer
Identical in content
Falls if CONS 62 AM 1324-IMCO 68-1328 Adopted
PV\1001717ES.doc 163/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 26 paragraph 1 introductory part
AM 1325 Milan Cabrnoch
Article 26 paragraph 1 introductory part
AM 1326 Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Malgorzata Handzlik, Boguslaw Sonik
Article 26 paragraph 1 introductory part
AM 1329 Linda McAvan, Karl-Heinz Florenz
Identical
Falls if CONS 62 AM 1324-IMCO 68-1328-INTA
57 Adopted
Article 26 - point a
AM 56 Linda McAvan
Falls if CONS 62 AM 1324 Adopted
Deletion
Article 26 paragraph 1 point a
IMCO 69 IMCO Falls if CONS 62 AM 1324-56
Adopted
Article 26 paragraph 1 point a
AM 1331 Holger Krahmer
Article 26 paragraph 1 point a
ITRE 73 ITRE
IdenticalFalls if CONS 62
AM 1324-56-IMCO 69 Adopted
Article 26 paragraph 1 point b
AM 1332 G. Willmott, A. Perelló Rodríguez, K.T. Liotard, C. Schlyter, C.Stihler, A.Parvanova
Article 26 paragraph 1 point b
ITRE 74 ITRE
IdenticalDeletion
Falls if CONS 62 AM 1324 Adopted
Article 26 paragraph 1 point b
AM 1333 C.Engström, C.Davies, C.Fjellner, R.Taylor
Article 26 paragraph 1 point b
AM 1334 Linda McAvan, Karl-Heinz Florenz
Identical
Falls if CONS 62 AM 1324 Adopted
PE516.894v01-00 164/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Article 26 paragraph 1 point b
JURI 73 JURI
Article 26 paragraph 1 point b
IMCO 70 IMCO
Article 26 paragraph 1 point b
AM 1335 Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Malgorzata Handzlik, Boguslaw Sonik
Article 26 paragraph 1 point c
AM 1336 Holger Krahmer
Article 26 paragraph 1 point c
ITRE 75 ITRE Falls if CONS 62 AM 1336
Adopted
Article 26 paragraph 1 a (new)
Nicotine containing products not in compliance
AM 1330 G. Willmott, A. Perelló Rodríguez, K.T. Liotard, C. Schlyter, C.Stihler, A.Parvanova
Falls if CONS 62 Adopted
Article 26 paragraph 1 a (new)
IMCO 71 IMCO Falls if AM 1330 Adopted
CONS 64
Annex 1 a (new)
S&D - EPP -GREENS/EFA - ECR - EFD -
GUE/NGL
+
Annex 1 a (new)
Additives approved for use in TP
AM 1337 G. Willmott, K. T.Liotard, C.Schlyter, N. Childers, C.Stihler, A.Parvanova, K.Van Brempt
Falls if CONS 64 Adopted
Falls also if AM 451 NOT
Adopted
All Amendments covered by
CONS 64 Fell
CONS 65
Annex 1 point 1
S&D - EPP -ALDE -
GREENS/EFA - ECR - EFD -
GUE/NGL
+
PV\1001717ES.doc 165/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Annex 1 point 1 AM 1338 Daniël van der Stoep
Falls if CONS 65 Adopted
Deletion
All Amendments covered by
CONS 65 FellAnnex 1 point 2 AM 1339 Daniël van
der StoepFalls if CONS
65 Adopted
DeletionAnnex 1 point 2 a (new)
Bladder cancer
AM 1340 Frédérique Ries
Annex 1 point 6 a (new)
AM 1343 Françoise Grossetête, Frédérique Ries, Karl-Heinz Florenz
Falls if CONS 65 Adopted
Identical
Annex 1 point 4 AM 1341 Daniël van der Stoep
Falls if CONS 65 Adopted
DeletionAnnex 1 point 5 AM 1342 Daniël van
der StoepFalls if CONS
65 Adopted
DeletionAnnex 1 point 7 AM 1344 Daniël van
der StoepFalls if CONS
65 Adopted
DeletionAnnex 1 point 8 AM 1345 Daniël van
der StoepFalls if CONS
65 Adopted
DeletionAnnex 1 point 9 AM 1346 Daniël van
der StoepFalls if CONS
65 Adopted
DeletionAnnex 1 point 10 AM 1347 Andrés
Perelló Rodríguez
Falls if CONS 65 Adopted
Annex 1 point 11 AM 1348 Daniël van der Stoep
Falls if CONS 65 Adopted
Deletion
PE516.894v01-00 166/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Annex 1 point 12 AM 1349 Daniël van der Stoep
Falls if CONS 65 Adopted
DeletionAnnex 1 point 13 AM 1350 Daniël van
der StoepFalls if CONS
65 Adopted
DeletionAnnex 1 point 14 AM 1351 Daniël van
der Stoep Falls if CONS 65 Adopted
DeletionAnnex 1 point 14 a (new)
Sudden infant death
AM 1352 P. Liese, A.Niebler, G.Franco, R.Morkunaite-Mikuleniene, A.Delvaux, K-H Florenz, J. E. Hibner, R.Sommer, A.Peterle, R.Seeber, F.Grossetête, E.de Lange, M.Thyssen, M.Mikolášik, E. O. Antonescu, C.Klaß
Falls if CONS 65 Adopted
Annex 1 point 14 a (new)
Nicotine.. damaging your health
AM 1353 G.Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F. E. Speroni, C. Morganti, L.Fontana
Falls if CONS 65 Adopted
Annex 1 point 14 b (new)
Premature birth
AM 1354 P.Liese, A.Niebler, G.Franco, R.Morkunaite-Mikuleniene, A.Delvaux, K-H.Florenz, R.Sommer, J.E. Hibner, A.Peterle, R.Seeber, F.Grossetête, E.de Lange, M.Thyssen, S.Auconie, M.Mikolášik, E.O. Antonescu, C.Klaß
Falls if CONS 65 Adopted
PV\1001717ES.doc 167/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Articles / Paragraphs
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Annex 1 point 14 c (new)
Asthma and meningitis
AM 1355 P.Liese, A.Niebler, G.Franco, R.Morkunaite-Mikuleniene, A.Delvaux, K-H.Florenz, R.Sommer, A Peterle, J.E.Hibner, R.Seeber, E.de Lange, M.Thyssen, S.Auconie, M.Mikolášik, E.O.Antonescu, C. Klaß, A.Rosbach
Falls if CONS 65 Adopted
Annex 1 heading 1 a (new)
List of text warnings
AM 1356 G.Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F. E. Speroni,C. Morganti, L.Fontana
-
Annex 1 a (new)
List of harmful and potentially harmful constituents
AM 1357 Frédérique Ries, Corinne Lepage
Falls if CONS 33 Adopted
Falls if AM 419 NOT Adopted
F
Annex 1 b (new) AM 1358 Frédérique Ries, Corinne Lepage
Falls if CONS 33 Adopted
Falls if AM 419 NOT Adopted
F
Annex 2 b (new)
EU legislation for nicotine-containing products
AM 1360 C.Engström, C.Davies, C.Fjellner, R.Taylor
F
Annex 3 b (new) IMCO 73 IMCO
Annex 1 a (new) JURI 74 JURI
Falls if CONS 57 Adopted
Falls if AM 1169 NOTAdopted
Identical
Citations / Recitals
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Citation 1 AM 59 A. ParvanovaCitation 1 IMCO 1 IMCO
Identical -
PE516.894v01-00 168/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Citations / Recitals
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Citation 1 AM 58 F. Ries, C.Lepage
Falls if AM 59-IMCO 1 Adopted
Art 168 of the TFUE only for
art 16
-
-
(+31-39)
Recital 1 AM 60 M.Anderson, K.T. Liotard
Oral Amendment by Greens/Efa:Change the text as follows:"including the increasedavailability on the market"If OA not adopted
Amendment without the oral
amendment
-
(+28-40)
Recital 2 AM 61 H. Krahmer -Recital 3 a (new)
Health warnings
AM 62 T. Skylakakis +
-
(+31-38)
Recital 4 AM 63 M. Anderson G. Willmott, A. Perello, C.Schlyter, N.Childers, C.Stihler, A.Parvanova
Split Voterequested by Greens/Efa:First part:"cross border sales of tobacco products"
2nd part:and point of sale displays
-
Recital 6 JURI 1 JURI Deletion -Recital 6 AM 64 M. Anderson Falls if AM
JURI 1 Adopted-
Recital 6 AGRI 1 AGRIRecital 6 ITRE 1 ITRE
Identical
Falls if AM JURI 1 Adopted
Compatible with 64
+
(+43-27)
Recital 6 a (new)
TP in disadvantaged areas
AM 65 Maria do Céu Patrão Neves, Nuno Teixeira, José Manuel Fernandes
-
Recital 6 a (new)
AGRI 2 AGRI Falls if AM 65 Adopted
-
PV\1001717ES.doc 169/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Citations / Recitals
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Recital 6 b (new)
Small Business act
AM 66 R. Sommer -
Recital 7 AM 1 Linda McAvan
+
Recital 7 a (new)
Loss in tax revenue
AM 67 Radvile Morkunaite-Mikuleniene
-
CONS 1
Recital 8
S&D - EPP -ALDE -
GREENS/EFA GUE
+
Recital 8 AM 68 K-H.Florenz, T.Ulmer, R.Seeber, E.de Lange, S. Auconie
Falls if CONS 1 Adopted
All Amendments covered by CONS 1 Fell
Recital 8 AM 69 M.Anderson, K.T. Liotard
Falls if CONS 1 Adopted
CompatibleRecital 8 AM 71 F. Ries Falls if CONS
1 Adopted
CompatibleRecital 8 AGRI 3 AGRI Falls if CONS
1 AdoptedRecital 8 AM 70 M. Pirillo Falls if CONS
1 AGRI 3 Adopted
Recital 8 IMCO 2 IMCO Falls if CONS 1 AGRI 3-AM
70 AdoptedRecital 8 AM 72 María
Auxiliadora Correa Zamora, Esther Herranz García
Falls if CONS 1 AGRI 3 - AM
70-IMCO 2 Adopted
Recital 8 AM 731st part
G.Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F. E. Speroni, C. Morganti, L.Fontana
Until prevention campaigns
Falls if CONS 1 AGRI 3- AM 70-IMCO 2-72
Adopted
PE516.894v01-00 170/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Citations / Recitals
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Recital 8 AM 732nd part
G.Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F. E. Speroni, C. Morganti, L.Fontana
Falls if CONS 1 Adopted
Compatible as addition
Recital 8 AM 74 Riikka Manner
Falls if CONS 1 Adopted
Compatible as addition
Recital 8 ITRE 2 ITRE Falls if CONS 1 Adopted
Compatible as addition
Recital 8 a (new)
Health of workers
AM 76 C. Lepage -
(+33-36)
Recital 8 b (new)
Under 18 - no access to points of sale
AM 77 C. Lepage -
Recital 9 a (new)
Right to receive objective health info
AM 78 T. Skylakakis +
(+39-31)
Recital 10 AM 79 R. Sommer Falls if COMP 2 Adopted
F
Recital 10 a (new)
Polonium 210
AM 80 Carl Schlyter, Satu Hassi
+
(+39-31)
Recital 11 ITRE 3 ITRE Falls if COMP 27-28
Adopted
F
Recital 11 AM 81 Milan Cabrnoch
Falls if COMP 27-28 ITRE 3
Adopted
F
Recital 11 AM 2 Linda McAvan
Falls if ITRE 3AM 81 Adopted
+
Recital 11 AGRI 4 AGRI Falls if ITRE 3 AM 81 Adopted
Compatible with 2
-
PV\1001717ES.doc 171/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Citations / Recitals
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Recital 11 AM 82 Sergej Kozlík
Recital 11 AM 83 Eleni Theocharous
Recital 11 AM 84 Cristian Silviu Busoi
Recital 11 JURI 2 JURIRecital 11 IMCO 3 IMCO
Identical
Falls if ITRE 3 AM 81- AGRI 4
Adopted
Compatible with 2
-
Recital 12 AM 85 Milan Cabrnoch
-
Recital 12 AM 86 Georgios Koumoutsakos
Recital 12 IMCO 4 IMCO
IdenticalCompatible
-
Recital 13 INTA 1 INTA 1 -Recital 13 AM 87 F. Ries, C.
LepageFalls if INTA 1
Adopted-
Recital 13 AM 88 María Auxiliadora Correa Zamora, Esther Herranz García
Falls if INTA 1 Adopted
Compatible with 87
-
(+32-37)
Recital 13 AGRI 5 AGRI Falls if INTA 1-AM 88 Adopted
-
(+20-50)Recital 13 IMCO 5 IMCO Compatible with
all+
Recital 13 AM 89 T. Skylakakis Compatible -CONS 3
Recital 14 a new
S&D - EPP -GREENS/EFA- ECR - EFD -
GUE
+
Recital 13 a (new)
Mandatory list
AM 90 F. Ries Falls if CONS 3 Adopted
All Amendments covered by CONS 3 Fell
Recital 14 JURI 3 JURI -Recital 14 AM 92 H. Krahmer Compatible -Recital 14 AM 91
1st partM.Anderson, K.T. Liotard
until coloring the tobacco smoke
Compatible with both
-
(+33-33)
Recital 14 AM 912nd part
M.Anderson, K.T. Liotard
Falls if JURI 3 Adopted
-
PE516.894v01-00 172/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Citations / Recitals
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Recital 14 AM 93 M. AndersonG. Willmott, K.T. Liotard, C. Schlyter
Falls if CONS 3 Adopted
Falls if JURI 3-92 Adopted
F
Recital 14 IMCO 6 IMCO Falls if JURI 3 Adopted
Compatible with others
+
Recital 14 a (new)
Safety of additives in TP
AM 94 K-H Florenz, P. Liese, T.Ulmer, R.Seeber, R.Sommer, S.Auconie
Falls if CONS 3 Adopted
F
Recital 14 b (new)
Additives in combustion
AM 95 M. Anderson G. Willmott, A. Perello, K.T. Liotard, C. Schlyter, N.Childers, C.Stihler, A.Parvanova
+
COMP 4
Recital 15
S&D - EPP -ALDE -
GREENS/EFA - ECR - EFD -
GUE
+
Recital 15 AM 96 Jaroslaw Kalinowski
Recital 15 AGRI 6 AGRI
Falls if COMP 4 Adopted
IdenticalDeletion
All Amendments covered by
COMP 4 Fell
Recital 15 –footnote 36
AM 103 Milan Cabrnoch Falls if COMP
4 Adopted
Deletion
Recital 15 INTA 2 INTA 2 Falls if COMP 4 dopted
Recital 15 JURI 4 Falls if COMP 4 INTA 2 Adopted
Recital 15 AM 99 G.Franco, J.E.Hibner, B.Sonik, E.Gardini
Recital 15 ITRE 4 ITRERecital 15 IMCO 7 IMCO
Identical
Falls if COMP 4 INTA 2- JURI 4
Adopted
Recital 15 AM 97 Milan Cabrnoch
Falls if COMP 4 2-JURI 4- 96-99
Adopted
PV\1001717ES.doc 173/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Citations / Recitals
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Recital 15 AM 98 Maria do Céu Patrão Neves
Recital 15 AM 100 Ewald Stadler
Identical
Falls if COMP 4 2 -JURI 4-96-99-
97 AdoptedRecital 15 AM 102 H. Krahmer Falls if COMP 4
2 -JURI 4-96-99-97-98-100 Adopted
Recital 15 AM 101 Carl Schlyter Falls if COMP 4 2 -JURI 4-96-99-
97-98-100 Adopted
Compatible with 102
Recital 15 a new
Tobacco Grown
AGRI 7 AGRI -
COMP 5
Recital 16
S&D - EPP -ALDE -
GREENS/EFA - ECR - EFD -
GUE
+
Recital 16 AM 104 Milan Cabrnoch
Recital 16 AGRI 8 AGRI
Falls if COMP 5 Adopted
IdenticalDeletion
All Amendments covered by
COMP 5 Fell
Recital 16 AM 105 Jaroslaw Kalinowski
Falls if COMP 5 AM 104 Adopted
Recital 16 ITRE 5 ITRE Falls if COMP 5 AM 104-105
AdoptedRecital 16 AM 106 M.
Anderson,G. Willmott, K. Liotard,C. Schlyter
Falls if COMP 5 AM 104-105-
ITRE 5 Adopted
Recital 16 IMCO 8 IMCO Falls if COMP 5 AM 104-105-
106-ITRE 5 Adopted
Recital 16 AM 107 H. Krahmer Falls if COMP 5 AM 104-105-
106-ITRE 5-IMCO 8 Adopted
PE516.894v01-00 174/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Citations / Recitals
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Recital 16 AM 108 Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Malgorzata Handzlik, Boguslaw Sonik
Recital 16 JURI 5 JURI
IdenticalFalls if COMP 5 AM 104-105-
106-ITRE 5-IMCO 8 Adopted
Compatible with 107
Recital 16 AM 109 G.Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F. E. Speroni, C.Morganti, L. Fontana
Falls if COMP 5 AM 104-105-107-IMCO 8
Adopted
Compatible with 106-ITRE 5-108
Recital 16 b (new)
Economic and social consequences
AM 111 Róza Gräfin von Thun und Hohenstein, Boguslaw Sonik, Czeslaw Adam Siekierski
-
Recital 16 c (new)
Demand of EU raw tobacco
AM 112 Czeslaw Adam Siekierski, Jaroslaw Kalinowski
-
COMP 6
Recital 17
S&D - EPP -ALDE -
GREENS/EFA - ECR - EFD -
GUE
+
Recital 16 a (new)
Lists of ingredients
AM 110 S. Essayah Falls if COMP 6 Adopted
All Amendments covered by
COMP 6 Fell
Recital 17 AM 113 H. Krahmer Falls if COMP 6 Adopted
DeletionRecital 17 AM 114 F. Ries Falls if COMP
6 AM 113 Adopted
Recital 17 AM 115 M.Anderson, K.T. Liotard
Falls if COMP 6 AM 113 Adopted
Compatible with 114
PV\1001717ES.doc 175/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Citations / Recitals
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Recital 17 a (new)
Asthma
AM 116 Claudiu Ciprian Tanasescu
+
Recital 17 b (new)
Addition of sugar
AM 117 F. Ries -
COMP 7
Recital 18
S&D - EPP -ALDE -
GREENS/EFA - ECR - EFD -
GUE
+
Recital 18 AM 118 S. Essayah
Recital 18 AM 119 C. Lepage
Recital 18 AM 120 M.Anderson, K.T. Liotard
Recital 18 IMCO 9 IMCO
Recital 18 AM 121 M. Anderson
Falls if COMP 7 Adopted
Identical Deletion
All Amendments covered by
COMP 7 Fell
Recital 18 ITRE 6 ITREFalls if COMP 7 -AM 118 to 121 Adopted
Recital 18 AM 122 A.Weisgerber, K-H.Florenz, M.Hohlmeier R. Sommer, H. Krahmer
Falls if COMP 7 AM 118 to 121-ITRE 6 Adopted
PE516.894v01-00 176/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Citations / Recitals
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Recital 18 AM 123 Georgios Koumoutsakos
Falls if COMP 7 AM 118 to
121-ITRE 6 and 122 Adopted
Recital 18 AM 124 F. Ries Falls if COMP 7 AM 118 to 121-ITRE 6
Adopted
Compatible as addition
Recital 18 AM 3 Linda McAvan
Falls if COMP 7 AM 118 to
121-ITRE 6 and 124 Adopted
Compatible as addition to 122-
123Recital 18 AM 125 F. RiesRecital 18 AM 126 O.Rossi,
M.Salvini, F.E. Speroni, C. Morganti, L. Fontana
Recital 18 AM 127 Claudiu Ciprian Tanasescu, Minodora Cliveti
Identical
Falls if COMP 7 AM 118 to 121-ITRE 6
Adopted
Compatible with others
Recital 18 INTA 3 INTA 3 Falls if COMP 7 AM 118 to
121-ITRE 6 and 122 Adopted
Compatible with others
Recital 18 a (new)
MS's Law on the protection of young people
AM 128 R. Sommer +
Recital 18 b (new)
FCTC Article 16
AM 129 Esther de Lange
+
Recital 19 ITRE 7 ITRE Falls if CONS 39-38 Adopted
F
Recital 19 AM 130 F. Ries Falls if ITRE 7 Adopted
-
Recital 20 ITRE 8 ITRE -
(+37-33)
PV\1001717ES.doc 177/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Citations / Recitals
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Recital 20 a (new)
Use of plain packages
AM 131 S. Essayah -
Recital 21 AM 132 R. Sommer, Monika Hohlmeier
-
Recital 21 AM 133 Milan Cabrnoch
Falls if CONS 39 or 38 AM 132 Adopted
F
COMP 8
Recital 22
S&D - EPP -ALDE -
GREENS/EFA - ECR - EFD -
GUE
+
Recital 22 AM 134 H. Krahmer Falls if COMP 8 Adopted
All Amendments covered by
COMP 8 Fell
Recital 22 AM 135 Georgios Koumoutsakos
Falls if COMP 8 AM 134 Adopted
Recital 22 AM 4 Linda McAvan
Falls if COMP 8 AM 134-135
AdoptedRecital 22 AM 136 G.Scottà, O.
Rossi, M.Salvini, F. E. Speroni, C.Morganti, L. Fontana
Recital 22 AGRI 9 AGRI
Identical
Falls if COMP 8 AM 134-135-4
Adopted
Recital 22 IMCO 10 IMCO Falls if COMP 8 AM 132 Adopted
Compatible with others
Recital 22 AM 137 M.Anderson, K.T. Liotard
Falls if COMP 8 AM 134-135-4
Adopted
Compatible with 136-IMCO 10
Recital 22 INTA 4 INTA 4 Falls if COMP 8 Adopted
Compatible with all
PE516.894v01-00 178/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Citations / Recitals
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Recital 22 a (new)
Combined health warnings
AM 5 Linda McAvan
Falls iif CONS 51 AM 34-897 Not Adopted
F
Recital 22 a (new)
Verbal encouragement
AM 138 G.Scottà, O.Rossi, L.Fontana, M.Salvini, F.E. Speroni, C.Morganti
-
COMP 9
Recital 23
S&D - EPP -ALDE -
GREENS/EFA - ECR - EFD -
GUE
+
Recital 23 AM 139 H. Krahmer Falls if COMP 9 Adopted
Deletion
All Amendments covered by
COMP 9 Fell
Recital 23 AM 140 Erminia Mazzoni
Falls if COMP 9AM 139 Adopted
Recital 23 JURI 6 JURI Falls if COMP 9AM 139-140
AdoptedRecital 23 INTA 5 INTA 5 Falls if COMP
9AM 139-140-JURI 6 Adopted
Recital 23 AM 6 Linda McAvan
Withdrawn
Falls if COMP 9AM 139-140-JURI 6- INTA 5 Adopted
W
Recital 23 AM 141 Ewald Stadler
Falls if COMP 9AM 139-140-
JURI 6- INTA 5 - 6 Adopted
Recital 23 AM 142 Jaroslaw Kalinowski
Recital 23 AGRI 10 AGRI
Identical
Falls if COMP 9AM 139-140-
JURI 6-INTA 5 -6-141 Adopted
Recital 23 IMCO 11 IMCO Falls if AM 139-140-6-141-142
AdoptedRecital 23 AM 150 Georgios
Koumoutsakos
Falls if COMP 9AM 139-140-6-141-142-IMCO
11 Adopted
PV\1001717ES.doc 179/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Citations / Recitals
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Recital 23 ITRE 9 ITRE IdenticalFalls if COMP 9AM 139-140-
JURI 6-INTA 5 -6-141-142-IMCO 11-150 Adopted
Recital 23 AM 143 Kristian Vigenin
Recital 23 AM 145 Eleni Theocharous
Withdrawn
IdenticalFalls if COMP 9AM 139-140-
JURI 6-INTA 5 -6-141-142-IMCO 11-150-ITRE 9
Adopted
W
Recital 23 AM 144 Milan Cabrnoch
Falls if COMP 9AM 139-140-
JURI 6-INTA 5 -6-141-142-IMCO 11-150-ITRE 9-
143-145 AdoptedRecital 23 AM 147 Maria do Céu
Patrão NevesFalls if COMP 9AM 139-140-
JURI 6-INTA 5 -6-141-142-IMCO 11-150-ITRE 9-
143-145-144 Adopted
Recital 23 AM 146 P.Bartolozzi, E. Gardini, S.Berlato, S.Tatarella, G.La Via, R.Angelilli
Falls if COMP 9AM 139-140-
JURI 6-INTA 5 -6-141-142-IMCO 11-150-ITRE 9-143-145-144-147
Adopted
Recital 23 AM 148 Sergej Kozlík
Falls if COMP 9AM 139-140-
JURI 6-INTA 5 -6-141-142-IMCO 11-150-ITRE 9-
143-145-144-147-146 Adopted
Recital 23 AM 151 K-H.Florenz, P.Liese, T.Ulmer, R.Sommer
Falls if COMP 9AM 139-144-
147-146 Adopted
Compatible with JURI 6-INTA 5 -6-140-141-142-IMCO 11-150-
ITRE 9-143-145-147-146
PE516.894v01-00 180/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Citations / Recitals
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Recital 23 AM 152 G.Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F. E. Speroni, C.Morganti, L. Fontana
Falls if COMP 9AM 139-144-
147-146 Adopted
Compatible with JURI 6-INTA 5 -6-140-141-142-IMCO 11-150-
ITRE 9-143-145-147-146
Recital 23 AM 149 J. E.Hibner, M.Handzlik, B.Sonik
Falls if COMP 9AM 139-140-
JURI 6-INTA 5 -AM 6-141-142-IMCO 11-150-
ITRE 9-143-145-144-147-146
Adopted
Compatible as addition to 6-
151-152Recital 23 a (new)
Danger of passive smoking
AM 153 K-H Florenz, P Liese, T.Ulmer, C.Klaß, R.Seeber, E.de Lange, R.Sommer, S.Auconie
+
Recital 23 b (new)
Plain Packaging
AM 154 M. Anderson -
(+29-33)
COMP 10
Recital 24
S&D - EPP -ALDE -
GREENS/EFA - ECR -
EFD - GUE
+
Recital 24 AM 155 S. Essayah Falls if COMP 10 Adopted
All Amendments covered by COMP 10
FellRecital 24 AM 157 M. Anderson Falls if COMP
10 AM 155 Adopted
Recital 24 AM 156 G. Willmott, K.T. Liotard, C.Schlyter, N.Childers, C. Stihler, A.Parvanova
Falls if COMP 10 AM 155-157
Adopted
PV\1001717ES.doc 181/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Citations / Recitals
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Recital 24 AM 158 Georgios Koumoutsakos
Falls if COMP 10 AM 155-157-
156 Adopted
Recital 24 AM 159 Claudiu Ciprian Tanasescu, Minodora Cliveti
Falls if COMP 10 AM 155 Adopted
Compatible with others
Recital 24 AGRI 11 Falls if COMP 10 AM 155-157-156-158 Adopted
Compatible with 159
Recital 25 JURI 7 JuriRecital 25 ITRE 10
Falls if CONS 47 Adopted
Identical
DeletionRecital 25 AM 160 R. Sommer,
Monika Hohlmeier
Falls if AM JURI 7 Adopted
-
COMP 11
Recital 26
S&D - EPP -ALDE -
GREENS/EFA - ECR - EFD -
GUE
+
Recital 26 AM 161 R. Sommer, Monika Hohlmeier
Falls if COMP 11 Adopted
All Amendments covered by COMP 11
FellRecital 26 JURI 8 JURI Falls if COMP
11 AM 161 Adopted
Recital 26 INTA 6 INTA 6 Falls if COMP 11 AM 161-JURI
8 AdoptedRecital 26 AM 162 María
Auxiliadora Correa Zamora, Esther Herranz García
Falls if COMP 11 JURI 8 Adopted
Compatible as addition
PE516.894v01-00 182/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Citations / Recitals
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Recital 26 AGRI 12 AGRI Falls if COMP 11 AM 161-JURI
8-INTA 6-162 Adopted
Split Voterequested by S&D:First part:The whole textwithout the last sentence: "The Commission and MS..in tobacco products"
2nd part:that sentence
Recital 26 AM 163 Linda McAvan
Falls if COMP 11 INTA 6 Adopted
Compatible with others
Recital 26 IMCO 12 IMCO Falls if COMP 11 INTA 6-
AGRI 12-AM 163 Adopted
Compatible with others
Recital 26 AM 7 Linda McAvan
Falls if COMP 11 Adopted
Withdrawn
W
Recital 27 AM 164 R. Sommer Falls if COMP 52 Adopted
Deletion
F
Recital 27 AM 165 S. Essayah Falls if AM 164 Adopted
-
Recital 27 JURI 9 JURI Falls if Falls if COMP 52AM 164 -165
Adopted
F
COMP 12
Recital 28
S&D - EPP -ALDE -
GREENS/EFA - ECR - EFD -
GUE
+
Recital 28 AM 166 R. Sommer Falls if COMP 12 Adopted
Deletion
All Amendments covered by COMP 12 Fell
Recital 28 AM 167 M.Anderson, K.T. Liotard
Falls if COMP 12 AM 166 Adopted
PV\1001717ES.doc 183/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Citations / Recitals
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Recital 28 AM 168 Carl Schlyter Falls if COMP 12 AM 166-167
AdoptedRecital 28 IMCO 13 IMCO Falls if COMP
12 AM 166 Adopted
Compatible with others
COMP 13
Recital 29
S&D - EPP -ALDE -
GREENS/EFA -ECR- EFD -
GUE
+
Recital 29 AM 169 Morten Messerschmidt
Falls if COMP 13 Adopted
All Amendments covered by COMP 13
FellRecital 29 AM 170 B.Bendtsen,
J. E.Hibner, J. Leszek Walesa, C.Fjellner, M.Weber, A.Rosbach, B.Sonik
Recital 29 ITRE 11 ITRE 11Recital 29 JURI 10 JURI 10
IdenticalFalls if COMP
13 AM 169 Adopted
Recital 29 AM 171 Nils Torvalds Falls if COMP 13 AM 169-170
AdoptedRecital 29 AM 172 Christofer
Fjellner, Bendt Bendtsen, Jaroslaw Leszek Walesa, R.Sommer, Nils Torvalds
Falls if COMP 13 AM 169 Adopted
Compatible with 170-171
Recital 29 a (new)
Snus
AM 173 Åsa Westlund, Marita Ulvskog
+
Recital 29 b (new)
Prohibition for other type of tobacco for oral use
AM 174 S. Essayah -
PE516.894v01-00 184/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Citations / Recitals
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
CONS 14
Recital 30
S&D - EPP -ALDE -
GREENS/EFA - EFD - GUE
+
Recital 30 AM 175 M. Anderson Falls if CONS 14 Adopted
All Amendments covered by
CONS 14 Fell
Recital 30 AGRI 13 AGRI Falls if CONS 14 AM 175 Adopted
Recital 30 INTA 7 INTA 7 Falls if CONS 14 AM 175- AGRI
13 AdoptedRecital 30 AM 8 Linda
McAvanFalls if CONS 14 AM 175 - AGRI
13-INTA 7 Adopted
Recital 30 AM 176 G.Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, C.Morganti, L.Fontana
Recital 30 IMCO 14 IMCO
Identical
Falls if CONS 14 AM 175-
AGRI 13-INTA 7 -8 Adopted
Recital 30 AM 177 Eija-Riitta Korhola
Recital 30 AM 178 J. E. Hibner, M.Handzlik, B.Sonik
Identical in content
Falls if CONS 14 AM 175-AGRI 13-INTA 7 -8-176 Adopted
Recital 30 AM 179 G.Willmott, A.Perelló Rodríguez, C.Schlyter, N.Childers, C.Stihler, A.Parvanova
Falls if CONS 14 AM 175-AGRI 13-INTA 7 - 8-
176-177-178 Adopted
Recital 30 AM 180 Riikka Manner
Falls if CONS 14 AM 175-AGRI 13-INTA 7-8-
176-177-178-179 Adopted
Recital 30 a (new)
Free distribution of TP
AM 181 Andrés Perelló Rodríguez
+
PV\1001717ES.doc 185/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Citations / Recitals
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Recital 30 a (new)
Ban o free distribution of TP
AM 9 Linda McAvan
Falls if AM 181 Adopted
F
Recital 30 d (new)
Free distribution of TP
AM 184 M.Anderson, K.T. Liotard
Falls if AM 181-9 Adopted
F
Recital 30 b (new)
Illegal trade
AM 182 Izaskun Bilbao Barandica
-
Recital 30 c (new)
Point of sale displays
AM 183 M. Anderson -
Recital 30 d (new)
Effective implementation of FCTC's protocol
JURI 11 JURI +
Recital 31 AM 186 Toine Manders
Falls if COMP 56 Adopted
F
Recital 31 AM 185 S. Essayah Falls if COMP 56 AM 186 Adopted
F
Recital 31 AM 10 Linda McAvan
Withdrawn
Falls if COMP 56 AM 186-185
Adopted
W
Recital 31 AM 190 T. Skylakakis Falls if AM 186-185-10 Adopted
-
Recital 31 ITRE 12 ITRE Falls if AM 186-185-10-190 Adopted
+
Recital 31 INTA 8 INTA 8 Falls if AM 186-185-10-190 Adopted
Compatible with ITRE 8
-
(+13-55)
Recital 31 AM 189 María Auxiliadora Correa Zamora, Esther Herranz García, Pilar Ayuso
Falls if AM 186-185-10- INTA 8
Adopted
Compatible to 190-ITRE 12
-
PE516.894v01-00 186/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Citations / Recitals
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Recital 31 AGRI 14 AGRI Falls if AM 186-185-10- INTA 8-
189 Adopted
Compatible to 190 ITRE 12
-
Recital 31 AM 187 Riikka Manner
Falls if AM 186-185-10-190-
INTA 8 Adopted
Compatible with 189-AGRI 14
ITRE 12
-
Recital 31 AM 188 J. E. Hibner, M. Handzlik, B.Sonik
Recital 31 IMCO 15 IMCO
Identical
Compatible as addition to all
-
Recital 32 AM 191 S. Essayah Falls if COMP 56Adopted
F
CONS 15
Recital 33Medicine Regime e-cig
S&DGREENS/EFA
GUE
+
(+48-22)
CONS 16
Recital 33
ALDE-ECR-EFD
Falls if CONS 15 Adopted
F
Recital 33 JURI 12 JURI Falls if CONS 15-16 Adopted
Deletion
All Amendments covered by
CONS 15 Fell
Recital 33 AM 192 Linda McAvan, Karl-Heinz Florenz
Falls if CONS 15-16 AM
JURI 12 Adopted
Falls if AM 1250 NOT Adopted
Recital 33 AM 193 F. Ries Falls if CONS 15-16 JURI 12
-AM 192 Adopted
Recital 33 AM 194 G.Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F. E. Speroni, C.Morganti, L. Fontana
Falls if CONS 15-16 AM JURI
12 Adopted
Compatible with others
PV\1001717ES.doc 187/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Citations / Recitals
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Recital 33 AM 195 S. Essayah Falls if CONS 15-16 JURI 12 -
AM 192-193 Adopted
Compatible with 194
Recital 33 AM 196 Toine Manders
Falls if CONS 15-16 AM JURI
12 Adopted
Compatible as addition to all
CONS 18
Recital 34
ALDE-ECR-EFD
-
(+21-48)CONS 17
Recital 34Medicine Regime e-cig
S&D, Greens/EFA, GUE/NGL
Falls if CONS 18 Adopted
+
(+46-20)
Recital 34 AM 198 R. SommerRecital 34 JURI 13 JURI
Falls if CONS 18-17 Adopted
IdenticalDeletion
All Amendments covered by
CONS 17 Fell
Recital 34 ITRE 13 ITRE Falls if CONS 18-17 AM 198
AdoptedRecital 34 AM 199 C.Engström,
C. Fjellner, R. Taylor
Falls if CONS 18-17 AM 198
Adopted
Recital 34 AM 200 G. Willmott, A.Perelló Rodríguez, K.T. Liotard, C.Schlyter, C. Stihler, A.Parvanova
Falls if CONS 18-17 AM 198-ITRE 13-199
Adopted
Recital 34 IMCO 16 IMCO Falls if CONS 18-17 AM 198-ITRE 13-199-200 Adopted
Recital 34 AM 201 G.Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F. E. Speroni, C.Morganti, L. Fontana
Falls if CONS 18-17 AM 198-ITRE 13-199-200-IMCO 16
Adopted
Recital 34 AM 202 F. Ries Falls if CONS 18-17 AM 198-ITRE 13-199-200-IMCO 16-201 Adopted
PE516.894v01-00 188/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Citations / Recitals
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Recital 34 AM 203 T. Skylakakis Falls if CONS 18-17 AM 198-ITRE 13-199-200-IMCO 16-201 Adopted
Compatible with 201-202
Recital 34 a (new)
AM 204 S. Essayah -
CONS 20Medicine Regime e-cig
Recital 35
S&D-GREENS/EFA
-GUE/NGL
+
CONS 19
Recital 35
ALDE-ECR-EFD
Falls if CONS 20 Adopted
F
Recital 35 AM 205 G. Willmott, A.Perelló Rodríguez, K.T. Liotard, C.Schlyter, C. Stihler, A.Parvanova
Recital 35 ITRE 14 ITRERecital 35 IMCO 17 IMCORecital 35 JURI 14 JURI
Falls if CONS 20-19 Adopted
IdenticalDeletion
All Amendments covered by
CONS 20 Fell
Recital 35 AM 208 G.Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F. E. Speroni, C.Morganti, L. Fontana
Falls if CONS 20-19 AM 205
Adopted
Recital 35 AM 207 Christian Engström, Christofer Fjellner, Rebecca Taylor
Falls if CONS 20-19 AM 205-208 Adopted
Recital 35 AM 206 S. Essayah Falls if CONS 20-19 AM 205-
208-207 Adopted
Recital 35 a new
Age required for nicotine containing products
JURI 15 JURI +
PV\1001717ES.doc 189/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Citations / Recitals
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
COMP 21
Recital 37
S&D - EPP -ALDE -
GREENS/EFA ECR - EFD -GUE/NGL
+
Recital 37 AM 210 R. SommerRecital 37 ITRE 15 ITRE 15 Falls if COMP
21 Adopted
Identical
Deletion
All Amendments covered by COMP 21
Fell
Recital 37 AM 213 Glenis Willmott, Carl Schlyter
Recital 37 AM 212 Jaroslaw Kalinowski
Identical
Falls if COMP 21 AM 210
Adopted
Recital 37 AGRI 15 AGRI Falls if COMP 21 AM 210-213-
212 AdoptedRecital 37 AM 211 Milan
CabrnochFalls if AM
210-213-212-AGRI 15 Adopted
Recital 37 AM 214 G.Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F. E. Speroni, C.Morganti, L. Fontana
Recital 37 IMCO 18 IMCO
Identical
Falls COMP 21-CONS 33
AM 445-451 if AM 210-213-212-AGRI 15-211 Adopted
Recital 37 AM 11 Linda McAvan
Falls if COMP 21 AM 210-
213-212-AGRI 15-211-214
AdoptedRecital 37 AM 215 Jolanta
Emilia Hibner, Malgorzata Handzlik, Boguslaw Sonik
Falls if COMP 21 AM 210-
213-212-AGRI 15-211
Adopted
Compatible with others
CONS 22
Recital 38
S&D - EPP -ALDE -
GREENS/EFA - EFD -GUE/NGL
+
Recital 38 AM 216 Gaston Franco Falls if CONS 22
All Amendment
PE516.894v01-00 190/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Citations / Recitals
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Recital 38 AM 217 R. Sommer, Monika Hohlmeier
Recital 38 AGRI 16 AGRI
Adopted
Identical Deletion
s covered by CONS 22 Fell
Recital 38 ITRE 16 ITRE Falls if CONS 22 AM 216-217 Adopted
Recital 38 AM 219 H. Krahmer Falls if CONS 22 AM 216-217-
ITRE 16 Adopted
Recital 38 JURI 16 JURI Falls if CONS 22 AM 216-217-ITRE 16-219
AdoptedRecital 38 AM 218 Milan
CabrnochFalls if CONS 22 AM 216-217-ITRE 16-219-JURI 16 Adopted
Recital 38 IMCO 19 IMCO Falls if CONS 22 AM 216-217-ITRE 16-219-JURI 16-218
AdoptedRecital 38 AM 220 Eleni
TheocharousRecital 38 AM 221 Sergej
Kozlík
Identical
Falls if CONS 22 AM 216-217-ITRE 16-219-JURI 16-218-
IMCO 19 Adopted
Recital 38 AM 223 Ewald Stadler
Falls if CONS 22 AM 216-217-ITRE 16-219-JURI 16-218-IMCO 19-220-221 Adopted
Recital 38 AM 222 A. Parvanova Falls if CONS 22 AM 216-217-ITRE 16-219-JURI 16-218-
IMCO 19 Adopted
Compatible with others
Recital 38 AM 226 G.Scottà, O.Rossi, M.Salvini, F. E. Speroni, C.Morganti, L. Fontana
Falls if CONS 22 AM 216-217-ITRE 16-219-JURI 16-218-
IMCO 19 Adopted
Compatible with others
PV\1001717ES.doc 191/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Citations / Recitals
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Recital 38 AM 12 Linda McAvan
Falls if CONS 22 AM 216-217-ITRE 16-219-
JURI 16-218-226 Adopted
Compatible with others
Recital 38 AM 225 Andrés Perelló Rodríguez
Falls if CONS 22 AM 216-217-ITRE 16-219-JURI 16-218-IMCO 19-220-
221-223 Adopted
Compatible with others
Recital 38 AM 224 Claudiu Ciprian Tanasescu, Minodora Cliveti
Falls if CONS 22 AM 216-217-ITRE 16-219-JURI 16-218-
IMCO 19 Adopted
Compatible with others
Recital 39 ITRE 17 ITRE Deletion -Recital 39 IMCO 20 IMCO Falls if ITRE 17
Adopted+
(+44-25)Recital 39 a (new)
MS'Preventive Actions
ITRE 18 ITRE +
(+42-26)
Recital 39 a (new)
AM 227 S. Essayah -
COMP 23
Recital 40
S&D, EPP, ALDE,
Greens/EFA, ECR,
GUE/NGL, EFD
+
Recital 40 JURI 17 JURI Falls if COMP 23 Adopted
Deletion
All Amendments covered by COMP 23 Fell
Recital 40 AGRI 17 AGRI Falls if COMP 23 JURI 17 Adopted
Recital 40 ITRE 19 ITRE Falls if COMP23 JURI 17-
AGRI 17 Adopted
PE516.894v01-00 192/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Citations / Recitals
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Recital 40 AM 228 Georgios Koumoutsakos
Falls if COMP 23 JURI 17-
AGRI 17-ITRE 19 Adopted
Recital 40 AM 229 Milan Cabrnoch
Falls if COMP 23 JURI 17-
AGRI 17-ITRE 19 AM 228 Adopted
Recital 40 AM 232 R. Sommer Falls if COMP23 JURI 17-
AGRI 17-ITRE 19 AM 228 Adopted
Compatible with 229
Recital 40 AM 13 Linda McAvan
Falls if COMP 23 JURI 17-
AGRI 17-ITRE 19 AM 228 Adopted
Compatible with 229-232
Recital 40 AM 230 Martin Callanan
Falls if COMP 23 JURI 17-
AGRI 17-ITRE 19 AM 228 Adopted
Compatible with 229-232
Recital 40 AM 231 Ewald Stadler
Falls if COMP 23 JURI 17-
AGRI 17-ITRE 19 AM 228 Adopted
Compatible with others
Recital 40 INTA 9 INTA 9 Falls if COMP 23 JURI 17-
AGRI 17-ITRE 19 AM 228 Adopted
Compatible with others
Recital 40 A (new)
AM 233 Maria do Céu Patrão Neves, José Manuel Fernandes
Recital 40 A (new)
AGRI 18 AGRI
Identical -
PV\1001717ES.doc 193/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Citations / Recitals
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
COMP 24
Recital 41
S&D, EPP, ALDE,
Greens/EFA, ECR,
GUE/NGL, EFD
+
Recital 41 AM 234 R. Sommer Falls if COMP 24 Adopted
Deletion
All Amendments covered by COMP 24 Fell
Recital 41 AGRI 19 AGRI Falls if COMP 24 AM 234 Adopted
Recital 41 AM 235 H. KrahmerRecital 41 ITRE 20 ITRE
IdenticalFalls if COMP
24 AM 234 AGRI 19 Adopted
Recital 41 IMCO 21 IMCO Falls if COMP 24 AM 234-
AGRI 19-235 Adopted
Recital 41 JURI 18 JURI Falls if COMP 24 AM 234-
AGRI 19-235-IMCO 21 Adopted
Recital 41 AM 236 G.Willmott, A. Perelló Rodríguez, C.Schlyter, N.Childers, C.Stihler, A.Parvanova
Falls if COMP 24 AM 234-
AGRI 19-235-IMCO 21-JURI
18 Adopted
Falls also if AM 34, 35 or 897 are NOT
adoptedRecital 41 INTA 10 INTA 10 Falls if COMP
24AM 234-AGRI 19-235-
IMCO 21-JURI 18-236 Adopted
Recital 41 AM 237 Georgios Koumoutsakos
Falls if COMP 24 AM 234-
AGRI 19-235-ILCO 21-JURI 18-236 Adopted
Compatible with INTA 10
Recital 41 AM 14 Linda McAvan
Falls if COMP 24 AM 234-
AGRI 19-235-IMCO 21-JURI 18-236 INTA 10
Adopted
PE516.894v01-00 194/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Citations / Recitals
Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote
Recital 41 AM 238 S. Essayah Falls if COMP 24 AM 234-
AGRI 19-235-ILCO 21-JURI
18 Adopted
Compatible with others as addition
Recital 41 a (new)
AM 239 Ewald Stadler
-
Recital 41 a (new)
AM 240 S. Auconie, Gaston Franco, Jean-Pierre Audy
-
Recital 41 a (new)Taxes and duties to finance prevention campaigns
INTA 11 INTA 11 -
Recital 42 AM 241 Ewald Stadler
Recital 42 ITRE 21 ITRE
Identical +(+37-30)
Recital 43 a (new)
AM 242 María Auxiliadora Correa Zamora, Esther Herranz García
Recital 43 a (new)
AGRI 20 AGRI
Recital 43 a (new)
INTA 12 INTA 12
Identical -
Recital 45 AM 244 Ewald Stadler
-
Recital 45 AM 243 R. Sommer, Monika Hohlmeier
Falls if AM 244 Adopted
+
(+39-31)Recital 45 AM 245 Toine
Manders, Karl-Heinz Florenz, F.Ries
Compatible as addition
+
Recital 45 IMCO 22 IMCO Falls if AM 245 Adopted
F
Recital 45 a (new)
AM 246 Izaskun Bilbao Barandica
-
PV\1001717ES.doc 195/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
VOTE ON THE DRAFT REPORT AS AMENDED
IN FAVOUR
AGAINST ABST.
51 12 8
VOTE ON THE DRAFT LEGISLATIVE RESOLUTION AS A WHOLE IN
FAVOURAGAINST ABST.
50 13 8
PE516.894v01-00 196/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Item 10 – ANNEX IV
VOTING RESULTS
on the proposal amending Directive 98/70/EC relating to the quality of petrol and diesel fuels and amending Directive 2009/28/EC on the promotion of the use of energy from
renewable sources (indirect land use change)2012/0288(COD), PR–PE 508.236v01-00 + AM–PE 513.032v01-00 + AM–PE 513.033v01-00
+ AM–PE 513.034v01-00 + AM–PE 513.035v01-00 + AD–PE 508.012v02-00 + AD–PE 510.683v02-00+ AD–PE 508.068v02-00 + AD–PE 508.069v02-00 + AD–PE 508.023v02-00 + AD–PE 506.337v02-00
Rapporteur: Corinne Lepage
Final – 10/07/2013
Concerned text AM Tabled by Remarks Vote
Art 1 – title 226 Panayotov -
Art 1 – point -1 (new)Art 1 – point b a (new)
TRAN 17 -
CONSOLIDATED 9Sustainability safeguards for forests and forestry plantationsSeveral Articles;Recital 11 a (new)
ALDE, S&D, GREENS/EFA, ECR, GUE/NGL
If adopted, 16, 17, 22-23, 50-51, 192, 261, 420, 497, 516, DEVE 29, DEVE 31 fall
+
16 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 9 adopted ↓
17 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 9 adopted ↓
18 Rapporteur +29/19/0
Art 1 – point -1 (new)Art 2 – point 9 a (new)
19 Rapporteur +
Art 1 – point -1 (new)Art 3 – para 3
227 Busoi Taken over by Krahmer(original author no longer a Member)
+
Art 1 – point -1 (new)Art 4 – para 1 –subpara 3
228 Busoi Taken over by Krahmer(original author no longer a Member)
+
Art 1 – point 1 –point -a (new)Art 7a – para 1 –subpara 2 a (new)
TRAN 18 +
PV\1001717ES.doc 197/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
CONSOLIDATED 4FQD trajectoryArt 1 – point 1 – point -a (new)Art 7a – para 2
ALDE, EPP, S&D, GREENS/EFA, GUE/NGL
If adopted, 20, 229-233, 237, 316 fall +
CONSOLIDATED 1Cap and subtargetArt 1 – point 1 – point -a (new)Art 7a – para 2 – subpara 1 a (new);Art 2 – point 2 – point bArt 3 – para 1 – subpara 2;Art 2 – point 2 – point c –point iiArt 3 – para 4 – subpara 2 – point d;Recitals 6, 9 and 10
ALDE, EPP, S&D, GREENS/EFA, GUE/NGL
If adopted, 40, 41, 42, 319-333, 336-339, 345-360, 361-363, 234-236, 246, 4, 6-7, 117-131, 152-176, ITRE 6, ITRE 8, ITRE 9, ITRE 10, ITRE 31 A, ITRE 31 B, ITRE 31 C, AGRI 8-9, AGRI 12-13, AGRI 32, AGRI 34, AGRI 36, AGRI 38, INTA 2, INTA 6, INTA 8, INTA 18, INTA 21, REGI 3, REGI 7, TRAN 4, TRAN 8, TRAN 28, TRAN 31, TRAN 34, DEVE 6, DEVE 9, DEVE 15, DEVE 19, DEVE 21, DEVE 24 fallCompatible with CONS 4 as an addition of a subparagraph to Article 7a(2) of Directive 98/70/EC
+
229 Panayotov Falls if CONS 4 adoptedIf CONS 1 adopted, the words "Member States shall ensure ... Article 3(4)(d) of Directive 2009/28/EC" fall
↓Art 1 – point 1 –point -a (new)Art 7a – para 2
230 Gerbrandy Falls if CONS 4 or 229 adoptedIf CONS 1 adopted, the words "Member States shall ensure ... Article 3(4)(d) of Directive 2009/28/EC" fall
↓
Art 1 – point 1 –point -a (new)Art 7a – para 2 –point a
232 Eickhout, Wils, Jørgensen
Falls if CONS 4, 229 or 230 adopted ↓
Art 1 – point 1 –point -a b (new)Art 7a – para 2 a (new)
237 Eickhout, Wils, Jørgensen
Falls if CONS 4, 229 or 230 adopted ↓
Art 1 – point 1 –point -a (new)Art 7a – para 2
20 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 4, 229, 230 or 237 adoptedIf 232 adopted, the amendment to point (a) falls
↓
Art 1 – point 1 –point -a (new)Art 7a – para 2 –introductory part
231 Davies Falls if CONS 4 adopted ↓
Art 1 – point 1 –point -a a (new)Art 7a – para 2 –point b – point ii
233 Eickhout, Wils Falls if CONS 4 adopted ↓
PE516.894v01-00 198/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Art 1 – point 1 –point -a (new)Art 7a – para 2 –subpara 1 a (new)
235 Wils Falls if CONS 1, 229 or 230 adopted ↓
234 Scottà, RossiArt 1 – point 1 –point -a (new)Art 7a – para 2 –point c a (new)
DEVE 15
Fall if CONS 1, 229, 230 or 235 adoptedIdentical
↓
Art 1 – point 1 –point b a (new)Art 7a – para 6 a (new)
246 Arsenis, Leinen, Jørgensen, Childers, Thomsen
Falls if CONS 1, 229, 230, 235 or 234 adopted
↓
Art 1 – point 1 –point -a (new)Art 7a – para 2 –subpara 1 a (new)
236 Delvaux Falls if CONS 1, 229, 230, 235, 234 or 246 adopted
↓
COMPROMISE 3ILUC factors: FQD, reporting and revisionArt 1 – point 1 – point aArt 7a – para 6;Art 1 – point 3 – point -aArt 7d – para 1 – subpara 1 a (new);Art 1 – point 3 – point aArt 7d – para 6;Art 2 – point 7 – point cArt 19 – para 6;Art 2 – point 9Art 22 – para 2;Recitals 11 and 12
ALDE, EPP, S&D, GREENS/EFA, ECR, GUE/NGL
If adopted, 28, 97, 239-244, 276-282, 289, 311, 429, 440-445, 450, 452-455, 483, 494-496, 498, 511-515, 517, 519, 178-184, 193-201, ITRE 12, ITRE 14, ITRE 16, ITRE 22, ITRE 26, ITRE 27, ITRE 37-38, ITRE 39, ITRE 42-44, AGRI 5-6, AGRI 14-15, AGRI 18, AGRI 23, AGRI 29, AGRI 48, AGRI 53-54, 59, AGRI 61-62, INTA 10, INTA 24-26, INTA 32, REGI 8, TRAN 10-11, TRAN 13, TRAN 22, TRAN 39, DEVE 11 fall
+
239 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
240 Ayuso, Arias Echeverría
241 Reimers
242 Schnellhardt
AGRI 18
Fall if COMP 3 adoptedIdenticalDeletion
↓
ITRE 22 Falls if COMP 3 or 239 adopted ↓
Art 1 – point 1 –point aArt 7a – para 6
244 Bánki Falls if COMP 3, 239 or ITRE 22 adopted
↓
PV\1001717ES.doc 199/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
243 Girling Falls if COMP 3 or 239 adopted ↓
Art 1 – point 1 –point bArt 7a – para 5 –subpara 1 –introductory part
245 Franco Deletion -
CONSOLIDATED 8Sustainability safeguards for second generation biofuels (excluding forestry)Several Articles;Recital 7
ALDE, EPP, GREENS/EFA, GUE/NGL
If adopted, 5, 24, 33, 52, 54, 61, 139-144, 238, 247, 258, 263, 400, 408, 423, 426, 433, 620, AGRI 10, INTA 11, REGI 4, DEVE 7, DEVE 17, DEVE 25, TRAN 5, TRAN 19, INTA 24, INTA 25, ITRE 7 fall
+
247 KlaßArt 1 – point 2 –point -a (new)Art 7b – para 1 –subpara 2
TRAN 19
Fall if CONS 8 adoptedIdenticalDeletion of Article 7b(1)(2) of Directive 98/70/EC
↓
248 Wils If adopted, 68 adopted(introduction of Annex Va)Typo: "Annex V" should read "Annex Va"
-Art 1 – point 2 –point -a (new)Art 7b – para 1 –subpara 2 a (new) 21 Rapporteur Falls if 248 adopted
If adopted, 68 adopted(introduction of Annex Va)
+
CONSOLIDATED 7Greenhouse gas emission savings thresholdArt 1 – point 2 – point aArt 7b – para 2;Art 2 – point 5 – point aArt 17 – para 2;
ALDE, S&D, GREENS/EFA, GUE/NGL
If adopted, 249-256, 411-417AGRI 19, AGRI 44, TRAN 20, TRAN 36 fall
+32/23/0
249 Fjellner Falls if CONS 7 adoptedDeletion
↓Art 1 – point 2 –point aArt 7b – para 2 AGRI 19
Art 1 – point 2 –point aArt 7b – para 2 –subpara 1
250 Bánki
Art 1 – point 2 –point aArt 7b – para 2 –subpara 2
255 Bánki
Fall if CONS 7 or 249 adoptedVote collectively(AGRI 19 identical to 250 + 255)
↓
Art 1 – point 2 –point aArt 7b – para 2 –subpara 1
251 Wils Fall if CONS 7, 249 or AGRI 19 adoptedVote collectively
↓
PE516.894v01-00 200/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Art 1 – point 2 –point aArt 7b – para 2 –subpara 2
254 Wils
Art 1 – point 2 –point aArt 7b – para 2
TRAN 20 Falls if CONS 7, 249, AGRI 19 or 251 adopted
Split vote (ALDE)
Part 1Without amending "50%" to "60%"
Part 2Amending "50%" to "60%"
↓
Art 1 – point 2 –point aArt 7b – para 2 –subpara 1
252 Panayotov
Art 1 – point 2 –point aArt 7b – para 2 –subpara 2
256 Panayotov
Fall if CONS 7, 249, AGRI 19, 251 or TRAN 20 Part 1 adoptedVote collectivelyCompatible with TRAN 20 Part 2 as amending "2014" to "2015" (twice)
↓
Art 1 – point 2 –point aArt 7b – para 2 –subpara 1
253 Franco, Vlasto Falls if CONS 7, 249, AGRI 19 or TRAN 20 Part 2 adopted
↓
Art 1 – point 2 –point aArt 7b – para 2 –subpara 3
257 Gardini, Girling Falls if 249 adopted -
259 Bánki
260 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
Art 1 – point 2 –point bArt 7b – para 3 –subpara 2
AGRI 20
IdenticalDeletion
-20/37/0
22 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 9 adopted ↓Art 1 – point 2 –point b a (new)Art 7b – para 4 261 Leinen Falls if CONS 9 or 22 adopted ↓
Art 1 – point 2 –point a a (new)Art 7b – para 2 a (new)
258 Van Brempt, Merkies
Falls if CONS 8 adopted ↓
Art 1 – point 1 –point -a (new)
23 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 9 adopted ↓
PV\1001717ES.doc 201/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
238 Panayotov Falls if CONS 8 adopted ↓
24 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 8 or 238 adopted ↓
Art 7b – para 5 a (new)
INTA 11 Falls if CONS 8, 238 or 24 adopted ↓
Art 1 – point 1 –point -a (new)Art 7a – para 4 a (new)
ITRE 23 -25/33/0
ITRE 24 -Art 1 – point 1 –point -a (new)Art 7a – para 5 a (new)
262 Klaß Falls if ITRE 24 adopted -
Art 1 – point 2 –point b a (new)Art 7b – para 6 –subparas 1 a, 1 band 1 c (new)
263 Wils Falls if CONS 8 adopted ↓
Art 1 – point 2 –point b a (new)Art 7b – para 5 a (new)
DEVE 17 Falls if CONS 8 or 263 adopted ↓
ITRE 25 +31/28/0
Art 1 – point 2 –point b a (new)Art 7b – para 7 –subpara 2
AGRI 21 Falls if ITRE 25 adopted ↓
Art 1 – point 2 a (new)Art 7c – para 3 –subpara 1
INTA 13 +
Art 1 – point 2 a (new)Art 7c – para 3 –subpara 3
INTA 14 +35/26/0
Art 1 – point 2 a (new)Art 7c – para 3 –subpara 5
INTA 15 +
Art 1 – point 2 a (new)Art 7c – para 4 –subpara 1
INTA 16 +35/25/0
Art 1 – point 2 a (new)Art 7c – para 5
264 Wils +
Art 1 – point 2 a (new)Art 7c – para 6
265 Wils +35/27/0
PE516.894v01-00 202/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
266 Wils +
INTA 17 Falls if 266 adopted ↓
Art 1 – point 2 a (new)Art 7c – para 9 a (new)
267 Leinen Falls if CONS 8 adopted ↓
268 Eickhout
DEVE 18
Identical +
26 Rapporteur Falls if 268 adoptedIf adopted, 64 adopted
↓
Art 1 – point 3 –point -a (new)Art 7d – para 1
269 Arsenis, Jørgensen, Childers, Thomsen
Falls if 268 or 26 adopted ↓
270 Delvaux Falls if 268, 26 or 269 adopted ↓Art 1 – point 3 –point -a (new)Art 7d – para 1 –point a
271 Delvaux, Jordan
Art 1 – point 3 –point -a a (new)Art 7d – para 1 –subpara 1 a (new)
272 Delvaux, Jordan
Fall if 268, 26 or 269 adoptedVote collectively271 falls if 270 adopted
↓
Art 1 – point 3 –point -a a (new)Art 7 d – para 1 a (new)
27 Rapporteur +37/26/0
Art 1 – point 3 –point aArt 7d – para 4
273 Franco Deletion -
Art 1 – point 3 –point aArt 7d – para 5 –subpara 1
TRAN 21 +
274 Franco
275 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
Art 1 – point 3 –point aArt 7d – para 5 –subpara 2
AGRI 22
IdenticalDeletion
-
PV\1001717ES.doc 203/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
276 Bánki
277 Ayuso
278 Franco
279 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
ITRE 26
AGRI 23
Falls if COMP 3 adoptedIdenticalDeletion
↓
280 Klaß Falls if COMP 3 or 276 adopted ↓
28 Rapporteur Falls if COMP 3 or 276 adopted ↓
281 Grossetête, Vlasto Falls if COMP 3 or 276 adopted ↓
TRAN 22 Falls if COMP 3, 276 or 281 adopted ↓
Art 1 – point 3 –point aArt 7d – para 6
282 Auconie Falls if COMP 3 or 276 adoptedCompatible with 281 or TRAN 22 as addition of "responding to ... challenges"
↓
Art 1 – point 3 –point aArt 7d – para 6 –subpara 1 a (new)
29 Rapporteur Falls if 276 adopted +
30 Rapporteur +50/14/0
283 Arsenis, Childers, Thomsen
Falls if 30 adopted ↓
Art 1 – point 3 –point a a (new)Art 7d – para 6 a (new)
31 Rapporteur Falls if 30 AND 283 NOT adopted ↓
284 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
285 Franco
Art 1 – point 3 –point bArt 7d – para 7 –subpara 1
286 Girling
IdenticalDeletion
-30/34/0
PE516.894v01-00 204/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
287 Bánki
AGRI 24
Fall if 284 adoptedIdentical
-
288 Ayuso
TRAN 23
Identical +34/27/4
ITRE 27 Falls if COMP 3 adopted ↓
Art 1 – point 3 –point c a (new)Art 7d – para 8 a (new)
289 Ayuso Falls if COMP 3 or ITRE 27 adopted ↓
Art 1 – point 5Art 8a – para 3
290 Franco Withdrawn(Deletion)
W
291 Ayuso +Art 1 – point 5 a (new)Art 9 – para 2 a (new)
292 Busoi Withdrawn (author no longer a Member)(falls if 291 adopted)
W
293 Franco Deletion -
294 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
Art 1 – point 6Art 10 – para 1
AGRI 25
Fall if 293 adoptedIdentical
-
Art 1 – point 7Art 10a
295 Franco Adopted if 245, 259, 274, 276, 284, 290 AND 293 adopted AND 27 AND 288 NOT adopted, falls otherwiseDeletion
No vote
296 Girling Falls if 295 adoptedVote only on "shall be ... each period"
+Art 1 – point 7Art 10a – para 2
AGRI 26 Falls if 295 or 296 adoptedVote only on "shall be ... this Directive"
↓
Art 1 – point 7Art 10a – para 3
300 Ayuso Falls if 295 adoptedVote only on "the decision ... Journal"
-
Art 1 – point 7Art 10a – para 5
304 Ayuso Falls if 295 adoptedVote only on amending "That" to "The"
-
PV\1001717ES.doc 205/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
32 RapporteurArt 1 – point 7Art 10a
ITRE 28
297 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
298 Ayuso
299 Arsenis, Childers
Art 1 – point 7Art 10a – para 2
TRAN 24
301 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
302 Girling
303 Arsenis, Childers
TRAN 25
Art 1 – point 7Art 10a – para 3
AGRI 27
305 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
Art 1 – point 7Art 10a – para 5
306 Arsenis, Childers
TRAN 26Art 1 – point 7Art 10a – para 3
AGRI 28
List of provisions conferring delegated powers to be adapted to the result of previous votes on Articles 7a(5), 7b(3)(2), 7d(1a), 7d(5), 7d(6), 7d(7), 7d(8a), 8a(3) and 10(1)
No vote
PE516.894v01-00 206/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Article 2 – Amendments to Directive 2009/28/EC (Renewable Energy Directive)CONSOLIDATED 6Target transfer possibility between overall national renewable energy target and 10% transport targetArt 2 – point 2 – point c –point -i (new)Art 3 – para 4 – subpara 1;Recital 11 a (new)
ALDE, S&D, GREENS/EFA, ECR, GUE/NGL
If adopted, 43, 307, 334, 402 fall +45/23/0
Art 2 – point -1 (new)Art 1
307 Scottà, Rossi Falls if CONS 6 adopted ↓
Art 2 – point - 1 (new)Art 2 – point e
308 Scottà, Rossi -
310 Scottà, Rossi -
309 Franco
Art 2 – point -1 a (new)Art 2 – point k
ITRE 29
Fall if 310 adoptedIdentical
-
Art 2 – point 1Art 2 – point p
33 Rapporteur +
34 Rapporteur +
35 Rapporteur +
36 Rapporteur +
37 Rapporteur +
38 Rapporteur +
39 Rapporteur +
312 Bánki
AGRI 30
Identical -
313 Ayuso
TRAN 27
Identical -29/39/0
Art 2 – point 1 a (new)Art 2 – point p a (new)
314 Westlund, Ulvskog Withdrawn(falls if 313 adopted)
W
PV\1001717ES.doc 207/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
315 Bánki
AGRI 31
Fall if 313 adoptedIdentical(fall if 314 adopted)
-
316 Davies Falls if CONS 4 adopted ↓
317 Eickhout +
318 Essayah, Pakarinen +
Art 2 – point 2 –point aArt 3 – title
319 Franco Falls if CONS 1 adopted ↓
320 Reimers
321 Scottà, Rossi
322 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
323 Ayuso
324 Franco
325 Klaß
326 Schnellhardt
AGRI 32
INTA 18
Fall if CONS 1 adoptedIdenticalDeletion
↓
40 Rapporteur Withdrawn(identical to 320 , falls if CONS 1 adopted)
W
327 Girling Falls if CONS 1 or 320 adopted ↓
328 Westlund, Ulvskog Falls if CONS 1, 320 or 327 adopted ↓
329 Eickhout, Wils Falls if CONS 1 or 320 adoptedCompatible with 327 or 328 ad addition of "shall be conditional ... soil fertility"
↓
Art 2 – point 2 –point bArt 3 – para 1 –subpara 2
TRAN 28 Fall if CONS 1, 320 or 327 adopted ↓
PE516.894v01-00 208/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
330 Scottà, Rossi
DEVE 19
Fall if CONS 1, 320 or 327 adoptedIdentical
↓
331 Bartolozzi Falls if CONS 1 adopted ↓Art 2 – point 2 –point b a (new)Art 3 – para 1 –subpara 2 a (new)
AGRI 33 -
Art 2 – point 2 –point cArt 3 – para 4
338 Scottà, Rossi Falls if CONS 1, 22, 50 or ITRE 22 adoptedDeletion of Article 3(4) of Directive 2009/28/EC
↓
332 Eickhout, Wils Falls if CONS 1 or 338 adopted ↓
333 Auconie Falls if CONS 1, 338 or 332 adopted ↓
334 Delvaux Falls if CONS 6, 338 or 332 adoptedCompatible with 333 as addition of "A Member State may derogate ... exceed those targets"
↓
335 Franco Falls if 338 adopted -
ITRE 31 A Falls if CONS 1, 338 or 335 adoptedLast sentence of subparagraph 1 ("Each Member State shall ensure ... petrol in that Member State")
↓
INTA 19 Falls if 338 adopted -
TRAN 30 Falls if 338 or INTA 19 adopted -
Art 2 – point 2 –point c – point -i (new)Art 3 – para 4 –subpara 1
DEVE 20 Falls if 338 adopted -34/34/0
Art 2 – point 2 –point c – point -i(new)Art 3 – para 4 –subparas 1 a, 1 b and 1 c (new)
ITRE 31 B Falls if CONS 1, 338 or 331 adoptedSubparagraphs 1a, 1b and 1c ("In 2016, at least 0,5% ... In 2020, at least 2,5% ... In 2025, at least 4% ... advanced biofuels")
↓
336 AyusoArt 2 – point 2 –point c – point -i (new)Art 3 – para 4 –subparas 1 a and 1 b (new)
337 Auconie
Fall if CONS 1, 338, 331 or ITRE 31 B adoptedIdentical
↓
PV\1001717ES.doc 209/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
CONSOLIDATED 5Targets for renewable electricity in transportArt 2 – point 2 – point c a (new)Art 3 – para 4 b (new);Art 2 – point 2 – point c –point i a (new)Art 3 – para 4 – subpara 2 – point c – second sentence;Recital 11 a (new)
ALDE, EPP, S&D, GREENS/EFA, GUE/NGL
If adopted, 9, 45, 205, 341-344ITRE 11, ITRE 17, AGRI 35, INTA 20, TRAN 9, TRAN 15, TRAN 29 fall
+
TRAN 29Art 2 – point 2 –point c – point -i (new)Art 3 – para 4 –subpara 1 a (new)
INTA 20
Fall if CONS 5 or 338 adoptedIdentical
↓
339 Ayuso Falls if CONS 1 or 338 adoptedDeletion
↓
41 Rapporteur Withdrawn(identical to 339, falls if CONS 1 adopted)
W
Art 2 – point 2 –point c – point iArt 3 – para 4 –subpara 2 – point b
340 Eickhout Falls if 338 adoptedCompatible with 339 as amending "For the calculation ... taken into account"
+
341 Delvaux Falls if CONS 5 or 338 adopted ↓
342 Jørgensen, Thomsen Falls if CONS 5, 338 or 341 adopted ↓
343 Eickhout
AGRI 35
Fall if CONS 5, 338, 341 or 342 adoptedIdentical
↓
Art 2 – point 2 –point c – point i a (new)Art 3 – para 4 –subpara 2 – point c – second sentence
344 Arsenis, Childers Falls if CONS 5, 338 or 341 adoptedCompatible with 342 or 343 as addition of "and electrified rail"
↓
345 Ayuso
AGRI 36
Fall if CONS 1, 229, 230, 236, 246, 272 or 338 adoptedFall if 320, 339, 320 or 338 NOT adoptedIdenticalDeletion
↓
42 Rapporteur Withdrawn(identical to 345, falls if CONS 1 adopted)
W
349 Franco, Vlasto Falls if CONS 1, 338 or 345 adopted ↓
↓Art 2 – point 2 –point c – point iiArt 3 – para 4 –subpara 2 – point d
INTA 21 Falls if CONS 1, 338, 345 or 349 adopted ↓
PE516.894v01-00 210/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
346 Klaß Falls if CONS 1, 338, 345, 349 or INTA 21 adopted
↓
347 Reimers Falls if CONS 1, 338, 345, 349, INTA 21 or 346 adopted
↓
AGRI 34 Falls if CONS 1, 338, 345, 349, INTA 21, 346 or 347 adopted
↓
348 Weisgerber Falls if CONS 1, 338, 345, 349, INTA 21, 346, 347 or AGRI 34 adopted
↓
352 Bartolozzi Falls if CONS 1, 338 or 345 adoptedCompatible with 349, INTA 21, 346, 347, AGRI 34 or 348 as addition of "Biofuels produced ... twice their energy content"
↓
350 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
351 Bánki
Fall if CONS 1, 338, 345, 349, INTA 21, 346, 347, AGRI 34, 348 or 352 adoptedIdentical
↓
TRAN 31 Falls if CONS 1, 338, 345, 349, INTA 21, 346, 347, AGRI 34, 348, 352 or 350 adopted
↓
ITRE 31 C Falls if CONS 1, 338, 345, 349, INTA 21, 346, 347, AGRI 34, 348, 352, 350 or TRAN 31 adoptedPoint (d) ("for the calculation ... energy in transport in 2020")
↓
353 Girling Falls if CONS 1, 338, v, 349, INTA 21, 346, 347, AGRI 34, 348, 352, 350, TRAN 31 or ITRE 31 C adopted
↓
354 Eickhout, Wils Falls if CONS 1, 338 or 345 adoptedCompatible with 338, 345, 349, INTA 21, 346, 347, AGRI 34, 348, 352, 350, TRAN 31, ITRE 31 C or 353 as deletion of "for the calculation ... numerator"
↓
355 Westlund, Ulvskog Falls if CONS 1, 338, 345, 349, INTA 21, 346, 347, AGRI 34, 348, 352, 350, TRAN 31, ITRE 31 C or 353 adoptedCompatible with 354 as deletion of "cereal ... sugars"
↓
356 Jørgensen Falls if CONS 1, 338, 345, 349, INTA 21, 346, 347, AGRI 34, 348, 352, 350, TRAN 31, ITRE 31 C or 353 adoptedCompatible with 354 and 355 as addition of "grown on land" and with 355 also as addition of "and other energy"
↓
PV\1001717ES.doc 211/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
357 Panayotov Falls if CONS 1, 338, 345, 349, INTA 21, 346, 347, AGRI 34, 348, 352, 350, TRAN 31, ITRE 31 C or 353 adoptedCompatible with 354, 355 or 356 as addition of "as set out ... Annex VIII"
↓
358 Scottà, Rossi
DEVE 21
Fall if CONS 1, 338, 345, 349, INTA 21, 346, 347, AGRI 34, 348, 352, 350, TRAN 31, ITRE 31 C, 353, 354, 355, 356 or 357 adoptedIdentical
↓
359 Fjellner Falls if CONS 1, 338, 345, 349, INTA 21, 346, 347, AGRI 34, 348, 352, 350, TRAN 31, ITRE 31 C, 353, 354, 355, 356, 357 or 358 adopted
↓
360 Leinen, Merkies Falls if CONS 1, 338, 345 or TRAN 29 adopted
↓
362 Westlund, Ulvskog Falls if CONS 1, 338, 345, 349, INTA 21, 346, 347, AGRI 34, 348, 352, 350, TRAN 31 or ITRE 31 C adopted
↓
363 Merkies, Thomsen, Jørgensen
Falls if CONS 1, 338, 345, 349, INTA 21, 346, 347, AGRI 34, 348, 352, 350, TRAN 31, ITRE 31 C or 362 adopted
↓
361 Bánki
AGRI 38
Art 2 – point 2 –point c – point ii a (new)Art 3 – para 4 –subpara 2 – point d a (new)
TRAN 34
Fall if CONS 1 or 338 adoptedIdentical
↓
CONSOLIDATED 2Multiple countingArt 2 – point 2 – point c –point iiiArt 3 – para 4 – subpara 2 – point e;Annex II – point 3Annex IXRecital 6 a (new)
ALDE, EPP, S&D, GREENS/EFA, GUE/NGL
If adopted, 364-399, 401, 521-619, 73-76.132-136, ITRE 31 D, ITRE 45, AGRI 37, AGRI 39, AGRI 42, AGRI 63, INTA 22, INTA 34, REGI 13-15, REGI 18, TRAN 35, TRAN 44, TRAN 45, DEVE 22-23 fall
+
364 Reimers
365 Klaß
366 Bánki
367 Schnellhardt
Art 2 – point 2 –point c – point iiiArt 3 – para 4 –subpara 2 – point e
368 Weisgerber
Fall if CONS 2 or 338 adoptedIdenticalDeletion
↓
PE516.894v01-00 212/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
369 Auconie
AGRI 37
ITRE 31 D Falls if CONS 2, 338 or 364 adopted(includes deletion of subparagraph 1 of point (e))
↓
370 Westlund, Ulvskog
371 Girling
372 Ayuso
373 Bartolozzi
Art 2 – point 2 –point c – point iiiArt 3 – para 4 –subpara 2 – point e – subpara 1
AGRI 39
Fall if CONS 2, 338, 364 or ITRE 31 D adoptedIdenticalDeletion
↓
374 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
Falls if CONS 2, 338, 364, ITRE 31 D or 370 adoptedDeletion
↓
REGI 13 Falls if CONS 2, 338, 364, ITRE 31 D, 370 or 374 adopted
↓
375 Essayah
TRAN 35 A
Fall if CONS 2, 338, 364, ITRE 31 D, 370, 374 or REGI 13 adoptedIdenticalPoint (i) of TRAN 35
↓
Art 2 – point 2 –point c – point iiiArt 3 – para 4 –subpara 2 – point e – subpara 1 – point i
376 Arsenis, Childers, Pirillo
Falls if CONS 2, 338, 364, ITRE 31 D, 370, 374 or REGI 13 adopted
↓
377 Essayah Falls if CONS 2, 338, 364, ITRE 31 D or 370 adoptedDeletion
↓
REGI 14 Falls if CONS 2, 338, 364, ITRE 31 D, 370 or 377 adopted
↓
378 Eickhout, Wils Falls if CONS 2, 338, 364, ITRE 31 D, 370, 377 or REGI 14 adopted
↓
TRAN 35 B Falls if CONS 2, 338, 364, ITRE 31 D, 370 or 377, REGI 14 or 378 adoptedPoint (ii)
↓
Art 2 – point 2 –point c – point iiiArt 3 – para 4 –subpara 2 – point e – subpara 1 – point ii
DEVE 22 Falls if CONS 2, 338, 364, ITRE 31 D, 370 or 377, REGI 14 or 378 adoptedIf 374 NOT adopted, the deletion of "Part B of" fallsCompatible with TRAN 35 B as addition of "after prior ... sustainability"
↓
PV\1001717ES.doc 213/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
379 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
Falls if CONS 2, 338, 364, ITRE 31 D, 370 or 377, REGI 14 or 378 adoptedIf 374 NOT adopted, the deletion of "Part B of" falls
↓
380 Arsenis, Childers, Pirillo
Falls if CONS 2, 338, 364, ITRE 31 D, 370, 377 or REGI 14 adopted
↓
381 Wils
INTA 22
TRAN 35 C
Fall if CONS 2, 338, 364, ITRE 31 D or 370 adoptedFall if 374 AND 377 adoptedIdenticalDeletionPart (iii) of TRAN 35
↓
383 Eickhout Falls if CONS 2, 338, 364, ITRE 31 D, 370 or 381 adopted
↓
382 Essayah
REGI 15
Fall if CONS 2, 338, 364, ITRE 31 D, 370, 381 or 383 adoptedIdentical
↓
Art 2 – point 2 –point c – point iiiArt 3 – para 4 –subpara 2 – point e – subpara 1 – point iii
384 Panayotov Falls if CONS 2, 338, 364, ITRE 31 D, 370, 381 or 383 adopted
↓
385 Franco, Vlasto Falls if CONS 2, 338, 364, ITRE 31 D or 370 adopted
↓Art 2 – point 2 –point c – point iiiArt 3 – para 4 –subpara 2 – point e – subpara 1 – point iii a (new)
386 Franco, Vlasto Falls if CONS 2, 338, 349, INTA 21, 346, 347, AGRI 34, 348, 352, 350, TRAN 31, ITRE 31 C, 362, 363, 364, ITRE 31 D or 370 adopted
↓
Art 2 – point 2 –point c – point iiiArt 3 – para 4 –subpara 2 – point e – subpara 1 a (new)
387 Pargneaux Falls if CONS 2, 338, 364, ITRE 31 D or 370 adoptedList of categories to be adapted to the result of the votes on 374, 377 and 381
↓
388 Essayah Falls if CONS 2, 338, 364 or ITRE 31 D adoptedDeletion
↓
389 Ayuso Falls if CONS 2, 338, 364, ITRE 31 D or 388 adopted
↓
Art 2 – point 2 –point c – point iiiArt 3 – para 4 –subpara 2 – point e – subpara 2
390 Girling Falls if CONS 2, 338, 364, ITRE 31 D, 388 or 389 adopted, otherwise adopted if 370 adopted
↓
PE516.894v01-00 214/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
DEVE 23 Falls if CONS 2, 338, 364 or ITRE 31 D adoptedList of categories to be adapted to the result of the votes on 374, 377 and 381Compatible with 370, 388, 389 or 390 as addition of "Member States ... action"
↓
392 Pargneaux Falls if CONS 2, 338, 364, ITRE 31 D, 388 or 370 adoptedList of categories to be adapted to the result of the votes on 374, 377 and 381Compatible with 389, 390 or DEVE 23 as addition of "Member States and ...imported waste"
↓
393 Scottà, Rossi Falls if CONS 2, 338, 364, ITRE 31 D, 388 or 392 adoptedList of categories to be adapted to the result of the votes on 374, 377 and 381Compatible with DEVE 23 as addition of "Member States ... their origination"
↓
394 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 2, 338, 364, ITRE 31 D, 388, 392 or 393 adoptedList of categories to be adapted to the result of the votes on 374, 377 and 381Compatible with DEVE 23 as addition of "Member States ... point of origin"
↓
391 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
Falls if CONS 2, 338, 364, ITRE 31 D, 388, 392, 393 or 394 adoptedList of categories to be adapted to the result of the votes on 377 and 381Compatible with 389 or 390 as addition of "The Commission [shall] submit ... which"
↓
AGRI 42 Falls if CONS 2, 338, 364, ITRE 31 D, 388, 392, 393, 394 or 391 adoptedList of categories to be adapted to the result of the votes on 374, 377 and 381Compatible with 389 or 390 as addition of "The Commission shall ... to which"
↓
395 Arsenis, Leinen, Childers
Falls if CONS 2, 338 or 364 adoptedIf 388 adopted, vote as new paragraphCompatible with ITRE 31 D as an additionIf ITRE 31 D or 370 adopted, the words "and the measures ... modified" fallList of categories to be adapted to the result of the votes on 374, 377 and 381
↓
Art 2 – point 2 –point c – point iiiArt 3 – para 4 –subpara 2 – point e – subpara 2 a (new)
TRAN 35 D Falls if CONS 2, 338, 349, INTA 21, 346, 347, AGRI 34, 348, 352, 350, ITRE 31 C, 362, 363, 364 or ITRE 31 D adopted"Advanced biofuels ... transport by 2020"
↓
PV\1001717ES.doc 215/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
396 Girling Falls if CONS 2, 338, 364 or ITRE 31 D adoptedDeletion
↓
397 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
Falls if CONS 2, 338, 364, ITRE 31 D or 396 adopted
↓
TRAN 35 E Falls if CONS 2, 338, 364, ITRE 31 D or 396 adopted"The list of feedstock ... Member States"
↓
Art 2 – point 2 –point c – point iiiArt 3 – para 4 –subpara 2 – point e – subpara 3
398 Franco, Vlasto, Grossetête
Falls if CONS 2, 338, 364, ITRE 31 D or 396 adoptedCompatible with TRAN 35 E as addition of "and take account ... diesel-type fuels"
↓
399 Essayah Falls if CONS 2 or 338 adopted ↓
400 Arsenis, Childers Falls if CONS 8 or 338 adopted ↓
TRAN 35 F Falls if CONS 2, 338, 364, ITRE 31 D, DEVE 23, 392, 393 or 394 adopted"The Commission shall ... in point (e)"
↓
Art 2 – point 2 –point c – point iiiArt 3 – para 4 –subpara 2 – point e – subpara 3 a (new)
401 Pargneaux Falls if CONS 2, 338, 364, ITRE 31 D, 370, 381, DEVE 23, 392, 393, 394 or TRAN 35 F adopted
↓
402 Arsenis, Childers Falls if CONS 6 or 338 adopted ↓
43 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 6, 338 or 402 adopted ↓
Art 2 – point 2 –point c – point iii a (new)Art 3 – para 4 –subpara 2 – point e a (new)
TRAN 32 Falls if CONS 5, 338, 341 or 344 adopted ↓
Art 2 – point 2 –point c a (new)Art 3 – para 4 –subpara 3
AGRI 40 -
Art 2 – point 2 –point c a (new)Art 3 – para 4 –subpara 4
AGRI 41 -
403 Korhola -
404 Takkula, Busoi Falls if 403 adopted -
Art 2 – point 2 –point c a (new)Art 3 – para 4 a (new)
44 Rapporteur If 338 adopted, the words "With a view ...set in paragraph 4" fall
+
Art 2 – point 2 a (new)Art 4 – para 3 a (new)
46 Rapporteur Falls if 44 NOT adopted +36/32/0
PE516.894v01-00 216/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
TRAN 33 Falls if 44 adoptedIf 338 adopted, the words "and may decide ... of [point] (b) [of paragraph 4]" fall
↓Art 2 – point 2 –point c a (new)Art 3 – para 4 a (new)Art 2 – point 2 –point c a (new)Art 3 – para 4 a (new)
ITRE 32 Falls if 44 or TRAN 33 adoptedIf 338 adopted, the words "The energy quantity ... point (b) [of paragraph 4]" fall
↓
Art 2 – point 2 a (new)Art 4 – para 3 a (new)
ITRE 33 Falls if TRAN 33 AND ITRE 32 NOT adopted
↓
Art 2 – point 2 –point c a (new)Art 3 – para 4 a (new)
45 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 5, TRAN 29 or 360 adoptedIf 338 adopted, the words "With a view ...set in paragraph 4" fall
↓
47 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 5 AND 45 NOT adopted +37/31/0
Art 2 – point 2 b (new)Art 4 – para 3 a (new)
ITRE 34 Falls if 338 adopted +
405 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
AGRI 43
Identical -Art 2 – point 3Art 5 – para 5 –second sentence
406 Gardini -
Art 2 – point 4 a (new)Art 15 – para 2 –subpara 4
48 Rapporteur +
407 Arsenis, Leinen, Childers, Thomsen
Falls if 338 or 345 adopted +Art 2 – point 5 –point -a (new)Art 17 – para 1 –subpara 1 –introductory part
INTA 23 +41/27/0
408 KlaßArt 2 – point 5 –point -a (new)Art 17 – para 1 –subpara 2
INTA 24
Fall if CONS 8 adoptedIdenticalDeletion of Article 17(1)(2) of Directive 2009/28/EC
↓
Art 2 – point 5 –point -a (new)Art 17 – para 1 –
409 Wils If adopted, 77 adopted(introduction of Annex IXa)Typo: "Annex X" should read "Annex IXa"
-
PV\1001717ES.doc 217/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
subpara 2 a (new) 49 Rapporteur Falls if 409 adoptedIf adopted, 77 adopted(introduction of Annex IXa)
+
PE516.894v01-00 218/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
410 Scottà, Rossi
DEVE 24
Fall if 407 adoptedIdentical
↓
Art 2 – point 5 –point aArt 17 – para 2
AGRI 44
Art 2 – point 5 –point aArt 17 – para 2 –subpara 1
411 Bánki
Art 2 – point 5 –point aArt 17 – para 2 –subpara 2
416 Bánki
Fall if CONS 7 adoptedVote collectively(AGRI 44 identical to 411 + 416)
↓
Art 2 – point 5 –point aArt 17 – para 2 –subpara 1
413 Wils
Art 2 – point 5 –point aArt 17 – para 2 –subpara 2
415 Wils
Fall if CONS 7 or AGRI 44 adoptedVote collectively
↓
Art 2 – point 5 –point aArt 17 – para 2
TRAN 36 Falls if CONS 7, AGRI 44 or 413 adopted
Split vote (ALDE)
Part 1Without amending "50%" to "60%"
Part 2Amending "50%" to "60%"
↓
Art 2 – point 5 –point aArt 17 – para 2 –subpara 1
414 Panayotov
Art 2 – point 5 –point aArt 17 – para 2 –subpara 2
417 Panayotov
Fall if CONS 7, AGRI 44, 413 or TRAN 36 Part 1 adoptedVote collectivelyCompatible with TRAN 36 Part 2 as amending "2014" to "2015" (twice)
↓
Art 2 – point 5 –point aArt 17 – para 2 –subpara 1
412 Franco, Vlasto Falls if CONS 7, AGRI 44 or TRAN 36 Part 2 adopted
↓
PV\1001717ES.doc 219/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
418 Bánki
419 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
Art 2 – point 5 –point bArt 17 – para 3 –subpara 2
AGRI 45
IdenticalDeletion
-21/47/0
50 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 9 adopted ↓Art 2 – point 5 –point b a (new)Art 17 – para 4 420 Leinen Falls if CONS 9 or 50 adopted ↓
424 Van Brempt, Merkies
+37/31/0
51 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 9 adopted ↓
423 Panayotov Falls if CONS 8 adopted ↓
52 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 8 or 423 adopted ↓
Art 2 – point 5 –point b a (new)Art 17 – para 5 a (new)
INTA 25 Falls if CONS 8, 423 or 52 adopted ↓
Art 2 – point 5 –point b a (new)Art 17 – para 4 a (new)
ITRE 35 -31/36/0
ITRE 36 -Art 2 – point 5 –point b a (new)Art 17 – para 5 a (new)
421 Klaß Falls if ITRE 36 adopted -
Art 2 – point 5 –point b a (new)Art 17 – para 6 –subparas 1 a, 1 b and 1 c (new)
426 Wils Falls if CONS 8 adopted ↓
Art 2 – point 5 –point b a (new)Art 17 – para 5 a (new)
DEVE 25 Falls if CONS 8 or 426 adopted ↓
CONSOLIDATED 10Third parties' legal rightsArt 2 – point 5 – point b a (new)Art 17 – para 4 a (new);Recital 11 a (new)
ALDE, EPP, S&D, GREENS/EFA, GUE/NGL
If adopted, 11, 25, 53, 188-191, ITRE 13, INTA 9, INTA 12, INTA 26, REGI 9, DEVE 12, DEVE 16, DEVE 26 fall
+
PE516.894v01-00 220/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
INTA 12 Falls if CONS 10 adopted ↓
25 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 10 or INTA 12 adopted ↓
Art 1 – point 2 –point b a (new)Art 7b – para 5 a (new)
DEVE 16 Falls if CONS 10, INTA 12 or 25 adopted
↓
INTA 26 Falls if CONS 10 adopted ↓
53 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 10 or INTA 26 adopted ↓
DEVE 26 Falls if CONS 10, INTA 26 or 53 adopted
↓
Art 2 – point 5 –point b a (new)Art 17 – para 5 a (new)
422 Morkunaite-Mikuleniene
-
425 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
TRAN 37
Art 2 – point 5 –point b a (new)Art 17 – para 6
AGRI 46
Identical -
Art 2 – point 5 –point b a (new)Art 17 – para 7 –subpara 2 – first sentence
AGRI 47 -
427 Wils
INTA 27
Identical +Art 2 – point 5 a (new)Art 18 – para 2 a (new)
428 Wils +
Art 2 – point 5 a (new)Art 18 – paras 3 and 3 a (new)
INTA 28 -
Art 2 – point 5 a (new)Art 18 – para 4 –subpara 1
INTA 29 +
Art 2 – point 6Art 18 – para 4 –subpara 2
DEVE 27 +
Art 2 – point 6 a (new)Art 18 – para 4 –subpara 2 a (new)
INTA 30 +
PV\1001717ES.doc 221/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Art 2 – point 6 a (new)Art 18 – para 5
430 Wils -
Art 2 – point 6 b (new)Art 18 – para 6
431 Wils -
432 Wils -
INTA 31 Falls if 432 adopted +
433 Leinen Falls if CONS 8 adopted ↓
Art 2 – point 6 c (new)Art 18 – para 9 a (new)
54 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 8 or 433 adopted ↓
434 Eickhout
DEVE 28
Identical +37/31/0
55 Rapporteur Falls if 434 adoptedIf adopted, 69 adopted
↓
Art 2 – point 7 –point -a (new)Art 19 – para 1
435 Arsenis, Jørgensen, Childers
Falls if 434 or 55 adopted ↓
436 Delvaux Falls if 434, 55 or 435 adopted ↓Art 2 – point 7 –point -a (new)Art 19 – para 1 –point a
437 Delvaux, Jordan
Art 2 – point 7 –point -a (new)Art 19 – para 1 –subpara 1 a (new)
438 Delvaux, Jordan
Falls if 434, 55 or 435 adoptedVote collectively437 falls if 436 adopted
↓
Art 2 – point 7 –point -a (new)Art 19 – para 1 a (new)
56 Rapporteur +
439 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
Art 2 – point 7 –point bArt 19 – para 5 –second sentence
AGRI 49
IdenticalDeletion
-
440 Bánki
441 Franco
Art 2 – point 7 –point cArt 19 – para 6
442 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
Fall if COMP 3 adoptedIdenticalDeletion
↓
PE516.894v01-00 222/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
443 Girling
AGRI 50
PV\1001717ES.doc 223/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
444 Ayuso
ITRE 37
Fall if COMP 3 or 440 adoptedIdenticalDeletion of Article 19(6) of Directive 2009/28/EC
↓
445 Klaß Falls if COMP 3, 440 or 444 adopted ↓
57 Rapporteur Falls if 440 or 444 adopted +37/31/0
Art 2 – point 7 –point c a (new)Art 19 – para 6 –subpara 1 a (new)
58 Rapporteur Falls if 440 or 444 adopted +
59 Rapporteur -31/38/0
446 Arsenis, Childers Falls if 59 adopted -
Art 2 – point 7 –point c b (new)Art 19 – para 6 a (new)
60 Rapporteur Falls if 59 AND 446 NOT adopted ↓
447 Franco
448 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
Art 2 – point 7 –point dArt 19 – para 7 –subpara 1
AGRI 51
IdenticalDeletion
-
449 Ayuso
TRAN 38
Identical -
ITRE 38 Falls if COMP 3 adopted ↓
450 Ayuso Falls if COMP 3 or ITRE 38 adopted ↓
Art 2 – point 7 –point e a (new)Art 19 – para 8 a (new)
TRAN 39 Falls if COMP 3, ITRE 38 or 450 adopted
↓
451 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
Art 2 – point 8Art 21
AGRI 52
-31/36/0
PE516.894v01-00 224/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
452 BánkiArt 2 – point 8 a (new)Art 21 a (new) AGRI 53
Fall if COMP 3, 55, 58, 59, 60, 434, 435, 438, 445 or 446 adopted, or if 440 NOT adoptedIdenticalIf adopted, 453, 511 AND 519 adopted(deletion of Annex VIII and introduction of Annex VIIIa)Typo: "Annex VIII" should read "Annex VIIIa"
↓
311 BánkiArt 2 – point 1 a (new)Art 2 – point p a (new)
AGRI 29
Fall if COMP 3 adopted or 452 NOT adoptedIdenticalTypo: "Annex VIII" should read "Annex VIIIa"
↓
429 BánkiArt 2 – point 6Art 18 – para 4 –subpara 2 AGRI 48
Fall if COMP 3 adopted or 452 NOT adoptedIdentical
↓
453 Reimers
454 Ayuso, Arias Echeverría
ITRE 39
AGRI 54
Fall if COMP 3 adoptedAdopted if 452 adoptedIdenticalDeletion
↓
455 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
Falls if COMP 3 or 453 adoptedDeletion of Article 22(2) of Directive 2009/28/EC
↓
Art 2 – point 9Art 22 – para 2
INTA 32 Falls if COMP 3, 453 or 455 adopted ↓
Art 2 – point 9 a (new)Art 23 – para 8 a (new)
61 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 8 adopted ↓
Art 2 – point 11Art 25b
456 Franco Adopted if 338 (or 364), ITRE 31 D, 405, 418, 439, 440 AND 447 adopted AND 54, 56, 313 AND 449 NOT adopted, falls otherwiseDeletion
No vote
↓
TRAN 40 Falls if 456 adoptedVote only on "shall be ... each period"
-Art 2 – point 11Art 25b – para 2
457 Girling Falls if 456 or TRAN 40 adoptedVote only on "shall be ... each period"
+
PV\1001717ES.doc 225/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
458 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
Falls if 456, TRAN 40 or 457 adoptedVote only on "shall be ... this period"
↓
459 Scottà, Rossi
AGRI 55
Falls if 456, TRAN 40, 457 or 458 adoptedIdenticalVote only on "shall be ... this Directive]"
↓
Art 2 – point 11Art 25b – para 3
TRAN 41 Falls if 456 adoptedVote only on "The decision ... in force"
-
62 RapporteurArt 2 – point 11Art 25b
ITRE 40Art 2 – point 11Art 25b – para 2
460 Ayuso
461 Ayuso
462 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
463 Girling
Art 2 – point 11Art 25b – para 3
464 Scottà, Rossi
465 Ayuso
466 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
467 Scottà, Rossi
Art 2 – point 11Art 25b – para 5
TRAN 42
List of provisions conferring delegated powers to be adapted to the result of previous votes on Articles 2, 3(4), 5(5), 17(3), 18(9a), 19(1a), 19(5), 19(6), 19(7) and 19(8)
No vote
Articles 3-5COMPROMISE 11Review clauseArt 3;Recital 20
ALDE, EPP, S&D, GREENS/EFA, ECR, GUE/NGL
If adopted, 15, 63, 468-479; 216-223ITRE 20, ITRE 41, AGRI 17, AGRI 56, REGI 10, REGI 16, TRAN 16, TRAN 43 fall
+
AGRI 56 Falls if COMP 11 adoptedDeletion
↓Art 3
468 Wils Falls if COMP 11 or AGRI 56 adopted ↓
PE516.894v01-00 226/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
ITRE 41 Falls if COMP 11, AGRI 56 or 468 adoptedIf 239, ITRE 22 AND 244 NOT adopted, the words "the report shall ... from September 2016" fall
↓
469 Eickhout, Jørgensen Falls if COMP 11, AGRI 56, 468 or ITRE 41 adopted
↓
471 Ayuso Falls if COMP 11, AGRI 56, 468 or ITRE 41 adoptedCompatible with 469 as deletion of "The report shall ... Directive 2009/28/EC"
↓
63 Rapporteur
470 Arsenis, Childers
Fall if COMP 11, AGRI 56, 468, ITRE 41, 469 or 471 adoptedIdentical
↓
473 Scottà, Rossi Falls if COMP 11, AGRI 56, 468, ITRE 41, 469, or 471 adopted, otherwise adopted if 26, 268, 269, 270, 272, 52, 434, 435, 436 or 438 adoptedCompatible with 63 as addition of "The report shall ... wood availability"
↓
TRAN 43 Falls if COMP 11, AGRI 56 or 468 adoptedCompatible with ITRE 41, 469, 471, 63 or 473 as addition of "Also, having regard ...food and feed", and with 471, 63 or 473 also as amending "The Commission ...greenhouse gas emissions"
↓
475 Schnellhardt Falls if COMP 11, AGRI 56, 468, ITRE 41 or 469 adoptedCompatible with 471, 63 or 473 as addition of "obtained ... scientific method", with 473 also as addition of "The application ... plants", and with with 63 or TRAN 43 as amending "2017" to "2020"
↓
472 Auconie Falls if COMP 11, AGRI 56, 468, ITRE 41, 471 or 63 adoptedCompatible with 473 as deletion of "from non-land ... Directive 2009/28/EC"
↓
474 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
Falls if COMP 11, AGRI 56, 468 or 469 adoptedFalls if 338 or 364 adopted AND TRAN 43 adoptedCompatible with ITRE 41, 471, 63, 473, 475 or 472 as addition of "In accordance with ... biofuels and bioliquids"If 338 AND 364 NOT adopted, compatible with TRAN 43, 63, 473 or 475 also as addition of "and (e)"
↓
PV\1001717ES.doc 227/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
476 Girling Falls if COMP 11, AGRI 56, 468, ITRE 41, 469, 471, 474 or 475 adopted
↓
477 Scottà, Rossi Falls if COMP 11, AGRI 56, 468, ITRE 41, 471, 472 or 474 adopted
↓
478 Franco, Vlasto, Grossetête
Falls if COMP 11, AGRI 56, 468, 469, TRAN 43 or 474 adopted
↓
REGI 16 Falls if COMP 11, AGRI 56, 468 or 469 adoptedCompatible with 474 as addition of "The report shall also ... Union's regions"
↓
479 Franco Falls if COMP 11, AGRI 56, 468, ITRE 41, 469 or 473 adopted
↓
Art 3 – para 1 a (new)
480 Arsenis, Jørgensen, Merkies, Childers, Pirillo, Thomsen
+37/32/0
Art 4 – para 1 –subpara 1
481 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
-
Art 4 – para 2 AGRI 57 Deletion -
Art 5 482 Audy -
AnnexesAnnex I – Amendments to the Annexes of Directive 98/70/EC (Fuel Quality Directive)
483 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
Annex I
ITRE 42
Fall if COMP 3, 21, 26, 29, 30, 31, 229, 235, 248, 268, 269, 272 or 283 adoptedFalls if 239, 244 AND ITRE 22 NOT adoptedFalls if 276 NOT adoptedIdenticalDeletion
↓
Annex I –introductory part
484 Panayotov Falls if 483 adopted -
64 Rapporteur Adopted if 26 adopted, falls otherwise No
vote↓
485 Delvaux, Jordan Adopted if 270 or 272 adopted, falls otherwise
No vote
486 Arsenis, Jørgensen, Childers, Thomsen
Adopted if 269 adopted, falls otherwise No vote
Annex I – point 1 –point -a (new)Annex IV – part C – point 1
487 Eickhout, Wils Adopted if 268 adopted, falls otherwise No vote
PE516.894v01-00 228/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
488 Reimers
489 Ayuso
AGRI 58
Fall if 483 adoptedIdenticalDeletion
-Annex I – point 1Annex IV – part C – points 7, 8, 9
490 Panayotov Falls if 483 or 488 adopted -
492 Delvaux Falls if 483 adoptedFalls if 26, 268, 269, 270 AND 272 NOT adopted
-
65 Rapporteur
493 Arsenis, Jørgensen, Childers, Thomsen
Fall if 483 or 492 adoptedFalls if 26, 268, 269, 270 AND 272 NOT adoptedIdentical
+37/32/0
66 Rapporteur
Annex I – point 1 –point b a (new)Annex IV – part C – point 19 a (new)
491 Wils
Fall if 483 adoptedFalls if 26, 268, 269, 270 AND 272 NOT adoptedIdenticalIf 270 or 271 adopted, "el" is amended to "edl"
+37/32/0
494 Bánki
495 Ayuso
Annex I – point 2Annex V
AGRI 59
Fall if COMP 3, 21, 26, 29, 30, 31, 229, 235, 248, 268, 269, 272, 283 or 483 adopted, or if 239, 244 AND ITRE 22 NOT adopted, or if 276 NOT adopted, otherwise adoptedIdenticalDeletion
No vote
↓
Annex I – point 2Annex V – Part A
496 Klaß Falls if 483 or 494 adopted -24/45/0
497 EickhoutAnnex I – point 2Annex V – part A –table – row 4 a (new)
DEVE 29
Falls if CONS 10, 483 or 494 or 496 adoptedIdentical
↓
Annex I – point 2Annex V – part B –point a
498 Klaß Falls if 483 or 494 adoptedFalls if 496 NOT adopted
↓
67 RapporteurAnnex I – point 2Annex V – part B –point b DEVE 30
Fall if 483 or 494 adoptedIdentical
-
Annex I – point 2Annex V – part B –point b a (new)
499 Leinen Falls if 483 or 494 adopted +48/18/1
PV\1001717ES.doc 229/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Annex I – point 2 a (new)Annex V a (new)
68 Rapporteur Adopted if 248 or 21 adopted, falls otherwise
No
vote+
PE516.894v01-00 230/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Annex II – Amendments to the Annexes of Directive 2009/28/EC (Renewable Energy Directive)69 Rapporteur Adopted if 55 adopted, falls otherwise
No vote
↓500 Delvaux, Jordan Adopted if 436 or 438 adopted, falls
otherwise
No vote
↓501 Arsenis, Jørgensen,
Childers, ThomsenAdopted if 435 adopted, falls otherwise
No vote
↓
Annex II – point 1 – point -a (new)Annex V – part C –point 1
502 Eickhout, Wils Adopted if 434 adopted, falls otherwise No vote
+503 Reimers
504 Ayuso, Arias Echeverría
505 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
ITRE 43
AGRI 60
IdenticalDeletion
-Annex II – point 1Annex V – part C –points 7, 8, 9
506 Panayotov Falls if 503 adopted -
507 PakarinenAnnex II – point 1 – point b a (new)Annex V – part C –point 11 REGI 17
Identical -
Annex II – point 1 – point b a (new)Annex V – part C –point 16
508 Essayah -
509 Delvaux Falls if 55, 434, 435, 436 AND 438 NOT adopted
-31/38/0
70 Rapporteur
Annex II – point 1 – point b a (new)Annex V – part C –point 19 a (new)
510 Arsenis, Jørgensen, Childers, Thomsen
Fall if 509 adoptedFall if 55, 434, 435, 436 AND 438 NOT adoptedIdentical
+39/32/0
PV\1001717ES.doc 231/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
71 Rapporteur Fall if 55, 434, 435, 436 AND 438 NOT adoptedIf 270 or 271 adopted, "el" is amended to "edl"
+
PE516.894v01-00 232/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
511 Reimers
512 Bánki
513 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
514 Ayuso, Arias Echeverría
ITRE 44
Annex II – point 2Annex VIII
AGRI 61
Fall if COMP 3, 55, 58, 59, 60, 434, 435, 438, 445 or 446 adopted, or if 440 NOT adopted, or if 453, 455 AND INTA 32 NOT adopted, otherwise adoptedIdenticalDeletion
No
vote↓
Annex II – point 2Annex VIII – Part A
515 Klaß Falls if 511 adopted -26/45/0
516 EickhoutAnnex II – point 2Annex VIII – part A – table – row 4 a (new)
DEVE 31
Fall if CONS 10, 511 or 515 adoptedIdentical
↓
Annex II – point 2Annex VIII – part B – point a
517 Klaß Falls if 511 adoptedFalls if 515 NOT adopted
↓
72 Rapporteur
DEVE 32
Annex II – point 2Annex VIII – part B – point b
INTA 33
Fall if 511 adoptedIdentical
-
Annex II – point 2Annex VIII – part B – point b a (new)
518 Leinen Falls if 511 adopted +
519 Bánki
AGRI 62
Falls if COMP 3 adopted or if 452 NOT adopted, otherwise adoptedIdentical
No vote
Annex II – point 2 a (new)Annex VIII a (new)
520 Westlund, Ulvskog Withdrawn W
PV\1001717ES.doc 233/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
521 Weisgerber
522 Scottà, Rossi
523 Bánki
524 Auconie
525 Westlund, Ulvskog
526 Eickhout, Wils
AGRI 63
Falls if CONS 2, 313, 314, 327, 340, 347, 348, 349, 352, 386, 393, 394, 400 or ITRE 22 adopted, or if 338, 364, ITRE 31 D AND 370 NOT adopted, or if 396 NOT adopted, otherwise adopted
INTA 34 Falls if CONS 2, 521 adoptedFalls if 338, 364, ITRE 31 D AND 370 NOT adoptedFalls if INTA 21 NOT adopted
528 Klaß Falls if CONS 2, 521 or INTA 34 adoptedFalls if 338, 364, ITRE 31 D AND 370 NOT adoptedFalls if 346, 347, AGRI 34 AND 348 NOT adopted
527 Weisgerber Falls if CONS 2, 521, INTA 34 or 528 adoptedFalls if 338, 364, ITRE 31 D, 370 NOT adoptedFalls if 346, 347, AGRI 34 AND 348 NOT adopted
ITRE 45 Falls if CONS 2, 521, INTA 34, 528 or 527 adoptedFalls if 338, 364, ITRE 31 D AND 370 NOT adopted
TRAN 44 Falls if CONS 2, 521, INTA 34, 528, 527, ITRE 45, 338, 364, ITRE 31 D or 370 adoptedFalls if 375 or TRAN 35 B NOT adopted
Annex II – point 3Annex IX
REGI 18 Falls if CONS 2, 521, INTA 34, 528, 527, ITRE 45, TRAN 44, 338, 364, ITRE 31 D or 370 adoptedFalls if REGI 13 AND 375 NOT adoptedFalls if REGI 14 AND 378 NOT adopted
Annex II – point 3Annex IX – part A – title
533 Takkula, Busoi Falls if CONS 2, 521, INTA 34, 528, 527, ITRE 45, TRAN 44 or REGI 18 adoptedFalls if 338, 364, ITRE 31 D or 370 NOT adopted
PE516.894v01-00 234/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
532 Ayuso Falls if CONS 2, 521, INTA 34, 528, 527, ITRE 45, TRAN 44, REGI 18 or 533 adoptedFalls if 338, 364, ITRE 31 D or 370 NOT adopted
534 Girling Falls if CONS 2, 521, INTA 34, 528, 527, ITRE 45, TRAN 44, REGI 18, 533 or 532 adoptedFalls if 338, 364, ITRE 31 D or 370 NOT adopted
535 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
Falls if CONS 2, 521, INTA 34, 528, 527, ITRE 45, TRAN 44, REGI 18, 533, 532 or 534 adoptedFalls if 338, 364, ITRE 31 D or 370 NOT adopted
536 Arsenis, Childers, Pirillo
Falls if CONS 2, 521, ITRE 45, 533, 532 or 534 adopted
Annex II – point 3Annex IX – part A
530 Fjellner Falls if CONS 2 or 521 adopted
Annex II – point 3Annex IX – part A – point a
537 Takkula, Busoi Falls if CONS 2, 521 or 528 adopted
538 RapporteurAnnex II – point 3Annex IX – part A – point a a (new) 539 Girling, Klaß,
Davies
Fall if CONS 2, 521 or 530 adoptedIdentical
540 Korhola
541 Merkies
Falls if CONS 2, 521, 528, 527 or REGI 18 adoptedIdentical
Annex II – point 3Annex IX – part A – point b
542 Pakarinen, Sarvamaa, Essayah, Takkula, Johansson, Jäätteenmäki
Falls if CONS 2, 521, 528, 527 or REGI 18 adopted
543 Girling, Klaß, Davies
Falls if CONS 2, 521, 530, ITRE 45 or REGI 18 adopted
544 Scottà, Rossi Falls if CONS 2, 521, 530, ITRE 45 or REGI 18 adopted
545 Essayah Falls if CONS 2, 521, 530, ITRE 45 or REGI 18adopted
Annex II – point 3Annex IX – part A – point c
546 Korhola Falls if CONS 2, 521, 530, ITRE 45, REGI 18 or 545 adopted
PV\1001717ES.doc 235/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
547 Pakarinen, Sarvamaa, Takkula, Johansson, Jäätteenmäki
Falls if CONS 2, 521, 530, ITRE 45, REGI 18 or 545 adopted
548 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
Falls if CONS 2, 521, 530, ITRE 45 or REGI 18 adopted
531 A
Franco, Vlasto Falls if CONS 2, 521, TRAN 44 or 530 adoptedDeletion of "(d) Straw"
Annex II – point 3Annex IX – Part A – point d
549 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
Falls if CONS 2, 521, TRAN 44, 530 or 531 A adopted
Annex II – point 3Annex IX – part A – point e
550 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
Falls if CONS 2, 521, 530 adopted
73 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 2, 521, 530 adopted
551 Arsenis, Childers
552 Wils
531 B
Franco, Vlasto
Fall if CONS 2, 521, TRAN 44 or 530 adoptedIdenticalDeletion
"(f) Palm oil ... bunches"
Annex II – point 3Annex IX – part A – point f
553 Takkula, Busoi Falls if CONS 2, 521, TRAN 44, 530 or 551 adopted
554 Essayah Withdrawn(falls if CONS 2, 521, TRAN 44, 530, ITRE 45 or REGI 18 adopted)
555 Korhola Falls if CONS 2, 521, 530, ITRE 45 or REGI 18 adopted(falls if 554 adopted)
Annex II – point 3Annex IX – part A – point g
556 Pakarinen, Sarvamaa, Takkula, Johansson, Jäätteenmäki
Falls if CONS 2, 521, 530, ITRE 45, REGI 18 or 555 adopted(falls if 554 adopted)
Annex II – point 3Annex IX – Part A – points i, k, l, m
531 C
Franco, Vlasto Falls if CONS 2, 521, TRAN 44 or 530 adoptedPoints (i), (k), (l) and (m) ("Bagasse ...cobs")
PE516.894v01-00 236/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Annex II – point 3Annex IX – part A – point i
557 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
Falls if CONS 2, 521, TRAN 44, 530 or 531 C adoptedDeletion
Annex II – point 3Annex IX – part A – point j
558 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
Falls if CONS 2, 521, 530 or 531 C adoptedFalls if 557 NOT adopted
Annex II – point 3Annex IX – part A – point l
559 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
Falls if CONS 2, 521, TRAN 44, 530 or 531 C adopted
Annex II – point 3Annex IX – part A – point m
560 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
Falls if CONS 2, 521, TRAN 44, 530 or 531 C adoptedDeletion
74 Rapporteur
561 Arsenis, Childers
562 Wils
531 D
Franco, Vlasto
Fall if CONS 2, 521, TRAN 44, 530, ITRE 45 or REGI 18 adoptedIdenticalDeletion
"(n) Bark branches ... cutter shavings"563 Scottà, Rossi Falls if CONS 2, 521, 530, ITRE 45,
REGI 18 or 74 adopted564 Pakarinen,
Sarvamaa, Essayah, Takkula, Johansson, Jäätteenmäki
Falls if CONS 2, 521, 530, ITRE 45, REGI 18 or 74 adopted
565 Korhola Falls if CONS 2, 521, 530, ITRE 45, REGI 18 or 74 adopted
Annex II – point 3Annex IX – part A – point n
566 Takkula, Busoi Falls if CONS 2, 521, 530, ITRE 45, REGI 18 or 74 adopted
567 Essayah Falls if CONS 2, 521, 530 adopted
568 Essayah Falls if CONS 2, 521, 530 adopted
569 Essayah Falls if CONS 2, 521, 530 adopted
570 Essayah Falls if CONS 2, 521, 530 adopted
571 Ayuso
572 Franco, De Veyrac
Annex II – point 3Annex IX – part A – point n a (new)
573 Takkula, Busoi
Fall if CONS 2, 521, TRAN 44, 530, ITRE 45 adoptedIdentical
PV\1001717ES.doc 237/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
574 Essayah
575 Ayuso
576 Takkula, Busoi
577 Essayah
Fall if CONS 2, 521, TRAN 44, 530, ITRE 45 adoptedIdentical
586 Takkula, Busoi Falls if CONS 2, 521, TRAN 44, 530, ITRE 45 or 575 adopted
578 Ayuso
579 Takkula, Busoi
580 Essayah
Falls if CONS 2, 521, TRAN 44, 530, ITRE 45 or REGI 18 adoptedIdentical
581 Ayuso
582 Pakarinen, Sarvamaa, Takkula, Johansson, Jäätteenmäki
583 Takkula, Busoi
584 Essayah
Fall if CONS 2, 521, TRAN 44, 530, ITRE 45 or REGI 18 adoptedIdentical
585 Takkula, Busoi Falls if CONS 2, 521, 530, ITRE 45 adopted
587 Takkula, Busoi Falls if CONS 2, 521, 530, ITRE 45 adopted
Annex II – point 3Annex IX – part A – para 1 a (new)
588 Panayotov Falls if CONS 2 or 521 adopted
589 Ayuso
590 Essayah
591 Takkula, Busoi
592 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
Falls if CONS 2, 521, 528, 527, ITRE 45, INTA 21, TRAN 44 or REGI 18 adoptedFalls if 338, 364, ITRE 31 D, 370, 377, DEVE 22 AND 379 NOT adoptedDeletion
Annex II – point 3Annex IX – part B – title
593 Girling Falls if CONS 2, 521, 528, 527, ITRE 45, INTA 21, TRAN 44, REGI 18 or 589 adopted
PE516.894v01-00 238/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
594 Arsenis, Childers, Pirillo
Falls if CONS 2, 521, 528, 527, ITRE 45, INTA 21, TRAN 44, REGI 18 or 589 adopted
595 Essayah
596 Franco, De Veyrac
597 Ayuso
Annex II – point 3Annex IX – part B – point a
598 Takkula, Busoi
Fall if CONS 2, 521, ITRE 45 or TRAN 44 adopted, otherwise adopted if 571 adoptedIdenticalDeletion
Annex II – point 3Annex IX – part B – point a a (new)
599 Arsenis, Childers Falls if CONS 2, 521 or 338 adoptedFalls if 561 NOT adopted
600 Essayah
601 Ayuso
Annex II – point 3Annex IX – part B – point b
602 Takkula, Busoi
Fall if CONS 2, 521, ITRE 45 or TRAN 44 adopted, otherwise adopted if 575 or 586 adoptedIdenticalDeletion
603 Fjellner
604 Essayah
605 Franco
606 Arsenis, Childers
607 Ayuso
608 Takkula, Busoi
Fall if CONS 2, 521, TRAN 44 or REGI 18 adopted, otherwise adopted if 578 adoptedIdenticalDeletion
609 Korhola Falls if CONS 2, 521, TRAN 44, REGI 18 or 603 adopted
610 De Lange Falls if CONS 2, 521, TRAN 44, REGI 18 or 603 adopted
Annex II – point 3Annex IX – part B – point c
611 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
Falls if CONS 2, 521, TRAN 44, REGI 18 or 603 adopted
612 Essayah
613 Franco
614 Arsenis, Childers
Annex II – point 3Annex IX – part B – point d
615 Ayuso
Fall if CONS 2, 521, TRAN 44 or REGI 18 adopted, otherwise adopted if 581 adoptedIdenticalDeletion
PV\1001717ES.doc 239/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
616 Takkula, Busoi
75 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 2, 521, TRAN 44, REGI 18 or 612 adopted
617 Scottà, Rossi Falls if CONS 2, 521, TRAN 44, REGI 18 or 612 adopted
76 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 2 or 521 adopted
618 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
Falls if CONS 2 or 521 adopted
Annex II – point 3Annex IX – part B – point d a (new)
619 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
Falls if CONS 2 or 521 adopted
Annex II – point 3Annex IX – para -1 (new)
529 Pargneaux Falls if CONS 2, 521, 338, 364, ITRE 31 D or 370 adopted
Annex II – point 3Annex IX – part B a (new)
TRAN 45 Falls if CONS 2, 521, 338, 364, ITRE 31 D, 370 or 529 adopted
620 Eickhout, Wils Falls if CONS 8, 521, 338, 364, ITRE 31 D, 370 or 529 adopted
Annex II – point 3 a (new)Annex IX a (new) 77 Rapporteur Adopted if 409 or 49 adopted, falls
otherwiseCitation 1 a (new) INTA 1
78 Eickhout, Wils Falls if CONS 1 adoptedFalls if 332 NOT adopted
TRAN 1
ITRE 1 Falls if TRAN 1 adopted
79 Scottà, Rossi Falls if TRAN 1 or ITRE 1 adopted
80 Auconie
81 Franco, Vlasto, Grossetête
Falls if 78, TRAN 1, ITRE 1 or 80 adopted
Recital 1
82 Reimers
DEVE 1 Falls if TRAN 1 or ITRE 1 adoptedRecital 1 a (new)
83 Klaß
PE516.894v01-00 240/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
AGRI 1
AGRI 2
85 Eickhout, Wils If 237 NOT adopted, the words "In order to ensure ... Union in 2025" fall
84 Gardini Falls if 338, 332, 333 or 85 adopted
Recital 2
DEVE 2 Falls if 85 adopted
86 Korhola, Essayah, Sarvamaa
87 Eickhout, Wils, Girling
Recital 3
AGRI 3
Identical
88 RapporteurRecital 3 a (new)
90 Wils
Recital 4 a (new) DEVE 3 Falls if 90 adopted
91 Bánki
92 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
ITRE 2
Fall if 91 adoptedIdentical
94 Franco Falls if 91 or 92 adopted
1 Rapporteur Compatible with 91 or 92 as addition of "That demand may be ... soil pollution" and "as well as ... biodiversity value"
AGRI 4 Falls if 1 adopted
Recital 4
93 Arsenis, Leinen, Jørgensen, Merkies, Childers
Compatible with 91 or 92 as addition of "which may result ... ecosystem services" and "as well as ... biodiversity"Compatible with 1 as addition of "and loss of critical ecosystem services"
PV\1001717ES.doc 241/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
96 Pakarinen, Essayah, Girling, Takkula, Johansson, Sarvamaa,
95 Westlund, Ulvskog
REGI 1
97 Bánki
AGRI 6
Fall if COMP 3 adopted or 452 NOT adoptedIdentical
Recital 4 a (new)
98 Panayotov
Recital 3 a (new) 89 Arsenis, Leinen, Jørgensen, Merkies, Childers, Thomsen
Falls if 98 adopted
2 Rapporteur
TRAN 2
Fall if 98 or 89 adoptedIdentical
ITRE 4 Fall if 98, 89 or 2 adopted
99 De Lange
AGRI 5 Falls if COMP 3, 26, 268, 269, 270, 272, 52, 434, 435, 436 or 438 adopted
Recital 4 a (new)
ITRE 3
100 Klaß
101 Hibner, Sonik, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
102 Weisgerber
103 Bánki
104 Reimers
Recital 5
AGRI 7
IdenticalDeletion
PE516.894v01-00 242/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
108 Arsenis, Merkies,Childers
Falls if 100 adoptedFalls if 26, 268, 269, 270, 272, 55, 434, 435, 436 AND 438 NOT adopted AND 338, 345, AGRI 36, 349, INTA 21, 346, 347, AGRI 34, 348, 352, 350, TRAN 31, ITRE 31 C, 353, 354, 355, 356 or 357 adoptedIf 26, 268, 269, 270, 272, 55, 434, 435, 436 AND 438 NOT adopted, the words "as well as ... Directive 98/70/EC" fallIf CONS 1, 338, 345, AGRI 36, 349, INTA 21, 346, 347, AGRI 34, 348, 352, 350, TRAN 31, ITRE 31 C, 353, 354, 355, 356 or 357 adopted, the words "set up the 5% ... as well as" fall
DEVE 4 Falls if 100 adoptedCompatible with 108 as addition of "and may have a significant … Union", "and such … impact" and "focus … on land"
109 Scottà, Rossi Falls if 100 or 108 adoptedCompatible with DEVE 4 as amending "could" to "will"
110 Eickhout Falls if 100 or DEVE 4 adoptedCompatible with 108 or 109 as addition of "Indirect land-use … emission targets"
3 Rapporteur Falls if 100, DEVE 4, 109 or 110 adopted
TRAN 3 Falls if 100 adoptedCompatible with 108, DEVE 4, 109, 110 or 3 as addition of "land-based biofuels ...and therefore" and "Furthermore ... land use changes"
105 Girling Falls if 100 adoptedCompatible with 108, DEVE 4, 109, 110 or 3 as addition of "it is appropriate for the Commission … indirect land use change"Compatible with TRAN 3 as amending "it is likely … are significant" to "there is a possible risk" … "are significant"
ITRE 5 Falls if 100, 108, DEVE 4, 109, 110, 3 or TRAN 3 adopted
106 Ayuso Falls if 100, 108, DEVE 4, 109, 110, 3, TRAN 3, 105 or ITRE 5 adopted
107 Schnellhardt Falls if 100, 108, DEVE 4, 109, 110, 3, TRAN 3, 105, ITRE 5 or 106 adopted
111 Franco Falls if 100 adoptedCompatible with TRAN 3 or ITRE 5 as addition of "such as … Member States"
PV\1001717ES.doc 243/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
112 Grossetête, Vlasto Falls if 100 or 111 adoptedCompatible with TRAN 3 or ITRE 5 as addition of "such as … Member States"
113 Auconie Falls if 100, TRAN 3, ITRE 5, 111 or 112 adopted
114 Morkunaite-Mikuleniene
Falls if 100 adopted
REGI 2 Falls if 100 adoptedIf 338, 332 or 333 adopted, the words "and to 10% in the transport sector" fallIf DEVE 4 or 109 adopted, the words "Such practices … social impact" fall
115 Scottà, Rossi Falls if CONS 1 adoptedFalls if 338 NOT adopted
116 Korhola, Essayah, Sarvamaa
DEVE 5 Compatible with DEVE 4, 109 or REGI 2 as addition of "in particular women"
Recital 5 a (new)
AGRI 8 Falls if CONS 1 adoptedFalls if 338, 345, 349, INTA 21, 346, 347, AGRI 34, 348, 352, 350, TRAN 31 AND ITRE 31 C NOT adopted
117 Girling, Klaß, Davies
Falls if CONS 1 adopted
AGRI 9 Falls if CONS 1 or 117 adopted
124 Scottà, Rossi Falls if CONS 1, 117 or AGRI 9 adopted
TRAN 4 Falls if 117, AGRI 9 or 124 adoptedFalls if 352 AND TRAN 31 NOT adoptedFalls if TRAN 31 AND ITRE 31 C NOT adopted
119 Bánki Falls if CONS 1, 117, AGRI 9, 124 or TRAN 4 adoptedFalls if 349, 346, 347, AGRI 34, 348 and 350 NOT adopted
118 Weisgerber Falls if CONS 1, 117, AGRI 9, 124, TRAN 4 or 119 adoptedFalls if 349, 346, 347, AGRI 34, 348 and 350 NOT adopted
Recital 6
120 Klaß Falls if CONS 1, 117, AGRI 9, 124, TRAN 4, 119 or 118 adoptedFalls if 349, 346, 347, AGRI 34, 348 and 350 NOT adopted
PE516.894v01-00 244/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
123 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
Falls if CONS 1, 117, AGRI 9, 124, TRAN 4, 119, 118 or 120 adoptedFalls if 349, 346, 347, AGRI 34, 348 and 350 NOT adopted
121 Reimers Falls if CONS 1, 117, AGRI 9, 124, TRAN 4, 119, 118, 120 or 123 adoptedFalls if 349, 346, 347, AGRI 34, 348 and 350 NOT adopted
122 Merkies, Thomsen, Jørgensen
Falls if CONS 1, 117, AGRI 9, 124, TRAN 4, 119, 118, 120, 123 or 121 adoptedFalls if 352, TRAN 31, 362 AND 363 NOT adopted
INTA 2 Falls if CONS 1, 117, AGRI 9, 124, TRAN 4, 119, 118, 120, 123, 121 or 122 adoptedFalls if INTA 21 AND ITRE 31 C NOT adopted
ITRE 6 Falls if CONS 1, 117, AGRI 9, 124, TRAN 4, 119, 118, 120, 123, 121, 122 or INTA 2 adoptedFalls if 349, INTA 21, 346, 347, AGRI 34, 348, 352, 350, TRAN 31, ITRE 31 C, 362 AND 363 NOT adopted
125 Ayuso Falls if CONS 1, 117, AGRI 9, 124, TRAN 4, 119, 118, 120, 123, 121, 122, INTA 2 or ITRE 6 adoptedFalls if 349, INTA 21, 346, 347, AGRI 34, 348, 352, 350, TRAN 31, ITRE 31 C, 362 AND 363 NOT adopted
126 Auconie Falls if CONS 1, 117, AGRI 9, 124, TRAN 4, 119, 118, 120, 123, 121, 122, INTA 2, ITRE 6 or 125 adoptedFalls if 349, INTA 21, 346, 347, AGRI 34, 348, 352, 350, TRAN 31, ITRE 31 C, 362 AND 363 NOT adopted
128 Franco, Vlasto Falls if CONS 1, 117, AGRI 9, 124, TRAN 4, 119, 118, 120, 123, 121, 122, INTA 2, ITRE 6, 125 or 126 adoptedFalls if 338, 349, INTA 21, 346, 347, AGRI 34, 348, 352, 350, TRAN 31, ITRE 31 C, 353, 354, 355, 356 or 357 adopted
129 Arsenis, Merkies, Childers
Falls if CONS 1, 117, AGRI 9, 124, TRAN 4, 119, 118, 120, 123, INTA 2, ITRE 6, 125 or 128 adopted
4 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 1, 117, AGRI 9, 124, TRAN 4, 119, 118, 123, 125 or 129 adopted
PV\1001717ES.doc 245/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
127 Scottà, Rossi Falls if CONS 1 adoptedCompatible with 117, AGRI 9, 124, TRAN 4, 119, 118, 120, 123 or 129 as amending "low" to "no" and with 117, AGRI 9, TRAN 4, 119, 118, 120, 123 or 129 also as addition of "After prior … sustainability"
DEVE 6 Falls if CONS 1 or 127 adoptedCompatible with 117, AGRI 9, 124, TRAN 4, 119, 118, 120, 123 or 129 as amending "low" to "no"
REGI 3 Falls if CONS 1 adoptedCompatible with 117, AGRI 9, 119, 128 as amending "Liquid … emissions" into "Liquid … taken into account", and with 119, 128 also as addition of "However, this Directive … own strengths"
130 Panayotov Falls if CONS 1, 117, AGRI 9, TRAN 4, 119, 118, 120, 123, INTA 2 or 129 adopted
131 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 1, 117, 119, 118, 123, 121 or ITRE 6 adopted
132 Scottà, Rossi Falls if CONS 2 adopted
133 Girling Falls if CONS 2 or 132 adopted
134 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 2, 132 or 133 adopted
135 Ayuso Falls if CONS 2, 132, 133 or 134 adopted
136 Girling
137 Busoi Withdrawn (author no longer a Member)(falls if CONS 2 or 136 adopted)
Recital 6 a (new)
138 Wils Falls if COMP 11 or 468 NOT adopted
AGRI 10 Falls if CONS 8 adopted
TRAN 5 Falls if CONS 8 adoptedCompatible with AGRI 10 as addition of "Ligno-cellulosic … potential"
139 Bánki Falls if CONS 8, TRAN 5 or AGRI 10 adopted
Recital 7
REGI 4 Falls if CONS 8, TRAN 5, AGRI 10 or 139 adopted
PE516.894v01-00 246/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
140 Pakarinen, Sarvamaa, Essayah, Girling, Takkula, Johansson, Jäätteenmäki
Falls if CONS 8, TRAN 5, AGRI 10 or 139 adopted
INTA 3
141 Ayuso Falls if CONS 8, TRAN 5, AGRI 10 or 139 adopted
5 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 8, TRAN 5, AGRI 10 or 139 adoptedCompatible with 141 as addition of "No negative … should be created"
143 Panayotov Falls if CONS 8, TRAN 5, AGRI 10, 139, 141 or 5 adopted
DEVE 7 Falls if CONS 8, TRAN 5, AGRI 10, 139, REGI 4 or 140 adoptedCompatible with 141, 5 or 142 as addition of "that do not compete … ecosystem"
142 Scottà, Rossi Falls if CONS 8, TRAN 5, AGRI 10, 139, REGI 4, 140 or DEVE 7 adoptedCompatible with 141, 5 or 142 as addition of "that do not compete … food rights"
ITRE 7 Falls if CONS 8, TRAN 5, AGRI 10, 139, REGI 4, 140, DEVE 7 or 142 adopted
144 Franco, Grossetête, Vlasto
Falls if CONS 8, TRAN 5, AGRI 10 or 139 adopted
DEVE 8
145 Eickhout Falls if DEVE 8 adopted
146 Wils
147 Merkies Falls if 146 adopted
148 Korhola, Essayah Falls if 146 or 147 adopted
REGI 5
Recital 7 a (new)
INTA 4
149 Bánki Falls if CONS 7 adoptedFalls if AGRI 19 or AGRI 44 NOT adopted
Recital 8
AGRI 11 Falls if CONS 7 or 149 adopted, or if AGRI 19 or AGRI 44 NOT adopted, otherwise adopted
PV\1001717ES.doc 247/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
150 Franco, Vlasto Falls if CONS 7, 149 or AGRI 11 adoptedIf 253 or 412 NOT adopted, amending "This increase" to "A threshold set at 50%" falls
TRAN 6 Falls if CONS 7, 149, AGRI 11 or 150 adoptedIf TRAN 20 Part 1 AND TRAN 36 Part 1 adopted, amending "2014" to "2015" is adopted, otherwise fallsIf AGRI 19, 253, AGRI 44 or 412 adopted, amending "This increase" to "A 60% minimum threshold" falls
151 Wils Falls if CONS 7, 149, AGRI 11, 150 or TRAN 6 adoptedFalls if 251 or 413 NOT adopted
REGI 6
INTA 5
Recital 8 a (new)
TRAN 7
Identical
152 Klaß
153 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
154 Schnellhardt
155 Weisgerber
156 Bánki
157 Reimers
AGRI 12
Fall if CONS 1 adoptedIdenticalDeletion
6 Rapporteur Withdrawn(identical to 152 , falls if CONS 1 adopted)
158 Girling Falls if CONS 1 or 152 adoptedFalls if 249, ITRE 22 or 244 adopted
Recital 9
159 Ayuso Falls if CONS 1, 152 or 158 adoptedFalls if 331, ITRE 31 B, 336, 349, INTA 21, 346, 347, AGRI 34, 348, 352, 350, TRAN 31, ITRE 31 C, 362 AND 363 NOT adopted
PE516.894v01-00 248/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
TRAN 8 Falls if CONS 1, 152, 158 or 159 adoptedFalls if 331, ITRE 31 B, 336, 349, INTA 21, 346, 347, AGRI 34, 348, 352, 350, TRAN 31, ITRE 31 C, 362 AND 363 NOT adopted
ITRE 8 Falls if CONS 1, 152, 158, 159 or TRAN 8 adoptedFalls if 331, ITRE 31 B, 336, 349, INTA 21, 346, 347, AGRI 34, 348, 352, 350, TRAN 31, ITRE 31 C, 362 AND 363 NOT adoptedIf ITRE 31 C NOT adopted, amending "to the share ... 2011" to "by introducing ... in 2020" fall
DEVE 9 Falls if CONS 1, 152, 158, 159, TRAN 8 or ITRE 8 adopted
160 Eickhout, Wils Falls if CONS 1, 152, 158, 159, TRAN 8, ITRE 8 or DEVE 9 adoptedFalls if 354 NOT adopted
REGI 7 Falls if CONS 1, 6, 158, 159, TRAN 8, ITRE 8 or DEVE 9 adoptedCompatible with 160 as addition of "Such a limit ... environment and climate"
161 Westlund, Ulvskog Falls if CONS 1, 152 or 158 adoptedCompatible with 159, TRAN 8, ITRE 8, DEVE 9, 160 or REGI 7 as addition of "To promote ... for advanced biofuels"
INTA 6 Falls if CONS 1, 152, 158, 159, TRAN 8 or DEVE 9 adopted
162 Arsenis, Jørgensen, Childers, Thomsen
Falls if CONS 1, 152, 158, 159, TRAN 8, ITRE 8, DEVE 9 or INTA 6 adoptedFalls if 235, 234 AND 246 NOT adopted
163 Panayotov Falls if CONS 1, 152, 158, 159, TRAN 8, ITRE 8 or DEVE 9 adopted
ITRE 9 Falls if CONS 1 adoptedFalls if ITRE 31 A NOT adopted
Recital 9 a (new)
INTA 7 Falls if INTA 19 NOT adopted
164 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
165 Ayuso, Arias Echeverría
Recital 10
166 Bánki
Falls if CONS 1 adoptedIdenticalDeletion
PV\1001717ES.doc 249/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
167 Reimers
AGRI 13
7 Rapporteur Withdrawn(identical to 164 , falls if CONS 1 adopted)
169 Klaß Falls if CONS 1 or 164 adopted ↓
168 Weisgerber Falls if CONS 1, 164 or 169 adopted, or if 349, 346, 347, AGRI 34 AND 348 NOT adopted, otherwise adopted
No vote
170 Eickhout, Wils Falls if CONS 1, 164, 169 or 168 adopted, or if 332 or 354 NOT adopted, otherwise adopted
No vote
INTA 8 Falls if CONS 1, 164, 169, 168 or 170 adoptedFalls if INTA 21 AND ITRE 31 C NOT adopted
↓
ITRE 10 Falls if CONS 1, 164, 169, 168 or INTA 8 adopted, or if INTA 21 AND ITRE 31 C NOT adopted, otherwise adopted
↓No vote
171 Girling Falls if CONS 1, 164, 169, 168, INTA 8 or 170 adopted, or if 353 NOT adopted, otherwise adopted
No vote
↓172 Westlund, Ulvskog
173 Jørgensen
IdenticalFalls if CONS 1, 164, 169, 168, INTA 8, 170 or 171 adopted, or if 355 AND 356 NOT adopted, otherwise adopted
No vote
↓
175 Panayotov Falls if CONS 1, 164, 169, 168, INTA 8, 170, 171 or 172 adopted, or if 357 NOT adopted, otherwise adopted
No vote
↓174 Auconie Falls if CONS 1, 164, 169, 168, INTA 8
or 170 adopted, otherwise adopted if 332 or 333 NOT adopted
↓
176 Essayah Falls if CONS 1 or 164 adopted ↓
ITRE 11
TRAN 9
Fall if CONS 5 adoptedIdentical
↓
177 Wils Falls if ITRE 11 adopted +36/34/1
Recital 10 a (new)
DEVE 10 Falls if DEVE 20 NOT adopted ↓
178 SchnellhardtRecital 11
179 Reimers
Falls if COMP 3 adoptedIdenticalDeletion
↓
PE516.894v01-00 250/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
AGRI 14
ITRE 12 Falls if COMP 3 or 178 adoptedFalls if 26, 268, 269, 270, 272, 52, 434, 435, 436 or 438 adoptedFalls if ITRE 41 NOT adopted
180 Ayuso, Arias Echeverría
Falls if COMP 3, 178 or ITRE 12 adoptedFalls if 26, 268, 269, 270, 272, 52, 434, 435, 436 or 438 adopted
↓
TRAN 10 Falls if COMP 3, 178, ITRE 12 or 180 adoptedFalls if 26, 268, 269, 270, 272, 52, 434, 435, 436 or 438 adopted
↓
181 Bánki Falls if COMP 3, 178, ITRE 12, 180 or TRAN 10 adopted
↓
182 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
Falls if COMP 3, 178, ITRE 12, 180, TRAN 10 or 181 adopted
↓
DEVE 11 Falls if 178, ITRE 12, 180, TRAN 10, 181 or 182 adoptedFalls if 26, 268, 269, 270, 272, 52, 434, 435, 436 AND 438 NOT adoptedCompatible with COMP 3 as amending "The estimated ... 2009/28/EC" to "In order to ... and Directive 98/70/EC"
+
183 Eickhout Falls if 178, ITRE 12, 180, TRAN 10, 181, 182 or DEVE 11 adoptedFalls if 26, 268, 269, 270, 272, 52, 434, 435, 436 AND 438 NOT adoptedCompatible with COMP 3 as amending "The estimated ... 2009/28/EC" to "In order to ... and Directive 98/70/EC"
↓
8 Rapporteur Falls if 178, ITRE 12, 180, TRAN 10, 181, 182, DEVE 11 or 183 adoptedFalls if 26, 268, 269, 270, 272, 52, 434, 435, 436 AND 438 NOT adoptedCompatible with COMP 3 as amending "The estimated ... 2009/28/EC" to "In order to ... and Directive 98/70/EC"
↓
184 Girling Falls if COMP 3, 178, ITRE 12, 180, TRAN 10, 181, 182, DEVE 11, 183 or 8 adoptedFalls if 243 NOT adopted
↓
REGI 8 Falls if COMP 3, 178, ITRE 12, 180, TRAN 10 or DEVE 11 adopted
↓
PV\1001717ES.doc 251/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
186 Wils Falls if 264, 265, 430 AND 431 NOT adopted
+35/32/0
187 Wils Falls if 186 NOT adoptedFalls if 266 AND 432 NOT adopted
+
10 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 9 adoptedFalls if 22, 23, 50 AND 51 NOT adopted
↓
192 Pakarinen, Korhola, Sarvamaa, Essayah, Takkula, Johansson, Jäätteenmäki
Falls if CONS 9 or 10 adoptedFalls if 22, 23, 50 or 51 adopted
↓
DEVE 12 Falls if CONS 10 adopted ↓
191 Merkies, Thomsen, Van Brempt
Falls if CONS 10 or DEVE 12 adopted ↓
188 Westlund, Ulvskog
189 Scottà, Rossi
ITRE 13
Fall if CONS 10, DEVE 12 or 191 adoptedIdentical
↓
190 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 10, DEVE 12, 191 or 188 adopted
↓
11 Rapporteur Withdrawn(falls if CONS 10, DEVE 12, 191, 188 or 190 adopted)
W
INTA 9 Falls if CONS 10, DEVE 12, 191, 188 or 190 adopted(falls if 11 adopted)
↓
REGI 9 Falls if CONS 10, DEVE 12, 191, 188, 190 or INTA 9 adopted(falls if 11 adopted)
↓
12 Rapporteur Falls if 30, 31, 283, 59, 60 AND 446 NOT adopted
-33/34/0
Recital 11 a (new)
13 Rapporteur Falls if 248, 21, 409 AND 49 NOT adopted
+42/28/0
193 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
194 Schnellhardt
195 Weisgerber
Recital 12
196 Bánki
Fall if COMP 3 adoptedIdenticalDeletion
↓
PE516.894v01-00 252/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
197 Reimers
AGRI 15
ITRE 14 Falls if COMP 3 or 193 adopted ↓
198 Ayuso, Arias Echeverría
Falls if COMP 3, 193 or ITRE 14 adopted
↓
TRAN 11 Falls if COMP 3, 193, ITRE 14 or 198 adopted
↓
INTA 10 Falls if COMP 3, 193, ITRE 14, 198 or TRAN 11 adopted
↓
199 Girling Falls if COMP 3, 193, ITRE 14 or 198 adoptedFalls if 338, 364, ITRE 31 D AND 369 NOT adopted
↓
200 Panayotov Falls if COMP 3, 193, ITRE 14 or 198 adopted
↓
185 Pargneaux
ITRE 15
Recital 12 a (new)
TRAN 12
Identical -
TRAN 13 Falls if COMP 3 adopted ↓
ITRE 16 Falls if COMP 3 adoptedCompatible with TRAN 13 as addition of "vulnerable"
↓
201 Ayuso Falls if COMP 3, TRAN 13 or ITRE 16 adopted
↓
202 Pargneaux Falls if TRAN 13, ITRE 16 or 201 adopted
-32/37/0
Recital 13
203 Panayotov Falls if TRAN 13, ITRE 16 or 201 adopted
-
Recital 11 a (new) 9 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 5 adopted ↓
Recital 15 a (new) 205 Pargneaux Falls if CONS 5 adopted ↓
TRAN 15 Falls if CONS 5, 9 or 205 adopted ↓
ITRE 17 Falls if CONS 5, 9, 205 or TRAN 15 adopted
↓
204 Gardini, Girling -
Recital 14 a (new)
TRAN 14 +
PV\1001717ES.doc 253/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Recital 15 DEVE 13 +
Recital 15 a (new) DEVE 14 +36/33/0
206 Girling Deletion -
207 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
208 Ayuso, Arias Echeverría
Falls if 206 adoptedIdentical
-
Recital 18
ITRE 18 Falls if 206 adopted -
209 Girling Deletion -
14 Rapporteur
210 Ayuso
ITRE 19
211 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
212 Bánki
AGRI 16
213 Auconie
214 Scottà, Rossi
Recital 19
215 Schnellhardt
Fall if 209 adoptedList of delegated powers to be adapted to the result of previous votes on Articles 7a(5), 7b(3)(2), 7d(1a), 7d(5), 7d(6), 7d(7), 7d(8a), 8a(3) and 10(1) of Directive 98/70/EC and Articles 2, 3(4), 5(5), 17(3), 18(9a), 19(1a), 19(5), 19(6), 19(7) and 19(8) of Directive 2009/28/EC
No vote
216 Hibner, Sonik, Kaczmarek, Kalinowski, Cymanski, Grzyb
217 Ayuso, Arias Echeverría
Recital 20
TRAN 16
Falls if COMP 11 adoptedIdentical
↓
PE516.894v01-00 254/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
AGRI 17
218 Wils Falls if COMP 11 adoptedIf 216 adopted, the words "by including ...land use change" fall
↓
ITRE 20 Falls if COMP 11, 216 or 218 adopted ↓
219 Arsenis, Jørgensen, Merkies, Childers, Thomsen
Falls if COMP 11, 216, 218 or ITRE 20 adopted
↓
220 Eickhout Falls if COMP 11, 216, 218, ITRE 20 or 219 adopted
↓
15 Rapporteur Falls if COMP 11, 216, 218, ITRE 20, 219 or 220 adopted
↓
223 Franco Falls if COMP 11 or ITRE 20 adoptedCompatible with 216, 218, 219, 220 and 15 as addition of "The Commission should conduct ... biomass-using sectors"
↓
221 Scottà, Rossi Falls if COMP 11, ITRE 20 or 223 adoptedCompatible with 216, 218, 219, 220 and 15 as addition of "The Commission should carry ... related industries"
↓
222 Girling Falls if COMP 11, ITRE 41, 471, 474 AND 476 NOT adopted
↓
REGI 10 Falls if COMP 11 adopted ↓
REGI 11 -
ITRE 21 -
224 Scottà, Rossi Falls if ITRE 21 adopted -
Recital 21
225 Franco Falls if ITRE 21 or 224 adopted -
Recital 21 a (new) REGI 12 -
DRAFT REPORT AS AMENDEDIn favour
43Against
26Abstentions
1
DRAFT LEGISLATIVE RESOLUTIONIn favour
43Against
26Abstentions
1
PV\1001717ES.doc 255/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Item 11 – ANNEX V
VOTING RESULTS
on the proposal amending Directive 2011/92/EU on the assessment of the effects of certain public and private projects on the environment
2012/0297(COD), PR–PE 508.221v01-00 + AM–PE 510.827v01-00 + AM–PE 510.870v01-00+ AM–PE 510.871v01-00 + AM–PE 510.872v01-00 + AD–PE 510.526v02-00 + AD–PE 507.937v02-00
Rapporteur: Andrea Zanoni
Concerned text AM Tabled by Remarks Vote
COMPROMISE 3DemolitionsArt 1 – point 1 – point aArt 1 – para 2 – point a –indent 1
ALDE, EPP, S&D, GREENS/EFA, ECR, GUE/NGL
If adopted, 100-110, PETI 18 and 477 fall
+
100 Klaß
101 Seeber
102 Fjellner, Korhola
103 Thyssen
Fall if COMP 3 adoptedIdenticalDeletion
↓
106 Florenz, Krahmer, Bánki, Schnellhardt, Reimers, Auconie, Mazej Kukovic
Falls if COMP 3 or 100 adopted ↓
107 Gardini, Tatarella, Bartolozzi
Falls if COMP 3, 100 or 106 adopted ↓
108 Poc Falls if COMP 3, 100, 106 or 107adopted
↓
PETI 18 Falls if COMP 3, 100, 106, 107 or 108adopted
↓
105 Scottà, Rossi Falls if COMP 3, 100, 107, 108 or PETI 18 adoptedCompatible with 106 as addition of "that do not fall ... 2010/75/EU"
↓
Art 1 – point 1 –point aArt 1 – para 2 –point a – indent 1
104 Franco Falls if COMP 3, 100, 107, 108, PETI 18or 105 adoptedCompatible with 106 as addition of "where this is not ... sector-specific rules"
↓
PE516.894v01-00 256/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
109 Rapporteur, Arsenis, Leinen, Childers, Prodi
Falls if COMP 3 or 100 adoptedCompatible with 106, 107, 108, PETI 18, 105 or 104 as addition of "or their operation"
↓
110 Wils, Ferreira Falls if COMP 3 or 100 adopted ↓
111 Rapporteur, Arsenis, Leinen, Childers, Prodi, Merkies
Art 1 – point 1 –point a a (new)Art 1 – para 2 –point a – indent 2
112 Poc
Identical +34/32/0
Art 1 – point 1 –point a a (new)Art 1 – para 2 –point a – subpara 1 a (new)
113 Klaß –
Art 1 – point 1 –point a a (new)Art 1 – para 2 –point c
114 Bélier +
Art 1 – point 1 –point a a (new)Art 1 – para 2 –point f
115 Thyssen –
12 Rapporteur Linguistic
116 Thyssen –33/35/0
117 Arsenis, Gutiérrez-Cortines, Leinen, Childers, Prodi
+
118 Pargneaux Compatible with 116 as addition of "by the developer" and "and/or by ... Article 6(1)"
+
119 Wils, Ferreira –33/36/0
Art 1 - point 1 -point bArt 1 – para 2 –point g
120 Klaß Falls if 119 adopted +59/8/0
CONSOLIDATED 6Environmental factorsArt 1 – point 3Art 3
ALDE, EPP, S&D, GREENS/EFA, ECR
If adopted, 13, PETI 20, 20, 21, 164-188, TRAN 8-10 and PETI 29 fall
+64/4/0
PV\1001717ES.doc 257/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
13 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 6 adopted
Split vote (ECR)
Part 1Without the word "all"
Part 2 – Falls if Part 1 NOT adopted"all"
↓
PETI 20 Falls if CONS 6 or 13 Part 1 adopted ↓
121 Gutiérrez-Cortines, Ayuso
+35/31/0
122 Rapporteur, Gutiérrez-Cortines, Arsenis, Ayuso
+
123 Rapporteur, Gutiérrez-Cortines, Arsenis, Ayuso
+
PETI 24 Falls if 123 adopted ↓
124 Gutiérrez-Cortines, Ayuso
125 Klaß
PETI 23
Identical +40/27/0
126 Gutiérrez-Cortines, Arsenis, Ayuso
+
127 Klaß
PETI 25
Fall if 126 adoptedIdentical
↓
PETI 22 +
128 Bélier Falls if PETI 22 adopted ↓
TRAN 5 +50/19/0
Art 1 – point 1 –point b a (new)Art 1– para 2 –point g a (new)
PETI 21 +
PE516.894v01-00 258/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Art 1 - point 1 - point bArt 1 – para 2 – point g
PETI 19 Adopted if PETI 20, PETI 21, PETI 22, PETI 23, PETI 24 or PETI 25 adopted, falls otherwiseNO VOTE
CONSOLIDATED 4DerogationsArt 1 – point 1 – point aArt 1 – paras 3 and 4Art 1 – point 2 a (new)Art 2 – para 4
ALDE, EPP, S&D, GREENS/EFA, ECR
If adopted, 14, 15, 19, 129-135, 159-163, TRAN 6, PETI 26 and PETI 27 fall
+
129 Gardini Falls if CONS 4 adopted ↓
130 Arsenis, Childers, Prodi
Falls if CONS 4 adopted ↓
14 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 4 or 130 adopted ↓
TRAN 6 Falls if CONS 4 adopted ↓
PETI 26 Falls if CONS 4 adopted ↓
Art 1 – point 1 –point cArt 1 – para 3
131 Perelló Rodríguez Falls if CONS 4 adopted ↓
132 Rapporteur, Arsenis, Gutiérrez-Cortines, Westlund, Childers, Prodi, Merkies
133 Bélier
Fall if CONS 4 adoptedIdenticalDeletion
↓
134 Gardini Falls if CONS 4 or 132 adopted ↓
Art 1 – point 1 –point cArt 1 – para 4
15 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 4 or 132 adopted ↓
135 Scottà, Rossi –Art 1 – point 1 –point c a (new)Art 1 – para 4 a (new)
16 Rapporteur +
Art 1 – point 9 a (new)Art 9 a (new)
PETI 51 Falls if 16 adopted ↓
PV\1001717ES.doc 259/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Art 1 – point 1 a (new)Art 2 – para 1
136 Rapporteur, Arsenis, Gutiérrez-Cortines, Westlund, Childers, Prodi
Split vote (EFD)
Part 1Without the word "after having consulted the public"
Part 2 – Falls if Part 1 NOT adopted"after having consulted the public"
+
+
CONSOLIDATED 5One-stop shopArt 1 – point 2Art 2 – para 3
ALDE, EPP, S&D, GREENS/EFA, ECR
If adopted, 17, 18, 137-157, TRAN 7 and PETI 28 fall
+
137 Florenz, Krahmer, Bánki, Schnellhardt, Reimers, Auconie, Mazej Kukovic
Falls if CONS 5 adopted ↓
138 Fjellner, Korhola Falls if CONS 5 or 137 adopted ↓
139 Bélier
140 Stevenson
141 Davies
142 Thyssen
Fall if CONS 5, 137 or 138 adoptedIdentical
↓
143 Seeber Falls if CONS 5 adopted ↓
PETI 28 Falls if CONS 5 adoptedIf 137, 138 or 139 adopted, the words "The most stringent ... shall apply" fall
↓
Art 1 – point 2Art 2 – para 3 –subpara 1
TRAN 7 Falls if CONS 5 or PETI 28 adopted ↓
144 Thyssen Falls if CONS 5 adoptedDeletion
↓
145 Stevenson Falls if CONS 5 or 144 adopted ↓
146 Bélier Falls if CONS 5 or 144 adopted ↓
147 Seeber Falls if CONS 5 or 144 adopted ↓
Art 1 – point 2Art 2 – para 3 –subpara 2
17 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 5 or 144 adopted ↓
148 Thyssen Falls if CONS 5 adoptedDeletion
↓Art 1 – point 2Art 2 – para 3 –subpara 3 149 Stevenson Falls if CONS 5 or 148 adopted ↓
PE516.894v01-00 260/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
150 Seeber Falls if CONS 5 or 148 adopted ↓
PV\1001717ES.doc 261/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
151 Florenz, Krahmer, Bánki, Schnellhardt, Reimers, Auconie, Seeber, Mazej Kukovic
152 Seeber
153 Thyssen
Fall if CONS 5 adoptedIdenticalDeletion
↓
154 de Lange Falls if CONS 5 or 151 adopted ↓
155 Stevenson
156 Davies
Fall if CONS 5 or 151 adoptedIdentical
↓
Art 1 – point 2Art 2 – para 3 –subpara 4
157 Sonik, Hibner Falls if CONS 5 or 151 adopted ↓
18 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 5 adopted ↓Art 1 – point 2Art 2 – para 3 –subpara 4 a (new) 158 Davies Compatible with CONS 5 as an addition +
Art 1 – point 2Art 2 – para 4
PETI 27 Falls if CONS 4 adoptedDeletion of Article 2(4) of the Directive
↓
159 Grossetête, Dantin Falls if CONS 4 or PETI 27 adopted ↓
161 Bonanini Falls if CONS 4, PETI 27 or 159 adopted ↓
160 Rapporteur, Arsenis, Gutiérrez-Cortines, Childers, Prodi
Falls if CONS 4, PETI 27 or 159 adoptedIf 161 adopted, point (-a) falls
↓
Art 1 – point 2 a (new)Art 2 – para 4
19 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 4, PETI 27, 159, 161 or 160 adopted
↓
Art 1 – point 2 a (new)Art 2 – para 4 –subpara 1
162 Bélier Falls if CONS 4, PETI 27, 161, 160 or 19adopted
↓
164 Thyssen Falls if CONS 6 adopted ↓
20 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 6 adopted ↓
Art 1 – point 3Art 3 –introductory part
165 Bélier Falls if CONS 6 adopted ↓
PE516.894v01-00 262/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
166 Florenz, Krahmer, Bánki, Schnellhardt, Reimers, Auconie, Seeber, Mazej Kukovic
Falls if CONS 6 adopted ↓
168 Scottà, Rossi Falls if CONS 6 or 166 adopted ↓
167 Thyssen Falls if CONS 6 or 166 adoptedIf 168 adopted, the words "fauna, flora" fall
↓
169 Korhola Falls if CONS 6 or 166 adopted ↓
170 Rapporteur, Gutiérrez-Cortines, Arsenis, Ayuso
Falls if CONS 6 or 166 adopted ↓
Art 1 – point 3Art 3 – point a
PETI 29 A Falls if CONS 6 or 166 adoptedPoint (a)
↓
TRAN 8 Falls if CONS 6 adopted ↓
171 Florenz, Krahmer, Bánki, Schnellhardt, Reimers, Auconie, Seeber, Mazej Kukovic
Falls if CONS 6 adoptedCompatible with TRAN 8 as deletion of "land" and addition of "and the landscape"
↓
172 Stevenson Falls if CONS 6 or 171 adopted
Split vote (EFD)
Part 1Deletion of "land"
Part 2 – Falls if TRAN 8 adoptedDeletion of "change"
↓
173 Klaß Falls if CONS 6, TRAN 8, 171 or172 Part 1 adopted
↓
174 Seeber
175 Sonik, Hibner
Art 1 – point 3Art 3 – point b
PETI 29 B
Falls if CONS 6, TRAN 8, 171,172 Part 2 or 173 adoptedIdentical
Point (b)
↓
PV\1001717ES.doc 263/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
176 Bélier Falls if CONS 6 adopted
Split vote (EFD)
Part 1"land, soil, subsoil, water, air, climate"Compatible with TRAN 8, 171, 172, 173 or 174 as addition of "subsoil"
Part 2 – Falls if Part 1 NOT adopted"and climate change ... resources"Compatible with TRAN 8, 171, 172, 173 or 174 as addition of "and natural resources"
↓
21 Rapporteur
177 Morkunaite-Mikuleniene
Fall if CONS 6 or 176 Part 1 adoptedIdentical
↓
178 Scottà, Rossi Falls if CONS 6 or TRAN 8 adopted ↓
Art 1 – point 3Art 3 – point b a (new)
179 Klaß Falls if CONS 6 adopted ↓
180 Florenz, Krahmer, Bánki, Schnellhardt, Reimers, Auconie, Seeber, Mazej Kukovic
Falls if CONS 6 adoptedAdopted if 171 adopted
↓
181 Stevenson Falls if CONS 6 adopted ↓
TRAN 9 Falls if CONS 6 adopted ↓
182 Gutiérrez-Cortines, Ayuso
Falls if CONS 6 adopted ↓
PETI 29 C Falls if CONS 6 or 182 adoptedPoints (c) and (ca)
↓
Art 1 – point 3Art 3 – point c
183 Klaß Falls if CONS 6, 182 or PETI 29 Cadopted
↓
Art 1 – point 3Art 3 – point d
PETI 29 D Falls if CONS 6 adoptedPoint (d)If PETI 29 C NOT adopted, the words "and (ca)" fall
↓
184 SeeberArt 1 – point 3Art 3 – point e
185 Krahmer, Reimers
Fall if CONS 6 adoptedIdenticalDeletion
↓
PE516.894v01-00 264/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
186 Thyssen
187 Stevenson Falls if CONS 6 or 184 adopted ↓
188 Seeber Falls if CONS 6 adoptedFalls if 184 NOT adopted
↓Art 1 – point 3Art 3 – point e a (new) TRAN 10 Falls if CONS 6 adopted ↓
Art 1 – point 3Art 3 – para 1 a (new)
189 Gutiérrez-Cortines, Ayuso
Compatible with CONS 6 as an addition +43/24/0
CONSOLIDATED 7ScreeningArt 1 – point 4Art 4
ALDE, S&D, GREENS/EFA, ECR, GUE/NGL
If adopted, 22-24, 190-233, TRAN 11, PETI 30-34 fall
+43/25/0
PETI 30 Falls if CONS 7 adopted ↓Art 1 – point 4 –point -a (new)Art 4 – para 2 190 Rapporteur, Arsenis,
Leinen, Childers, Prodi
Falls if CONS 7 adoptedCompatible with PETI 30 as addition of "after having consulted the public"
↓
191 Bélier Falls if CONS 7 or PETI 30 adopted ↓Art 1 – point 4 –point -a (new)Art 4 – para 2 –subpara 2
192 Ferreira Falls if CONS 7, PETI 30 or 191 adopted ↓
193 Florenz, Krahmer, Bánki, Schnellhardt, Reimers, Auconie, De Lange, Seeber, Mazej Kukovic
Falls if CONS 7 adoptedIf adopted, 478 adopted(deletion of Annex II.A)
↓
196 Franco Falls if CONS 7 or 193 adopted ↓
194 Stevenson Falls if CONS 7 adopted ↓
197 Sonik, Hibner Falls if CONS 7 or 194 adopted ↓
198 Grossetête, Dantin
TRAN 11
Fall if CONS 7, 194 or 197 adoptedIdentical
↓
PETI 31 Falls if CONS 7 adoptedCompatible with 196, 194, 197 or 198 as addition of "significant adverse" and "The information ... paragraph 2"
↓
Art 1 – point 4 –point aArt 4 – para 3
195 Fjellner, Korhola Falls if CONS 7, 194 or PETI 31 adopted ↓
PV\1001717ES.doc 265/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
199 Ferreira Compatible with CONS 7 as an additionCompatible with PETI 31 as addition of "which shall ... public accessibility"
+35/34/0
Art 1 – point 4 –point aArt 4 – para 3 –subpara 1 a (new)
200 Gutiérrez-Cortines, Ayuso
Falls if CONS 7 adopted ↓
Art 1 – point 4 –point aArt 4 – para 4 –subpara 1 a (new)
208 Franco Falls if CONS 7, 193 or 200 adopted ↓
Art 1 – point 4 –point aArt 4 – para 3 –subpara 1 a (new)
202 Franco Falls if CONS 7, 193, 200 or 208 adopted ↓
PETI 32 Falls if CONS 7 adopted ↓
203 Thyssen Falls if CONS 7 adopted ↓
204 Stevenson Falls if CONS 7 or 203 adopted ↓
205 Franco Falls if CONS 7, 203 or 204 adopted ↓
206 Fjellner, Korhola Falls if CONS 7, 203, 204 or 205 adopted ↓
Art 1 – point 4 –point aArt 4 – para 4
207 Florenz, Krahmer, Bánki, Schnellhardt, Reimers, Auconie, De Lange, Seeber, Mazej Kukovic
Falls if CONS 7 or 203 adopted ↓
210 Sonik, Hibner Linguistic
PETI 33 Falls if CONS 7 adopted ↓
209 Thyssen Falls if CONS 7 or PETI 33 adopted ↓
211 Arsenis, Leinen, Westlund, Childers, Prodi
Falls if CONS 7 adoptedCompatible with PETI 33 as addition of "after having ... public concerned"
↓
22 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 7 adopted ↓
Art 1 – point 4 –point bArt 4 – para 5 –introductory part
214 Perelló Rodríguez Falls if CONS 7 or 22 adopted ↓
PE516.894v01-00 266/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
212 Florenz, Krahmer, Bánki, Schnellhardt, Reimers, Auconie, Mazej Kukovic
Falls if CONS 7 adopted ↓
213 Bélier Falls if CONS 7 adopted ↓
Art 1 – point 4 –point bArt 4 – para 5 –point a
215 Florenz, Krahmer, Bánki, Schnellhardt, Reimers, Auconie, Seeber, Mazej Kukovic
Fall if CONS 7 adoptedDeletion
↓
216 Fjellner, KorholaArt 1 – point 4 –point bArt 4 – para 5 –point c
217 Seeber
Fall if CONS 7 adoptedIdenticalDeletion
↓
23 Rapporteur LinguisticArt 1 - point 4 -point bArt 4 – para 5 –point d
218 Ferreira Falls if CONS 7 adopted ↓
219 De Lange Falls if CONS 7 adoptedDeletion
↓
201 Gutiérrez-Cortines, Ayuso
Falls if CONS 7 adoptedFalls if 219 NOT adopted
↓
221 Scottà , Rossi Falls if CONS 7 or 219 adopted ↓
222 Krahmer, Reimers Falls if CONS 7, 219 or 221 adopted ↓
220 Sonik, Hibner Falls if 219 adopted
Split vote (ECR + EFD)
Part 1 – Falls if CONS 7, 221 or 222 adoptedDeletion of "Depending ... is expected"
Part 2Addition of "or other decision ... Directive"Compatible with CONS 7 as an addition
↓
–
223 Stevenson Falls if CONS 7, 219 or 221 adoptedCompatible with 222 or 220 as amending "within three months" to "within one month"
↓
Art 1 – point 4 –point bArt 4 – para 6 –subpara 1
224 Korhola Falls if CONS 7, 219, 221, 222,220 Part 1 or 223 adopted
↓
PV\1001717ES.doc 267/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
225 Gutiérrez-Cortines, Ayuso
Falls if CONS 7, 219, 221, 222,220 Part 1, 223 or 224 adopted
↓
226 Poc Falls if CONS 7, 219, 221, 222,220 Part 1, 223, 224 or 225 adopted
↓
228 Gardini, Tatarella, Bartolozzi
Split vote (EFD)
Part 1 – Falls if CONS 7, 219, 221, 222, 220 Part 1 or 223 adopted"The competent ... information"Compatible with 224, 225, 226 as amending "within three months" to "within 90 days"
Part 2 – Falls if CONS 7, 219, 221, 222or 220 Part 1 adopted"Depending ... causes of the delay"
↓
↓
230 Klaß
PETI 34
Fall if CONS 7, 219, 221, 222,220 Part 1, 223, 224, 225, 226 or228 Part 1 adoptedIdentical
↓
227 Thyssen Falls if CONS 7 or 219 adopted
Split vote (EFD)
Part 1"Member States ... paragraph 3"
Part 2Deletion of "and the date ... expected"
↓
24 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 7, 219, 221, 222 or220 Part 1 adoptedIf 223 adopted, the words "in writing" fall
Split vote (EFD)
Part 1"The competent ... decision is expected"
Part 2"making available ... Article 6(2)"
↓
229 Gardini Falls if CONS 7 or 219 adopted ↓
Art 1 – point 4 –point bArt 4 – para 6 –subpara 1 a (new)
231 Thyssen Falls if CONS 7 adopted ↓
Art 1 – point 4 –point b
232 Seeber Fall if CONS 7 adoptedIdentical
↓
PE516.894v01-00 268/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Art 4 – para 6 –subpara 2
233 Thyssen Deletion
COMPROMISE 8Environmental reportArt 1 – point 5Art 5 – paras 1 and 3
ALDE, EPP, S&D, GREENS/EFA, ECR, GUE/NGL
If adopted, 25, 26, 29-32, 234-247, 294-332, TRAN 12, PETI 35 and PETI 38-41 fall
+
234 Thyssen Falls if COMP 8 adopted ↓
236 Pargneaux Falls if COMP 8 or 234 adopted ↓
235 Davies Falls if COMP 8 adoptedCompatible with 234 or 236 as addition of "The developer shall ... scope of the EIA"
↓
241 Klaß Falls if COMP 8, 234 or 236 adoptedCompatible with 235 as addition of "by the developer"
↓
25 Rapporteur
237 Arsenis, Prodi, Childers
238 Korhola
Fall if COMP 8, 234, 236, 235 or 241adoptedIdentical
↓
242 Florenz, Krahmer, Bánki, Schnellhardt, Reimers, Auconie, De Lange, Seeber
Falls if COMP 8, 234 or 236 adoptedCompatible with 235 or 241 as addition of "which ... to the same extent"
↓
239 Scottà , Rossi Falls if COMP 8, 234 or 236 adoptedCompatible with 235, 241 or 242 as deletion of "be based ... this Article and"and addition of "a description of", and with 241 also as addition of "adapted ... to its specific features"
↓
240 Gardini, Bartolozzi, Tatarella
Falls if COMP 8, 234, 236 or 239adoptedCompatible with 235 or 241 or 242 as deletion of "be based ... this Article and" and addition of "an outline of", and with 241 also as addition of "relevant and specific"
↓
244 Stevenson Falls if COMP 8, 234, 236, 235, 242, 239or 240 adopted
↓
Art 1 – point 5Art 5 – para 1
243 Gutiérrez-Cortines, Ayuso
Falls if COMP 8 adoptedIf 234, 236, 235, 242, 239, 240 or 244 adopted, the words "that refer ...significant impacts" fall
↓
PV\1001717ES.doc 269/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
PETI 35 Falls if COMP 8 adoptedIf PETI 22 AND 128 NOT adopted, the words "as defined in Article 1(2)(fa)" fallIf 243 adopted, the words "including a visual impact ... relevant" fall
↓
245 Wils, Ferreira Falls if COMP 8 or 234 adopted ↓
246 Klaß Falls if COMP 8, 234 or 245 adopted ↓
26 Rapporteur Falls if COMP 8, 234 or 236 adopted ↓Art 1 – point 5Art 5 – para 1 –subpara 1 a (new) 247 Thyssen Falls if COMP 8 adopted ↓
CONSOLIDATED 9ScopingArt 1 – point 5Art 5 – para 2
ALDE, EPP, S&D, GREENS/EFA, GUE/NGL
If adopted, 27, 28, 248-293, TRAN 12, PETI 36 and PETI 37 fall
+
248 Fjellner, Korhola Falls if CONS 9 adoptedDeletion
↓Art 1 – point 5Art 5 – para 2
249 Stevenson Falls if CONS 9 or 248 adopted ↓
27 Rapporteur Linguistic
250 Seeber Falls if CONS 9 or 248 adoptedCompatible with 249 as deletion of "and the developer"
↓
251 Gardini, Tatarella, Bartolozzi
Falls if CONS 9 or 248 adoptedCompatible with 249 as deletion of "and the developer", and with 249 or 250 as amending "determine ... be included" to "provide guidance on the information"
↓
252 Scottà , Rossi Falls if CONS 9, 248 or 251 adoptedCompatible with 249 as deletion of "and the developer", and with 249 or 250 as amending "determine ... details of" to "provide guidance on"
↓
253 Thyssen Falls if CONS 9, 248, 251 or 252 adoptedCompatible with 249 or 250 as amending "shall determine ... of this Article" to "shall give ... paragraph 1"
↓
256 Davies Falls if CONS 9, 248, 251, 252 or 253adopted
↓
Art 1 – point 5Art 5 – para 2 –subpara 1 –introductory part
PETI 36 Falls if CONS 9, 248 adoptedCompatible with 249, 250, 251, 252, 253 and 256 as addition of "and the public concerned" and with 249, 250, 251, 252 and 253 also as addition of "as provided in Annex IV"
↓
PE516.894v01-00 270/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
254 Florenz, Krahmer, Bánki, Schnellhardt, Reimers, Auconie, Mazej Kukovic
Falls if CONS 9, 248, 249, 250, 251, 252, 253 or PETI 36 adopted
↓
255 Klaß Falls if CONS 9, 248, 249, 250, 251, 252, 253, PETI 36 or 254 adopted
↓
258 Bélier
259 Ferreira
Fall if CONS 9, 248 or PETI 36 adoptedIdentical
↓
257 Arsenis, Leinen, Westlund, Childers, Prodi
Falls if CONS 9, 248, 258 or PETI 36adopted
↓
260 SeeberArt 1 – point 5Art 5 – para 2 –subpara 1 – point a 261 Thyssen
Falls if CONS 9, 248 or 249 adoptedAdopted if 250 adoptedIdenticalDeletion
↓
Art 1 – point 5Art 5 – para 2 –subpara 1 – point b
262 Seeber Falls if CONS 9, 248 or 249 adoptedAdopted if 250 adoptedDeletion
↓
263 Seeber
264 Klaß
265 Thyssen
Fall if CONS 9, 248 or 249 adoptedAdopted if 250 adoptedIdenticalDeletion
↓
266 Gardini, Tatarella, Bartolozzi
Falls if CONS 9, 248, 249, 250 or 263adopted
↓
Art 1 – point 5Art 5 – para 2 –subpara 1 – point c
267 Scottà , Rossi Falls if CONS 9, 248, 249, 250, 263 or 266 adopted
↓
268 Seeber
269 Franco
270 Pargneaux
271 Gardini, Tatarella, Bartolozzi
272 Scottà , Rossi
Fall if CONS 9, 248 or 249 adoptedAdopted if 250 adoptedIdenticalDeletion
↓Art 1 – point 5Art 5 – para 2 –subpara 1 – point d
273 Klaß Falls if CONS 9, 248, 249, 250 or 268adopted
↓
PV\1001717ES.doc 271/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
275 Florenz, Krahmer, Bánki, Schnellhardt, Reimers, Auconie
Falls if CONS 9, 234, 236, 248, 249, 250or 268 adoptedFalls if 239, 240, 242, 243 AND 244 NOT adopted
↓
276 Gutiérrez-Cortines, Ayuso
Falls if CONS 9, 248, 249, 250 or 268adopted
↓
274 Bélier Falls if CONS 9, 248, 249, 250 or 268adopted
↓
277 Arsenis, Leinen, Childers, Prodi
Falls if CONS 9, 248, 249, 250, 268 or 274 adopted
↓
PE516.894v01-00 272/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
278 Seeber
279 Gardini, Tatarella, Bartolozzi
Fall if CONS 9, 248 or 249 adoptedAdopted if 250 adoptedIdenticalDeletion
↓Art 1 – point 5Art 5 – para 2 –subpara 1 – point e
TRAN 12 Falls if CONS 9, 248, 249, 250 or 278 adopted
↓
280 Seeber
281 Klaß
282 Gardini, Tatarella, Bartolozzi
283 Scottà , Rossi
Art 1 – point 5Art 5 – para 2 –subpara 1 – point f
284 Thyssen
Falls if CONS 9, 248 or 249 adoptedAdopted if 250 adoptedIdenticalDeletion
↓
285 Seeber Falls if CONS 9, 248 or 249 adoptedAdopted if 250 adoptedDeletion
↓Art 1 – point 5Art 5 – para 2 –subpara 1 – point g
286 Thyssen Falls if CONS 9, 248, 249, 250 or 285adopted
↓
PETI 37 Falls if CONS 9, 248 or 249 adopted ↓
287 Seeber Falls if CONS 9, 248 or 249 adoptedCompatible with PETI 37 as addition of "or technical considerations"
↓
288 Thyssen Falls if CONS 9, 248, 249, PETI 37 or 287 adoptedFalls if 250, 251, 252, 253, 254 AND 255 NOT adopted
↓
289 Rapporteur, Gutiérrez-Cortines, Arsenis, Ayuso
Falls if CONS 9, 248, 249, PETI 37, 287 or 288 adopted
↓
28 Rapporteur
290 Gardini, Tatarella, Bartolozzi
291 De Lange
Fall if CONS 9, 248, 249, PETI 37, 287, 288 or 289 adoptedIdentical
↓
Art 1 – point 5Art 5 – para 2 –subpara 2
292 Bélier Falls if CONS 9, 248, 249 or PETI 37adoptedCompatible with 287, 288, 289 and 28 as deletion of "and ... competent authority"
↓
PV\1001717ES.doc 273/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Art 1 – point 5Art 5 – para 2 –subpara 2 a (new)
293 Thyssen Falls if CONS 9, 248 or 249 adoptedFalls if 250, 251, 252, 253, 254 AND 255NOT adopted
↓
Art 1 – point 5Art 5 – para 3 –subpara 1 –introductory part
294 Thyssen Falls if COMP 8 adopted ↓
295 Thyssen Falls if COMP 8 adopted, otherwise adopted if 294 adoptedDeletion
↓
PETI 38 Falls if COMP 8, 294 or 295 adopted ↓
296 Florenz, Krahmer, Bánki, Schnellhardt, Reimers, Auconie
Falls if COMP 8, 294, 295 or PETI 38adopted
↓
298 Seeber Falls if COMP 8, 294, 295, PETI 38 or 296 adopted
↓
29 Rapporteur Falls if COMP 8, 294, 295, PETI 38, 296or 298 adopted
Split vote (EFD)
Part 1Without the word "and"
Part 2 – Falls if Part 1 NOT adopted"and"
↓
297 Rapporteur, Gutiérrez-Cortines, Arsenis, Ayuso
Falls if COMP 8, 294, 295, PETI 38 or 296 adoptedCompatible with 298 or 29 as addition of "independent"
↓
299 Stevenson Falls if COMP 8, 294, 295 or 296adoptedCompatible with PETI 38, 298 or 29 as addition of "qualified"
↓
300 Fjellner, Korhola
301 De Lange
302 Pargneaux
Art 1 – point 5Art 5 – para 3 –subpara 1 – point a
303 Gardini, Tatarella, Bartolozzi
Fall if COMP 8, 294, 295, PETI 38, 288, 29, 297 or 299 adoptedIdentical
↓
PE516.894v01-00 274/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
304 Bélier Falls if COMP 8, 294, 295, PETI 38, 296, 298, 29 or 297 adoptedCompatible with 299 or 300 as addition of "independent"
↓
PV\1001717ES.doc 275/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
305 Thyssen
PETI 39
Falls if COMP 8 adopted, otherwise adopted if 294 or PETI 38 adoptedIdenticalDeletion
↓
306 Florenz, Krahmer, Bánki, Schnellhardt, Reimers, Auconie
Falls if COMP 8, 294, PETI 38 or 305adopted
↓
308 Gardini, Tatarella, Bartolozzi
Falls if COMP 8, 294, PETI 38, 305 or 306 adopted
↓
307 Rapporteur, Gutiérrez-Cortines, Arsenis, Ayuso
Falls if COMP 8, 294, PETI 38, 305 or 306 adoptedCompatible with 308 as addition of "independent"
↓
309 Seeber Falls if COMP 8, 294, PETI 38, 305 or 306 adoptedCompatible with 308 or 307 as deletion of "technically"
↓
310 Stevenson Falls if COMP 8, 294, PETI 38, 305 or 306 adopted
↓
30 Rapporteur
311 Fjellner, Korhola
312 De Lange
313 Pargneaux
Fall if COMP 8, 294, PETI 38, 305, 306, 308, 307, 309 or 310 adoptedIdentical
↓
Art 1 – point 5Art 5 – para 3 –subpara 1 – point b
314 Bélier Falls if COMP 8, 294, PETI 38, 305, 306, 308 or 307 adoptedCompatible with 309, 310 or 30 as addition of "independent"
↓
Art 1 – point 5Art 5 – para 3 –subpara 1 – point b a (new)
315 Sonik, Hibner Falls if COMP 8, 294 or PETI 38adopted
↓
316 Thyssen Falls if COMP 8 adopted, otherwise Adopted if 287 or 288 adoptedDeletion
↓
317 De Lange Falls if COMP 8 or 316 adopted ↓
318 Fjellner, Korhola Falls if COMP 8, 316 or 317 adopted ↓
Art 1 – point 5Art 5 – para 3 –subpara 2
319 Seeber Falls if COMP 8, 316 or 317 adoptedCompatible with 318 as deletion of "technically"
↓
PE516.894v01-00 276/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
320 Rapporteur, Gutiérrez-Cortines, Arsenis, Ayuso
PETI 40
Fall if COMP 8, 316 or 317 adopted, or if 289 NOT adopted, otherwise adoptedIdentical
321 Stevenson Falls if COMP 8, 316 or 317 adopted ↓
31 Rapporteur
322 Florenz, Krahmer, Bánki, Schnellhardt, Reimers, Auconie
323 Pargneaux
Fall if COMP 8, 316, 317, 318, 319, 320or 321 adoptedIdentical
↓
324 Florenz, Krahmer, Bánki, Schnellhardt, Reimers, Auconie, De Lange
325 Fjellner, Korhola
326 Thyssen
Falls if COMP 8 adopted, otherwise adopted if 296 AND 306 adoptedIdenticalDeletion
↓
327 Seeber Falls if COMP 8 or 324 adopted ↓
32 Rapporteur Falls if COMP 8 or 324 adoptedExpression "the technically competent experts and committees of national experts" to be aligned with the expression resulting from the vote on 30, 294, 306-314
Split vote (EFD)
Part 1"The detailed ... Member States"
Part 2Addition of "In any case ... authorities"
↓
328 Pargneaux Falls if COMP 8, 324, 327 or 32 adopted ↓
329 Stevenson Falls if COMP 8 or 324 adoptedFalls if 299 AND 310 NOT adopted
↓
Art 1 – point 5Art 5 – para 3 –subpara 3
PETI 41 Falls if COMP 8 or 324 adoptedFalls if 297, 304, 307, 314, PETI 35, PETI 37, PETI 38 AND PETI 40 NOT adopted
↓
PV\1001717ES.doc 277/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
330 Bélier Falls if COMP 8, 324 or PETI 41adoptedFalls if 297, 304, 307, 314, PETI 35, PETI 37, PETI 38 AND PETI 40 NOT adopted
↓
331 Morkunaite-Mikuleniene
Falls if COMP 8 or 324 adopted ↓
Art 1 – point 5Art 5 – para 3 –subpara 3 a (new)
332 Gutiérrez-Cortines, Arsenis, Ayuso
Falls if COMP 8 adoptedFalls if 297, 304, 307, 314, 32, PETI 35, PETI 37, PETI 38, PETI 40 AND PETI 41 NOT adopted
↓
Art 1 – point 5 a (new)Art 5 a (new)
TRAN 13 +45/24/0
Art 1 – point 6 –point -a (new)Art 6 – para -1 (new)
333 Ferreira +
Art 1 – point 2 a (new)Art 2 – para 4 –subpara 1
163 Ferreira Falls if CONS 4 or PETI 27 adoptedFalls if 333 NOT adopted
↓
Art 1 – point 6 –point -a (new)Art 6 – para 1
334 Scottà , Rossi +45/23/0
Art 1 – point 6 –point -a (new)Art 6 – para 2
335 Rapporteur, Arsenis, Gutiérrez-Cortines, Leinen, Childers, Prodi, Poc
+
Art 1 – point 6 –point -a (new)Art 6 – para 2 –introductory part
33 Rapporteur Falls if 335 adopted ↓
Art 1 – point 6 –point -a (new)Art 6 – para 2 –point f
34 Rapporteur –
Art 1 – point 6 –point -a (new)Art 6 – para 3
336 Rapporteur, Arsenis, Gutiérrez-Cortines, Leinen, Childers, Prodi, Poc
+
Art 1 – point 6 –point -a (new)Art 6 – para 3 –subpara 1 a (new)
337 Scottà , Rossi –
PE516.894v01-00 278/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
339 Arsenis, Gutiérrez-Cortines, Leinen, Childers, Prodi
If 248 adopted, the words "and Article 5(2)" fall
–34/34/0
Art 1 – point 6 –point -a (new)Art 6 – para 4
338 Scottà , Rossi –
Art 1 – point 6 –point -a (new)Art 6 – para 5
340 Rapporteur, Arsenis, Leinen, Childers, Prodi
+
341 Gardini, Tatarella, Bartolozzi
–Art 1 – point 6 –point aArt 6 – para 6 –introductory part 342 Scottà , Rossi Falls if 341 adopted –
Art 1 – point 6 –point aArt 6 – para 6 –point b
343 Thyssen –
344 Krahmer, Reimers
345 Thyssen
IdenticalDeletion
–
346 Scottà , Rossi Falls if 344 adopted –
347 Klaß
Art 1 – point 6 –point bArt 6 – para 7
PETI 43
Fall if 344 or 346 adoptedIdentical
+43/25/0
348 Gutiérrez-Cortines, Ayuso
–32/33/0
PETI 42
Art 1 – point 6 –point b a (new)Art 6 – para 7 a (new)
PETI 44
Vote collectively +
Art 1 – point 7Art 7 – para 5 a (new)
TRAN 14 +
349 Rapporteur +36/33/0
Art 1 – point 8Art 8 – para -1 a (new) 350 Seeber Falls if 349 adopted ↓
CONSOLIDATED 10Decision and monitoringArt 1 – point 8Art 8
ALDE, EPP, S&D, GREENS/EFA, ECR
If adopted, 35-43, 351-410, TRAN 15-18 and PETI 45-48 fall
+
PV\1001717ES.doc 279/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Art 1 – point 8Art 8 – para 1 –introductory part
351 Ferreira Falls if CONS 10 adopted ↓
352 Bélier Falls if CONS 10 or 351 adopted ↓
TRAN 15 Falls if CONS 10, 351 or 352 adopted ↓
35 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 10, 351, 352 or TRAN 15 adopted
↓
Art 1 – point 8Art 8 – para 1 –introductory part
353 Thyssen Falls if CONS 10 adopted ↓
354 Thyssen Falls if CONS 10 adopted ↓
355 Stevenson Falls if CONS 10 or 354 adopted ↓
356 Sonik, Hibner Falls if CONS 10, 354 or 355 adopted ↓
Art 1 – point 8Art 8 – para 1 –point a
357 Seeber Falls if CONS 10, 354, 355 or 356 adopted
↓
358 Thyssen Falls if CONS 10 adopted ↓
359 Florenz, Krahmer, Bánki, Schnellhardt, Reimers, Auconie, Mazej Kukovic
360 Korhola
Fall if CONS 10 or 358 adoptedIdentical
↓
362 Arsenis, Leinen, Childers, Prodi
Falls if CONS 10 or 358 adopted ↓
Art 1 – point 8Art 8 – para 1 –point b
361 Seeber Falls if CONS 10, 358 or 362 adoptedCompatible with 359 as addition of "by the developer"
↓
363 Stevenson
364 Sonik, Hibner
365 Thyssen
Falls if CONS 10 adoptedAdopted if 355 or 356 adoptedIdenticalDeletion
↓
36 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 10, 355, 356 or 363adopted
↓
Art 1 – point 8Art 8 – para 1 –point c
TRAN 16 Falls if CONS 10, 355, 356, 363 or 36 adopted
↓
Art 1 – point 8Art 8 – para 1 –point d – subpara 1
366 Thyssen Falls if CONS 10 adopted ↓
PE516.894v01-00 280/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Art 1 – point 8Art 8 – para 1 –point d – subpara 2
367 Thyssen Falls if CONS 10 adoptedDeletion
↓
Art 1 – point 8Art 8 – para 1 –point d a (new)
368 Sonik, Hibner Falls if CONS 10 adopted ↓
Art 1 – point 8Art 8 – para 2
369 Fjellner, Korhola Falls if CONS 10 or 335 adoptedDeletion
↓
370 Stevenson Falls if CONS 10 or 369 adopted ↓
371 Thyssen Falls if CONS 10, 369 or 370 adopted ↓
372 Florenz, Krahmer, Bánki, Schnellhardt, Reimers, Auconie, Seeber, Mazej Kukovic
Falls if CONS 10, 369 or 370 adoptedCompatible with 371 as addition of "under the relevant law"
↓
373 De Lange Falls if CONS 10, 369 or 372 adopted ↓
37 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 10 or 369 adopted ↓
Art 1 – point 8Art 8 – para 2 –subpara 1
374 Arsenis, Prodi, Childers
Falls if CONS 10, 369 or 37 adopted ↓
375 Thyssen Falls if CONS 10, 369 or 370 adopted ↓Art 1 – point 8Art 8 – para 2 –subpara 1 a (new) 38 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 10, 369 or 370 adopted ↓
376 Stevenson Falls if CONS 10 adoptedAdopted if 370 adoptedDeletion
↓
377 Florenz, Krahmer, Bánki, Schnellhardt, Reimers, Auconie, Seeber, Mazej Kukovic
Falls if CONS 10, 369, 370 or 376adopted
↓
378 Gardini, Tatarella, Bartolozzi
Falls if CONS 10, 369, 370, 376 or 377 adopted
↓
379 Thyssen Falls if CONS 10, 369, 370, 376 or 377 adoptedCompatible with 378 as amending "unforeseeable" to "unforeseen"
↓
Art 1 – point 8Art 8 – para 2 –subpara 2
380 Scottà , Rossi Falls if CONS 10, 369, 370, 376, 377, 378 or 379 adopted
↓
PV\1001717ES.doc 281/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
PETI 45 Falls if CONS 10, 369, 370 or 376adoptedCompatible with 377 as addition of "of both ... operational phases"
↓
TRAN 17 Falls if CONS 10, 369, 370, 376, 377 or PETI 45 adoptedCompatible with 39 and 378 as addition of "and to facilitate corrective action"
↓
39 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 10, 369, 370, 376, 378, PETI 45 or TRAN 17 adopted
↓
382 Sonik, Hibner Falls if CONS 10, 369, 370 or 376adopted
↓
PETI 47 Falls if CONS 10 or 369 adoptedIf the word "accredited" has been deleted in Article 5 as a result of previous votes, the words "or a serious breach of accreditation standards" fall
↓Art 1 – point 8Art 8 – para 2 –subpara 4 a (new)
41 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 10, 369 or PETI 47 adopted
↓
Art 1 – point 8Art 8 – para 2 –subpara 2
381 Arsenis, Leinen, Childers, Prodi
Falls if CONS 10, 369, PETI 47 or 41 adoptedIf 370 or 376 adopted, vote as new subparagraph
↓
383 Florenz, Krahmer, Bánki, Schnellhardt, Reimers, Auconie, Seeber, Mazej Kukovic
Falls if CONS 10 or 369 adoptedDeletion
↓
384 Gardini, Tatarella, Bartolozzi
Falls if CONS 10, 369 or 383 adopted ↓
385 Scottà , Rossi Falls if CONS 10, 369, 383 or 384 adopted
↓
PETI 46 Falls if CONS 10, 369 or 383 adopted ↓
386 Bélier Falls if CONS 10, 369, 383 or PETI 46 adopted
↓
40 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 10, 369, 383, PETI 46 or 386 adopted
↓
Art 1 – point 8Art 8 – para 2 –subpara 3
TRAN 18 Falls if CONS 10, 369, 383, PETI 46, 386 or 40 adopted
↓
Art 1 – point 8Art 8 – para 2 –subpara 4
387 Florenz, Krahmer, Bánki, Schnellhardt, Reimers, Auconie, Seeber
Falls if CONS 10 or 369 adoptedAdopted if PETI 46 adoptedDeletion
↓
PE516.894v01-00 282/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
388 Gardini, Tatarella, Bartolozzi
389 Scottà , Rossi
Fall if CONS 10, 369, PETI 46 or 387adoptedIdentical
↓
390 Thyssen Falls if CONS 10, 369, PETI 46 or 387adopted
↓
PV\1001717ES.doc 283/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
391 StevensonArt 1 – point 8Art 8 – para 3
392 Thyssen
Fall if CONS 10 adoptedIdenticalDeletion
↓
393 Krahmer, Reimers Falls if CONS 10 or 391 adoptedDeletion
↓
395 De Lange Falls if CONS 10, 391 or 393 adopted ↓
394 Sonik, Hibner Falls if CONS 10, 391 or 393 adoptedCompatible with 395 as deletion of "including ... Union legislation"
↓
396 Gardini, Tatarella, Bartolozzi
Art 1 – point 8Art 8 – para 3 –subpara 1
397 Scottà , Rossi
Fall if CONS 10, 391, 393, 395 or 394 adoptedIdentical
↓
398 Krahmer, Reimers
399 De Lange
400 Scottà , Rossi
Fall if CONS 10 or 391 adoptedIdenticalDeletion
↓
401 Sonik, Hibner Falls if CONS 10, 391 or 398 adopted ↓
403 Klaß
PETI 48
Fall if CONS 10, 391, 398 or 401 adoptedIdentical
↓
402 Gardini, Tatarella, Bartolozzi
Split vote (EFD)
Part 1 – Falls if CONS 10, 391, 398, 401or 403 adoptedWithout the words "and inform ... causes of the delay"
Part 2 – Falls if CONS 10, 391 or 398adopted, or if Part 1 NOT adopted"and inform ... causes of the delay"
↓
↓
Art 1 – point 8Art 8 – para 3 –subpara 2
42 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 10, 391 or 398 adopted ↓
PE516.894v01-00 284/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
404 Florenz, Krahmer, Bánki, Schnellhardt, Reimers, Auconie, Seeber
405 Seeber
406 Fjellner, Korhola
407 Thyssen
Fall if CONS 10 adoptedIdenticalDeletion
↓
408 Arsenis, Leinen, Childers, Prodi
Falls if CONS 10, 369 or 404 adopted ↓
Art 1 – point 8Art 8 – para 4
409 Sonik, Hibner Falls if CONS 10 or 404 adopted ↓
43 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 10 adopted ↓Art 1 – point 8Art 8 – para 4 a (new) 410 Morkunaite-
MikulenieneFalls if CONS 10 adoptedExpression "accredited and technically competent independent experts" to be aligned with the expression resulting from the vote on 30, 294, 306-314
↓
411 Thyssen If adopted, 414, 415, 418 and 419 adopted
+
412 Bélier Compatible with 411 as addition of "as soon as possible" and "at the latest ...days"
+
Art 1 – point 9 –point aArt 9 – para 1 –introductory part
413 Sonik, Hibner +44/25/0
Art 1 – point 9 –point aArt 9 – para 1 –point a
414 Thyssen Adopted if 411 adoptedDeletion
+
415 Thyssen Adopted if 411 adoptedDeletion
+
416 Scottà , Rossi Falls if 411 or 415 adopted ↓
+Art 1 – point 9 –point aArt 9 – para 1 –point b
417 Stevenson Falls if 411 or 415 adopted ↓
Art 1 – point 9 –point aArt 9 – para 1 –point c
418 Thyssen Adopted if 411 adoptedDeletion
+
Art 1 – point 9 –point aArt 9 – para 1 –point d
419 Thyssen Adopted if 411 adoptedDeletion
+
PV\1001717ES.doc 285/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
PETI 49 Falls if 411 adopted ↓Art 1 – point 9 –point aArt 9 – para 1 –point d a (new)
420 Bélier Falls if 411 or PETI 49 adopted ↓
421 Sonik, Hibner
422 Scottà , Rossi
423 Thyssen
IdenticalDeletion
–
TRAN 19 Falls if 421 adopted +
Art 1 – point 9 –point bArt 9 – para 3
44 Rapporteur Falls if 421 adopted +
Art 1 – point 9 –point aArt 9 – paras 3 a and 3 b (new)
PETI 50 +35/33/0
Art 1 – point 9 a (new)Art 10 – para 1
45 Rapporteur +
Art 1 – point 9 b (new)Art 10 a (new)
46 Rapporteur +
Art 1 – point 9 a (new)Art 11 – para 2
424 Bélier +35/34/0
Art 1 – point 9 a (new)Art 11 – para 3
425 Scottà , Rossi –
Art 1 – point 9 b (new)Art 11 – para 4 –subpara 2
426 Bélier +
427 KlaßArt 1 – point 9 a (new)Art 11 – paras 5 a and 5 b (new)
PETI 52
Identical –
Art 1 – point 10Art 12 – para 2 –introductory part
428 Thyssen If adopted, 429, 430, 431, 432, 433 and 434 adopted
–
Art 1 – point 10Art 12 – para 2 –point a
429 Thyssen Adopted if 428 adoptedDeletion
–
Art 1 – point 10Art 12 – para 2 –point b
430 Thyssen Adopted if 428 adoptedDeletion
–
PE516.894v01-00 286/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Art 1 – point 10Art 12 – para 2 –point c
431 Thyssen Adopted if 428 adoptedDeletion
–
Art 1 – point 10Art 12 – para 2 –point d
432 Thyssen Adopted if 428 adoptedDeletion
–
Art 1 – point 10Art 12 – para 2 –point e
433 Thyssen Adopted if 428 adoptedDeletion
–
434 ThyssenArt 1 – point 10Art 12 – para 2 –point f 435 Morkunaite-
Mikuleniene
Adopted if 428 adoptedIdenticalDeletion
–
436 Florenz, Krahmer, Bánki, Schnellhardt, Reimers, Auconie, De Lange, Seeber
437 Stevenson
438 Fjellner, Korhola
439 Sonik, Hibner
440 Thyssen
Art 1 – point 11Arts 12a and 12b
PETI 53
IdenticalDeletionIf 193 adopted and 436 NOT adopted, the reference to Annex II.A in Article 12a is deleted
–
Art 1 – point 11Art 12a
TRAN 20 Falls if 436 adopted –
Art 1 – point 11Art 12b – para 2
TRAN 21 Falls if 436 adopted –
Art 1 – point 11Art 12b – para 5 a (new)
441 Gutiérrez-Cortines, Ayuso
Falls if 436 adopted +
442 Pargneaux –
47 Rapporteur Falls if 442 adopted +
Art 2 – para 1 –subpara 1
443 Thyssen –
Art 2 – para 2 444 Thyssen Deletion –
445 Poc Deletion –Art 3
454 Gutiérrez-Cortines, Ayuso
Falls if 445 adopted +42/25/0
PV\1001717ES.doc 287/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
446 Panayotov Falls if 445 or 454 adopted ↓
447 Franco Falls if 445, 454 or 446 adopted ↓
450 Scottà , Rossi
451 Stevenson
Falls if 445, 454, 446 or 447 adoptedIdentical
↓
448 Pargneaux
449 Gardini, Tatarella, Bartolozzi
Fall if 445, 454, 446, 447 or 450 adoptedIdentical
↓
455 Florenz, Krahmer, Bánki, Schnellhardt, Reimers, Auconie, Mazej Kukovic
Falls if 445, 454, 446, 447, 450 or 448 adopted
↓
453 Thyssen Falls if 445, 454, 446, 447, 450, 448 or 455 adopted
↓
48 Rapporteur Falls if 445, 454, 446, 447, 450, 448, 455 or 453 adopted
↓
452 Seeber Falls if 445, 454, 446, 447, 450, 448, 455, 453 or 48 adopted
↓
Point -1 (new)Annex I – title
49 Rapporteur +38/31/0
Point -1 (new)Annex I – point 4 a (new)
PETI 54 +60/9/0
Point -1 (new)Annex I – point 7 –point a
456 Wils +
Point -1 (new)Annex I – point 7 –point a a (new)
457 Wils +35/34/0
PE516.894v01-00 288/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Point -1 (new)Annex I – point 14 a (new) and point 14 b (new)
50 Rapporteur (NB: the following amendments, marked by a gray background, concern non conventional hydrocarbons/shale gas)
Split vote (ECR)
Part 1Without the words "Exploration, evaluation and", "regardless of the amount extracted" (in point 14a) and "Exploration and"
Part 2 – Falls if Part 1 NOT adopted"Exploration, evaluation and" and "Exploration and"
Part 3 – Falls if Part 1 NOT adopted"regardless of the amount extracted"
+51/16/0
+56/11/0
+54/13/0
462 Groote Split vote (ECR)
Part 1 – Falls if 50 Part 1 adoptedWithout the words "Exploration, development and"
Part 2 – Falls if 50 Part 2 adopted, or if 462 Part 1 NOT adopted"Exploration, development and"
↓
↓
463 Perelló Rodríguez, Badia i Cutchet
Split vote (ECR)
Part 1 – Falls if 50 Part 1 or 462 Part 1 adoptedWithout the words "Exploration, evaluation, hydraulic fracturing and"
Part 2 – Falls if 50 Part 2 or 462 Part 2 adopted, or if 463 Part 1 NOT adopted"Exploration, evaluation, hydraulic fracturing and"
↓
↓
Point -1 (new)Annex 1 – point 14 a (new)
464 Bélier Falls if 50 Part 1, 462 Part 1 or463 Part 1 adopted
Split vote (ECR)
Part 1Without the words "The use of hydraulic fracturing for the purpose of the"
Part 2 – Falls if Part 1 NOT adopted"The use of hydraulic fracturing for the purpose of the"
↓
PV\1001717ES.doc 289/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
458 Sârbu Falls if 50 Part 1, 462 Part 1, 463 Part 1 or 464 Part 1 adopted
↓
459 Morkunaite-Mikuleniene
Falls if 50 Part 1, 462 Part 1, 463 Part 1, 464 Part 1 or 458 adopted
↓
460 Scottà , Rossi Falls if 50 Part 1, 462 Part 1, 463 Part 1, 464 Part 1, 458 or 459 adopted
↓
Point -1 (new)Annex I – point 14
461 Sonik, Hibner Falls if 50 Part 1, 462 Part 1, 463 Part 1, 464 Part 1, 458, 459 or 460 adopted
↓
Point -1 a (new)Annex I – point 19
465 Perelló Rodríguez +
Point -1 (new)Annex I – point 20
466 Perelló Rodríguez, Badia i Cutchet
+
Point -1 (new)Annex I – point 24 a (new)
467 Perelló Rodríguez +
Point -1 (new)Annex II – title
51 Rapporteur +
Point -1 (new)Annex II – para 1 –point f a (new)
468 Bélier +34/33/0
Point -1 (new)Annex II – para 2 –point c
469 Rapporteur, Arsenis, Leinen, Childers, Prodi, Merkies
+35/34/0
470 Stevenson
471 Sonik, Hibner
Fall if 50 Part 1, 462 Part 1, 463 Part 1 or 464 Part 1 adoptedIdenticalIf 458, 459, 460 or 461 adopted, the words "and extraction" fall
↓
472 Stevenson
Point -1 (new)Annex II – para 2 –point d – point iii a (new)
473 Sonik, Hibner
Falls if 50 or 464 Part 1 adoptedIdenticalIf 458 or 459 adopted, the words "and extraction" fall
↓
474 StevensonPoint -1 (new)Annex II – para 2 –point e 475 Sonik, Hibner
Fall if 50 Part 1, 462 Part 1, 463 Part 1 or 464 Part 1 adoptedIdenticalIf 458, 459, 460 or 461 adopted, the words "and extraction" fall
↓
Point -1 (new)Annex II – para 10 – point d
476 Wils Adopted if 456 adopted +
Point -1 (new)Annex II – para 13 – point b a (new)
477 Thyssen Falls if COMP 3 adoptedFalls if 100, 104, 105, 106, 107, 108 AND 109 NOT adopted
↓
PE516.894v01-00 290/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
COMPROMISE 11Screening informationPoint 1Annex II.A
ALDE, EPP, S&D, GREENS/EFA, ECR, GUE/NGL
Falls if 193 adoptedIf adopted, 52-56, 478-491, TRAN 22, PETI 55 and PETI 56 fall
+
Point 1Annex II.A
478 Florenz, Krahmer, Bánki, Schnellhardt, Reimers, Auconie, De Lange, Mazej Kukovic
479 Pargneaux
Adopted if 193 adopted, falls otherwiseIdenticalDeletionNO VOTE
Point 1Annex II.A – title
52 Rapporteur Falls if COMP 11 or 478 adopted ↓
480 Rapporteur, Gutiérrez-Cortines, Arsenis, Ayuso
Point 1Annex II.A – para 1 – point a
PETI 55
Fall if COMP 11 or 478 adoptedIdentical
↓
Point 1Annex II.A – para 1 – point b
481 Perelló Rodríguez Falls if COMP 11 or 478 adopted ↓
482 Wils, Ferreira Falls if COMP 11 or 478 adopted ↓Point 1Annex II.A – para 1 – point b a (new) 483 Klaß Falls if COMP 11, 478 or 482 adopted ↓
Point 1Annex II.A – para 2
484 Fjellner, Korhola Falls if COMP 11 or 478 adoptedDeletion
↓
Point 1Annex II.A – para 3
485 Fjellner, Korhola Falls if COMP 11 or 478 adoptedDeletion
↓
Point 1Annex II.A – para 3 – introductory part
53 Rapporteur Falls if COMP 11, 478 or 485 adopted ↓
Point 1Annex II.A – para 3 – point -a (new)
54 Rapporteur Falls if COMP 11, 478 or 485 adopted ↓
Point 1Annex II.A – para 3 – point a
486 Gutiérrez-Cortines, Ayuso
Falls if COMP 11, 478 or 485 adopted ↓
487 Stevenson Falls if COMP 11, 478 or 485 adopted ↓
488 Sonik, Hibner Falls if COMP 11, 478, 485 or 487adopted
↓
Point 1Annex II.A – para 3 – point b
TRAN 22 Falls if COMP 11, 478, 485 or 487adopted
↓
PV\1001717ES.doc 291/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
PETI 56 Identical
Point 1Annex II.A – para 3 – point b a (new)
55 Rapporteur Falls if COMP 11, 478 or 485 adopted ↓
489 Fjellner, Korhola Falls if COMP 11 or 478 adoptedDeletion
↓
490 Stevenson Falls if COMP 11, 478 or 489 adopted ↓
Point 1Annex II.A – para 4
491 Gutiérrez-Cortines, Ayuso
Falls if COMP 11, 478 or 489 adopted ↓
Point 1Annex II.A - para 4 a (new)
56 Rapporteur Falls if COMP 11 or 478 adopted ↓
CONSOLIDATED 12Screening criteriaPoint 2Annex III
ALDE, EPP, S&D, GREENS/EFA, GUE/NGL
If adopted, 57, 58, 492-542, TRAN 23-25 and PETI 57-62 fall
+
Point 2Annex III – title
57 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 12 adopted ↓
492 Fjellner, Korhola Falls if CONS 12 adoptedDeletion
↓
493 Thyssen Falls if CONS 12 or 492 adopted ↓
Point 2Annex III – para 1 – point b
494 Pargneaux Falls if CONS 12, 492 or 493 adopted ↓
495 Sonik, Hibner
496 Thyssen
Fall if CONS 12 adoptedIdentical
↓
497 Morkunaite-Mikuleniene
Falls if CONS 12 adopted ↓
TRAN 23
Point 2Annex III – para 1 – point c
PETI 57
Fall if CONS 12 adoptedIdentical
↓
499 Thyssen Falls if CONS 12 adopted ↓Point 2Annex III – para 1 – point e 498 Perelló Rodríguez Falls if CONS 12 or 498 adopted ↓
500 Krahmer, Reimers Falls if CONS 12 adoptedDeletion
↓
501 Stevenson Falls if CONS 12 or 500 adopted ↓
Point 2Annex III – para 1 – point f
502 Thyssen Falls if CONS 12 or 500 adoptedCompatible with 501 as addition of "where relevant"
↓
PE516.894v01-00 292/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
504 Seeber Falls if CONS 12 or 500 adoptedCompatible with 501 or 502 as addition of "consideration ... nature of the project"
↓
503 Sonik, Hibner Falls if CONS 12, 500 or 501 adopted ↓
505 Morkunaite-Mikuleniene
Falls if CONS 12, 500 or 501 adopted ↓
PETI 58 Falls if CONS 12, 500 or 501 adopted ↓
506 Seeber Falls if CONS 12 adoptedDeletion
↓
507 Florenz, Krahmer, Bánki, Schnellhardt, Reimers, Auconie
Falls if CONS 12 or 506 adopted ↓
508 Stevenson Falls if CONS 12 or 506 adoptedCompatible with 507 as deletion of "contribution ... changing climate)"
↓
509 Scottà , Rossi Falls if CONS 12, 506, 507 or 508adopted
↓
Point 2Annex III – para 1 – point g
510 Sonik, Hibner Falls if CONS 12, 506, 507 or 508adopted
↓
511 Seeber Falls if CONS 12 adoptedDeletion
↓
512 Stevenson Falls if CONS 12, 511 adopted ↓
Point 2Annex III – para 1 – point h
513 Klaß Falls if CONS 12, 511 or 512 adopted ↓
514 Gutiérrez-Cortines, Ayuso
PETI 59
Fall if CONS 12, 511 or 512 adoptedIdentical
↓
515 Thyssen Falls if CONS 12, 511 or 512 adopted ↓
516 Seeber Falls if CONS 12 adoptedDeletion
↓
517 Stevenson Falls if CONS 12, 516 adopted ↓
TRAN 24 Falls if CONS 12, 516 or 517 adopted ↓
518 Wils, Ferreira
Point 2Annex III – para 1 – point i
519 Klaß
Fall if CONS 12, 516, 517 or TRAN 24adoptedIdentical
↓
Point 2Annex III – para 1 – point j
520 Seeber Falls if CONS 12 adoptedDeletion
↓
PV\1001717ES.doc 293/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Point 2Annex III – para 1 – point j a (new)
521 Perelló Rodríguez Falls if CONS 12 adopted ↓
Point 2Annex III – para 2 – point a
522 Stevenson Falls if CONS 12 adopted ↓
Point 2Annex III – para 2 – point b
523 Stevenson Falls if CONS 12 adopted ↓
Point 2Annex III – para 2 – point c – point ii
PETI 60 Falls if CONS 12 adopted ↓
Point 2Annex III – para 2 – point c – point iii a (new)
524 Thyssen Falls if CONS 12 adopted ↓
525 Thyssen Falls if CONS 12 adopted ↓Point 2Annex III – para 2 – point c – point iv 526 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 12 or 525 adopted ↓
58 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 12 adopted ↓Point 2Annex III – para 2 – point c – point v 527 Thyssen Falls if CONS 12 adopted ↓
528 Seeber Falls if CONS 12 adopted ↓Point 2Annex III – para 2 – point c – point vi 529 Thyssen Falls if CONS 12 adopted ↓
Point 2Annex III – para 2 – point c – point vii
530 Perelló Rodríguez Falls if CONS 12 adopted ↓
531 Rapporteur, Gutiérrez-Cortines, Arsenis, Ayuso
PETI 61
Fall if CONS 12 adoptedIdentical
↓
532 Rapporteur, Gutiérrez-Cortines, Arsenis, Ayuso
Point 2Annex III – para 2 – point c – point viii a (new)
PETI 62
Fall if CONS 12 adoptedIdentical
↓
Point 2Annex III – para 2 – subpara 1 a (new)
533 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 12 adopted ↓
PE516.894v01-00 294/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Point 2Annex III – para 3 – introductory part
534 Seeber Falls if CONS 12 adopted ↓
Point 2Annex III – para 3 – point b
TRAN 25 Falls if CONS 12 adopted ↓
Point 2Annex III – para 3 – point g
535 Seeber Falls if CONS 12 adoptedDeletion
↓
536 Seeber Falls if CONS 12 adoptedDeletion
↓Point 2Annex III – para 3 – point h 537 Thyssen Falls if CONS 12 or 536 adopted ↓
Point 2Annex III – para 3 – point i
538 Seeber Falls if CONS 12 adoptedDeletion
↓
539 Seeber Falls if CONS 12 adoptedDeletion
↓Point 2Annex III – para 3 – point k 540 Thyssen Falls if CONS 12 or 539 adopted ↓
541 Seeber Falls if CONS 12 adoptedDeletion
↓Point 2Annex III – para 3 – point l 542 Thyssen Falls if CONS 12 or 541 adopted ↓
543 Gutiérrez-Cortines, Ayuso
Compatible with CONS 12 as an addition –Point 2Annex III – para 3 a (new)
544 Rapporteur, Gutiérrez-Cortines, Arsenis, Ayuso
Compatible with CONS 12 as an addition +55/14/0
CONSOLIDATED 13Information in the environmental reportPoint 2Annex IV
ALDE, EPP, S&D, GREENS/EFA, ECR
If adopted, 59-61, 545-591 and PETI 63-68 fall
+
Point 2Annex IV - title
59 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 13 adopted ↓
Point 2Annex IV – para 1 – introductory part
60 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 13 adopted ↓
545 Rapporteur, Arsenis, Childers, Prodi
Falls if CONS 13 adopted ↓
547 Seeber Falls if CONS 13 or 545 adopted ↓
Point 2Annex IV – para 1 – point a
PETI 63 Falls if CONS 13 adoptedCompatible with 545 and 547 as addition of "energy"
↓
PV\1001717ES.doc 295/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
546 Rapporteur, Gutiérrez-Cortines, Ayuso
Falls if CONS 13, 545, 547 or PETI 63adopted
↓
Point 2Annex IV – para 1 – point a a (new)
548 Rapporteur, Gutiérrez-Cortines, Arsenis, Ayuso
Falls if CONS 13 adopted ↓
549 Stevenson Falls if CONS 13 adopted ↓
550 Thyssen Falls if CONS 13 adopted ↓
Point 2Annex IV – para 1 – point b
PETI 64 Falls if CONS 13 adopted ↓
Point 2Annex IV – para 1 – point c a (new)
551 Thyssen Falls if CONS 13 adopted ↓
552 Franco Falls if CONS 13 adoptedDeletion
↓
553 Pargneaux Falls if CONS 13 or 552 adopted ↓
554 Auconie Falls if CONS 13, 552 or 553 adopted ↓
555 Florenz, Krahmer, Bánki, Schnellhardt, Reimers, Auconie
Falls if CONS 13, 552, 553 or 554adopted
↓
556 Seeber Falls if CONS 13, 552, 553 , 554 or 555adopted
↓
557 Thyssen Falls if CONS 13, 552 or 553 adopted ↓
Point 2Annex IV – para 2
558 Stevenson Falls if CONS 13, 552 or 553 adopted ↓
559 Pargneaux Falls if CONS 13 adopted ↓
560 Florenz, Krahmer, Bánki, Schnellhardt, Reimers, Auconie, Seeber
Falls if CONS 13 or 559 adopted ↓
561 Panayotov Falls if CONS 13, 559 or 560 adopted ↓
562 Stevenson Falls if CONS 13, 559, 560 or 561adopted
↓
Point 2Annex IV – para 3
563 Thyssen Falls if CONS 13, 559 or 560 adopted ↓
Point 2Annex IV – para 4
564 Seeber Falls if CONS 13 adopted ↓
PE516.894v01-00 296/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
565 Thyssen Falls if CONS 13 adopted ↓
566 Korhola Falls if CONS 13, 564 or 565 adopted ↓
567 Scottà , Rossi Falls if CONS 13 or 564 adopted ↓
568 Sonik, Hibner Falls if CONS 13 or 564 adopted ↓
Point 2Annex IV – para 5 – subpara 1 –introductory part
569 Thyssen Falls if CONS 13 adopted ↓
570 Stevenson Falls if CONS 13 adopted ↓
571 Seeber Falls if CONS 13 or 570 adopted
Split vote (ECR + EFD)
Part 1Without the word "sustainable"
Part 2 – Falls if Part 1 NOT adopted"sustainable"
↓
572 Thyssen Falls if CONS 13, 570 or 571 adopted ↓
Point 2Annex IV – para 5 – subpara 1 – point b
573 Korhola Falls if CONS 13, 570, 571 or 572adopted
↓
Point 2Annex IV – para 5 – subpara 1 – point c
PETI 65 Falls if CONS 13 adopted ↓
574 Thyssen Falls if CONS 13 adopted ↓
PETI 66 Falls if CONS 13 or 574 adopted ↓
Point 2Annex IV – para 5 – subpara 1 – point d
575 Seeber Falls if CONS 13 adopted ↓
576 Gardini, Tatarella, Bartolozzi
Falls if CONS 13 adoptedDeletion
↓
577 Thyssen Falls if CONS 13 or 576 adopted ↓
Point 2Annex IV – para 5 – subpara 1 – point e
578 Pargneaux Falls if CONS 13, 576 or 577 adopted ↓
579 Stevenson Falls if CONS 13 adopted ↓Point 2Annex IV – para 5 – subpara 1 – point f
PETI 67 Falls if CONS 13 or 579 adopted ↓
PV\1001717ES.doc 297/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Point 2Annex IV – para 5– subpara 1 – point h
580 Thyssen Falls if CONS 13 adopted ↓
581 Korhola Falls if CONS 13 adoptedDeletion
↓Point 2Annex IV – para 5 – subpara 2 582 Stevenson Falls if CONS 13 or 581 adopted ↓
583 Pargneaux Falls if CONS 13 adopted ↓Annex– Point 2Annex IV – para 6
584 Thyssen Falls if CONS 13 or 583 adopted ↓
585 Bélier Falls if CONS 13 adopted ↓
PETI 68 Falls if CONS 13 or 585 adopted ↓
586 Thyssen Falls if CONS 13 adopted ↓
Point 2Annex IV – para 7
587 Seeber Falls if CONS 13 adopted
Split vote (EFD)
Part 1Without the word "avoided,"
Part 2"avoided,"
↓
588 Seeber
589 Thyssen
Fall if CONS 13 adoptedIdenticalDeletion
↓
590 Stevenson Falls if CONS 13 or 588 adopted ↓
Point 2Annex IV – para 8
61 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 13, 588 or 590 adopted ↓
Point 2Annex IV – para 10
591 Pargneaux Falls if CONS 13 adoptedDeletion
↓
Recital 1 PETI 1 +
62 Stevenson +45/23/0
PETI 2 +
63 Klaß Falls if PETI 2 adopted ↓
Recital 3
64 Gutiérrez-Cortines, Arsenis, Ayuso
Falls if PETI 2 or 63 adopted ↓
PE516.894v01-00 298/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
65 Bélier +
66 Klaß +
Recital 3 a (new)
PETI 3 Falls if 66 adopted ↓
Recital 21 a (new) TRAN 2 Falls if 66 or PETI 3 adopted ↓
67 Klaß +44/24/0
Recital 3 a (new)
PETI 4 Falls if 67 adopted ↓
PETI 5 +
68 Rapporteur, Gutiérrez-Cortines, Arsenis, Ayuso
Recital 4
69 Klaß
IdenticalCompatible with PETI 5 as addition of "including visual impact"
+
PETI 6 +Recital 4 a (new)
PETI 7 +39/29/0
Recital 5 PETI 8 +
Recital 6 70 Klaß –
Recital 9 PETI 9 –
Recital 11 71 Rapporteur, Gutiérrez-Cortines, Arsenis, Ayuso
+
Recital 11 a (new) 72 Rapporteur, Gutiérrez-Cortines, Arsenis, Ayuso
+
73 Perelló Rodríguez +Recital 12
74 Panayotov –
Recital 12 a (new) 75 Morkunaite-Mikuleniene
Falls if CONS 10 adoptedFalls if 410 NOT adoptedExpression "independent, accredited and technically competent experts" to be aligned with the expression resulting from the vote on 30, 294, 306-314
↓
PV\1001717ES.doc 299/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
76 Rapporteur, Arsenis, Gutiérrez-Cortines, Leinen, Westlund, Childers, Prodi, Poc
Falls if 335, 336 AND 340 NOT adopted +
77 Gutiérrez-Cortines, Ayuso
Falls if 189, 441 AND 543 NOT adopted +
78 Gutiérrez-Cortines, Ayuso
Falls if 544 NOT adopted +34/30/3
79 Rapporteur, Gutiérrez-Cortines, Arsenis, Ayuso
Falls if 544 NOT adopted +
CONSOLIDATED 1Recital on derogationsRecital 13
ALDE, EPP, S&D, GREENS/EFA, ECR
If adopted, 1, PETI 10, 80 and 81 fall +
1 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 1 adopted ↓
PETI 10 Falls if CONS 1 adoptedCompatible with 1 as addition of "under the condition ... facilitating role"
↓
80 Bélier Falls if CONS 1 or PETI 10 adoptedCompatible with 1 as addition of "subject to ... public concerned"
↓
81 Arsenis, Prodi, Childers
Falls if CONS 1 or PETI 10 or 80adoptedCompatible with 1 as addition of "after having ... public concerned"
↓
Recital 13
82 Klaß Compatible with COMP 1 as an additionIf PETI 10 adopted, the words "In such cross-border ... facilitating role" fall
+
2 Rapporteur +
83 Gutiérrez-Cortines, Ayuso
+
Recital 13 a (new)
84 Rapporteur, Arsenis, Westlund, Childers, Prodi
Falls if CONS 4, 132 AND 133 NOT adopted
+
Recital 16 PETI 11 +
Recital 16 a (new) 85 Gutiérrez-Cortines, Ayuso
+38/29/0
PE516.894v01-00 300/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
CONSOLIDATED 2Recital on scopingRecital 13
ALDE, EPP, S&D, GREENS/EFA
Falls if CONS 9 NOT adoptedIf adopted, 86, 87 and PETI 12 fall
+
86 Ferreira Falls if CONS 2 adopted ↓
87 Rapporteur, Gutiérrez-Cortines, Arsenis, Ayuso
Recital 17
PETI 12
Fall if CONS 2 adoptedIdentical
↓
90 Ferreira –
88 Auconie –29/38/0
89 Korhola Falls if 88 adopted –
3 Rapporteur Falls if 88 adopted +
Recital 18
PETI 13 –17/46/0
Recital 19 4 Rapporteur Adopted if COMP 8, 25, 234, 235, 236 or 241 adopted, falls otherwise
Recital 19 a (new) 5 Rapporteur +
Recital 20 PETI 14 +
6 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 10, 41, 381 AND PETI 47 NOT adopted
+Recital 21
PETI 15 Falls if 6 adoptedFalls if CONS 10, 41, 381 AND PETI 47 NOT adopted
↓
Recital 21 a (new) TRAN 1 –
91 Panayotov +44/23/0
Recital 22
7 Rapporteur +
92 Perelló Rodríguez +
TRAN 3 Compatible with 92 as addition of "Elements ... on the environment"
+42/25/0
PETI 16 Falls if 92 or TRAN 3 adopted ↓
Recital 22 a (new)
93 Ferreira Falls if 92, TRAN 3 or PETI 16 adopted ↓
PV\1001717ES.doc 301/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
8 Rapporteur Falls if 50 Part 1, 462 Part 1, 463 Part 1, 464 Part 1, 458, 459, 460 AND 461 NOT adopted
Split vote (ECR)
Part 1Without the words "In accordance with theprecautionary principle" and "regardless of the amount extracted"
Part 2 – Falls if Part 1 NOT adopted"In accordance with the precautionary principle" and "regardless of the amount extracted"
+
+
95 Perelló Rodríguez, Badia i Cutchet
Falls if 8 Part 1 adoptedFalls if 50 Part 1, 462 Part 1, 463 Part 1, 464 Part 1, 458, 459, 460 AND 461 NOT adopted
↓
94 Scottà, Rossi Falls if 8 Part 1 or 95 adoptedFalls if 50 Part 1, 462 Part 1, 463 Part 1, 464 Part 1, 458, 459, 460 AND 461 NOT adopted
↓
Recital 23 a (new)
96 Cymanski Falls if 8 Part 1, 95, 94, 50 Part 1, 462 Part 1, 463 Part 1, 464 Part 1, 458, 459, 460 or 461 adopted
↓
97 Panayotov Falls if 445, 446, 447, 448, 450, 453 AND 455 NOT adopted
↓
98 Gardini, Tatarella, Bartolozzi
Falls if 445, 446, 447, 448, 450, 453 AND 455 NOT adoptedFalls if 97 adopted
↓
99 Scottà, Rossi Falls if 97 or 98 adopted, otherwise adopted if 445, 446, 447, 448, 450, 453 or 455 adopted
↓
Recital 24
9 Rapporteur Adopted if 48 adopted, falls otherwise
Recital 24 a (new) TRAN 4 +49/17/0
Recital 26 10 Rapporteur
Recital 27 11 Rapporteur
Fall if 436 adoptedVote collectivelyIf 436 adopted, Recital 26 and 27 are deletedIf 193 adopted and 436 NOT adopted, the reference to Annex II.A in Recital 26 is deleted
+
Recital 28 PETI 17 –29/34/0
PE516.894v01-00 302/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
DRAFT REPORT AS AMENDEDIn favour
49Against Abstentions13 3
DRAFT LEGISLATIVE RESOLUTIONIn favour
48Against Abstentions15 4
PV\1001717ES.doc 303/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
ПРИСЪСТВЕН ЛИСТ/LISTA DE ASISTENCIA/PREZENČNÍ LISTINA/DELTAGERLISTE/ ANWESENHEITSLISTE/KOHALOLIJATE NIMEKIRI/ΚΑΤΑΣΤΑΣΗ ΠΑΡΟΝΤΩΝ/RECORD OF ATTENDANCE/POPIS NAZOČNIH/LISTE DE PRÉSENCE/ELENCO DI PRESENZA/APMEKLĒJUMU REĢISTRS/DALYVIŲ SĄRAŠAS/JELENLÉTI ÍV/ REĠISTRU TA' ATTENDENZA/PRESENTIELIJST/LISTA OBECNOŚCI/LISTA DE PRESENÇAS/LISTĂ DE PREZENŢĂ/ PREZENČNÁ LISTINA/SEZNAM NAVZOČIH/LÄSNÄOLOLISTA/DELTAGARLISTA
Бюро/Mesa/Předsednictvo/Formandskabet/Vorstand/Juhatus/Προεδρείο/Bureau/Predsjedništvo/Ufficio di presidenza/Prezidijs/ Biuras/Elnökség/ Prezydium/Birou/Predsedníctvo/Predsedstvo/Puheenjohtajisto/Presidiet (*)
Matthias Groote, Gerben-Jan Gerbrandy, Carl Schlyter, Christa Klaß
Членове/Diputados/Poslanci/Medlemmer/Mitglieder/Parlamendiliikmed/Μέλη/Members/Zastupnici/Députés/Deputati/Deputāti/Nariai/Képviselõk/ Membri/Leden/Posłowie/Deputados/Deputaţi/Jäsenet/Ledamöter
Martina Anderson, Kriton Arsenis, Sophie Auconie, Pilar Ayuso, Paolo Bartolozzi (1), Sergio Berlato, Franco Bonanini, Biljana Borzan, Milan Cabrnoch, Martin Callanan, Nessa Childers (2), Tadeusz Cymański, Chris Davies, Anne Delvaux (1), Bas Eickhout, Edite Estrela, Jill Evans, Karl-Heinz Florenz, Elisabetta Gardini, Nick Griffin (2), Françoise Grossetête (1), Cristina Gutiérrez-Cortines, Satu Hassi, Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Karin Kadenbach, Eija-Riitta Korhola, Holger Krahmer, Jo Leinen, Corinne Lepage, Peter Liese, Kartika Tamara Liotard (1), Zofija Mazej Kukovič (2), Linda McAvan, Radvilė Morkūnaitė-Mikulėnienė, Paul Nuttall (1), Miroslav Ouzký (1), Vladko Todorov Panayotov, Gilles Pargneaux, Antonyia Parvanova, Andrés Perelló Rodríguez, Mario Pirillo (1), Pavel Poc, Frédérique Ries, Anna Rosbach, Oreste Rossi (2), Dagmar Roth-Behrendt, Horst Schnellhardt, Richard Seeber (1), Theodoros Skylakakis, Bogusław Sonik, Salvatore Tatarella (1), Glenis Willmott, Sabine Wils, Esther de Lange, Kārlis Šadurskis, Dubravka Šuica (1)
Заместници/Suplentes/Náhradníci/Stedfortrædere/Stellvertreter/Asendusliikmed/Αναπληρωτές/Substitutes/Zamjenici/Suppléants/ Supplenti/Aizstājēji/Pavaduojantysnariai/Póttagok/Sostituti/Plaatsvervangers/Zastępcy/Membros suplentes/Supleanţi/Náhradníci/ Namestniki/Varajäsenet/Suppleanter
Margrete Auken (1), Nikos Chrysogelos, José Manuel Fernandes (1), Christofer Fjellner (1), Gaston Franco (1), Julie Girling, Jutta Haug (1), Romana Jordan (2), Georgios Koumoutsakos (1), Marusya Lyubcheva, Judith A. Merkies, James Nicholson, Justas Vincas Paleckis, Vittorio Prodi, Britta Reimers, Michèle Rivasi (1), Christel Schaldemose (1), Giancarlo Scottà (2), Renate Sommer, Alda Sousa (2), Bart Staes (1), Struan Stevenson (2), Marianne Thyssen (1), Marita Ulvskog, Vladimir Urutchev, Kathleen Van Brempt, Andrea Zanoni (2), Anna Záborská
187 (2)
Fabrizio Bertot (2), Jean-Paul Besset (2), Philip Claeys (1), Tarja Cronberg (2), Albert Deß (2), Ingeborg Gräßle (2), María Irigoyen Pérez (2), Nicole Kiil-Nielsen (2), Csaba Őry (2)
193 (3)
46 (6) (Точка от дневния ред/Punto del orden del día/Bod pořadu jednání (OJ)/Punkt på dagsordenen/Tagesordnungspunkt/Päevakorra punkt/Ημερήσια Διάταξη Σημείο/Agenda item/Točka dnevnog reda/Point OJ/Punto all'ordine del giorno/Darba kārtības punkts/Darbotvarkės punktas/ Napirendi pont/Punt Aġenda/Agendapunt/Punkt porządku dziennego/Ponto OD/Punct de pe ordinea de zi/Bod programu schôdze/ Točka UL/Esityslistan kohta/Föredragningslista punkt)
Наблюдатели/Observadores/Pozorovatelé/Observatører/Beobachter/Vaatlejad/Παρατηρητές/Observers/Promatrači/Observateurs/ Osservatori/Novērotāji/Stebėtojai/Megfigyelők/Osservaturi/Waarnemers/Obserwatorzy/Observadores/Observatori/Pozorovatelia/ Opazovalci/Tarkkailijat/Observatörer
Присъствал на/Presente el/Přítomný dne/Til stede den/Anwesend am/Viibis(id) kohal/Παρών στις/Present on/Présent le/Presente il/Piedalījās/ Dalyvauja/Jelen volt/Preżenti fi/Aanwezig op/Obecny dnia/Presente em/Prezent/Prítomný dňa/Navzoči dne/Läsnä/Närvarande den:(1) 10.7.2013(2) 11.7.2013
PE516.894v01-00 304/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
По покана на председателя/Por invitación del presidente/Na pozvání předsedy/Efter indbydelse fra formanden/Auf Einladung desVorsitzenden/Esimehe kutsel/Με πρόσκληση του Προέδρου/At the invitation of the Chair(wo)man/Na poziv predsjednika/Sur l'invitation du président/Su invito del presidente/Pēc priekšsēdētāja uzaicinājuma/Pirmininkui pakvietus/Az elnök meghívására/Fuq stedina taċ-'Chairman'/ Op uitnodiging van de voorzitter/Na zaproszenie Przewodniczącego/A convite do Presidente/La invitaţia preşedintelui/Na pozvanie predsedu/Na povabilo predsednika/Puheenjohtajan kutsusta/På ordförandens inbjudan
Valentinas Mazuronis, Vigilijus Jukna, Vytenis Povilas Andriukaitis
Съвет/Consejo/Rada/Rådet/Rat/Nõukogu/Συμβούλιο/Council/Vijeće/Conseil/Consiglio/Padome/Taryba/Tanács/Kunsill/Raad/ Conselho/Consiliu/Svet/Neuvosto/Rådet (*)
Комисия/Comisión/Komise/Kommissionen/Kommission/Euroopa Komisjon/Επιτροπή/Commission/Commissione/Komisija/Bizottság/ Kummissjoni/Commissie/Komisja/Comissão/Comisie/Komisia/Komissio/Kommissionen (*)
Barbara Steffner (DG ENV), Andras Bartal (DG ENV), Mr Owen (DG CLIMA), V. Larruscain (DG CLIMA), Dominik Schnichels (DG SANCO), Sigrid Wimmer (DG SANCO), Anna-Eva Ampelas (DG SANCO), Alina Timofte (DG SANCO), Ovind Vessia (DG ENER), Stephanos Ampatzis (DG ENV)
Други институции/Otras instituciones/Ostatní orgány a instituce/Andre institutioner/Andere Organe/Muud institutsioonid/ Άλλα θεσμικά όργανα/Other institutions/Autres institutions/Altre istituzioni/Citas iestādes/Kitos institucijos/Más intézmények/ Istituzzjonijiet oħra/Andere instellingen/Inne instytucje/Outras Instituições/Alte instituţii/Iné inštitúcie/Druge institucije/Muut toimielimet/Andra institutioner/organ
Други участници/Otros participantes/Ostatní účastníci/Endvidere deltog/Andere Teilnehmer/Muud osalejad/Επίσης Παρόντες/Other participants/Drugi sudionici/Autres participants/Altri partecipanti/Citi klātesošie/Kiti dalyviai/Más résztvevők/Parteċipanti ohra/Andere aanwezigen/ Inni uczestnicy/Outros participantes/Alţi participanţi/Iní účastníci/Drugi udeleženci/Muut osallistujat/Övriga deltagare
Секретариат на политическите групи/Secretaría de los Grupos políticos/Sekretariát politických skupin/Gruppernes sekretariat/ Sekretariat der Fraktionen/Fraktsioonide sekretariaat/Γραμματεία των Πολιτικών Ομάδων/Secretariats of political groups/Tajništva klubova zastupnika/Secrétariat des groupes politiques/Segreteria gruppi politici/Politisko grupu sekretariāts/Frakcijų sekretoriai/Képviselőcsoportok titkársága/Segretarjat gruppi politiċi/Fractiesecretariaten/Sekretariat Grup Politycznych/Secr. dos grupos políticos/Secretariate grupuri politice/Sekretariát politických skupín/Sekretariat političnih skupin/Poliittisten ryhmien sihteeristöt/Gruppernas sekretariat
PPE
S&D
ALDE
ECR
Verts/ALE
GUE/NGL
EFD
NI
Gersony
Schöner, McCone
Maury
Beier
Lehtonen, Singhofen, Francker
PV\1001717ES.doc 305/306 PE516.894v01-00
ES
Кабинет на председателя/Gabinete del Presidente/Kancelář předsedy/Formandens Kabinet/Kabinett des Präsidenten/Presidendi kantselei/Γραφείο Προέδρου/President's Office/Ured predsjednika/Cabinet du Président/Gabinetto del Presidente/Priekšsēdētāja kabinets/Pirmininko kabinetas/Elnöki hivatal/Kabinett tal-President/Kabinet van de Voorzitter/Gabinet Przewodniczącego/Gabinete do Presidente/ Cabinet Preşedinte/Kancelária predsedu/Urad predsednika/Puhemiehen kabinetti/Talmannens kansli
Schenk
Кабинет на генералния секретар/Gabinete del Secretario General/Kancelář generálního tajemníka/Generalsekretærens Kabinet/ Kabinett des Generalsekretärs/Peasekretäri büroo/Γραφείο Γενικού Γραμματέα/Secretary-General's Office/Ured glavnog tajnika/Cabinet du Secrétaire général/Gabinetto del Segretario generale/Ģenerālsekretāra kabinets/Generalinio sekretoriaus kabinetas/Főtitkári hivatal/Kabinett tas-Segretarju Ġenerali/Kabinet van de secretaris-generaal/Gabinet Sekretarza Generalnego/Gabinete do Secretário-Geral/Cabinet Secretar General/Kancelária generálneho tajomníka/Urad generalnega sekretarja/Pääsihteerin kabinetti/ Generalsekreterarens kansli
Генерална дирекция/Dirección General/Generální ředitelství/Generaldirektorat/Generaldirektion/Peadirektoraat/Γενική Διεύθυνση/ Directorate-General/Glavna uprava/Direction générale/Direzione generale/Ģenerāldirektorāts/Generalinis direktoratas/Főigazgatóság/ Direttorat Ġenerali/Directoraten-generaal/Dyrekcja Generalna/Direcção-Geral/Direcţii Generale/Generálne riaditeľstvo/Generalni direktorat/ Pääosasto/Generaldirektorat
DG PRES
DG IPOL
DG EXPO
DG COMM
DG PERS
DG INLO
DG TRAD
DG INTE
DG FINS
DG ITEC
Tomczyk
Правна служба/Servicio Jurídico/Právní služba/Juridisk Tjeneste/Juristischer Dienst/Õigusteenistus/Νομική Υπηρεσία/Legal Service/ Service juridique/Servizio giuridico/Juridiskais dienests/Teisės tarnyba/Jogi szolgálat/Servizz legali/Juridische Dienst/Wydział prawny/ Serviço Jurídico/Serviciu Juridic/Právny servis/Pravna služba/Oikeudellinen yksikkö/Rättstjänsten
Секретариат на комисията/Secretaría de la comisión/Sekretariát výboru/Udvalgssekretariatet/Ausschusssekretariat/Komisjoni sekretariaat/Γραμματεία επιτροπής/Committee secretariat/Tajništvo odbora/Secrétariat de la commission/Segreteria della commissione/Komitejas sekretariāts/Komiteto sekretoriatas/A bizottság titkársága/Segretarjat tal-kumitat/Commissiesecretariaat/ Sekretariat komisji/ Secretariado da comissão/Secretariat comisie/Sekretariat odbora/Valiokunnan sihteeristö/Utskottssekretariatet
A. Huber, Amanatidis, Carmona, Findlay, Fuchs, Imeroni, Kovacheva, Laky, Romano, Vervloet
Сътрудник/Asistente/Asistent/Assistent/Assistenz/Βοηθός/Assistant/Assistente/Palīgs/Padėjėjas/Asszisztens/Asystent/Pomočnik/ Avustaja/Assistenter
Patyi-Horvath
* (P) = Председател/Presidente/Předseda/Formand/Vorsitzender/Esimees/Πρόεδρος/Chair(wo)man/Predsjednik/Président/ Priekšsēdētājs/Pirmininkas/Elnök/'Chairman'/Voorzitter/Przewodniczący/Preşedinte/Predseda/Predsednik/Puheenjohtaja/ Ordförande
(VP) = Заместник-председател/Vicepresidente/Místopředseda/Næstformand/Stellvertretender Vorsitzender/Aseesimees/Αντιπρόεδρος/ Vice-Chair(wo)man/Potpredsjednik/Vice-Président/Priekšsēdētāja vietnieks/Pirmininko pavaduotojas/Alelnök/Viċi 'Chairman'/ Ondervoorzitter/Wiceprzewodniczący/Vice-Presidente/Vicepreşedinte/Podpredseda/Podpredsednik/Varapuheenjohtaja/ Vice ordförande
(M) = Член/Miembro/Člen/Medlem./Mitglied/Parlamendiliige/Μέλος/Member/Član/Membre/Membro/Deputāts/Narys/Képviselő/ Membru/Lid/Członek/Membro/Membru/Člen/Poslanec/Jäsen/Ledamot
(F) = Длъжностно лице/Funcionario/Úředník/Tjenestemand/Beamter/Ametnik/Υπάλληλος/Official/Dužnosnik/Fonctionnaire/ Funzionario/Ierēdnis/Pareigūnas/Tisztviselő/Uffiċjal/Ambtenaar/Urzędnik/Funcionário/Funcţionar/Úradník/Uradnik/Virkamies/
PE516.894v01-00 306/306 PV\1001717ES.doc
ES
Tjänsteman