texto_182922123

8/19/2019 texto_182922123

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/texto182922123 1/6

MANDADO DE SEGURANÇA 32.450 DISTRITO FEDERAL

RELATOR : MIN. MARCO AURÉLIO

IMPTE.(S) :NERY DA COSTA JÚNIOR ADV.(A / S) : IGOR SANT'ANNA TAMASAUSKAS E OUTRO(A/S)ADV.(A / S) :PIERPAOLO CRUZ BOTTINI IMPDO.(A / S) :CONSELHO NACIONAL DE JUSTIÇA PROC.(A / S)(ES) :ADVOGADO-GERAL DA UNIÃO

DECISÃO

PROCESSO ADMINISTRATIVO –

AERTURA – ELUCIDAÇ!O DE FATOS

– SE"U#NCIA – LIMINAR

INDEFERIDA.

PROCESSO ADMINISTRATIVO –

AERTURA – AFASTAMENTO DEMAGISTRADO – MEDIDA E$TREMA –

INADE"UAÇ!O – LIMINAR

DEFERIDA.

! O G"#$%&& &*+, "* *&,$%&* $%.+"01&*2

N&3 4" C+*" J5%$+ $,%" + "+ + &$+ 4+ 6,"7 +

C+%*&78+ N"9$+%"7 4& J,*$0" 4&&$%+, " $%*","0:+ 4&+9&**+ "4$%$*"$;+ 4$*9$7$%" 9+%" *$ & + "."*"&%+9",&7" 4"* &*&9$;"* "$;$4"4&* <,$*4$9$+%"$*!

C+%*+"%& %""= +9," + 9"+ 4& <,$> .&4&"7 4+ T$#,%"7R&$+%"7 ?&4&"7 4" @ R&$:+= &%4+ &&9$4+ " .,%0:+ 4&C+&&4+ R&$+%"7 & <"%&$+ 4& = *,#*$,$%4+ " $,7"=$&4$4" "%*$+$"&%& 4& ","! N&**& &+4+= 4$> 8";&

&9&#$4+ &6,&$&%+ 4" F,$%" T," 4+ T$#,%"7 & 4+ <,$>.&4&"7 L,$> S&."%$%$ "" 6,& &%.&%"**& +#7&"* 4& ""*+%" &*"0:+ <,$*4$9$+%"7 & V"" ?&4&"7 4" S,#*&0:+

Documento assinado digitalmente conforme MP n°2.200-2/2001 de 24/08/2001, que institui a Infraestrutura de Chaves Públicas Brasileira - ICP-Brasil. O

documento pode ser acessado no endereço eletrônico http://www.stf.jus.br/portal/autenticacao/ sob o número 4831052.

8/19/2019 texto_182922123


MS 32450 / DF

J,4$9$$" 4& P+%" P+:= %+ E*"4+ 4& M"+ G+**+ 4+ S,7!E*97"&9& 6,&= 4,"%& +* "#"78+* 9+&9$+%"$*= &"7$>"4+* &7"

.+0"-"&." $%*","4" + $%&4$+ 4+ A+ % !/= 4"P&*$4%9$" 4+ T$#,%"7= , 4+* "$*"4+* 4&*$%"4+* ""+ $*&= G$7#&+ R+4$,&* J+4"%= +.&$, *&%&%0" & "0:+9",&7" &%"7 4& *&6,&*+= "**&%"%4+ " "9$"7 +9&4%9$"4+* &4$4+* & 4&&$%"%4+ + 4&*#7+6,&$+ 4"6,&7&* #&%* 6,&%:+ &&%9&**& "+* *9$+* 4& &&*" &6,&$4+* %++9&**+!

S&,%4+ $%.+"= & &&*&%"0:+ &%9"$%8"4" "+

C+%*&78+ N"9$+%"7 4& J,*$0"= + M$%$*$+ P5#7$9+ ?&4&"7*,*&%" 6,& + $&"%&2 $) &;& %+ G"#$%&&= 9++ "**&**+=4& " = S"%4+ P$**$%$= , 4+* "4;+"4+* 4+*

#&%&.$9$"4+* &7+ &.&$4+ +%,%9$"&%+ $$) +**,$ 9++98&.& 4& "#$%&& A%4 C+*" ?&">= "4;+"4+ 9+ "**"&%+ &*9$$+ 6,& "&%4& +* &*+* .";+&9$4+* $$$) ;&%4&, ,$;&7 ,"7 "" S"%4+ P$**$%$ & $;) *9$+ 4& , *,+*+$:+ 4& S"%4+ P$**$%$= ?&%"%4+ P$**$%$= %" "6,$*$0:+ 4&

&&%+* & A"#"= E*"4+ 4& M"+ G+**+ 4+ S,7!

S"7$&%" & $%+"4+ + C+%*&78+ 6,&2 ") + "4;+"4+S"%4+ P$**$%$ .+$ "**&**+ 4+ $&"%& 9$%9+ "%+* "%&* 4".+"7$>"0:+ 4" "0:+ 9",&7" & 4&> 4" *&%&%0" 9$"4" #) +"+%+ ".$+,= & 4&+$&%+= %:+ 8";& "%$4+ 9+%"+9+%*$+ 4&+$* 4& 9) " ;&%4" 4" &%9$+%"4" +$&4"4&,"7 +9+&, & 4) S"%4+ P$**$%$ & ?&%"%4+ P$**$%$ %:+

*:+ $:+* &) " "6,$*$0:+ 4+* &&%+* "9+%&9&, & .)A%4 C+*" ?&"> .+$ %+&"4+ 98&.& 4& "#$%&& &7+$&"%& & ">:+ 4" .+"0:+ 9,7,"7 & 4& &7"01&*&**+"$* & ."$7$"&* %" 9$4"4& 4& +$& 4& "#+* & &+&%+ +*&$+ "+* ."+* ;&*"4+* & ) $%&+, + &*9$$+4& "4;+9"9$" 6,& "+9$%" " 9",*"= "* %:+ ",+, %+ +9&**+& "&0+!

D$*9+& *+#& " "$"0:+ 4" *$%4$9Q%9$" &"%& +



8/19/2019 texto_182922123


8/19/2019 texto_182922123


MS 32450 / DF

;++* ;&%9$4+* +.&$4+* %+ <,7"&%+ 4& "%4"4+ 4&*&,"%0" $&"4+ &7+* &6,&$4+* 9+%" + 4&.&$&%+ 4&

&4$4" 7$$%" %&7" +9+$4+! A9&*9&%" & + M$%$*$+P5#7$9+ ?&4&"7 *,#7$%8"4+ 6,& + +9&**+ &*";" .+" 4+Q#$+ 4& "#"%%9$" 4" .+0"-"&."= " 4&*9""9&$>"6,"76,& ;%9,7+ &;&%,"7 &%& + "+ "$9"4+ &7+ $&"%&& " ;$%4" #"78" 4" 4&9$*:+! T"%*9&;& &98+ 4+ ;++ 4+&%:+ 9+%*&78&$+ $%$*+ C"7+* A7#&+ R&$* 4& P",7"=9++#+"%4+ +* ",&%+* 7"%0"4+*!

I%*,&-*& 9+%" + "."*"&%+ 4"* .,%01&* <,$*4$9$+%"$*!

A7,4& * $%9+%*$*%9$"* "+%"4"* %" +"$" 4& $%*"7"0:+ 4++9&**+ 4$*9$7$%"! D$> 4" ."$7$4"4& 4"* ">1&*

<,*$.$9"4+"* 4" &*$0:+ &$$ ","0:+ "$* "%6,$7"4+* ."+* & ."9,7" &78+&* 9+%4$01&* "" + &&99$+ 4+4$&$+ 4& 4&.&*" = *,*9$"%4+ " %,7$4"4& 4" 4&9$*:+ "%& "$%*,.$9$%9$" 4" .,%4"&%"0:+! M&%9$+%" + 4$*+*+ %+ "$+ 4" R&*+7,0:+ % @/= 4+ C+%*&78+! D$*9+& *+#& "4&*++9$+%"7$4"4& & " $">+"#$7$4"4& 4" &4$4"! S"7$&%" "

&$*%9$" 4& &+ %" +97""0:+ 4+ <,7"&%+= +6,"%+ "+;$4%9$" 9",&7" %:+ .+$ 4&&$%"4" + ,%"%$$4"4&="* + "$+$"!

S+# + Q%,7+ 4+ $*9+= ".$" 6,& + "+ "#$$+ 4+C+%*&78+ &<,4$9" +* <,$*4$9$+%"4+* 4+ &*&9$;+ T$#,%"7 &"9,7" + $%9$+ 4+ <,$> %","7! P7&$&$" " 9+%9&**:+ 4&7$$%" "" *,*" +* &.&$+* 4+ "+ .+"7$>"4+ %+ +9&**+

"4$%$*"$;+ 4$*9$7$%" $%*","4+ + &$+ 4" P+"$" %/@= %+ +9"%& &4$4" "9",&7"4+" 4&.&$4"= #& 9++"" *,*&%4& + 9,*+ 4"6,&7& " 4&9$*:+ .$%"7 %&*&"%4"4+ 4& *&,"%0"! S,9&**$;"&%&= +*,7" + &+%+ *.,%01&* <,$*4$9$+%"$*! N+ $+= &6,& + &9+%8&9$&%+ 4"",*%9$" 4& <,*" 9",*" "" " $%*","0:+ 4& +9&**+4$*9$7$%" &= %" &;&%,"7$4"4& 4+ %:+ "9+78$&%+ 4+ &4$4+=4" %,7$4"4& 4" P+"$" % /@ +,= "$%4"= 4" &*$0:+ "+4&*&&%8+ 4+ +.9$+!



8/19/2019 texto_182922123


MS 32450 / DF

O +9&**+ &%9+%"-*& 9+%97,*+ "" " "&9$"0:+ 4"

&4$4" "9",&7"4+"!

! O#*&;& "* #"7$>"* +#<&$;"* 4+ +9&**+! O C+%*&78+ N"9$+%"74& J,*$0" 4&&$%+, " $%*","0:+ 4& *$%4$9Q%9$" ;$*"%4+ "," "+9+%9$" 4& $79$+* .,%9$+%"$* + "& 4& "&%&* 5#7$9+* & &,%$&7&&%+* +#"$+* %$+* 6,& $%4$9"**& "* "%*&**1&*! C+&*"74+ %"* 9+%97,*1&*= + P7&%$+ &*+7;&, $%$9$" +9&**+"4$%$*"$;+ ;+7"4+ " ++;& " &*+%*"#$7$>"0:+ 4+* $%;&*$"4+*=

"."*"%4+-+* 4+ &&99$+ 4+* 9"+* +9,"4+*! C+%" + "+ .+$$&"4" &*" "0:+ "%4"&%"7!

N" 4&9$*:+ $,%"4"= " &;&7" + "9+78$&%+= + "$+$"= 4&*,#*"%9$+*+ ;++ +.&$4+ &7" &%:+ C+&&4+" N"9$+%"7 4& J,*$0"=$%$*" E7$"%" C"7+%= .+" "&*&%"4"* "* 9$9,%*Q%9$"* 6,&7&;"" + C+%*&78+ " 4&&$%" " "#&," 4+ &%9$+%"4+ +9&**+! OS,&+ %:+ 4&;& *& *,#*$,$ "+ &.&$4+ C+7&$"4+ "" $7&&%"

&4$4" &9$" & &.&"= *,#;&&%4+ + &"& 9+%9&%&%& " "7"$%*,0:+= & 6,"$*6,& 9"*+*! O +%,%9$"&%+ 8 4& *& &*&;"4+ "*$,"01&* 9+%9&"* %"* 6,"$*= 4& $%9$+= +*&-*& +**;&7 &9&#&$7&"7$4"4& %+ "$ &*""7! I**+ %:+ *& ;&$.$9" %" &*9$&= %+ +9"%& "&9$"0:+ 4" <,*" 9",*" "" ";&$," &;&%,"7 9++"&%+ $79$+=9+%*$4&"4+* +* "Q&+* &;&7"4+* &7+ $&"%&!

O 7&$+ *,9&**$;+ &&9& +," *+&! A**$ 9++ *,#7$%8"4+= +"."*"&%+ 9",&7" &%9+%" *,+& & .,%4"&%"0:+ *,$"= %"6,"7 *& .&> &.&%9$" ";$4"4& 4+* ."+* *+# + 9$;+ 4+ P7&%$+ #&9++ %&9&**$4"4& 4& "**&," " "%6,$7$4"4& %"* $%;&*$"01&* &;$"#$7$>" "$+ ">+ 4&*$%"4+ &7"#+"0:+ 4& 4&.&*"! A "4+0:+ 4&+;$4%9$" 4&**" &%;&"4," &$& " 9+%*""0:+ 4& 6,"4+ %+ 6,"7 "&"%%9$" 4+ *&;$4+ & "$;$4"4& &&*&%& ," "&"0" +,+#*9,7+ &.&$;+ "+ 4&*4+#"&%+ 4" $%;&*$"0:+= *&%4+

$&*9$%4;&7 6,& + C+%*&78+ "+%& +* +$;+* 6,& &$& 9+%97,$



8/19/2019 texto_182922123


MS 32450 / DF

&7" +**$#$7$4"4& 4& &#""0+ "+ &&99$+ 4+ +4& 4$*9$7$%"!I%&$*$%4+ &%0:+ " $9" &%4&%& " $&4$ +, 4$.$9,7" " ++0:+

4& &;&%,"7 &*+%*"#$7$4"4& "4$%$*"$;"= 4&*9"#& $7&&%" + "+"9",&7"4+= 9++ +9+&,!

N+ 9"*+ 4& &%;+7;$&%+ 4& <,$>= 9+ "$+ ">:+= 8:+ 4& *&*+&*"4+* ;"7+&*= +$* + 4&*"*& +9"*$+%"4+ $"& &7+"."*"&%+ "#,+= *& #"*& 6,& + *,*&%&= 4+ +.9$+ <,4$9"%& "79"%0"+ J,4$9$$+ 9++ , +4+= %+ 6,& &**,1& " 9+%.$"%0" 4+*

<,$*4$9$+%"4+*! P+ $**+ &*+= " "%&9$"0:+ 4" &4$4" &&" *& "

$%*,0:+ $" "+ +9&**+ "4$%$*"$;+= 9+%97,*:+ 4&*&= %:+ *&9+"4,%" 9+ " %",&>" +;$*$"! D&;&-*& "98" 9+ "#*+7,"*&,"%0"= &;$"%4+-*& + "0+4"&%+! E$* ;$*:+ " *& 7&;" & 9+%"=&*&%& " ">+"#$7$4"4&= + E*"4+ D&+9$9+ 4& D$&$+= "&*+%*"#$7$4"4& "4$%$*"$;"!

@! D&.$+ "9$"7&%& " 7$$%" 7&$&"4"= 4&&$%"%4+ + $&4$"+&+%+ 4+ $&"%& * .,%01&* <,$*4$9$+%"$*!

! S+7$9$& $%.+"01&*!

! I%$& " U%$:+ ""= 6,&&%4+= 4$>& 4+ $%&&**& & $%&**"%+ +9&**+!

! A* "* "%$.&*"01&*= 9+78" + "&9& 4+ P+9,"4+-G&"7 4"

R&5#7$9"!

! P,#7$6,&!

B"*7$"= 4& %+;&#+ 4& @!

M$%$*+ MARCO AURLIOR&7"+



texto_182922123

Documents

Transcript of texto_182922123