8/17/2019 Sentencia de Primera Instancia Oscar Cornejo

1/6

CORTE SUPERIOR DE JUSTICIA DE PIURASEGUNDO JUZGADO DE PAZ LETRADO DE PIURA

EXPEDIENTE N° : 0329-2010-0-2001-PJ-CI-02ESPECIALISTA : GARCÍA VARGAS, EDWIN SANTIAGO

DEMANDANTE : ÓSCAR RENE CORNEJO ZAPATADEMANDADO : LUIS ALBERTO FARFAN SANCHEZMATERIA : INDENIZACIÓN!

RESOLUCIÓN NÚMERO: QUINCE (15)P"#$%, %'$( )* +%(D* %.( )(/ +" )(&*!-

SENTENCIAI.- ANTECEDENTES.

V!"#!$ S% %&'%&"* %+,%"# ,** !%&"%&'* % ,%!%&"% ,#'%!# !#/%I)*+"%&" P($ D%.(/ P*$#"&"(/-R*/4(/%5"")%) E6'$%&('$%&'#%, /*7#")(

4($ OSCAR RENE CORNEJO ZAPATA,  &('$%  LUIS AL0ERTO ARANSANC2EZ &( % 8%")%) )* #*  '3,* '#& &%3&4*% * !3* %S678999.99 (T%&"* S%! 99199 N%;#! S#%!:  #* $*4$*/*'% %&%3&4*'->996-9->991-JR-PE-? "#3#! I8 II III8 '*% %%3/*@# N° 671>->996-7->991-JR-PE-? '*% % %+'%,'#&%! N°671>->996-19->991-JR-PE-?

II.- 2EC2OS QUE SUSTENTAN LA DEMANDA B CONTESTACIÓN DE DEMANDA

DE LA DEMANDA

>.1.- C(/'% * %#'(/ * */&$"'( )* )*+%)% 4$*/*'%)( 4($ * /*.($ OSCAR RENECORNEJO ZAPATA * )( % '$*"'% #*;*? )*/4$*)"@)(/* )* *'$* /#/ +/ "+4($'%'*/=#)%+*'(/ (/ /"7#"*'*/ #*, * % 4%7"% +*$( )* % *)"&" )* )% 22 )* (;"*+5$*, * %4%7"% 4("&"% N 19, )* %'*/ +*&"(%)( )"%$"(, * )*+%)%)( $*%"% %/"7#"*'* 4#5"&%&" “sentencian raude de terrenos las capullanas”   *'$*% ('"&"% /* )*/&$"5* )"&>(/ )"$*&'";(/ /* >% +%'*")( * (/ &%$7(/ =#7"*)(%/%+5*%/ )* /(&"(/ )()* /* %&($)%5% ;*'%/ )* 7$%)*/ *6'*/"(*/ )* '*$$*(K: *7%)( % *6'$*+( )* 4%7%$ % 7*$*'* 7**$% &( "+#*5*/.MMMMMMM>.6.-  A7$*7%, * )*+%)%'*, #* #*;%+*'* &( =*&>% 2 )*)"&"*+5$* )* %.( 200, * % 4%7"% N 10, )* +"/+( +*)"( 4*$"()

8/17/2019 Sentencia de Primera Instancia Oscar Cornejo

2/6

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

* % =(%/ &"*'% /"*'*? '*"@)(/* 4($ (=$*&")(/ (/ +*)"(/ 4$(5%'($"(/ #* /*")"&% * * ..- 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

8/17/2019 Sentencia de Primera Instancia Oscar Cornejo

3/6

)* =*&>% 10 )* %7(/'( )* %.( 2010 * )*+%)%)(, L#"/ A5*$'( F%$= S&>*,/("&"'% % &($$*&&" )* % $*/(#&" N , *+"'")% * % A#)"*&"% )* /%*%+"*'(4$(&*/% &(&""%&", /("&"'#) #* =#* )*&%$%)% "+4$(&*)*'* +*)"%'*$*/(#&" N )* =*&>% )"*&"(&>( )* %7(/'( )* )(/ +" )"*, % +"/+% #* &($$* %=(%/ &"*'( )(/ &"*'( '$*/! MMMMMMMMMMMMM6.6.- &($$* % =(%/ &"*'( %'$(* A&'% )* A#)"*&"% )* P$#*5%/, % % % /* &($$"*$( %+5%/ 4%$'*/, %/"+"/+(

* )*+%)%)( )*&%$( #* %/ 4#5"&%&"(*/, #* /* * "+4#'%, ( */ * %#'($ )*%/ +"/+% %)*+/ #* )*/&((&* #"@ */! A/"+"/+( /* /("&"'% )* (8&"( %P$"+*$ J#7%)( P*% L"#")%)($ )* P"#$% #* $*+"'% * *64*)"*'* 312-2003 %*=*&'(/ )* +*($ $*/(;*$! MMMMMMMM

IV.- PUNTOS CONTROVERTIDOS.

.1.- D*'*$+"%$ /" % )*+%)% $** (/ $*#"/"'(/ )* $*/4(/%5"")%) &";"!

.>.-D*'*$+"%$ /" * )*+%)%)( /* **'$% (5"7%)( % 4%7( )* '$*"'% /*"/+" #*;(/ /(*/ 4($ )%.( +($%!

V.-UNDAMENTOS DE LA DECISIÓN

PRIMERO E E/'%)( 7%$%'"% % '()% 4*$/(% %'#$% ( #$%5"*)( #*)%)( */'%5*&")% % &(+4*'*&"%, &%5* %>($% )"#&")%$/" % 4$*'*/" )* %&'($ >% /")( )*5")%+*'* %&$*)"'%)%, 4#*/ &(+( ( */'%5*&** %$'*&>(/ #* &(87#$* /# 4$*'*/"? 4%$% *( )*5* *;%#%$/* )"&>(/+*)"(/ 4$(5%'($"(/ * =($+% &(#'%, '% &(+( ( 4$*/&$"5* * %$'*&>(/ *64#*/'(/ 4($ %/ 4%$'*/, 4$()#&"$ &*$'*% * * J#7%)($ $*/4*&'( % (/ 4#'(/ &('$(;*$'")(/ =#)%+*'%$ /#/ )*&"/"(*/,

&(=($+* % ( )"/4#*/'( * * %$'

8/17/2019 Sentencia de Primera Instancia Oscar Cornejo

4/6

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

4*$"()(($%5"")%) $*4#'%&" )* )*+%)%'*? */ 4$*&"/%+*'* */* )%.( */ #* /* >% 4*'"&"(%)( %*/'* $7%( #$"/)"&&"(% )*'*$+"%$(? 4#*/'( #* *=*&'";%+*'* >% #*)%)()*+(/'$%)( %&$*)"'%)% % %=*&'%&" % % >(($%5"")%) )* $*$$*'*!MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMSPTIMO: A $*/4*&'( #*/'$( C)"7( C";" &('"** #% )* %/ =($+%/ )* %$*/4(/%5"")%) * * %$'. D*=# E+"*P*"3#&*!- R*&(7"*)( % F*$)* S*//%$*7(, ( )*8* &(+( % */" %% 4*$/(% * /< +"/+% &(+( # ;%($ */4"$"'#%, 4/"&(7"&( * "+%'*$"%/.-. Da$o 0oral .- %#)* % #% 4*$'#$5%&" 4/( +/%+4"( #* % /"+4* */=*$% *+(&"(% ( /*'"+*'% )* /*$ >#+%(, %5%$&%#% 4$('*&&" +%/ "'*7$% )* */'* 4(/"5""'% # $*/%$&"+"*'( &(+4*'()* (/ 4*$#"&"(/ "$$(7%)(/ )* % %=*&'%&" )* (/ 5"**/ +%/ 4$*&"%)(/ )*'()( >(+5$* *'$* *(/ % )"7")%) 4*$/(% $*Q*%)% * % &(/")*$%&" )*

1 J#% E/4"(% E/4"(%, D*$*&>( % % R*/4(/%5"")%) C";", G%&*'% J#$

8/17/2019 Sentencia de Primera Instancia Oscar Cornejo

5/6

'*$&*$(/ * % 4*$/(% +"/+%!MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM

/) A&"'*!- E'*)")% &(+( % &('$%$"*)%) )* % &()#&'% >#+%% %(/ ;%($*/ #$%5$

8/17/2019 Sentencia de Primera Instancia Oscar Cornejo

6/6

)%.( #* * *+4%%)( &( * =#*$'* &('*")( )* %/ ('%/ 4*$"()18999.99(VEINTIUN MIL CON 99199 NUEVOS SOLES) N('"=